This is Hidden Brain, I'm Shankar Vedan. We're back in the 3rd century AD, a monk in the Egyptian desert, who are one of evil spirits, people should try to overcome. In Christianity, these became known as a 7-day sense. Pride, bloodening, greed, lust, sloth, wrath, and one more.
Enemy. It's an ugly, miserable, unflattering motion, and a universal. Everyone at some time or another, we experience the ceiling of wanting what someone else has and presenting them for having it. Hi, my name is Jessica Kyle from Atlanta, Georgia.
In 2014, Jessica had her best friend traveled to the remote commorose islands in the Indian Ocean. They were there to teach English. There was meant to be a grand adventure and could be a high point in their friendship. Except Jessica and her friend got sick, really sick, with N'Giviva.
I was single and she was married to a doctor, and her husband was really worried about her and was able to get her evacuated to Kenya. To Nairobi to be exact, to a hospital with air conditioning, good food, and excellent medical care. Jessica meanwhile was stuck on the island. Where it was about 100 degrees, and we had no electricity, and I was very hot and not any good food.
Jessica couldn't stop thinking about how her friend was getting much better care than she was. Now, this has been sick. Jessica felt she was suffering from a new place. I was really, really envious of her to the point where it was actually physically painful, other than just having to get fever.
That envy I felt because I wanted to be in her place. Indeed, that is a purpose of envy. It's a tool for social comparison. It keeps you into your relative position among friends, colleagues, and peers.
In Jessica's case, she was clearly in a weak position and her friend. The envy was sounding the alarm. Jessica did eventually recover as a friend, and when they were reunited, Jessica told her friend about the pain of being abandoned. And it took several conversations with her when she got back on the island, explaining how much I was hurt by that, knowing it wasn't her fault, but still needing to get those feelings out there.
She's still one of my best friends, and I did get over it eventually. That was really, really hard. Of course, not all stories of envy end with growth and understanding, very often, and relates to wicked places and tragic consequences. People sort of sending me a link to a story about people in the Gaza Strip War, people in Israel who are sitting on their couch, is watching bombs get lobbed at the other side and cheering.
This weekend in brain, we bring you a favorite episode from 2018 that delves deeply into an emotion most of us prefer to hide. It's an emotion that can have a positive side dropping us to take steps to improve our lives, but envy can often turn malicious, dropping us to resentment, rage, even revenge. Are you ready to take your savings to a home level? During ragged and to big gively, you can earn the 15% cash back at the stores you love, from May 4th to 11th, the rewards are soaring at your favorite stores, like sporting life, Lego, Dyson, and more.
So go ahead and refresh your closet, book that special experience, and much more. It's not just a discount, it's actual cash back in your pocket. There's a reason millions of savvy shoppers use ragged in every day, they know that when big gively gets, they don't just shop, yes, or, so don't let these deals fly back. Up to 15% cash back only happens from May 4th to 11th.
Join for free at ragged and dot C-A, or get the ragged and app and browser extension, that's R-A-K-U-T-E-N, ragged and the most rewarding way to shop. Finding mental health support should have been feeling more lost. This mental health week, your donation can be double. From May 4th to May 10th, every dollar you contribute will go twice as far to provide double hope and double impact for Canadian-based mental illness and addiction.
Let's build a future where everyone can get the care they need, when they need it. You can help us build that mental health care for everyone. Don't eat today at kemmy.ca slash double. That's kemmy.ca slash double.
Imagine yourself in Ottawa surrounded by thousands of vibrant tulips, and discovering your new favorite micro-proof, before cycling along scenic by cats, and wandering through a museum in Ottawa. Adventure awaits in Ottawa from, oh, to ah, plan your gateway at Ottawaism.ca. It's hard to imagine life without a pleasure of happiness or the pain of deep sadness. These emotions help make us whole.
They give us a way to understand life in all this beauty and suffering. When emotion like envy isn't hardly different, it feels repugnant, useless. Of course, that's far from the truth. Envy in fact, drives us in fascinating ways, sometimes making us better people, sometimes not.
Don't understand it. We begin. We're only good conversation on every show begin. We're going to have a sea of sun, with Homer Simpson.
It's funny, but it's true. Homer is an excellent example of pretty much all the seven deadly sins. Please, lazy. I'm just a big toasty cinnamon bun.
I never want to leave this bed. And gluttonous. 64 slices of American cheese. 64, 63.
And greedy? Wait, wait, wait. First, like, month eight. Homer's also consumed with envy, especially if he's do good on neighbor, netlanders.
You know, if he gave that for Anderson James. Don't we go again, we'll get a little bit of a clear plan. The next is going to work at Jerk. Homer can't stand for landers.
Why? What flander is a pillar of the community. He's on nicer house, a fancier grill, a better job. End of story.
We can't hold it against them, just because he hasn't heard that we do. If you'd meet better, thanks a lot, Marjorie. You really put me in my place. No, no, no, no, no.
No, we're feeling three inches tall. If I know what kind of a person you really are, if Marjorie seems in prison of the international wheel of landers band club. Usually, Homer's left to stew is on bitter bile. But one day, flander is just something unusual.
He announces he's quitting his job. As a fraggy, I'm saying too low to the pharmaceutical game. You need to do something. No, I can't do that.
Wait, I don't need to do that. Well, sir, like one of the very nine Americans, I'm left handed. And let's take it out of a pizza and green. You're writing it's mere word.
You don't want to drive a standard transmission. And I'm going to be going up one stop store for some cause, everything from left handed apple, peelers, left handed scissors, like garlic, leftorium. The leftorium, a snorbid gadgets for left handed people. Finally, Homer feels he has the upper hand.
The leftorium people use is a truly stupid idea. Homer dreams that will finally lead to flander's downfall. And tell me, you lander's sword was deserted. So when you think you're best is buddy, no, Mark.
Dad, do you know what shot in Florida is? No, you're not know what shot in Florida is. Please tell me because I'm dying to know. If the German term for shameful joy, they can play you in the suffering of others.
Oh, come on, Lita. I'm just glad it's him for a plan. That is what is usually all happy and comfortable. It's your round of my loved ones.
They make me feel what the opposite of the simple joy thing is. Sour grapes. Oh, you're in trouble. Happily and openly expresses thoughts and feelings.
Many of us seem to identify with, including envy and snassy psychic, shot in Florida. And he taps into a dark side of human behavior. But that doesn't mean it's without value. Like all emotions, it has purpose.
The anthropologist Christopher Boom has written extensively on the hierarchies of long-existent among our ancestors, both early hunter-gatherer tribes and our primary relatives. Christopher makes two points by the origin of envy. The first, inequality is everywhere. In a hunter-gatherer group, there are always individuals who are more gifted, individuals who are more intelligent, individuals who are more attractive, socially or sexually, and so on.
So there are a considerable number of inequalities within an even The other point Christopher makes is that such differences matter. They're not lost on the members of a tribe. Even primates pay attention to social ranking. Who has less?
Who has more? Over half a century ago, a friend told his name chance wrote an article on Baboon behavior, which he discussed the direction of attention in the group. And he simply measured where different individuals' cases were directed. In a systematic way, he found that the alpha male, no surprise, was gaze out every so much more than anybody else.
And it wasn't just the alpha male. Every member seemed to be intimately aware of where he or she stood in hierarchy of the tribe. This combination, the reality of inequalities and the fact that we are hardwired to notice them, this is a fuel for our endless capacity for ending. Minajakara, a social psychologist at Harvard, says it's exactly the same with humans.
We make sense of the world for social comparisons. When you meet a new person, there are a lot of things about them that you register immediately, but you don't just register them in some abstract or absolute sense. You register them relative to yourself. So not just how tall is this person, but how much taller or shorter are either I am.
We do this because comparison tells us where we fit in. What are places in the human hierarchy? What's more, it alerts us to imbalances that might be our attention. Sometimes, in comparison, we make your mind a lot of that much.
I might get my colleague Stephen's key. I notice he not only hosts a popular ponker at the great program. It's my relationship with your audience. But you also manage to find time to write a new book nearly every other year.
I feel any of us to leave, but in a way, so I just call benign. I don't wish anything bad to happen to him. I just wish that I was more likely. Okay, Sharga, thanks very much.
Maybe the theme might push me to work harder. So if you have more than what I have, I may be inspired by what you have. And so I may have, I may experience these benign forms of envy, which will also manifest admiration. I remember this one time in college, I was going with two girlfriends to go shopping and they were about to write a new table for their apartment.
They were getting together. This is Liam Mothi from Houston, Texas. On the shopping shop with friends, she found herself suffering from benign envy. One of the friends had just gotten married to a senior who graduated, and he was out on somewhere else in the country making money.
And she had a she checked her bank account before we left and she had a $1,500 in her. And that was a substantial amount of money to me back in college days where I only had a few hundred dollars on a good day in my bank account. Liam was envy as a friend and I kind of tabled her for it. She needed to go one day to get her own, nice table.
My first table that I bought for my apartment was $15 from Goodwill. And of course it didn't last, but years later when we saved and when we were patient, my husband and I, and we finally were able to buy a good table and spend with us for almost 10 years now. And I think learning that patience when it came to money and time was a very good lesson. So Liam has envy motivated her to plan and save and build a kind of life she wanted.
And at work, when envy does not work in this happy fashion. In fact, his evidence that envy makes us unhappy and there are ever more sources of envy in our modern world. In an earlier episode of Penn Brain, we featured a researcher at OHA Barzalei who conducted a study in the effects that Facebook has on our lives. He compared the metal well being of people using the site regularly against a control group that was prevented from using Facebook.
Our first finding is that using Facebook makes you more comparative. You compare yourself to others more often. You judge yourself, you compare them in my better or worse than my friends in my happier, how they happier and so on. OHA found that spending time on social media puts people in the mode where they engage constantly in social comparison.
They look at whether friends are having dinner and compare it to their own sad ball of microwaved ramen noodles. They look at whether friends are having a new thing and think about their lonely lives. They look at posts about the blue ribbon that friends got to come from the science fair and wonder why their own kids have only been on a low. Being engaged in excessive social comparison decreases once happiness.
So it's not that you think that others are happier than you are, but you need to prove yourself to yourself over and over again and this social comparison engagement makes you less happy. At the University of Pennsylvania, psychologist Barbara found out something similar. Hostions were often reported that they were unhappy while they were often doing amazing things and ending the destination wedding or on a great vacation. Their Facebook feed told them that they were missing out on fun things that their friends were doing back home.
What we found out from a lot of experiments that we ran, the thing that was generating the foam out, the feelings of fear of missing out, it isn't really a fear. It's like a social anxiety and it's really more about what are your friends doing in building up their social group history that you're missing out on. So it's not really about the experience per se. In all of our experiments, we found that it was really more a function of an anxiety that something might happen in the group experience that will shape the group history in the future that you may not be part of and that will undermine your group belongingness.
And in fact, when we went back and said, okay, if you could make this decision again, would you choose to go to the beach weekend or to the wedding, although we didn't use that example in our studies. But that kind of thing, would you choose to go to the clearly better experience or would you go to the routine thing your friends were doing on a regular basis? Almost every time people said, oh no, I go to the exotic event. It wasn't that they didn't think that the exotic event would better end of smarter decision.
They had no regret about making that decision. What they were anxious about and we're using the word anxiety was that maybe something would happen in the group that would forever change the dynamics of the group and they wouldn't have been there when it happened. But sometimes seeing that others are doing things that you can't do or that others have what you don't have doesn't really produce feelings of envy. It produces anger, resentment, as we saw with homo systems.
When we come back, how a different kind of envy sometimes called hostile envy and either terrible consequences. The more hostile forms really have to do with leveling the playing field not by bringing up to where you are but rather bringing you down to where I am. This is Hidden Brain. I'm Shocker Vedanta.
Say with us. to catch back only happens from May 4th to 11th. Join for free at rakta.ca or get a rakta app and browser extension that RAK-UTEN. Rakta, the most rewarding way to job.
Envy and Shocker. Psychologists and apologists and pharmacologists have also done how animals make close attention to how well they are doing compared to their peers. In one classic study, every university of pharmacologists ran through all in the colleagues found that monkeys refused to do a task if they feel that other monkeys are getting a bigger reward than they get for the same task. In another study conducted by researchers at the University of Zurich at the University of Nottingham, teams composed of two workers had their pick up.
In one case, both workers received the same pick up. In another, only one worker received the pick up while the other salary remained unchanged. The researchers found their productivity declined more deeply when only one workers had their pick up. The reason they feel intuitive.
Workers were comparing their salary to those of their peers. When everyone suffered a pick up, it didn't make them feel good, but it didn't make them feel envious because everyone was in the same boat. When only one person suffered a pick up, there was instantly envy. We can understand and empathize with this form of envy, but it can be harder for us to confront than until your form.
What sociologists sometimes call malicious envy. What's interesting and sad is that we reserve this kind of envy for our neighbors, classmates, friends, our peers. Here are sociologists at college as me in Chicago. People pick relevant comparisons and are on relevant dimensions, so those are two key ingredients.
That's an extremely important point. I'm not going to compare my salaries, A to Warren Buffets. I'm going to compare it to another assistant professor in my department or another university in the same department. So again, I run into the most virulent forms of envy in our research people in some ways ways to learn the same boat as us.
Let me back me right. The first time salary sees Mozart, the musical genius is groping a young woman, his hand stuffed down her blouse. salary is disgusting, he's envious. Why he has himself, has God given such a dirty mind of creature, such talent.
Soon enough, salary has his opportunity to promote his art of his pedestal. My favorite scene of the movie is the country's the envy is when Mozart's wife comes to a salary. I've come on behalf of my husband. I brought you some samples of his work so that he can be considered for the royal appointment.
At first salary is what pretends if he wants to help. I'm looking at him at the moment I can. I'm not going to be too much trouble, sir, to ask you to look at them now. I'm afraid I'm not glad you'll miss precise moment.
Let's leave them with me. I sure you'll look quite safe. I really cannot do that, sir. You see, he doesn't know I'm here.
You can send you? No, sir. This was my own idea. We're desperate.
We really need this job. Then he doesn't achieve music. He gets up and looks at it. Looking with me frantic if you found those were missing.
You see they're all originals. And it's what I'm wondering for the film. These are originals? You hear him imagining the music inside because he's a position he can still look at the notes and hear the music.
He's also talking about music. He's a position that no music is ever finished. He's a place where he's not. And it would be a bit of anishment.
It's a place where my phrase and structure would fall. The way the film shows that you see his face and it's in pain. So the thing that's very moving and very beautiful about this is also the idea that salary is someone who actually is talented enough to actually appreciate what it is that Mozart can do that he actually can't look at that sheet music. And he knows the music come to life, which obviously most people will not be able to do.
I suppose you can say that in hand it says, of course, similarity and way of he knows what it is that he's a pretty that's part of the pain that I acknowledge. The pain is too much. And the only thing that we believe it is the joy, salary and emergency will feel when Mozart is destroyed. And that is exactly what happens.
salary becomes the architect of Mozart's downfall. He watches with pleasure as the younger composers come to overwork and dies, penillists and desperate. In our modern lives there are endless examples of this kind of enemy. You have an obligation.
You have an obligation to walk wholly and to walk righteous and to walk pure before God. In 1980s, Jimmy Swagger was one of the most popular TV evangelists in the United States. He described himself as God's manager. But I'm going to preach when I believe this word says our bodies are typical to the Holy Spirit.
We are personifications on the Lord Jesus Christ. We are supposed to be examples of righteousness. Swagger said there was no room for moral compromise. Our church in Baton Rouge was the other day.
We just started a bold team and I told him I said, if girls show up on that bold diamond with short zone, I will appreciate you and do everything I can to help you in Jesus, but I'll send you home to get some clothes on. But Swagger apparently had trouble keeping his own clothes on. It came out that he was involved with a prostitute. Sometimes meeting over trips at a run down hotel.
Swagger confessed on his national TV broadcast. I have sinned against you my Lord. And I would ask that your Christmas would wash and cleanse every same. Many of Swagger's followers were devastated.
But plenty of his critics curled with a light. There was no need to even hide the shine for it because after all, Swagger was a hypocrite. He got rich between righteousness while using his money to sin. Me and Chicago said it was in fact a perfect recipe for shine for it.
So if a person has ill gone gains and those gains and it's taken away from them, we feel pleasure. In large part, again here we're not benefiting ourselves, but we feel good because some justice has been done. There's some karmic restoration in taking place. In fact in the TV interview, even the sex worker had been caught with Deborah Mothrie, fairly gotten his justice hurts.
He's up there crying and I'm a little too smart real. How you know? Do you think I'm going to be a good person about all this stuff and doing it? Not surprisingly, Jimmy Swagger is down for good irresistible, but those who thrive on Charlotte Frida, late night comedians.
The Reverend Dr. Carl Paytho, this ministry is spiritual. God, I call it your style. Me and Richard point out that hypocrisy often triggers Charlotte Frida, but it's often not the only part of this emotion.
We tend to feel pleasure when people who get too big for their religion taken down a pen. Too big for their bridges or to put it another way. But cutting down a tall puppy, the cutting down of tall puppies. These are not just hypocrites, but people who are also too greedy, too rich, but also perhaps too nice, too smart, too pretty, too successful.
Hello, welcome to Marjorie Stewart Living. I so glad you've been joining us today. We have a program filled with great ideas and very interesting projects. In 2004, Marjorie Stewart was accused of insider trading.
A jury in New York convicted Marjorie Stewart today on all four counts against her in the enclosed stock case. She was charged with a lot of incentives was announced. It was open season for Marjorie and Frida. Marjorie Stewart is just the sum total we have a of the same.
She was too tall a puppy. Marjorie Stewart is recognized that she got into people's skin. She acknowledged as much to now former NBC anchor Matt Lauer in an interview after her release from prison. You're a magnet for praise and sometimes criticism.
It's very equally. You think it's 50-50? I think it's sometimes much worse. I don't understand.
I write books. I publish beautiful magazines. I don't know. I don't know.
I don't know. Maybe because I'm confident. Maybe I should have failed. Maybe I should have just gone away and done a whole and jumped in.
Who knows? Marjorie Stewart is a bit. People use humans to evolve to resent those who are performance. The words that we have available in our language for, say, feeling happy or someone's success, I actually can't think of any single word.
You have to add other words to clarify what kind of happiness. The ending we do have words for ending and so forth. So I don't think it's so natural for us to feel happy for other success, just all other things we need. Promontons are just for both.
There's no dissimilar behavior in the studies of 100 Gather Drives. These groups are extremely vigilant to the person who gets too big for his bridges. They make a precise and if it gets too bad, they may ostracize him. It really gets too bad.
Don't kill him. We're not just doing fabulous behavior that we are. Our instinct is to pull them down closer to where we are. When that happens, when they fall, well, it feels good.
Of course, mothers do want to join these Swagger at both anecdotes. A feeling to what they haven't been measured in any scientific way. They turns out, envy and shock and fraud are very hard to study. Most people know it's wise to hide these negative emotions.
When we come back, measuring these unseen emotions in a lab. They know that when big give we get, they'll just shove your score. So don't let these deals lie by. A 15% cash back only happens from May 4, 2011.
Join for free at rec.ca or get direct and app and browser extension. That's R-A-K-U-T-E-N. Rec. The most rewarding way to job.
Finding mental health support should have been feeling more lost. This mental health week your donation can't be told from May 4 to May 10. Every dollar you contribute will go twice as far to provide double hope and double impact for Canadian-based mental illness and addiction. Let's build a future where everyone can get the care they need when they need it.
You can help us build mental health care for everyone. Don't need today at kammh.ca slash double. That's kammh.ca slash double. This is him brain.
When we open the pantry and devour a box of cookies, we usually hide the evidence. When we fantasize about winning the lottery and hoarding the cash or imagine flipping the desk of our most irritating colleague, we talk those emotions away. Gladney, greed, wrath. We don't want to expose them to the light of day.
But envy and tweak it cause and shine for it. These may be the emotions. We're very deepest. I think we all know we all learn very early on that we're not supposed to express pleasure and sponsor people's expressions.
Now there's another perhaps less overt reason to do that. Once you express shout out to it, it demonstrates that you were feeling envious of that person in the first place. And so one of the problems with expressing envy, of course, is that you have to admit that you understand that you are inferior on some dimension. And so what you're going to do that.
Of course, as with most things in life, there are some exceptions. Times when it's okay to express emotions. Politics is one, so nobody gossip at the second, and force is a theory. And so these areas, especially sports, that social scientists have honed in on in their efforts to study envy and shine for it.
Coach K, in the nuclear levels against Coach Kal and the Kentucky Wildcats early on. Richard Smith and colleagues at the University of Kentucky, putting together a study on basketball rivalry between the Kentucky Wildcats and the Duke New Devils. Hey, hey, can't have student fire. Now obviously, Kentucky fans experience a type of shine and fright at the Blue Devils loose.
But what the researchers want to know is when a shine and fright are letting more sinister places. So the last university of Kentucky students will respond anonymously to an article describing an injury to a star player on the rival Duke team. The county found that students would incur by basketball that no shine for it and considerable sympathy for the injured player. Hard court Kentucky fans, however, had an entirely different reaction.
We showed pretty clearly that especially people who were highly identified as a basketball fans were quite happy when the rival player for opposing team got a severe injury. These fans were happy when a rival player got seriously injured. Shine for it, in other words, is such a powerful emotion that it can make us feel good when a rival suffers serious physical harm. Me and Chicago wanted to know what exactly was happening inside the brain when a fan feels a pleasure of shine for it.
So she decided looking at baseball fans. We recruited Red Sox and Yankees fans to participate in our study. And so the idea here was that we recruited hard court Red Sox and Yankees fans and they would see baseball plays unfolding while they were lying in the functional MRI machine. Me and the assistant of the party that activated when a person is experiencing pleasure.
And so we had these participants, these Red Sox and Yankees fans watching these plays and holding the scanner after each play, we asked them how good they felt about the play, how bad they felt about the play, and what we found was that participants not only felt the most pleasure when their own team did well, particularly against their rivals. But they also felt more pleasure than a controlled condition when they saw their rival fail even against a third party team. And the idea here is that there's no material benefit to your own team. So if you're a Red Sox fan and you see the Yankees get tagged out by the end of one play, there's no material or actual benefit to use Red Sox.
You can make the argument, you know, might change league standing. But we're always showing participants plays in the very beginning of the game, where couldn't determine the outcome of the game, and therefore each team's perspective leads standing. The idea is that the reason this is pleasure is driven solely by the rivalry. You haven't benefited material in any way.
You only feel pleasure because it feels good to watch a rival fail. You know the study, Mina and Akali, is trying to measure shine for either by analyzing muscle movements and face. We've used something called facial electromiography whereby we place electrodes on the main muscles of the face, and we measure specifically from the cheek muscles, because those are the muscles that pull your lips into a smile. And in case you know the muscle is very reliably related to people feeling pleasure.
Now it can't tell us the difference between happy pure on the build rate of joy and shouting for now, which is this more malicious form of pleasure. It can tell us that there's some positive affect being felt, or it suggests that there's some positive affect being felt. So we've used that as an indicator of shouting for when people are exposed to target suffering with fortune. If I remember correctly you could have to study once where you evaluated how people were reacting to various people in various situations where people can solve their taxi droves through a paddle, and some of those experiments would utilize the same measurement techniques.
Exactly. So for example, one of our arguments, one of the questions that we asked ourselves, which groups tend to be the envy groups. You know, people respond with less empathy to all sorts of out groups, and when I say out group I just mean groups to which I do not belong. But not all out groups are equivalent.
So for example, if I saw an elderly man who splashed by a taxi driving past him, I don't think I would feel any pleasure. But if I saw a brain man on the next one, I feel also a pleasure. And the idea is that people feel bad when bad things happen to people from the field pride or people from the field pity. Like, the elderly, they even feel bad when bad things happen to homeless and drug individuals.
The only time that they feel good when bad things happen to those groups, again, there's no competitive and high status in society. So that's well the individual who's business people and so on. Part of what's interesting about this research is that it's looking at brain responses like pleasure and pain that are quite primal. They may have helped come together as one strong tribal entities.
But for modern humans, these neurological responses might have a downside. Now one of the things that we were interested in in large part inspired by some of the work by Richard Smith and his colleagues was whether or not this pleasure response that people self-reported was related to a desire to harm the rebel team associated individuals. In the MRIs of the baseball fans, men discovered that those who reported the most pleasure at watching their rival fail were also people who had the most activation in a small part of the brain known as the ventral striator. So without a mind, men followed up.
So two weeks after we came in them, we sent all of our participants a website where we asked them how likely they would be to engage in a regular recipe here. And the thing that we found that was really exciting for us as academics, but probably about for the world was that those people who exhibited that much more ventral striator activity when watching the rival fail too, earlier in this manner were the same people who eventually would be that much more likely to threaten, haggle and hit a rival fail. In other words, the amount of pleasure you take in a rival failure is a potent predictor of how far you might take matters into your own heads. What do you do with you, in fact, in another group, and if it was a legitimate envy, it reminds one of the ones if you're already one solution to that is to find ways to eliminate that source of insanity.
Eliminate the source of the ones envy. Maybe that happens by accident when a rival team star player blows out of me. But Richard says it could also be an act of cutting down of an envy group. In fact, he believes that malicious envy and shine-froider may have been one of the underlying triggers of the Holocaust.
The suffering of Jews in the 1930s and 1940s came after a time of Jewish prosperity when many average Germans were struggling financially. If you look at a lot of the history of Jews in Germany, also in Austria, they're very successful. And in a way, we're disproportionately successful in many areas of German life. Richard's theory is that this may have spawned malicious envy amongst some Germans.
This envy was never scored on by Nazi propaganda. A long way, of course, not since the very things before they engineered the final solution. But any time Jews suffered it some way, either because of things that Nazis did deliberately to engineer it like Christon-Nautica and so forth, would be satisfying that sense of what understands how envy would produce that type of reaction in the first place. And if you have enough experiences of feeling good when someone suffers or some group suffers, then the next step, in a sense, is to actually literally engineer fully.
Sometimes, however, there's nothing we can do to pull down those about us. They're too powerful, too distant. That's what I mean by Richard's thing. Our insecurity is finding different dominance.
There's a very strong psychological impulse to avoid being placed in the last place. That is, the last place of version. This idea that as long as you can look down and see that there's another person or another group, and there's comfort from which you can derive from knowing that information. So one of the interesting things that people often bring up is, as a paradox, whereby poor people will oftentimes support policies that are bad for them.
And one of the potential arguments for explaining why that is, is not because you don't necessarily have to appeal to some broader idea about belief in a just world or everybody gets what they want. It's simply just the last place of version. So these policies, though they may be bad for me, and it's made sense. They're at least maintaining some hierarchical structure so that I don't end up at the very bottom.
Anytime someone's doing worse than us, any kind of way, there is a potential, okay, that's good. I'm not as bad as they are. And especially if some reason we're needing a boost because we have some insecurities, whatever case may be, then that now comparison is more potential boost. There are studies about this.
But Richard likes to give us an example of the one popular reality TV show to catch a credit. They're online and on a prowl grown man, targeting children on the internet. The show features under cover string operations in which people pose is underage youth. When adult men contact the decoys over the internet, looking for sexual liaisons, they're lured to a meet-up spot and then confronted by journalists with cameras rolling.
Those guys that were part of that thing, nobody could see themselves as a down-compare person compared to them. They're sort of lowest at the lowest. If you wanted to find someone, you could really say, what a low life. I'm certain like that.
I'm not being well in all these kind of ways. I may not be unemployed, maybe this may not, but I am not. Showing up to see an underage person. Our pleasuring people fall below us, allow for behavior on the show that most of us will find unacceptable in other situations.
So much so that the producers that show could humiliate these men in a very extreme way. In a way that you can imagine doing somebody else and feel good about it, but there's almost no guilt, humiliation of another human being and quite the opposite. The viewer is probably getting a lot out of it. I just wanted to talk a little bit about it.
I was going to use a lot of people. I was going to use a lot of people. I was going to use a lot of people. When envy and shunned Freud are playing out among individual people, the outcome's tend to be limited.
Feelings are hurt, a French event, a colleague comes away. When it comes to group behavior and group identity, these emotions can be far more destructive. If Richard's theory of envy and shunned Freuder and Hitler is Germany are true, these feelings may have contributed to the murder of millions. You see similar things are small scale in the United States.
Richard's men said shunned Freud has become a powerful force in our politics, and it operates through the lens of partisanship. The increasing bottom line is whether one's party is gaining some way. In one study, Richard and some colleagues ask college students for their emotional reactions to a variety of new circles. The eye goes to striking its fortune to happen in two others, like stories of home foreclosures or economic woes.
It turned out that the students with the strongest political party identification were also most likely to see the news to the prison of shunned Freud. Some partisans who had joy were American service members came home dead from the war in Iraq because they made the other party look bad. We also looked at reactions to troop deaths. Democrats just before they went up to the midterm election.
So it just, the fact, remained that if you were wanting George Bush or the Republican Party to do poorly, more troop deaths in Iraq would be a good thing in the sense of swinging the election. Democrats were willing to slightly feel or acknowledge that the bad news coming out of Iraq made them feel good to extend, like to see the political consequences. In the same vein, a few decades ago, some Republicans felt pleasure knowing that President Jimmy Carter's Iran hostage rescue debacle would help their candidate in the presidential election, Ronald Reagan. This is terrible stuff.
Minajikara believes that malicious envy and shunned Freuder may in fact serve as a gateway who wants people to act. A couple years ago when scurroaches and Israel started to keep up again, it was the summer of 2014 people started sending me a link to a story about people in the Gaza Strip war. People in Israel who were sitting on the couch and watching bombs get a lot of the other side in cheering. And oftentimes I hear things like, oh, the shot of bread, this is just relegated to the domain of sports or celebrity gossip.
You know, context in which it really doesn't matter. But actually it turns out it's President and situation. And it was dire of human conflicts and situations. If I feel good every time I watch about anything happen, maybe that's how I'll make about anything happen.
The reason this feels is just beginning. It's still unclear how much the pleasure of shot of Freuder can lead to actions that cause harm. If an angry young man feels pleasure watching white supremacists assault someone, will he become a white supremacist himself? How much cannot pain prompt us to fight pleasure and how much can this pleasure prompt us to cause pain?
If we can be led by shot in Freuder down a path of destruction, where does it end? We began this episode with a story of Jessica. She was left behind on an island with dengue fever while her friend was airlifted to a modern hospital on the mainland. Jessica's envy was so intense it caused her physical pain.
It might have led to the end of a long friendship. But that didn't happen. And the reason it didn't is that Jessica brought her envy into the light of day. She exposed fully what she had been feeling.
And that simple act admitting to what we are talking inside allowed her ultimately to try and forward this emotion. Perhaps it's a lesson in Jessica's story. The first step of fighting envy is to admit we have it. This episode was produced by Jenshmit and Pasha, edited by Tara Boyle.
Our team at Keel's Raina Cohen, Laura Cornell and Tom Slu. Our own son Keel this week is Adam Sussman. Adam is a lawyer at NPR and he's involved in many complex issues that come up when you run a journalism organization. I got into no item as he and I have worked out the framework and business model for him brain.
We've had many long conversations over the years and I've always come away impressed by his tenacity and flexibility. Thank you Adam. If you enjoy this episode, please tell a friend about it. We're always looking for new listeners to discover hidden brain.
I'm Shankar Vittantam and this is NPR.