Hello and welcome. You're listening to Fourth Estate, the show where journalists talk journalism, coming to you from 2CR and Sydney on the Gallego lands of the Aura, nature and ride across Australia on the community radio network and directly to your device across the globe via podcast. My name is Peter Frey and I'm the Co-Director of the Centre for Media Transition at UTS and my producer today is Anthony Dockrell. Well, coming up, it seems only last week, well in fact it was only last week, we were getting all a bit gloomy about job losses at BuzzFeed and Vice.
Then up pops, Blue Blood Media Guys, John B. Fairfax and Cameron O'Reilly to fund a new investigative journalism venture under the auspices of private media in its chairman and editor-in-chief, Eric Beecher who joins us on the line from Melbourne. Thanks for being on the show Eric. This is great news of course, so sketch us out your plans.
What's going to happen? What do we mean by the investigative journalism? When are you going to start? Give us some basics.
So the plan is that we are now hiring a Crikey which is on a private media's digital publication, World New Reporters and an editor. Today we'll be doing what we call inquiry journalism. So it's like investigative journalism but I think investigative journalism has very particular kind of hand we certainly embrace those investigations. Yeah, let's just dwell on that inquiry versus investigative thing for a second.
I personally like the idea of inquiry journalism. I guess you might argue that all journalism is inquiry but nonetheless. So why would it be distinct to be think investigative it sort of says yeah big heads, take six weeks to do whereas what you're going to do, we'll have a mixture of things. Is this what I'm hearing?
That's right. I mean we're going to have a team of people that will enlarge team onto that, midterm projects for a week or two weeks and then some of them will work out. They'll try and kind of look under rocks and I think there's a lot that goes on in the news because the news cycle now I think there's a lot that goes on the news that just human knowledge on the part of the consumer and they move it moves from subject to subject and yet I think there's often a lot more to these stories you know who's behind something connecting the dots follow the money trail to is this person what's their motivation you know that kind of thing and often it just gets lost in the in the fast movement. Yes, you know I can agree with you more.
So an idea say right now would be something like the submarine contract. So like that would it or yes I mean there's almost it's subject. I think it's more about a mindset and I think if you kind of like wearing a particular pair of glasses if you look at these things move that prism and you pass those quick even in like news meetings and the assumption knowing things and I'll answer and say well what do you know about this and you don't know anything following the news? Have you possibly you know last month or last year?
No, I mean I guess what you're talking about is in part a symptom of as you mentioned the sort of fast-paced digital planet we live in but also this sort of in a way one of the things eroding journalism right this idea that oh yeah every knows about that I'll move on you know get on so so you have a massive challenge then to kind of if you like slow it down a bit right? Yeah, so I'm not saying slow it down I'm saying tease it out. Okay, yeah fair enough. So yes you mentioned kraki I was that was my next line to mention that private media was a kraki was part of private media which kraki kind of started off as a thorn in the side blog of politicians and business people by Stephen Maine and now it's a fully fledged news news and current affairs website with a very high payable.
So what would be the relationship between kraki and this new as yet unnamed venture? Just to be clear so that all the content will fit within kraki that is website and content and so it will be it will be kraki and this will be included. Okay and you don't have a name at the moment unless you'd like to share it with us now. No we don't have a name but we are looking at giving it its own hockey but it's not a separate publication it won't have a separate website right it will be part of kraki it will really be adding a real we think a real time so so if it had a persona so you know just I'm gonna be one of those design type people now if it had a persona what would it be its persona?
I think it's for Sony with the someone who walks in the door and kind of chipping away at the things I mean who's behind it you know who's pulling the strings so not and cynically but really kind of with a lot of these issues there's far more the news characters. So it's a yes it's a basically it's a polite pain in the arse. Yeah that's a good way of putting it. There you go.
Like you I suspect there too. That's not the mutual love in one thing you were a little bit coy about was not saying how much this is all going to cost why so coy? Well we talked about the show you know we don't we're not going to but we have a business model because kraki's subscriptions we have a little bit of advertising and so the beauty of this and what we really like about it we have and so print newspapers, drivers in kraki trials and then they're in the tent and their tricks we don't have to worry about that. So do you have in mind a kind of an idea a number I suppose what success looks like?
Well we have a three year plan so our plan is that in about two and a half years time we will be okay what's that number again? Well I'm not telling you that. Sorry I don't ask again just you never know so tell me about John B Fairfax and Cameron right we did ask John B on to the show he was unavailable he's out on the farm or something so you know I'm not asking for too many words in their mouth but what's motivating them to back this are they wanted to turn up quid or are they kind of local Jeff Bezos who bought the Washington Post is it is it about deep pockets is it basically they've got deep pockets and deep convictions or they want to they want to earn some money as well. It's all three it's deep pockets it's deep convictions but yeah no fear of that do they ranking I mean it's interesting to see John B back in the game you know a reasonable person would say well he had a get he and his family gave it a huge go in many ways and what we've been out of the media since 2011 but here he is back in it so again without putting too many words in his mouth but he's just simply in his blood.
Look it is in his blood and of his son Nick who's in so they and Cameron O'Reilly have been chair of his okay and we looked at a number of obviously. And one of the things you mentioned to me in the past not when we've been on air is media part in France what did you particularly like about that operation? What we like for 10 years old now it's digital only and it was entirely on the basic environment but I think what it did show us. Just remind them listeners how much is a sub to a sub to Cricky now?
Cricky now I think is too much a year. And will it go up with this? It may it may we'll just see how it go away it won't kind of double printing like that but it may go up fine. Okay and do you I mean you have a pretty good idea given you a crick experience and your experience with other properties you have titles you have of the kind of how elastic I suppose you know the market is in terms of price.
Do you you know what do you sense do you do you have a sense that you know there is if you give them if you give the audience is audience what they want they're prepared to pay for it. I don't think there's any so we're covering the audience 20 dollars a year. Yes it's interesting though I don't know whether you've tested this or thought about this so what is that number you know you say it's possibly a lot bigger than 220 is it I know do 5,300? I don't know do you have any ideas about that?
Well you know Cricky delivers out to dozen stories a day five days and it's not it doesn't cover the news so they're not a lot of time but you know we're not going to do that we're not. Yeah so if there are these and I don't disagree with you by the way that there are lots more people they're prepared to pay what stops them from paying why aren't they paying? Well they are paying to a reasonable extent I mean between the Australian and the natural view the señon close now I think on their... There are a lot of people if you like people like us who want to be informed who believe in public interest journalism and yet still don't put their hand in the pocket is that because of the ABC or is it because they don't fundamentally believe that journalism they should pay for journalism and do any thoughts about that?
Yes I mean the ABC does it's really josho that's free so that has to be a factor I mean you know the BBC does the same thing and the same in Canada but they're actually I think the other thing is that remember when people just paid and there were you know millions and millions of people what's happening now is that the news and we've moved the digital and the digital bit pay. One point about newspapers of course is that they were cheap and so if we keep you know with subscription model do we risk making kind of public interest journalism a luxury product? Well I think if you're being asked to pay you know dollar a day which is what crikey's charging at the moment that's pretty cheap. Yes that's not luxury giving a price of a cup of coffee for instance.
You wrote back in July last year when the Fairfax 9 merger was announced that this would be a death of some there'd be quality journalism would be collateral damage in that merger. Is that kind of also what's is this giving you the window? the opportunity is that a factor in all this? No not at all.
I think what we're trying to do here is completely separate from any going on in the marketplace. In other than anyone else's we're saying it's going to be different and it's bigger than us. If we do this we already have a slice of this. I don't think it's in any way in any way.
Okay. Have you subscribed to this crikey? Have the moment? Uh, it's about 11,000.
Okay. All right well it'll be very interesting to see you know the impact of this at King it can only go up really think right? Absolutely. Yeah of course.
So to digress a little bit from your good news I'm interested in your thoughts on two things have you know come up one thing that I think the deadline for resubmission to the atriplices inquiry into digital platforms is tomorrow. I'm sure you've knocked one out for that and I'm interested in and then we'll get to the can cross review in the UK in a second. One of the couple things in the preliminary report from the atriplices was the idea of tax offsets to support public interest journalism and a separate thought was to make subscriptions tax deductible again in the name of public interest journalism. Does journalism need this sort of does quality journalism need this sort of government support?
Well I think public interest journalism is what I would regard as a fact sphere and that kind of journalism is just exclusively on this so it's um occupation. It's getting on the phone it's knocking on doors. Yep. Exactly.
So if you take those two what I would regard as facts and put them if it's important to democracy and if thousands maybe you know it's a truth. So to me that's the issue then you'd say well okay do we all accept that or do we say no we need to find a supplementary funding tool. If the same thing was happening to the court or so why aren't we saying the same thing about public interest journalism? Okay so what would you prefer tax offsets or tax deductible for subs or any other is it what do you think?
So this is and so number one it has to be. So is that is that well that could be any number of mechanisms do you have a preferred mechanism on that? Well I think it ends up probably seamless on journalism. If each other would therefore be 30 to 40 percent more public interest journalism.
Yeah I think so. Okay I mentioned the Kankross review in the UK was just came out of the day or so ago. That was a parliament inspired inquiry into how to make journalism sustainable which so it's different the ACCC on the Facebook because the ACCC was really looking at the impact of the digital platforms on the news environment although it's right or went into a lot of other areas. So that's just reported the Kankross review is just reported and it's a couple very interesting thoughts that came out of it.
You might have picked up on some other things as well Eric but two things that treat my buttons. One was it suggests that there needs to be a new body something called it calls the Institute for Public News to ensure the provision of public news public journalism including possibly this institute would manage a fund to support local news. And the second and really interesting thought and obviously very contentious thought in the UK and would be so equivalent here I imagine is that the BBC the market impact of the BBC should be explored and at the very least the corporation should do more. The BBC should do more to help local publishers.
What do you think of those two things and what else did you get out of that review? Detailed yeah and I you know the issues are different. The issues are exactly the same you know that they've really what did you do about it. Used to be a role for government and government funding data questions.
I don't want to kind of have to kill a point of view or talk about the ABC necessarily. The most important thing is to try and establish both the mind of is a legitimate and that you know is there any other public. Some big publishers because they want the market so you're going to get public debate against the idea of it and I think as long as they're based on 100% arm length independence in the mechanism that we have. What do you think of an idea of an institute dedicated to public news as the Kankross thing has called it.
It could be called lots of other things of course but I guess what I'm asking is does the industry to answer your question how do we get these things in sync is one of the answers to have a new body or new bodies because ACC has some ideas about new bodies as well that can essentially raise the profile to a level where there is no more need for more debate. It's basically accepted that journalism is a public good and in some way needs support. So does a new body institute public news or whatever or the public interest journalism initiative or whatever we may call it what do we need something like that. Look I think if there's the day media so one or two I mean essentially outside the ABC the nine news corporation you know between them you know if they decided one or I got on the agenda.
Do you sense I mean again this is a very subjective question and probably answer I mean do you sense that if you like the good guys are winning on this debate. I think it's too early but I think as someone who's kind of involved in this from very fine that when you do talk to people regardless of political persuasion or their pose to the idea of discussing should we explain it in nearly all of them then. Two quick final questions one is in all this we haven't mentioned the digital platform even though the ACC was part you know it concentrated on essentially Google Facebook. What do you want to see happen in terms of the digital platforms.
There's a lot of suggestions around one of them is a some sort of carrier tax a levy that is then passed into journalism in some way there's a lot more you know more robust ideas about breaking the whole thing up. What do you want to see in terms of those digital platforms what needs to happen. Well I think there's a number I mean that would be just normal beyond that I think you know there are all the issues about well I personally think the idea of sort of saying Google and Facebook stole the funding that's appropriate. Your point being is that the kind of the business model that's supported print had blown up before they really arrived.
The revenues that they're got they're different. There's different different sorts of money yeah okay well that's that's the subject of a whole new show I guess but yeah okay so what is there anything else you what about this idea of a carrier tax this idea that they should be taxed in some way to pay for the content they carry that they find eyeballs with which is content made by imparts on the journalists that you employ. I mean he's most appealing here with sovereign and clearly there needs to be more equilibrium in the funding. Okay all right all right well as I say look this is a massive subject and maybe I can get you back on the show when the ACCC comes out with its final report with a couple other folks we can put it apart then.
My last question really is quite simple when do we expect to see going back to the new venture when do we expect to see the first copy to arrive in my inbox. So you know obviously Crockett comes out every day anyway and a couple of months to add a bit of it but putting that in April and then we'll take. Great in time for the election of course. Yes, of course you have a happy days.
Eric Bicha thank you so much for being on the Fourth Estate been great to talk to you and to bring your massive experience and wisdom and courage really to the show thank you very much for spending time with Fourth Estate tonight. Thank you for that. And just to remind you please keep subscribing to the Fourth Estate on your favorite podcast so you can hear us talk about media politics and a few things in between when you like not just at in the evening on the evening show or whenever your community radio network rebroadcastes. We will be back with more next week but in the meantime you can stay in touch with us on Facebook or Twitter where our handle is for the state.
My name is Peter Frey, producer of Anthony Dogrel and thank you so much for listening.