Hello and welcome to For For State, a show about journalism. We're coming to you from T Chamin of Newscorp, and of course he is the eldest son of Rupert Murdoch. After a legal back and forth between Chrikey News and Lochlan Murdoch's law team, over an opinion piece about the US capital riots, Chrikey made the bold decision to publish all their legal correspondence and direct an open letter to Lochlan Murdoch published in The New York Times. The defamation case originates from an article on the 29th of June by a Chrikey News journalist Bernard Keene.
In the legal action against private media, Lochlan Murdoch's lawyers claim the opinion piece is defamatory because they alleged links to the Murdoch family to the US capital riots on January 6th. While the article did not refer to Lochlan Murdoch, rather the family name, Lochlan Murdoch filed a defamation lawsuit last week to discuss all of this we are joined by Peter Frey, editor-in-chief of Krikey and managing editor of private media. Peter is of course a former host of Fourth Estate and Janine Parrot, generalist, broadcaster and commentator. Previously a presenter for Sky News and a columnist for Krikey News, she previously worked at the City Morning Herald, the Australian Nine Network and also guest host of ABC's Media Watch.
Peter Frey and Janine Parrot welcome to Fourth Estate. Peter, most media organisations are dodging deformation cases, not walking directly into them. You've effectively challenged Lockler Murdoch in an advertisement in New York Times to take out this deformation case. Why?
Well we published what we consider a very fair and reasonable piece of analysis that looked at the role of Fox News in the rise of Donald Trump in a particular the insurrection on January 6th in Washington DC. I will I've said this many times but it's the sort of piece that has been published in the United States many many times and for reasons that you know I'm not inside of Lockler's head so I can obviously the headline had the word Murdoch in it and there was a reference to the Murdoch's in the piece. Loplin chose to take that as meaning himself and send us a you know concerns notice and I guess our first response was really I mean really really saying that you that we shouldn't be able to publish this article in this country and so I guess we're fighting this one. I don't guess I know we're fighting this on a matter of free speech and we believe that Australian audiences should be able to read the sort of robust debate that Craggy published on January the 29th of this year and which is we repubished recently because even though we first took it down and we decided that we were going to go the whole way here and so I'm looking forward to seeing Mr Murdoch in court and hearing what he has to say.
Are you touched on freedom of speech and you know the defamation laws changed in July last year public interest journalism has been pushed forward in the changes. Janine do you believe these changes may protect Craggy? Look I'm not a legal expert and as we know this is going to be a test case for the new laws I mean I am very pleased to see changes in defamation laws I've been doing this for 40 years and I think it's the greatest threat to press freedom the Australian defamation law so any changes are great I'd like to see them tested in this case unfortunately most as we know get settled out of court. The public interest defense the free speech defense it's going to be interesting because there is and I know it's being talked about and I'm not buying into this the head of the case but there is an argument that there is investigating journalism and there is opinion and that is going to be interesting given that there is so much more opinion mixed with fact these days in media it's going to be a very interesting line that I'll have to walk.
Yeah I do want to touch on this distinction between investigative journalism and opinion later in the piece. Look in March Lachlan Murdoch spoke at the IPA lamenting YouTube's attack on freedom of speech in Australia and he went on to say in Australia we should reject every effort and there are many to limit points of view to obstruct a diversity of opinion and to enforce a singular worldview. Those efforts are fundamentally anti-Australian. Peter will you a little bit surprised that he took up the section?
Oh I was amazed, fairly amazed and I look I look at Lachlan Murdoch and his father and his grandfather. Keith Murdoch have all spoken over many decades in this country and elsewhere about the importance of a free press. News Corp and Fox News in particular you know defends what he says on the basis that people have a right for robust free speech. Yes I agree I agree with Lachlan Murdoch we we there are considerable constraints on what can be said especially in this country and I really when he wrote that stuff at the IPA we covered it and we've covered it subsequently and you know good on him for saying it so for him to then turn around and seek to sue us and threaten to sue us seems to be at odds with those sentiments let's put it politely.
Janine Rupert Murdoch has never sued for defamation even though he's been a major target of division and criticism for decades. Why do you think Lachlan Murdoch decided to launch this defamation suit when his father you know clearly hasn't been interested? Well somewhat arguing he must have a much thinner skin I think it's a terrible trend I think given Rupert Murdoch yes has had a lot worse things said about him and he has taken that stand I think it is a disturbing trend that his son has pointed out who is an advocate even as recently as this year for free speech would take this action knowing that his media empire here runs into the same problems of people suing them for defamation I mean he knows what it's like on the other side so I think it's a disturbing trend I actually think it's part of a broader problem I've always had if we take it Lachlan Murdoch with you want to call him a media proprietor or a journalist journalist suing journalists I have a problem with there was one case I don't know if you want to talk about Aram Aladdin this week but we're seeing more of it we're seeing politicians we're seeing as I said media people suing media people I think this goes to the heart of what is wrong we can all be hypocrites underneath if we rail against the defamation laws and then want to use them ourselves I mean obviously when there are particularly bad cases you want to use the law but I think we have to think carefully of this whole broad issue and when you've got media proprietors like Lachlan changing something that his father had obviously felt that he would not sue that is a major sea change and it's something we have to talk about in a broader context okay well look at you both have previously worked for new school how do you view the organization today I mean have you used change in recent years I mean Janine you can go first look I was out I worked at Sky for a couple of years ago before it was owned by all the major media groups and then used to get over a few years ago I started my career at the Australian as do many people the greater Del Ferguson and Fairfax there's many many good journalists who work there it was a different newspaper than it was a proper newspaper less opinion under less holings it had it was probably not a snorchly right wing as it is now or not as polarizing opinionated but over years it's changed different editors change have different views but there's no doubt they have moved to the right there's no doubt that the whole media has become more polarized more political moves into their silos there is a lot of good journalism at News Corp we've seen that with teachers pet this week I'm in great victory there for them I think the shame is that you see more and more opinion creeping into the news pages and I get very frustrated the Australian being my heart I won't even start on the daily telegraph and the other or News.com because I call it News.com.au I mean they're entertainment let's get serious if you take them seriously if you think they're a threat well I'll argue the debate point they're more entertainment than serious journalism so there's a lot of arguments I can make about Skyr other sky is not Fox US I agree with it Janine although you know it is a very sort of fully clear picture I mean talk about News.com.au year whilst I made and you know last year when the gold walkie for her work which disappeared and news.com and rightly so and then you mentioned Hedy Thomas and teachers pet an amazing piece of journalism and Kristoffson would not would still be a free man if that hadn't happened so that's what makes news of conundrum in some ways it does do some really great pieces of journalism but at the same time it has an agenda and it basically has moved further to the right in general you know I think again to Janine's point the immediate landscape has got more polarized and I don't think that serves readers as well as perhaps editors think it does you know I think if you know why people turning off news look at the recent you know news survey by the University of Canberra you know we're losing people we're losing people because in part you know in part because of time poor but also because you know if they want their opinions there's lots of places to go get opinions you know I think this is always a challenge for something like Frankie you know I think we are robust you know the piece that Bernard Keene wrote about Fox and Trump and the Hadnadok in the headline was a robust piece of analysis that you know I some people would seek to portray that as a you know a lefty kind of piece I don't I think that is something just being very robust and through the middle but we are living in this terrible polarized place and I don't know where we go from I don't know where we get back to something that's a little bit more modest maybe is the right way and look it's interesting you've both kind of teased out that there's more to news than what you would read in a tweet on Twitter there's more diversity there's more subtlety that there's more there's more things going on and there's great journalism going on but at the same time you know the new sculpt didn't wake up the day after Donald Trump was elected and suddenly changed on some level have we all been a bit naive well yes perhaps perhaps we've a bit a bit naive I mean I think Bernard Keene wrote a piece this week which you know I think is fundamental to this debate which is what happens on Fox News we kind of I think we sort of dismiss it as a bunch of you know raving right being right being a nut job but the truth is and as we saw in January the 6th what happens in Fox News spreads an illness the sickness and we have so much skin in the game of a US democracy being you know existing you know I don't think we I think we are naive about this point that you know Fox News inside of that riot and there's no you know inside of this problem again and amplified the Trump's big lie that the election was stolen and and here we are and if we have this sort of insurrection that goes to the very heart of American democracy and what happens in the US has a direct impact on us I mean do you think if Trump got back in he would be doing what Biden's doing on Ukraine do you think Trump would have the same attitude towards you know Taiwan and China I mean there's a extraordinary number of things that could affect us do you think the you know the the alliance you know August I mean go you know go any place that affects us so that's why what happens in Fox News is so so important to what happens to our own country in our own region and then people that perhaps is a bit weird to realize. Janine I mean a lot of people say Sky News is in Fox News but is it just is that true or is it just because Sky News doesn't have the audience reach a Fox News?
Well obviously it doesn't have the audience reach it doesn't have the influence but then other newspapers, Tamblooms do and they don't seem to have the same political influence that they would like to I don't think I say it's not Fox News because while it's had some I don't know how you describe them some similarly offensive or dangerous comments made by certain commentators there it is not the norm as it's more entertainment than dangerous or now that could be naive than it's early days but you do have to pay for Sky here it's not the ABC where it's very very broad in the US. One thing I will point out though that has been a disturbing trend is some of the more extreme views one of whom is not there anymore had been distributed on YouTube this has been now this is the access everybody attacks the mainstream media the Murdoch media Fox YouTube Twitter YouTube has been running a lot of Sky they've been making a lot of money on that and running that and I think one of the January 6 writers had been holding up a YouTube video from an Australian Sky commentator so when I say Sky is not Fox it's probably the danger to big game all back the other way than here but we can't just isolate the Murdoch press without how YouTube is amplifying it now YouTube did disciplines guy this year over some things but Twitter there's a whole other area which is not as regulated nobody talks about where it can be just as dangerous. I absolutely agree and Crockett's Campbell since there's a lot of time writing about what happens on YouTube and other parts of the online space and I agree totally that there is a massive debate to be heard about how we regulate people and we did a story this week where people being knocked off of YouTube ending up on another you know platform called Rumbel you know I this is a big game of work and all and it's a game that I'm afraid we're destined to keep doing you know it's there's no end of this and that's why that's why really the good honest ethical journalism becomes so important. You're listening to Forf Estate on the Community Radio Network this week we're talking about Crockett versus Lockland Murdoch defamation case and the Australian defamation law more broadly I'm joined by Crockett's editor and Chief Peter Frey and journalist Janine Parrot.
Look last week the ages Chief Reporter, Chip LeGrand, wrote a pretty harsh take on all parties involved in this matter Peter I'm assuming you've read it did he make any other points. I've sort of forgotten Chip's piece I was made me sort of put out by him suggesting that I was thought I was one of the smartest people in the room which if anyone knows me I would know that that's a prime thing to say about me but anyway Chip yeah look I don't know what the genesis of Chip's piece was it was a centurion piece we've got raw shoulders chips allowed to write what he likes I noticed that the day or so afterwards the age ran an editorial which essentially backed cricky up so you know that's the ages if you like a fish or editorial point of view yeah we should have a diverse media if Chip or anyone wants to have a crack you know yes can I just say it was an entertaining piece but I was more disturbed I mean I thought it was great that we have different views and I thought there was a couple of things they're not the person was sold on Peter of course before a funny line though but I thought there was some interesting points right there but to me the bigger concern was the Fairfax papers not I still call them not taking the ad that crock you want when they run Cli Palmerate so I found that oh yes sure I have in your opinion page a different view and I thought it was good to have a different view but I still have never heard the answer I don't know Peter has on one of the New York Times got all these other media organizations except in the ad about this but I don't yeah the New York Times and the camera times and it's important to mention the camera times both around that ad we had we're still not clear why Fairfax 9 didn't run the ad one viewpoint was oh well you know you're a subscription based news business therefore you're in competition with us which things a little bit over over reaching but you know perhaps as well you can think we're in competition with the city money here on the age from the AFR I think we are you know why not but anyway and the other ones we don't want to piss off the medals yeah well take it take it take it that's an interesting thing and I was thinking when I read ships piece just in the back my mind you know is the duopoly that we have in this country now just a little bit too cozy having said that I did think he made a couple of points we should talk about and one of them was that you know he made the point that you know bashing the Murdoch's good business for krikey is that true and how in your mind what krikey does is different to the Australian going after the ABC that's a great question I mean point one question the first part your question is you know krikey has throughout its 22 year history offered robust commentary on all parts of the media we are pretty robust about the agency at times with robust about nine facts and yes we're very robust about Murdoch but then why wouldn't we I mean we you know I mean we need to call this stuff out I mean the position of power and influence of Murdoch media in this country is what has everyone ever in this thing with no I mean it's obviously a matter of public debate so we should have robust commentary about that I only have various viewpoints in krikey about all sorts of media so I don't resolve for that for one second this sort of sort of thing that's been put around that we're attacking the Murdochs just because for a subscription drive is not true and we are attacking we are in this case because of free speech the fact that people have sought to you know support us by taking a suspicion that's great the fact that we've raised you know over four to thousand dollars in our go-fummy campaign is fantastic I thank everyone for that but the heart of this is about free speech so that's where we're coming from are we the same as the news going after the ABC no I don't think so because clearly the new news called particularly Australian and I know there've been plenty of studies about this I mean they were kind of obsessed with the ABC I mean they're obsessed with the ABC because the Murdochs going again back to Keith Murdoch I've had a long agenda for multi-generational hatred of public broadcasting because of course the ABC is a massive competitor to for the eyeballs of news book so it's a commercial decision as well as anything else so I don't think you can apply the same you know we're not seeking to offer robust critique of the ais or any of the other news book properties because we think they should be in the market I mean I have said many many times that there needs to be greater diversity on our media market not less I'd be a very sad day if you know we lost you know the joys of sky I just want to pick up on that though while I'm supporting free speech and what you're doing it very bold brave old words I was slightly worried that and good on you getting more subscriptions or we all want that I've been a contributor to cracky very pre-contributor over the years but I had started to get a bit worried that I was just every day I got my cracky daily that maybe we're becoming a little obsessed on this little bit of thing there were an awful lot of stories and I just I'm pleased to see you're getting back to your good broader political and business journalism and whatever because we wouldn't want it to look like you would be coming a little obsessed no I mean to be honest to be honest I'm so tired when some of the other moment is attacking you he's friend and said it with my mind every day you know that's just understandable and when we decided to take the take off an arm obviously we were gonna write a lot about it I don't I know it's often that I thought one second but yes no I agree thank you for saying that we are look I think you know we try to be we try to upset all sides really because isn't that the job of journalism you know we I make again I think no we upset you know if you read today's cracky there's probably a pretty robust piece about the greens probably the leader of today's cracky and which might upset some people who think we are we are kind of partisan green left conspiracy which we're not let's return to a point that Janine made earlier and it's the last one I want to discuss about the grounds piece he said Bernacane wasn't doing investigative journalism he was basically the offending article was opinion what do you the two of you say to that and you know is that distinction pivotal perhaps to the defense but this is in the public interest if I could go first on that I'm not gonna litigate on this radio show or defense so I would make the point and I thought it was a very curious thing for Chip to write what it suggested to me was that there's a kind of hierarchy of journalists that journalism that deserve legal protection now I am an enormous supporter and have been all throughout my career of domestic journalism it is a remarkably important and difficult thing to do full stop but the idea that just because Bernac's piece was some sort of analysis and it didn't deserve the same sort of legal protections as I think you've used the BRS case as an example this seems to be rather absurd I don't think quite understand that to be honest Janine can opinion be in the public interest of course I can if we don't have opinion you get a different opinion different opinion you get an echo chamber the danger it's obvious that for the interests of good democracy you need a robust and diverse opinion again I don't want to prosecute the cracky case because but I do think what Chip LaGrat I mean that bit of a chip maybe on the nine Fairfax shoulders on it but the point that this ludicrous and this comes back to the defamation has been Robert Smith case that there has been this will be a record mistake $25 million spent on this now it's obviously that's investigative journalism but it's a much bigger story about how much who has the pockets to that even craic taken a lot of obviously this is the important issue and I can see why not it's a bit sensitive about it a deal focused on Kate McQuine on to two of our greatest investigative journalists they're very dear friends of mine I see day in day out the toll it takes on them to do those stories the backing they need for it so while all journalism is good journalism we shouldn't start trying to fight each other within each other I do understand a bit when the nine newspapers are coming from I mean the head of the Thomas one great but day in day out Nick McKenzie Kate McQuine to Dell just doing such vital work and they have to fight these ridiculous defamation laws which may be crickety will be the first to test them but I'm just not sure and I think that most people who I'm there when people come up on the street and congratulate Kate and thank her for what she's doing she saved tax pay as money but I don't think they realize what goes on behind the scenes and these these tweaks to defamation law I hope they work but it doesn't stop good journalists having to spend most of their time talking with lawyers over frivolous and bullying and threats from other people you don't see not as high-profile as a murder and that disturbs me. Well, the crickety has a go-fund me to raise money for the coming legal battle. Peter have you been amazed by the level of support shown so far?
Oh yeah no I think we're up to about 440k this morning. Fantastic I mean and you know I know there's been a few high-profile people like Mark and Kevin Rudd have put in serious money but every dollar every dollar I mean you know some people putting in five bucks some you know ten bucks they still think so I think we've hit a nerve here I think look Kevin Rudd's petition for a real commission to have 500,000 signatures so it's clearly a lot of people in this country are concerned about the murder of influence so we've hit you know and I think everyone has done that we estimate we need our go-firmary target is three million so we are way to go yet. And look on that number Bernard Keene on Forf Estate just two weeks ago said that for small media organizations one large information case is an existential threat. Peter is quite going to disappear if you lose.
No crackling will definitely not disappear if you lose. I mean I'm without fear of contradiction I'm sure the crackling will be here after we've gone through the machinations of this case. And look we spend a lot of time on Forf Estate talking about media concentration in this country but it does seem interesting that the ABC News 9 those big organizations can afford to take on a big defamation case without passing around the bucket. For small media organizations we have a fundamental problem in this country don't we?
Oh absolutely no absolutely and look this is not breaking news but our defamation laws are more often than not used by rich people to suppress information about them and to suppress free debate. I mean it's not breaking news but there is something fundamentally wrong because the law should be open to everyone and the laws of defamation should encourage support robust debate no matter how big you are and yes it's not right that access to defamation laws you know skews towards media organizations is completely not right. Okay look we're media show and you two work in the news of course we're going to complain about defamation laws and want more and more reforms and I know that Peter Grestor is arguing strongly for more reforms but let's also look the other side of the coin the Daily Mail just got hit overhead for what to my mind was some pretty poor work even if even if we can argue that the case probably shouldn't have happened you've got Ad Friendly Jordi's the Daily Telegraph's Rush case to the list if you're looking from the outside the case for reform is a pretty shaky one. Oh no I just pick you up on that.
When I say we need defamation reform that's not an excuse for bad journalism I mean there has to be rules of course there are rules not saying they should rules it should be a free for all and if journalism gets it wrong which it does from time to time then you know so be it what I'm saying is that we need to be always conscious that the rules are serving interests of the public. And your name would do you agree with that? Yeah I mean as I said at the outset I actually believe the greatest threat to free speech here is defamation laws and I've been saying that for years I'm not you know I'm hopeful that small changes in there but the fact is people complain about the concentration of media but you've just summed up the problem small outlet cuts of the hype because of our defamation laws it doesn't matter if you broke up news talk tomorrow and sold it off to all these wonderful independent groups as craggy showing if you still have rich people wealthy people who can sue you know they don't even have to win I mean it's a war of attrition in many cases it's the threats as I talked about and even those big companies find it difficult so it is a problem and I know as I say bad journalism is bad journalism I don't want to pick out any particular cases but when journalists start saying journalists when politicians I mean you talked about Rupert never super Rockland does there was a time politicians didn't sue I mean we've had Peter Costello years ago we had the Joe hockey case we've had Peter John Baralaro for goodness sake and you know let's not forget that he'd be originally won a defamation suit against Kate McQuine which was paid out years later when it changes there's nothing you can do when journalists proved right the Ben Roberts Smith case I find extraordinary that the defamation case went ahead when there is a concurrent brere to report on the same issue so we might have an issue where he wins the defamation case and then we see other cases come out of it there is something fundamentally wrong with the system there and I don't want to have to wait 10 years to find out we're right but media organizations have been absolutely emasculated in me time okay we've talked about what happens to Crockett losers Peter what happens if you win what does it mean for Crockett and for the Australian media well if we win we'll go to lunch and if we win we will hopefully I've made what we would have made you know a firm stand in favor of free speech you know I still go back to my original point we should in this country be able to debate these sorts of things in a robust way that's the fundamental point we're trying to argue about here and that's why we're taking you know the sound we've taken so if we win it'll be a great day it won't be the end of this debate I'm sure I mean like you know the sky the clouds are not going to part and it'll be sunny days and in journalism and defamation forever more but we will have made a you know a blow for free speech that's for sure and to know how would you view victory will have any lasting impact well I've been relieved to hear that Crockett will exist either way so but hopefully it will exist in a healthier form if they will be wrong thing so this journalist maybe more money but journalist be employed and that's a good thing but for the broader argument I do sometimes wonder what will it mean will it really change I'm more of a cynic perhaps I mean I don't know how much it will change I'd be interested to read the ruling and see whether the new deformation laws hold up and give us cause for hope for change in the way here one thing I just add to that is already there's been a positive evidence which is that we and a lot of media around the world are talking about Australia's defamation laws that can only be a good thing well finally do you think people in America are watching this guys closely and when I say people I don't mean the writers of succession well they should be watching you for the right of the situation but yes absolutely well I mean we've had remarkable coverage in the United States it's hard to actually list a major and minor media organization that we haven't had a you know be mentioned so there's a lot of interest in this case I mean there's a parallel case happening as your as your listeners might know which involves the voting machine companies that Fox News claimed you know we're responsible for a stealing election from Donald Trump and in the courts in Delaware two of the voting machine companies are taking actions against Fox News for very large amounts of sums billions of dollars have been bended around there so I think you know that that context is given an added so pickency to what we're doing down here on that note I'd like to thank Craigies Peter Fray and Janine Parrot thank you and thanks for listening to the program this edition was recorded at the studios of tourist ER and heard across the country on the community radio network for the state is produced with the assistance of the community broadcasting foundation thanks to the foundation for their continuing support make sure you subscribe to for the state on your favorite podcast app so you can hear us talk media and politics and a lot in between we'll be back with more next week but in the meantime you can stay in touch with us on Twitter our handle with for the state are you thanks to my producer Marlene even I'm Anthony Topple thanks for listening