Skip to content
Criminalising journalism in Australia episode artwork

May 10, 2018 31 min

Criminalising journalism in Australia

from Fourth Estate Hosted by 2SER

The 2018 budget will bring $84 million worth of cuts to the ABC over three years. So is this a big deal for the national broadcaster? Plus the draft law that could see Australian journalists locked up for 20 years, just for doing their job. And the sex column in a college paper that ventured into the realm of academic advice and rubbed some people the wrong way. Andrew Fowler ( Author and ex ABC), Katrina Strickland (Good Weekend) and Kylar Loussikian (Daily Telegraph) discuss all these issues and more with host, Peter Fray. This episode was produced by Ninah Kopel in the studios of 2SER 107.3 in Sydney and is broadcast across the Community Radio Network in Australia.

Episode details come from the podcast's RSS feed.

Embed this episode

Ready to play

Criminalising journalism in Australia

0:00 31:30
of matches

Transcript Auto-generated, may contain errors

Hello and welcome, you're listening to Fourth Estate, the show where journalists talk about journalism, coming to you from 2SCR in Sydney on Gadigal lands of the E-Orination right across Australia on the community radio network and directly to your device across the globe via podcast. My name is Peter Frey, and this show is produced by the Inesible of Nina Copel, a picture of health and vitality keeping the show on the level, trust me. Coming up, the ABC loses $84 million in this year's budget, the Australian Law that could criminalise journalism, and the study advice in a college paper that sparked outrage. All that and more.

Joining me in the studio tonight is Andrew Fowler, ex-ABC Ambassador, Generalist and author of the most excellent shooting the messenger criminalising journalism, Hello Andrew. Hello Peter. Katrina Strickland, the editor of Good Weekend and a woman of many, many talents, Hello Katrina. Hi Peter.

And on the line from Canberra's Kylo Lissickian, National Political Reporter at the wonderful Daily Telegraph. Hi Kylo. Hi Peter. The Miss Talk of Tax Reform and Perks for Pensioners, Last Night's Budget brought some bad news for the National Public Broadcasting.

The government will freeze indexation of the ABC from July 2019, which will cost the broadcaster $84 million over three years. This comes at a challenging time for the ABC, which is already facing cumulative cuts worth $254 million that have imposed since 2014. For a bit of background, I called up for a coffee with Professor Ed Davis, President of the New South Wales Chapter, or the Friends of the ABC. To begin with, I asked him whether he was surprised by the cuts.

I'm not sure that I was very surprised, but I was disappointed, appalled and angry with the cut. Is it too early to fully understand? Or do you have an early understanding of what the cuts will mean? The ABC has had its funding cut now for 30 years.

So it's something like a third of its real levels 30 years ago. It looks a bit held together by a bit of a last surplus. I guess Ed would say that, but nonetheless, what are we seeing here? More evidence that the coalition government doesn't like the ABC and wants to keep the broadcaster on ever tightening leash.

Or is the ABC being told to tighten its belts and be more careful with taxpayers' money? What do you think Kylo? Well, I think the professor needs to go up to the ABC's Canberra Bureau, because it doesn't seem to be at all held together by Stiggy Tate. There are more journalists there than probably in the entire news court than Fairfax Office has combined.

So I saw the news yesterday, of course, in the budget. And then we had all of these people come out and say the end of the world almost, or actually I think it was one of the union groups, basically said, well, if we keep going under the ABC, we'll no longer exist. Which is, with what evidence? Absolutely none.

It appears to be some tightening of the belt. Over the same course, at the same period of time, the ABC is going to get some three or $1 billion in public money. And that's fine. I think absolutely support making sure that the ABC is well resourced.

But, you know, carving off $80 million or so. I don't think it's that big a deal. There was another general professor on the internet called it Financial Terrorism. Who are these people?

So you don't go and subscribe to the idea that the coalition government has it in for the ABC? Well, we've got it into the ABC, they're not doing a particularly good job of going after them. Okay, fair point. That's kind of small amount of money from the ABC budget, which is enormous, already, they're pretty well resourced.

And, you know, if you can't probably man a newsroom on $3 billion, then what hope to the rest of the media out there? Well, that's an interesting point of view. I'm going to throw to Andrew a minute. But already there was talk that news gathering resources and suburban news bureaus in Jelong, Ipswich, Gosswah, Parramatta, maybe the ABC investigations team, the Specials reporting team and the RMIT, ABC fact check unit, will all of those things be hit.

Andrew, I'm assuming you wouldn't, as an xABC person, you wouldn't necessarily agree with Kyle's point of view? Well, I actually don't. I mean, I think the math is a little difficult too, because you say 3 billion, that's fine for 3 years, but it's 1 billion a year, and going so fast. And as looking for the cut for 3 years, people are throwing around this $80 million figure, like next year they're going to lose $80 million, which is just not true.

Well, I'm not throwing it. You might put it in the context, $3 million in the right number. Well, I'm not talking about 3 years, I'm talking about 1 years. Let's take one year at a time.

Let's take one year at a time. Anyway, I think comparing the ABC and its national coverage to the Daily Telegraph and the way that the Daily Telegraph operates is rather sort of spurious comparison. Because if you look at what the ABC does, it calls podcasts, it does television, it does radio, it covers country towns, it covers major metropolitan areas, and so consequently, yes, there are a lot of journalists working there, but a lot fewer now as the years go by. But what about this idea that the ABC, you know, it's funded by the taxpayers, and you know, we live in straight and times, we all know that, and the government is trying to reduce the size of government overall.

Why shouldn't it share somewhere else? Andrew, I think it has to share some of those birds over the years now. I mean, the figures quoted before by the Friends of the ABC show, the slide and the amount of money coming into the ABC. I worked there for about 20 years, and I'll tell you what, you worked very, very hard at the ABC.

I also worked at News Limited. I know how hard you worked there as well. What I really find quite disturbing is journalists attacking other journalists. I find that particularly a problem when we're all in this together, trying to bring out the truth and trying to bring out and expose things to the best interests of the Australian public.

So to have news corporation attacking the ABC, the way it does, day in, day out, day in, day out, I find that to be a little disconcerting. Okay, that's an interesting point of view. I mean, I'm going to go to the umpire then maybe, Katrina, with the Fairfax House. So we all use the ABC.

It's a national institution. I would hazard to say that the country would be poorer without it. But do you putting these cuts into context? Do you think these are a problem?

Is it a sort of thin end of the wedge? Is it evidence that the likes of Mitch Feifield? And possibly other people like, for instance, Peter Dunne really have it in for the ABC? Well, I think it's almost normalised that the ABC gets cut in a budget, isn't it?

Like so, in some respects, it would be more surprising if they got an increase. That's why you would be or not a cut. I haven't worked at the ABC, so I don't know actually how much fat there is to cut or not. But I don't think it's good when cultural institutions like ABC get cut and I find it, I do think there's an ideological component.

I mean, the Liberal government has long been talking about how it doesn't like the ABC aspects of it, to think it's left leaning and things. So I don't think you can say it's just about tightening given how often it happens. Tyler, on that point, you're a keen observer of camera. So you live there, you eat and breathe it.

Is this a ideological thing? Just to get closer to the idea? In terms of the funding, I mean, obviously an ideology difference between, well, disagreeing, I guess, what some of the senior government ministers think of the ABC coverage. I really, I think they make those comments.

But that's for them. I mean, the point I was trying to make, and no point did I ever compare the ABC to Daily Telegraph, the point I was trying to make is that when people, I think there is a disproportionate level of outrage at what is, you know, unfortunate, sure, enormous, probably not, you know, when it's happened by everyone, because it's the end of the world, but somehow the ABC is going to end, or, you know, financial terrorism or some garbage like that. Really, there's a lot more stuff in the budget you could be outraged about if you want it. You sure, I mean, I agree with the, I mean, the over-egging of stories and the end of the world is nine or rest of it.

I think the problem is it's just the never-ending, clobbering the ABC gets from your organisation and also from the government. And you seem to be in lockstep on this. I mean, to just say, for example, you think that public broadcasting has a place in the cultural world of Australia, would be a good thing for the Australian, particularly the Australian, maybe in the Telegraph as well, to come out and say and to defend the right of journalists to be employed by a public broadcaster, not to totally denigrate them. And that's the real problem, rather than the cash.

I mean, believe me, there isn't that much there, and I did work there on pretty reasonable wages, but when you're as high as the ones with paper and news Corp. So I think that you've got to bear that in mind as well. When you, as fellow journalists, we deal with this issue. We're all in this together.

And, you know, with editorial line of a newspaper, I think journalists should try and stand apart from that. Well, can I throw something at you just before we move on to another scintillating subject? And that is the under Michelle Guthrie, she had a very different tone and has tried to deal with the government in a very different way. And one of the things that was recently called our I, of course, was the handing back of the Cabinet Files, the big leak.

I mean, do you think this is shows that Michelle Guthrie is sort of way of handling government relations needs to change? I think for the government, it's a perfect way for the ABC to handle a cache of Cabinet documents, which would give the Australian public a view of how Cabinet actually operates. Going to the central question about Michelle Guthrie, I think she's way out of a league, way out of a depth. She has no understanding of the way that a leading a public broadcaster should be carried out.

And I think this lack of editorial leadership, and she is the editor-in-chief, is actually a major problem for the ABC. I think going down the line, there are other problems as well in senior management where they don't take journalistic leads. Can you imagine the daily telegraph or the Australian having a trove of Cabinet documents and not producing hundreds of stories about them? I can't imagine that ever happening.

So do you see that as a failure of journalism, then? I see it as a failure of journalism, sure. And do you feel that that's a failure that starts with the editor-in-chief? I quote, if you're asking a leading question, I must say, you put it so well.

I think it does start with the head of the ABC. Sure. I mean, I think that's the position. It was a position.

I think Brian Johns became the editor-in-chief, and with all the attendant problems you have with that flowing through the organization, she is the editor-in-chief. And as a big problem, if she's calling the editorial shots, they are really missing the target. So finally, Katrina, who would want to be an editor-in-chief of the ABC? Is this a job you'd ever aspire to?

No, because you're always going to be attacked. And I think you're always going to have the government attacking you. You're going to have everyone saying, you know, you're doing this wrong, you're doing that wrong. No, I wouldn't want that job.

OK. Well, you're listening to the Fourth Estate. You're with me, Peter Frey, and I'm speaking with Andrew Fowler, the Ambassador-Generalist, an author of Shooting the Messenger, Criminalizing Journalism, Katrina Strickland, the editor of Good Weekend, and on the line from Cameron Carla Sooken, who part from working for the Daily Telegraph was the initial presenter of this very show. If you want to hear more of my chat with Professor Ed Davis, check out our podcast.

It's there for you to take a list to whenever you like. The media entertainment and the Netherlands, the M.E.W.A., has released this report into the state of press freedom in Australia. The Journal's union is particularly concerned about draft laws on national security and interference. The M.E.W.A.

is calling these bills and appalling new assault on press freedom and says that if introduced, they can see journalists locked up for 20 years just for doing their job. Andrew, your book is looking at this very issue, the criminalization of journalism. Are these very dark days in terms of press freedom? They are indeed.

Very dark days in terms of press freedom in Australia, particularly if you're looking at what really matters in the heart of government, which are decisions about war and peace and our strategic interface with other countries. They make it very difficult for a journalist to carry out the function of revealing what governments are really doing, as opposed to sometimes the outright lies they tell the population. What this new draft of laws does is to make it a criminal offence if these laws are passed to even have carried or no information, which the government has determined is not in the best interest for it to be revealed. This is the very antithesis of what the media should be doing.

This is why we're here, in large part, to keep them honest and report fairly and freely. That's why they have an army of public relations people in the attempt to persuade us to better the truth. They're telling the truth. What we ask is of course the transparency and information will be revealed to us.

That's virtually impossible, particularly with the government we have in Australia at the moment. This is one of the most repressive places to be as a journalist. There is no real defence for revealing the truth in this country. If these laws go through, it will be even worse if it's possible to be.

Since 9-11, 54 separate pieces of anti-terrorism and surveillance legislation have passed through this parliament more than any other member of the Western Alliance. The real squeeze is on not to actually protect us from terrorism, but to protect the government from exposure. This is a remarkable state of affairs. Before I return to that, I'd like to ask Katrina and Carter to reflect on this.

It seems to me that we have a high level of tolerance to what we're talking about here. We, journalism as a profession, but also citizens broadly, seem to be a septingness. How would you rate Katrina our press freedom on a scale of 1-10, being very bad and 1-8? What I would say, perhaps not to answer that question but to say something different to that, is that it's interesting that most journalists in what they're doing, this doesn't affect them because they're covering all sorts of areas and it's more the PR overrun that's the real problem.

But it's the ones who are working in this area that are doing the really great investigative work that is uncovering the things that are very important and they're the ones that you want to protect. So I can see why journalists, perhaps most working journalists, aren't really perhaps even across the detail of these laws because they don't apply to their own work, but they apply to the pointy end which really matters more than what most of us do. Can I suggest to you that maybe as time we all got a bit further? Yeah, I think we're not that engaged.

Most people in journalism these days are so overworked that they're paying attention to what they need to pay attention to in their little area and perhaps not. I mean, I can't speak for everyone, but I think we're not all across these things because they apply to a very certain small group of journalists who are doing perhaps the most important work of any of us. I don't think I can anticipate a future cover story of the weekend about this. Perhaps Andrew could...

Oh, look, we're doing business on air. Special rights. Karla, you're close to that pointy end. Do you feel that your freedoms are impinged and what do you think about these new laws?

I'm not surprised by the pointy end, I really am at all. But the new laws, I mean, the government has watered them down until we took a swipe at them, I think on the front page of the photograph we had a photo of Turnbull, almost as a communist or something like that, a Stalinist. But it has been watered down. I think they're somewhat unfortunate that they might get journalists.

I don't think that's the intention of them. I think it's particularly incredible and stupid thing to say about Australia somehow, one of the most repressive places in the world for journalism. I mean, that's just the fact that I... Andrew, to back that up.

Andrew, the right of reply for you. I mean, the thing is, I think the worst few bits are rather clumsy words to use, I'm sure you didn't mean to say that. But I think the problem you have in Australia is we're not protected by, as they are in the United States, by the First Amendment, which guarantees freedom of publication. And in the European Union and in the UK is part of that as well at the moment, journalists are protected.

Sources are protected by the European Human Rights Act. And so there's a protection there, which we don't have because we still operate under the old UK law, which basically gives no protection or no protection for journalists to protect their sources, and no protection from being possibly jailed for, revealing information that's not that the government thinks is not in the public interest. So that's why I say it's quite repressive, and it is quite a repressive... How many journalists have been jailed recently?

The point I'm making, the point I'm making, is simply that the stories cannot be told because people are very often too careful, too terrified, too rightly concerned that if they do step too close to the Crimes Act, they will end up in charge. So perhaps to Andrew's point, Carla, I'll just go back to that MEAA survey, which found that 72% of the public rate of the health of the press freedom in Australia's poor or very poor, compared with only 60% of journalists said the same, even though 90% of the thought press freedom had worsened in the past decade. So are we trying to be overly optimistic? And are we perhaps comparing ourselves when we talk about press freedom with overtly repressive regimes, whereas I think Andrew is talking about in the book, is something a little bit more nuanced and subtle than that?

What do you think about that, Carla? Well, I mean, it was put in that way, I think that's probably more correct. But I think there are many things that get in the way of proper functioning of the press in terms of getting stories, also this idea that the government is coming for us and I want to make sure that we can't hold them to account. I mean, I think for instance, defamation laws are just completely out of whack.

Or another thing, you know, FOI laws are basically laughable. There is no real actual freedom of information. They block them on the most spurious reasons whatsoever. I mean, they're actually tactical.

Well, it is, but it's also true that we can get away, rather than this idea that the government just want to lock us up if we've got a story to tell that they don't like. But it is true, and Andrew can talk about this better than I expect, but it is true that, for instance, your phone could be being tapped right now and you wouldn't even know about it under these new laws. Is that right, Andrew? Yeah, that's right.

I mean, under ASIO could have what they call a journalist warrant to them, the right to intercept phone calls. And in fact, the Director of ASIO was questioned about this in Parliament and declined to actually say how many journalists warrants there were out at the moment. So these are warrants to actually tap the phones of journalists, and the United States, you can't do that, and in the UK, it's with great difficulty that you do it. Here it seems to be the AG signs, so many general signs often in ASIO can do it.

That's the danger. I mean, this is the problem. It's like it's not how do you prove that you're in that much danger until it actually happens. There's such an increase in the number of laws passed, and such as against a backdrop that you quite rightly point out, the FOI system is broken.

I'm not just in this country, but also certainly in the United States and also in the UK. And also the defamation laws here are absolutely appalling, as you know, in the United States, because of the First Amendment, Trump is talking of introducing or hardening up some of the state's defamation laws. So the screws are really coming on. I mean, when Trump says that the media is the enemy of the American people, and Peter Dutton talks about being dead for Fairfax and the ABC.

I mean, these are really interesting words to look at when you look at what's happening in the world of journalism that we inhabit. Okay, so we haven't seen Malcolm Turnbull or Bill Shorten say that we are the enemy of the state. But I do want to finish Katrina on another and perhaps broader point, which is, Maury Schwartz gave the Brian John's, the fourth annual Brian John's lecture this week, and his subject was slow news, thinking in public. Among the many things he said, it was an excellent speech, and one of the many things he said was, I quote, we seem to be sliding into illiberalism without panic.

The government should protect democracy as much as the media does. Do you agree with that statement? So what does he mean by that? He doesn't even hear the whole speech.

So what's his point? His point is that the media generally seeks to speak up about press freedom and make a point of this, whereas really, if you think about a function democracy, it should be one of the primary functions of the government of the day, no matter what colour to support, you know, pluralism, media diversity and transparency and accountability. So we're speaking up ourselves rather than the government speaking up. And I think it goes to this other point, which is that Australia has a high tolerance maybe of illiberalism, and we may be sliding into this kind of slightly illiberal sort of state, without we don't really know it.

I think that's true, but I think that's a global thing. I mean, the whole Cambridge Analytica thing shows that it doesn't. There's a lot of ways in which we just are kind of fine with things happening that actually when it's pointed out to us, we're not really fine with it at all. But until it goes back to that point I made before, until it impacts us directly, we seem to be kind of not turning our minds to it.

And I think that is a problem, but as Andrew said, you need to know what the outcome of the problem is to then be upset about it. And if people aren't really... Well, that goes to a final point maybe in this extended video of Katrina is what should we be doing that we're not doing? Because if we are sliding into this illiberal state and we are displaying a high level tolerance, maybe we have to stop the rot.

Maybe we get a bit more vocal. For a second, we obviously have to buy Andrew from his book, but apart from that... But you need to know, don't you? You need to have it pointed out to you.

I'm just going back to Cambridge Analytica. Everyone who did all those surveys on Facebook and things, everyone kind of knew they were giving away data. But until all of that came out, no one really knew the extent of it. And then, of course, when everyone realized their report, but we kind of knew and decided we didn't care in a way, didn't we?

Or maybe we can't. But yeah, that's right. So I think it's about it being really brought home by an example in a way that then, you know, same with the whole Me2. Like we've all known that all that's been going on for a long time.

But when there's specific cases that are highlighted and brought to the fore, then everyone decides it's terrible, but it was always terrible. And we always kind of knew it was going on and that there were sleazy guys around. Very good point. Very good point.

You'll listen to Fourth Estate. You're with me, Peter Frey. And I'm speaking with Carlos O'Kill from National Political Reporter, at the Daily Telegraph from Canberra. The author of Shooting the Messenger Criminalizing the Journal.

A student journalist in Texas has sparked controversy with a sex column that ventured into the realm of academic advice. The message of the story, which was headlined, finals aren't the only thing going down, explored the way sex could be used as a stress reliever during challenging assessment periods. The cartoons included in the article offered a visual aid to students who wish to attend summary relaxation strategies of their own. But these images seem to rub certain individuals in the university up the wrong way.

Kyla, you have had some extensive experience as an editor of Student Media. Would you publish something like this in a campus publication? Yeah, why not? Well, why not?

Well, I would have written something particularly offensive. I mean, I think we published a 100 cent garden, how to turn a student newspaper into an origami painter. I missed that edition. That would have been something else.

You're still going to copy that. Can you send me a copy? Oh, absolutely. Well, I think we should republish that.

But then just to help us understand what caused all the outrage, the illustrations that went with the column included various boils of the story. And various boy on boy, girl on girl, kind of a pharmaceutical like positions, which maybe that's only in the United States. But I do detect Katrina, a slight error of this puritanical nature creeping into this fair land. What do you think about that?

The sex game I've been talking about? Just on this one, I think it's absolutely ridiculous. If you can't do that kind of stuff in student newspaper, we're on Earth. Can you do it?

But yeah, I think the Shong-Song dress incident in the US recently was a bit similar where the girl bought it for a prom and then social media went berserk on how she was appropriating someone else's culture. I think it's kind of a social media problem, isn't it? The people can complain. They always have been able to complain or dislike something.

But now they kind of get validity because they can do it publicly and then everyone turns it into a big issue. But it's a complaint non-issue. And yeah, I think there is a puritanic word creeping in everywhere. Andrew, well, this could be interpreted as a way of the student editor just making a name for himself.

What do you think about that? It's a smart strategy. Absolutely nothing beats being banned. If you can be banned and then be published, you've got it made.

And that's what he's done. He's made a name for himself. He's been read around the world. He's been read here.

Circulation must be up. Going to the central question about about sex and student politics. Well, we've just heard him in student politics and sex kind of go together almost inseparable. I would have thought he'd be pretty happy with the outcome.

He's actually got his name up there as a magazine. He's won the argument. I mean, if you go back to 1970, school kids are in the UK. There was an obscenity trial involving Richard Neville, a famous Australian.

And Jeffrey Robertson was number two in the Barris list and he was up there. And they fought this thing out. And they actually lost the case. But eventually I think they won on appeal when it was.

But it was a huge argument, much the same about this, like this, where you had, apparently, they scored a school kids' all issue where they had naked women. So it was like school kids and naked women. That was a no-no. So we come along way, but apparently not in Texas.

Not in Texas. And finally, what happened to your penis or a gownie thing, Carly? Did that get you banned? No, I didn't.

I don't get one read it to be perfectly honest. No, it wasn't the start of your brilliant career then. No, unfortunately not. I can't recall actually the other one.

We were kind of taken off the shelves for a few things. But I think that would mainly be because we write Nazi stories about the student union and the student union magazine. I can't think that was anything smart, unfortunately. Just a cursory question.

Did you write Nazi things about the ABC? No, I don't think so. Not a university anyway. No, that's right.

That came later in life. Thank you all. You've all been listening to The Fourth Estate with me, Peter Frey. I'd like to thank our guest this evening, Andrew Fowler, the author shooting the messenger criminalising journalism.

Thank you, Andrew. Katrina Strickland, the editor of Gubee, and Kylo Sickin, who's broken from the busy life of a camera reporter. He's from the Danny Telegraph, and he's also the original presenter of this fine show. Thank you, Kylo.

Thank you all for being on the show, and I'd like to put out a special mention to my producer, Nina Cappel. And until next time, thanks for listening. Safer Ontario means more police and prosecutors making sure my card doesn't get stolen. It means building new jails that keep criminals behind bars.

And it means there's no need to worry when I play at the park. We're making every corner of Ontario safer to make all of Ontario safer. That's how we protect Ontario. For all of us.

Learn how at ontario.ca.ca. Pay for it by the Government of Ontario.

Frequently asked questions

How long is this episode of Fourth Estate?

This episode is 31 minutes long.

When was this Fourth Estate episode published?

This episode was published on May 10, 2018.

Is there a transcript available for this episode?

Yes, a full transcript is available for this episode. You can read the complete transcript on the episode page.

Can I download this Fourth Estate episode?

Yes. Use the download control on the episode player to save the publisher-provided media file.