Skip to content
▓▒░ Cropsey was real. Willowbrook part 2. episode artwork

May 26, 2026 52 min

▓▒░ Cropsey was real. Willowbrook part 2.

from TrueCrime.FM

Grab a coffee, or whatever your favorite true-crime drink might be, and let's get into the details of the Cropsey case. I've been digging into the details…let's listen. 📂 SUPPORT THE RESEARCH & UNLOCK MORE: Join the Coffee Tier for Early Access or the Beer Tier for Exclusive Extras. https://TrueCrime.fm/support ⚠️ Haven't watched Part 1 yet? Start there first — it's right before this one in your feed. You need that one first. Every kid on Staten Island grew up hearing about Cropsey — a disfigured man living in the tunnels under Willowbrook, who comes out at night to take children. Most people, rightly so, would just think this was a story. It wasn't.In Part 2, we get into what happened exactly and how this Cropsey horror story ended up being incredibly real for some people. Sources & Research Original reporting in the Staten Island Advance dating back to 1965, including coverage of Willowbrook, the Cropsey legend, and the Andre Rand trials. Additional sources: Cropsey (2009 documentary) — available on streaming Unforgotten: 25 Years After Willowbrook (1996) — tubitv.com/movies/438228 Geraldo Rivera's 1972 Willowbrook broadcast — archive.org/details/willowbrook-the-last-great-disgrace-geraldo-rivera-1972-documentary 🎙️ FIND TRUECRIME.FM HERE TOO: 🔔 YouTube: @TrueCrimeFM_Official 🎧 Podcast: https://TrueCrime.fm 📸 Instagram: instagram.com/TrueCrimefm 👥 Facebook: facebook.com/TrueCrimeFM #truecrime #truecrimedocumentary #murdermystery #interrogation #truecrimecommunity #truecrimefm

Episode details come from the podcast's RSS feed.

Embed this episode

Ready to play

▓▒░ Cropsey was real. Willowbrook part 2.

0:00 52:09

Chapters

  1. 0:00 Cropsey Was REal
  2. 3:31 The Cropsey History
  3. 8:09 Frank Ruchan
  4. 12:39 Frank Ruchan Arrested
  5. 13:29 Frank Ruchan becomes Andre Rand
  6. 15:12 Alice Periera
  7. 16:28 Back at Willowbrook
  8. 17:07 Shin Lee goes missing
  9. 17:38 Ethel Atwell goes missing
  10. 20:23 Holly Ann Hughes goes missing
  11. 21:53 Psychic brought in
  12. 23:02 A Stranger Loads a bus at a YMCA
  13. 24:41 Tiahease Jackson goes missing
  14. 28:43 Hank Gafforio goes missing
  15. 31:27 Jennifer Schweiger goes missing
  16. 33:38 Search for Jennifer
  17. 35:14 George Kramer finds Jennifer
  18. 36:31 Andre Rand arrested and campsites searched
  19. 38:07 The Rand Investigation
  20. 40:13 Rand goes to trial
  21. 43:16 Holly Ann
  22. 45:00 Holly Ann Brother
  23. 45:37 Andre Today

No transcript yet.

Requests help us decide what to transcribe next.

Frequently asked questions

How long is this episode of TrueCrime.FM?

This episode is 52 minutes long.

When was this TrueCrime.FM episode published?

This episode was published on May 26, 2026.

Can I download this TrueCrime.FM episode?

Yes. Use the download control on the episode player to save the publisher-provided media file.