Skip to content
Cruel To Be Kind episode artwork

Oct 5, 2024 14 min

Cruel To Be Kind

from The Daily Vedantic Hosted by James Beshara

In this episode of The Daily Vedantic, we dive into the powerful concept of "cruel to be kind," inspired by Shakespeare’s famous line from Hamlet. We explore the crucial difference between kindness and niceness, showing how tough conversations and temporary discomfort can lead to long-term growth, healing, and true generosity. Learn why real kindness sometimes requires making difficult choices that are uncomfortable in the short term but beneficial in the long run. The Daily Vedantic is a daily podcast and YouTube channel dedicated to the timeless wisdom of the Upanishads (https://thedailyvedantic.com/). Dating back to over 5,000 years ago, the source of nearly all Eastern Philosophy, and loved by Western giants from Emerson to Thoreau to Carl Jung and Alan Watts, studied daily by Joseph Campbell to Aldous Huxley to Arthur Schopenhauer and countless others, The Daily Vedantic aims to make this ancient philosophy as modern and accessible as it is simple, practical — and profound. James Beshara (https://www.twitter.com/jamesbeshara) is a renowned startup founder of multiple companies, a prolific startup investor in 200+ others including some of the biggest startup names on the planet, a husband and father of three little girls, and philosophy student and teacher in Los Angeles. James also co-hosts Yoga For Your Intellect (https://www.YFYI.co), a biweekly long-form conversational podcast with his teacher Joseph Emmett ( https://www.instagram.com/yogaforyourintellect ) James is a student of Swami Parthasarathy, the acclaimed author of Vedanta Treatise (Vedanta Treatise – The Eternities) and teacher at Vedanta Academy in Malavli, India. As James says often, when you’re ready for the real thing, Swami’s daily lectures are where the true wisdom and systematic discovery of the world’s oldest continually studied philosophy resides: https://www.vedantaworld.org

Episode details come from the podcast's RSS feed.

Embed this episode

Ready to play

Cruel To Be Kind

0:00 14:26
of matches

Transcript Auto-generated, may contain errors

Imagine what the world would look like and I'd be like, our lives would look like. People are truly kind to us if we were truly kind to others. All right, everybody, we back with another reflection on the daily Vedantic and today's reflection is on the timeless advice and reorientation around kindness, not niceness but kindness. This is a phrase that is somewhat controversial because we can fuse kindness with being nice all the time, pleasant, leaving nothing to be unpleasant in our attempt to be kind.

And yet this is one of the most famous phrases from Shakespeare, comes from Hamlet, and the same way speaking saying must be, grew only to be kind. This concept is so needed so often in the world we live in, not all the time every day but often, couple times a week, maybe need to have a hard conversation. I mean, you say something that isn't nice that it's unpleasant, that someone at work does not want to hear or a child. You know, it's going to result in a bit of unpleasant reaction from the recipient of whatever you have to say, but it is liberation on the other end.

For you for that relationship, it is growth. It's getting something off of your chest or it's just doing the right thing and it's unpleasant in the beginning, but it is so pleasant. It's so much better. Conditions have improved massively.

On the other side of that, unpleasant, and the other side of that is comfort. So what is this phrase saying? It is, to give an example. It's like a five-year-old.

That's bit by a wild animal, a dog in the street, and they need a shot to ensure that they don't develop rays and become stable. That example, you have the child protesting that crazy, please don't know more pain. You know pain is stricken by the bite, already bleeding, freaking out, and you know better. You know that they need the shot or they can die, or helpful vaccine.

That warms off, hey, potentially terminal disease, and it's as simple as taking a shot when the child is three, four, five, and same scenario they protest like crazy. But if our intellects and wisdom is the capacity to see the end in the beginning, then we recognize that momentary discomfort is absolutely critical for the comfort, safety security on the other side of it. That momentary discomfort is critical, not just helpful, but absolutely critical. There's a thing that the five-year-old ultimately wants, which is their health back, their safety back.

This cruel to be kind concept, it is a better pill to swallow for many of us, because we think we should never be cruel, we should never rock a boat. So many of us are people pleasers. And when we people please we're not thinking about the other people. We're thinking about ourselves.

When we choose to not have a hard conversation, we give critical and helpful feedback. We're not choosing the comfort for the other person, because wisdom is the capacity to see the end in the beginning. We actually know that, oh, if I don't say this, and they're going to run into a lot of discomfort in their life. If I don't do this, hard thing that that person or myself will be a lot of discomfort in the long run, it's an unwise lack of clarity, choosing momentary comfort for ourselves, and it's not for the other person.

People pleasers, such a misnomer. They're not choosing to please other people, they're choosing self-preservation and the midst of community or family, or parents or a friend group where they're just definitely afraid of being kicked out. I'm not getting that relationship. I'm not getting that affection or that sense of belonging, sense of security.

They're so afraid of it. So if you're a full losing it, that internally is just saying, I'm going to tell you what everyone here. I'm going to do whatever you want me to do, as long as in return that transaction, you're going to get sense of belonging. I'm not going to be, I'm not going to think critically on what is best for you, or what is best for this group of friends or this community.

No, no, no, I want to do and say all the pleasing things. So that I don't even have a semblance of being kicked out. That's how it just be too painful. So I'd rather use self-renewalment.

I mean, not telling you something that might be cruel to be kind. I might want you to self-renewalment, but not doing something. That might be my seam harsh in a moment. I'm going to do what I want to say those things at your detriment, before I'm not going to fit.

It is misguided and misinterpreted oftentimes by ourselves. And that's kindness. But it has the good to say, the right tool used in the wrong way becomes the wrong tool. That is a kindness, kindness.

It's an unselfish act. It's not for your benefit. It's for the other person's in fact, it might be to your detriment. And you willingly, voluntarily, go into that cave saying, all right, yeah, this is, I'm not going to fit for this.

So I'd set me back personally, but it's going to fit them. My brother, oldest brother, he's married at 26 and divorced at 31. When he got divorced, there's four of us, four boys. The three of us put each other in, like, man, I kind of do it.

She was not the right fit for it. We're not the right fit for each other. I never saw the attraction. It didn't seem like it was a natural fit or relationship.

Kind of felt forced. We said these things to each other as we processed the news that they were getting divorced. And realized we all knew that. The day he was getting married, we all knew that.

He's six months into the day. So fast forward, three years and a close friend of mine, one of my best friends from college, saving a girl for about four years. And I saw the same things. It's like, hey, what car this is?

Hey, my car in UN, Sarah, I don't think you all are. That's fit for each other. And just fit the bullet and have the conversation with him to say that out loud. Knowing that this is going to be quite dejecting.

And I don't think all of the best fit for each other could be dating on distance for two years now, dating in total for four. And I have a feeling it's, they're all going to kind of just slip into engagement because if you like that's an accept. And I want to say I don't think that's the right fit. I don't think no one you as well as I know you.

No one's Sarah pretty well. Don't think this is the right relationship for either of you. I gave him back story of my brother and he not saying something. And I'd be in a whole world of her because I didn't say something.

And I wanted to avoid that world of her before maybe a few weeks of her, maybe some volume to something that he already thought internally. He didn't talk me for a year. They did everything up six months after that and then six months later, he reached out to me saying that I was only friend willing to tell him that. And he thought about that over and over again and realized it was the truth and they were kind of just coasting out of comfort.

Not wanting to pull the band out off of something that they both knew. And after a year of being pretty angry and not talking to me. Don't know. It was the only friend to tell him that once they broke up with the other 10 of us were thinking as every friend jumped in with a text to our phone call saying yeah, things for the best I don't think you're the best way for each other.

I was totally fine with being in the dog house and this friendship for however long he took. She could have been for the rest of our lives to avoid the pain in the car wreck. And I saw a new from what you happen to our oldest brother concept of cruel to be kind. It's a helpful reorientation away from niceness and to true kindness to true generosity to giving not taking and reorientation on what kindness really is, which is to the other benefit, perhaps at your own detriment to give that is generosity not to preserve, not to hold on not to act out of fear.

To do what we ought to do not what we want to do. The entire world would be so much more harmonious if we did what we ought to do instead of what we want to do all the time. I think how better off you would be if everyone was truly kind to you. I always say what startups in the early stages, the band news is good news.

You want to chew that up, gobble up, more band news on where the product needs work or where the customers are still unmet by the product that's out there, how you're building, how you're designing it, how you're marketing it, the more band news early on, the better because band news later on is terrible news. But band news early on, that's good news. When we get this feedback on ourselves, when we get that shot, we can avoid that eternal disease, when we have that conversation that can help us avoid a world of hurt for a few weeks or a few months, if it feeling like harshness or cruelty, but ultimately ultimately being kindness, imagine what the world would look like and I would, our lives would look like. If people were truly kind to us, if we were truly kind to others, it might be chock full of discomfort here and there.

But as we say on the podcast, the more discomfort we can handle, the more comfort we are always in. That's just pure logic, the more discomfort that we can handle, the more comfort we're always in and, the more comfort we can provide those around us, giving them those shots that help them. Avoid those eternal diseases, but in a moment feeling like, oh, this is cruel, this is harsh. But then on the other side of it, you, those people, your relationships survive and thrive.

Instead of decay and die, quite the alarming contrast between confusing niceness and kindness. And that's today's reflection on the day of the Atlantic. We'll see you next time.

Frequently asked questions

How long is this episode of The Daily Vedantic?

This episode is 14 minutes long.

When was this The Daily Vedantic episode published?

This episode was published on October 5, 2024.

Can I download this The Daily Vedantic episode?

Yes. Use the download control on the episode player to save the publisher-provided media file.