Hello and welcome back to Fourth Estate, a show about journalism. We're coming to you from TUICR in Sydney on the Gadigal lands of the Eora nation, right across Australia on the community radio network and directly to your device across the globe via podcast. I'm Tina Quinn and it's always a pleasure to have your company. Well, hold on to your data.
The big news this week is the security breach at Optus. Last week it was revealed that the personal information of many present and former customers of the major telecommunication company have been compromised. The Minister for Cybersecurity Clara Neal told the ABCs 730 that 9.8 million Australians may have had basic personal information stolen, while 2.8 million may have had extensive personal information accessed, such as their passport details or driver's license. Sadly, it's not the first breach and it won't be the last.
According to the Australian Cybersecurity Centre, an essential service or critical infrastructure is attacked every 32 minutes. So in light of this, we ask what role the journalists have in reporting on cyber attacks and data security. To discuss this and more, I'm joined by Johnny Blackley, formerly of SBS and now an investigative journalist for Choice, Australia's leading consumer advocacy group. Johnny, a warm welcome to Fort The State.
Nick Bonnhardy also joins us. He's the technology editor of the Sydney Morning Herald and the age. Nick, welcome to Fort The State. Yeah, thanks for having me on.
And Amber Schultz, she's an associate editor and investigative journalist for Cranky. And welcome back to Fort The State. Hey Tina. Alright, well, let's jump right in.
The Optus data breach has affected millions of Australians. Nick, were you surprised about how the story has unfolded as we've continued to find out more and more? It's the nature of how quite the information doesn't come out immediately. It takes time to pay for two investigations and that's in to know I haven't been surprised at the pace of information, but does seem like Optus was initially very forthcoming in the first days and had a wide range in media conference with the CEO answer questions briefly and at length.
The communication strategy does seem to have changed in later days to be able to multiply it. Johnny, any surprises for you? I think the prize is to be an optimist. Yeah, a response, as Nick mentioned.
I think particularly in the last couple of days and this week, it's being very amateurish to me. The interviews that they corporate business and talking about how, you know, it was a pretty tone deaf. And I think, yeah, it's been interesting to see the way that the media has gone from, I guess, just accepting opposite narrative to really challenging it about the situation and challenge. Nick, just to put this into perspective, how does this data breach compare to others within Australia?
So there have been larger breaches in Australia just by the sheer number of paper for example, for example, the graphic design software platform can but suffered a very large reach a couple of years back. But that was very different kinds of data. They even collectively very personal information that are disappeared to have collected and retained on an enormous number of their customers. That's things like making others, personal numbers, drivers, license and so if you're comparing both the size of the attack and the sensitivity of the information that is taken, it looks to be the largest in the country.
And in fact, relatively relative to Australia's population is one of the largest attacks on a country in the world. So we've mentioned that, you know, how the Australian media has gone from accepting the line to actually really challenging optimists on this. And but do you think the Australian media has responsibly reported on this data breach without feeding into the panic or the fear that can go along with that? I would say it's been fairly responsible and this is a huge data breach with so many people impacted them.
I think it's absolutely right to keep drilling down on off just about their claims that this was a sophisticated attack, which you know, claira-nail has completely rebuffed. And it could be quite serious, you know, this they do have 100 points of ID that could be significant before the comes of this. So I think the attention has been warranted though, saturated. And I think the media is, you know, I haven't seen too much fear mungering.
I have seen quite straight down the line reporting, which has been refreshing. If I add to that, I think that there's been a sort of latent build up of the tension on cyber issues. They're often very difficult to report because they lack something that is tangible. So for example, statistically, there are constant attacks, one critical infrastructure, mentioned earlier, constant attacks on banks.
That's like, well, that's a bit abstract. What does that actually mean for me, your consumer? And so oftentimes, these stories are not widely picked up in the media because they are not something we can make intelligible, intangible, for readers or listeners or viewers depending on the medium. And so this attack is both about offices and what specifically occurred here.
But there's also this wider policy debate happening. How do we have privacy laws, what does this say about cyber security defenses are we investing in? And I think that's also played into the volume of coverage that we're saying. Well, understandably, everyone wants to know who's responsible and who's to blame.
And we've got a lot of the government pointing the finger and now the bill to optis, as it would seem. While the CEO of Optis, on the other hand, told ABC in an interview that we know this is the work of some band actors and really they're the villains in this story. Do you think the villain architect is really helpful in getting to the bottom of this journey? I think if you have to say, maybe, or if you're not the villain, do you just say?
Yeah, maybe or if you're not the villain, I'm waiting for the letter villain in. So I think there's a lot to be said about officers as one to this. And I think the media has been a responsible job in really centering tech and people who actually know this stuff a lot better than the average reporter does and centering those voices. And maybe trusting those voices more than trusting.
They opted to voice me. Johnny, you work for Kinsumah advocacy group choice. Now, it makes sense that the media will focus on what consumers can do as well as reporting on the government and industry response. Do you think there's been a balance in emphasizing individual responsibility and as well as systemic responsibility in the media?
Yeah, I mean, there's obviously a lot that individuals do have to do now that they've reached things like credit reporting, monitoring and stuff like that and replacing your ID documents. But in the article that I wrote yesterday, I was also really hoping to drive home at the end of the article, the emphasis that even though there's a lot that individual consumers do have to do now, it shouldn't at the end of the day be up to them to map out this metal office is making. Nick, we've had a number of laws passed in the last two years that put obligations on critical infrastructures like telcos to address cyber threats. The ministerial powers have also increased recently.
Are you keeping a close eye to report on how this may be used in the Optus Bridge? Yeah, so the government has said that the telecommunications industry argued for and ultimately received essentially carve out some of these provisions that abide by the other industries. So they're not subject to quite as onerous obligations as some other sectors. Now, the basis for that is basically the telecommunications sector said look, we're very sophisticated, we understand cyber, we understand data and technology and we can handle it largely on our own.
That's a claim that the government is now rubbishing and all but saying that they will change in terms of how those laws apply. So that's one facet of the legislation I'm expecting governments to bring in. And then the second is there's been long a way to change is to have privacy law works in this country. There's been numerous law reform commission reports that have recommended changes and very little has happened spoke to a privacy expert yesterday who described enforcement as basically a black hole, at least until the tenure of the current privacy commissioner.
So Mark Dreyfus is just this morning that he's going to bring in changes to privacy acts. Now that's also going to be a really important thing for the media, right? That is not just about data and privacy, the privacy act is a broad thing. So that's going to be a conversation for journalists about if there are changes in their own say, letting individual people sue for privacy breaches, are journalists at risk of reaching out if they go into a sort of foot in the door styling to do or really rigorously report a story or overstep them up, perhaps it could be a good way of ensuring the journalists don't breach people's privacy.
That's going to be a fascinating debate to come another different technology perspective, but also make it respected. But do you think this could perhaps allow governments more broadly to stymie journalists efforts when it comes to holding power to account? It's really hard to say, as Nick said, the Privacy Act is so broad and the government keeps saying it will be making announcements, but hasn't really said what announcements it will make. It just keeps teasing us with these announcements to come.
But I think it will be really interesting to see what kind of changes are proposed. We know that companies collect far too much data, they don't store it well, and they hold on to it for way too long, which I think the Optus breach really revealed. People are asking why four years down the line after not being a customer, why Optus still has its data. So I think when it comes to data management data storage, this could have really wide-ranging impacts, but the impacts on journalists, I think we'll have to wait and see what clear our nail announces.
You read an article comparing this with government response to the Optus breach with the NDIS data breach. Why do you think there's been a different response by the media this time? Well, I mean, this is what always happens with people with disabilities or those at risk or with vulnerabilities. We rarely see the kind of hyper-focus.
There are differences. The NDIS data breach impacted far fewer people than the Optus breach did. This breach occurred in May and it's a cloud management software system that is routinely used by a lot of NDIS companies and out-of-home care organisations, so foster care aged care. So it wasn't a breach of NDIS's data itself.
It was the data about NDIS clients or aged care residents that was uploaded to the system. But I think the main thing is that while Optus has been in the spotlight and it's been really scrutinised here, how many were impacted, what information was accessed, where it's gone. We haven't got any kind of that information about this data breach affecting NDIS participants. We don't know how many were impacted, the company that had its data hacked, which is CTAS won't release it.
We don't know which companies, which NDIS service provider companies had their data breach, which means we don't know if those that were impacted were actually told that their data had been released. There's just so little information and of course the government didn't respond. It didn't really get picked up by a lot of media organisations and there's been no changes. So these people with disabilities have some really, really sensitive information potentially out there.
And this information is a lot more sensitive than that was involved in the data hack. This is stuff about people's medical conditions, how their disability is progressing, potentially stigmatised issues like incontinence or suicide iterations. So it's a lot more serious in many ways but didn't get any of the amount of attention and response. You're listening to Fourth Estate on the Community Radio Network.
This week we're talking about the media's reportage of data security and cyber attacks. I'm joined by Johnny Blackley, Nick Bonnaje and Amashiltz. Johnny, we've also seen the media spotlight issues around facial recognition technology this week. Choice has been investigating retailers use of the technology for quite some time.
Did you purposely choose to discuss this in the light of the Optus data breach while all eyes are on data security right now? No, actually. So we, I mean, I was down in the field of investigation and then we've been doing a series of follow-up articles and all that, including the article that went out this week. The timing actually was just purely coincidental, it's been in the works of some time.
But I think that the two issues do feed in together but at the end of the day, if as the Optus data actually companies are not storing your data properly, the more sensitive data they have on you, it came out in Bunnings, which is the equivalent of a fingerprint. You've got that and access to that and that's all. The timing ended up incuincidental but the two feed in together and the privacy attributes. Nick, there was a US study recently which looked at how the media reports on cybersecurity issues.
Now, they found historically the media reported on the hack of the moment, more so on a service level. But they found that now there's a growing trend of more in-depth reportage looking at root causes as well as the real world consequences and potential policy solutions. Would you agree that the nuance to how media report on cybersecurity has changed in recent times? I haven't done nearly the kind of quantitative work that I suspect the office of that study have done.
But I think that it depends in part on the scale of the hack. If that generates the kind of interest among readers necessary to sustain the ongoing one-year-olds in detailed reporting, it's probably a major factor. Another thing is that it takes us a long time for the public to be educated about technical matters. And so it seems likely that as the internet just lasts longer and comes in ever greater part of people's lives, hopefully they'll gain a greater baseline understanding that then enables more detailed reporting to penetrate into the public consciousness.
But would you agree with an exclamation of that? Look, yes, absolutely. I think it's really interesting that people's literacy on their data in houses is probably not fantastic. And as we saw more and more data biometrics, information, facial recognition, everything, we're going to have to keep asking these really difficult questions about what happens to that data, what the rules around it are, and how it's stored.
And I think one good example would be my health record. The government did ask everyone to agree to have all their medical information lumped together and accessible by a single port of entry. And then a 2019 audit found that the government failed to manage security risks and privacy risks. So it's all well and good for all these companies and organisations to hold out their hands and say, give us our data.
But people aren't aware of how it's stored, how it's used. And there's just not a lot of oversight about the protections that we're given. Johnny, do you think we're not as, I guess, the public on a broader scale? We're not as savvy as we should be when it comes to data storage.
I think a lot of people are really confused by what this all means and what the broader implications are. Yeah, I think generally people only really think about these issues when something goes wrong. You're not thinking about, yeah, as I mentioned, you're handing over your health record onto a website, or even your real estate agents requesting all the nations for you to apply for a rental property. We're not thinking about it as we consume it on an everyday basis, as we have.
There's only these brief moments of attention when something goes wrong. But I think there needs to be great protections and kind of keep it in mind on an everyday level as well. But in heart, because at the end of the day, we live so much about life and these companies. So yeah, I think there needs to be more.
Nick, how do you think that the media can help the broader public become a little bit more data or data security literate, in a sense, without creating that sort of big brother fear kind of mungering that we've been talking about that we don't really want to create? Because already, I feel a lot of suspicion around large corporations, how they hold our data, how that plays into government and all that sort of thing, data retention. How do we inform the public to become a little bit more literate around these issues? The key thing I think is that there is genuine reason to be concerned about the rather styled data collection.
If it's not something that has been feasible at any time in human history, until now, the technology has evolved to a point where governments and companies can obtain enormous amounts of data on their people. And as we've seen in some authoritarian regimes overseas, use it for incredibly nefarious purposes. And even in very advanced liberal Western democracies, there have been plenty of examples where companies and governments have used it in a wrong way. And that is something that people should be watchful for.
As was struck in the balance between alarmism and the truth, I think it's just the basic things of reporting, ensuring that everyone has the adequate right of reply, ensuring that we double check out facts, ensuring that the basis of the presented in a balanced manner, there's any specifics for cyber reporting really, except that because it is such a technical area, it's an area in which the standard domain is about how much language reveals versus how much it hides are probably high. And so to give an example of that, the optimist described this hack has been sophisticated as the sample was saying, whereas the government has said it is quite basic. Now, one of those positions is right, and one of them is wrong. Sophisticated and quite basic are not reconcilable terms.
But to get to the bottom of that, we'll have to have some quite detailed technical explanation of how exactly this hack was conducted. Similarly, the data has been described as quite encrypted. Now, does that mean it was encrypted when it was on the Office of Service, but not when it was sent out, does that mean it was encrypted only in transit as almost all internet communications now are again, there's going to need to be some technical analysis, but it is our job to try and present that technical analysis because of course, most people do not spend their time processing over such things is our job to present that in plain English, which both Office and the Minister have done it different ways, but still in a non partisan and balanced neutral way such that it's going to be properly in one of the trace. I know that sounds very, you know, probably preachy and high-minded, but hey, you've got to strive for it, right?
Well, we can only hope, Amber. You know, it is a really difficult thing to wrap your head around. And if you're just a general member of the public and you've got a million other things going on, I don't, you know, I do agree that people need to be a little bit more aware of it, but I'm not sure it's fair to put the onus on them into understanding it. You know, it is really complex and it is a generalist's role to try and make that less complex, but I think it would be fair for us to expect that we can have a little bit of trust and faith in those systems and yes, be wary of these big brother things and yes, try and have a little bit more literacy, but I don't think that onus should be on the person and I don't think a person should have to read numerous news articles of journalists driving to get the bottom of it just to understand what their mandatory data, what's happening with it with the data that they had to, you know, put forward to function in society.
There have been reports about threats and ransoms from the alleged optist hacker or possibly opportunistic scammers, it depends, I guess, how you look at it. How wary should the media be when reporting on these threats and verifying how legitimate they are? You know, there were so many texts and scams that emerged from optists, they were someone saying, just put $2,000 in my bank account on this text message and while it's important not for the media not to come out and say, oh, this is the hacker look at look and go, I think it's fair to, you know, to expose the scams that are out there because we do know that elderly populations, especially are pretty susceptible. So it's an important job of the media, not to say, this is a really common scam, this is going to happen to you, but just to kind of highlight, hey, this is an example of one circulating scam, it might not be ever present, it might not be, you know, a huge number, but here's an example so that we can educate those who aren't too technologically aware or illiterate as to what kind of methods are used.
Nick? We didn't pay that much attention to those kind of messages that we're circulating. We paid more attention to the posts that were being made on hack reforms by someone who claimed to be the optist hacker themselves on the basis that was a person who had a vast amount of data. And again, I'm not myself as cybersecurity expert, but there were some things that we could do in the newsroom to verify the legitimate, or not the legitimate, that was very diligent in some ways, the authenticity of those posts.
So one was that there was data that was revealed by that person, a small sample of data initially 200 records and then 10,000 records. And so in that, there are people's contact information. And so you can contact those people and say, hey, are you an optist customer? I have your address here, is that accurate?
Of course, we are also at the same time saying there are services that can help you, you should call that optist, you should call that government, ensure that you are self protected, so giving advice at the same time, but also using that process to verify whether the information that has been released is authentic. One researcher just happened to live near where someone on that list lived and just went around and said, not necessarily one of the general journalists, but a third party just said, hey, is this you? And then also that's a sign that it's not confirmation that details could be obtained in some previous hack or leakdell's weather. That's one thing that journalists did in another, is there's a website how it been pwned, which is like a database of email addresses that have been caught up in previous hacks.
So if the email address released in these datasets was not in previous hacks, then it suggests that it is probably fresh information that has been obtained somehow. And then the other thing is that the government has jumped on aspects of the data that's been released in this. And you think that the government was being informed by very sophisticated professionals within Australia's cyber spy agencies. And so if as happened, you had, for example, the government saying, the health ministry, the attorney general, and I was saying, we are very concerned that Medicare data has been leaked.
And that came just after this person's leak disampled and included Medicaid others, then you would think it is at least likely that the government has ascertained that this is genuine. Again, none of this has been 100% verified. It could still be false. He is under investigation.
Those are really important caveats and things that we make clear to our readers, but they are signs that we use to ensure that when we take it seriously, we're doing so with never-dentral basis. What did we think of the $1 million ransom rumor that's been circulating? Not the highest, but not the lowest. I think there's a bit of you that's so low as to be ridiculous or just comical.
Actually, there have been hacks like this one over a few years back where hackers have only demanded or received a few hundred thousand. Part of that is because using this information to make money on people is a laborious and legal risky process. It's the legal that the risks have been caught as you go out and individually scam and spam people go up. I mean, plenty of this has been weird.
If you're a hacker, typically you want to contact a company in silence and do it before the notice of the hackers out such that they can avoid embarrassment and have maximum incentive to pay. It's not the lowest, but then on the high side, there have been hacks that have generated ransoms in the tens of millions, but they're mostly a different character, which is where the hacker goes in, uses software to essentially lock up an entire company's networks, and then says pay me cash or I'm not going to let your business function whatsoever. Office is taking a huge heat here, no doubt in terms of bad publicity, customer anger, and so on, but it is still operating. It's not as severe as that kind of hack.
So that's not the longer to take. Well, finally, do you think this Office data breach will change the discussion on how our data is stored and used? Or do you think it's just one more data breach? Johnny, do you first?
Yeah, I think the attention that this Office hack has brought to private, it's definitely changed the conversation or not maybe not changed the conversation, but it's highlighted the conversation. I think the thing that it mainly has done is that it's given the government cover to buy it done so whether they will and whether what the impact on that will be. But there is a lot of community anger out there. I mean, people have been caught up with this and except for some reputational damage, as Nick mentioned, and maybe there isn't actually any sense of recourse.
So I think that whether that leads to change, it's the way to see. Abba, it's interesting. I mean, even Attorney General Mark Dray says just this morning, questioning exactly why companies once they verify your identity with those underpoints of identification, why they need to hold onto it for 10 years. So I think one of the major changes that we will see is that companies will have to delete the data that they store on you.
They're no longer going to be able to hold onto that and use that in ways we don't really know how. I think that will be one of the most positive changes because if companies don't have the data, it can't be leaked. If they don't store it, it can't be released. Nick, final thoughts and observations?
Yeah, it is possible that under existing law, this will have to pay out a whole work of cash because it's now class action firms circling and there are provisions for class actions under the Privacy Act that are jointly and under absolutely right that there's been an understanding cause for a bunch of people, greater recourse. And I think that this will change the discussion around it. It's funny when you look at articles, one, some titular example can be used in media stories for years after something occurs because it grounds a conversation in the readers' minds and makes complex issues intelligible and relatable. And I think that this is what this hack will provide in this country for discussions about cybersecurity.
On that note, I'd like to thank my guests on Fourth Estate this week, Johnny Blackali, Nick Bonnajati, and Amish Alts. Thanks, Nina. And thank you for listening to the program. This edition was recorded at the studios of Tue Siara and heard across the country on the community radio network.
Fourth Estate is produced with the assistance of the Community Broadcasting Foundation, a big thanks to the foundation for their continuing support. Make sure you subscribe to Fourth Estate on your favorite podcast app so you can hear us talk about media, politics, and a lot in between. We'll be back with more next week of course, but in the meantime, you can stay in touch with us on Twitter. Our handle is Fourth Estate AU.
Thanks as always to my producer, Malin Evan and executive producer, Anthony Dockrell. On Tina Quinn, please do stay well, stay safe, and catch us next week on Fourth Estate.