This podcast is an audio recording of a live event. It may reference visual material that cannot be represented in this recording. It may also contain strong language and adult themes. The opinions expressed in this podcast do not necessarily reflect those of ACMI.
And I want to talk about in terms of the affect, like what is Bowie doing? Because I think he's doing something really remarkable and breaking through into new space and also involved with political concepts. But in a way that's very interesting, very specific to him. Now, if you remember the song, it's very hard to hear the lyrics. I won't put them up until the end. But the performance is overwhelming. And that's what I want to focus on. But here's what the song seems to be about to me. It seems to be about a guy who's in a room maybe. And there's probably like a TV playing. And on the TV there's...
visions or documentaries of people being tortured or political problems in other countries being shot against targets people who shot there they're getting broken by fascists and the main person who's singing the song presumably bowie is just just horrified i don't know how you guys feel about this i always find this song just so fascinating and strange and i want to talk a little bit about the, very briefly, about the history of screaming in music. And I won't have time to go in a very big way, but we'll talk about how it comes into popular music. Generally attributed to Kansas City Blues in the U.S., where you had performers who in the 30s, 40s, 50s were performing with big bands, saxophones, horns, and performing to audiences that were notoriously excited and loud. And so you had to kind of scream, they sort of had to yell or scream the lyrics out over their own band and the audience to be heard. And this became a performance style that affected the actual songwriting and really became central to what the blues has become.
That particular idea of sort of yelling, screaming, I think we all know it comes into popular music in a big way. I find this fascinating that this is happening in popular culture at a time when we're also getting a sense of the... the need for certain groups, African-Americans or young American adolescents, to find their voice and to communicate clearly, right? I'm here and I've got something to say. What I've got to say is important. And if you think about screaming and music, it often has this role, right? In fact, probably most often, which is that you just give emphasis with your Jim Morrison, whoever. I've got some time. I'm in love with you. Or don't you talk to me like that. There's an intentionality about it. And it's definitely connected to the lyrics, right? It's a form of communication. It's very direct. And it's about really getting out there and being heard. Now, John Lennon changes this.
John Lennon puts out an album in 1970. What's fascinating to me about this is that Lennon has actually been doing primal scream therapy for about a year before this album comes out. And if you're not familiar with what this is, this Dr. Arthur Janoff would bring people to a place where they were to scream, to get in touch with suppressed memories, hidden desires, traumas from their childhood. And Lennon, all over this album, Lennon is doing these kinds of vocal work. So a new thing is happening here. We're getting into a kind of intimacy, right? It's not the same as just getting your voice heard. It's about going inside yourself and finding something that is traumatically hidden, maybe even to yourself, and having it come out.
You know, that's more of a Foucaultian kind of concept of performance and of investigation. And so I think that this is where we've got a big change in the history of screaming. And I wanted us to think a little bit about this kind of gamut from yelling to screaming to just like breaking down, right? Because with screaming, it sort of has that risk, right? It's got this panic about it. It's got the sense that it might end up in a completely animalistic place. Now, yelling is intentional communication, as I was saying, right? But screaming is kind of borderline between intentional and involuntary, you know? Maybe your passion is so big that you've lost control, right, in some sort of botchic frenzy. Or maybe like Bowie, you're just in this painful, anxious place where you just can't, you don't know what to do anymore, and you're in, you're just, you're losing it.
And so I think it's important for us to think about that. Also, not only in terms of language breaking down, but in full breakdown, there is no longer any language, right? We're just on the ground, curled up in a ball, crying, screaming, or whatever it is. And we relate to this very differently, right? When we see someone going through this, we stop what we're doing. We have, in a sense, an animalistic urge to help or to find out what's going to stop the problem. And this is also true in terms of performance.
When you're yelling, you can yell for a whole lifetime as a performer, right? Opera singers do, blues singers do it. Screaming, of course, is different. Because when yelling, you're just pushing air through the vocal cords and so you can be heard much more deeply, right? Much more loudly. And you can do that with training. Screaming, you're taking the vocal cords and you're crushing them down and you're pushing the air against it. So it turns into my voice. You can actually cause a ragged problem there. And we know this as people, right? That people scream only when they're in panic because it can actually destroy their voice. And it's also true performance, which is why we don't hear it very much. Leonard is starting to go there with his particular traumatic explorations, but Bowie is there too.
I think that what I want to talk to you now is the sense of the breakdown. I wrote an essay on Young Americans where Beau is also having a bit of a breakdown there. It's in the new book that Sean and Toya are editing. And I want us to think a little bit about what breakdown is, both in normal communication as well as in song. This is a moment where we feel the performer losing it, right? He's got or she's got something to tell us about. And it's so powerful that as they're doing it or singing about it, as they're telling us or singing, they themselves find their emotions coming up very big, right? And they have trouble keep going on, right? And our hearts go out to them. I mean, our performativity, our relationship with them changes.
Completely. It becomes much more intimate. Like Lennon when he's screaming about his mother. That we stop being able to see them in their performance and there's the person there. Even if they're a star and it gets very complicated with issues of performativity. But this is what I find fascinating in general. And I think in the interest of time I'm going to skip Beyonce. But I know. But Beyonce does this actually in the 2008 inauguration of Obama. It's an online clip if you get to see it. She sings At Last, which is an echo of Martin Luther King's I Have a Dream speech. At Last, we're free at last. She does this soul song. She does some blues techniques there and then she starts to break down.
And, you know, I don't think you have to be an American to find it so moving. You understand the experience that she's having, and it has this larger, larger political context. So we've seen this in a lot of things. We've seen this in Oscar acceptance speeches, so it can be performed as well. But I want us to think about what happens there, and this different relationship that happens, a sense of time, and also a sense of interiority of the performer that just kind of opens out to us, right? Usually connected with intimacy, as with Lenin, as with our UN representative, who's overcome whatever he's seen. But it is thought, and that's where we get back to Bowie, where Bowie's doing something, I think, brand new in popular music. We often talk about how Bowie takes from...
high art, and he's trying to bring pop music up into Ralph high art. So I want to just remind us, we've got folks in the 20th century who have been working on the voice, as well as working on going inside into a non-vocal place to find new things to say that are going to change our relationship to the audience. Artaud is the most famous example. So I think he's definitely influenced on Bowie in this particular song. We won't have time here to go into what Beckett's doing here, but I think Beckett's performances, his techniques, and also his issues of erasure. Beckett's very abstract. We don't often have characters. We have tone and we have anxiety. There's definitely something there in terms of an influence for Bowie in this song.
Beckett's an influence on The Elephant Man, right, which is always actually being interviewed for it while he's recording Scary Monsters. Again, a story about a person who has trouble communicating in a very crippled voice about the pain of the world that's out there that he can't quite cope with. It's a little bit similar to the narrator or the person in It's No Game. Brecht and Lenya, I think we won't have time to go into that, but they're definitely there in terms of making a ragged voice, an ugly voice that takes us into a new space. But what I wanted to focus on last year, in the interest of time, is we'll go into the lyrics now of It's No Game. So he's erased in the context of this song any actual political thing, right? It's just...
All that bad stuff in the world, right? It's kind of an infantile reaction to it. I don't mean infantile in a bad way, but that gut reaction, lower brain, which I certainly have that feeling. Oh, no, I don't want to hear anything more about this or about that. It's a guy who's just fed up and wants to push it away with his voice and just curl up in a ball. So he's erased himself. Unlike Lenin, we don't have that intimacy. And yet he's very immediately in the moment. We know nothing about the politics. He's also giving us no information about the person who's experiencing this kind of crippling thing that's happening, right? And that's really, I think, unique to Bowie.
So I just want to point this out. I think it's a very interesting song for me because it shows the moment where the personal is the political and we're finding another way to talk about our anxieties without actually speaking about it in language but through affect. Another great invention of David Bowie and taking us to the border of breakdown. Thank you very much. You have been listening to an ACMI podcast. For more recordings, go to soundcloud.com slash ACMI online or the ACMI website.