Skip to content
David Bowie Symposium Toija Cinque episode artwork

Jan 11, 2016 16 min

David Bowie Symposium Toija Cinque

from ACMI Stories & Ideas Hosted by ACMI

Relive The Stardom and Celebrity of David Bowie, a two-day multi-discipline symposium we hosted that saw artists, academics and cultural commentators reflect upon the influence of and on David Bowie in rock, pop, film, art, fashion and performance.

Episode details come from the podcast's RSS feed.

Embed this episode

Ready to play

David Bowie Symposium Toija Cinque

0:00 16:33
of matches

Transcript Auto-generated, may contain errors

this podcast is an audio recording of a live event it may reference visual material that cannot be represented in this recording it may also contain strong language and adult themes the opinions expressed in this podcast do not necessarily reflect those of acme My interest in surveillance has been with me a long time. I came to David Bowie's work, probably not unlike yourselves, through the sibling of a friend. And for me it was changes, but of course it was a disrecording because I am too young to have heard the original press of it, like I wish. But from that then it was, and some of you probably have read this book yourself, The Man Who Fell to Earth, and this for me was tremendous, this link of the technological communications I subsequently went on and studied telecommunications. And this to me is wonderful, and you can see that I accidentally...

I forgot to return it to Catholic Girl School where I went. But this literature should not be in their library anyway. So I took it upon myself to relieve them of their copy. But to me, this brought out the significance of a techno star man who was forever more part of my life in different ways. Not least in the imagery as well from The Man Who Fell to Earth. Of course, he's not bad to look at, but for me, the multiple television screens behind were fantastic. And this telephone, it's got a cable. But at the time, it was like, wow, this new technology, it's interesting. What does that mean in his life? But the underlying current for me was, what is this notion of the surveillance? And who is it that is looking? Who is the they? So certainly the lyric harks to the idea of celebrity culture. Perhaps it is we, the public, and fans. Or is it a deeper look at who is doing surveying? And what are the implications for privacy and security as examples? So...

My research relates to the idea of visual networked culture and again tracing this idea of the multiple television screens that Thomas Jerome Newton had behind him but now how we use screens for all things and this science fiction future come to our own realities was incredibly powerful. So again I like statistics and data and communications and so my research question came about how do we survey and how have stars and celebrities to an extent been normalised? How do they bargain certain aspects of privacy as a fair exchange in return for public attention? And I look at Panoptic Visions here, subsequently afforded spaces for discussion and commentary about stars and celebrity via the increased ubiquity and distribution of platforms such as YouTube, Twitter, Facebook and imaging devices on multiple mobile devices, screen devices. So the paper that I'm developing further, and please see me with comments or questions afterwards, I'd be most grateful, looks at Bowie and the fan interactions with them through looking at David Bowie's own star image via social media. And here social media was chosen not only because of my own personal love for it, but...

because a number of sites are the primary spheres through which engagement between stars and celebrities and their fan bases emerge. Here I'd also note the idea of a definition between star and celebrity, if we like, where stars, for example, are people, to look at Nick Stevenson's work, that are in some way extraordinary. They're people that last. and to whom we might look up to. David Marshall has explained that someone achieves stardom through a special textual performance, such as acting in a film or through music, but celebrity speaks of a perceptual movement outside of the initial cultural form, whether film or popular culture. So Marshall argues that celebrity implies it is the dimension of the performer and how we use them in all sorts of other ways in our popular culture. The celebrity aspect implies that we are concerned with the star's everyday life to the extent that they become a study of the private, the intimate, but in the most public way.

Bowie's star image rests largely upon his private emotional life, a mentality, a psychology perhaps, trauma and scars, to borrow some Ahmad's work, taking precedence arguably for the listening or viewing body, asked perhaps to be the fans over his private life. Now this doesn't discount when I look at the research that certainly there are comments out there about Bowie's private life and does he bite people and here's a picture of David Bowie in Sao Paulo on his holidays. There are certainly comments out there. They don't however tend to be circulated quite as widely as the comment that... that fans or others make about him and his work, his art, influence, for example, the more psychic aspects of it. My work finds that it is Bowie's private emotional life that has long provided an interpretive framework for fans in contemplation, raising questions for us of the value of stars and their art for the individual becoming, if you like, or positive self-actualisation, to borrow Maslow's term, and perhaps the collective will. Precisely because the star performer can establish an intimate connection with a willing individual, a fan, can be affected in a positive way.

certainly sometimes negatively where it can spiral downward, as they navigate their way through, as we navigate our way through life's key moment. And arguably a relationship is able to form between the celebrity or star, performer and a listening body or viewing body who might self-identify as a fan as they closely connect virtually. to an experience or a particular medium, a particular materiality and a particular cultural phenomenon that matters. And here I'd use the term phoenokenn. It's one that I've developed where phoenokenn means shining and ken is one's range of knowledge or a perception which is proposed as a single word where music arguably is inadequate to convey a deeper...

understanding, it loses some depth of meaning that might be conveyed. It borrows from Julia Christiva's notion of phenotex, certainly useful here, where phenotex is a structure. It obeys certain rules of communication and presupposes a subject of an enunciation and an addressee. Certainly Barth's own work on the Fano song is also marked here, and this idea of the Fano can borrows on that, but moves more deeply into an understanding of what it might mean on a more personal, emotional level. As I've noted...

stars have come to bargain a certain amount of loss of privacy for the benefits of their own material world. What I wanted to then get into, and this is only scratching the surface, please note, is I wanted to have a look at some data that was circulating by us in the Twittersphere, and I particularly looked at Twitter for brevity. So my primary data was collected from a key digital source, which was Twitter, using Tweet Archivist, having tried to go through different means, but finding that third-party agreement, meaning what can I do with the findings in terms of recreating data? Would I be able to use it? Were there implications for privacy? Who actually owns it?

I chose Tweet Archivists, and I chose the period between 26th of April and 14th of July this year, primarily because it was leading up to this Acme event, and I wanted to find out what were the conversations that were circulating. Certainly, please don't start to panic and think, oh my God, what did I put out there? This is more just a trend, if you like. The hashtags that I used were hashtag David Bowie, for which there were 20,629 tweets over that brief period. I also used the hashtag Bowie and Bowie Acme. I know, I'm getting really excited, right? The last speaker.

statistics, just to quote Angela here, blah, blah, blah, eyes blaze over, yawn. But no, no, no, this is really good. So the statistics I want to look at were what are the tweets that are happening? And I've colour coded it because I'd like to do a little bit of colour coding. A large circle here indicates a significant number of tweets that are being sent out by a single user and key usernames are included there. Secondly, the depth of colour for its part equals the number of retweets that were sent out. And the retweets are probably the most interesting because it's not just a tweet that's going out, but it's the users that are then recirculating that information about...

David Bowie. The second aspect is probably the more notable of the data because it represents a subsequent action from the original tweet about David Bowie during this period of 26 April to 14 July. And so what I did here was where there were significant colours, I wanted to then drill down into the data and find out, well, who were these users? And here's an example here of Tanpreet. This person did send out retweets. I thought, well, that's interesting. What is the data? So what I primarily did was I had all the data downloaded into an Excel spreadsheet, through which I could then do a filter, and then I came up with one particular user and then all their tweets. Just taking a sidestep, this is a new area of research. It's a social network analysis. I still don't think we as users know enough about the implications, and not least if I can jump on my hobby horse about metadata legislation in Australia and that we...

need to consider what happens with the data because this does have geolocation. metadata that comes with it, where a tweet was sent from, to whom it was sent, what the nature of the tweet was. You might say on its own it means nothing, but put together it could be something more significant. Certainly here we're saying, well, is it just ephemeral it's about Bowie? Yeah, but it could be about something more significant. But I'll get on to privacy and security in another paper. Now, these are the tweets that were sent out by this user, and they were retweets, and obviously it was about a competition. So can we make the assumption that this person works for a radio station? Yeah, it's probably likely where they're running a competition, certainly, but indicates some of the interest about David Bowie at this particular time. This is another user, and I thought this was lovely.

Bowie wakes us. A lovely phrase. For me personally, it says so much about how I consider his work and this inner awakening, if you like. I also wanted to have a look at this person, addicted to Bowie. Of course, who isn't? And these are just some of the lovely notes that are made. And using it as a forum, moving away perhaps from the likes of BowieNet to connect with others. Nye from London Boy. This is beautiful stuff. This is a lovely emerging community. So this is some more. This is using the hashtag David Bowie over this time. This was a significant user here and it was interesting that this was around the time of the Scottish referendum where Bowie was speaking about Scotland's day within.

as examples. So these are some of the tweets that came from Blackfast006. This person, Claude Starr, also makes quite emotional tweets about Bowie. And again, for privacy reasons, I haven't put some up, but if you're interested, you can have a look at Claude. He lives in Italy and he loves David Bowie too.

Which I'm pleased to see. Now, this is coloured differently. This is a number of tweets that were sent out using the hashtag Bowie. And you can see up here, quite a large circle. I want to find out a little bit more about that, about just this specific aspect of Miracle Goodnight and what they were talking about in terms of Bowie. And so I had a look at a post that they'd put up on Facebook through a Facebook channel and a video that they had put up. And the key one's, it looks like even the thin white duke is happy. He really loves her.

Love and the Thin White Chick. I thought, yeah, okay. I love you, honey. Love is the tune and love the video. Awesome bit of 1990s. Again, an emerging community. This time linked to Twitter and on Facebook. So that was lots of fun. Then I wanted to have a look at specific ideas coming to ACME of what was the conversation about David Bowie using the hashtag BowieACME.

And this is what I found. So this is some lovely network analysis. And just to be brief, it shows the representation of the relationship between certain nodes. And the colours here show particular attractions, if you like. So in terms of layout and node presentation, the linked nodes attract each other and the less linked nodes are pushed away. So you can see at the time where I started, mine's the red one up there that's pushed far, far away. And then these are some of the communities, you might even recognise your own name down here, that we're talking about Bowie. And in terms of colour groups, I found certain tweets going out from local government, for example, that are promoting the event and just how ACME sits there in the middle.

Networked or influential a node is the bigger the circle here, and same with the label here. So obviously ACME stands out here as a subtle difference from the other text as well, representing the significance. Different colours refer to different communities or clusters, as I mentioned. Here you can see a clockwise and anticlockwise curve. The clockwise curve from a node or a circle means that this person has mentioned another person. So the clockwise is mentioning, again, related to ACME and Bowie. And anticlockwise curve from a node means the opposite. It means that person has then been mentioned by another. So, for example, you can see...

Where the thickness of the curves comes out, certain terms have been mentioned there. OK, so what does it all mean? Well, I'm still collecting data. This time I'm using a data analysis tool called TagSleuth and we've found that we have collectively, thank you everyone, we have started to trend. We've made over 500 posts to Twitter, only one to Vine. So if you're not using Vine, this might be the time that we do a disco dance downstairs and we post it. We've had eight posts to Tumblr and this is using the hashtag Bowie Symposium. Again, what does it mean? Well, it certainly does show a dialogue around the use of Bowie and David Bowie and thinking about him to what extent is he significant in his...

Well, two provocations have been intertwined here. The first being that the star is fundamental, arguably, to a listening or viewing body for the purpose of, in ideal circumstances, positive and purposeful identity formation for becoming... So I'm going to work this up a little bit more, and I'll hope to publish the results. And please give me any feedback. Keep tweeting, and I'll keep collecting, and it'll be another lovely analysis. So what is David Bowie? David Bowie's laid. He's complex. He's challenging. He's a social rebel. Thanks. Thank you.

You have been listening to an ACMI podcast. For more recordings, go to soundcloud.com slash ACMI online or the ACMI website.

Frequently asked questions

How long is this episode of ACMI Stories & Ideas?

This episode is 16 minutes long.

When was this ACMI Stories & Ideas episode published?

This episode was published on January 11, 2016.

Is there a transcript available for this episode?

Yes, a full transcript is available for this episode. You can read the complete transcript on the episode page.

Can I download this ACMI Stories & Ideas episode?

Yes. Use the download control on the episode player to save the publisher-provided media file.