Skip to content
Debate Night in America: Post Debate Analysis Part 2 episode artwork

Oct 2, 2024 45 min

Debate Night in America: Post Debate Analysis Part 2

from Anderson Cooper 360 Hosted by CNN Podcasts

Tim Walz and JD Vance faced off in a civil, policy-focused vice presidential debate in New York City. CNN brings you an instant poll on the debate. Panel members Scott Jennings, Ashley Allison, Alyssa Farah Griffin, and David Axelrod join to give reaction and break down key moments from tonight.

Episode details come from the podcast's RSS feed.

Embed this episode

Ready to play

Debate Night in America: Post Debate Analysis Part 2

0:00 45:33
of matches

Transcript Auto-generated, may contain errors

Welcome back. It is about tonight here in New York City. We are breaking down the substance and surprises and the first and only vice presidential debate of 2024. It began with a traditional handshake between the public and the state of advance of Ohio Democratic Governor to walls of Minnesota.

The debate went on to be mostly civil, especially given the history of attacks in his campaigns and advanced and counter walls. We were very sure of contrast on policy while repeatedly shifting the focus of the candidates at the top of their tickets to Donald Trump and Kamala Harris. Take a listen to it to walls and dances. They saved their sharpest lines for the presidential nominee of the other party on the issue after issue.

Fundamental areas, that steady leadership is going to matter. It's clear and the world saw it on that debate stage a few weeks ago. A nearly 80 year old Donald Trump talking about crowd sizes. When did Iran and Hamas and their proxies attack Israel?

It was during the administration of Kamala Harris. Senator Vance has said that there's a climate problem in the past. Donald Trump called it a hoax. We have a historic immigration crisis because Kamala Harris started and said that she wanted to undo all of Donald Trump's border policies.

How is it fair that you're paying your taxes every year and Donald Trump hasn't paid any federal tax in the last 15 years. Kamala Harris has already done it because she's been the vice president for three and a half years. She had the opportunity to enact all of these great policies and what she's actually done instead is drive the cost of food higher by 25%. When Donald Trump said, I got a concept of a plan.

It cracked me up as a fourth grade teacher because my kids would have never given me that. Honestly Tim, I think you got a tough job here because you've got to play whack a mole. You've got to pretend that Donald Trump didn't deliver rising take home pay, which of course he did. You've got to pretend that Donald Trump didn't deliver lower inflation, which of course he did.

And then you've simultaneously got to defend Kamala Harris's atrocious economic record. Well this hour we're getting more reaction to this debate from our team of political watchers as well as from voters. Right now we have the first results from our instant poll of the bait watchers and the tag giants over the number. Yeah, Anderson, I just should note at the top, this is not a poll of registered voters or likely voters overall.

This is a poll of registered voters who watched the debate. So I just want to make clear that it's about a third Democrat, a third Republican, a third independent in our sample. Overall, about 5 percentage points more democratic than a poll of registered voters nationwide would be. So keep that in mind as we look at these results of debate watchers.

First, foremost, who won the debate? It was basically an even split. 51% of debate watchers say Vance won. 49% say WALLS won.

What about expectations versus reality? So who did you think was going to win the debate? Before the debate, 45% said Vance would win, 54% said WALLS and you see it ended up 51% to 49% of Vance. Best in expectations, WALLS underperformed expectations of this group of debate watchers going into the debate.

And I just want to show you how this scorecard stacks up to recent vice presidential debates. You see here it looks more in the realm of 2016 and 2012. This was not an outsized, lopsided victory the way we saw in 2020 or 2008. Roughly even here in how the debate watchers in this poll saw this debate tonight, Amazon.

All right, I'm telling you, I'm just going to say back here with the team in New York. Scott Jennings, actually, what do you think? What stood out to you? We haven't heard from you tonight.

Yeah, the thing that stood out to me the most and that I've been seeing in my Twitter feed in my group chats is that J.D. Vance says, Hey, you weren't going to fact check me. You weren't going to call me out that I'm lying to the American people. And I thought that was interesting because a lot of what J.D.

Vance had a good performance tonight, but a lot of what he said is not actually what the American people really were thinking or his actual policies are. And so I think that because he presented himself in such a compelling way, that's why he outperformed expectations from our snap pool. The American people thought he was going to come out and talk about cats and dogs like his running mate did, but he didn't do that. He presented himself like he has a reasonable position on abortion.

And so he favored better, I think, on the other side of the debate from our folks who watched his performance. Scott, were you surprised by the poll that it sort of seems revivantly? It's a slightly democratic sample. I mean, it's pretty clear Vance outclass walls tonight.

I mean, I was watching this and all I could think of was man walls are so in over his head. I mean, can you imagine this guy sitting in the White House situation room with that facial expression that's like 50% sheer terror and 50% extreme bafflement? I mean, it was amazing. A split screen difference between a competent Vance and a totally in over his head walls.

The answer on why he lied about his trips to China and the Tiananmen Square thing was probably the worst VP debate meltdown since Stockdale in 92. You know, who am I and why am I here? It was two and a half minutes of absolute terrible. For Vance, night of redemption, all the political media has told us that Vance was a terrible pick and walls was going to bring in all these voters.

That charade is now over. Walt does not belong at this level of American politics. Vance does. Final verdict.

Tim Walz wandered into the wrong bar tonight. We missed you, Scott. You got it. You got it.

You got it. I'm going to get warm. I'm going to say he's got it. He's got some time to talk.

That's several hours there. There was a split screen effect. I agree with you. But it was the split screen between the JD Vance who's out there on the stump and the JD Vance who's on the debate stage.

And he put on a great performance tonight. I think he was very, very good. He came out there. He wanted to be reasonable.

He wanted to be cordial. He wanted all of the sort of acid lines that he delivers on the road he didn't deliver. And he probably profited from that. You said, and I agreed on it.

If you were here earlier, I said if I were walls I would have delivered that line about Tiananmen Square, that answer in Chinese. And it would have been more understandable than the one he gave. But when you look at a dial group of this debate, the things that did the worse, Scott, were two things. His January 6th answer, worse than anybody.

And his abortion. And saying he never supported a national abortion ban because people know that's not true. So that was one place where he couldn't do the split screen effectively because people knew too much. Listen, do I think Josh Shapiro maybe would have been a more formidable opponent up there?

Would you dance? Absolutely. That's just simply a fact. It took Waltz a while to get his footing in this debate.

But I think actually both Waltz and Vance did incredibly effectively, and I think that's why you see this basically split down the middle. Is they talked about their personal stories, their humble beginnings, and then use that to say, we understand your struggles and we're going to have solutions to solve them. And it just brings us kind of back to where we started here, which is this is a hyperclose race by the hair it's going to be decided. And this is not going to move the needle.

Don't you think that on these VP debates though, there's two issues. One, does this person look like they're capable of stepping into the job? Waltz totally failed on Vance Rose of the occasion. The other thing is people are evaluating Trump and Harris on their choices.

And up until now we've been told what a terrible choice Trump made and what an inspired choice Harris made. And now the veil is off. The charade is over. And I think it calls into question.

I mean she's got a staff, the whole government. This was her first choice. No, I mean I hear you're talking point about he's, you know, you're not attacking him, he's not a good governor. You're saying that he's terrible governor.

He doesn't look apart. Look, Vice President Obama's debate, like people have said it's a do no harm. Tim won't do harm tonight. Also at the end of like when we started really talking about domestic policies, abortion, J.D.

Vance's answers were empty. They're all we have to do better. We had he didn't tell actually what his policy was. He says that like our party is not doing well on this issue and rather than saying like we need to change our policy, just win in circles.

And then Tim Walts came back and actually said what the overwhelming majority of people actually want the abortion policy to be is to at least restore a row. Yes, that is why in J.D. Vance's state my home state, J.D. Vance's the overwhelming population of Ohio voted against J.D.

But then he didn't say what his position would be. He said they don't like what I believe, but I'm not going to tell you what I believe. Two things on abortion. Walts totally lied about the post-abortion infant bill.

Totally lied about that. Number two, he totally sidestepped the question about what restrictions do you prefer. Just like here, I mean he essentially ratified the position which is no restrictions. I thought Vance talked about the issue with some compassion and he acknowledged the political reality in Ohio which he just brought up.

I couldn't believe it. He was a masterful pivot by Vance. I think he won the exchange. On the support thing because I do not think that's what the Minnesota law says.

I think Republicans would stop saying they're allowing babies to be killed once they're born. Why not talk about the fact which is actually a valid point? Babies are now being resuscitated 23 weeks. They've lived in the NICU at that point.

That's where you could start the conversation if you want some restrictions on abortion. I feel like J.D. Vance is actually right to say Republicans are completely in the wrong space around the issue of reproductive rights. But he didn't offer the right solution or even identify with the proper policy.

You guys have shown solicitude for the victims of policies that he supports. They're so giving credit for solicitude. The policies may be not. I just had this thing in Minnesota.

There were eight deaths among infants who survived abortion attempts during ten walls as tenure as governor. It happened. They don't want to talk about the fact that it happened. But there were children.

First of all, let me ask you a question since you've deeply researched this. What were the condition of these babies when they were born? What was the participation of the family? You survived the abortion and they died.

You think that families casually tossed them aside. Tell me what their condition was. They have survived the decision. Was it a case of the families not wanting children to suffer when they were told that they are doomed?

Yes. That is the reality. But you know what? Here's what I was saying.

Keep talking about that. When you all talk about abortion like this, it is when women and that gender gap continues to divide not in your favor. Because women, it is disrespectful to pretend like women are making choices about abortion that is intent to just let a baby die at nine months. Let me finish this here.

And it is this honest for JD Vance to go up there and try and push that narrative. And that is what I'm saying when I said he presented well, but his policies and what he was saying was not truthful. It just wasn't. And that is why the overwhelming American people, since Roe has been overturned, you guys are not winning.

You are not winning. And if you run on this issue, you will not win in November. They are not running on this issue. They are running on it.

They are running on it is up at the states. And they are running on Donald Trump's moderate position of some reasonable restrictions. They are running on this issue. You are one of your frequent go to points.

Kamala Harris said this in 2019, that is her position. Donald Trump said women should be punished if they had an abortion. Why shouldn't we hold him to that. You talk about his moderate position.

His moderate position has been adopted over the course of this campaign for purposes of this campaign. this campaign after he put the justices on the Supreme Court who overturned Roe, who've created a crisis for women who live in 20 states in this country. His position is moderate and it is in line with what I think most Americans have. Do you believe that when he said that women should be...

And I think Harrison Walsh had proven they cannot discuss even a single restriction that they want. Do you believe when he said women should be punished? Do you believe... Do you believe...

Do you believe... No, but he said it. Do you believe him when he said it? And at the time it was really criticized by the Republicans.

Did you believe him when he said it? I can tell you what Republicans believe, which is... I'm just asking you what Trump believes. I'm telling you what he's running on right now.

I know what he's running on right now. No, it's running on right now. He's not running on it because it's what he actually believes. If I couldn't articulate a single restriction, I would attack Trump.

This is what Kamala Harrison and Tim Walsh believes is that is none of your business what women do with their body. And so stay out of our doctors offices and stay out of our bed. Well, I guess I'd have to speak up with the babies. They're not here to speak with themselves.

Lord have mercy. Let's check back in with Jake in the DC. Jake. Anderson, Lord have mercy.

We are going to talk a little bit more about the poll, the Snapple. 51 to 49 percent. 51 percent. Vance won, 49 percent.

Walls won. That's two points difference with the margin of error. Five points, so basically a statistical tie. I'm still stuck on you quoting Uncle Jesse from Full House.

No, I was quoting, I was quoting Scott Jennings from Full House. But just ahead, more debate reaction. We're getting some additional results from our CNN incident. Plus we're going to check in once again with our panel of undecided voters in Michigan.

Stay with us. I'm CNN tech reporter Claire Duffy. This week on the podcast in terms of service, the idea of riding in a car with no driver can feel daunting. And this technology raises questions about safety and the future of transportation.

That's why I'm here with Nicole Gable, head of business development and strategic partnerships at WeMo. We've always been about safety. No distracted driving. No drunk driving.

We may follow the rules of the road. Listen to CNN's terms of service wherever you get your podcasts. We're going to try to enhance their favorable numbers. We're going to try to bring up the negatives of their opponents.

That was one of the things we were watching for. Take a look here. We asked people whether they have a favorable view of the candidate or not. Before the debate, Walt was at a plus 14.

So if you take his favorable minus, he was at a positive 14. After the debate, he's at plus 37. And look at Vance. He did a ton of progress on his favorable ratings.

We know he's been one of the most unpopular vice presidential picks out of the gate. But look at the good he did himself here. He went from a minus 22 favorable rating before the debate with this group of debate watchers to a minus three. We also asked for each one, is this person qualified to serve as president if necessary?

So Tim Walts, the governor of Minnesota. Before the debate, 62% said yes. After the debate, 65% said yes. So a slight improvement on that sort of commander in chief score.

Same question about Vance. Is he qualified to serve as president if necessary? Look at the good he did here. Only 50% of the bait watchers said yes before the debate.

That went up to 58% after the debate. Not as high as the Walts numbers. But again, this group of debate watchers is about 5% points more democratic overall than an overall registered voter population would be. Well, it's interesting.

So it's just basically it keeps with what we kind of thought they were doing after the debate. It was over which was they're trying to be likable. They're trying to be folksy. They're trying to be agreeable.

They're not trying to really attack each other all that much. And it looks like they both succeeded. Vance had a lot more work that needed to be done, but they both succeeded. They both succeeded.

Then I would just add to that it seemed like they were making a play for the middle at this debate and not just trying to drive out and throw out red meat for their bases. And that probably contributed to this as well. Probably makes sense. We also want to hear directly from some of the voters who had not yet made up their minds before watching tonight's debates.

CNN's Phil Madeline was sent to Michigan, battleground Michigan, joining us again right now alongside his panel of undecided voters. Phil, you've had a little more time to speak with these lovely seven individuals. What else are they telling you? Yeah, Jake, we're on the campus at Grand Valley State University, critical battleground state of Michigan.

We started this night with seven undecided voters. That number is now six. One of our individuals here is the site he's going to vote for Vice President Kamala Harris. But one of the things you guys haven't been able to see is we've really been talking about what we saw over the course of the last several hours.

And one of the issues that has had pretty inspired debate amongst this group is about health care. If something came up during the debate, we heard from Governor Tim Walms. This is what he said about the Affordable Care Act. But first, keep in mind, what you're seeing at the bottom of the screen is lines that will tell you how people are responding.

This sound in particular had a significant positive response. The pink lines are for the female voters, the blue lines are for the male voters. Listen. He ran on the first thing he was going to do on day one was to repeal Obamacare.

On day one, he tried to sign an executive order to repeal the ACA. He signed on to a lawsuit to repeal the ACA, but lost at the Supreme Court. And he would have repealed the ACA had it not been for the courage of John McCain to save that bill. So again, you could see it watch it live in real time on the bottom of your screen where you saw the pop.

Honest, I want to go to you because we introduced the world to your wife who is expecting last segment, congratulations as well. You also just became American citizen a few months ago. So this will be the first election you're voting in. But you've talked a lot about health care given the moment you're in in your life.

What do you see? So there are two main things that I really value about my family and our baby daughter that is being born soon. One is health and two is time. With health, like I want to be assured that my wife and daughter are going to be healthy and safe.

Time I would love to spend time with my daughter maybe through a medical leave. But for those two, it would be really unfortunate if I can't afford it in the first place. So any kind of assistant to that and to my family and to allow me to enjoy the health of my family as well as to spend time with my family would definitely help me decide with my vote. I hope the family knows it's a girl.

Congratulations. That's awesome. They didn't. That's breaking news.

I do want to step back with this group again. We noted we had seven on the side voters coming in. We have six now. For the six of you who have not decided, 35 days left.

I want to start with you. What's the main issue that you're going to be looking for to make that decision? Absolutely. Thank you.

So the biggest thing that I'm still looking at is foreign policy and international relations. Watching the debate today, it was touched on for maybe six minutes total, only on the breaking news that was happening in Iran today or in Israel today with Iran attacking them. I think that there's still so many issues at hand with international politics and seeing how our president or possible president and our vice president possibility would react to those situations. It's extremely crucial looking at Ukraine and Russia and looking at China and Taiwan.

Not just focusing on the attacks today, but kind of looking at international relations as a whole. It's still probably one of the heaviest part of my decision. Hope. What's the one issue you're keying on these last 35 days?

So coming into this debate, I was definitely focused on how trustworthy are the candidates. I think that's still my main issue. I thought this was a great civil debate and how trustworthy I think the candidates are grew for both of them, in my opinion. But the one thing that stuck out to me was Vance's refusal to say whether or not Trump lost the 2020 election and then also how he said that carbon may not cause climate change and kind of just his refusal to agree with those things that most people very clearly see makes me think he's not as trustworthy.

But I did like a lot of his other policies. All right. This was a great group democracy also the deciding factor for Ryan who did make up his mind. Hang out for a couple more hours just talking to Jake back to you.

Thanks Phil. Appreciate it. So that's interesting. A second member of this again, unscientific but still seven percent focused group of unsight about about it voters in battleground Michigan.

A second person really not liking J.D. Vance's answer in which he refused to acknowledge and to abide in one election in which he gaslight and pretended that Donald Trump had handed over power peacefully and that really bothered them. Democrats, we should know these people are not sitting there reading Twitter. They're in this focus group with Phil.

They're in kind of like a silent chamber. Yeah, exactly. And they don't know what's going on. They don't know how the political world, they're not getting texts from members of Congress.

I will tell you this when we were talking about this earlier. I did get a message from a Harris campaign person who said that they're already cutting that January 6 answer for an ad. So it has resonated and resonated in the information that they were receiving from their surveying undecided voters to try to see how this is landed. That was by far, I think Tim Walts' best moment and the worst moment for J.D.

Vance. But I think it also speaks to another aspect of this which is that J.D. Vance was trying to rehabilitate his own image and did so to a great degree. But that really hurt him.

That January 6 answer really hurt him. So we should know they both did themselves favors when it came to making a good impression on viewers. Walts' favorability rating among this group of people poll the snap hole from 14 percent net approval to 37 percent net approval. And J.D.

Vance went from negative 22 percent to negative 3 percent. Again, he had more of a haul. But still, that is progress. It's interesting also, Abby, what you said because so much of what the Trump and the RNC and Harris and the DNC, what they are doing right now and all their surrogates in the media and such are trying to win the post debate, trying to win the post debate, finding the clips, finding the bad moments for the other guy, the good moments for theirs, and mostly the bad moments for the other guy, and putting it out there on social media, on TikTok, in Facebook ads, all sorts of places that we won't even see it.

And that is a battle that is going on right now. Yeah. No. It's for the people who didn't sit and watch the entire debate.

Which is most of the American people. It's a lot of people, right. I mean, we know painfully so that a lot of people these days, especially younger people, get their information from the quick clips that they see online. But I will go back to this insta poll that David Challion just gave us.

Again, all the caveats, it's not registered voters, it's not likely voters, it's the people who watch the debate. Who are 5 percent points more likely to be Democrats than Republicans? Yes. And even with that caveat, especially the fact that both candidates, both of these vice presidential wannabes, did so much better with the likability factor.

And that's not nothing in today's politics. It really isn't. And I know that, you know, what we're doing is saying, well, Wallston answered this or Vance sort of glossed over that. But in a time when people are disgusted by politics, yes, it wasn't exactly, you know, totally factual because of the fact that they didn't correct each other all the time.

But the fact that they were cordial and by the end, Vance was calling him Tim and Wallston was calling him, yeah, Wallston is calling him Vance and they shook hands and the wives came up. And maybe it was cordial and maybe it was effectively do no harm for both candidates to a degree. But I do think that J.D. Vance had to make up some ground and clearly in our poll has showed that he did.

He's still a little bit underwater, but that was mainly what he had to do tonight and it looks like he did it. Because they had, we're going to give you more of our singing and instant pull of the vice presidential debate. Did this face off do anything to change voters minds about who they would support at the top of the ticket? Stay with us.

And welcome back to your watching this discussion coverage. We get more reactions. It's a nice vice presidential behavior in New York between Governor Tim Wallston and Senator James Vance. During the debate on Trump's busy sharing his thoughts on the truth socials he's going to do.

Let's get more on that from Kristen Holmes. So I have not looked myself, Kristen. What did he post on the what was going on? Well, interesting.

One of the things that was actually probably the most notable was the fact that he finally said that he would veto a national abortion ban if he was reelected into office. Now, this is what he posted during this debate between J.D. Vance and Tim Wallston. He said, everyone knows I would not support a federal abortion ban under any circumstances and would in fact veto it because it is up to the states to decide based on the will of their own voters.

Now, the real point in your Anderson is that not everybody knew that because during the last debate between Donald Trump and Kamala Harris, he was asked repeatedly he was pressed on the issue. Would you veto this ban if it came across your desk? And he refused to answer that. In fact, J.D.

Vance had said in an interview that Donald Trump would veto a national abortion ban if he was reelected. And when asked about that in the debate, he said he had it talked Trump said he hadn't talked to Vance about it. Not only that, he said, I don't think he was speaking for me. Later Vance said that he learned a lesson about speaking out ahead of Donald Trump.

But this really comes at a time again when Donald Trump has tried to walk this fine line when it comes to abortion. He knows it's not a political winner. He doesn't want to engage on the topic. But he also wants to take full credit for the overturning of Roe v.

Wade. One of the reasons we suspected told by some of Trump's closest allies that he wouldn't fully embrace this idea of a veto was because he wanted to appeal to the right. Clearly here he has moved a step further there saying he would in fact veto a national abortion ban if it came across his desk. Anderson.

All right, Chris, thanks very much. Right now let's take another look at some of the results from our brand new recent poll of debate watches. And I think the challenge is taking in for the numbers. David, when you were talking about this with Jake a short time ago, you showed some really interesting numbers that basically this debate improved the favorables for both candidates.

Both candidates kind of approval went up. Yeah, they definitely did some good work. Both of them did on that. Take a look at some more findings from our instant poll Anderson.

We asked who's more in touch with people like you. 48% of debate watchers say walls. 35% say JD Vance who shares your vision for America. Another walls win here.

48% say walls. 39% say Vance. This is really intriguing to me. Who did a better job of defending their running mate?

You know sort of bolstering the top of the ticket? Well, here Vance scores best. 37% say he did a better job of that. 33% said walls and 27% said both of them did a good job.

That only 3% said neither of them did. Did the debate affect your presidential choice? Right. We talk about does a VP debate matter?

Well, here's your answer. Only 1% said that it changed their mind. 1% of Harris supporters, 1% of Trump supporters say it changed their mind. So the answer there is overwhelmingly minds were not changed by this debate Anderson.

All right, David Gillian back with the team here in New York. It is interesting to see these numbers because for all of the concerns about well JD Vance, you know, was or walled for Democrats that walls was you know, not up to the job of debating. I mean, their favor abilities both went up. Look, I think they both sort of played to their strength.

Right. JD Vance is a professional public personality. Like he's excellent on TV shows and comfortable in an arena like this. Walts is a very genuine, authentic guy.

And he speaks in a language and an idiom that people here, I was looking at some numbers from a focus group. And it reflects exactly what this was a dial group, exactly what was said here. And Walts made more progress than Vance. Neither presidential candidate gained much from their performance.

So, you know, professional political commentators can say what they will, but people judge through a different lens and they see in Walts kind of authenticity and genuineness and identification with them. Do you think this changes also given what you know about the former president that calculus about whether there be another debate presidential debate? I still think there's a chance that Donald Trump wants to do another presidential debate, even though JD Vance performed well, I think he likes to have the final word. I think he loves a camera and he sees the benefits of getting in front of one.

So if this is still neck and neck, I could absolutely see him deciding to do one. This, I think what this underscores is that the public is so thirsty for a little bit of civility and decency on our politics. And JD Vance has never made that kind of a capstone of who he is in American life, but tonight he showed a different side of him. Why he can't behave this way more often is beyond me, but I think people were just happy to see handshakes introducing spouses acknowledging each other, showing empathy, things that we really did not see in the presidential debate.

And by the way, if we have another presidential debate, I don't think we're going to see it again. Enjoy what lasted folks. Do you think this doesn't change? You don't think this changes the game at all?

I don't think it changes the outcome of the election. I don't think, but I do think it can give you some opportunity. It's like, so Tim Walz, go out and start communicating with people having more direct conversations. I even think he should do a few more interviews with different publications, more local than, don't look at me like that.

It's the point of doing that to get better for the debate. No, no, because I don't think these debates are determinative of voters' behavior, particularly vice presidential debate. I think that voters will read their local newspaper. So if Tim Walz goes and has a conversation, goes to an ice cream shop or a pizza shop or whatever, and has a conversation with a local newspaper, he can get his message out there.

What I will say though is that I do wish he would have pushed back a little bit more on JD Vance, the way Kamala Harris showed up and pushed back and knocked out Donald Trump. Even during the Harris debate, she clearly had thought of, or their team had thought about the cutaway shots of her watching, because these debates are just split-screen debate. It doesn't seem like there was any thought given to this one. For JD Vance, it seemed like there was thought given it to him because he had the same kind of expression of sort of a slight smile, sort of listening, not really, you know, just stipulating and reacting.

Walz was just sort of turn fully looking. It was not... He did look at the moderators every time he wanted to say something. When I was watching it on television, it was kind of like a pick me kind of teacher at moment.

I felt like from him, which was a little weird, but... I mean, he didn't like do the jazz hands or whatever, which he does it a lot of the rally, so that was a step in the right direction from a theatrical perspective. Walz, I mean, I don't understand something. Why is it that...

I mean, he's like a serial exaggerator or fabricator of his own personal narrative. He's been asked about it twice, once by Danne Besh, once in this debate. And in both cases, he sort of defaulted to some, like in Danne's case, it was, I don't have a good grammar tonight. I think he said, you know, well, I'm just a knucklehead.

Like, why can't you just sort of own up to it? I don't understand. I know you said people who is authentic and that, you know, this is just who he is, but he has clearly gone way over the line on his own personal narrative, something that only he would know the facts of. And he's done it repeatedly.

And when asked about it, effectively, he's just like, well, I'm... No, look, there are... There's no doubt that there are places where, you know, for example, on the gun thing, we... I don't know whether you were here when we talked about this earlier, whether we were on the air, but he was...

There was video at one event in which he misspoke, didn't put in literature, didn't put in an ad. There's no... So far as we know another example of it, he misspoke. You can call it as part of serial exaggeration.

I agree with you, though. Be straightforward. Own up to it. But if you're going to be concerned about serial exaggeration and misstatements and biographical rewriting and so on, it's really hard to sit here as an advocate for Donald Trump.

You're right. Somebody in the press should absolutely spend a lot of time focusing on Donald Trump and all the things he said. Look, of course, of course, you're right. But walls, why is he held to a different standard?

Why is it okay for him to just kind of sluff it off when it's not really okay for... I'm sorry, I'm not asking. I'm not asking. I know what you're giving him here.

I mean, you got... No one seems to care. Like, you care deeply about every time Donald Trump does something like this, and I'm the first one to admit that he does it, but you don't seem to care as much when... I'll tell you what I cared about tonight.

I cared about the way JD Vance presented Donald Trump's role relative to January 6th. That was more than a slight exaggeration. That was a complete rewriting of history on something that was a heck of a lot more serious than some of the things that that Walts has said. I'll still head.

Rich Vice President Kennedy, if you're farther from the truth tonight, we'll go ahead debate backtrack that. Here in Manhattan, Senator JD Vance and Governor Tim Walts just wrapped up their vice presidential debate, effectively getting the last word in this race for the White House before an audience this large. Unless, of course, Donald Trump and Kamala Harris agree to debate again before Election Day figures crossed. We've made the invitation.

Harris has accepted. Tonight's debate was civil. The question of how factual it was is another matter. Let's find out from our fact-checker Daniel Dale.

What do you think, Daniel? It certainly wasn't a perfect debate from Governor Walts from a fact-checker's perspective, but I think there was more in accuracy from Senator Vance, and I think Vance had the two biggest whoppers of the night, both of them actually in what he left out rather than what he said. Listen to his claims about Trump's post-election behavior in 2020 and early 2021. He said that on January the 6th, the protesters ought to protest peacefully.

And on January the 20th, what happened? Joe Biden became the president. Donald Trump left the White House. He peacefully gave over power on January the 20th.

This is a pretty wild rewriting of history. Trump peacefully gave over power on January the 20th. Sure, Trump did not like lock himself in the Oval Office, but he left office after trying extremely hard to not give over power. We all know this.

He tried to manipulate everyone from the American public to state elections officials, to state legislators, to the Justice Department, to his very own vice president. He helped trigger a deadly riot. And then a fence that Trump called for peaceful protest on January 6th. Yes, Trump did that once in that January 6th speech after calling supporters to Washington with a promise it would be wild, spending weeks whipping them into a frenzy with lies about the election.

Vice President Pence has non-existent power to overturn the result. And then in that same January 6th speech, using combative language far more often than that calming language, saying things like, if you don't fight like hell, you're not going to have a country anymore. When you catch somebody in a fraud, you're allowed to go by very different rules. You'll never take back our country with weakness on and on.

Now, let's turn to another egregious distortion of history from Senator Vance. This one on Obamacare. When Obamacare was crushing under the weight of its own regulatory burden and healthcare costs, Donald Trump could have destroyed the program instead. He worked in a bipartisan way to ensure that Americans had access to affordable care.

Casting Donald Trump as the savior of Obamacare, I think is bananas. Donald Trump tried very hard to repeal Obamacare. The only reason it was not repealed in 2017 was because he barely couldn't find enough Republican votes in Congress. And then he tried to undermine Obamacare in various ways.

He cut the open enrollment period in half. He slashed funding for advertising for people who helped other Americans sign up. He ended a key set of subsidies for insurers. His administration refused to defend some critical provisions of the law in court, instead arguing that they should indeed be invalidated.

I could go on. So, yes, Trump did keep operating the Obama exchanges. He didn't completely give up on it. But casting him as a savior of Obamacare, I think Jake is pretty dishonest.

All right, Daniel, thanks so much. Really appreciate it. Those were some fairly stark, I mean, in politics, we get used to people fiving and bellishing, but those were some pretty direct, black-as-white-day-as-night gaslighting examples. The idea that Donald Trump supported a peaceful transfer of power, the idea that Donald Trump tried to save Obamacare.

Yeah, I mean, it's too clever by half. It's just straight up not true. But that is actually what JD Vance is there to do. I mean, he's there to be the person who can do sort of Trumpism in a way that sounds nice to more people and is more polished.

And in many ways, I mean, talking to many Republicans over the last several months, there are a lot of Republicans who make the case for Trump's candidacy way better than Trump himself does. Trump rarely executes these arguments in ways that are coherent. And Vance has been really the only person out there doing it for him. And tonight, he did it.

Look, I think that they kind of both ended up net positive at the end of this. But there were some key moments there that I think will sort of let slide and allow Vance to improve his reputation with voters a little bit. Just so our viewers, I just want to make sure that people understand. You can come over.

We're live on CNN. This is trying to insult comic Robert Smigold's brainchild and was floating around behind. And I just want to make sure people understood. It's me, Ma.

I'm JD's me, Ma. So I don't know that you're Mike. All right. I'm Mike.

We're not going to make fun of getting Vance's grandmother, but we do appreciate the comedy, comedy, artistry of Robert Smigold and triumph with it. Thank you. Well, how about the holster? I'm here to speak for the JD Vance.

So good to see you. Thank you. Back to the topic at hand. JD Vance is doing what Donald Trump wants him to do, what the campaign wants him to do.

And when you heard Donald Trump doing earlier in the night say, that was a master class, that is exactly why they wanted JD Vance in that role. Right. But the JD Vance on the debate stage tonight is not the JD Vance we have seen on the campaign trail at rallies doing the interviews that he's been doing. It's just not.

I mean, he has been very much trying to defend and explain Donald Trump's positions tonight. He's lost over the controversial positions that Donald Trump has. But when it comes to abortion, number one, when it comes to Obamacare, the issues that Donald Trump disagrees with Kamala Harris on that are very popular with a lot of swing voters. Vance pretended like it wasn't a difference at all.

CNN's Caitlin Collins is going to pick up our debate coverage along with an update on the crisis in the Middle East after this break. Thanks for watching. This is CNN meteorologist Derek Van Damne, thrilled to introduce the new CNN weather app be prepared for anything with comprehensive coverage from real experts like me. Download the CNN weather app on iOS today.

Hey, I'm Anderson Cooper. On my podcast, all there is we explore grief and loss in all its complexities. As Ken Burns said on an earlier podcast, the half life of grief is endless. Mariska Hargate knows that very well.

Jane Mansfield was killed in a car crash in 1967. Mariska was in the car with her after decades spent coming to terms with her past and wanting to learn more about the mother she doesn't remember. Mariska has made a remarkable documentary called My Mom Jane. Our vulnerability is our greatest strength and our greatest connector.

And so in telling the story, I don't feel vulnerable. I feel free. We all have a story and you never know what somebody else carries. Talking grief, building community.

That's what the podcast is all about. This is all there is. Listen and follow wherever you get your podcasts.

Frequently asked questions

How long is this episode of Anderson Cooper 360?

This episode is 45 minutes long.

When was this Anderson Cooper 360 episode published?

This episode was published on October 2, 2024.

Is there a transcript available for this episode?

Yes, a full transcript is available for this episode. You can read the complete transcript on the episode page.

Can I download this Anderson Cooper 360 episode?

Yes. Use the download control on the episode player to save the publisher-provided media file.