A safer Ontario means more police and prosecutors making sure my card doesn't get stolen. It means building new jails to keep criminals behind bars. And it means there's no need to worry when I play at the park. We're making every corner of Ontario safer to make all of Ontario safer.
That's how we protect Ontario. For all of us. Learn how at Ontario.ca.ca.ca. Pay for it by the Government of Ontario.
And welcome to Fourth Estate, a show about journalism. We are coming to you from 2SER in Sydney on the Gadigal lands of the Eora nation, right across Australia on the Community Radio Network. And directly to your device across the globe via podcast. I'm Aline Even.
The Australian Government announced their fourth federal budget this week. As journalists poured over the many, many pages in the budget lockup, it wasn't a surprise in a pre-election budget that there would be a cash splash. Today we focus on the media coverage of federal budgets. Is the media actually making the budget into a giant monster, gobbling up all our attention for weeks on end, when budgets are in reality or steer and largely boring documents?
Through the prism of winners and losers, a cash splash here and a budget cut there, how do journalists get through the fine print and present the budget? To discuss this and more, we are joined by two journalists, Kishaw Napia Raman, Federal Politics reporter, Krikey and Michael Rodan, national correspondent at the Australian Financial Review. Welcome both back to Fourth Estate. Hey, how's it going?
Good to be here. So the budget lockup is a unique event where journalists are stuck in a room with six hours without any internet to go over the budget papers. If we put the actual content of the budget aside for a moment, what is that actual experience like to report in that way? Look, six hours without my phone is really difficult, but jokes aside, not being able to have internet and that kind of thing does make it a little bit more difficult.
I think on the other hand, if you didn't have maybe that ritual of being in the lockup for six hours before, you'd lose two things. I think firstly, maybe the budget wouldn't be seen as quite as important by some media as it already is. I think that whole sense of ritual kind of elevates it a little bit. But I think the other thing on the flip side of that is maybe you won't get the kind of depth in terms of coverage.
I think when you've got six hours to stare at the budget papers, literally not doing anything else because you're locked in a room, you can sort of dig into the weeds a lot more than people might. If they're not in that room and having to cover other things and whatever, does that make sense? It certainly does. Is that the same experience for you, Michael?
Yeah, sort of. Get your eyes not wrong. The entire process is sort of like a ridiculous anachronism in the internet age. Basically, it's unfair more to think that if on any other normal day, the government could lock up hundreds of journalists in one room, take away all their devices and give them a stack of documents that are made by the government without being able to go outside and talk to anyone else about what's in them.
And then that's all you get to do for the days. You just have to do this. It's crazy because the government sort of set this thing up as a way to sort of massage the message that it's giving to everyone. And the budget in the years gone by was quite a big deal.
The ratings on television were much more ory oaks would get the scoop and have the first interview afterwards. But now it's a bit more rigmarole. There's drapes and drabs of the budget announcements that are leaked out beforehand. We basically knew everything that was in the documents this time before we went in.
And then once you're in there, you just have to sort of, it's almost like dictation. There's some interesting detail throughout the books which probably go to the length of a few hundred pages. But in reality, if all the announcements have been made beforehand, the documents are really just sort of an amalgamation of forecasts that may not ever come to fruition and a couple of speeches where the government dictates to the journalists that it's doing amazing things. And they're all sort of, they're political documents in a sense, but the entire sort of apparatus of the budget day is just another way for the politicians to sort of control the message.
The good thing about this part was that the ratings were pretty dismal. I think everyone sort of tuned out of it. So the longer it goes on, I guess the more people lose interest in it. Yeah, shocking people are more interested in watching maths than drabs bechlust the other night.
You kind of mentioned there, Michael, that the lockup had this purpose of not leaking information to influence markets. And that was the purpose of the lockup. Now that we have information already announced ahead by the government and markets are becoming much more sophisticated and complex. Does it make sense to have the lockup now?
Is it just a bit of theatre? Well, a couple of years ago, the government put a $6 billion tax on the banks, called the Major Bank Levy. And that was an actual market sensitive. I think if word got out about that, it would cause stop prices to fall, which is what happens because there was a leak on Sky News the night before.
And during the day, the bank share started panicking and then the financial review followed up on it because someone got information out somehow. They did a big sort of investigation that came to naught because it probably came from a senior treasury official or something like that. I also had a little, a couple of years ago, had a little budget scoop that was deemed market sensitive, although in retrospect, I don't think it was. But when I was going around trying to confirm it ahead of time, I'd call up official contacts and everything like that and notice we cannot talk to you about this.
And so they take it pretty seriously. In that respect, there does need to be some sort of limit on the information that comes out. But in terms of, in today's age, you don't need seven hours to lock journalists up to not be able to talk to their contacts or to get outside and buy some things. You just upload it to the internet and everyone gets it at the same time and they can go through it.
So when a company announces something that's market sensitive to the Australian Stock Exchange, they don't lock it up and give it to people ahead of time. They just say, here it is. And it's now public, so everyone has equal access to it and equal opportunity. And it might be that the computers can read these documents faster than financial traders can and high-frequency trading can do this and that.
But generally, it's like these things aren't big enough to move the dial anything. Senically, I'd have to say that it's just a matter of the government wanting to have the focus entirely on itself to the exclusion of all other critical voices. Do you agree, Kishol? Obviously, the whole budget, the service is very much about the government controlling the messaging.
And look, the purpose of the lockup does seem to kind of fall away when this was like Michael Smith's internet, utterly predictable budget. I mean, when you was going to be a kind of pre-election cash splash, a lot of the things that made it. So we're kind of teased and eventually dropped into the media in the days, weeks before. So like, you know, all that kind of headline stuff is already really out there.
You kind of have a sense of what the narrative is going to be like, at least this one. So yeah, it does seem to be an element of utility and sitting through that six hour lockup sometimes. Yeah, it is a kind of it is about the government controlling, their string controlling, and everything that kind of thing. But I think even then, what was interesting, it was sort of in the coverage that followed on Tuesday night and on, you know, despite what the government was, so yes, we're to do in sort of making this budget look big and generous and that kind of thing.
I think there was a bit of understandable criticism that sort of how sickle the whole purpose of this budget was that a lot of people calling it out as a cash splash. I saw the word bribe using one of the coverage as well. So I don't know, it felt like maybe they'd been so obvious and telegraphing what this was about that it kind of opened its open the government up to a bit of critical coverage. But then again, you know, when no one's actually watching the budget out on TV that night, and that kind of thing, I wonder how much of that kind of critical coverage is actually going to feel to go to the regular punter and what messaging people are actually going to take away from the budget itself and whether that actually changes any votes and so on and so on.
Yeah, it was interesting. Like you sure it says, the whole thing was sort of just like this gift wrap sort of pre-election splash and the rating, there was a good story by Samantha Maven that looked at the ratings of the overnight and usually the Treasurer's speech at 730 is the big one that rated 12th of its time, so way behind maths and behind a show on Channel 10 about, you know, rescue dogs or something like that. What was interesting was that the government actually dropped at 6pm news that it was going to give out in the budget, so this is before the journalists around, they can talk about what's in it. So before anyone was out there, the government drops this story to all of the commercial stations that everyone was going to get, you know, the $420 or $250 if you're a pensioner payment and so they did that, so it would make the 6pm news buildings which have about double the viewership that the 730 speech got.
So it's like, the whole thing is just sort of falling apart and we're seeing the politicians react differently to it because they know they can't compete with Mary the first side or rescue dogs on Channel 10. Yeah, I guess the other point there as well is, you know, if the budget is about sort of, you know, media control, it's very much about media control and a kind of outdated, an update of you about how people are internalising news, like the days of people sitting down and watching terrestrial TV or news buildings are really kind of like, you know, I mean, maybe some people are, but a lot of people aren't anymore, and especially my younger viewers, although I'm not sure how much the government cares about younger voters, but you know, especially my younger viewers, there's a lot of people aren't doing that, not consuming news information the same way, it's the idea of this like 730 ritual, everyone sits down at the TV to watch the treacherous speech. I don't know, it seems like something from the 90s, I don't know if that's going to change anytime soon, but certainly one of the incentives and the reasoning behind presenting it in that way seem to be, you know, related to a reality in terms of news viewership that doesn't really exist anymore. It's an interesting point to talk about how we're presenting it with getting attention in like that nightly bulletin.
It's fair to say that a lot of people tune into the budget coverage primarily to see how it's going to affect them, and then I suppose looking at issues that are important to them, which cues the, who are the winners and losers of this budget article, I want to ask you both, what is the impact of presenting the budget through this winners and losers lens? If I want to go first, then I guess, you know, it's obviously problematic because it sets up sort of, even when there's sort of sewage policy, you know, there's always going to be losers because the budget sort of, it's not a zero or something, but basically there has to be someone paying money if there's money going out the other end. And so I do think that it is quite reductive in one sense, but then again, we're trying to get the public to be interested in this incredibly boring document. So telling them what they might get out of it is one way that people actually do connect and, you know, they might read further and, you know, so on and so forth.
The problem, I guess, on framing it like that, I think it works both ways, it's because it does sort of cause haywire for when you actually need to do good things that there was some tax changes made in the 2016 budget that affected people with superannuation savings over two, no, sorry, yeah, $3.2 million if you're a couple. And it was such a small change, but it just led to sort of months and months and months and coverage and, you know, apparently even sort of hampered Turnbull's reelection prospects in that election. And that's sort of bad when you're going around telling, you know, rich retirees, if they're losers, even if they're extremely comfy and whatnot. But then, you know, like this year, there was nothing in the coverage.
And I was looking at a couple of like the winners and losers sort of tables that were in various things. And, you know, it was like, in one of them, like there was just nothing to go on this year, it was just, it was such a nothing budget. But one of the tables was like, who would have loses electric vehicles, I loses. And I was like, I didn't know that they were like, do electric vehicles pay tax?
Not at all. You know, it's like, I think it's sort of like, it's a meme that sort of jumped the shark by now because it's just, you know, it's just beyond its use, I guess. Yeah, I think we certainly had some discussion about what we have to do at all. I mean, there's often an element of, well, everyone's doing it.
It's a sort of box-teak budget story that it is kind of do. I do think sometimes like actually looking for losers itself is rather than winners necessarily is an interesting way of attacking a budget, particularly, you know, one like this, obviously really trying to be as generous as possible. And when as many votes as possible, you know, trying to find which sort of smores and go as well as they could have, like higher education, wasn't great for them. It hasn't been for the last couple of years.
But even then, the losers were few and far between. Look, I think it can be reductive. And then, like Michael said though, if the point is like trying to communicate what's in the budget papers, what's really, or if they're going to be reading the budget papers, those kind of graphics that you can have with me as a loser, it's kind of a good way to get engagement. And you can see the attraction for a news organisation to sort of fall back on that as a way of communicating things.
Yeah, and you think about the 2014 budget, Tony Abbott's first one with Joe Hockey, it was like the loser list on that thing was, you know, longer than a roll of toilet paper. It was everyone who was, and it just energised the whole sort of mood of the electorate against that government. And Tony Abbott never got clear arrogant after that. And some of it went to like, you know, $100,000 degrees, putting dull bludges on, you know, cutting them off after six months, things like that.
And it just, you know, it lit a fire under, you know, all these sort of like activism groups and unions and whatnot. And so in that way, it probably, reporting it in terms of winners and losers like that is probably helpful in giving the public a sense of the overall political feel of the document. And after all, it's a political thing, you know, it has to pass parliament if too many people are losers, then they're going to tell their elected representatives not to pass it, and they won't. So it's not a budget after all, you know.
That's the other point of those losers, but it's not actually lose out. If I'm from the stuff in it doesn't get through and, you know, if it's too antagonistic, like a lot of that that budget was, then yeah, it's going to struggle. I think the 2014 budget is a really interesting example. The overall response, the next morning, wasn't actually very negative at all.
But then Ross Giddens, for instance, gave it a high grade, later he reversed his position. It took over a week for the full story to break. And in the end, it became an incredibly toxic one for the government. Was 2014 an outlier or has the media learned some lessons from that budget?
Michael, I'll go to you. It's an interesting question. I think that the 2014 budget was the last time the government ever tried to do anything sort of that resembled inverted comments reform. You know, it was a really ambitious sort of document.
And I think it came off the back of that commission of audit that Tony did when he first came in. Since then, I think everyone's got pretty scared of policies that might leave the electorate a bit unnerved. The interesting thing is, it might have taken a couple of days or a week for it to really sort of like crystallizing people's minds. But on budget night, the first interview that Joe Hockey went along to as Treasurer that evening was Laurie Yokes.
And the first question Laurie Yokes asked him was, why were you caught dancing in your office to the best day of the song, the best day of my life with your son when you're cutting this, you're cutting that and you're putting welfare recipients, you know, you're cutting one of five to six months. And it's just like, it was just this perfect sort of like snapshot of the electorate's mood of this budget. And they never recovered from it. And so it's like, you know, considering gagging about how budget coverage is becoming increasingly meaningless.
But sometimes those little moments do just sort of set the tone for the for the for the rest of the year, you know. Yeah, look, I was in first year, you knew when that budget was handed down. So I can't say I was paying quite so much attention to like media coverage as I would be now. That said, yeah, look, I think my point there, which is that, you know, it was the last time really you got a budget that was, you know, without obviously like, necessarily endorsing what the advert was trying to do, just like quite bold and big in terms of what he was putting out there.
And you know, ever since then, all the ones I've kind of just been really, really predictable, I want to say, like, just, you know, you kind of know exactly what you're going to get. I love it's been dropped. You kind of it's so tethered to kind of what the political and obviously all budgets are, but what the immediate political program of the government is at the time. And yeah, I do think the response to that advert budget really has sort of made the elements a bit wary about how much they're going to give away, and how I think ideological we're going to make the budget.
So look, it'll be interesting as well on that note to see that was obviously the first budget after a change of government after two terms of labor. Labor have said that they want to do another budget later this year, they get really like, which I really hope they don't because I've tapped to leave us alone. Just like, just wait a little bit. But it'll be interesting to see a, you know, what they do, you know, that budget, whether they do, you know, signal a big transformation of the country and, you know, everything they've done before leading up to the election suggests they want to finally say.
And again, how the media does choose to cover that budget and have a tackle a change in government. So, you know, if that comes about, it'll be an interesting time. Okay, I have a scenario for you both. You two have just been made editors.
When it comes to your budget analysis, what would you like to see covered in the media that doesn't receive as much attention? Because I'll go to you first. God, we might be in it. Yeah, no, I'm also not an editor.
But look, if I did, I would hope that the analysis dug a little bit further in the Treasurer's speech. Obviously, the speech is the big thing that signals where the government is going, but I would want maybe more coverage that really delved into specialist topic areas. And I think that's maybe a problem that you sometimes have in media itself, you know, just by the industry, shrinking over the last couple of years and whatnot. You don't have a heap of like specialist knowledge in certain areas.
I'd like a lot of kind of that kind of thing. So, you know, you have someone who's really clearly on climate doing the climate coverage the same with defense. And you know, you have that a little bit, but I'd like to see more of that and look at it through the prism of those kind of areas. If I was editor, you know, which I don't want to be, I would opt to, I would willingly lose my job by not covering the budget or I just send, you know, one or two people and run it on the inside of, you know, down page 16 or something like that.
I just, I think that it plays too much into the government's hands. And if they aren't going to take these documents seriously, which they increasingly don't, I don't think it's worth just giving them like a huge amount of, like you look at the coverage of the papers, it's, you know, it's the Treasurer, Josh Fryne, burgle in front of everything. The wrap around is, you know, 16 pages sometimes. It's increasingly boring and it's just, it's messaging, messaging by the government.
And because the only things you can quote from these speeches that are handed to you with the name of the minister on the top, more and more, it's just, you know, I don't want to, if I was editor, I wouldn't want to run sort of like a proctor operation. I don't think that the way that we cover these budgets is suitable for the really overtly political documents that they become. That's not very likely to the extent that there is interesting stuff in there. There was plenty interesting in the budget papers in spite of, you know, what they are trying to do with them.
But you know, one of that stuff is the kind of minutiae, the fine print that only comes through a lot of, you know, digging in parts and how ones are looking at it. And you know, that stuff is interesting, you know, maybe to me it's interesting. But but also, you know, I think it's often more interesting than the stuff that really means the coverage, which is, you know, just like Michael says, quite almost verbatim, just quality of the Treasurer's speech, putting out what they want you to put out, what all the generous handouts are going to look like and that kind of thing. So, you know, there's a lot in there.
I would necessarily avoid covering it completely. But, you know, I think there's just going to be like a little bit of, you know, maybe specialisation out of coverage looks and maybe just a bit of like, I don't know, awareness of what the point of this whole circus is. And going on from that, when you're talking about, I guess, holding account beyond just the speeches or the media releases, the federal budget reflects what the government's plan is. It puts their full values on display.
What role do you think journalists have to connect the dots between what the government says they'll do versus what they actually do in terms of the budget? Yeah, it's with this one. I mean, it's shown that the government's plan is get reelected. Like, there's just nothing really beyond that.
There's no thought beyond that. There's no real policy or even ideology, despite this being a conservative government beyond that. And they've kind of, they've kind of shown that, you know, a lot over the last term, especially the last year, that that really is their kind of the start and end point of what they're about. You know, it's tough because, you know, as generalist, this kind of, this, I guess, both sides isn't the profession.
This desire to sit in the middle and not editorialise too much. And I think while, you know, maintaining that stance of objectivity, while also bringing critical analysis to a budget and to something that is primarily about government speed, is always like a kind of slightly difficult type rope for people to walk. That's it. I've actually thought, you know, a lot of the coverage this year, I think I find this earlier has actually been pretty good to the extent that it has that have been fairly blunt in calling out this budget for what it is, which is primarily just a thing designed to like fix up some short-term political problems, make the government that has been struggling in the polls for a while look as palatable and as generous as possible and just get them reelected.
And then it's like, I don't even know what the hell happens after that. I don't really seem to know what's happening after that. So, look, I think the media has been decent at connecting the dots. It would be interesting to see how they cover a hypothetical fourth college in London Morrison because I don't really know what they're going to do.
They don't really seem to know what they're going to do either. Yeah, I think that's a good point because, you know, when you open up the documents and says, we're doing this, this, this, you know, I think the government also knows at this point as well as that, you know, they've got a hostile Senate and they have for, you know, God knows how long they are. Whatever they say that they're planning to do, it's always, you know, a great deal of horse trading to get anything through the Senate at the moment. And you look at the legislative record of not just the Morrison, but the Turnbull and the Tony government.
It's very thin. And I think that's part of the reason probably why they haven't opted to do very much is because they know that they can't really get anything through there. On the fiscal side of things, you know, the budgets are funny and that, you know, we put so much effort into covering what Treasury's forecasting for wages, inflation, deficit, yada yada, none of that ever sticks, you know, it's like, no one knows what's going to happen next week, let alone next month or in a year's time. You know, the government printed the back and black mugs before it unveiled, I think, the biggest deficit in history because of COVID.
So, you know, there's only so much credit you can put in towards a fourth looking document because, you know, the past is unknowable, but the future is, you know, twice as. That's a good point. And I don't think we really heard much about, you know, the budget deficit or surplus as we have in previous budgets. Would you attribute that to a pre-election budget?
Like, do we care about deficit spending anymore? Should we? Well, the budget debt is set to peak in 2026, I don't know, well over a trillion bucks. And so that's enormous considering that in 2009 or 10, Rudd was like crucified for having $40 billion in the red during the GFC.
One, I think it's a function that the liberals are in power and if labor is in power next budget, they'll probably make someone dance about how much debt and deficit we have on the books. The other side of it is that costs as, borrowing costs for the government, you know, on our debt and interest repayments lower than they are, lower than they have been, historically, thanks to low interest rates. That could change for the moment. But right now, you know, debt doesn't matter because it's cheap to service.
It'll, it'll change obviously once interest rates go up globally. Even, you know, even saying that is like a prediction that might not come to fruition because the world economy is going to be in the crapper's room because we can't grow wheat in the Ukraine or buy it from Russia. So who knows what's going to happen? You know, maybe debt will be twice as big.
But yeah, I think people, we had like a lot of fair, we're talking about debt deficit during the Rudd-Gillard years, but you know, it was all conveniently forgotten when the coalition government came to power. We decided that no, no, no, no, no be problem. Yeah, there's a hypothetical world which will be short and won the last election and the pandemic hits that they don't do any of this, you know, job people already have a big spending stuff, is this so terrified of, you know, what happened after the GFC and that whole narrative of labor being reckless at spending in the debt and deficit that was so effectively used by Tony Abbott as well as opposition leaders. So I think that effectiveness of that sort of labor being bad with money, debt, meme, it, you know, shows that I think the things that become political talking points do change.
I mean, obviously the fact that that labor have sort of tried to talk about the government in their record debt, obviously they don't talk about it too much and it hasn't really stuck as a kind of line of attack. So yeah, look, I wonder how much people kind of plugged into it. There was certainly a point in our political history where that was quite a kind of potent line of attack, you know, for an opposition politician. But yeah, like Michael says, I think that there is maybe a kind of acknowledgement in some of the chatter around the budget, in some of the discourse around the economy that we are living through a particularly volatile time right now.
So yeah, I do wonder again, how even how, you know, stuff like that will be politicized if Albany's even the election, if labor now, you know, the government with all that big deficit, again, remains to be seen. We can, and again, you know, if it happens, you can cry all day about like the hypocrisy of coverage, the hypocrisy of like what becomes a political attack line. But I guess that's just kind of the reality of the world we live in sometimes that things are going to be run like those kinds of attacks are going to be run, you know, if a party can't deal with them in the mid-stand and have an effective response to them and they're just not doing a very good job, maybe. And we are expecting the government's call the election any day now.
Do either of you think the budget will make much impact or even be talked about in a week's time? I mean, I think the idea of a budget bounces sometimes over hyped a little bit. You know, the people that follow the budget closely are like the same people that watch inside of the Sunday for fun, which is a class of people that already knows exactly how they're going to vote for, and probably not the kind of people that will decide the selection and the kind of people that the Morrison government is really pitching to to get reelected. I think people have just switched out, don't care.
You know, it's like we've had like the worst two and a half years in living memory and people just don't care about the politics. They may not be about Scott Morrison, I think that's for sure. And I don't think that anything is going to change their mind from where they are at the moment. You know, like they might pull out some little spending things, you know, chuck a road there, a bridge over here, some rail over there.
But I think that people have made up their mind about this government. And normally before they do the whole lock up shenanigans, the Treasurer and the Prime Minister sit down for a little photo opportunity and they sort of flick through the budget papers together and they go, oh, it's interesting, look at this line over here and take a few pictures from the news. This year, it was Frydenberg and the Financienis, Simon Birmingham, and where was Skymo? You know, were they having a cigar at the back?
Who knows? But yeah, obviously, I think they know that he's a bit on the nose. I guess it's Josh's big week as well. I think it's a big week as well, I think to kind of maybe finish up his credentials as the next leader of the Liberal Party should Morrison go down in May.
But yeah, no, if ordinary phone, whatever, necessarily, you know, sorry, ordinary phone, people that aren't like really, really clued in plug-in politics watches, were ever paying a huge amount of attention to a budget such that it would swing their boat and swing their boat as well in a matter of like a month. If the Morrison government cleans onto power, I don't think it's going to be because of the budget itself. I think it will probably be, you know, obviously a bunch of factors, but you know, probably managed to convince enough people that in a kind of slightly uncertain time, it's worth holding their nose and sticking with the devil. I know even if Morrison himself, I think people just kind of like don't seem to like him that much at the moment.
I suppose we will have to wait and see. Thank you both so much for taking the time to join and bring your insight. On that note, I'd like to thank Michael Rodin and Qia or Napier-Raman for being on Fourth Estate. And thanks for listening to the program.
This edition was recorded at the studios of 2SER and heard across the country on the Community Radio Network. Fourth Estate is produced with the assistance of the Community Broadcasting Foundation. Thanks to the Foundation for their continuing support. Make sure you subscribe to Fourth Estate on your favorite podcast app so you can hear us talk about media, politics and a lot in between.
We'll be back with more next week, but in the meantime you can stay in touch with us on Twitter. Our handle is Fourth Estate AU. Thanks to our executive producer, Anthony Dockroll. I'm Marlene Even.
Thanks for listening.