Skip to content
Did the media just change the PM? episode artwork

Aug 30, 2018 39 min

Did the media just change the PM?

from Fourth Estate Hosted by 2SER

The recriminations and anger are still being felt around the country after another PM has been ruthlessly cut down. So on Fourth Estate we asked did sections of the media play a part? To make sense of the events of last week we are joined by Monica Attard, Jamie Smyth, Damien Cave and Nick O'Malley

Episode details come from the podcast's RSS feed.

Embed this episode

Ready to play

Did the media just change the PM?

0:00 39:45
of matches

Transcript Auto-generated, may contain errors

Hello and welcome, you're listening to Fourth Estate, the show where journalists talk journalism, coming to you from two S.E.R. in Sydney on Galigal Lands of the Aurora Nation, right across Australia on the Community Radio Network, and directly to your device across the Globe of Fire podcast. My name is Peter Frey and my producer this evening is the wonderful Anthony Dockrell, coming up. It's been less than a week since another Australian Prime Minister was torn down, and as with the five other changes in the past 11 years, yes, six in all, last week was messy, brutal and played out fully in the media.

It is fair to say that this leadership change was particularly messy and especially shocking. So tonight's show is dedicated to Australian politics and Australian journalism. In particular, we are going to look at three aspects of the rolling of Malcolm Turnbull. In Self-I-Shidad, a former journalist among many other things.

Perhaps you'll turn back to it, who knows? Anyway, number one, we're going to look at the role played or not played by the Fourth Estate in the leadership change. Did some journalists as nine security women say, cross the line between reporter and activist? Number two, whether the news media was far more interested in playing the men and the one woman instead of examining the substantive issue behind Turnbull's rolling, namely climate change as expressed in energy policy.

And three, what on earth do all these machinations say about Australia and how can you report this former madness to quote the former Prime Minister to an overseas audience? To help us through this madness, through this maze, we are joined by Monica Asard, who I've got a very long introduction if I could just give it to you. Monica Asard, who has had extensive career in the media starting in Channel 7 through various roles in radio and at the ABC, including being the Russian correspondent reporting for the late-night and hosting media watch. She has a couple of walkies to her name and has now started as head of journalism at UTS, welcome Monica.

Thanks, Peter. And we also have Nico Malley, not the basis from the Arctic monkeys. No, that's not me. I'm sure you love his money.

But the senior writer and former US correspondent for the City Morning Herald, or what we used to call Fairfax Media. Where's the New York? We are. Yes, that's right.

Let's go back to our roots. Joining us for the first time, we have Jamie Smith. That's Smith with the Y for people following his byline, who is the Australian Pacific correspondent for the London Financial Times. I know why we put London on there.

Welcome, Jamie. Do we still put London Financial Times? No, we don't know. Global newspaper night owned by Nikkei in Japan.

Right. We should say the Tokyo Financial Times. And finally, Daniel Cave, the New York Times Australian Bureau Chief Correspondents. No stranger to the show.

Welcome back, Daniel. Thank you. Happy to hear. So let's get straight to it.

Oh, that's not. The Malcolm Turnbull did call it a type of madness. And after six prime ministers in 11 years, it's really hard not to see his point. But can we start on a slightly positive note?

In many respects, the events of the past which showed what the media and the press gallery do best. Reporting news, fast-breaking news, and coming through the fog of war to keep all Australians and many politicians in form. So first impression, just quickly around the panel, and we'll get to the specifics of what we talked about in a minute. But overall impression, how did the news media do last week, Mark said it 10 and why?

So with your moniker? Well, I mean, parts of the news media did exceptionally well. I mean, there were parts of the news media that reported it straight down the line. And it was, you know, reasonably objective.

And they were checking their own facts. And if you look at the efforts of, I think, in particular, Catherine Murphy, the Guardian, who was so intent on not putting to print or putting online anything that was remotely, you know, ify. Fantastic. Wonderful.

So, Mark's the Guardian? Mark's the Guardian? And the ABC thing. I'm wrong with the 10.

Oh, I don't think you can do it overall. I think you can do it. I think you can do it. We'll pause on that.

That's fine. Daniel, what do you think? I'm also going to avoid the 7 out of 10 or 6 out of 10 because we all end up in the middle with those things anyways. But I do think that there was a pretty strong showing.

My journalism in a lot of ways. I mean, I think this is the kind of thing that media is good at, fast-breaking political news. If there's a criticism, I would say that sometimes, you know, how much sort of step back analysis there is as part of the conversation. There wasn't a ton of that.

But I think that sort of emerged later after the spelling. It was moving so quickly. It was harder in the middle of it. Exactly.

So I think it was a pretty strong showing. Okay. Indeed. We're certainly going to get back to the activism.

Okay, Jamie. Yeah, I thought it was pretty good. One interesting factor, I guess, was the social media aspect. There was a few rumors going around in social media.

So I suppose that some of the reporting would be particularly accurate on that. So that's something that I guess we're beginning to grapple with, you know, during the- Social media, sorry, reporters using social media. Exactly. Which is a problem, right?

Well, I think sometimes- Spreads true. Sometimes it turns out not to be. And in that case, you've got to evaluate, you know, which news organization you're working for and can you put on unsubstantiated rumors. So I think that's something that we've all got to think about now in this age of social media.

Okay. So let's get to the gets of the next degree Jamie. Turnbull uses last press conference as Prime Minister to settle a few scores as is one of these events. He basically singled out Tony Abbott and Peter Dunne.

But he also kind of was a little bit more subtle, but he basically talked about the news media by picking for the first three questions in order the ABC, Fairfax and Guardian. So he was sort of, if you like, a bit subtle, but nonetheless, people in the gallery would know exactly what was going on. So what do you think? Do you think that Chris Yeoman, who was much more direct than the Prime Minister obviously, who was the first guy in the Australian Telegraph, said he'd tell the graph, did he have a point that there was this line that was crossed last week between reporting and activism?

I think last week probably isn't the right time period to call this in. I think there has been a lot of activism on Sky over the last year. But the question is, are they really news reporters, the people that appear after seven o'clock in Sky, probably not a term that was commentators. I don't think much of what they're talking about in areas actually news.

But certainly it is a form of activism. And I think this is where we're getting to the whole, you know, the foxification of Sky News here in Australia. We've seen what Fox has done in America with Trump. And there's a real question mark over whether you can actually trust a lot of the news.

What is packaged up in news in that and what is commentary? Where is the line? Well, so your point is that does the average punter know that they're looking at a commentator rather than they're looking at a reporter? The lines blurred even further, you've got to say, when during the straight news line up during the day, they're interviewing all the commentators from the line.

They're interviewing the guys that say, hey, they're the commentators. Don't mix them in. But they're being interviewed by David Spies at 11 o'clock in the morning. So the specific allegation, Damien, was that, and I don't know this for a fact, but the specific allegation that Chris Newman said was that some reporters were calling up MPs and kind of berating them as to change their vote for leader.

That would appear to me. So I think just having been in situations like it, you're asking the politician who you're going to vote for, that's a legitimate question. The illegitimate part of that is saying, oh no, actually you should change your vote. Who knows how these conversations went down, but I think what it speaks to is this filter bubble and this ideological filter bubble where when you have a cozy press with a cozy political class who sees themselves as on the same side of a given issue, it's pretty blurry whether or not the reporter says, okay, well, are they saying, well, you should go for this person or is the MP saying, hey, what are you hearing?

And then the reporter's reporting back as to what the same people who agree with him are saying. It's clear that there was an agenda from conservative elements of the country that includes media and politicians to push for some kind of house stir of turnball, right? And so how that plays out, I think, is complicated, but I think it speaks to a world in which we're all often speaking only to people who agree with us and where it's not even clear if you're pushing an agenda, if you know it, half the time. So just to that point, though, it's just sticking with you.

This isn't always been this, I mean, there's always been a conservative media. I mean, the fact that there's a conservative media in this country or other countries is not a big surprise. It's true, but I do think there are questions about whether or not the way that social media works and the way that audiences work these days create an amplification of this, where you're actually hearing from the loudest voices who were most outraged, and so all of democracy and media, to some degree, is being forced to listen to the loudest, squeaky as people, and they tend to be very agenda-driven and very demanding of all of us in this world. And so I think that that's what's changed.

I think the access to power, the access to the gatekeepers of journalism and politics has changed dramatically, and we're all trying to adjust. Okay, that's a great point. Well, there's a two-step process here. There are two things that you'll have raised.

One is that there had been this campaign from sections of the media for a long time to remove Turnbull. I don't think you can argue that. And I don't think it'd be possible for Abbott and Dutton to have mounted this challenge, and the sky news had been wearing in Parliament House for the last 12 months, backed up by 2GB, the telly and the odds. But what he really spoke to that day was he said that the day after the spill, when the momentum stopped, the first spill, when the momentum stopped, commentators called and lobbied MPs, and I have spoken to people close to the Prime Minister and I have called those journalists, and it turns out that as far as we know, it's true.

Alan Jones has confirmed the ADC. Yes, he did. But he's not a journalist. I mean, he's a commentator.

Ross Cameron told me that he actually declined to comment. No, he's hired by Skye, though. Yeah. And Ray Hadley didn't speak.

Also not a journalist, right? No, not a journalist. But you also know how close these people are to Abbott. But it's the amplification of their views, as expressed on Skye News, as Damien says, that is actually the problem on social media, because Sky News has what?

Twenty-five, thirty thousand people watching it at the night. You're on the parmour thought. That's true. That's true.

So they're speaking to them, obviously. However, it is the repetition of those views and the amplification of those views on social media, that caused the problem in this instance. And I think also in relation to Chris Orman's comments, it's one thing to say, News Corp, and that's a pretty broad land. Very big statement.

Very big statement to say. I think actually that Sherry Markson did some fantastic reporting on this issue, in the lead up to the issue. She was reporting it as she saw it as it was coming to her, I think it's grossly unfair to say that she was a player. I don't think Chris said that.

But the implication was there. It's interesting what Chris did, because he did down the whole news. When he had a direct interview with her, the two of them were put together, and he said, no, of course not. That story broke on Friday.

A legitimate good story. And she's broken some great stories. By the big choice. Indeed.

I'm interested in Chris's. I wish I had him in the studio today, maybe we'll get him next week. But Chris's motivation for doing this. I guess what it says is here's a senior member of the Press Gallery, Jamie.

A senior member of the Press Gallery who kind of reads the tipping point and goes, no, I'm going to call this out. It was a big emotional week, and Journer's are tired and tired and emotional, and they get carried away. He was very brave for saying that. I have to say, because calling out Sky News is no name.

He told us what his motivation was. People from the PM down told him they believed that a bunch of commentators hadn't changed the prime minister. They were calling him. He didn't admit it to commentators.

The way he did it wasn't that. He actually wrote a piece of opinion making, rather than writing it as a piece of news. But he explained why he did it. Which is a new style of journalism that we're all becoming very accustomed to, especially on morning breakfast shows, on the sort of shock joc.

It's becoming much more. Yeah. This is it. There is very little division nowadays, which is a problem.

It is a problem for other punters. It's a problem for other punters. It's a problem for democracy as well. I guess it could be a problem for democracy as well.

Oh, it's a problem for democracy. Oh, democracy. That thing. Yeah.

What is it? We are at the fourth of the city. So, we're there to be a check on par, and whenever you're jumping over that sort of news agenda on the commentating and becoming involved in a political process, I mean, so, Pedicred is not a journalist, a news reporter, so a commentator, but she's given this platform in Sky, and then to ring someone up in lobby on behalf of the the party. So, can I ask, where do we place insights on ABC2V in its scheme of things?

I mean, are they also players? Because they're commentating. They're commentating. They're commentating.

They're discussing politics. Well, I think the question is, do they ring up particularly MP and say, is this why they're on the Monst, you're the one? This is the line that, well, we all know that Alan Jones has been monitoring. I'm not sure he's answering the politicians.

Well, that's what I'm sure. We all know that Jones and Harry have been Monster in Politicians since the year. Right? Yeah.

Jones in particular is that's his stuff in trade. That's his whole... And that thing. That's what they do.

That's what they're audience expects of them. So, should we be surprised if they do what their audience expects of them? Well, no, but I just think the issue is that they can skew the way power dynamics work. I mean, the question that I think is important, which you raised, is would this have happened if not for those commentators amplifying things?

And so, you know, that means that they're playing a disproportionate role in democracy. And I think that's a question that's worth asking. Do commentators wield this bully pulpit in a way that is anti-democratic and goes against the will of the people? Does this...

Is that an example? I think that in many cases it is. That doesn't mean there aren't great reporting that comes out of there. Some of them kept me alive in various difficult places.

But I do think that it's worth asking the question of what, to what extent does media, when it turns that dial on commentating, skewing democracy towards its own views as opposed to the views of the public. You know, if you look at certain issues in Australia, whether it's climate change or same-sex marriage, you have to ask this question, well, why isn't democracy working according to what most of the people want? And part of the factor has to be these commentators who are skewing a perspective and telling people that it's a mass perspective when it's not. And they have a disproportionate amount of power, even in our world where social media is an equalizer and democracy is equalized by technology and all these things that are happening in our disrupted universe.

The bottom line is there are still some people who have louder voices and politicians who are likely to listen to certain people who they think represent their base as opposed to the mass. But it's always been less, isn't it? It's just the amplification of social that's changed it? I mean, sure, you can go back to the era of hers.

You can go back to the various areas of journalism. It was absolutely existed to produce them. But you didn't have 24-7 rolling news channels. That made quite a big difference.

But going back to Monica's point is that sky after dark is watched by the four of us in this room. It's watched by 85 liberal MPs religiously. They all have it on in their parliamentary office. So in a curious way, I don't think sky has probably much influence on the general public coming up to an election, probably a lot less.

But in that strange, cloistered environment of the parliament and Canberra, which is set up on a hill away from the public as far as possible, I think it's probably Dostin. And they've been damned. The pollies have been rightly damned for allowing themselves to be held hostage by the view. This is the other thing I think we're getting from the news corp and its effectiveness model.

I think the rest of the country is getting a taste of what it's been like to cover politics in Sydney in New South Wales. So for a long time we've had this 2GB back and forth with the daily telegraph. And politicians will tell you, OK, we can put up the telegraph beating us up, we can put up with our own Jones beating us up. But when they're doing it together, we're in trouble.

So now sky has unrolled this across the national media market. And whether or not the threat is legitimate, politicians feel it. They feel scared of. I can say a lot better politicians than if they can be influenced by...

That's what I was going to say. At some point you have to hold them accountable and say, come on. And they have been called out in the last week. The pollies.

The pollies. They've been fam-lofting on many levels. Let's move on to Kevin Rudd and Cibith unit because you had the joy of writing this story in the Herald the other day. Kevin Rudd is opinion piece.

Going off, and absolutely off in the very Kevin Rudd way, calling Rupert Murdoch a cancer. Overstatement. It's a colourful language from an effective comment writer who is also very well known for his invective. It's certainly not language I don't think any other people could have got away with.

I think he argued A.K.S. well and he's looking at news court globally. And he mounted a reasonable argument. I don't know if he's language like that.

Well, okay, so, Jamie, Kevin Rudd. Is Kevin Rudd right? Is Rupert Murdoch a cancer? I mean, that's good.

No, that's good. He's Rupert Murdoch a cancer. Well, if you look at the Levinson inquiry and what happened in the UK, the precarious questions re-asdepited his newspapers in the way he did business. And I think that has had a very negative and corrosive effect on public trust in the media.

If you look at the US, you can see the rule that Fox has had in promoting Trump and the way it covers Trump. If you look at the UK, again, you've got Brexit. Now, Rupert Murdoch's newspapers had argued for sifistly for years and reported on the European Union in a particular way with a lot of vindictive. And I think that actually I think that had a real impact over the very long term in the public's attitude towards the EU in Britain.

So I think he's had a pretty negative effect on... Isn't he allowed to? I mean, he's the proprietor of this news organisation. He's allowed to have views and he's allowed to write?

No one's saying otherwise. I'm just saying, I'm just saying... I'm not saying we should be regulating this, you know, changing regulation, cracking down on this. But what I'm saying is this, when you look at the three countries and the impact that it's had, you can point to some significant political events where Murdoch has had a very strong view articulated in a very strong way, and from being based in Brussels for four years, the coverage of the EU and the straight banana syndrome, a lot of it wasn't based on real hard news values of truth.

Although it did talk to the... Talking about straight banana, it did talk to that particular audience, right? Off Brits. Yeah, the Brits are going to make their bananas.

And yes, they loved it and they sucked it up and neither leave in the EU. And yet, though, I mean, I often sort of question and push back on this idea that media sort of controls everything. You know, we all get hate mail as journalists, we all have people tell us that we're doing things wrong. And I sometimes wonder what the world would look like if that frustration was directed, actually had elected officials opposed to the media.

We're an easy punching bag. And that includes, you know, people whose views are maybe different than ours and whether or not the Murdochs of the world are corrosive or not. You know, is it right for democracy to be focusing on the fourth estate? Or should they actually be saying, you know what, let's change the way politics works.

Well, I mean, it's a very good point, but the fourth estate does set itself up as the middle between the politicians and the people. Yeah, but that's the job. Exactly. But the people also have a responsibility to hold democracy to account and not simply scapegoat media when they have an issue.

I mean, politics has become more insular over time in all of these countries. The political class has become a more closed loop of people from the same world. You don't see democracy as representative of the variety in all of these countries. These are problematic issues that are directly related to the way our democracy's function separate from media.

And also, I think the challenges to the business models have made the number of voices, you know, average people are getting to hear a fewer and fewer, particularly in Australia. And I think that is the problem that we're probably talking about here when we talk about Murdoch and News Corp. I mean, you know, is Murdoch and Cancer, I think he's got a lot to answer for. I mean, it always happens to be, you know, at the center of momentous and generally, you know, challenging events that a lot of people don't agree with.

But at the same time, News Corp has got a stable, fantastic journalist who produces wonderful, you know, objective journalism. That is completely awesome. I mean, you know, we can sit here and name them all. So in terms of, and that's what's getting out.

But in terms of, you know, market share in terms of what Australians are actually getting to hear, I mean, I think that is the problem that we're just looking at this contracted media. And News Corp's oversized place in that. That's why we need to do it. So that's why we need to do it.

Yes, that's why we need to do it. That's why we need to do it. That's why we need to do it. Well, put to me by someone, a senior at LibCipathetic to Turnbull, who I think understands media more broadly pretty well, who said that at a time when media is fracturing and falling apart as you were suggesting, and business models are looking very shaky at best, reflecting people's views back to them and amplifying them is actually a really effective business model that runs into your audience on.

So there is a business, whatever reproductive and ideological views, there is also a good business model. We're seeing it in Fox News, we see it in Sky in ratcheting up the volume and the stock. Okay. So we're going to talk about Chris Kenny for a second, who does work for the Australian, which I should add, I'd just be deputy editor of that August Morgan.

He wrote a piece today which essentially said that the press gallery kind of missed the whole point of what was going on, that it was really all about, you know, another rerun of climate policy, as for energy policy this time, essentially climate policy. And that was the issue that brought Turnbull unstuck and the audience was writing this for weeks before months before. And the audience got all wrong by kind of playing it out as some sort of personality crisis. Jamie, I mean, I mean, I've read both New York Times and FTE reporting on this, of course, and I would say you report a lot about the climate change debate, isn't it?

But Chris, can you have a point? Is there this tendency to, in essence, play, you know, the persona rather than look at the policy that was behind it? Well, I mean, why did Turnbull get rolled? There's probably six or seven different connecting factors to it.

It was just one. So the climate debate, the fact that he brought that policy into the public and then changed it dramatically within the space of a week, you know, that undermined his political authority. You know, that's not just the only issue. You know, Turnbull was never really liked by his party, but he was only surviving because he was popular, you know, they wanted him there to win elections.

But he lost 38 news polls in the Rose Week, undermined his position. He didn't get a lot of policies to be. Where are the big flagship policies? Most of them got dumped.

So that didn't give him the political capital to ward off Abbott. And then there was the campaign by the media. You know, I think it's a mixture of all these things, which have effectively in the end forced him to be rolled. But there is obviously the climate energy debate.

It's pretty toxic in this country. It's caused the job of numerous leaders, you know, Turnbull himself back in 2009. Twice there, yeah. Yeah, I mean, and Chris Kelly probably has a point, you know, maybe Turnbull shouldn't have have been so brave and actually tried to fix the problem at all.

Maybe he should have sat back and twiddled his thumbs and I wouldn't have helped that. He's just one of them. The core problem. He was never one of them.

And that's why they were never going to tell. I'm surprised he's lost at this one. Right. Okay.

So Chris, Kenny, was he right? What do you think Chris was saying? I mean, I'm still trying to talk about it. It was hard to talk about.

I thought they were basically saying that, listen, we covered this. We saw this coming. Only all of you missed this. And I thought, well, there's a thin line between saying we saw this coming and we helped facilitate this, you know, and he didn't really address that nor there was this other giant glaring omission in that piece, which was he didn't actually explain what the climate policy was in the degree to which it's actually quite modest compared to lots of other things that have happened.

There was no policy in a piece that was essentially arguing that people should pay attention policy. This was the point that policy at the end. Turnbull had conceded everything. Yeah, no policy.

People like Chris Kenny who was saying you should completely ignore climate change. You should completely ignore Paris. Turnbull had conceded that. So the media has it both ways.

What you're saying? Well, Chris, in a way, the old. Yeah, I think that if it wasn't that issue, it would have been another issue. This is the reason why Turnbull didn't touch the Euro a second because he knew that forces on his right were mobilising and they got him on that.

I mean, Chris, other point which he's made a career I was saying is that there is a kind of the love media, the sort of guy in the MC that Harold, and it kind of, you know, in a way, it's the antithesis of what news is. You know, it wants to play, it wants to virtually signal all the time. It wants to have everything. It doesn't really think about the economy.

Costing anything, it doesn't think about the real people. It's all busy living in this bubble. I mean, that's a fair thing to point out. That's a fair thing to point out.

But in this case, if you look at energy policy, there's no constituency for Chris Kenny's or Tony Abbott's energy position, big business, manufacturing, the energy companies themselves and 80% of Australians want a climate policy and an energy policy that's combined to recognise the impact of climate change. Well, we're going to stick with this for a second. Isn't it kind of crap that we can't solve this energy, climate policy? Well, we can't.

While there is a powerful group that is forcing, not forcing, but you know, championing perhaps combat on this issue. Not to mention a Prime Minister who thinks it's okay to take a big lump of coal into power. Yeah. But are we giving, I mean, at that point, we're giving the media a bit more power.

We're suggesting, again, we're having it both ways. Well, I think we're going back to the point that you came to earlier, which is why in the politicians, this is the new environment as Jack Bailey said recently, I think I'll be be seeing. Volitians should be able to be tougher. And the media should be looking at why, you know, the core reasons why does Australia find it so difficult to tackle this issue?

Is it the coal lobby? Are they buying off politicians? Where are the donations? Well, both you and Daniel are in pieces of the basic say that it is the power of the coal lobby.

And local media has written that as well. I mean, the ABC has looked at that issue with the Guardians, looked at that issue. I mean, it's not as though it's not looked at. No, that's true.

I think it's been looked at quite heavily. But it's the issue is that it appears to make no difference. Isn't it also the fact that, you know, the politics here are just so roughly evenly divided? I mean, this is a government with very little power to some degree when you have, you know, it's a small minority can really block so many different things in a divided government.

And so on one hand, it's called isn't it also just the fact that the society itself is pretty divided and that leads to gridlock. So, okay, let's just let's touch on this on this, you know, you report Australia to Australia and also to the world to the MIT audience. What do you make of this? When you kind of, when you call up the news essay and go, and they go, what the, what the, really, another prime that really was the growth of the economic.

I think the world is completely confused by Australia's political difficulties. I think that it's confounding. I mean, I was in Canberra and it felt a little bit like being a new kid in a high school cafeteria and all kinds of rumors and craziness going around and you having no idea who the cool kids are, who's in charge or where you're supposed to get your food. I mean, it just felt like a chaotic bunch of juveniles.

And that's basically what I think the world was looking at was how does this country with, you know, 26 years of growth with highly developed economy that solved all kinds of political challenges from health care to guns to all kinds of things. How does it devolve into the state of chaos? Do you have a theory about that? No, I do not.

I mean, I mean, I mean, I think there's a whole bunch of different factors. I'm very much still trying to figure it out. I do think that it's part of what is happening in democracies over the world, where there is this divide between a political class that's basically living in a systematically sealed environment and a public that's increasingly disengaged. And so this to me is a little bit of the consequence of decades of politics becoming more insular and distant from the people it's meant to serve, parties becoming more insular, and a public that can do more on its phone than it can do in the voting booth.

And so there's a whole bunch of factors that are at play here that go beyond Australia. And I think this is just one example of many. So maybe what did your audience make of events, Oscar? I will tell you they were very interested.

I mean, I was surprised to see the degree to which a global audience was paying very close attention to Australia. And I think that there were certain issues that they were really wondering about. Climate change was one, definitely one of them. I mean, this is a country that has a punishing drought.

That is one of the most vulnerable countries to climate change in the world. And yet they can't figure out how to do something about this. So I think that's one question. And then I do think it just comes.

The world is also wondering, well, where is the line of populism going to be drawn in the world's mature democracies? And then Australia ends up being a kind of test case for that anyway. Yeah, I think so. Or one of many test cases.

I mean, you've got Hungary, you've got Germany, you've got all kinds of places, but this is one that they're in. I love the idea that we're in the same sentence as Hungary. That's really, that's really important. I'm a little so part obvious.

That happens right? He can change their latest so easily. Yeah. I got a lot of questions about that too.

Well, gosh, would this ever happen to the United States, hinting to anyone? Maybe, maybe like in the future. Jamie, what did, you know, what did, so London's on the Blower or Tokyo's on the Blower going? Well, and you're going, yeah, I'm sorry.

I don't have to do it all again. Yeah, it's my second actually. You don't usually get these when you go and do it four years, 10, somewhere. But yeah, I mean, one of the ironies here is that Australia, of course, has a pretty strong economy.

It hasn't had a recession in 28 years. So, you know, most of the populism that we've seen, I think in the last decade has come out of the financial crisis in 2008. So really, there isn't that excuse for it here. But I think what you do see is some institutional factors that have play a role.

And, Jamie, you mentioned this three, you mentioned the Senate getting anything through the Senate. It's pretty difficult in this country. You know, there's only been a government's only had a majority for three years in the last 30. I mean, that means it's really tricky.

There's a three-year electoral cycle, which is just not because government gets in. You've got one year to pass some stuff through or try to get it through. And then you're electioneering again. And so I think that's a factor.

You've got the States against the federal government. So there's this division. It's quite a complex balance. And then you've got the Westminster type system.

So we've got too much democracy, is that we're saying that. You have compulsory voting. It's a very specific system that I think is probably playing a role in this because then you mix in the whole social media, the 24-7 news cycle, the quite a strong ideological bent on the media. And I think that's quite a volatile combination.

But this is just sort of my point too, is like we have all these democratic issues, but we're talking about like why the media is screwed this up. Well, you know, what would it look like if there were more proposals about how to structurally fix the way political debate and political parties work in Australia? And how and why is that not a bigger part of the discussion? I think we should do a radio show.

I mean, I mean, I mean, actually Bill Shorten and Michael Malcolm Turnbull talked about this living in a four-year cycle recently. Yes, but the general consensus from everyone was nothing's possible because you've all these checks and balances. But in the UK, didn't they change the system of how, you know, question time worked for the Prime Minister is not as visible? Like, their examples of democracies actually fixing themselves.

It's this is a fixable party. Exactly. I was just saying that on a very small level, I suppose in the inside the party, the Labour party has prevented, well, mainly prevented, sitting leader to be rolled as easily as they look. Do they drag nothing?

Well, I mean, nobody would be able to do the Labour party as well. Would they want to do the same? Exactly. That might happen.

Well, it might happen. I think if there was ever a moment for it to happen, we haven't got a lot more time. Nick and Monica, you know, you've both been foreign correspondents. You and Russia are famously Nick.

You and the US famously as well. If you were sort of transposing what happened in Australia to the countries that you were reporting, how would you go about reporting what happened in Australia last week? If you get my drift. I think Monica should go on that first.

Oh, geez. That's such an easy question, mate. What would you tell the Russians? What would I tell the Russians?

That's why I really meant to say. What would you tell the Russians? We have coups without an army. Yeah.

And we do it. Would we try? And we drag it out over five to seven days. Yeah.

We give everybody a say in it. So you know you have a view. It's a democratic coup. No army involved.

Easy. The other upside to this is that it isn't a change of administration. There's a regig and a reshuffle. It took a week.

Elections only take 40 days as well, which Americans just blew them away when you're using reporting an American election campaign and you tell Americans we do it a month. There are some benefits. Right. Oh, well, that's a happy note to any other.

I mean, this is sort of subject we could talk about for a long time, but I think we're probably out of time. Unless anyone's got a summation. I mean, we've had another conversation. Let's just think.

So what needs to change, Monica? What needs to change? Well, I think as we've said, I mean, I think there are some structural changes that need to be addressed, but they're not going to be because they're too big and they're too high. What needs to change in the news media?

Oh, in the news media? Well, goodness, more of it. That it helps. More diversity of ownership.

More diversity of ownership will be fantastic. That's not going to happen either. And, you know, a little less naval casing. Change.

What needs to change? Maybe more than one person for the FT would be a start. That would be great. Especially for moments like this.

But I guess one of the ironies is we'll talk about media diversity. Of course, Turnbull got media reform through, which I think was very much welcomed by Newscore, but he didn't get a lot of money. Really? Really?

It's a little more diversity. Painting. I think someone like you better needs to work out a new business model. I'm sorry.

The readers have already opened and we can put in acres of news pretty about policy. Oh, what a great idea. I'm working on that. Damien, what needs to happen?

I think readers and consumers of news and media need to work harder to get outside some of these levels of the media tries to push them into. I think we're not alone in this. This is something that our readers and our audiences need to take responsibility for too. Okay.

Wonderful. No. I'd like to say that's all from the fourth estate this week. I would like to thank my esteemed guests.

Monica Atard. Thank you, Monica. Welcome. Nick O'emali.

Thank you. Thank you. Jamie Smith. Thanks.

And Jamie Kate. Thank you. Thank you all for listening. I'd like to say that next week we got Evie McGuire, which will be back in the hot seat.

And make sure you subscribe to Fourth Estate on your favorite podcast app so you can hear us talk media politics and a few things in between very soon. I'd like to thank my producer Anthony Buckrell. My name is Peter Fray. Thank you very much for listening.

Good night.

Frequently asked questions

How long is this episode of Fourth Estate?

This episode is 39 minutes long.

When was this Fourth Estate episode published?

This episode was published on August 30, 2018.

Is there a transcript available for this episode?

Yes, a full transcript is available for this episode. You can read the complete transcript on the episode page.

Can I download this Fourth Estate episode?

Yes. Use the download control on the episode player to save the publisher-provided media file.