Welcome to the SXU Business Roundtable, a discussion-based program featuring St. Xavier University faculty and business members from the local community discussing the current state of business, its impact on the economy, and the future. Please welcome your host, Julie Gardner. Alright, welcome back to the SXU Business Roundtable.
My name is Julie Gardner and today we have Dr. Cheryl Luzak and Kathy Hayes with us in the studio here. How are we today? Very good, very good.
Great, doing great. Thanks for coming out. So we're going to start off today just by talking about your experience in digital and social media advertising and marketing. So Kathy, if you'd like to start off, we'd love to hear it.
Sure, thanks, Julie. Well, it's great to be here this morning. My name is Kathy Hayes and I founded Hayes Digital Group back in 2009 when digital was still evolving. It is still today, but even in less than 10 years, the changes have been tremendous.
And what we focus on are marketing consulting, social media, email marketing, SEO, website development, traditional digital services. Nice, and Dr. Luzak, if you'd like to give a little bit of background information about yourself? Certainly.
I'm a marketing and social media professor at the Graham School and I created our internet marketing and social media concentration just about the same time that Kathy opened up her business around 2009. And that's about the time that social media was beginning to really blossom. Great, great. During your time in digital and or social media advertising, what specific changes have you noticed?
Sure, that's such a great question. I can talk about that. I'm sure Dr. Luzak could too for the whole time we have together.
Bottom line, what I've noticed is that everyone, no matter what your age range today, has one of these mobile devices in their pocket and it literally rules the world. That's a real short, short answer. But over time, I mean, the changes have been gradual, but the shift has, the sand or the weight or whatever you want to say visually has landed clearly in the palm of our hands. I would agree with Kathy.
The proliferation of mobile social media has just amazing. It has skyrocketed. It's become ubiquitous in all of our lives. What's interesting is that companies, both small, medium and large, have not transitioned as quickly as society has.
And so that, I think a lot of companies, even some large companies are still playing catch up. You know that when you go on your phone and you're trying to find something and they don't have a real mobile app. And it's very frustrating for people to try to use a traditional app or traditional website on their phone. So it's very interesting.
And I also think the proliferation of social media can be looked at if we think about the incident yesterday on United Airlines. And everybody there had their phones and there's so many people that were videoing it. So that certainly, I think, shows us how ubiquitous this idea of social media has become. So kind of going along with that then, does the media presence in a company, does that equal success?
Are companies more likely to succeed if they have this strong media presence? And I guess you can kind of do that in a positive view as well as a negative view as we're talking with United Airlines. So the presence from the company, how does that equate to the successes? And then also, I guess, the information that's coming through social media from the customers as well.
Well, one of the things that we talk about in class when it comes to social media is that it's not a what if I have a presence in social media. Even if you're a small business, it's no longer what if you have to have a social media presence to validate your business in most customers' minds. And so that, from our student standpoint, I think gives them a great advantage because we have a lot of people who are not, who may have industry experience, but their experience in terms of social media may not be the same as our students or it may be even less. I mean, our students are what we call digital natives.
They've been speaking social media and the Internet since they were born. And if you think about anybody who takes up a foreign language, they're never as good of a speaker as the digital natives. And so us digital immigrants have a hard time catching up. And so that being said, since every company really needs to have a presence, it's a great opportunity for our students.
But it doesn't necessarily equal success because having a presence that's static and not dynamic may have no effect or it could have a negative effect on your company. But you certainly nowadays cannot put your head in the sand and say, I'm not going to be involved in social media. I would just agree completely with Dr. Luzak's comments.
And I like the digital immigrant. Yeah, that was great. I like to say in my presentations that we live in an era of what I call digital distress. And what I mean by that is we have messages competing for our attention.
And it just can be overwhelming. But back to your question, you know, in terms of does a digital media presence equal success? I would totally agree with Dr. Luzak.
It isn't a question of if. It's just a question of how are you managing it and if you are getting your message in front of the correct target audience. Yeah, so we can continue on with question four here. So who uses social media?
How do companies know whether they are reaching their target audiences or not? And if they're not reaching their audience, what are some ways that they can go ahead and do so? Well, I'll take the first part of the question, who uses social media, and then pass the ball to Kathy, if that's okay. Sure, absolutely.
So obviously we know that the millennials are deep in social media, right? We know about the digital immigrants and kids are using social media. Before they get to kindergarten, they're starting to use social media. It's quite amazing how I bet they are, that type of technology.
What we're seeing now is also a large growth, though, in the senior market. And by senior, I don't mean a senior in college, right? I see what we sometimes call our gray market. And Twitter, seniors are one of the largest growing demographics on Twitter.
And so we are having a lot of seniors who are becoming nuanced in social media. And a lot of it, obviously, initially was to keep in contact with their grandkids, see what's going on with their grandkids. Now they've gotten more comfortable. And as social media has become so user-friendly, they are adapting at a significant rate.
Yeah, again, just to piggyback on Dr. Luzak, it's absolutely the case. Actually, and this is from eMarketer, but the numbers in terms of ad spend, Facebook is still the number one biggest player in terms of ad spend for digital advertising. And that shouldn't come as any surprise because it just blows every other social media out of the water in terms of usage.
And to Dr. Luzak's point, the highest growing demographic on Facebook is people over 50 for many reasons. Yes, to see the grandkids, but also because the accepted mode of communication. And Facebook this year expects to capture about 35.4% of the total display advertising in the U.S.
Second place is Google, okay, taking in just $4.79 billion in ad spend. But that being said, it's just for myself, and I think I can speak for Dr. Luzak on this side of the table, we grew up before digital. And I've never seen anything like this in my professional career.
So an opportunity for businesses, and I think that's what we're speaking to today, is just unparalleled. So are there any, so social media advertising, specifically Facebook, why is it doing so well compared to others? So, you know, you have Facebook and, like, maybe Twitter, Instagram, all the others. Why is Facebook the number one?
Well, I would think for the sheer number of people that are on there, number one. Number two, Facebook is continually changing the game. I mean, literally almost every week. And what I mean by that is our group manages some Facebook campaigns for clients.
And there's constant updates to my Facebook app that I use to manage campaigns. By way of example, they are now wanting you to share. They've added video, what, a year or two ago. They purchased Instagram.
In my mind, if Mark Zuckerberg could own the world of social media and exclude all the other players or somehow have everything that's good about all the other social media channels morph into Facebook, he would and he will if he can. So to answer the question, Julie, it's a matter of how much time someone's hanging out there, if that makes sense. So by sheer time spent in front of a platform, they have more people spending more time there than on other platforms, in general speak. And there is mostly positive things about that.
But there are, you know, some experts say that there are some negative aspects to the time that we spend online and a significant amount of the time that we spend online is still on Facebook that they have created these apps now. These apps you can put onto your phone and they will basically monitor how much time you spend and almost like an alarm clock and say, okay, you need to stop now. You put on too much time. And it's interesting because Apple, I was just watching a 20, I think it was a 2020 segment, and they're talking about one of these apps that were developed.
And Apple would not allow the developer to sell it on iTunes because it was not something that would be enhancing Apple's business model. So it is interesting that we are trying to figure out ways because Kathy talked about how much time you spend. And from a personal standpoint, these apps are targeting that. But from a business standpoint, too, I mean, how much time.
We always say people think social media, they go, oh, that's free, that's free marketing. Well, no, there's no such thing as a free lunch, right? You have people and they're spending time and your resources, so it can be a huge time suck. Yeah, yeah, yeah, for sure.
All right, great responses to that. Thank you. So the next one here we have for Dr. Luzak, and that is, what are the benefits of an Internet and Social Media Marketing degree versus a traditional marketing degree, especially at an AACSB accredited institution like our Grand School of Management?
And then what were some of the necessary steps taken to create this degree at our university? Certainly. First, let me say that AACSB accreditation puts us in the top 5% in the world for business schools. And so we got that accreditation two years ago, and that was something that we've worked about 10 years to get.
So it's a very high-level accreditation. We're very happy and proud to have received that accreditation. About seven years ago, we looked into creating an Internet and Marketing and Social Media concentration. And the reason that we looked into it, I'd love to say it's because we were so in front of the curve and so trendy, but realistically, why we looked into it is because I had a number of businesses that would come to me and ask me for interns.
They said they wanted interns in Internet and Social Media, and I had no interns to give them. And these were businesses that were looking for paid internships, which is the golden crown in academics, and I had to turn them away. That's what started us looking at their concentration. And once we made that decision, we actually created a board of 12 business members, all from Internet Marketing and Social Media, and we asked them to help in developing the curriculum to make sure that it was something that would be effective and that our students would have the tools that they need that companies would be asking for when they graduated.
So that was, I said, seven years ago, we've had the concentration in Internet Marketing and Social Media for six years, and right now you can have a traditional marketing concentration or Internet Marketing and Social Media. We are going to be phasing out both of those concentrations because when we first started, social media was at its beginning phase. And, well, if you were a traditional marketer, you always have an option to take some classes in Internet Marketing and Social Media. You don't have to.
It's not required. Well, as you just heard us talking, Kathy and myself, for companies, it's not an if. It's a when. And so we no longer feel that we're equipping our students if we let them get out without having that as part of the degree.
So we'll be creating a new concentration that will be marketing and social media, and all of our students that come out will be equipped with the right tools to go into either traditional route in marketing or a social media route, and maybe like Kathy, become an entrepreneur, start your own business. Okay, thank you. So for Kathy, I have a, taking a quote from your website, I was taking a look there, so I'll read it here. I was actually under your philosophy.
So, we know that companies today have more demands placed on them with less time available. As media continues to evolve at breakneck speed, businesses are unable to keep up. Our philosophy is simple, to provide exceptional strategic and digital marketing expertise to enhance your brand and online presence. So can you explain how this process works in terms of the clients that you have, and then what do you do for the specific companies that you serve?
It's very individual. The need is the same. Each client, each business that we work with has the same struggle. I need to get my message out in the digital world, but I don't know how.
Or I've done things this way for 30 years. How do I do it? So, the answer to your question is, a lot of it depends on a company's budget. I typically will recommend that we incorporate, as Dr.
Lucek was saying, you know, phasing in, phasing out. Social media is part of the overall digital mix. It's not the only tool in the toolkit, if you will. There's text.
There's SEO. There's pay-per-click still. There's retargeting. There's landing pages, website redesign.
Certainly, a mobility solution needs to be part of the overall digital mix. So, when we sit down with a client, we find out what their biggest, what I like to call a pain point or need is. And at the end of the day, each client has a product or service to sell. And it's about getting more sales, getting more exposure to answer in a general way.
The need is always the same. When I sit down with businesses, the struggle is, how do I get my message out there? So, depending on what the most specific need might be, like right now, I'm talking with a company that represents and makes floor cleaning equipment. And they have niches in breweries, believe it or not, these big industrial machines that you see that may be driven or may be robotic.
And so, they work in breweries is one of their niches. School districts is the niche that they are looking to break into. As a matter of fact, SXU would be probably somebody he would love to be in front of. And so, what we're doing is we are charged with, it's a new product to a brand-new market.
Okay, and how can we drive results online? So, we're recommending landing pages, ad spend in terms of social media, certain social media outlets, but also SEO, website optimization. So, the answer to the question is it would depend on the business's need, but in general speak, the need is always the same. I would agree with Kathy in that social media is one of the tools in the toolbox.
And that's why for our internet marketing and social media concentration, we had other classes that required you to delve more into internet marketing where you would look into SEO, you would do landing pages. In fact, if you are a graduate of our program, you have, you know, your Google Analytics certified, your AdWords certified, and we'll probably be moving into getting our students who speak certified, too. And that's because they need to have a whole array of tools because you need to hit the consumer where they are. You can't have the consumer charged with finding you.
So, you have to find the consumer at the appropriate time where they're thinking of that type of product. I tell my students, for instance, if you were trying to get me to buy a textbook and you were trying to do that via social media and I was doing grocery shopping at Juul, I'm not, my social media professor hat is not on. And my mom hat is on and probably would not give as much time or to look at that type of social media. So, it's very complicated.
And that's why there are companies like Kathy to be able to say, I have to hit them on the platform they use at the time that they're in the role that they would actually benefit from my product. Yeah. Dr. Lucek, it's like she's taking the words out of my mouth because I say we have to meet people where they hang out.
So, where Julie and you may be hanging out online may be very different from where potentially Dr. Lucek and I might. spend our time online hanging out if you will um so it is a very complex and increasingly challenging landscape to navigate yeah thank you um so for the second time here we'll kind of combine eight and nine if you have any advice for maybe a student who's interested in a career in internet and social media marketing maybe what would that be is it beneficial to have that degree and what does the future of social media advertising look like is it is going to continue to be as important as it is today or do you maybe see a decline at some point i'm going to just take the very beginning of the question and i think that you have a lot to add to this but from an academic standpoint you know i said we're going to be creating a new concentration that's digital marketing so that you will continue to have this tool set of internet marketing you know seo landing pages you also have the social media side of the different platforms and so from the academic side i think it's absolutely crucial and i tell my students all the time internships you need internships and it's never too early to have an internship you're a freshman and you know you're going in your freshman summer do an internship you don't have to do one internship when you're in college you could do two three internships four internships right they're quality internships the more internships the better your perspective on what you want to do and you may meet a mentor from an academic standpoint internships are really important also it's important that you have a academic mentor and you have a practitioner mentor someone out in the business world that is willing to mentor you and you know it's very simple you just need to ask people follow them on social media and if you think what they do is interesting reach out to them most people are willing to help younger people they want to see the younger generation succeed so that's my advice for people or students who are going to be going out into the work world and i will turn it over to kathy because she probably has a little different perspective than what she does every day the advice that i would give somebody as much what dr lucic is saying try to garner as much experience as you can wherever you can okay i'm so pleased to to try to help when i can and give back when i can but if somebody comes to me and says you know kathy look here's what i've done for this company this company this company super great right i can see that this person is enthused passionate and has actually taken steps to enhance themselves enhance their professional as well as academic skill set that being said i won't speak to a beneficial degree but what i would like to say and i think this is a trend that is only going to continue and that is to stay certified and i heard something that dr lucic said earlier which is extremely critical which is google adwords hootsuite certification i think my feeling is that as the digital landscape continues to evolve and these niches continue to be carved out we will not be able to be one for all you will need to be able to differentiate yourself in a specific area and that may be in the way obviously of additional education you know through sxu and certifications that can be offered i i feel strongly that students should look to continually hone in on their craft through once they've graduated now and they're working right you're gainfully employed i believe that the importance of certification can't be understated in the future um the future of social media advertising yes it's going to be as important if not more important people will still drive a car and see a billboard there's no question about it this is not the only option but again back to what i said about our use of mobility mobile devices you know i have lots of stats here i could i could share with you but at the end of the day over 80 percent of folks own a mobile device so social media digital advertising takes place again in the palm of your hand and even now tablets are kind of falling back a little bit in terms of well was a tablet was it mobile no it's definitely mobile so number nine what does it look like um ever changing so if you are looking for a career in digital or social media advertising i think you'll have a great career path one that what you learned in college or what you learned and did in your career when you were ago will not be the same as what you're doing today and i would agree with that the idea of the mobile even if you're a local company here you know there's the internet has changed the marketplace right and there are local companies here that deal with you know a global demographic and we're used to having laptops and pcs desktops and tablets and a cell phone in a lot of emerging countries all of their internet is done by their mobile device they don't own a laptop and a you know and a um mobile phone okay it's all mobile and so the rate at which things are going mobile as we said is really significant it is increasing every day the strong push and so i think you're going to see a lot more of that people are not going to go to their desktop to check them even people outside of the millennials kathy made me think about it when she said when she looks at someone that she might employ if they can come to her and say look what i did for this company this company this company for our mba program we have our students especially if you're an internet marketing social media or if you'll be a new a student in our new concentration by the time you get out of that you'll have actually consulted for two to three a minimum two to three companies because for small companies we create this internet marketing social media plans for them and so that they have some idea you know and then probably hopefully from that a lot of them might not be equipped to do the work that's required for that but they now understand why this is so important and then hopefully they can reach out to a professional like kathy who can go ahead and take a look at what we've done and really hone in on on increasing increasing their revenue that's great so i'd like to thank dr cheryl luzak and kathy hayes for coming out today for sxu business roundtable for the digital and social media advertising interviews so thank you very much you're welcome you're welcome i'd like to thank julie for being such a wonderful host oh thank you you're a great interviewer thank you thank you for listening to the sxu business roundtable the sxu business roundtable was hosted by julie gardner ian hands is the producer and editor the executive producers are peter crayton director of student media at st xavier university and dr anthony campbell vice president for student affairs at st xavier university for more information on st xavier's gram school management please visit www.sxu.edu keyword gram school for more information on the chicago southland chamber of commerce please visit chicago southland chamber.com to listen to the complete archive of the sxu business roundtable search itunes by typing in wxav you can also visit our soundcloud account soundcloud.com slash wxav883 thank you for listening to the sxu business roundtable