EPISODE · Apr 6, 2026 · 40 MIN
Dividends vs. Buybacks & The Great Tax Deferral Debate
from The Investing for Beginners Podcast - Your Path to Financial Freedom · host By Andrew Sather, Stephen Morris, and Evan Raidt | Stock Market Guide to Buying Stocks
In this episode of the Investing for Beginners podcast, Stephen and Andrew break down the ultimate capital allocation debate: Dividends versus Stock Buybacks. They discuss the mechanics of how retiring shares increases your slice of the pie, why Wall Street treats dividend-paying companies like "boomers," and the hidden dangers of buybacks used to mask executive compensation. Andrew defends the psychology of cash dividends against Warren Buffett’s tax deferral arguments, and the duo run a live stock screener to identify the biggest buyback monsters and dividend growers of the last five years. Key Takeaways A dividend pays cash directly to your brokerage account, while a buyback retires shares, making your remaining percentage of the company more valuable and mathematically increasing Earnings Per Share (EPS). Wall Street currently favors buybacks, often viewing companies that initiate dividends as having reached the end of their growth phase. Some companies use buybacks as their primary wealth-building engine. For example, Marathon Petroleum has aggressively reduced its share count by nearly 15% a year over the last 5 years, driving massive stock appreciation. Timestamps 01:02 - Dividends vs. buybacks debate. 02:57 - How dividends work vs. how buybacks retire shares to increase EPS. 05:41 - The Wall Street stigma: Why paying a dividend is seen as a "boomer" move. 11:53 - The tax deferral argument and Warren Buffett's stance on buybacks. 17:50 - Red flags to watch for: High payout ratios and debt-fueled payouts. 18:39 - The danger of using buybacks to mask stock-based compensation (The Snowflake example). 23:20 - Do you have to choose? Companies that offer both dividends and buybacks. 24:07 - Gun to your head: Andrew chooses dividends to fulfill the ultimate retirement dream of living off the income. 29:13 - Running the stock screener: Surprising dividend growth from Ford. 32:38 - Marathon Petroleum's massive 15% annual share reduction. 35:36 - Stephen's interest in Caterpillar's 30,000-pound EV machines. 41:44 - Why Andrew prefers to invest in management teams that already have a proven track record of returning capital. Resources Mentioned The Value Spotlight Newsletter: https://einvestingforbeginners.com/value-spotlight-newsletter/ Have questions or want your story featured? Email the show at [email protected] or comment below. Your feedback shapes the podcast! Remember, invest with a margin of safety—emphasis on the safety. Have a great week, and we’ll talk to you next time. Timestamps are generated by artificial intelligence, and are not 100% accurate depending on the platform used for listening. Today’s show is sponsored by: Go to SHOPIFY.COM/beginners to start selling with Shopify today. https://www.shopify.com/beginners Download the Plynk app today to start building your investing confidence: https://plynkinvest.app.link/IFB Upgrade your wardrobe with Quince to get high-quality, luxury essentials at a fraction of the cost by visiting https://quince.com/beginners Get your free quote and see how much you could save at SelectQuote.com/beginners Turn your passion into profit, connect directly with eager buyers, and grow your business by hosting live, interactive auctions at https://whatnot.com/sell Supercharge your productivity and automate your daily tasks by building custom AI agents in your all-in-one workspace at https://notion.com/investing Get your free quote and see how much you could save at SelectQuote.com/beginners Interested in how your company sponsor the show? Reach us at [email protected] SUBSCRIBE TO THE SHOW Apple | Spotify | YouTube | Amazon | Tunein Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices
What this episode covers
In this episode of the Investing for Beginners podcast, Stephen and Andrew break down the ultimate capital allocation debate: Dividends versus Stock Buybacks. They discuss the mechanics of how retiring shares increases your slice of the pie, why Wall Street treats dividend-paying companies like "boomers," and the hidden dangers of buybacks used to mask executive compensation. Andrew defends the psychology of cash dividends against Warren Buffett’s tax deferral arguments, and the duo run a live stock screener to identify the biggest buyback monsters and dividend growers of the last five years. Key Takeaways A dividend pays cash directly to your brokerage account, while a buyback retires shares, making your remaining percentage of the company more valuable and mathematically increasing Earnings Per Share (EPS). Wall Street currently favors buybacks, often viewing companies that initiate dividends as having reached the end of their growth phase. Some companies use buybacks as their primary wealth-building engine. For example, Marathon Petroleum has aggressively reduced its share count by nearly 15% a year over the last 5 years, driving massive stock appreciation. Timestamps 01:02 - Dividends vs. buybacks debate. 02:57 - How dividends work vs. how buybacks retire shares to increase EPS. 05:41 - The Wall Street stigma: Why paying a dividend is seen as a "boomer" move. 11:53 - The tax deferral argument and Warren Buffett's stance on buybacks. 17:50 - Red flags to watch for: High payout ratios and debt-fueled payouts. 18:39 - The danger of using buybacks to mask stock-based compensation (The Snowflake example). 23:20 - Do you have to choose? Companies that offer both dividends and buybacks. 24:07 - Gun to your head: Andrew chooses dividends to fulfill the ultimate retirement dream of living off the income. 29:13 - Running the stock screener: Surprising dividend growth from Ford. 32:38 - Marathon Petroleum's massive 15% annual share reduction. 35:36 - Stephen's interest in Caterpillar's 30,000-pound EV machines. 41:44 - Why Andrew prefers to invest in management teams that already have a proven track record of returning capital. Resources Mentioned The Value Spotlight Newsletter: https://einvestingforbeginners.com/value-spotlight-newsletter/ Have questions or want your story featured? Email the show at [email protected] or comment below. Your feedback shapes the podcast! Remember, invest with a margin of safety—emphasis on the safety. Have a great week, and we’ll talk to you next time. Timestamps are generated by artificial intelligence, and are not 100% accurate depending on the platform used for listening. Today’s show is sponsored by: Go to SHOPIFY.COM/beginners to start selling with Shopify today. https://www.shopify.com/beginners Download the Plynk app today to start building your investing confidence: https://plynkinvest.app.link/IFB Upgrade your wardrobe with Quince to get high-quality, luxury essentials at a fraction of the cost by visiting https://quince.com/beginners Get your free quote and see how much you could save at SelectQuote.com/beginners Turn your passion into profit, connect directly with eager buyers, and grow your business by hosting live, interactive auctions at https://whatnot.com/sell Supercharge your productivity and automate your daily tasks by building custom AI agents in your all-in-one workspace at https://notion.com/investing Get your free quote and see how much you could save at SelectQuote.com/beginners Interested in how your company sponsor the show? Reach us at [email protected] SUBSCRIBE TO THE SHOW Apple | Spotify | YouTube | Amazon | Tunein Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices
NOW PLAYING
Dividends vs. Buybacks & The Great Tax Deferral Debate
No transcript for this episode yet
Similar Episodes
Mar 26, 2026 ·1m
Mar 19, 2026 ·34m
Feb 18, 2026 ·11m
Feb 11, 2026 ·45m