Skip to content
dog training rules to live by | deep talk radio episode artwork

Aug 21, 2024 23 min

dog training rules to live by | deep talk radio

from deep talk radio Hosted by the smartest animal

all great dog training starts with great rules. annarose is back on deep talk radio to discuss the three rules she implements in her work with beloved canines. this episode is part of the deep talk radio archive, presented by the smartest animal. originally released under an earlier version of the show, this conversation is preserved for context, continuity, and long-term discovery. deep talk radio explores creativity, self-awareness, and the relationships we build—including the human–dog bond. select episodes focus on dog training, canine behavior, communication, and building trust between dogs and their handlers. these conversations may cover: positive reinforcement training behavior modification obedience foundations dog psychology owner awareness the role of consistency and emotional regulation in effective training all archived episodes are part of a broader creative universe centered on intentional listening, long-form discussion, and thoughtful exploration—whether the subject is art, identity, or working with animals. this show values consistency over trends, depth over noise, and long-term thinking over short-term attention. tags / keywords deep talk radio, the smartest animal, dog training podcast, canine behavior podcast, positive reinforcement dog training, dog obedience training, dog behavior modification, human dog relationship, dog psychology, training dogs with consistency, dog communication, responsible dog ownership, long form dog training conversations, thoughtful dog training, animal behavior podcast

Episode details come from the podcast's RSS feed.

Embed this episode

Ready to play

dog training rules to live by | deep talk radio

0:00 23:14
of matches

Transcript Auto-generated, may contain errors

You're now listening to Vices and Vultures, a podcast on cultures. What's going on everybody? This is A2 and on Fridays we'll feature regular guests who will share the cultures that they're passionate about. Anna Rose is back so I'll let her introduce the next doc topic.

Hey everyone. In this episode we're playing about the conversation about three rules that I live by when working with dogs. So last episode we talked about timing motivation and consistency. We're going to go into detail with it today.

What is it that you as a dog trainer would like to emphasize the clients working with their dogs as far as timing is concerned? There are a lot of different instances where it comes out differently in how timing is really important. But I like to give a couple examples to kind of help clarify what it means. So if I were to leave my dog loose in the house and he were to get in the trash and trash everywhere when I get home and he's just laying on the couch happy as it can be.

If I were to correct him at that point then he wouldn't associate that correction with getting into the trash. But he would rather associate it with the situation of becoming home and trash being everywhere and probably associate it with being on the couch too because that's where he was when I corrected him and what he was doing. He was just sleeping on the couch. So a lot of people will say that like, oh my dog looks guilty or like you see those videos online all the time.

It's like this dog is guilty. No, it's what he did. But dogs are so in tune to our energy and our body language and the way that we act and how like consistent we are about things. So if we react the same way every time to something then they're going to react to how we're reacting the same way every time.

But the dog's still getting the trash. Oh he's not really understanding the correction with getting into the trash. So timing is more of where are you when the incident actually happens. Yes, they have to be caught in the act pretty much.

Whether it's a positive thing or not, it's like, oh you're doing the right thing right now. So I have to catch you in the act of that with a reward. You are like actually physically getting into the trash in this moment. I'm going to give you a correction for that.

Right correlation. Exactly. Yeah, an association. So yeah.

Another example we have. Another example for rewards would be this kind of a simplified one. But if my dog is sitting and I go to give him a food reward and as he takes the food, he stands up, then he's going to associate the reward with standing up and not with being in a sit position because at that moment when he took the reward, he was standing up. So it's like that close and timing.

Yeah. But we have a saving grace. Some people utilize clicker training. I don't actually use clickers, but I use the same similar method.

I use markers. So I just use a word. It's a word association. So you can use any word or sound you wanted to.

But whenever I write before I reward my dog, I use the word good. So when I start working with a new dog, then let's say he sits down and then I want to reward him for that. So his body's the ground. I say good and then I reward right away.

So eventually he learns like, oh, when I hear this word good, then I'm going to get a reward. A reward is coming. So I can bridge the timing gap by being further away and say good and then walk to him and get him a reward and just like I'm able to communicate that way of like using that sound, that marker, that good word to show him that he's doing the right thing because he knows that a reward is coming when I say good, the same with correction. So utilizing teaching a dog what no actually means by when they do something that they shouldn't be doing, marking, saying no, and then following up with a correction right away.

Eventually it won't mean that you probably won't even need corrections anymore depending on the dog. But if it's consistent that every time that they give the word no, they get a correction right away afterwards when they're first initially in training, then they'll have an association with the word no meaning hey, stop what you're doing. That's good. I like that a lot.

And right into the next point is motivation. So dogs understand communication physically better than anything else. So positive motivation can be treats, it can be petting them, it can be toys, it can be anything really that that particular dog likes and it's going to be different for every dog just because one dog loves this kind of treat doesn't mean that the next dog will and just because this dog loves all toys doesn't mean that the next dog will be motivated by toys. So I have to really like find what the speech specific dog is motivated by positively to be able to teach them behaviors utilizing that.

And different breeds have different personalities more or less but it's still very dependent dog right? Correct. Yeah, I see a lot of people get a dog of a certain breed and then they get a second one thinking it's going to be like the same dog or similar dog and it's completely different. So yeah, there are certain breed traits but it really is like no guarantee.

It's not just like set in stone that if you get this breed you're going to get this kind of dog. So it's also conditioning like where they came from. Absolutely. Yeah conditioning training imprinting all that stuff.

Cool. So physical rewards as opposed to verbal which is super important. I think we're going to talk about that in like another episode. Yeah.

So we're motivated by praise like if you're just talking more like highly towards them and you brings up your energy brings up their energy they can be motivated by but like it's usually not enough and usually they're motivated by praise because it's been paired with something higher value to them in the past. Like when it's like when your first house breaking a puppy and they go potty outside and you're like oh good boy good boy and you give him a treat at the same time then like if you stop giving him the treats at some point and you just like good boy good boy and then he's like a associating he's being motivated by the praise because in the past he had gotten a treat with it. So he's really like it's again back to the timing thing the markers thing of like words and praise are usually positive only once they've been paired with something more valuable. Got you and the immediacy of it not waiting because then he's done the teaching thing.

They're not associating it with what you intended yeah. Got you. Yeah well and that can be shown too like at first you start with like rewarding the puppy right after it goes potty outside and then eventually they are they wait till you come back inside and they're like excited because they know they get their cookie because they went potty outside. Got you.

So that's like you can bridge that time and gap almost inadvertently because if you're consistent about it. So that's positive motivation? Yeah that's a basic sketch of it. Do you have any other examples for positive motivation?

I utilize toys with my dogs in training and like releasing them to go play with a toy rather than like rewarding them on the spot. So like different kinds of motivating. So when I first was working with my dogs some of my dogs are more like competition obedience trained so it's a little bit different than just basic obedience. So when I was first working with them it was a lot of food rewards right away.

So let's say I wanted them to stay in a down position. So they go into the down and I'd be like good reward good reward good reward and just like powerhouse rewards all over and then eventually once they understood the down command and understood that it was a rewarding place to stay then I would stretch it so they'd have to stay in it longer without being rewarded and then I would release them to go get their toy when they stayed for a longer period of time. So that can be another way to utilize like a different kind of reward if like the dog doesn't like food or you just want to kind of get away from using it as much. I follow.

I like that. Yeah. So going into negative motivation again dogs are going to understand best when it's physical. I mean just think about the way that you could they communicate with each other if you just watch dogs together they're always physical with each other.

I mean if they're just playing they're like figuring out who the where the pack is and you know who's the pack leader where the hierarchy is all that using their mouths they're using their paws they're using their arms their entire body is there like they're all about that's how they communicate with each other's primarily physical. So we have to match that for them and communicate with them in a way that they understand. So I use all kinds of different physical negative motivation. Dog trainers will usually call them corrections or correctional devices or communication devices I like to call them.

Collars pretty much like whether it's a flat collar a prom collar a remote collar it's going to be different for every dog and different for every goal really. So I'm going to have like a separate podcast we're going to do a separate podcast that's going to cover those like actual correctional devices in more depth because there's a lot that goes into them and a lot that needs to kind of be heft out about them. But pretty much it comes down to it needs to be physical and something that that specific dog sees as motivational. So you know some dogs might be fine with just a little pop on the flat collar on the leash and they're like okay I'll stop what I was doing and others need like a pretty high level correction on a remote collar to stop the behavior.

And I mentioned before that I use negative motivation to reinforce behaviors. So that is definitely one thing that like if once a dog fully understands a command and I can tell that like when I say down you understand that that means to lay down and to stay there then I can start bringing in corrections for either refusing to do it or breaking the position or moving from the position before I've told them that they can. So it's to reinforce that like hey you know this you understand this and even when you don't want to do it you still need to because it could mean your safety. And then on want to behaviors like chewing on furniture jumping on you rushing out the door you know so obviously all of those have to be communicated differently but it's like call those avoid directions usually if you want the dog to stop something and never do it again you will utilize a higher level correction than their typical correction level.

So there are two examples that I like to utilize that help to clarify what motivation means and kind of a way that we would understand better. So positive motivation is like a dog's paycheck. So we don't go to work to receive something that we don't see as valuable right like everybody sees money as valuable. There's not one thing across the board that all dogs see as valuable and if you go to another country then like they might not see a dollar as valuable you know so it's like a similar concept you know not every dog is going to see toys as valuable or treats as valuable even the same treats as valuable you know you get the point.

So we go to work and we get a paycheck so we have to pay our dogs for working for us you know like at least for a period of time and then you can kind of taper off on certain rewards once like a behavior is more learned but if it's just negative motivation all the time then you'll have a negative dog. You'll just see like I'm just like corrected for things like what do I do right so we need a balance of reward paycheck for doing the right thing as well as like hey I'm communicating to you that you did the wrong thing as well that's that's clear you know to anybody it's like we need a balance of both in the same way for like similar to negative motivation like to compare it to a speeding ticket. If I were to get pulled over and get like a 10 cent speeding ticket then I will probably continue to speak because it didn't really affect me that much. If I were to get pulled over and get like a $50,000 speeding ticket I may never drive again.

I would be like okay that's terrifying I'm just gonna you know curl up and ball whenever leave. If I get a $200 speeding ticket then that's like ouch that hurts a little like you know but I'm motivated now to stop speeding and that's you know similar to what dogs the difference of correction level for dogs it just has to be physical so again some dogs may see like a little pop on a collar as they're like okay that's motivating for me and there are people that may be motivated to stop speeding by a 10 cent speeding ticket but I'm not. And then other people may see a $50,000 speeding ticket and say like whatever like you know I'll still keep speeding and in the same way some dogs are gonna need that higher correction level then so it's really gonna be different for every dog case by case and just you know has to be figured out. And has to be consistent with the third one.

Yeah it is. Yeah correction the correction level and see correction level can be hard too because it changes based on environment and situation and destruction and everything like that too so you know I utilize remote collars with all of my dogs and for example like Drogo's level is all over the place usually like his typical working level is probably like a 40 and then the collars that I use go from a zero or one to 127 so if he if we're playing with a ball and he's like all excited and amped and he really wants the toy then I'm gonna have to hire his correction level probably if because he wants something more if he's just lazing around the house and then he just starts to like sort of non something that he shouldn't be he probably doesn't need that correction so it's like you know if there are tons of dogs around and he just like is all excited then correction level has to go high it's really you know for any dog but his then then Kena her correction level is start off is lower so you know if she's typically on a 30 I would have to jump up probably to like double that to a 60 so general rule is like I usually go up by 5 so like go to 35 and then 40 and like whatever they start to respond and this is for a dog that's like been trained on a remote collar they understand remote corrections and how to respond to them for the certain behaviors so but just to show that different situations are gonna affect correction level. So we're at a third point which is consistency and pretty much everything that you've been talking about goes one into the other which is really really nice so let's talk a little bit more about what consistency is according to you when your dog training. So I think a common kind of misconception with consistency is that it means like you have to work with the dog you know this much every day you're like you know an hour every day or whatever it is but more so when I talk about consistency it's that when you work with the dog you work with them the same way in the same manner you know giving the same kind of correction and building up on that so because I can go work with the dog once a week and the next week they like pretty much remember where we left off like we can pick up where we left off and they because I consistently am working with them the way that I was before.

It's when if I were to go work with the dog you know this way that week and then I try to go the next week and work with them differently then that would be super confusing and they wouldn't actually like learn much and advance much. It gets really difficult because it can be really hard to be consistent because dogs are always watching what we're doing and always catching like what's the purpose of a dog's life. It's just like eat, sleep and be with your human if you're a pack. So they're always observing they're always feeling even our energy and just like what's they're just part of their environment all the time.

So they're going to notice things that we didn't even realize we were being inconsistent about. A good example of an inconsistency that's kind of you might not even be aware of. So let's say I'm like in the backyard with my dog on a Sunday afternoon and we're playing ball and he like goes and grabs the ball comes back jumps on me and we're just playing a cake take the ball throw it again. And then Monday morning comes and I have my work clothes on and I'm like trying to get ready to leave and he's out in the backyard and I walk out there and he comes running out with the ball and jumps on me.

If I yell at him or correct him in that moment then he's like what the heck like yesterday this was permissible and now it's not like he has no idea that I have like different clothes on that I'm trying to leave that like the situation you know this is different. He sees it as the same situation of like we're in the backyard. I have my ball we're playing yesterday I jumped on you you were happy about it today you're not that's confusing that's inconsistent. So and usually inconsistency will mean that the dog will try to do the behavior more because they're trying to figure out when they're going to be corrected and when it's permissible.

So they almost test the unisense. Yeah in a way or they're just you know it depends on the dog too like I I'll give an example of like two of my dogs so Kenna she's more compliant. You know if I were to let her run out the door some days and other days make her sit before I told her she could go up the door then she would probably choose to sit first just in case I was going to ask her to do that before going out the door versus Drogo who's just like a bull in a china shop and just like does everything quickly. He would if I was did the same thing just let him run out the door sometimes and then ask him to sit other times he would try to like bum rush the door every time because I was inconsistent about it.

So it's just the difference of like compliance and kind of temperament and disposition as well that plays into you know how consistency is going to affect them but if for both of them if I were to be consistent about hey every time right before I open the door you sit you wait and then I let you run out the door that's clear communication there's no confusion there's no should I sit should I run should I you know what should I do it's oh this is this is what we do next. Right absolutely cool. Alright so that is timing motivation consistency in detail thank you for explaining that and I love the examples that you use because they're very very applicable to human everyday life and I love how clear you make it so you can relate it to dogs and dog training so are there any last words that you have regarding timing motivation consistency as well. Pretty much just like reminding that every dog is different and everything is case by case there's nothing that's like across the board these three things are like definitely proven to be main principles of training and main ways that we can utilize to communicate with dogs but within that you know again every dog's motivation is different every dog's gonna be affected differently by consistency by timing so there's just there's really no cookie cutter way to train dogs there's no this is how you train a dog there's no this is what a dog trainer is it's like it's all kind of case by case.

Okay cool thank you so much thank you. Thank you for tuning into this episode my goal is to educate and feature Fridays allow me to share what I have learned and I'm learning about dogs. Thank you for taking the time to listen to this episode of vices and vultures and considering being a supporter of this project even leaving a review on your preferred podcast platform goes a long way for us. There is more information about this episode as well as who we are in the show notes this includes all of our social media links so you can see us and not just hear us.

Vices and vultures is brought to you by aesthetic and is based in the great state of New York be sure to subscribe to this podcast for more episodes and tune in next time to vices and vultures.

Frequently asked questions

How long is this episode of deep talk radio?

This episode is 23 minutes long.

When was this deep talk radio episode published?

This episode was published on August 21, 2024.

Is there a transcript available for this episode?

Yes, a full transcript is available for this episode. You can read the complete transcript on the episode page.

Can I download this deep talk radio episode?

Yes. Use the download control on the episode player to save the publisher-provided media file.