Don't Worry-He's Only "Mostly Dead" | UYNC S3 Ep 15

Nobody stays dead in comics… except Bucky, Jason Todd, and Uncle Ben. Well. About that. This week, CiCi is getting into the many, many flavors of comic-book death: actually dead, presumed dead, retconned dead, resurrected, restored, undead, and “technically I survived the explosion, but things have not exactly been going great since.” We’re looking at what happened when Superman died—and why bringing him back didn’t erase what happened while he was gone. Then we get into Marvel Zombies, DCeased, and Blackest Night before asking the most important question in superhero medicine: did anybody actually see a body? From there, we’re talking Jason Todd’s extremely complicated road from Robin to Red Hood, including the reader vote that killed him, the explosion that actually did it, and the reality-warping/Lazarus Pit mess that eventually brought him back. Then there’s Bucky Barnes, whose famous death turned out to be a decades-long case of “actually, he survived,” and Uncle Ben, who is currently doing most of the heavy lifting for the concept of staying dead. Because maybe the question isn’t whether a character can come back. Maybe it’s whether their death still matters after they do. A couple of nerdy housekeeping notes: Bucky Barnes debuted in Captain America Comics #1 (1941)—CiCi shortened that to “Captain America #1” while recording. And during You’ve Got Issues, CiCi managed to hold up and discuss The Lady or the Tiger? and Other Logic Puzzles without actually saying its author’s name. The book is by Raymond Smullyan, and we apologize to Professor Smullyan’s ghost for discussing a book about logical reasoning while neglecting one extremely relevant fact. Follow @UpYourNerdCredPod on Instagram, and find the show on Apple Podcasts, Spotify, and YouTube. If you’ve got a burning nerd question you want us to tackle, leave a comment—and if we use it, we’ll shout you out in the discussion segment.