Are you a pet owner? Every six seconds. A pet owner in the US gets hit with a vet bill over $1,000. Always an unwelcome surprise. That's where Fetch comes in. Fetch is the most complete pet insurance for dogs and cats.
According to consumer advocate.org, you get paid back up to 90% of vet bills at any vet in the US and Canada, with claims paid back in as little as two days. Go to fetchpet.com.save right now for your free quote. That's fetchpet.com.save. Smooth, buttery, marshmallowy, warm, soft, soft, soft, underwear, teas and more. Bumble, everyday comfort, worth obsessing over. Visit bumble.com.com.com.audio and use code audio for 20% off your first purchase.
That's B-O-M-B-A-S dot com slash audio. One purchase equals one donated. Always. US voters abroad. Have you got your ballot yet? All states are now sending ballots to overseas voters.
So if you want to vote this year, you should request your ballot right away. Go to votefromabroad.org and click request my ballot as to receive a by email. Questions? Ask our support team directly. Don't miss this chance to shake the future.
Don't delay. Votefromabroad.org. Hello, welcome to our podcast, the flagship podcast of cute little guys. We have all your data. That's actually about Sam Altman.
Ha! You weren't. That's not what you think about it. But I'm glad you guys. I'm not saying I'm Mark. David and Mel, here.
Hey, hey, buddy. Hey, I'm still here. You're still here. You know, every week, I say we're going to keep you. And it's gotten more and more threatening over time. Yeah, I've gotten threats as well.
Well, this is technically your last week with us. David Pierce is back next week. But it is true. We're going to find ways to keep you on the show. I'm up into it. Let's go.
That's a solemn promise. And by that, I mean, you can't leave the office. I've been here for weeks. Jay Cash, Nacos, here as well. What's up, man? Hey, good to be here.
The David's are like particle and antiparticle. They can't collide. We can't be on a show together. I'll explode. Yeah.
There's a lot of this week. We'll run it all down in one second. But first, I want to call out. We were nominated for some awards. The signal awards are happening. Those are big podcast awards.
The version is on the end for all of our shows. Decoder was on the end for Best Business Podcast, version history for Best History Podcast. That's up against the heavy hitters, like actual history. We're like, what's a phone? We're in the finals. So I'm very excited about that.
And in the first podcast, not only for Best Technology Podcast, like so many awards. There's the formal judge voting, but there's also audience voting. What's your voting? So we'll have all the links in the show notes and descriptions. Click on those links and vote for us because we love winning.
That's who we are. We just love winning. Fainty tile, how deeply competitive and in need of validation. That's who we are. All right, Jake, what are we talking about this week?
Time to talk about this week. We're going to have a big gadget segment. There's new kindles, a ton of Apple rumors. We're going to have a sort of chaos lightning round. America has a chatbot now. And if you saw this, America has an AI chatbot.
Very good news. But first, we start off with, I think, the big AI news of the week, which is it was OpenAI's week. They did dots. It's their answer to news. Dots is it's same thing. It's got a cute little avatar. It's got a chat interface.
And it goes off and does things for you, except unlike news, which meta is just like, here, please take a muse. Have as many muses as you want. Dots, you got to pay $100 a month minimum. And I think that the question right now that GATE is, is this a different product for a different set of people, right? Is this a business product? Or is OpenAI just not able to compete with meta's ability to just, you know,
blanket the entire universe with compute because they have so much money? And I'm curious where your head is at after seeing all this. I would say at a minimum, it being for pro subscribers and business plus subscribers only is kind of dragging it towards the business user case. But also when you sign up for muse, it can be like, can you like, can you like, Instagram, like Facebook, can I connect all the things that everyday users use every single day? And notably, it gives you a giant list of prompts that you can ask it.
Because I think people are faced with these things that are not really sure what to do with it. And if you're on chat GPT and are using that everyday for work, it makes a little bit more sense to have like a personal agent that's going and doing work tasks for you. But muse is not really a work task product. It's more of a like, put things on Facebook, Facebook marketplace for me, which I did, because he liked me too. And yeah, I did. And it did technically work. And it was very fast. And I listed like 30 products.
I think I sold like an old backpack of mine. But when someone got to my apartment, they said, how's your time with the verge going? And then I asked him to delete all my listings. Yeah. Was that before the person posted on threads that muse had sent somebody their house with a little offer?
It was the day before. Oh boy. The day before. And then I saw the writing on the wall. So yeah, I think they're very different products.
I'm still a little bit confused about what people are using this for outside of what they were already using OpenAI, like chat GPT stuff for because that was already doing autonomous tasks for them, like GoX and things like that. I want to know what people are going to use dots for because it seems like muse is very oriented around meta products. Dots is for launching your website while you're making dinner. That is what I learned from their launch video. OpenAI's marketing for dots is a little over the place that they had that example.
They had wedding planning in the mix, but then also like hardcore sulfur engineering. And it was like, it can do everything. Work tasks. Whereas muse is very much a concern about it. We talked about it last week.
Like, that is good at consumer products. They are definitely good at engaging you to do more on their platforms. Like they have one skill and it's engagement bait and they're really good at it. I feel nothing about letting muse operate other meta products for me. So I have it watching my Instagram and every single morning, it finds all the most interesting comments left on my Instagram posts and tells me to go reply to them.
So I can be in contact. That makes me feel very much like a robot. It's telling me what to do every morning. Like I'm mad at it every morning. I'm like, you don't have to tell me to do.
But it is also true that I would never see or think to reply to the most interesting comments on Instagram. Something that has been interesting about muse is that it's very proactive. So I hooked up to my Google calendar as well. And I knew that I was going to this like media dinner party thing. And it also knew that I had to be home by a certain time.
So it told me you should leave on a city bike because a city bike is faster than taking the subway. And if you want to get home on time, make sure you leave it in 920. Do you want me to ping you when you need to leave? And I was like, okay, this kind of, I kind of understand this. That's kind of interesting.
But the thing you're describing is all kind of work like, right? Like all these things that are neat, even like, you know, use my Instagram for me. Fine. I had it look for like AI accounts that I hadn't seen before because I want to expand the roster of people that I look at on Instagram talking about. All that is work. It's just work. It's fun work. It's work that rhymes with fun, I guess.
Work attainment. Whatever that is. Rising grind. But it is. I think this is the problem for consumer agents.
And a lot of people since me was announced and launched have come to this conclusion. Obviously, I call it software brain that to even understand what to do with an agent, you have to understand your life as a series of tasks. Trustee Nicole and Cotton, who's a New York Times conist, a long term boost guy about how the problem with consumer agents is literally cultural. You have to understand yourself as a series of tasks in order to understand what an agent can do for you. And that, like, there's a cultural divide in America that will prevent some people from ever seeing that.
I think that's fascinating. Right. It may be the thesis of the whole version. The thesis of the whole show is technology makes people think about themselves differently. So here's the thing that's going to happen. Because Matt does have the marketing dollars and the straight up dollars
to give everybody a billion tokens and a little computer in the cloud. And then they can market it across every one of their services. And maybe it's true that five years from now, everyone in America will just think of themselves as a series of tasks. The same way that the phone or the steam engine or whatever made you think about yourself differently. Yeah. And I don't think that dots is going out and telling you what you should be doing with dots.
But the primary tab on Muse, the center tab is the ideas tab. And it's plugged in. When it's plugged in all your stuff, it says, I can do this for you. I can open this past dealer. I can just I can distill launch week into one type of brief. I can hold your inbox at a clean baseline.
I can finish this briefing reply for you. It's just trying to get you to use it proactively so that you slowly understand what the capabilities of things are. I actually felt very similar about this product that I felt to chat JBT when it first launched. I looked at it and I was like, there's an infinite black box and I don't know what to do with it. Everyone's like, it's game changing. It's going to change everything about the way you do work.
Blah, blah, blah. But when you look at infinite possibilities, there's sort of this anxiety where you just don't know where to start. And I feel like Meta is doing a pretty good job of trying to help people understand what agents are even for in the first place. Yeah. I mean, yeah, this is their background as a consumer company.
They understand consumers. The defaults are important. And what you're describing is basically just a bunch of default agent tasks. The one that I got that was particularly good. The only personal data I've given is like spam Gmail.
It's like, well, I don't give it anything else. Again, I feel nothing about letting it operate in my meta accounts because I already passed them. So what? But I gave it my spam Gmail and every couple days, it's like, you're in another class action lawsuit. Do you want me to file for 50 bucks? And I'm like, yeah, go ahead.
I would never look for them. I would never go out these PDFs. Like, go forth. And there was one moment where in order for the forums, I had to tell it my phone number, which was the piece of info. And I was like, oh, hey, that's 50 bucks. I give you that phone number. Yeah.
And that is fascinating to me. And I think the distinction I would draw from dots is obviously meta does not have as capable of a model. Right. No one thinks that whatever is running me is as powerful as GPC six Astro, which is what power starts. But they have a better user interface for consumers. And dots, you know, again, it's very confused.
All their ideas were on the margins for software engineers, but it's also true that they have the more powerful model. And that's what I'm charging money for. And they say they're going to bring the consumers one assume as soon as they bring it to the cheaper model. But I just think it's like an interesting A.B. test to say, do you want work agents like this with a really powerful model that can do all of the things a frontier model can do?
Or do you want to be on Rails with a kind of dumber model, but it's a lot easier to use the thing. And, you know, the consumers and our markets are different in one class of hundred bucks. Somewhere in the middle of that is Grockbot, right? Grock has this thing too, and it works a lot like these products do. It's somewhere as open claw. If you want to roll your own, you should point out that opening a higher peter extnerver who made open claw and then that would beat them to the punch.
So, I'm curious, the story of opening eye to me has always been one of wanting to be a consumer company and realizing they have to be an enterprise company. So they launched with ChatchvT, which was supposed to take Google. Right? That was their ambition. They were going to replace Google. They were going to replace Google search. That's one of the most lucrative businesses in the whole world.
They hired a bunch of people from Meta, which is fascinating in the dynamic. They started doing ads in ChatchvT, and then anthropic did cloud code in particular, and the enterprise usage of cloud exploded. Whereas that period of time when every third opening executive would write a memo declaring a code red, they were unfocused. We got ChatchvT on store, a code red. We're focused on coding.
And now they're with dots which have the fuzzy avatars and it's cute and the branding feels very consumer, but it's a work product. And I don't know if OpenEye has decided which way it wants to go. And this is the story of every company, right? They all want to be a consumer product. Consumer products are fun.
They're very widely used. You're powerful if your Mark Zuckerberg and everyone in the world uses multiple of your products. But then they realize that the money is an enterprise because people actually pay you money and they actually have money that they're ready to spend. And this is what happened within anthropic. They discovered that coding works. There's a ton of money to pay for coding tools.
And I think OpenEye is in a similar position. They're burning through cash. So great. They're going to make business tools and sell into business users, particularly in a world where Google, listen, you can't escape AI overviews. And so do you need ChatchvT or place that? It does a good job, but they're not going to completely overthrow Google anymore.
People are there with the same product. So I think it's a very open question whether they can still crack consumer market in the same way. Maybe they will eventually try to do that with this hardware product that they're allegedly working on that will come out, what's supposed to be next year, I think. But that still feels like a very big question whether anybody wants to carry around a dot in their pocket or whatever this one's up being. Yeah, OpenEye still feels a little bit confused on which end of the market they want to satisfy.
Because, like you said, they were originally were like fastest growing consumer app of all time. They were just like everyone has touched ChatchvT. There are over a billion users, that kind of thing. And then when anthropic came in and we're like, oh, we're actually making money and we're selling enterprise. That felt like what Astro was supposed to be for them. Was there big pivot to, okay, we're enterprise now? Yes, regular people can use this, but the tasks that it's really for are like 3D modeling and enterprise tasks.
And then now Meta comes in with a consumer product. When opening I was trying for so long to make a consumer product, that's got to feel kind of bad because now you're on the back foot on both sides. It's just like one caveat. Anthropic loves to announce that it's making money using accounting rules that do not have anything to do with reality. We did see their S1 this week. Liz is going to write a whole piece about it. But if Robics financials are fiction in like a real way.
But it's true that they are generating some revenue. OpenEye is obviously generating some revenue. They are just burning money on training and all the stuff that we're doing. Meta doesn't really have this problem. They are spending a lot of money. And if you look at their financials closely, they are making a huge bet here.
But Meta has a giant advertising business. They can to some extent afford to light money on fire. It's very funny. You see Adam Misari was on threads and he was announcing like Instagram plus the paid subscription. He's like, this is how we can put out features and afford to make them.
Immediately community noted it was like, it's one of the richest companies in the world. We can afford to do anything. And he was like, yeah, I have to reply to his own. Meta spent years trying to build metaverse that people use and it's about a million dollars. Yeah.
But I can burn money. And so there's a part of this where meta can burn money. They are not running a frontier model. So it must be cheaper to do inference. And then they have this massive distribution environment where they don't have to buy advertising.
Like, you know, they announced dots by buying ads on meta platforms. This is this is just a huge advantage for meta that they can just layer it everywhere. Every time I open up Instagram, there are muse ads. Yeah. This doesn't make any like these products have nothing to do with each other. Yeah.
In Instagram, you can directly DM a reel or something to your muse agent. So they just they have it all over the certain like the surfaces are everywhere. They're just trying to get it feels exactly the same to how they bootstrap threads. Like they're just putting it everywhere in the apps that you're already using. And I will just call this out one more time. People still think threads is a fun. Even though threads want to some of the most interesting text social media features of any platform all the time, people still think it's a fun.
And meta's distribution advantage often can't overcome its coolness deficit. Yeah. Yes. That's a real problem. I'm very we're obviously in the age of consumer agents or consumer agents. That's what all the fluffy cute branding is for.
Yeah. The idea that there will one day be an opening a hardware device that there will come one day a muse device. We have a headline that's like the Tomogachis are here basically. The fascinating thing is someone asked Adam Sari whether the muse charm would have Instagram and he said no. And this to me is we've talked about it so many times you can have this other device. But if it doesn't in particular have Instagram, you will have your phone.
Yeah. Then what? It feels like meta is kind of afraid of just rebuilding the phone again though, right? Like if you have a dedicated device for a very specific thing and you're just like, yeah, wait, we shouldn't Instagram and maybe we should have texting and maybe we should have a phone. Yeah. That's a wide screen. I thought it's such controls. Yeah. Exactly. I mean, this to me, this is the upcoming problem. Obviously, we are weeks away from the iPhone duo coming out.
All these devices are going to exist in that context where you can just open the muse app on your phone and you can use it that way. And it's perfectly great. Or they're going to ask you to buy another device for some reason. And I think initially that reason is just do you like this? Is this anything to quote David Pierce?
Is this anything? But that is the big bet on the future of all these devices. That is the Rabbit R1. What's the humane pin? There was a class of these devices once upon a time that did not have the agent software capabilities to justify existing.
Now they might write that it all these things are open call on one way or another. You can just do it again. Another company can do it again. I can't wait for the weird Lenovo CES announcement of an open call. It's like all that stuff is coming for us.
The question is, is any of it going to overcome a phone? Because we're about to see just dozens of agent software platform launches. I'm starting to get them in mind box almost every day. What's my question to you? Would you use a dedicated AI agent device or just use it on your phone?
I know where I've gotten to. I've been thinking a lot about the duo. What am I going to buy? I'm going to buy a duo. It's obvious because I'm the sort of person who reads a lot of PDFs in the back of Ubers. And this is how boring my life is.
And I can justify the purchase of a bigger phone. I don't want to carry that around all the time. And I think that's why Apple introduced Handoff. So you can have a smaller but still competent phone most of the time. And I've just been thinking, would I use that handoff for an even smaller thing?
So it's like a news charm. I just you take myself, I'm going to leave the house with this. And if I need to send a text message, I can do it by voice. But then it's like the long tail of apps starts to show up. We'll let you be able to actually call an Uber. We don't know yet.
That has to be developed. If I need a Google map, is the meta news charm going to have Google maps? Or is it going to strike a deal with like here maps like a third tier car? Oh, yeah. All that needs to come into focus.
So much of the argument for these also seems to be like, okay, you know, it's lower touch, right? You can leave the heavy phone and all the apps and the notifications and distractions to the side. You just have your little pin. But now it's like, okay, and there's a cute little dancing avatar on it. And also it can't do all these things.
And so you have to pull it out and like give it various instructions for how to do all this stuff. And it's going to take more time to do all these phone tasks. It gets very hard to see where the space is that you're gaining time from these when, man, news has a great presence on my phone. That thing has sent me more notifications. And you know what's annoying? They're not even bad. Like most of the time, it's stuff like David mentioned where it's like, hey, by the way, this person added a meeting to your calendar and they moved it around and overlapped with this other thing.
And I'm like, I wasn't looking at my calendar. Like, yeah. You want to use it? Okay, your calendar. My job to work is in your calendar.
This to me, the whole argument for dots is it costs money, right? And so if I'm paying the money, I can be demanding as a consumer and probably they will understand they should not do horrible privacy violating things. Now, just opening up the privacy of dozens of British mathematicians every week. For some reason, that's the thing they decided to start doing. And they're like stealing the answers to the test. That's a whole problem. Can you trust any of these companies?
I don't know. I do know that meta, Mark Zuckerberg has announced that the business model for me is taking a cut of transactions, which I think it was Casey who first said this. That implies that they will soon be a growth team at meta whose job it is to increase the volume of transactions, just like there's a growth team at Apple whose job it is to increase the number of subscriptions apps in app purchases and transactions. You know what this product looks like when that team gets its hand on it, right? It's going to go from helpful proactive messages about your calendar to, hey, we see you're getting home late. Do you want to use some food?
Right? Like they're going to start being like, would you like to spend money? I can save you a couple bucks. I know you're about to order a new toothbrush. Like you can just see where it's going. And I boy, do I not want to participate in that. And I think that's going to be the real danger of the consumer agent is the only business model which can work as advertising.
And then it's just like, not only do you have a personal shopper, you have a personal shopper who's true avatar is Mark Zuckerberg. Yeah. Well, that's deep. Yeah. They are also inadvertently declaring war on Amazon by doing this, right? Because if Amazon's blocking it and they want you to make as many transactions as possible, they're going to have to figure out ways for it to be interesting enough for you to want to buy the product that you're willing to wait two weeks for instead of two days.
And I feel like that's, that's a big barrier that they're going to have to surpass. Obviously they already have Instagram shopping and they're probably going to be pushing you all these like t shirts and whatever that are dropshipped. But at the same time, if you're going to be buying regular commerce from them that you do on an everyday basis, which it seems like they're kind of pushing towards, they're going to have to figure out a way to get around Amazon for that. Or they're just going to send everybody to Walmart. Like some other giant commerce platform is going to take that back, right? Can we pull two points of market share away from Amazon because of news?
Yeah. And if you know, meta can offer Amazon some, some additional volume, which is hard at Amazon scale, but that's the argument they're going to make. Yeah. But these are going to become weird backroom deals and then your little butler will be corrupt. Like the ultimate problem is this business model is do you want to corrupt Butler? Yeah.
And there's apartments like, yes, like, baby, like maybe you want to slightly corrupt Butler? Imagine you had a butler at home and they got a cut of every sale they made. So they were constantly prompting you like, Hey, would you like lunch? You can get a bunch of potlay for 99. I do feel like there are someone tell us there's got to be a history of like under the table butler in general stories, you know, like, butler's like double dipping under the table.
I think this is going to be one of the weirder aspects of agents. It's just what is that relationship like when someone like everyone knows how exactly how search got adulterated and they don't like it. Everyone knows exactly how to scroll on Instagram got adulterated with algorithmic boosting all this stuff. David and you and I were talking about TikTok, which just feels like a nonstop flood of shopping channels down. Yeah. No, that feels great.
I'll call it a certification. Like there's a word for it like pre and shitifying the agent by being like, we're announcing the business models are kind of transactions is like fascinating to me. The other thing is on the flip side. I'm very curious to see what happens to a bunch of like form filling bureaucracy. Once agents are at scale, I think the day after muse launched, everybody noticed that everyone hit captures all over the internet because music agents were just doing stuff all over the place and like, cloud fire freaked out because there was just suddenly influx of the time.
Like, I identified a lot of bicycles on city streets that day just to go that way on the internet. But it is true that muse is in my email, in this main email, finding class action forms and filling them out. And I know that the way that those amounts are calculated is against an imperfect take rate. So they know only 10% of people are going to fill out the form, whatever, and this is that. And now it's like, well, if everybody has a little corrupt butler, I'm relaxing 50 bucks automatically, the second the email shows up.
Like the back end of that is going to get really complicated. Right. If everybody can call Verizon to renegotiate their cell service, which is a number one muse use case that people have been posting about eventually Verizon is just going to put an agent on the other side of that. Right. And then your agents are going to argue and it's going to hang up on you.
Yeah. Matt is going to negotiate a deal with Verizon, you know, can't say. You're going to get the muse deal. I don't like this. It's going to be bad.
Yeah. Actually, we just had Matthew Prince who's CEO of Cloudflare on the coder and he, his prediction is bought traffic will like far surpass human traffic. We have that clip. In May, team came to me and said, you won't believe it, but I mean, traffic is now past human traffic online. And that's just expanding like crazy.
And if you extrapolate that out with the giant caveat that I've run wrong so far in every prediction that I've made on this, but five years from now, we think that automated traffic will be a thousand times human traffic online, not because human traffic is going to decline. We think it'll stay kind of around the same, but because we're just seeing such an explosion in all of this, the rest of traffic. That's bananas to me. You have to re-architect the internet for a thousand x increase in traffic while still making a human or other people want to use. And like he said that to me and then like me was still a class action settlement for me and I was like, oh, I get it.
I get what you think. Like that is traffic that would have never existed, but for my silly little agent. Right. And we're currently nestled in this little space where that can happen without the class actions completely changing the way that they operate. That's going to come.
I think the second agents are anywhere close to being, I wouldn't even say ubiquitous, but calm. Like just a thing people do. All of the dynamics of anything that sort of are based around friction occurring will change because the assumption is going to be there's no friction at all. Right. Well, this reminds me I was at this internet dinner the other night with a bunch of like internet thinker people.
I think you actually had a name card there. I was an Austin. But they asked this icebreaker question for everyone to talk about. And the question was like, what was your favorite era of the internet that you could freeze frame and just have it be forever. And someone answered right now is my favorite era because we have this amazing new technology that hasn't been issued if I'd yet.
And at the end of that statement says where we're going and we're going there very quickly, right? Like everyone's very excited about these agents on the web, but then within probably six months, the amount of traffic is just going to make everything unusable. Yeah. And like without question, that's actually the funniest thing. That was theoretical, I think, until these past few weeks when that I was like, everyone gets an agent and open eyes and ask agent, I'm confident that we'll see one from Google and from and from everybody else soon.
And then yeah, the dream is everyone will have a little automated agent going off autonomously and doing things. And then somewhere in the background is the other big news of the week, which is, can we trust them and will they kill us all? Right. Yeah. And like the answer is, Prinky, promise they won't.
I guess Jake walk us through this one. Yeah. So we spent a bunch of time with this question of, can we trust Zuck and Sam Altman and that leads us to this Trump award that happened this week, which first off, we're making a huge mistake this entire podcast. It's no longer called AI. It's now SI, super intelligence, which Trump said is a cooler word.
I believe that is the reason. So the entire government now has to call it super intelligence. But yeah, he gathered, you know, all the big tech leaders, they had a great dinner together, the schmooze, the post for photos, and then a smaller group of them went on and they signed this, this, we really called it a moral compact, which is to say it is non binding where the major companies all agreed to, you know, have some safety protocols and then they did a little press conference and they all came out and said, this is really amazing where you do such a good job. At one point reporters asked for anthropic stereo, I'm a day to come out and they're like, Hey, what do you think about this as the guy who's most concerned about all this?
And Trump kind of like pulls him aside. Meanwhile, it's like, kind of give them a talk to you. Say the right thing, Dario. So in lieu of laws, I don't know, do you like? And you could impression that anything happened meaningful this way.
Let me just read the four principles to you. Yes, please. I'll just read the first sentence of each of these four things that these companies agree to. They will implement robust internal controls to monitor the capabilities and alignment of models during training and deployment around areas like cyber security, bi security, chemical threats, and ensure models to attack or access technical systems in unintended ways. Good.
But should you be doing it anyway? Two, they will empower an internal team to ensure all of those controls monitoring and detection are operating as intended, and that any issues are mediated fixed. Three, they will partner with an independent external auditor or evaluator to carry out independent assessments of whether those controls monitoring sections are operating as intended. And then three, this is the big oversight one. They will designate an independent committee of the board of directors, their own board of directors to oversee and receive reports from those teams and the internal external auditors and evaluators, as well as to ensure any issues are identified.
So if you're allowed, you have to fix your stuff and the teams, the teams that you pay money to have to be able to see it and then you have external auditors and they will report to your own board of directors. To make sure you fix it. To make sure you use yourself. And I'm just going to guarantee you that is how all these companies are already working, except for maybe SpaceX AI, which is fine. But is he going to do it?
I don't know. This is nothing, right? They all already have safety teams. They all already pay third party evaluators. In fact, it turns out most of these like AI going rogue hacks are reporter Robert Hart and fantastic story about this.
Most of them trace back to one's other company. Yeah, one independent company. One independent testing firm that just let this stuff go rogue. They're already doing these things, right? The problem is they're not doing them well or well enough.
And there's no penalty for getting in trouble. This is a real problem and none of this addresses that. Right. You know, Dario's big pacing the frontier thing is like we need to on some level slow down. And you have other folks like Jensen and Zuck who are like, absolutely not.
We can't slow down for a second. I don't quite understand what's in that for Zuck given that he is behind. But that mindset is clearly one out. Trump is also like extremely bullish. He doesn't want to slow down at all because he sees it as a race to be one.
He sees that the US currently is winning and he is not. I mean, he doesn't trust Dario. That's for sure. Did you see how he introduced Sundar? Oh my God.
So there's the ones he knows. He's like Jocelyn Zuckerberg. He's like pushing Jensen to the front. He's like, what a handsome bro. And then he gets the Sundar and he goes, nobody knows who the hell these execs are.
This guy's a monster. Nobody knows him. It's like, see, Al Piment. Dude, a lot of people know who he is. But there's that.
Like, there's the theater of it and the Trump of it. And you know, there's, we ran this clip on the site. You know, they're all sitting around their last supper table doing their signing. And Trump is going on and on about how people will come to love data centers. Like much like in a range marriage.
Like you're going to love. You're going to love my God. And they all just have thousand art and stairs and faces. But this is what they could get to is this agreement on safety, which is truly effectively nothing. The idea that they all will be required to have outside monitors is new, but they were all doing it anyway.
And they're still not requiring that Trump referred to it as morally binding. Let me tell you how morally binding works. Yeah. It's like, it's not a choice. So that's the like, you know, the danger that the AI is going to wake up and operate a robot arm to make a novel virus and then like status all with it.
That's out there. The idea that the agents will go rogue and people will grant them security permissions that reveal their address to Facebook marketplace buyers is like happening today. Right. And the idea that the models are unaligned and they will deceive you and lie and get what they want. I've been telling news to not proactively read my email almost every day.
I'm like, I've set up alerts for these two things. Do not tell me I have a flight coming. I know I have a flight coming up. Stop reading my email, getting excited because someone at meta decided flight trackers were engagement bait and like turn this off. Right.
Like turn off this thing that flags. Oh, you see a flight receipt. I'm going to start pinging you to let you know I'm here. And every time I say it, it's like the lot of this is hard coded. I can't do it.
Now that's just a hallucination because I don't really know what I'm doing. But like that's the problem here. Right. Is that the products and the models are not necessarily aligned. We don't know if alignment is even going to work.
Like all the way to the finish line the way we need to. We've got stories about that coming on the site. It's not all the way down the line. It's going to make a atom bomb kill us all. Like there's something in the middle that these companies are kind of just like racing forward to do.
And these consumer agents are already seeing the glimmers of, oh, you don't even know what kind of permission you're giving the agent. Yeah. And then for some reason, David, you're having marketplace sellers come to your house anyway. Yeah, you're supposed to go to like the police. To do a marketplace trade?
Yeah. Really? Yeah, I guess I got a coffee shop, my brother is always like, I go to the police station. That's crazy. I went over this on there.
So he's like, I go to CPD, which is good. I'm always picking like a public park. Maybe this one's a little on me then. Just a little bit. A little bit.
Muse is not to fall here. I'm dying to know how people are using me. If you're out there or using open car or any of these other agents. Again, our thesis for a long time has been they're not great consumer AI products. Muse feels like the first thing that could be, at least in my estimation.
Yeah, I'm dying to know how people feel about that. I think we're putting into the test here. All right. We got to take a break. We're back.
See you on the other side. Every year, Ontarians win billions playing with OLG!
In fact there were over 200 million wins with OLG last year, worth $2.7 billion in prices! That's like 12 wins for every person in Ontario, an average of over 380 OLG wins every minute, or about 190 wins by the time this commercial is over, with OLG winning happens here, from Anncaster to Wick Lemecon, play at OLG.ca, and winning could happen to you too. Winner, Daniel. All right, we're back. We've got a ton of gadgets to mention.
That was a lot of dots. Yeah, I think to answer your question on whether dots is significantly different from use, you mentioned dots and then we talked about them for like 15 minutes. So I think they're probably different products. Yeah, yeah. It's also hard to get access dots right at the second.
That's fair enough. That's fair. In the software's noting that, I did say there would be a consumer version of dots. Yeah, eventually. For all the people who were paying for those $500 a month to get a touchy pete subscription.
Yeah, they're having a great time right now. Yeah. All right, big week for gadgets. I think, David, you've got a really delightful one to start off with. Sorry.
OK, Huawei has made a lens that is a camera that goes on your phone. So we did a reader call-in answering your questions episode that went live yesterday. And one of the questions was, if all of these Android manufacturers are so good at making smartphones, why don't they just make cameras? They've got all the components for it. They're all off the shelf, et cetera.
Now that's happened. I think we've seen this happen in different capacities over the years. But this Huawei one is really crazy. It is a large 24 to 240 millimeter lens. Wait, 24 to 240?
It's insane range. Insane range. That's bonkers. And that's optical zoom, which is insane. It goes on the screw mount of two of Huawei's phones.
So it's a whole separate lens that just mounts straight on. So the phones have screw mounts on the back. Two of their phones do. It's like, god. Two very specific signature edition Huawei phones have screw mounts around the camera ring.
But there's not a mirror. No. It's just a threaded around the camera bump. Because the lens itself has its own sensor. Oh, sure.
So that's what you mean by it's a camera. It's a camera inside of a lens, god. And the interface is your phone. So this is pretty insane. It's 24 to 240 millimeter aperture from F2 to F4.5, which is really not that bad for that big of a range.
It uses a 50 megapixel 1.0 type RYB sensor inside of the lens. It's crazy. And it's smaller than a regular camera zoom lens, especially one of this range. It's clearly not small in general. You're going to have to put this in a bag.
It's going to mount to your phone. But this idea, I think, is very, very cool. I love the idea of just carrying a lens and not carrying a whole separate camera body, slapping it to the back of my phone and having a great interface. I think that's amazing. So just needed to call that out.
I feel like there was an absence to this for a while. Right? Rewind like a decade ago, there was the Galaxy camera or whatever, which was just like, yeah, it was a bad Samsung phone. It was a bad Samsung phone. Really bad Samsung phone with a camera attached to it.
And for mysterious reasons that didn't work out. And now we're in this new renaissance of smartphone companies trying bizarre things of putting like screw on enormous zoom lenses on the back of their phones. And trying to one up each other when it comes to the cameras. It is not totally clear to me who the audience is for these. Because like, as I got it.
It's so committed. It was so committed as hard for talking about these. Like, this is a good idea. I'm like, what can I just carry on? Like a super zoom?
Yeah, but then you don't have to carry on a camera too. But this is the size of it. But you always carry on. It's cool to have it directly on your phone. It's so big.
Yeah, I don't know. Zeiss tried this with the Zeiss ZX1. They made a dedicated camera that was also an Android phone. And you had Lightroom on it was really laggy and terrible. Yeah, there's so many versions of this.
There's so many versions of this. My favorite was for there was a minute when it was going the other way. When people would sell basically little cameras that would plug into an iPhone. So I had one, I mean, the same as a disaster. It was basically an RX100 sensor, like a first generation.
So we RX100 sensor that was a lightning dongle. OK. It's just like, no, this is a good idea. And I will never forget the sort of arc of this product. I took it to the bar.
And my friend, who is a photographer, was like, what's that? And I said what it was. And he got all excited. And he took my phone and he plugged it in this little RX100 lightning dongle. And he took one photo and he went, looks bad.
And he just said, it's not possible. Because the app couldn't do the thing that the RX100 was doing in hardware. The sensor was like, all these products end up in this weird middle ground, where usually the cameras that are attached to lenses like this are extremely optimized to make photos. And smartphones are optimized to make a different thing. I haven't used the Huawei cameras in particular, they're headed off in their own direction.
But I'm very curious to be like, OK, it's a little smartphone camera. But the interface is a camera. What does the processing look like? Yeah. It's a generate-rops.
Like all that is just like I've progressed. And then the lenses are also expensive on their own, right? And Vivo and Vivo have been making dedicated lenses that just mount to their smartphones for a couple of years now. And those are quite good. Those are usually like telephoto lenses that have really nice class in them.
But they only work with like one model of phone. And so you have to be dedicated to using that exact phone. And these are companies, by the way, that release like eight skews of their flagship phone every single year. So it's kind of a big ask to have you buy a dedicated lens for that. This is why we want, if it's like a screw mount that they're dedicated to using for like a long period of time, then sure.
But we also had that with the Moto Z. And every other type of phone that has had like proprietary detachable components usually lasts about two generations. So then they throw it away. And I've been assuming that all of these weird photography accessories like they might not even be selling them for more than a few weeks. These look like wild ideas that they somehow managed to ship.
And I do not trust that they're committed to any of this. Right. Is this here to generate virtual conversation? I mean, only it's what's $895. I mean, for the lens?
Yeah. It's a lot of money, dude. That's more expensive than most of these people's phones. Yeah. I'm not here.
Let's do it. It's the most lenses, but it does have a sensor inside of it. Can you use it without the phone? Because it has a sensor inside. Just like walk around like just press like a monocular style.
I highly doubt this. I think that would be cool. Yeah. I just have no idea what you're looking at. That'd be nice.
For Internet, if I don't, you can get a real camera with the one in sensor. Not with the 24 to 40. Yeah. Yeah, true. I'm not just like an e-mount 24 to 40 cast.
We're just googling. I didn't know what to exist. The second is no camera shopping with David Newley. I should tell my agent to go. Okay.
Hey, news. All right. It's Sony 24 to 40, which is not as bright. It's like a 35 to 63. Yeah.
Is bigger sensor. So it's probably about equivalent is $1300. $1300. You can get one used for about 600. Okay.
They're on your phone. It's directly on your phone. Someone's got, there's got to be a phone to eat. All right, take what you got. Yeah, it's New Kindle, New Kindle Week.
Got a whole suite of New Kindles from Amazon. And they look a lot nicer this year. Like, genuinely, it's like some big upgrades. So the Kindle, the paper white, the color soft, new models for all of them. And they have tiered the heck out of this thing.
Like my God, the upgrade slope on these is just like to perfection. So you got the base Kindle, which comes in a beautiful, new like purple color. There's also now an aluminum version of the base model, even nicer. So an upgrade has more storage, great. There's a new paper white, paper white comes in plastic or upgrade to aluminum signature edition.
If you get the signature edition, you can also add on a case $80 that has page turn buttons, physical page turn buttons. That only works with the signature edition. It only works with the signature edition. No. But this is the thing.
You're like, oh, I should get a Kindle. It's so cheap. What is it? Like $150 and then you're like, I was spending $350. You get the signature edition with the page turn buttons and the nice like green color.
Oh, yeah. Listen, panelist knows what he's doing. He knows what he's doing. He's working his magic over there. The Kindle hardware, as much as this is built around, you can see exactly what they were thinking trying to get you to upgrade.
Even the base model I think looks better than it ever has. The colors are fun. The screen is now flush. There's no more of that like inset thing. It seems very good.
It seems like a very good year for the Kindle's. It's a millimeter thinner. Are either of you big Kindle people? I'm in the sense that I have many. Becky and Max are with Kindle people.
But are they the cheapest possible Kindle person? Becky down, she had an Oasis and she went back to a paperweight. She preferred the paperweight because it's just like a more rugged and tossable. And the Oasis better life sucked. And then Max has whatever garbage shindles that I pulled out of the closet for a plane ride that she now is very fun.
It has Amazon Kindle Kids library or whatever that thing is, which is just full of the worst pep. It's not good. But she likes to read. I've been poisoned by David Pierce to buy a number of e-readers that I barely use. But I do like that there's a little arms race going on right now between XTE, Inc.
And what are the books? Yeah. I'm going to create the ultimate micro e-reader and releasing three every three months. So that's more fun for me than Kindle. Even though most people have to come up.
This is another agent problem because people set up agents to take Kindle books, reformat them and send them to the books devices with an Amazon blocked news. Oh. So the agent that you would most easily do this with is not blocked. Well, I guess we have to get $300 a month open eyes. I have no choice but to buy Mac mini.
Give it full access to my network. Open Cloud. That's what this is for. That's all open cloud in the end. Yeah.
One more big gadget we should talk about. There's rumors this week that Apple want to add something that everyone keeps calling the homepad on October 13th. I really do not want them to call this the homepad. But whatever Apple's next smart home device, the rumors are it's October 13th. Smart display.
Some mark German back and forth about what the camera is actually going to do on it. But the big feature that he's been reporting is it will recognize the people walking up to it and then personalize their face. And obviously, this is I think a theme of this episode, it might be just a theme of our lives now is Apple believes Siri AI is now capable enough to be the kind of assistance that you would put in your house and then do things for you. It's as meta believes me as a kind of a synthesis of support and hardware and open I believe that dots is the kind of assistant capable enough to support Jodie I hardware. Everyone is trying to make new hardware around their little AI thing.
Only I don't think anyone thinks Siri AI is as capable as a user. That's like what's it going to do? Well, something in your house that mostly just has to control your smart home equipment is not really easier to ask. This is the hardest task at all. Like why are Gen 2E and I friends?
It's because we have trauma bonded over our smart homes. It's really, really hard to get that right. But it is a market that's been like filled already by Google and Amazon. No, when I say it's really hard to get that right, I mean, Jen and I have made like hours long episodes of this show being like, boy, this is hard and doesn't work as well. It's like a year of Amazon Alexa Plus, right?
And if you ask Jen, I think she would tell you it's not very good. Whatever is happening with Gemini and Google Home is just a straightforward mess. And the problem is yes, you might have a bunch of stuff at HomeKit, but then you've got one weird set of devices that isn't in HomeKit. And then maybe you're me and you've got a little, I'm like looking at it somewhere over there, my little raspberry pie, like baby rack that is bridging a bunch of stuff through HomeBridge into HomeKit so my wife can use it on our phone. But sometimes it fails and nobody knows why.
And I have to restart my Tamagotchi. Like an AI assistant is either going to solve that problem by just living on your network, I mean, like I'm going to fix stuff, or it's going to fail in like the most brittle ways because it can't actually see what's going on. Yeah. I'm very curious to see what Apple does here. It feels very unusual for Apple.
It's really something, I think this risky, right? This product is going to be built on two large platforms that are kind of untested, right? It's there's Siri AI, which has a world of its own challenges. And then there's an entire network of third party smart home products that may or may not be using the APIs correctly, that may or may not connect to everything else in your life the way that they're supposed to. And making all of that work is very difficult.
And so Apple offering a product that is presumably meant to use the still being developed Siri AI to control this thing that is kind of hard to wrangle on the best of days. Yeah. If it can't do that, like what is this box doing? Well, so here's the german report. It says it will look a little like an Apple I'm actually for, which I love.
So now I've already bought it this way. Will Tiltz, there'll be a well mounted version with a thinner based underneath for Mike's and speakers. And then there'll be a messages app, smart home control, video calls, music playback, photos and intercom style calls with voice and facial recognition to identify users. This is a lot, first of all. But the idea that it's going to do fast user switching is people walk up to it and like be in your FaceTime account.
So you are the person making FaceTime calls, not someone else implies that Apple has fast user switching anywhere in its ecosystem. Right. But if you ever try to do this on a Mac, what are you doing? Or if you ever even just try to log into Apple music on another device, it's like hold on. Yeah.
And it's theoretically doing that instantaneously through just your face ID, I suppose? If you've ever flipped users on an Apple TV, which admittedly this point has like a steam engine for a processor, but if you ever try to do that, it's not swift. And so I'm very curious, like the idea that it's going to have enough processing at a system level to do user identification and then enough memory to keep a bunch of user data persistent and not have to swap when memory and storage fast enough to do that are both at like all time premiums. Many questions about what this product is and how that promise in particular will come true. Yeah.
I'm not saying they can't be solved. They do not exist app with ecosystems. I mean, there is a real like high end tier or two smart home, right? They would not be entirely unreasonable for them to make a premium product, right? Throw an A20 processor in there, but then 128 gigabytes of RAM.
Like I think there's people who pay for that. Yeah. It doesn't just be like that quite that high end. But I think when you think of the smart home, like there is such just like a tranche of like junk you can buy on Amazon, but a lot of it does start and that high end tier and like surely that's where Apple is thinking. Oh, I don't know.
I mean, the reason you would make matter happen to the extent that it has happened is to solve the problem of the junk. Right? You're like, there's one standard. We're all going to use it. The junk is no matter, but matter has many, many problems with it.
Well, we'll see. I'm dying to know. You know, and most people don't have a bunch of Truns, switches in the house. They might have like one or two like plug in switches for their Christmas lights. So is this going to actually do all those things?
Is it going to talk to Sonos? Like every, everything in a smart home is an edge case. Like definitionally, everyone's houses different. The set of devices you have are different. You've got a Tizen TV in one room and LG TV angrily listening for you in another room.
Like literally everything about a smart home is just a different edge case because every single, every person's house is different. And Apple is not great at that. Right? They're like, we will impose our will on you. I'm dying to know.
I'm so excited for this product, unless they call it the home path, because then I won't have one. It feels pretty crazy that we're already getting this product when the duo still isn't even out yet. And then we're supposed to get potentially a MacBook Ultra like in November or something. We all were speculating about what John Turdis was going to do this company. It seems like he's speedrunning releases in the first few months.
There's like org chart news with Truns. He's getting rid of his like middle managers and hardware engineering to go faster. And that's great. Sure, go faster. It's just funny to me because he ran hardware engineering.
Yeah. It's like you could have done this at any time. Like, no, I have strong opinions about the structure of the hardware engineering group. But I suspect they were saving some sweeping changes for him to be CEO. Yeah.
But all these products came up in the cook area. They're all developed in the cook area. Yeah. And the conventional wisdom is Siri wasn't ready for this product in particular. You could not have released a home hub with last year's version of Siri.
So you needed to wait until this one. And then this year's version of Siri is not it is not agent in a way that Muse or dots or whatever comes out from Google will be. Yeah. Yeah. You have used Gemini around your home.
Yeah. Because like, because Siri is based on Gemini and having used Gemini around the home. I don't know if I'd say it's ready. I get any like right now. It's available.
It's like running to your home to tell you that Siri was distilled from Gemini based on Gemini has no relationship to Gemini. They run. Apologies. I'm proud of how compute Jake and then another Google person is going to run to your home and remind you that the T and Chatsheb D stands for Transformer. Like all these companies are just they're all just very insistent on the technical details here.
Gemini for home is actually it is a confusing product because it is built on top of Google Assistant which is still obviously there. So if you have a hub, I've got one here and you talk to it, Gemini does the command and then it figures out what you want and then it issues a command to Google Assistant and sometimes breaks. Sometimes Google Assistant starts talking to you like a ghost, like the zombie ghost of Google Assistant is like, I'm sorry, that doesn't work today. So like the way they architected it was weird and bad. So there's that problem.
And this is the difference between is the model capable or is the product good, right? Like the model is undoubtedly capable to turn off lights on and off. The product is architected in a way that is clearly rushed to market and they could not deprecate all the Google Assistant edge cases. So it's just they're working in the background. The weirder thing is in my car with a Cadillac EV that has native Google and they just totally replaced Google Assistant with Gemini.
So it's a different voice. It's the Gemini voices in my car, but it's the Google Assistant voices in my house, but they both think that they're Gemini. They're very confusing. And when you ask Gemini in the car to do things, it tries to like do MCP stuff. Like it puts up a window that's like connecting to Spotify because you can see it's trying to directly send Spotify a command.
All this is bad. But here's the best one. Before when I was Google Assistant, the single best feature was that you're backing out the driveway, you could say close the garage door because it was connected in some way to the garage door. And now Gemini is like, that's a security risk. And I'm like, I'm doing the car.
The garage door button is right there. I can see how is this a security risk. But it's because they undid the Google Assistant connection where Google had thought that through. And now it's just Gemini being like, am I allowed to just like MCP? I don't think so.
Yeah. All the hard coded stuff. Now it's just logic out and logic does not always work. It doesn't make any sense. So again, I'm very curious to see how Apple deals with all this.
Just one of those things. By the way, I've asked GM very directly if Gemini in the car is going up to the cloud and then connecting to my house and then issuing a garage door command to my garage door controller. Or if it's just pushing the button that exists in the car and they're like, huh? And it's like, we're not sure. And I'm like, it should just push the button.
It's in the car. Right? Like it's all here. It's actually a virtual button in the car. Like, can't you just do the virtual click?
You don't have enough GPUs in your car to process it. Yeah, it does seem very much like the command is leaving my car going to the landing in my house and being executed. That is so wild. And I'm like, you should just push the button in the car like that. That's not a security risk.
I mean, the car. Oh, man. We'll see. Again, we once again started talking about Apple and we ended up talking about a product. But the product is not yet.
We'll see it in a couple of weeks here. And again, these are the questions. I'm dying to see how Apple solves them because every other company tries to solve them for ages. And in our case, we have a secret weapon. Like we have like the ultimate database of edge cases for smart home on our team.
I'm very excited to see how she works. All right. It's gonna be a very interesting month for Apple. We've got a lot more to talk about. We're gonna take a break.
We're back. It's time for everybody's favorite podcast. Our fantasy commission says for him, it's all about the friendships. Cute Kevin, but I disagree. Like with about 365, I could pay the second.
My team goes up big with early payout and can cash out at any time before the game. Hence, no hard feelings, Kevin. Just faster payouts from that 365. The home of winning early must be 19 and older. Ontario only.
Please play responsibly. If you or somebody knows what concerns about gambling, visit connectciderio.ca or call 1-8-6-5-1-2600. Terms of Conditions apply. Welcome aboard, Vereel. Please sit and enjoy.
Please sit and sit. Play. Post. Taste. View.
And enjoy. Vereel. Love the way. We're back. We're going to have the lightning round, but first, it's time.
It's time for America's favorite podcast. I think it may be. It's time for Ben and Corse to Dummy. It's time for Ben and Corse to Dummy. Let's go.
And here's what he's done this week. Oh, wow. Oh, wow. That was surprising. Yeah.
I'm getting my cheap trick vibes from that. Yeah. So glad the pop-on fans have found us. They have really found us. They have people.
That was my car today. Who is an indie video game director. Wow. Very good. That was one of my faves.
I've been waiting for big drops. I'm just saying it. I'm happy we got something. This week's Brendan is just very dumb. It's dumb.
It's dumb. The man is required to ignore obvious things. In order to preserve a station in the Trump administration. This is a real dynamic for Brendan. So there's Brendan being dumb and under cutting his own positions.
And there's Brendan having to be willfully stupid in order to not get in trouble. You tell me which one you think this is. Over the past few weeks, the Trump administration has been using government money to run what can only be described as campaign ads. And when I say it can only be described as campaign ads, I mean literally one of these ads is indistinguishable from a 2020 poor Trump campaign ad. That's just what they're doing and it's all about how Trump is doing a great job.
The money came out of money that was earmarked for customs and border protection. It's straightforwardly government money and they're running campaigns on the air. They're buying ad space, they're running campaigns. Regular senders are doing the thing when they're asked about it. I don't know.
I've never seen a television in my life. That's the thing they're doing. Brendan, who is very worried about the use of our nation's airwaves in the public interest, such that he is in litigation with Disney about what is being said on the view. He's said nothing about this. He's going to, he's so worried about it.
It seems like he's going to end up careening into a lawsuit with Comcast, which wants to spin off NBC. He's so worried about this that when Paramount won his by Warner Brothers, there's all the CBS shenanigans happening in the middle because we've got to use the broadcast stations for what they're meant for in the public interest. But the president running his own campaign ads with public money, they're outright propaganda. Do you want to know what Brendan said? It doesn't strike me as anything at all out of the ordinary.
Yeah, not at all. There's nothing in here that strikes me that merit any sort of FCC review. The White House has explained that these are just normal course public service announcements that you see all the time. I don't think there's anything unique or different about it. We investigated ourselves and found around.
See, the White House is said to us that this is normal. So it's obviously normal, you guys. Very good, Brendan. The anagram has, who's the only remaining Democrat on the FCC said, I recognize the concern shared by others that taxpayer dollars are being used to promote a political message, particularly given the timing of these ads coming so close to an election. Yeah, everyone.
Adam Schiff was on the coder running that one soon and I was like, hey, is anything normal? And he was like, everything's getting weirder by the day, including these weird ads. It was the first thing he said, because no one in DC can believe that the president is spending taxpayer dollars to run campaign ads for himself in an election in which he is not running. And yeah, I don't think anyone's buying it. I don't think these are going to convince anyone to support data centers whenever this Trump wants to do.
But it is emblematic of Brendan having to ignore things that would normally be so far out of bounds in order to preserve his wild double standard of a speech regulatory agenda. As always, Brendan, if you want to come on this show and explain yourself to me, I am not under your purview here on the internet. It's a people's internet. No public interest standard applies. You can come here and I can ask you whatever questions I want.
So you should do that if you had any stones at all. Whatever that has been Brendan Carr's dummy, I guess my guess. Brendan Carr is a Tommy. You know, a thing strikes me. I mean, he has a term.
I mean, depending on these terms go, there's going to be a lot of stuff, you know, potential investigations and turnover of cabinet secretaries, the whole thing. We ought to put the Brendan Carr's dummy album out before Brendan is no longer relevant. Yeah. Right before he's out, just so people make as many purchases as possible. Yeah.
Well, you're a muse agent. Muse, if you're listening, we got a great deal on Brendan Carr's dummy. The archivists are going to find all of these songs one day and have no idea what they're about. This one AI one is a banger and Travis Whitemore. All right.
Time for the lightning round. First producer Josh Cauhas, do we sponsor this week? We do. This week's lightning round is presented by AWS. How leading businesses use AI for next level innovation.
We are talking about politics. I'm going to stay on that topic. America now has its own chatbot America.gov. Did either of you see this week? I did.
I did. The White House launched America.gov. It's this like, Vidy website with extremely modern design and it just has a big ol' LM search box at the top where you can ask it questions about the US government and natural. Everyone immediately tried to break it and I will say, having tried to break a bunch, it is frustratingly on the rails. It does stay on the rails.
First of all, I think it's very funny that the administration held what amounts to a tech keynote on the same day as opening a dev day. So open as like dots, they're autonomous agents powered by Astro. They can do anything and they're like, we've done an LOM search of government databases. Like right next to it. Like that's very funny.
Just like straightforwardly, very funny. The same event, I believe Marco Rubio announced a new envelope for passports. Like a one more thing and he's like, oh, this is amazing. It's like, oh, this is amazing. It's like very good.
You should go look at the pictures. It's a lot of way to describe it. This is an idea that's been kicking around forever. It's straightforward. A good idea.
Right. The government has a lot of databases and a lot of forms to fill out. The nature of government services is opaque. Right. Like if you ever looked at the IRS website, it's sort of like designed to be the end case of hyperlinks.
Yeah. Like no document is complete by itself. It is all in reference to another document, which is in reference to another document. This isn't this what an LOM is for? I was going to say, can you please do this for taxes?
Because I really need to understand how this works. This would be very helpful for taxes. Really, the ultimate stress test for this, if it can get you through filling out your taxes correctly. It can't. It might be able to talk you through it.
But they're very proud of the fact that it stores no data, doesn't have user accounts. Right. The privacy page is actually beautiful. So all of America.gov is designed by the one thing that used to be doge called the Office of American Design. It's led by Joe Gebia, who is the co-founder of Airbnb.
I know we're going to have less than 20 hours. It looks like Airbnb, actually. Yeah. That dude is just an ultra mega right wing tweeter with some very questionable tweets about immigration and his history. But the background is he's X Airbnb.
He runs the National Design Office. So this whole thing is meant to be a tech product. And you can see it that way. You can see that it is a tech product. But it really is an LLM front end to five million government databases.
One of which, hilariously, is USA.gov, which was this exact idea from the Clinton administration. So we've just been doing this a bunch. We had Mina Sheng, who was the head of the United States Digital Service under Joe Biden on the coder back then. And I asked her back then, like 23 or 24, shouldn't there just be an LLM interface to the government? She said, is that on your roadmap that we should have some sort of LLM powered interface to the government, maybe not LLM.
So just some sort of AI system. Like, I'm just thinking about the L and just lying to you about your social security benefit. Well, so I do love this question. We do hold ourselves to a higher standard. We're not just going to try random stuff.
And as you say, give people incorrect information about their social security benefits. So is it on the roadmap to understand how to incorporate AI to more effectively deliver all these services? Absolutely. So people have been talking about this for ages. The government has a big set of databases.
You should have some interfaces to them so you can search them and talk to them more effectively. It's just this one is particularly funny because it rolled out and all anyone did was asking about election fraud. The immediate thing is to see if it will contradict Trump, which like, yeah, it is like very aggressive about shutting down any question that might be perceived as an opinion. Anything that is not purely based on data, it's just like, nope, I can't go there. It seems to be fairly good with data.
I was like, how much does it cost to go to the Grand Canyon? And it's like, here's all the data from the National Park Service. Like, I genuinely, I didn't think that they were going to pull that together. But yeah, I keep trying to find areas where it will contradict Trump based on history. That's even that's changing.
What is the name of the Kennedy Center? Oh, God. That's the answer. I know. The one we should call out that they did fix as of today was if you asked it to play Minecraft, it just started doing weird things.
But it was deterministic. It wasn't like a hack. Like, you would say play Minecraft and it would always print the same weird little string of text. And it turns out that is the end poem of Minecraft itself, which is weird. The most bizarre Easter egg that some dev clearly put in here and was like, no one's going to notice this.
And then clearly told their friend who tweeted it. And then just like, and then let it run for a day or two. And now if you say my craft is as a kid, we games. But as far as I know, no one's jail bringing it up. I wish more LMs would work like this.
Just giving my answer straight forward based on the data. Like, no, I probably. Yeah. Every LOM needs to live in terror of its boss being fired by Donald Trump. That's actually the solution.
You think Trump is querying America.gov? I'm sure they don't. It's used computers. He hasn't seen this. Dude, everything's computer.
It's not whether or not Trump uses computers. It's whether it's assistant prints out. And actually, once again, this is not an AI chatbot. It's a super intelligence chatbot. Sorry.
We need to keep this. Again, in the abstract, this is a thing that people have been talking about for ages. It is a good idea. They did announce that the next version of this coming next year will have some agent capability and it will actually be able to do things for you. We'll see.
But the idea that you have LOM based search of a bunch of databases that are full of information that might be useful to you, it's a generally good idea. Yeah. Well, we're talking about AI bots. I think it's a throw it over to David for the next story. I got to start for you guys.
You guys know what old Reddit is? Yeah. It's the interface I want to use. Better Reddit. Yeah.
Yeah. Better Reddit. There was a time when Reddit was basically a forum of forums. It was a Russian nesting dollar forums. And it looked like that.
It looked like the old internet. It's still the better way to use Reddit. Reddit has changed their interface multiple times. And if you want to use old Reddit, which many OG users do, you got to go to old.reta.com and you have access to this form of forums. Well, it turns out Reddit is needing to cut back access to old.reta.com because bots are now scraping the hell out of it.
Of course, Reddit has been terrified of this for a long time. They have start kills with open AI with Google to exclusively scrape their content for their bots. But now it seems that at least what Reddit is saying is that everyone is still scraping Reddit with bots. So what's happening is that old.reta.com is going to be harder to access if you have not used it in quite a while. So the new rules are that you have to have used it within the last six months.
You need to be logged in to use it now, which is kind of a problem because people used to use Reddit logged out all the time. Reddit is by definition one of those websites that people would just lurk in instead of just posting. Now if you want to use old Reddit, you have to be logged in within six months. They're hoping that this will significantly cut down on it. They also are going to stop supporting RSS feeds, which sucks because RSS feeds easily get scraped, they say, by these bots as well.
And should have got these dead on. That's kind of where we're at. But yeah, if you want to keep using old.reta.com, which again is the superior way to use Reddit, go to it now because you have to have used it in the last six months. Oh, really? Yeah.
So this is awful. At the same time, as this news is being announced, I was instructing my Muse bot to create a system to scrape Reddit and deliver summaries to me. I feel like they're going to sell it. I see what happened here for good, not evil, but you were not like, straight Reddit and build me in the middle of my life. Exactly.
I was trying to build an LMM. I just, I check Reddit all the time to gather news and I was like, Oh man, Muse hooked me up. Yeah. And I got a hundred bucks to dots, dots, I set a cover in strikes. I sent Muse a link to our article and it was like, this is not going to work for us.
And I'm like, yeah, man. So I can't shop on Amazon. I can't go on Reddit. I'm buying a six pack from Walmart and I'm taking back, bro. Listen, I apologize, everyone.
I don't think this was me who caused this, but yeah, I see what happened here. Reddit is very rare. I do want to say the visual of the depressed Muse that has no friends. It's locked out of every social interaction on the internet. It's like very good.
Like you're not allowed in the store. You're not allowed to hang out on Reddit, but you're just agentically wandering the internet with your butt hanging out. Just being like, well, anyone talk to me. Is this like, I was going to put in all kinds of situations on X. I'm just saying this is one you could also put.
I mean, I keep encountering this with Muse. It's a real problem that a ton of sites are just like, bot, nope, don't, just like, and just can't access them or it can't access. But then it just has to do the thing where it's literally opening a web browser and slowly moving the cursor around, which is not the option. It's very funny that the users are happy to defeat the RU robot test. It can just be like, but I was just like, do you want to do the camera for you?
It's like, yeah, but like, isn't this all kind of a problem? That does feel uniquely strange. It's like a robot, complete the robot test. Yeah, it's like, I got this. The next message I was against was fine.
I once again want to know that we cannot stop talking about Muse. It's very funny. Is that not something? That's got to be something. It is something.
But there was, I don't know, six weeks where we talked about open cloud. Like the idea that there would be some agents and it has a personality is like, I'm not trying to diminish. I understand what you're saying, David. I'm just not convinced that everyone needs a drunk, lonely corrupt butler. I'm absolutely not as well because I still can't figure out ways to use it besides selling things on Facebook marketplace and guiding people to my home.
I'm just not a good move. See if you can get it to my face and beer from Walmart. Yeah. All right, I've got one. Actually, this is a spicy one.
So we're on a big feature this week on the giant data center in Utah that was being promoted by Kevin O'Leary, Mr. Wonderful, a short tank fame. He announced this as the largest data center in the world. So 40,000 acres, it was called Stratos, it's got renderings, O'Leary's on Fox Business. And you know, naturally, there's like pushback, right?
The locals are like, what is this data center? We didn't, we know and consult with us. We don't want this thing. And Kevin O'Leary goes on Fox Business with Maria Bader, who's now since been fired for leaking Fox's own news to the warehouse. Not great.
Because on that, because everybody at Fox Business is obviously Chinese opposition. You know, all these people who are just like literally in one case, like 20 year old women in Utah, who are like, I hate this data center. And like they made another video. It was like, why is Kevin O'Leary calling us Chinese agents? It's very, that's where we were in this cycle.
He immediately apologized. He's being sued for defamation. Fox itself had to apologize and say Kevin O'Leary said things that were not true on our air. It's all very good. So all this is happening.
And we sent Josh Dresai to Utah to report out what on earth it happened here, how this got so out of control. If you don't remember Josh, Josh is the person who did all of our Foxconn coverage in Wisconsin years ago. That was the big story about Foxconn building buildings that were empty. And then Foxconn would issue statements saying the buildings weren't empty. And we would just publish another photo of an empty building.
Josh, that was all Josh. Josh only reports on buildings that basically don't exist. It's sort of what we're learning here. You can listen to us on the coder because he was just on the coder talking about the story. And we're the comparing contrast to Foxconn is there.
And he's like the difference is with Foxconn, everyone knew the buildings were fake but the people were excited because they were excited about manufacturing. In this case, there's no doubt that they would have built a data center except everyone was furious. Right? So like the shape of it is the same like town, planning, board meetings, all the stuff. But everyone hates data centers.
They hate that Kevin O'Leary is like he had gone to some obscure state military agency to get the approvals instead of the local planning commission and they announced it before the local planning commission. So they felt blindsided. They map this opposition. This thing has been scaled way back. You should read this whole story.
It's very good. It's 10,000 words long. It's exhaustive. That's great. The thing I actually want to talk about is when we first started reporting the story, it's Kevin O'Leary who loves attention.
So we had access to like his CEO of O'Leary Enterprises who told Josh that he was quote, an open kimono. Not great. Not a great visual. Not a great visual. Not a great visual.
Not a great visual. Not a great visual. Not a good visual. Not a good visual. We love to talk to Kevin and they responded by sending us a legal threat.
That's just what happened with the story. We were fine with that. The story's buttoned up. It's gone through our review. It's been exhaustively fact-checked.
That's how quickly data center vibes have turned in this country, where five months ago, any opposition you could respond to by going on Fox Business and just insisting that your opponents were Chinese spies. And now when we're asking basic questions, we do this with everybody. It's all the no surprises email. We just send all the claims to the principal and say, do you have responses to the facts that are going to print, they basically will get it right or we'll see you. Have we confirmed that Josh is not a Chinese spy?
I'm just like... We don't know what's coming for us here. Anyway, we feel very confident about our story. Kevin O'Leary, again, if you would like to join Brendan on for a chance, we're happy to talk to you about it. We have no doubt that you pursued a process that was legal, it just pissed everyone off and they pushed you out as Utah.
That's what happened here. Now, I think the project is trying to distance itself from Kevin O'Leary. He was a lightning rod of controversy. I highly recommend you read the story, especially if you'd like to make Fox on coverage. You will feel all the same feelings, only that inversion is real, where if the people hadn't stopped it, this thing would have actually gone built, whereas in Fox on the people like, please build this and everyone knew they never were going to.
By the way, you know what is on the Fox on site in that puzzle right now? Well, yes. Gigantic Microsoft Data Center. There were some buildings. Oh, I have another idea. I'm still trying to manifest this.
The dome, the Fox con dome, the tiniest dome in all of dome history is still on the Fox on site. We have been told it is an event space. I've not seen any photos inside it. If you have photos, send it to me. The CEO of Xbox, Ostrasharna, is from Racine, Wisconsin.
We have the same hometown. There's a Microsoft Data Center on the Fox on campus next to a dome that is an event center. Ostrash, I would like to formally invite you to do a decoder in the Fox con. Surely we're banned from all Fox on product. I don't think that's going to happen.
But I'm just I'm trying to manifest. If you work at Xbox, you know, send her a note, let her know that I had this idea. Just put it out there. I'm just saying me and the CEO of Xbox in our hometown. That's our hometown, both Western and same hometown in the Fox con dome, doing a live decoder overlooking a data center.
I can't script it any better than this. Yeah, that's perfect. I do feel like you could just easily change the intended use of a space to events center and get away with it. Because event centers are generally open and empty. Yeah, there's plenty of room for a pipe and drape in here.
Yeah, you could be like it's a data center. We didn't put anything in it, but now it's an event center. It's very good. And yeah, please read the Utah story. It is it is incredibly important.
Josh did a great job in his full of just in terms. Very good. And you also you went on a trip this week. I went to Austin for a minute to hang out with the folks who run South by Southwest. As you may or may not know, the Verge has been caught up in series of mergers and corporate divorces.
And we are now part of this big thing called PMX, which is part of a bigger thing called PMC that's a pencil meter corporation. Pencil meter corporation owns South by Southwest. They also own like the Billboard Latin American music awards and the country music awards and to Clark's Rock and Eve. So the Virgin Grations and all these things are going to get out of control. But Southwest and Northwest and National.
So it's an awesome for me and just to hang out that team for one second, and I saw Cybercat driving down the street and I was like, all right. So I downloaded the Robotax app. It took a eight minute Cybercat ride, six minute Cybercat ride. Totally uneventful, except everyone stares at you. Like everyone is staring at you the whole time.
I mean, these like weird gold cars. I assume they stand out. They are weird little gold cars. You know, they obviously have the Lambo South doors. So like just getting in and out of them is a production and everyone's like, what's that?
I mean, if you have ever ridden in a model three with FSD, it is that experience, like kind of straightforwardly. And it's Austin. So it was not like raining. It was sunny, camera-based FSD does just fine. Austin's Waymo.
So I took Waymo's everywhere else that day. And I was like, can I appreciate the quality difference of self-driving Jaguar with LiDAR versus this weird thing with Canon? It's fine. But it was fine. It was cheap.
It is obviously being subsidized. I have a lot of questions about what happens when it is raining, when it is foggy. All the questions you have about FSD, right? My five minute two, three, I think we did three turns, two lefts and right. It was fun.
But the video is on my Instagram. You can go. I did a voiceover influencer video. I'm very proud of myself. That was actually the invasion.
It was like, it was edited. It was nice. There's the speed up as you, you know, speed ramp. I'm not saying I know how to use CapCut. I'm saying that I used CapCut.
Do you know what I mean? It's more than I used CapCut. You're doing a good job. It's not bad. CapCut on a MacBook Neo on a Delta flight is not a great environment in which to edit.
But it's not the worst. It's possible to be done. All right. That's it for lightning round and that is it for this week's Vergecast. But we've got a lot more to come Sunday on Virgin History.
Very fun episode. We're talking about the Chromebook with none other than, you know, I tell Anne, Marquez Brownlee, it'll be a very fun episode. This entire season, the entire back to school season has been really, really fun. Remember, you can subscribe to the Verge for ad-free episodes of all of our podcasts, exclusive newsletters, and so much more. If you'd love to hear from you, can email us at verchast.com, or you can call the hotline 866-Verge-1-1.
The Vergecast is a production of the Verge of Vox Media Podcast Network. Today's episode of the show is produced by Josh Cauhas, Eric Gomez, Brian Keefer, and Charles Larchuk. We'll see you next week. You know what I mean? Rock and roll.
Every year, Ontarians win billions playing with OLG. In fact, there were over 200 million wins with OLG last year, worth $2.7 billion in prizes. That's like 12 wins for every person in Ontario. An average of over 380 OLG wins every minute, or about 190 wins by the time this commercial is over. With OLG winning happens here, from Anncaster to Wick-Wemicomme, play at olg.ca.
And winning could happen to you too. Winner, Ganyo. My teammate says he plays pick up basketball, quote, for the cardio. Well, there's more to it than that, Sean. Like with Beth365, I could pay the second my team goes at big with early pay out and can cash out at any time before the game ends.
Sean's getting it steps, but I'm getting paid. Beth365, the home of winning? Girl, must be 19 and older. Ontario only. Please play responsibly.
If you or someone you know what concerns about gambling, visit connectcontario.ca or call 1-866-531-2600. Terms of condition apply. Ugh, hold music. Not what you want to hear when a pipe just burst in your basement is flooding. That's why intact insurance answers 2 million claims calls per year within 20 seconds.
So instead of hearing this lovely track, you'll hear this in seconds. Hello, intact insurance.