Skip to content
DSR 5/13/20: ChipChat: "Obamagate" episode artwork

May 13, 2020 23 min

DSR 5/13/20: ChipChat: "Obamagate"

from District Sentinel Radio Hosted by District Sentinel Radio

In the latest edition of Chip Chat, journalist Chip Gibbons tackles the "intrigue" of "Obamagate" Subscribe at Patreon.com/DistrictSentinel

Episode details come from the podcast's RSS feed.

Embed this episode

Ready to play

DSR 5/13/20: ChipChat: "Obamagate"

0:00 23:59
of matches

Transcript Auto-generated, may contain errors

This is District Sentinel Radio. It's the Wednesday Chip Chat edition. We're joined by Chip Gibbons, the policy director at Defending Rights and Dissent. Though everything he says on Chip Chat are his own words, maybe not even his own, they could be somebody else's, but they're definitely not Defending Rights and Dissent. Chip, it's Chip Chat. Welcome. Hello, thank you for inviting me to this segment again that just coincidentally bears my name. It's always a pleasure when you get invited to things that have your name in it. So for Chip Chat, I just wanted to let the audience know that this week I've been enjoying...

Some Utz brand crab chips. They've been pretty tasty. It's actually one of those duality flavors. It's a sweet tangy barbecue with crab flavor, and it's actually pretty good. A duality flavor, huh? Yeah, it's one of those mixtures. I always have crab chips with just like Old Bay on them. Yeah, so these have Old Bay and their barbecue. Okay, okay, okay. Pretty good. Okay. Anybody else got anything to share about the snacks or chips they're eating?

The kettle cook softened vinegar chips. That's my preferred chip type. I mean, I've been eating a lot of sunflower seeds. I'm a sunflower seed boy. You're being healthy. Are they healthy? I don't think they're healthy. I don't know. They come from the earth. They must be good for you, right? That's a thing? Certainly making a much bigger mess. I'm eating one right now. It has a mountain of shells. It has a gritty realism to chip chat over here. He's got his mountain of shells next to his computer.

Wrong. I threw them in the trash just before we recorded. He's got a layer of sunflower seed dust all over his computer and mousepad. No comment. All right, let's get down to business here. I'm also covered in food, so I cannot judge Sam. All right, this week we're tackling the burgeoning scandal that is Obamagate. Yeah!

I'll let you take it away in just a second, Chip. Okay, I'll let you take it away now. Have you seen the clip of the journalist asking Trump what crime he's referring to? And he says the crime is called Obamagate. And the journalist, again, asked him what crime is it. He goes, the crime is obvious if you read a newspaper other than yours. You know, as I said on the Twitter.com, I was a vociferous critic of Obama, both for his foreign policies and his surveillance policies. You know, he was president when the Snowden revelations happened.

As soon as he clinched the Democratic Party nominee in 07, 08, he voted to give telecoms immunity for participating in an illegal NSA spy program. I was never on the Obama bandwagon. I backed Dennis Kucinich. I think history proved me right on that one. You know, just never an Obama fan, very large critic. I remember being in college and bringing Jeremy Scahill to speak about his policies because I'm like, people need to really know what's really going on with Obama. So I'm not an Obama fan, especially on the surveillance stuff. And I have no clue what the fuck Donald Trump is talking about.

The decision to give phone companies immunity for participating in a warrantless surveillance scheme, that wasn't President Obama planning nine years into the future to spy on a patriot, General Flynn, the three-star general? So here's how much I hate myself. I keep clicking on the Obamagate trend on Twitter, and I keep reading all of the different posts from people who believe in Obamagate about what's going on. And it's like, he was making money to mullahs in the dead of night. And it's like, what, what, what? And there's this one cartoon that's like the Obamagate snake, and it has all the different elements of it. Element one is treason. Another one is fast and furious. It's like all this, like...

You know, there are real Obama administration scandals you could be talking about. Yeah, that's that's that's the key here is that once again, we have a situation in which the right has arrived at a correct conclusion, which is that the Obama administration actually did have a lot of scandals. Unfortunately, when you ask them to show their work about how they arrived at this conclusion, it's a complete mess. But, you know, if you ask them, oh, are you referring to. uh using drones to assassinate a 16 year old american like no not referring to that oh are you referring to the fact that uh obama allowed wall street to pretty much escape by without throwing any bankers in jail and in fact had his treasury secretary sign off on a bunch of golden parachutes for them as they were leaving their their firms it's like no not really referring to that uh what they're actually referring to is stuff related to like michael flynn Yeah, and we discussed Michael Flynn on this program before, and my opinion of Michael Flynn is that he was an unregistered agent of the Turkish state and tried to conspire to kidnap a U.S. person, which seems like would probably violate one of the Reconstruction-era civil rights laws. Nonetheless, the laws against kidnapping.

And I think that's a very serious crime, lying to the FBI about things that aren't illegal, technically a crime, not Michael Flynn's greatest crime. But, you know, the whole sort of Mueller thing where we sort of ignore all of the big picture stuff. I'm like, ah, Michael Flynn lied. And you get these liberals who think he's somehow like an active Russian agent engaged treason. A lot of talk about treason on the TL. Everyone has apparently committed treason. And I'm very unclear if any of the people making these claims, either the Rachel Maddow types or the Sean Hannity types have any idea what treason is. Maybe I don't know what treason is. I don't know. But no, I actually did see one person on the Twitter, one of the Obamagate twitters, like list drone strikes on there. And I sort of wanted to write to them, but you know, Donald Trump has dramatically escalated drone strikes.

And the other thing that keeps bothering me is you have these conservative people who are so enraged about the deep state, and you can debate whether or not that's a good conceptual framework for thinking about our intelligence and security apparatus. I think there's arguments that it is, there's arguments that it isn't. But imagine being super angry about the deep state, but also being super into neocon foreign policy against Iran, or neocold war policy against Venezuela. One of the times Trump was trying to escalate the war or start a war with Iran, you had all, oh, the deep state's undermined. So do you really think the career intelligence people are like actively trying to prevent Trump from going to war with Iran because Obama gave money to mullahs in the dark?

You know, like that weird ass thing that people on Twitter or Benghazi keeps coming up to. I don't I don't know. You know, I think Hillary Clinton gave the stand down order because she was too politically correct to say radical Islam. I think that's the Benghazi scandal. I'm not actually I'm not actually sure. It's definitely not the fact that the U.S. invaded and destroyed a country with no congressional or no congressional authorization. And they definitely went beyond the U.N. mandate for a no fly zone and just engaging in regime change. And that now Libya is now a failed state. That's apparently not the Benghazi scandal, which I find a tad bit more scandalous than whatever, whatever.

happened with this embassy. The conservative ravings about Benghazi, as you noted, they obscured a real failing by the Obama administration in launching a disastrous war or supporting that war in Libya. And I'm afraid as well that Trump's ravings here about Obamagate is going to give more fodder to the type of people who sincerely believe that the only scandal that President Obama committed was wearing a tan suit or whatever. And I find people absolutely annoying, but like... When you hear Trump talk about Obamagate, I mean, I almost, I almost become a resistance liberal when Donald Trump starts going on. You have to, you have to understand the context in which this is being brought up. It's being brought up as the U.S. economy enters a Great Depression and as the number of COVID deaths, you know, move past 80,000 people. Trump, in the same way that he's blaming China, he's trying to like put a lot of blame on Obama for this stuff. And even he tweeted about it over the weekend, like, oh, we're doing a fantastic job responding to the COVID-19 pandemic, unlike how Obama responded to H1N1, swine flu or whatever.

And the president clearly does not want people to compare those two responses because I think like a thousand people died in a year in the total cycle of H1N1. And we've had 80,000 people die in two months here related to this. But so it's clearly an attempt by the White House to deflect blame and responsibility for the crisis that they're making a lot worse right now. But at the same time, you know, we need to reckon with the failures of the Obama administration in a way that also isn't providing an exoneration to Trump right now and how he's dealing with this crisis. I spent eight years reckoning with the failures of the Obama administration and the Kucinich supporter. I spent an enormous amount of time arguing with people during the primary. We have, Chip. We have done that. But clearly it has not worked because the nominee is now Joe Biden running on like four more years of Barack Obama. So, yeah. Yes. I was not saying you were calling me out. I was just commenting on the fact that I.

Yeah, you know, and Trump was tweeting that he had no COVID-19 test because the test Obama left him for a disease that did not exist then. Obviously, COVID existed, but this strand of COVID did not for a bad test. I was like, what are you talking about, right? And I believe he tweeted 100 times in 24 hours. Did I see that? Is that a correct thing that happened? I mean, it's not hard to...

The COVID crisis, though. Yes, he tweeted 100 times on Mother's Day, more than 100 times in one day on Mother's Day. Do those count as retweets? I think they're counting as retweets, yes, which is fudging the numbers. I agree. But yeah, no, no, no, it's it's just.

It's an awful situation. I mean, you have somebody who's out there telling people that they should, you know, drink bleach to prevent the coronavirus and is clearly downplaying the crisis, who clearly wants to reopen the economy, to send working people to their death, is saber-rattling against Iran and Venezuela, is just a horrible human being. And the alternative is Joe Biden, which is, you know, equally bleak in its own right. I do have to remark on how Trump has also, in his sort of blame-shifting mode, brought in Joe Scarborough into this. Yeah.

rekindled doubts about Joe Scarborough's innocence regarding the affair with, well, I shouldn't say affair because I don't think there was an actual affair going on. I mean affair in the broadest sense of term as in something happening regarding Joe Scarborough's intern about two decades ago dying in Scarborough's. Some blame deflection I can get behind. There we go. Yeah. The president of the United States just alleging that a talk show host is a murderer. And frankly, maybe we can look a little more into this.

He wants Comcast to investigate because when I suspect someone of murder, I want Comcast to not like the police to investigate. It reminds me of those old movies. where there's like a murder. And for some reason, the only person doing any investigatory work is like a representative of the life insurance company. And they're like searching the home without a warrant and a wiretap. Well, like double indemnity, right? The investigator in that is a life insurance. I'm going to send them to the gallows. And it's like, is that really your job as a life insurance company to seek the death penalty for murder? Yeah. Chip, one last topic here before we conclude Chip Chat for the week. The Senate's considering the surveillance reauthorization bills, Patriot Act.

provisions. And there's a story, Ron Wyden is raising the alarm. There's a story in the Daily Beast this week that McConnell is trying to move an amendment that would essentially allow the FBI and other surveillance agencies to begin collecting people's web browsing history. I'm guessing this would be under Section 215. So 215 is what's up for, well, three things are up for renewal. 215, roving wiretap, and the lone wolf provision, which has allegedly never been used. But 215 would be the grounds for collecting people's web browser history. And this would be new.

This would potentially be new. I mean, I don't know how the FISA courts or FBI, whoever, are interpreting this to begin with. You have to remember that when 215 was passed, the big fear was that it would allow the FBI to find out what library books we were reading. I don't want to downplay library books. But 215 then turned out to be what the NSA used as its sort of secret justification for its secret bulk collection of metadata, which is not what anyone intended when 215 was passed.

uh yeah but he looked at he's going to expand he wants to expand the powers it's very very disturbing um they should not renew 215 they're probably they're clearly are going to there's a number of amendments that have been proposed that i think as amendments it's worth pushing to support even if you don't necessarily want to end up supporting 215 in the end and you can discuss whether or not that's contradictory or not but um No, they're going to vote on this. It's sort of interesting that the Republicans are all up in arms about Obamagate, and they're going to turn around and expand some of the worst portions of the Patriot Act. Just like Bob Barr. I want to just talk about – Barr, who's the attorney general. Yeah, it's Bill Barr. I'm sorry. I always confuse Bob Barr, the former –

georgia congressman whose big campaign was kicking wiccans out of the military and then somehow became the libertarian uh presidential candidate and then after that was the lawyer for baby doc the former haitian dictator really prestigious career uh from um crusade against witchcraft in the military unconstitutional crusade against witchcraft in the military to uh voice of libertarianism He was also a prominent spokesperson for the ACO around civil liberties issues. His voting record in Congress didn't reflect it, but after he got out of Congress, he had a change of heart that allowed him to get the Libertarian presidential nominee before being a baby doc lawyer and then a Newt Gingrich surrogate. But yeah, Barr, he has now the Carter Page investigation and the Mike Flynn investigation implied that neither investigation was properly predicated. He said there was no predication for the Mike Flynn to ever be questioned.

With Carter Page, he said the amount of intrusive techniques that were allowed were too low for the amount of predication that they had for the case. And you know who sets the predication requirement for opening an investigation and what techniques can be used for the FBI? Pop quiz. Unless it's like FISA warrants or warrants or things like that, then it's set by statute. But when the attorney general guidelines were first created in the late 1970s, you could not use an informant, a confidential informant, unless you were doing a full investigation. There were preliminary investigations, there were full investigations, and full investigations, the most stringent investigation there was, that was when you could use an informant. Now, thanks to the George W. Bush administration.

No one has amended this since then. You can investigate someone without any factual predicate. It's called an assessment. And you can use an informant in that investigation. And one of the things the OIG commented on in the Operation Crossfire Hurricane report was that sensitive investigative matters, those that involve first-time effective activity, don't require a higher degree of predication than other investigations. They just require a higher degree of supervisory approval, which is not that much of a check. And Barr could completely be going after this if he really cared. The other thing...

Barr was attorney general twice, once under Bush, once now, George H.W. Bush, not George W. Bush, not to get wonky, but like. When he was attorney general under George H.W. Bush, he operated under the quote-unquote Thornburg guidelines, the ones put in place by the previous attorney general, which were significantly more stringent than the Michael McKenzie guidelines he operates under now. I mean, he could just literally say, I'm bringing back the guidelines from 1990. You know, they worked fine then, and I'm disturbed with what the FBI is doing. I don't think it would solve the problem, per se, but just the level of hypocrisy coming from Barr and the fact that no one in the media has enough sense to ask him this question is just literally infuriating.

Every time he says to a journalist, blah, blah, blah, blah, blah, not enough predicate, too intrusive techniques, they should say, why the fuck don't you amend the attorney general guidelines? Isn't this something you can do? How do you feel about the fact that you can have an assessment which requires no predication? Which is the first time since the church committee you can do this was put in place in 2008, another failed Obama thing. They put these guidelines through months before Obama becomes president. He's already won the election, the lame duck period. And no, no one in the media even has enough sense to ask that. They just go with like, oh, the FBI is becoming politicized. And it's like, okay.

Well, I'm sure the attorney general will, if McConnell's amendment goes through, and here's hoping that it doesn't, and because senators can come up the works pretty good there, and I don't think Ron Wyden's going to let this thing sail through pretty easily. But if it is approved, I'm sure that Barr will use these powers sparingly. Yes. I mean, he's considered the architect of mass surveillance because one of the things he did is Bush's attorney general. He loves surveillance. He loves policing. He hates police reform, but he has...

adopted this hypocritical and sanctimonious position about FBI surveillance or policing when it applies to people who are associates of his boss, which is very transparent. But instead of focusing on, oh, FBI is becoming politicized or going to lose important spy powers in these handful of cases, we should be asking Barr, OK, why don't you rein in the FBI with these actual real firms? I would love to meet with Attorney General Barr. I would love to meet with him and just be like, hey, Barr. why don't you do this thing or that thing? Because I actually know what's in the Attorney General Guidelines and the DIOG, the FBI, what is it, Domestic Investigations and Operation Guidelines the FBI uses. I'm like, I could have a very extensive conversation with Mr. Barr. I would probably not be invited to do this. Maybe we can arrange this. Maybe we can arrange this for a future Chip Chat. Chip Gibbons, Policy Director at Defending Rights and Dissent. You can follow him on Twitter at ChipGibbons89. Thanks for doing another Chip Chat with us. Thank you for having me on this segment. That just coincidentally bears my name.

Frequently asked questions

How long is this episode of District Sentinel Radio?

This episode is 23 minutes long.

When was this District Sentinel Radio episode published?

This episode was published on May 13, 2020.

Is there a transcript available for this episode?

Yes, a full transcript is available for this episode. You can read the complete transcript on the episode page.

Can I download this District Sentinel Radio episode?

Yes. Use the download control on the episode player to save the publisher-provided media file.