Skip to content
DSR 6/4/22: South Florida Socialism? episode artwork

Jun 4, 2022 26 min

DSR 6/4/22: South Florida Socialism?

from District Sentinel Radio Hosted by District Sentinel Radio

An interview with Angel Montalvo, who’s running for Congress in Miami on a Berniecrat platform, and down to lock horns with reactionaries in both parties This is an excerpt from District Sentinel Radio. To listen to the full episode, subscribe at Patreon.com/DistrictSentinel

Episode details come from the podcast's RSS feed.

Embed this episode

Ready to play

DSR 6/4/22: South Florida Socialism?

0:00 26:54
of matches

Transcript Auto-generated, may contain errors

Moving on to our interview. Earlier this week, additional light was shed on the mainstreaming of fascism in the United States. The New York Times reported on how the Republican Party of Miami-Dade County now includes several known Proud Boys. It's not surprising when considering all the reactionary garbage coming out of South Florida. Take, for example, Republican Congresswoman Maria Elvira Salazar, who represents part of Miami. On Sunday, Salazar called for President Biden to intervene in Colombia politics to stop leftist candidate Gustavo Petro from becoming president. Petro won 40% of the vote Sunday in the first round of voting to advance in a runoff, despite Salazar's best efforts.

And it's not that Florida Democrats inspire any confidence. Most of them engage in anti-communist pandering to appeal to mythical moderate Republicans. And in the process, they only manage to accomplish abandoning policies that appeal to working class voters, and they still get called communists by Republicans. But there is one candidate hoping to break that mold. Angel Montalvo is running for the Democratic nomination in Florida's 27th congressional district. That's the one Salazar represents. And he's running on a Bernie Sanders-style socialist platform and refusing to bow to Miami's increasingly fascist establishment.

We talked to Montalvo earlier this week about his campaign, the big money Democratic frontrunner, Ken Russell, and what it's like being a leftist in Miami, especially as the son of a Cuban immigrant. We started our conversation by asking Montalvo about Congresswoman Salazar calling for a coup in Colombia. Thank you so much for having me on. I really appreciate the opportunity to talk about this, especially in the political climate in Miami. You know, we often don't get the counter counter narrative to this really just right wing reactionary element. And I think that so Maria is very much so a good encapsulation and representation of that kind of position. For me, it's just another like she represents the Republican Party, you know, who tows the party line, which is corporate interest over any cost.

period with regards to the specific you know policies you know and i i think that as a as a principle you need no military intervention it's never worked we see what happened in afghanistan and like throughout history we saw what happened in vietnam and we reprob up and like it's not our role and not even just because it's not our role it's because of the harm that we do like the hundreds of thousands of innocent people that died in afghanistan the trillions of dollars that we spent that could have been spent on health care on housing and and a big part is the fact that their entire policy salazar specifically but especially salazar but the entire republican party and in some cases the democratic party is just um there there's no like for example i went to a press conference where she spoke at and uh she was talking about central south america and like how communism is destroying and we need freedom for spanish-speaking countries and yet that i think it was that week or like that month she had voted against like uh the the voting rights legislation that has been out so how are you going to support like freedom in other countries and you're voting down you know talking like getting people to be able to vote um for example and then you know there's like this narrative that the loudest voices kind of get to dictate the terms of like the conversation so you know oh all cuban my dad was cuban he came on around from cuba like after the revolution and the whole thing

um where they're basically they have no domestic policy um they don't they don't talk about housing they don't talk about health care and then when you talk when i spoke to a gentleman like an older cuban uh man who who worked at the restaurant that they did the the press conference he also worked in another restaurant at the other place and this is in hialeah so like the stereotype of like the reaction in cuban but when he asked me like why are you here it's like well we're talking about voting rights and i want to can i ask you a couple questions uh do you support making uh voting day a national holiday so people don't have to pick between going to work and and voting he says yes do you support making voter registration automatic yes Do you support having transparent elections where we know who's giving money? Yes. And that is everything that, you know, the Republicans will vote against. So like in broad strokes, you know, there's a lot of different elements and components to it. But generally speaking, I don't take it seriously at all.

Like as a community organizer, like I understand that we need to go into the community. We have a winning message. And I think it resonates more with people when you're actually talking, especially in Miami. The housing crisis is a big thing. Gun violence is a huge thing when you talk to people and like health care. You know, those are kind of the three main things. A lot of people talk about climate, which is, you know, central to all of these issues. But yeah. Well, I guess there is some internal consistency on the part of Representative Salazar when she's asking for the U.S. government to do a coup in Colombia and also trying to fight voting rights here in the U.S.

Yeah. Yeah. In that sense, absolutely. Yeah. But for me, like being born and raised here, having heard this line all the time, it's just like, it's tired. It's old. It's boring, especially younger generations. We're so tired of listening to their, you know, frankly, just garbage. Well, it doesn't sound like the Cold War rhetoric really plays into much of it. I mean, the members of Congress are still using it to like whip up the base when they use terms like Marxist and stuff. And I guess there is a new left coming to power in South America, in Latin America, that does have values that are rooted in sort of, you know, socialist thought from the past.

which might make these attacks more relevant than they were before. But that's good. We stand by the fact that there's left-wing governments coming to power. So let them whine about it. Right. Yeah. I mean, I don't especially here for our campaign, you know, we're a small grassroots small dollar campaign. We're never going to have any any campaign that runs in Miami is never going to have the kind of resources and support from the institutions, whether that be the Democratic Party or like the NGOs, like the non-governmental associations, I mean, organizations. We're never going to have that. But what one of the things that the Democratic Party does here consistently is that I'm sorry if there's also background noise. There's like a trap. Can you hear it?

No, we're good. We can hear you. I mean, we can hear a little bit, but it just adds to the ambiance of you being in South Florida right now. You can see my blurry palm trees. We just need a speedboat to go by. Yeah, there's a lot. You were talking about, like, leftists. Yes, my mom is Honduran, so, you know, I was following the Honduran elections and, like, a series of other, you know, the Colombian election, but where we're seeing the trend in Latin America, where we've seen past the veneer of, like, capital and, like, for instance, again, on, like, profit and, you know, using populist messaging with, like, fascist undertones, you know, to really mobilize people. But I think that...

Especially with technology, it's just so much harder for people to keep the line. Like, don't get me wrong. Like, it's still a very potent force. But like with what you were saying, yeah, it's like pretty consistent being like talking about a coup. I mean, look at what happened with Juan Guaido. And oh, and that was the point that I was going to make. If you want bipartisanship in America with the United States government, you just need to start a war. And we're seeing that. And the same goes for like communist rhetoric. It's just like the demo. And that was the point that I was going to say. Democrats here, they accept the Republican Party framework. They're like, we're not communists. Whereas they don't actually.

If you look at, for example, in Florida, the state, Obama won Florida twice. In 2018, there was something Amendment 4, which is to reinstate the voting rights for returning citizens. That passed with over 60% of the vote. The right-wing legislature attacked that, typical going against the will of the people. Then you have in 2020, the $15 minimum wage. Albeit, and a lot of people don't like to recognize this, it is a conservative $15 minimum wage. It started at $10 and it increases a year. We have to be honest about these things. But the fact that it passed with over 60% of the vote is telling you something. And then also on top of that...

Joe Biden lost the state of Florida, but $15 minimum wage was like a pillar of the platform, allegedly, you know that. But at the end of the day, he loses. South Florida, we lost my district of Donna Shalala, Mikasa Powell. And, you know, it really speaks to the weakness of the Democratic Party, because if you're able, like, think about the fact that Joseph Biden was able to successfully be portrayed as a communist. That is absurd on its face and just goes to see like how reductive and infantile the conversation is right now. And so our postulation, our position as a campaign is that we're going to take up a lane that's separate from them.

We have that if we get the Democratic Party nomination, we will have that base. And I would love to see like I would love to see them if we get the nomination because of who we are as leftists, not support us in favor of Salazar. No reputation for the Democratic Party at face value. Like, you know, it's absurd. So we have the Democratic Party base that would vote in a general election. And then what we need to do as a campaign is speak to the tens of thousands more people who are MPAs, like non-party affiliates in Florida. It's more than Republicans. It's more than Democrats. Not necessarily combined, but it's pretty up there. It's like tens of thousands for sure more than the Democrats. And so you take that into consideration. One of the things that I want to work with is getting folks who are eligible.

eligible after Amendment 4 in 2018, formerly incarcerated folks to be registered to vote who have paid their also Jim Crow fees. That number is greater than the amount of people that voted for DeSantis over Andrew Gillum. When we talk about the Puerto Rican community, that also is being affected by the Biden administration policies. When you talk about the Haitian-American communities and the immoral and wrong policies that the Biden administration has, there are all these communities that we can really talk to and organize and do deep organizing in a way that the Democratic Party just isn't doing that here. They're just throwing money at the problem. And we're seeing how that's just not working. The conservative framework is just not working for the people. And then there is a lot of resentment as far as me personally.

Democratic Party, because your loss is not just your loss. It's the loss of the community. Then you do have like these ultra right wing reactioners like Maria Salazar, who are in positions of power and saying these very unhinged, irresponsible things just because, again, they know that it's not going to happen. And, you know, it's just, you know, the Marco Rubio's of the world, like Donald Trump himself was not anti block. I mean, was trying to do business in Cuba. You know, so it's just like once Marco Rubio and the presidential primary got absorbed into the Trump kind of like.

blob, you start to see this hardline reactionary rhetoric. So it just goes to show there's so many examples of how the Democratic Party isn't doing anything because they're able to successfully paint Joe Biden as a communist. And then the Republican Party is just completely unhinged. And I just take it for granted that they're not going to do anything meaningful to address the issues that our communities are facing in Miami and in the district. Your primary opponent, as far as I know, he's a man named Ken Russell. He is a local elected down there. Is that right? He's a city of Miami commissioner. So that's like a city councilor in a lot of other cities. Okay. So he...

is raising a ton of money. I was actually pretty surprised when I checked his FEC records. Is that somewhat intimidating, the amount of money that he has been raising? How do you approach that in terms of the financial advantage that he has? Right. Well, I'll start off by saying that none of the things that I ever talk about are personal, but I will never shy away from saying like what's what. No candidate that is trying to fight for something meaningful for our communities, any policy is ever going to have the backing. We're always going to be called like the reincarnation of Fidel Castro, like the anti-Christ kind of deal. So in that regard, we're kind of in that position. We're never going to be able to raise the amount of money that they will. You know, the reality is that Ken Russell was running for a state Senate race and that got him, that garnered him like a larger audience. And, you know,

For whatever it's worth, whether or not he was originally planning to run for this race and decided to run for Senate and then dropped out and happened to grandfather in that support, or if it was intentional, I can't speak to that because I don't know. That's purely speculation on my part. What we really need to do in the primary is really hammer it home. How are you going to be talking about one thing and then and promising that you're going to deliver on reform for voting rights? But then again, take this amount of money, which is the root of the problem. And so as a grassroots campaign, we're able to say, look, we don't take any corporate money and baseline. And we've been saying the entire time as a campaign, our community has no reason to trust anybody that takes money from corporations, period. Like, I don't care if you're a Democrat, I don't care if you're a Republican. We've been consistent. They like to paint it, especially Ken Russell's campaign likes to paint it as hashtag unity. And our campaign is like flat out. We reject that. There's no accountability. There's not going to be any unity because look at what's happening in our communities. The Democratic Party has abysmally failed. The Florida Democratic Party, especially and the Miami-Dade Party. And I say this with love.

I say that as a member of the board of the Progressive Caucus. I say that as a member of the Democratic Executive Committee, who has dedicated a lot of my time as a working person, not like Ken Russell. I don't have the kind of resources personally or, you know, as a campaign. So I say with a lot of love, we have our bylaws. I've read them. We're not living up to our standards. This is another example of that. My hope...

is that we can organize in a way that they're not able to. And we have a message that is that they're not able to say. In fact, recently, I know that there was a mention about like from their camp, how Salazar takes dark money. The irony of that is not lost on me. And the fact that there is a campaign like ours that is not expected from, I'm sure, any political calculations from anybody, but we're there, we're getting on the ballot and you have to contend with our ideas. You don't get to be a fake progressive. You have to deal with the fact that there is somebody who was born and raised in Miami, who represents a large swath of the communities, being a Cuban Honduran, who was born in Miami Beach, raised here. I'm a working person. I'm a baker. I'm a farmer. I do Uber as a side hustle because it's impossible to live here. Like all of my friends.

are leaving the city. We're expected to not have like basically Miami anymore within the next two years. So we really have to stress the people. Housing, that is like a central thing. We have gentrification is rampant. And a lot of the times people in the city and county commission are responsible, especially with the city of Miami mayor, but the entire commission, I would say. You have the fox guarding the hen house.

And so, you know, we really need to hammer that home. And our position is go nuclear. It doesn't matter if it's the Democrats. It doesn't matter if it's the Republicans. And our hope is to really go into, like Martin Luther King said, they went to Birmingham, Alabama to organize there in the South. And different people have different feelings about whether the South is Florida's the South, especially the Miami Florida. But he went and they went to Birmingham, Alabama because it was the stoutest fortress of reactionary segregation. Like he said, the racism in this country is like an affected wound that you have to cut open and squeeze it out and expose it to the natural medicine of air and the sun. And that's what we need to do as a campaign.

There seems to be a constant struggle on the anti or tension among the anti-capitalist left between pursuing electoralism and getting involved in politics and running for office versus trying to get into more community work and trying to like, you know, directly affect people who are facing evictions. And, you know, you brought up all these housing issues and where the Democratic Party is failing, which makes it necessary for these local groups to kind of fill in and help each other in these failures. As someone who's been involved in both, you know, you talked about your work within the Democratic Party down there and also your work as a community organizer. And as someone who spent much of this podcast correctly identifying all the problems with the Democratic Party, how do you balance that tension between like, I mean, you're going to have to ask for money from donations from people. You're going to have to devote your time to running for office, to knocking on doors, to making phone calls. How do you make the decision that that is an effort worth pursuing versus other avenues of change you could be pursuing?

I love this conversation. I actually have, I recently had it with one of my good friends who's also, it's funny enough, well, he's an active member of the DSA. I'm a lapsed dues-paying member. I need to really get on that. But he's actually the, you know, the president of the local progressive caucus. And we have this conversation a lot. My lane is...

This is my line. It's what I'm passionate about. And a lot of my position has been informed by my working community. The reality of the situation is the biggest issue that is affecting our communities, bar none, is the planetary crisis. In Miami, especially, we have the aquifers, which is where we get our fresh water. The salt water is displaced in that fresh water because of sea level rise. We have the industrial agricultural runoff, the fertilizer, which is feeding the algae blooms, which is destroying the acidification of the ocean. Sea level rise. If you read the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change, the reports are saying that within the century, it's expected that in Florida, two million people are going to leave.

within a century. And in Miami-Dade County, 2 million people are expected to leave within the century just because of sea level rise. And it's like if you make less than $100,000 a year, which is the majority of people who live here. So my understanding of the scope and magnitude of the issues, that's why I'm running for a congressional seat as well. But those are not mutually exclusive things. And I think it's going to be a matter of a proof of concept. We have a proof of concept.

an argument that we're making. And in practice, we're going to show because down ballot races are important. You know, at the end of the day, you have to contend with elected officials, whether it's the school board, city or county commission, whether it's the state, House, Senate, or like governors mentioned, or the federal policies, especially in a reactionary right wing, like ultra right wing. We're talking about Governor DeSantis, who's not running for governor. He's running for president right now. And we have to be real about this. Like, I don't think that the amount of harm that's being done and the amount of change that needs to happen is going to happen right now with the way that things are going. I respect and I'm involved with a lot of like, you know, the Miami Workers Center and a lot of these other groups that have been really active with getting a tenant bill of rights that was amended significantly.

but it was an incredible win. The fact that if they wouldn't have been organizing around that, that wouldn't have happened. The fact that they had something with like, if your rent was increased by more than like a certain percentage, I can't remember the number right now, they wouldn't need to give you a 60 day notice for evictions. That's only happening because of organizing. But again, they're not mutually exclusive. I go to these meetings. And if anything, what we're going to be able to do in the future as the congressperson for the congressional district, we would be de facto essentially the leaders of Miami County because the highest position after that is the Senate, which we have Rick Scott and Marco Rubio. I hear it and I get it. I've had this conversation a million times, but in my heart of hearts, I really do believe that like.

Like I said, we need to contend with these elected officials in any case. And so, you know, it's one thing to pontificate in our circles, you know, calling out a lot of my good friends. But when you actually step into the arena, when you stick your neck out and you're realizing like, OK, do you believe in defunding the police? Talk about it. Say that honestly. Move the conversation or win an election if you think that it'll resonate, if you'll do the work, if you have the capacity. But like I said, this is a long haul thing. And we will not, as the elected official for this district, I guarantee you, we will not support any candidate.

takes money from corporations so imagine all of a sudden we're able to put the weight of a congressional seat in a way that's never been done in the democratic party because again the democrats unfortunately have the like what we have to understand about like us congress people united states uh congressional representatives are some of the most powerful people in the history of humankind in human history so to just shrug your shoulders and say like we can't no we have the bully pulpit we have an insane amount of resources compared to a lot of things and frankly like a lot of these the the resources that organizations have even if they're well funded it's putting a bandage on a broken limb i think we really need to get serious with all due respect with all the love in my heart for like community orgs and people who are doing this kind of work for the scope and magnitude of the issues you know it's not going to help us to have rent control if we have sea level rise up to like our knees and waters and we have flooding you know so that's kind of my position and i understand where people are coming from So I'm going to do my best to be the best vehicle for our message and not be apologetic about our positions. Use this as an opportunity to expose people. But we also need to win. This isn't just a messaging campaign.

trying to win so that we can do all of these things down the line. We can help down ballot progressives who imagine, you know, a lot of these races, too, is because of lack of voter participation are won by a couple thousand, a couple hundred votes for the city and county commission, especially the county. They have so much power. The main source of income, I think, for the city of Miami is parking tickets. And you know that money is going to to the friends and family of a lot of these corrupt elected officials. So I believe that once we get into these positions, like there's a great guy. I shout out, shout out to him. You should maybe reach out to him. Richie Floyd. He's a DSA member who won and he's on a commission. I can't remember what position it is, but he won on a very progressive message or populist left message. And so.

It's like the writing is on the walls. I think a lot of people are very concerned and I understand that this deign for the electoral process, but at the end of the day, look, we have to, in my mind. And so once we, I believe that once we get into these positions, we're able to actually materially better people's quality of life, you know, that's what's gonna be able to make it so that we have loyalty. Down the line. If we're able to get these wins and people were able to say, look, we did that and you'll never get that with a Republican and you'll never get, especially not with a Republican, but you'll never get that with a Democrat, like an establishment Democrat. That's what's going to be able to change the city of Miami drastically. And wherever the city of Miami goes, the state of Florida goes. Again, think about the fact that it's Central and South America's gate. Think about the fact that the presidential election runs through here. It's not a coincidence that the first Democratic primary in 2020 was here in Miami, Florida.

When you think about the fact that, you know, we are, I think it's like the third largest state in the country. Again, it's a swing state. If we're able to say a progressive can win here, it'll be transformative across the board. I really do believe that. And that's my message to progressives. If you're hearing this, please support us. Even if it's just sharing this on social media, if you can make a small dollar contribution, please do so. Our Instagram and social media is Montalvo Florida 27. Just got to put that shout out there. Well, we appreciate you taking the time to chat with us here today. And any final things that you want? I know you plugged your various fundraising channels. If you want to plug social media in.

um how people can get involved with your campaign etc 100 well i want to first say i want to acknowledge the fact that i should have said in the beginning like we're on settled land i want to talk about the legacy and history of like slavery and genocide in this country because that's the reality of what we're going and that's where we're grounding our work um so like i said my name is angel montalvo i was born and raised in miami florida i'm running this campaign out of the love for our city and our state and our country you know what i mean uh and so like i Right now, what we need to do is we need support with regards to fundraising. If you could do $5, $10, $15 contributions, that makes a big deal. We're completely funded by small grassroots donations and powered by our volunteers. And what we really need help with is making sure that we get that message out there. And a big part of that, unfortunately, is raising a lot of money. So our social media is M-O-N-T-A-L-V-O-F-L, like Florida, Montalvo, Florida 27. That's on Instagram and Twitter. And then just go to our website, montalvoforcongress.com, and you can make a donation through that.

And if you DM on Instagram or Twitter, that's me directly. So you'll have a handle on me. I'm happy to talk to people. I want to be like a people's candidate so that, you know, we can actually have these dialogues. Like I've talked to reactionary right wingers who get upset because I use the hashtag. So, yeah, much love to everybody here. I really appreciate the opportunity to talk. Shout out to David for helping us set this up. And, you know, all the love to people, all power to the people. And like, please help us out. Well, Angel, thank you so much for taking the time to chat with us. It was a very enlightening conversation and we wish you all the best. And we're going to keep.

keep our eyes open on, on the 27th district of Florida primary is August 23rd. Is that right? Correct. Correct. And I'm looking forward to having a follow-up email after we win that primary. Oh yeah.

Frequently asked questions

How long is this episode of District Sentinel Radio?

This episode is 26 minutes long.

When was this District Sentinel Radio episode published?

This episode was published on June 4, 2022.

Is there a transcript available for this episode?

Yes, a full transcript is available for this episode. You can read the complete transcript on the episode page.

Can I download this District Sentinel Radio episode?

Yes. Use the download control on the episode player to save the publisher-provided media file.