Skip to content
DSR 7/15/20: Chip Chat: SRUF’s Up episode artwork

Jul 15, 2020 25 min

DSR 7/15/20: Chip Chat: SRUF’s Up

from District Sentinel Radio Hosted by District Sentinel Radio

-Via FOIA, the Sams obtained the Minnesota National Guard’s Standard Rules for Use of Force (SRUF) for Gov. Walz’s response to the George Floyd Uprising. Chip Gibbons lends his expertise to parse through them on this week’s Chip Chat. -Plus, the grim resumption of federal executions by the Department of Justice. -To have your own look at the Minn. National Guard’s SRUF, click here: https://drive.google.com/file/d/1yuAQyUiuOhHodNXbH34vJcd_I0qVCxSM/view?usp%3Dsharing&sa=D&source=hangouts&ust=1594922668681000&usg=AFQjCNHfwssBovewZ1BtCh-QRSyKxQ5Kiw

Episode details come from the podcast's RSS feed.

Embed this episode

Ready to play

DSR 7/15/20: Chip Chat: SRUF’s Up

0:00 25:25
of matches

Transcript Auto-generated, may contain errors

This is District Sentinel Radio, the newscast of record for the left. I am Sam Sachs. I'm Sam Knight. We are broadcasting out of Washington, D.C. Check out the website, districtsentinel.com. It's Wednesday, which means it's time for another edition of Chip Chat, where we're joined by journalist Chip Gibbons. Hey, Chip. Hello. Welcome back. Welcome back. We're doing a little something special this week. Sam Knight acquired some documents via FOIA that we want to bring you in to talk about, Chip. First, Sam, set up what you've received.

So I filed a FOIA with the Minnesota National Guard for their rules of engagement for the mission that Governor Tim Walz sent them on to put down the uprising after the George Floyd protests, after the killing of George Floyd. I filed for the rules of engagement. They replied that the rules of engagement is actually a term that only refers to overseas military operations. But they nevertheless decided to give me their standard rules for use of force or their SRUF, as they call it in their military jargon. And they gave it to me 13 pages unredacted.

And I suspect part of the reason that is, and I suspect part of the reason for that is because it's very generalized and it says that basically these rules can change at any time for any specific mission for whatever reason. And so, yeah, basically they're very generalized and hence the release to me, all 13 pages unredacted. So, Chip, did you have any takeaways looking at the documents? Yeah, so I read over them two or three times now. And my takeaway is that a lot of them are fairly standard articulations for the general legal standards that govern use of force.

in a domestic law enforcement context. Use of force is governed by the Fourth Amendment. People might be surprised to hear that. The reason for that is because a use of force by law enforcement is considered a seizure of a person. So if they shoot you unnecessary, they have unreasonably seized your person. That is a very bizarre sort of legal way of approaching it. But just looking through some of the specific rules, you can't shoot a fleeing felon. That's, of course, from a Supreme Court decision when you can use deadly or lethal force. They're fairly in line with what...

what the courts have articulated over the years i know that the one thing that jumped out as sam is concerning and i i do sort of share some of these concerns is with the arrest and detention um part they explicitly tell people not to read miranda rights and while that's troubling the reason given is of course that they're not supposed to be interrogating um suspects or people like that uh the miranda warnings according to the courts only apply um in what the courts called custodial interrogation. So that means you're in custody. A reasonable person would not feel free to leave. When the courts think a reasonable person would feel free to leave is quite a story in and of itself. And then also, A, they're asking you questions that are designed to elicit an incriminating answer. Once again, the courts have interpreted that in a very law enforcement-friendly way.

one of my favorite Supreme Court cases on this subject. I'm blanking on the name. It involves a suspect who is alleged to have left a gun in a playground and the police are driving around the cop guard talking about how a lot of children with disabilities play at that playground. it would be a real shame one of them got a hold of a gun and shot themselves, and then he goes, wait, I'll tell you where it is, and then he wasn't against Miranda Rights, and the courts ruled that without interrogation because their statements were not designed to elicit a community response. On the flip side, though, and it's different not to go too far off on the inconsistent rulings of the Supreme Court, in a different case, though, they ruled where someone was told that a girl supposedly murdered, he didn't have a Christian burial, that that was a coerced confession, because anyone being told that someone was denied a Christian burial would, of course, you know, instantly confess, whereas, you know, potentially murdering alive.

child disabilities with a weapon is apparently not not inducing you to confess it's a very strange world they they live in up at the Supreme Court um it would be far more concerned about the uh child disability being injured by gun violence and I would be Christian burial but I am also an atheist so uh It's generally an ungodly guy, I guess. Well, I think the Miranda rights thing jumped out at me because on one hand, here you have the National Guard being asked to perform domestic law enforcement operations while at the same time trying to jump through certain procedural loopholes so that while they are basically being cops, they're not being cops as per strict legal definitions. And for example, they're instructed not to search and seize to comply with the Fourth Amendment. The text of the Fourth Amendment is quoted.

in the SRUF, but then it says it is authorized if a person presents an immediate danger or to protect safety of people in the area, to prevent the destruction of property, et cetera, et cetera. I guess that is pretty standard, but for me, it gets a little more troubling reading that in the context of the addendum, tab A, Minnesota criminal statutes that may apply, and there's some obvious ones like assault, robbery, theft, arson, damage to property, et cetera. Then you have stuff like disorderly contact, presence at an lawful assembly, concealing identity. public nuisance and i don't know it just i guess it's a miracle things weren't worse in the crackdown Yeah, I mean, I don't want to say this isn't concerning because, I mean, the state of the Fourth Amendment is extremely concerning and extremely distressing. But once again, over the years, the courts have authorized a number of exceptions to when the Fourth Amendment requires a warrant, including exigent circumstances, search pursuant to arrest, things like that. And while this doesn't articulate, as far as I can tell, any of the specific legal language that the Supreme Court has used, some of it seems to be referring to some of the same general concepts.

So I do question, I don't necessarily know if this is a standard that is less than what the Supreme Court has decided the Fourth Amendment requires. That's a very low standard. The Supreme Court has sort of, I think someone else described it as killing the Fourth Amendment with death by a thousand paper cuts, which is basically what they've done. So from a legal standpoint, it doesn't jump out at me as being like, I mean, the only thing that is sort of like the special orders may require and it's not clear what special orders are. But the search has to be limited to the perceived immediate danger. That's sort of getting into the exigent circumstances or sort of like the searching for a weapon when you're detaining someone. So it isn't getting that. I don't know. It seems to be within the letter of the law, which obviously I don't think is good. But that constitutional analysis, nothing is jumping out at me. Yeah, I guess to be clear, I'm not necessarily suggesting that the Minnesota National Guard are instructing their.

um they're certain the guardsmen to do anything illegal just that reading the through the legalities of it and it seems like damn um by letter of the law it seems like they can just get away with anything yeah yeah We can switch topics here. I just want to note something that I chuckled a bit to myself when I read these use of force guidelines is where National Guard members are reminded that no private weapons are allowed nor no private ammunitions are allowed. You can only use weapons issued by the Guard. Curious why that needs to be in writing and how often Guard members in the past tried to bring their own custom-made skins on their rifles and stuff.

That's a really good point. And the other thing that jumped out to me was one of the first things in this document is that they do not limit the inherent right to self-defense of guard members, right? So they have all this stuff about use of force. They're not law enforcement, but it's very similar to sort of use of force in the law enforcement Fourth Amendment type context. But then you have this sort of carve out that it doesn't limit the inherent right of self-defense. I assume it's self-defense defined at the common law level or defined by Minnesota state law, which, you know, obviously you can't limit that right, I suppose. But it is a very weird thing to start with, in my opinion.

Staying on the issue of use of government force here, we saw on Tuesday morning the Department of Justice resume federal executions for the first time in 17 years. An inmate in Indiana was executed by lethal injection following a Supreme Court ruling in the middle of the night. Chip, your thoughts on what we're seeing transpire here with the resumption of the death penalty at the federal level. I mean, this is really a very dark day, right? I mean, I don't personally believe in the death penalty in any circumstances. I'm not going to say, you know, Daniel Lewis Lee.

person who was murdered by the government was a great person by all accounts he was a white supremacist though there's some you do not have to hand it to daniel lewis lee let's make it clear i don't but but you know there's there's his um accomplice who i believe there's some dispute about which one of them actually carried out the killings only got life in prison without parole whereas he was sentenced to death he maintained he wasn't the one who actually did the physical killings i assume he was convicted under like a felony murder type rule um and it's just really very horrific you know there's no place for the death penalty in like the criminal law context at this point in our nation's history or that of any other nation. And to see sort of Barr and Trump resume it because there's this sort of long history in this country of, for lack of a better term, almost right-wing populists sort of using sort of the death penalty as this sort of very disturbing wedge issue to rile people up and get political support. So this is a clear murder of a person as a political stunt. The way it was carried out was really very disturbing and just sort of...

mind-blowing in that you know there was a stay of execution issued so first of all the family opposed this execution and they had tried to stop it on the grounds they wanted to bear witness to this because they opposed it and if they couldn't they didn't want to travel because of COVID you know so there's all these issues about how do you have a socially distanced execution which I was reading about before it happened and that's just like I mean, planning a socially distanced execution during a pandemic is like a mind-numbing proposition. It's just terribly ghoulish. And they tried to stop it, saying they couldn't travel because of COVID. That was turned out. But there was some challenge to the execution method. A judge issued a stay, and appellate court kept this stay in place. And the execution was originally supposed to happen at 4 o'clock on Monday, and it was stayed. And then at 2.30 in the morning,

2.30 in the morning, the Supreme Court comes with this five to four opinion, and the five part of the opinion is unsigned, but we can deduce who it was from based on the dissent, and just authorize the execution. So then they reschedule it for an hour and a half later at four o'clock in the morning, but they're still pending appeals, and they leave this man strapped to the gurney with the curtain closed for four hours as Barr and creepy crew try to get rid of the last-minute legal obstacles, and they don't even notify the attorney when the final one, the final... blockage of the execution is lifted and they just sort of you know then have them still strapped to the gurney and then you know pull back the curtains and murder him like it's very very um like dead of the night very quick it's very sort of shocking especially since you know this matter had already gone on for so long and i was talking to other people do you ever remember a situation where the supreme court you know makes a decision in the middle of the night on an execution and they call everyone back in the middle of the night not even waiting to the next day and and you know when i've spoken to can ever recall something like this and there's also some question about the warrant the death warrant because you know not that it really matters at this junction but the death warrant expired at 12 o'clock on monday so

in theory this was a warrantless execution right they didn't even bother to issue a new warrant where they just carried it out very quickly in the dead of night after the Supreme Court did this thing in the middle of the night it's just I don't I don't understand the whole thing then you you throw in the fact that these these drugs the lower court initially put this this execution on hold because lots of medical experts and witnesses to previous executions had testified to the effect of these drugs and how they could cause suffering and the Supreme Court basically takes those that testimony and evidence and says well the government presented opposing testimony so sorry we're gonna sign off on this I think the Supreme Court has been really horrific in their death penalty decisions on the lethal injection and this was listed you know come down on party lines 254 not an issue you often think about of the Supreme Court determining on party lines but it is now Yeah, I mean, Kennedy used to be the swing vote on the death penalty. People might not remember this, but in 2002, 2003, he ruled you couldn't execute minors. And there was this huge right-wing backlash. And he got all these death threats and stuff because you couldn't kill children. Or was it children or was it people with mental handicaps? I don't know. He ruled both of those. But one of them provoked a bunch of backlash from right-wing people. I believe this is one of the impetuses for the Justice Sunday, these sorts of weird evangelical anti-Supreme court rallies that took place.

And Tom delay was very angry that he had done research on the internet He was I don't know if any remembers who Tom delay was this feels like a different lifetime ago, but the dancing with the stars guy Did he go on Dancing with the Stars? Yeah, yeah. Aren't you thinking of Rick Perry? No, they both did. Didn't Tom DeLay get put on criminal trial? Remember he had a really ridiculous mugshot? He was a Republican congressman who was in the leadership. I forget what. He was the whip. He was the whip. And he got very angry about Kennedy's decision in the case where you could not execute children. And he started this whole sort of backlash that the media labeled the war on judges. And Kennedy started getting like really...

inflamed death threats and the whole impetus for this was don't kill children um and he had this really sort of over the top I used to listen to Air America radio at the time so that's why I can remember all of this um unfortunately um which is like he used the internet the internet like just Tom DeLay on the floor of the house having a meltdown because a Supreme Court judge used the internet to find facts which shouldn't do Guess not. I mean, on the one hand, you know, if like Alito was like, well, I read the Wikipedia article on lethal injections, I would be having help now. But also, like, I used the internet and discovered that, like, you know, very few countries murder children. Seems kind of unusual. Some of these...

these execute the backlash against using quote-unquote foreign law or international law in u.s. Courts comes from she saw a whole bunch of weird like uh local legislation ban like sharia law and then also foreign international law when cinema war was confirmed the republicans kept asking about the use of quote-unquote foreign law and once again coming from two cases one about life without parole for juveniles one about life with one about death sentence for juveniles where kennedy in order to determine whether something was cruel and unusual looked to sort of general international norms as like a soft like persuasive authority not even a binding authority but just to sort of like along with what the majority of states does do. And it prompted a whole bunch of backlashes from the right. It's taking me back to the agenda 21 days when that section of the right thought there was some...

nefarious UN agenda called Agenda 21. We still do. There's like that Facebook status thing, like 12 questions about COVID you should ask, and like question seven is, what is Agenda 21? It's like, I don't know, what is Agenda 21? You know, why not ask, like, you know, any, like, what's the weather outside? Like, a bunch of, like, non-sequitur questions, like, looped together, like, what is you and Agenda 21? What does it have to do with COVID? It's like, what does it have to do with COVID? With regard quickly, or with regard briefly to these, the timing of these executions that you spoke of,

What do you think the impact of the election year has on these? I mean, this kind of reminds me of when Bill Clinton during the primary presided over an execution and tried to gain politically from it and probably did. Yeah, so Bill Clinton, when he was running for president in 1992 in the Democratic primary, makes a big stunt out of leaving the campaign trail to go back to Arkansas and sign the death warrant and preside over the execution of a man with a mental disability. He asked to save his dessert for after his execution from the last meal, like really horrific stuff, and clearly was just about Clinton sort of using the death. And Clinton presided over a huge expansion of the federal death penalty. There's no federal death penalty from like 1972 to about 19—

88 89 maybe and even then it's very narrowly defined and then in like the 90s the joe biden crime bill and bill clinton just brings back the death penalty for any of the statutes that had it before that were struck down as unconstitutional as well as creates a whole bunch of new new death penalty offenses something like 90 new death penalty offenses or something like that like really very shocking expansion of the federal death penalty and that was uh part of bill clinton's political savvy and that was a time when A lot of politicians were using sort of the issue of the death penalty, the issue of, you know, quote unquote, tough on crime to make political careers for themselves. And that's clearly the playbook that Donald Trump has been using since 2015 when he first started running. You know, he sounded an awful lot like George Wallace at times. And, you know, in 2020, it just feels like rhetoric from another time. I don't know what political saliency this still has.

you know, on the one hand, this seems like very out-of-touch rhetoric, but, you know, when the Supreme Court struck down the death penalty in the 70s, you know, the majority of the country disapproved of the death penalty, and then shortly after that, there was this huge demagogic right-wing, you know, pseudo-populist campaign to give us back our death penalty. After that, public support for the death penalty, like, just shot, like, to an all-time, all-time high, like, really quick period of time, which is a dramatic reversal. So, you know, on the one hand, the type of language Trump is using feels like it's out of a political playbook from a different era, but on the other hand, you know... that playbook was manufactured by politicians from above. It was not something that organically came from below. So I wouldn't call it a day and rest easy. Chip Gibbons, Policy Director at Defending Rights and Dissent, host of the podcast Still Spying. That's still going on, right? Yeah, I know. Alex Vitale joined us for our last episode. Ooh, big episode. Yes, and then I conducted an interview with one of Fred, the lawyers for Brighampton and the Black Panthers, who interviewed survivors the night of the raid that killed Brighampton, and that's going to premiere sometime in the next month.

Well, I encourage everybody to check it out. This concludes another edition of Chip Chat. We didn't even get into snacks. I've been eating some Nilla wafers this week. Today's not really a day for snacking, I don't feel like. Dried chickpeas. Sea salt. They're good. Sounds like some hippy-dippy shit. Roasted chickpeas. It sounds like it, but you know what? They're salty snacks. I don't know. It tastes like any potato chip would. Alright, Chip. We're out. Thank you for having me.

Frequently asked questions

How long is this episode of District Sentinel Radio?

This episode is 25 minutes long.

When was this District Sentinel Radio episode published?

This episode was published on July 15, 2020.

Is there a transcript available for this episode?

Yes, a full transcript is available for this episode. You can read the complete transcript on the episode page.

Can I download this District Sentinel Radio episode?

Yes. Use the download control on the episode player to save the publisher-provided media file.