Skip to content
E169: Why Does Disappointment Shake Me So Much? episode artwork

Oct 9, 2026 17 min

E169: Why Does Disappointment Shake Me So Much?

from The Happiest Lives Podcast Hosted by Jill M. Lillard

Why does disappointment affect me so deeply when life doesn’t go the way I hoped? Sometimes the hardest part of disappointment isn’t simply what happened. It’s the gap between the life you’re living and the picture you carried of how you thought things would be. Your marriage was supposed to feel different by now. Retirement was supposed to be more enjoyable. Your health, family, friendships, or future didn’t unfold quite the way you imagined. In this episode of the Why Don’t I Feel Secure? series, Jill explores what disappointment can reveal about where we’ve been looking for security. Using the picture of the tree planted by streams of water in Psalm 1, she looks at what it means to stay rooted in Christ when circumstances change, prayers remain unanswered, or the fruit you hoped to see hasn’t appeared yet. You don’t have to stop wanting good things. But you can begin noticing when a good desire has quietly become the thing you believe you need in order to be okay. In This Episode • Why disappointment can feel much bigger than the event itself • How expectations create a picture of what we think life should look like • What disappointment reveals about where we’re looking for security • Why Psalm 1 describes a secure life as a tree planted by a dependable source • How seasons and timelines influence the way we interpret unanswered prayers • What it means to magnify God without denying the disappointment in front of you Key Takeaways • Disappointment often reveals what you believed an outcome would finally give you. • Good desires become heavy when we ask them to provide our deepest security. • The absence of visible fruit doesn’t mean God is absent or inactive. • Faith allows you to acknowledge what’s missing without letting it become the whole story. • Security grows as your roots reach toward Christ rather than the picture you hoped your life would become. Series Note This is the second episode in the four-part Why Don’t I Feel Secure? series. We’re exploring identity, disappointment, emotional reactivity, and what it looks like to live from a secure foundation in Christ. Keywords disappointment in marriage, Christian women and disappointment, unmet expectations in marriage, finding security in Christ, dealing with disappointment as a Christian, trusting God when life doesn’t go as planned Ready to experience something different in your marriage in the new year? Join me inside The Happiest Lives Academy, a three-month, Christ-centered coaching experience for wives who want to stop waiting for their husbands to change and start becoming the women God says they already are. Through practical tools, biblical truth, weekly coaching, and a supportive community, you’ll learn to become more emotionally steady, Discover ways to work with me at www.thehappiestlives.com or www.myhappyvault.com Questions? Email Jill directly at [email protected]

Episode details come from the podcast's RSS feed.

Embed this episode

Why does disappointment affect me so deeply when life doesn’t go the way I hoped? Sometimes the hardest part of disappointment isn’t simply what happened. It’s the gap between the life you’re living and the picture you carried of how you thought things would be. Your marriage was supposed to feel different by now. Retirement was supposed to be more enjoyable. Your health, family, friendships, or future didn’t unfold quite the way you imagined. In this episode of the Why Don’t I Feel Secure? s...

Ready to play

E169: Why Does Disappointment Shake Me So Much?

0:00 17:37

No transcript yet.

Requests help us decide what to transcribe next.

Frequently asked questions

How long is this episode of The Happiest Lives Podcast?

This episode is 17 minutes long.

When was this The Happiest Lives Podcast episode published?

This episode was published on October 9, 2026.

Can I download this The Happiest Lives Podcast episode?

Yes. Use the download control on the episode player to save the publisher-provided media file.