Skip to content
E271: MURDER - Lizzie Halliday (part I) episode artwork

Feb 28, 2025 53 min

E271: MURDER - Lizzie Halliday (part I)

from Fresh Hell Podcast Hosted by freshhellpodcast

Lizzie Halliday is often called America’s first female serial killer, but long before she made headlines, she was already leaving a trail of chaos behind her. In this episode, we look at her early years—from her family’s immigration from Ireland to her first marriages and the, let’s say, unfortunate fates of the men in her life. Lizzie had a habit of marrying quickly, fighting dirty, and possibly poisoning anyone who got in her way. With lawsuits, accusations, and more than a few suspicious deaths, it’s clear that Lizzie was not your average 19th-century housewife. Lizzie Halliday, serial killer, true crime, 19th-century crime, historical murder, female killers, New York history, Irish immigrants, Victorian crime, marriage scams, arsenic, Nellie Bly, Fresh Hell Podcast

Episode details come from the podcast's RSS feed.

Embed this episode

Ready to play

E271: MURDER - Lizzie Halliday (part I)

0:00 53:45
of matches

Transcript Auto-generated, may contain errors

This episode is brought to you by Netflix. Think you know Cinderella? Think again. In the new animated film Steps, the stepsisters team up for a hilarious adventure beyond the palace walls. Expect monsters, a hot troll, and plenty of family drama on their journey to happily ever after. Featuring Ali Wong, Amanda Seyfried, Nikki Glaser, Bette Midler, and Daniel Radcliffe. Don't miss Steps, coming November 20th, only on Netflix.

Hey there, I'm Suzy and I'm the host of Beyond the Ferns podcast. Each week I take you beyond the headlines into the stories that linger long after the news fades. From chilling true crime and unsolved cold cases, to paranormal encounters, cults, and extraordinary survival stories. It's a little bit of everything for everyone. Whether you're drawn to mysteries, fascinated by the strange and unexplained, or simply love a good story, I focus on the truth, the details, and above all, justice for the victims and survivors. So buckle up, things are about to get a little scary. Follow Beyond the Ferns wherever you get your podcast. Thanks y'all.

You're listening to the Fresh Hell podcast. Fresh Hell contains stories of a disturbing and often graphic nature and is intended for a mature audience. Please don't let your kids listen to this or they might turn out like us. Hi, I'm Annie in America. And I'm Johanna in Austria. And you're listening to your favorite international podcast. Yeah, that's right. We met online about seven years ago now. We realized we had a very similar interest in macabre history. And then Johanna was all, do you want to start a podcast? And then she audio called me to discuss. And I was like, OK. And that was our first phone call. And then I think our second phone call was the intro that we recorded way, way back in the day. Yeah. And here we are, over five years later, bringing you the freshest tale we can find every week so we can tell you.

all about it. Because mystery or misery loves company. And we're also now four times award winners. I know. Can you believe it? I don't even know how this happened, but apparently we won the 2024 Discover Pots Award in the category Best History. That's right. We won another history award. Thank you everyone who voted for us. Thank you so much, really. And honestly, we couldn't do this without you, our listeners, our hellions, everybody who supports us, everybody who sends us messages, encouragement, and of course, our Patreon supporters.

Absolutely. Before we start, we'd love to give a huge shout out to our newest Patreon member, Alice Pilchman. Yes, thank you so much. If you're listening, everybody who's listening right now and who's a murder patron, if you haven't checked out our new Cinema Macab episodes yet, please go check them out. This is a new thing we're doing where we watch a documentary, true crime documentary or true crime TV show drama on a real case and then we discuss it episode by episode. Our first show is Candy on Hulu, starring Jessica Biel and Melanie Linsky, and it's a dramatized true story of the murder of Betty Gore.

So even if you don't have Hulu, even if you've never seen Candy, we're here to recap the episodes as we discuss. So listening is maybe a little bit like listening to two of your friends just tell you the plot of any TV show. Yeah, that's right. So if you don't have access to the show, don't worry, we'll tell you all you need to know. And now we're starting the next show we're covering, and it's going to be, and I'm so excited, welcome to Chippendales. I had no idea how wild the Chippendales story was. It's also on Hulu, so we promise the next show will not be Hulu. We'll pick it different, we'll cycle it around. We didn't realize initially, but we have to talk about it, so.

It's good. And now it's time to get into today's case. And it's a wild one. It's a huge one. It's a crazy one. And I can't believe that I've never heard about this before we started researching. I know. Today, we're talking about one of America's earliest serial killers. And yeah, she's a real piece of work with a really wild and disturbing story. This story has every bad thing you can think of. And these episodes are not suitable for children. I mean, I know we always say that, but we mean it this time. Okay.

So the woman we're talking about today is known as Lizzie Halliday. And her story was first mentioned for me. How I learned about it was this book I had called Lady Killers, Deadly Women Throughout History by Tori Telfer. And that's how I first found her. And, you know, I said, Johanna, do you know about this woman? And she did. So then we found the biggest source for these episodes, which is a book called Killing Time in the Catskills, The Twisted Tale of the Catskill Ripper, Elizabeth Lizzie McNally Halliday. And that book is by Kevin Owen. I know.

It's like Fresh Hell podcast, Murder, Mystery, and the Macabre throughout history. Like, we have a long title, but we just call it Fresh Hell, right? So Killing Time and the Catskills. I love that the way he titled the book is kind of like when you read an old-timey newspaper. Do you know what I mean? It's like a headline and then a synopsis underneath. I loved it. You get all the information you need immediately. That's right. That's right. And so his book was fantastic. And I also, we dug through so many contemporary newspaper articles from the time, including those by Nellie Bly, who we'll be talking about a little bit later on.

There are, of course, going to be some vagities in the story. It's often the case with these things where they're this old. Some things are sort of wrong. And that's one thing that Kevin Owen points out in his book is how many times we've seen it so many times in the past, right? One newspaper outlet reports something that's wrong and everybody picks up on that. So I apologize if I got any. It would be minor details, but that's on me. So this is a really, really long story. And everything that we've read about it kind of hops back and forth in time. And a lot of what we know about her came out way later in her life.

But there is just seriously so much to unpack here that we're going to go chronologically so that I don't confuse myself. It's so much. And it's all terrible. Okay. Eliza Margaret McNally was the daughter of John and Pam McNally, who together had nine children that survived into adulthood, or at least until childhood. From oldest to youngest, their children were Sam, Frank, John Jr., Rosa Ann, Mary, Nancy, Jane, Martha, and finally our murderer, little Eliza Margaret McNally.

Eliza, who we're going to call Lizzie, was called Margaret by neighbors and Maggie by close friends and family. She's going to have a lot of husbands and her first and last names will change a lot because she also uses aliases. So we're going to keep referring to her as Lizzie, even though we might mention that someone else knew her as whatever. If that makes sense, I hope that makes sense. We don't know her exact birthday. She was born sometime between 1857 and 1864. A lot of things say around 1860, but we honestly don't know. She was born in Ballymena in County Andrum, Northern Ireland. Absolutely beautiful. Beautiful part of the world.

She was the baby of the family, and so she was born after the Great Hunger, which was between 1845 and 1852. This would be an episode all on its own, probably a multi-part episode, but one unfun fact to take from it is that the situation many know of as the Irish potato famine or the potato blight, which did cause around a million Irish people to starve to death. It was preventable, and there was loads and loads of fresh produce, things like butter and meat, that were available and being sent by armed convoy over to England, where nobody was really starving to death. It's a really long, complicated story, but if, like me, you sort of naively thought that it was just this really terrible situation that nobody could prevent, that was not the case. During this time, there was also a huge migration of Irish families who were just desperate to start a new life and get away from a place where they would never have any hope of, what's the word, just building a family. Security. Security, having a better opportunity. That's it, yeah. Better opportunity. Opportunity, thank you.

So between 1845 and 1855, nearly 2 million people emigrated from Ireland to America and Australia, and the McNally family were one of them. Yeah, and as was common at the time, and I think mostly still common today, it looks like her oldest brother and her father went out to America first to establish themselves, to find work and to save wages, and then once they established themselves, to bring the rest of the family over, which makes sense, right? Her father, John McNally, believed that when he arrived in Philadelphia in 1867, he'd have a business opportunity there with a family by the name of Macquillan, who were also from Ballymena. They ran a pub located at 1218 North Front Street. And when John arrived, he found out that there had been a huge miscommunication because he thought he was arriving as a business partner. And he was in for a surprise when he learned that Thomas MacQuillan's wife had died and that they were actually wanting to offer John's wife, who was still in Ireland with the kids, a job as a barmaid earning minimum wages. So this was a blow to John. But he was a man who was used to hardship and disappointment. And so he and his son Sam got jobs at the very busy ports of Philadelphia as laborers working very long, very grueling hours loading and unloading ships.

Philadelphia was, as so many cities at that time, a booming city, and Thomas McQuillen decided to leave his oldest son to run the pub and left the city for the Hudson Valley and settled with his children in the town of Newburgh, located 60 miles or 97 kilometers north of New York City and 90 miles or 140 kilometers south of Albany on the Hudson River. So Sam and John McNally followed them not long after and found the beautiful rolling green fields around Newburgh and it reminded them a lot of Ireland. And so John sent for Pam and the other eight kids to come over and they arrived after a very long trip by steamship. They were reunited in 1872. Lizzie was about eight-ish when she arrived in America. As we said, we don't know really when she was born, but she was somewhere in the area of eight years old. And her life consisted of chores, school, and play.

Her sister, Mary, one of the older daughters, was engaged not long after her arrival. She was marrying a man from a very good family who worked in the lumber business. Lizzie was friendly with and maybe had eyes for Nathaniel McQuillen. But that maybe budding relationship ended in 1879, when the McNally family moved north to Greenwich, north of Albany, east of Saratoga Springs, also near the border with Vermont. In 1880, the population of Greenwich was 3,860. The town of Greenwich was formed from part of the town of Argyle in 1803, adopting the name Greenwich in 1867. One thing that I thought was interesting to note is Greenwich is...

proud of its role in the Underground Railroad. And there's a list of former safe houses there on a marker in a park. So that's kind of fun. I also wanted to thank my friend Mike because he grew up in this area and I wasn't sure how to pronounce Greenwich because it's spelt the same as Greenwich Village. But it is Greenwich and it looks like their mascot might be the Green Witches. Not as cool. Witches. I enjoy that very much. Fun. So yeah, they make that move and Lizzie's around 15-ish and she dropped out of school and now she needs to find herself a husband or a job. And there was no marriage prospect around and so she needed to get to work. And at that time...

It would have meant factory work or because she came from a respectable family, she could get work working as a domestic. So looking for a job, she goes to this wealthy neighborhood and to a very nice home and she starts knocking on the door of Mrs. G over and over again. And every time... The door opens. There's Lizzie claiming that she's going to be a hard worker and she wants her to hire her. Just over and over again, she tells her, I will crawl on my hands and knees to please you. Like, please hire me. And this, it just seems like a nightmare for me. Like, how much would you enjoy having someone bang on your door over and over asking them to hire you? Yeah, I think back in the day, it would have been a huge nightmare as well. I mean, I know it was rather normal in those days to just, you know, go knock on the door, ask if they needed help. But to basically harass the people going there over and over and over again is kind of a huge red flag parade. Like, Barnum comes to town. Right. 100%.

But it works for Lizzie. She's hired. And for the first three weeks, everything is fine. Then, one day, there's some sort of really minor issue with the baking. Something that Mrs. G points out to Lizzie, like maybe the bread needed to be proofed longer. That's a thing I think that happens with bread. Or maybe it was over or underdone. I don't know. Everything I know about bread baking I learned from watching The Great British Bake Off. I don't bake. But, you know, it's just something minor, right? Something, no big deal. The normal reaction would be, oh, I apologize. I'll try not to make that mistake again. Like, no big deal. But what happens instead is Lizzie began screaming and swearing.

at her employer and she screams that she's going to have her arrested. She slams out of the house and she stomps on down. I keep imagining that stompy bird meme. She stomps on down to the justice of the peace and she's fuming and she says she wants to file a formal complaint because her employer has been beating her, that she's been given a bloody nose and that she's regularly being mistreated, which is clearly not the case. This has not happened, right? Meanwhile, back at Mrs. G's home, they're packing Lizzie's things up. But a few hours later, Lizzie comes back.

and puts her apron on like she's going to go back to work. And they basically had to drag her kicking and screaming out of the house and forcibly, forcibly remove her from the home. So that's fun. We have two witness statements about the behavior at this time. Lizzie becomes a frequent client of a local attorney who was actually quite well respected and would later be elected as a district attorney for the area. And he had this to say about Lizzie. I was engaged in no lawsuits for her, but was called upon by her on several occasions to aid her in a collection of balances alleged to be due from the persons for whom she had labored as a domestic.

I think we can be just very grateful that she didn't find herself a slip in Jimmy. sort of attorney but I just love the fact that he's like yeah she kept coming to me wanting to sue people and I'd look into it and be like uh you're wrong they don't owe you anything and she'd be like okay and then and then on with the next thing over and over again that's wild I think that's got that's deliberate I don't I think she knew the difference right had to probably yeah so then we have another quote also from Owen's book which explains some of the lawsuits that she'd used to try to get money from people saying quote a justice of the peace E.W. Mandel for Greenwich New York had Lizzie appear in his court on more than one occasion and recalled her cases quite easily saying I had several dealings with Lizzie Halliday

then known as Margaret McNally. She first appeared in my court in a civil suit, alleging that one David Nichols, a reputable farmer by whom she had been employed, owed her $6.75 for wages. The defendant paid the claim and settled the case, although there is no doubt it was a trumped-up charge. Her second appearance was shortly after this occurrence when she tried to bring about the arrest of Mrs. G, who had employed her as household help and whom Lizzie had charged with assault. She next began suit against the wife of an editor, whom she alleged owed and would not pay the sum of $10 in borrowed money.

End quote. So that second example was the Mrs. G that we talked about that had to drag her kicking and screaming. It's terrible. It's terrible and it gets worse. Another job she had was for a Mrs. M, a preacher's wife in South Argyle, who she was also boarding with. She was known for slacking off and working on her own projects rather than the sewing or knitting Mrs. M was paying her to do. But the way she'd get caught in the act and her employer would say, are you working on your own things? And Lizzie would make eye contact and just calmly switch back to what she was supposed to be doing. Oh, that's so creepy.

That's like just so brazen, you know, like just put down her stuff and pick up the worksheet. The audacity. The audacity. And more importantly, Mrs. M made sure to never let her children alone with Lizzie because she had a bad feeling about her, and later she would of course be horrified to learn that Lizzie liked to get her little girl to go to the basement with her, and once there, she'd threaten her with a butcher knife. Terrible. Terrible. So I think Mrs. M had the right gut feeling there. Her employment wasn't working out well, for obvious reasons, and she decides maybe a husband is the way to go now. After all, her sister Mary had made a great match, so why shouldn't she find someone to take care of her? Her family weren't keen on the idea of her staying at home because she treated all of them actually terribly.

And she was known to physically attack her sisters and even her father at times. And she was burning bridges all over the place left and right with her family members, who hadn't washed her hands off her yet. Her first husband was a man she met in the fall of 1879 named Charles Hopkins. Maybe that was his name. He was apparently a deserter from the British army who had been living under the alias Cat's Pool or Keats Pool Brown. He was a carpenter living in the Greenwich area who was courting Lizzie, who was working as a washerwoman at the time. She's hired and fired a lot, but taking in washing provides her at least with a little bit of income at that time. Yeah, and I don't know why, but...

Charles Hopkins, I sort of imagine this sort of Michael Caine in Dirty Rotten Scoundrels, but older than he was when he made that movie. But this sort of charming British con man is sort of the vibe. Yeah, they met when he hired her to do his laundry. And so he has his eye on this 15-year-old and starts wooing her. But also he was seeing a married housekeeper named Mrs. Campbell at the time, with whom he was running a love scam. Charles was doing carpentry work in the home of Mrs. Campbell's employer, and Mr. Campbell was traveling all the time for work. And so Charles and Mrs. Campbell began an affair.

And over time, he'd convinced Mrs. Campbell to embezzle money from the farmer she worked for and to give it to him. And he told her the reason for this was so that he could get enough money for the two of them to start a new life. After she had gotten about $200, which was horse money at the time, he was ready to end things with her. So he writes Mrs. Campbell this letter explaining that he was a lying liar who lied and who had scammed her for money and that he was unworthy of her and that their relationship was over. Ouch.

Yeah, that's painful. Mrs. Campbell was determined to save their love and she starts appealing to Charles prepared to fight for him. And this catches Lizzie's attention and she does not like it one bit. And wouldn't you know it, Mrs. Campbell was soon found dead in her bed, a bottle of poison on the nightstand. There was no note, but it was ruled a suicide. Lizzie later said that Hopkins had killed her, that he was a bad man, and she had seen him give Mrs. Campbell some poison, telling her it was medicine for an illness. But this would not be the first or last time that Lizzie would blame someone else for her actions. And it is actually believed that this was possibly her very first murder.

Yeah, we don't know if Charles was in on it with her. She would say that he's the one that did it, right? It's possible, but I think most people think that this was all Lizzie's plan because when this happened, Charles seemed visibly upset. Like people who knew Charles noticed that he was struggling with the news of this woman's death, but Lizzie had no, she was just thrilled that she was out of the way. After Mrs. Campbell had died and was sort of out of the way, Lizzie and Charles were married by the local Baptist minister. She was around 15 and he was, we don't know, he's described as considerably older.

Lizzie definitely has a type. Girl has a type. And it is men who seem like they're going to die pretty soon and also have a pension from the Civil War. You need both of those things to catch Lizzie's eye, right? Like if you're just going to die soon, but you don't have anything to leave her, move along. She's not interested. So after the wedding, they moved to Vermont and their first child was born less than a year later, a son that they would name Charles Hopkins Jr. It's interesting to note here that Lizzie's sister, Martha, would later say that her behavior got worse after the birth of her son. This quote is from Owen's book. Quote.

We never saw the first thing wrong until she married Charles Hopkins. She never acted right after her boy was born. She acted so strangely that sometimes I would be frightened. I didn't know what ailed her. By all reports, Lizzie started to show signs of being very moody, irritable, and suffer delusions. She did not live happily with Hopkins and told her sister that he used to get up nights and threaten her life, but that something kept telling her she ought to take care of him. On one occasion, after the birth of her child, she sat mending in Mrs. Allen's house, apparently depressed. She exclaimed, what's the use of living, and tore the dress she was mending into shreds.

She complained at this time of singing in her ears and appears to have had hallucinations of sight. She asked her sister, don't you see that light? There's a light going around the house. Mrs. Allen would get up to investigate, but saw no light. End quote. So one of the things that came to my mind when I read that account immediately, I thought, I wonder if she's having migraines. Because my migraine headaches, and I know I'm not alone in this, these are really common sort of things that happen when you have a migraine. I get ringing in my ears, one ear or both ears.

And I regularly will have an aura, which for me often looks like a floating glowing light that's sort of always drifting around in my vision. And then I'll often get visual disturbances without pain, which are ocular migraines. Those are all common, too. And the other thing that's really common with migraine is mood swings. I generally will get a case of the morbs, right, where I'll just have a day where I cannot stop crying. And I think to myself, like, what is going on? And then boom, the migraine will hit that night. You know, I also once I don't know if you remember.

Last year, I have no sense of time, but we did an episode on something and I couldn't stop laughing. It was like inappropriate, hysterical laughter. And I kept saying to you, like, I don't know why I can't stop laughing. I remember. I don't remember which episode. Yeah. And I remember later, again, in bed with the worst migraine. And I was like, oh, OK, I don't just get the morbs. Sometimes I can get a little kooky. Right. But there's no reason not to assume that a person might feel irrational anger. Right. Moods are includes all sorts of feelings. So I don't know what that issue was. A lot of people think that these are the first symptoms of her mental illness and they might be or they might not be. It's.

It's hard to know, but we can certainly feel compassion for Lizzie here because it seems clear that she was having some sort of neurological condition, whether it was a mood disorder or whatever was going on, which would cause her to lash out and be very physically and verbally abusive. And we know it worsened postpartum, and we know that it was also reported to be worse with her period. And so as a lot of mood disorders are greatly affected by hormonal fluctuation, that sucks. You know, we always feel terrible when people are going through things, and it was at a time when nothing could really help them. But the reason you're not going to hear the same level of compassion for her that you hear from us in some of our other episodes when we are dealing with very clear mental illness is because it's equally clear, if not more so, that she is a conniving sociopath who never feels remorse for anything. She is abusive. She spends her whole life hurting people and ruining their lives. And she absolutely knows right from wrong, right? Her crimes are premeditated. She takes pains to hide her involvement. She makes up these elaborate lies and stories over and over again as just horrific things happen around her.

She'll claim that she just saw the crime, that she's a victim. She was too scared to speak up. She was hiding this sort of thing, right? And you can see why people might believe her. She was a very petite woman, only about five feet tall or 152 centimeters and just over 100 pounds or 45 kilograms, right?

This episode is brought to you by Netflix. Think you know Cinderella? Think again. In the new animated film Steps, the Stepsisters team up for a hilarious adventure beyond the palace walls. Expect monsters, a hot troll, and plenty of family drama on their journey to happily ever after. Featuring Ali Wong, Amanda Seyfried, Nikki Glaser, Bette Midler, and Daniel Radcliffe. Don't miss Steps, coming November 20th, only on Netflix.

Welcome to Brew Crime, a true crime and beer podcast. Join me, Mike. And me, JT. As we explore the world of crime, conspiracies, or whatever catches our attention. This is a podcast where we pick a theme, cover a few cases, and pair them with a brew. Between themes, we do what we call Brew Crime News. A funny look at current news stories, be it crime, animals, sports, or even celebrities. You can find us on all social media at Brew Crime. Our website is brewcrime.com. And you can find us on any podcast app at Brew Crime Podcast. Join us as we discuss the horrible crimes that surround us. And maybe, definitely, tip a bottle or two back as you do it. Drink with us weekly.

She's sometimes described as ugly, but I think that's maybe because of the nature of her crimes. We have a sketch of her that was printed in the papers during her trial much later on. And it does mention that she was forced to do her own hair for the trial. So this first picture of her, Johanna, what are your feelings? The drawing you mean? Yeah, I have the feeling that it's like kind of an act. Yeah.

Yeah. The hair, the wild hair is an act. I think so. Performative. Yeah. And then we also have a couple of photographs of Lizzie. And interestingly, in the drawing of her, she's wearing a striped dress. And I think it's the same striped dress that's in this photograph where she looks like she's tied to the chair, doesn't it? Yeah, it definitely looks like she's tied to the chair. And also the dress could be like an inmate's uniform, right? That's true. That's very true. But she's not unattractive when you can see her in the pictures. She would maybe be played by a young Amy Adams.

Anyway, doesn't really matter. We'll share some pictures with you of her. So now Lizzie and Charles and Charles Jr., they are in Vermont and Charles is working at a brush factory. And not even two years after the wedding, Charles dies suddenly in 1881 under somewhat strange circumstances. Lizzie would later say it was typhoid that killed her husband. Now you might wonder, hold on, Johanna, was it really typhoid? And my answer is, maybe. But here's the thing, the doctor would say that Charles had terrible inflammation all in his throat and lungs, caused by the brush factory, which caused an infection. This death is not considered Lizzie's doing, however.

The doctor also later admitted that Charles had confided in him that Lizzie had threatened to kill him and that he was afraid she was trying to kill him. And one can't help but wonder how similar throat irritation from working in a brush factory and throat irritation from your wife poisoning your tea every day might look. The folks in town clearly thought that she had murdered her husband and so, to avoid the rumors, she takes the rest of the money made from scamming the late Mrs. Campbell and she and her son leave Vermont and move back to Greenwich. There, she quickly meets and marries husband number two. Yeah, Lizzie is working as a washerwoman and she's living with her son over a blacksmith shop.

Rent over the blacksmith shop is a little bit more affordable than other areas on account of the incredible noise and heat. And this is where she's living when she meets husband number two. He is an older war veteran by the name of Artemis Brewer. Artemis had been born around 1841 in the state of New York, and he had been wounded in the Civil War and also suffered from rheumatism and dropsy of the heart. Dropsy was an old-time word for edema or too much fluid around the heart. Way to make a very bad thing sound super cute in a way. I know.

Dropsy of the heart. Isn't that cute? Yes. All I could think of is like one of Peter Rabbit's lost sisters. Like this Easter, everybody, when you tell your kids about Flopsy and Mopsy, don't forget to tell them about Dropsy. She was taken by the neighbor's hound dog. Anyway, so yeah, poor Artemis Brewer. All right. He's described as being unusually short with a large head and very large feet. His beard was unkempt and scraggly. And because of his war injuries, he needed two canes in order to walk. But it was still not easy for him to get around.

He was also addicted to opium pills, which that whole thing had started, of course, as a result of his injuries in the war. So he's probably thrilled to have found a pretty young woman to marry because at this point, Lizzie's 17, maybe 18. And so Artemis Brewer moves in with her and Charlie above that blacksmith shop. And she'll then go on to make the rest of his life a living hell. She was verbally and physically abusive to Artemis. She had been seen beating him with his own canes on more than one occasion.

She also would do this thing where she would hide his opium pills until he did certain specific chores. But the chores she was asking him to do were, like, for example, she'd say, if you go outside and chop that wood, I'll give you a pill. But like, how is someone who needs two canes to stand and walk going to be, you know, chopping wood with an axe? That's not, that's not, it's the torturing him was the point, right? So she was reported to be seen regularly walking at a brisk pace through town with her husband just really struggling to keep up with her, and she'd just scream insults at him. She also used to grab him by the beard and drag him down the street by his beard. It's also at this time that people take note and recall how physically and verbally abusive she is to her son, Charlie.

So about a year after they were married, Artemis dies. And at his bedside with him when he's dying is his brother, Albert Brewer, and his best friend from the war, a man named George Smith. Albert was 10 years older than Artemis, who had been the baby of four sons in their records. In the census records, it looks like their father had died by the time Artemis was eight and that the four boys then grew up with their mother. Albert is not convinced that Dropsy is what caused the death of his brother. And he would go on to make a statement saying that when his brother was dying, he was blue and frothing at the mouth. And he believed his brother had died of an overdose of opium that he believed had been administrated by Lizzie, who was clearly unbothered by the death of her husband. Artemis was only 44 when he died. So now she's widowed again, so single again, and Lizzie's now known as Maggie McNally Hopkins Brewer. That's more names, I think, than Elizabeth Taylor had. No, not yet, but she's getting there. She's getting there.

And husband number three is on the way. It's a man named Hiram Parkinson, who hires her, again, to do his laundry. I personally always have a sweet spot for these kind of old biblical names like Hiram, Ezra, Silas, Sebulon. Yes. I love these names. I'm with you on that. Being a washerwoman is a great way for Lizzie to meet single men, and it would seem she definitely chose a good profession. Hiram tells her that he's a widower with grown daughters. He does not mention that he's already technically married and that he has been living apart from his estranged wife when he woos and moves in with Lizzie over the blacksmith shop.

They are married, and when Lizzie learns that Hiram already has a wife named Ada, she insists they move back to Vermont to get further away from said first wife. This marriage falls apart pretty quickly as Christmas approaches. Hiram tells Lizzie he's planning to go to Greenwich to visit his children and spend Christmas with them. Lizzie says, absolutely not. He insists, but she says that they can't afford it. And he says, yes, they can, and he's going. And so what else is there for her to do but to physically attack him? And he's fighting her off and trying to get dressed, and she's trying to undress him so he can't leave, but he finally is dressed and he's ready to get the hell out of there.

But he realizes that all of his money, which is around $180, and his keys are missing. Hiram is now at his breaking point, and he storms out of the house and returns with the constable and the lawyer. And they confront Lizzie, who admits to taking the money. And she cries, and she says the money is gone, and she's given the money to an attorney of her own. And Hiram tells her he's had it. He's leaving to spend Christmas with his family in New York, and when he returns, he wants her gone. She obliges, and when he does return to Vermont, he finds the house bare. Lizzie has seriously taken every single piece of furniture, every article of clothing, every plate, every glass, every spoon.

Everything. And she sold everything. She left him with nothing. She, in the meanwhile, had made her way back to Greenwich and is staying with her son at a hotel in Greenwich, probably paid for with the money she took from Hiram. And she'd be there for about a month. And she did not leave a good impression. The owner of the hotel said that she was slovenly, that she swore like a sailor and had terrible character. On one occasion, when she saw him giving a lodger alcohol on Sunday and told him if he didn't give her $10, she'd report him. So he paid the money to bribe her. She had arrived over Christmas and the hotel owner's two boys had been given toy guns.

and the kids jokingly pointed them at her one morning, so she threatens to have the kids arrested, and then went to the Justice of Peace and demanded a $10 settlement for this absolute injustice that had just occurred, which, again, he pays just to get rid of her. Yeah. So now it's 1886, and husband number four is a name that we've heard before. You remember when her second husband, Artemis, died? With him was his brother, who thought Lizzie had murdered him, and also with him was Artemis' old war buddy, George Smith. She remembered that George was also a war pensioner, and he worked on a horse farm, and he had lodging as part of his work there.

So she just turns up at his house and she's asking all sorts of questions. And she proposes that she'll take care of the laundry and housekeeping in exchange for a room for her and her son. And he's like, that's great. He probably thinks that he's helping out his old friend's widow, right? And then before long, she is putting the moves on him. Now, he's interested. He's like 50s and she's maybe 20. But he says to her, you know, I really can't be getting involved with someone else's wife because he is pretty sure she had married Hiram and he didn't want any part in getting together with a married woman.

And she tells him that she never married Hiram. But he doesn't believe her. And she swears it's true. And so he says, all right, well, if you swear it in front of an attorney, I'll believe you under oath. And she does it. And as soon as that's done, they are married by the town squire. George had mentioned to Lizzie at least once or twice that he used to have this wonderfully comfortable feather bed, which his ex-wife had given him. And this brings us to Lizzie's first real arrest. Because in July of 1886, Lizzie, who is not completely clothed herself, breaks down the door of Mrs. Mary Berenger.

And I'm not sure if Mary was his ex or if Mary was just storing the bed for George. But either way, Lizzie hits her, knocks her down, and then drags Mary across the floor screaming, quote, by God, I'm going to have that feather bed, unquote. She gets her hands on the feather bed. She drags it into the street and rips it open. And now there's just feathers flying everywhere. And she is arrested for the first time. Like I said previously, she wasn't totally dressed when she did this. And so you have to wonder if maybe he made a comment as they were waking up in bed, you know, like, oh, I miss my old, more comfortable bed.

which I think probably just immediately sent her off in a rage. So then when it's time for her to arrive for her trial, she pretends for the first but not the last time to be quote unquote insane. She acts like she doesn't know what her shoes are, like she walks in barefoot holding her shoes. I think she's wearing her petticoat like tied around her waist over her dress and she stares off and ignores proceedings. And the judge doesn't believe any of this and he thinks it's all an act. And so she is fined and she has to spend 15 days in jail.

So George pays the fines and after her two weeks in jail, George takes her back. She's really abusive to George as well. And you see that familiar pattern that often shows up in abuse, right? Where Lizzie is physically abusive. One instance, she came at him with a pair of scissors trying to kill him. She threw an iron at his head and barely missed him. Like she would literally try to kill him on occasion. But then she'd be so sweet and affectionate and apologetic and they'd just carry on as before. So one night early on, he comes across Lizzie who's going through items in a trunk, which immediately makes me think of candy. So much in that.

what we've been talking about now. Right? So much, so much. And so she's going through this trunk and he recognizes the trunk as belonging to her late husband, his old war buddy, Artemis Brewer. And he says something like, oh, hey, that's Art's trunk. And then he's like, oh, are you holding a stack of marriage certificates? So she hands him one and it's for her marriage to Charlie's father, Charles Hopkins. And then she hands him another one and it's the certificate of marriage between her and his old friend Artemis. And she takes it back and she sort of laughs and goes to put them away. And he's like, well, what's the other paper? And she's like, oh, it's nothing. And he's like, no, I insist. What is it?

And so she gets this sort of diabolical grin on her face and she hands it over. And he opens up the piece of paper and he gets to see for himself that it is the certificate of marriage she had sworn had never happened to Hiram. And so he says, you took an oath. And she just starts cackling with uncontrollable laughter. And she says that she is crafty. And if he knew that she was already married, then he never would have married her. Meanwhile, after spending the holiday with his family, Hiram has gotten back in touch with Lizzie. And Lizzie, who is at that point already sick of George, starts sneaking out of the house to be with Hiram. The first time this happens, George is really worried because Lizzie hasn't come home.

And he goes to the police to say he's worried for his wife. And they eventually come to him and say, she's not missing, she's with Hiram. And this would happen more than once. Over and over, poor George is going to the police, reporting his wife missing. And over and over, they're like, yeah, she's with her other husband. And then one morning, Lizzie makes her husband George a cup of tea. George usually drank his tea black, but she had put a lot of milk and sugar in it. And when he tells her that he doesn't like it that way, she makes him feel bad about it.

that he's ignoring her efforts. And so he's like, well, it's okay. I'm gonna drink it. Thank you for giving me the tea. And he takes a big sip. And very quickly, he feels terrible and he begins to shake and sweat profusely. And he looks at his wife and he asks her if she had just poisoned him. In response, Lizzie looks him in the eye, starts laughing manically, grabs the teacup and runs out the door.

So that's not the reassurance he's hoping for. No, that's not. I see when you ask her, your spouse, have you just poisoned me? That's right. That's the worst, the last thing you want to see. And so he begins to shout for help and he's in pain and he's screaming. And a neighbor hears this and he runs to fetch the doctor. And the doctor arrives and he gives George and a medic. And he began to vomit violently for about half an hour before resting exhausted, but alive. And the doctor tells George that was a close call. And he tells him to avoid drinking or eating anything prepared by his wife. And then the doctor is on his way, which is also kind of... Can you imagine? Listen.

My advice is don't ingest anything she gives to you. You're going to be fine. Yeah, she's clearly trying to kill you. So just don't drink anything her wife gives you or eat. So after two days, Lizzie is back like nothing had happened. And in the book, Annie mentioned before, it says that her attitude and demeanor made him forgive her.

Okay, so, I mean, do we think she was just an absolute dynamo in bed? I know it's the elephant in the room, right? It's a cliche, but there had to be something going on, right? Were there just no other prospects in town? These were fairly decent-sized towns. There are thousands of people in them, not hundreds, so that doesn't make sense, you know? But her husbands, they just forgive the most atrocious things, don't they? Maybe she was just really good in doing the laundry. I mean, yeah, must have been. No, but I was thinking maybe they were all really super serious about the for better or worse part in the wows. But on the other hand...

Some of them had no problem leaving other wives behind, right? Right, that's the thing. Liz definitely must have had something to her that kept the guys around and kept them coming back and kept forgiving her. This is it. And it gets complicated. You think she poisoned you to take her back? She's sneaking out meeting her other husband, the other husband. And she's often described as a bigamist too, but that gets confusing because it's like, but the first guy that she married, he was already married. So didn't that negate? So then that wouldn't have made her married to him. It's true, right? Because technically the marriage to Hiram would have been...

invalidated because he was already married. It all gets very... I just don't know. I don't think that they necessarily kept her around because they felt an obligation, but there's something. Maybe she just really knew how to use the stove and wash clothing, which men back then had no idea. Like cooking, I think, was an all-day thing. Like just getting the stove up and running, right? So not long after they reconcile, George comes home one day. Oh, George. And he finds that the house is locked and he's knocking on the door and calling for Lizzie and there's no answer. And so he has to try to find a way to break into his house through a window. And when he does, he finds that she has left him and taken absolutely everything that she could carry with her.

She had been seen leaving the area with Hiram in a cart and George would never see her again. But at least he survived to tell his story. And I think looking at the time, this is maybe a good place to stop for today because we are just getting started with this story and there is still so much to tell you. We haven't even scratched the surface. This story, man, you're going to love it. I mean, you're going to hate it, but you're going to love it. Yeah. Do you have something good? I did. So last week I mentioned that we were going to be doing something for my sister's 40th.

And we ended up going to this hotel on the Cape that we've just always wanted to stay at. They were having a whole Harry Potter theme thing going on. And so it was really fun with my niece, seeing her and my sister. And we just had such a nice family weekend playing games and doing arts and crafts. And it was great. It was a really, it was a really nice time. How about you? My something good is that today was the first day that at least for an hour, I could open the door to the garden and leave it open because it was so nice and sunny and warm.

And I turned the heating for the house off. And it's lovely. It was lovely. So we're getting there. Yes, it's not that nice here yet. But we do have snow melting. It's above freezing finally. So it's like... I think over the years we learned that we are usually like three weeks ahead of you. At least, yeah. Well, I'd be surprised if we don't have at least one more big winter storm. But it's just been so bad lately because we had the snow rain snow thing. So it's just sheer ice everywhere here. Like two or three inches of solid ice. And I'm so anxious watching.

opus like bambi on ice out there i'm jealous of your warm weather the dogs must be loving it too yeah and i'm i can't wait for having the door open again the whole day because now at the moment it's like it's sunny but cold so they want outside the whole time but then they're cold and they want back in so during the day it's like getting up opening the door leaving them out sitting back down they're barking getting up leaving them back in and it's like a whole day thing oh yes yeah yeah and with ours they don't often don't want to go out at the same time so sometimes opus will go out and it's like oh come on you guys especially when it's cold When it's nice out, they'll both go out together. But when it's cold, they only go if they absolutely have to. So I feel like I get up five times more frequently than I do when it's just nice. Yeah. Yeah. All right.

Yeah, that's it, right? If you enjoyed this episode or any of our other episodes, please do us a huge favor and go to your podcast app that you use. Leave us a rating and or review. Also subscribe. That's also helpful, also for you, because you always get the newest episode. Absolutely. Go check out our webpage, which is thresholdpodcast.com. Our email address is thresholdpodcast at gmail.com. Thank you, Lynette, for your case suggestion. What else? Patreon. Go check out our Cinema Macabre. Check out all the other tiers that we have get-together coming up in March, our monthly get-together. And...

Check out our Facebook group. It's always fun. Fun group of weirdos. And I think that's it, right? That's right. Please tell your pets we said hi, hug them, cuddle them. Still put them a little bit under the blanket if you're living in the Northern Hemisphere. And be kind to them. Be kind to your fellow human being. And the most important and hardest part of it all, be kind to yourself once in a while. That's right. Absolutely. And just remember, if you're going through hell, keep going. Tschüss. Bye.

This episode is brought to you by Netflix. Think you know Cinderella? Think again. In the new animated film Steps, the Stepsisters team up for a hilarious adventure beyond the palace walls. Expect monsters, a hot troll, and plenty of family drama on their journey to happily ever after. Featuring Ali Wong, Amanda Seyfried, Nikki Glaser, Bette Midler, and Daniel Radcliffe. Don't miss Steps, coming November 20th, only on Netflix.

Welcome to Weekly Creep, a mostly paranormal podcast hosted by me, Adam. And me, Gulze. We like to talk about all things strange and spooky. We've covered everything from werewolves to poultry eyes, survival stories, and even a little weird nature because why not? We also enjoy reading listener stories and talking about movies, books, TV shows, and games that we're really into at the moment. Or going to spooky places and chatting about our experiences, like when I may have received a telepathic image of a little ghost girl at the Stanley Hotel. Or when I heard high heels walking around my home in the middle of the night. Anyway, there's over 100 episodes of Weekly Creep already on our feed, so look us up wherever you get your podcasts and get caught up.

Frequently asked questions

How long is this episode of Fresh Hell Podcast?

This episode is 53 minutes long.

When was this Fresh Hell Podcast episode published?

This episode was published on February 28, 2025.

Is there a transcript available for this episode?

Yes, a full transcript is available for this episode. You can read the complete transcript on the episode page.

Can I download this Fresh Hell Podcast episode?

Yes. Use the download control on the episode player to save the publisher-provided media file.