This episode is brought to you by Netflix. Think you know Cinderella? Think again. In the new animated film Steps, the Stepsisters team up for a hilarious adventure beyond the palace walls. Expect monsters, a hot troll, and plenty of family drama on their journey to happily ever after. Featuring Ali Wong, Amanda Seyfried, Nikki Glaser, Bette Midler, and Daniel Radcliffe. Don't miss Steps, coming November 20th, only on Netflix.
Hey there, I'm Suzy, and I'm the host of Beyond the Ferns podcast. Each week, I take you beyond the headlines into the stories that linger long after the news fades, from chilling true crime and unsolved cold cases to paranormal encounters, cults, and extraordinary survival stories. It's a little bit of everything for everyone. Whether you're drawn to mysteries, fascinated by the strange and unexplained, or simply love a good story, I focus on the truth, the details, and above all, justice for the victims and survivors. So buckle up, things are about to get a little scary. Follow Beyond the Ferns wherever you get your podcast. Thanks, y'all.
You're listening to the Fresh Hell podcast. Fresh Hell contains stories of a disturbing and often graphic nature and is intended for a mature audience. Please don't let your kids listen to this or they might turn out like us. Hi, I'm Annie from Massachusetts, where the winters are long and the historical grudges are even longer. I'm Johanna from Austria, land of beautiful mountains, questionable royal bloodlines, and excellent, excellent pastries. And we have more than just Sachertorte. And you're listening to your favorite international podcast, the podcast hosted by two women who think too much information is just the right amount. If we find it interesting, we'll tell you about it. We just happen to be a couple of highly inquisitive ladies, and that's what makes us good at trivia, right? Exactly. Before we jump back in, we wanted to take a moment to say a huge thank you to all of our patrons.
Seriously, you are the only reason that we're able to keep digging into these stories in the way that we do. So, an extra special welcome to our newest Patreon patrons, and they are Tammy Smith, Jared Barton, and Bridget Bauer. Thank you so much. We're just so happy you're here. We really, truly appreciate your support so much. If you haven't taken a look yet, we have a few different tiers on Patreon. Early access to episodes, some bonus content, fresh health stickers, and the occasional strange little surprise.
We also have the Cinema Macabre series. If you want to watch that on Patreon, that is where Johanna and I watch, what's the right word, docudramas about real life cases. So we've so far done the series Candy starring Jessica Biel, as well as the series Welcome to Chippendales starring Kumail Nanjiani. Yeah, join us if you want a recap and breakdown of those. true crime-inspired shows. So if you want to know more about that or any other way, you could support our weird, independent little podcast. Please listen until the end, because that's where we'll tell you all about that. As always, we thank you very much for listening and supporting and just being your very excellent selves. Because now it's time to talk about the trailblazing woman that was Nellie Bly. The biggest source for this episode was, of course, Nellie's own words from her book, 10 Days in a Madhouse. Johanna, what did we discuss in part one? Could you give us a very quick recap?
Of course, and as always, if you haven't listened to part one yet, please go back and do that now. And for everyone else who needs a quick refresher after one week, and I promise I make it super quick. So last time we talked about Nellie Bly's early life growing up in Pennsylvania, losing her father, dropping out of school and refusing to settle for the limited life that was expected of her and of most women around the time. We covered how she wrote a letter to the Pittsburgh Dispatch that launched her journalism career and how she immediately pushed the limits of what women reporters were supposed to cover. She was going undercover to expose working conditions for women in Pittsburgh's factories, for example.
When her editors tried to sideline her to the society pages and Nelly found a way out, she convinced them to send her to Mexico as a foreign correspondent. She spent nearly six months there writing about everyday life, but also about social injustice and even government corruption. Until she criticized the Mexican authorities a little bit too publicly and had to leave the country before they could arrest her. Back in Pittsburgh, it didn't take long for her to realize she had outgrown the dispatch. So she packed up and moved to New York with no job lined up, no real connections, and almost no money. But she was determined to make it as a serious journalist.
After months of rejection, she finally talked her way into an assignment at the New York World, Joseph Pulitzer's New York World. The plan? To fake insanity, get herself committed to the Women's Lunatic Asylum on Blackwell's Island, and to uncover the truth about what was happening behind those locked doors. And that's exactly where we're picking up today. Exactly. Now, before we get into what Nellie Bly actually did inside the Women's Lunatic Asylum, we need to talk about where she was going. Because without that context, it's easy to miss just how dangerous her plan really was.
Blackwell's Island sits in the East River between Manhattan and Queens. Today, it's called Roosevelt Island. You can take the F train subway to the Roosevelt Island station, the Roosevelt Island tramway, or the New York City Ferry Astoria line will take you there. Years ago, we did this on a trip to New York City. We took the tram.
It's really pretty. Once you're there, you can stroll past nice apartment buildings, schools, and a fancy lighthouse. But in the 19th century, Blackwell's Island was basically New York's version of sweeping your human problems underneath the rug. The city used it as a dumping ground for anyone who didn't fit perfectly into the polite, prosperous image New York liked to sell to the world. There was a prison, a borehouse, a charity hospital, a smallpox hospital, a workhouse, and of course, the Women's Lunatic Asylum, opened in 1839 and already infamous by the time Nellie Bly showed up in 1887.
Some of you might remember the term, the name Blackwell Island, because in our Paul and Lizzie Halliday episodes, you might remember that Paul Halliday's second wife, Hannah, died in the asylum. In theory, the asylum was supposed to be a humane place where mentally ill women could go to receive treatment, rest, and hopefully make a recovery. But in practice, it was something much darker. The conditions were horrific. The asylum was constantly overcrowded. It was designed to hold about 250 patients, but it regularly crammed in twice that many. There was almost no heating in winter and no ventilation in the summer.
The food was barely edible, watery soup, dry bread, sometimes spoiled meat. Bathing meant being shoved into ice-cold water, often as punishment, not just hygiene. Medical treatment, quote-unquote, was a mix of heavy sedation, isolation, physical restraint, and what we now recognize as just outright abuse. And the staff? Let's just say that the hiring standards weren't exactly rigorous. Some attendants were, of course, well-meaning, but overwhelmed. Others were downright violent, indifferent, or simply cruel. People who had no business being responsible for anyone, let alone vulnerable women trapped behind locked doors. Yeah, and it's important to remember not everyone in the asylum actually was mentally ill. Many women were perfectly sane, but had the bad luck to be poor, or homeless, or sick, or simply a little too inconvenient. If a woman didn't speak English, for example, she could easily be labeled insane, simply because no one bothered to understand her.
If a husband or a brother or a neighbor wanted a woman out of the way and had the right connections, getting her committed was frighteningly easy. All it took was a single accusation, no trial, no lawyer, no real medical evaluation. Once you were inside, there was almost no way out. And society liked it that way. Middle class and wealthy New Yorkers could go about their lives without having to think about the poor, the sick, or the women who didn't fit. Blackwell's Island took care of the problem and they were out of sight, out of mind. And, of course, there had been some gossip about conditions on Blackwell's Island before Nellie Bly took the assignment. There had been other journalists before Nellie who had speculated about abuses there. Some reformers had called for inspections, but no one, no one, had ever gotten inside to witness it firsthand. The authorities made sure of that. Now, you might be wondering, why didn't someone just walk in and check on the place?
Why did Nellie have to go fully undercover just to see what was happening inside the asylum? Well, in the 1880s, there was no such thing as real oversight for places like Blackwell's Island. There were no laws forcing asylums to let outsiders poke around, no surprise inspections, and zero accountability. Doctors and administrators had total control over who got in, and once a woman was labeled insane, her credibility was gone. Even if she told someone she was being abused, no one would believe her, because after all, she was mad. Mad, quote unquote. That's what the doctors said, and the case was closed. And doctors...
They are authorities and they have to be believed, right? They wouldn't say something that isn't true. The truth was most people didn't want to know what went on behind those locked doors anyway. Mental illness was treated like a dirty family secret. Better to just ship someone off and forget about it. City officials certainly didn't want journalists snooping around there either. That's why Nellie realized that there was only one way to find out what was really happening inside the women's lunatic asylum. She would have to get herself committed. Which brings us to why Nellie's plan was so dangerous. She was putting herself in a place where women were routinely mistreated, forgotten.
and sometimes died without anyone ever asking why. Once she was in, she had to hope her newspaper would actually get her back out again, which was something she had no guarantee of. Because Blackwell's Island wasn't built to let people leave. It was built to keep undesired people confined, and in a way, to make them disappear. We have a few more interesting facts about the asylum itself. The architecture was classic early 19th century institutional design. Greystone buildings, long corridors, barred windows.
Originally, it was run on a Quaker-inspired model of moral treatment. Quiet, rest, and kindness were supposed to be the cure. Doesn't that sound nice? Like, I mean, we can all need some quiet, rest, and kindness, I think. Yes, absolutely. Unfortunately, by the time Nelly got there, the Quaker ideals were long gone.
Patients were often locked in freezing cold rooms, tied to their beds, or forced into quote-unquote seclusion cells. If you acted out, even out of sheer terror, you were beaten, starved, or subjected to even harsher isolation. And many of the women Nellie would meet there were not crazy at all. They were poor Irish and German immigrants who didn't speak enough English to explain themselves. They were elderly women with dementia. They were sick women who had no family to care for them. And once they were labeled insane, that label stuck permanently.
Doctors rarely questioned a patient's commitment. If you were brought in, you must be mad. If you protested that you weren't insane, that of course was taken as further proof that you were insane. Of course, yeah. And the city had no real incentive to fix any of this. As long as the problem stayed off the streets and out of the newspapers, nobody in power cared what happened to the women on Blackwell's Island. And that is the reality Nellie Bly was walking into when she proposed her undercover assignment. She wasn't just risking a bad experience. She was risking her freedom, maybe her life. Because once the system decided that you didn't count anymore...
You are invisible. And invisible people don't get second chances. And Nellie wasn't going to have like a safe word or a secret way out once she was inside. You know, there were just no guarantees at all that the New York world would be able to send someone in to rescue her. Which is a really scary thought. I mean, you have to imagine there was just no way of communicating with the outside. She was all alone.
all this time she was in there. But before Nellie could worry about getting back out, she needed to worry of how to get in in the first place. That meant she had to convince a whole lot of people she was insane. And she had to do it so well that no one would even think to question it. It was in early September of 1887 that Nellie had pitched the idea to the New York World editor. And when she asked her editor how they would get her out of the asylum, he simply replied, I don't know. So basically they said, we have no idea how any of this will play out, but it's fine. Everything's fine. Don't worry. This is fine. One of the editors also told her he was worried that her lovely smile would give her away immediately. So she told him,
Don't worry, she would simply not smile anymore at all. She also remembered that she had read that insane people just stared a lot with big eyes and often without blinking, so she practiced that at home for a few hours. And then it was time for her to find the right place to start her performance. She chose a women's boarding house called the Temporary Home for Working Women, located on 2nd Avenue in New York City. The name sounded promising. Temporary? Working? Women? Perfect. But the reality was grim. It was a basic, cheap boarding house for single women who didn't have much money and often didn't have many options either.
The women staying there were clerks, seamstresses, factory workers, women scraping by on the barest edge of respectability. Many of them lived one mistake away from ending up in the album house, or worse, maybe the asylum even. In other words, not the kind of place where eccentric behavior went unnoticed. If Nelly started acting strangely, people would notice fast. And they'd act even faster to get her out before she scared away the other paying boarders.
And that was actually the whole point. Nellie needed them to panic. She needed them to call the police. And so, once she checked in, she started her act. She stayed up all night, piecing around the shared bedrooms, refusing to sleep. She stared at the other women with white, suspicious eyes. She muttered under her breath that everyone else there was crazy and that she was afraid of them and that someone was trying to hurt her. She didn't shout or scream or cause a huge scene. She just made herself unsettling enough that the normal, exhausted, working women around her didn't know what to make of her. And they didn't want to find out. They felt very uneasy.
But there was one woman, one of the boarders, Nelly later described her as a kind and concerned woman, and she actually tried to help her. This woman, instead of being scared of her or mocking her like the others did, approached Nelly gently, asked if she was alright, and she offered to assist her if she was in trouble or sick. It's a small detail, but I think it says a lot. Even in a place where everyone was struggling just to survive, even when it would have been easier to turn away, someone was there and still reached out. Yeah. She was being kind to another human being, basically. Nelly later said that this almost broke her cover because she had to steel herself, not to respond normally, not to drop the egg and say, thank you.
Instead, she just stared blankly, murmured nonsense, and pulled away. The rest of the women weren't as charitable. They whispered about her, they avoided her. And pretty soon, someone made the decision Nellie had been waiting for. They called the police. And the officers who arrived didn't waste much time trying to figure out what was going on. They saw a young woman acting oddly, talking strangely, refusing to explain herself. All Nellie told the police officers was that she was missing her luggage, that someone must have stolen her belongings, and that she was scared of the women in the house because they were clearly all insane.
The residents and the substitute maiden explained that the woman who called herself Nellie Brown, I think she used the name in the book because she said it would explain the initials on her belongings, the Nellie Bly, Nellie Brown. So they said that Nellie Brown had arrived the evening before without any luggage and that she had acted strangely ever since. And that was good enough of an explanation for the officers. And so she was taken into custody and she was brought to the Essex Market Police Court for examination. At court, the judge decided she should be taken to Bellevue Hospital in Manhattan.
I have to say that apparently Nellie was treated with a bit more kindness and decency than maybe lesser working class women or immigrants might have been treated with in her position because the judge and officers and later doctors saw that she was dressed nicely and had a very educated way of words and speaking. And so the judge thought that she was clearly someone who would be missed by someone who was, in his opinion, from a good family. He even wanted to call in journalists to report about Nellie so that her family could be found. This would have been really disastrous for the whole stint. But Nellie got lucky and they couldn't find any reporters in time.
So instead, she was taken to Bellevue, where Nellie faced a series of doctors, the so-called experts, who were supposed to determine if she was truly insane or not. And if you're thinking this would involve careful evaluation, maybe a second opinion, maybe someone double-checking her story, no. The whole thing took a few minutes. Nellie didn't do anything dramatic. She didn't tear at her clothes or scream or rock back and forth. She kept it simple. She acted confused, scared, wary of everyone around her.
just enough to trigger the biases and assumptions that the doctor already had. I'm starting to think, because remember, like, in cases like Lizzie Halliday, she was overdramatic, right? I'm starting to think. Hear me out. Maybe it wouldn't matter if she would act overdramatic or quiet and scared. Maybe it's just like, hey, this person is clearly weird. I think so. Yeah, I don't think it would have mattered if she was calm or raving. Off you go. They only asked her a few very perfunctory questions. Where was she from? Did she know anybody in New York? Why was she afraid? And her answers were really vague and disjointed.
And sometimes she said that she was from, she lived on a hacienda in Cuba, and then all of a sudden she would just reply with, si, senor. So I guess it's a couple of Spanish words she picked up in Mexico. Of course. I love that. And the doctors, after barely 10 minutes with her, nodded sagely to each other and declared her undoubtedly insane. Oh, look at this. Hopeless case. Danger to herself and others. Let's get her committed immediately.
It was shockingly easy. And Nellie later wrote that what struck her the most wasn't just how quickly they made up their minds, it was how eager they seemed to be to get rid of her. No attempt to see if she had been drugged, robbed, or abused. All real dangers for young women in New York at the time. They simply wrote her off. From the boarding house to the police station to the courtroom, the entire process took about 48 hours. Two days to go from new girl at the boarding house to officially insane girl with a one-way ticket to Blackwell's Island. And to be fair, even though it was exactly what Nellie needed and wanted, it was also terrifying because now that the machinery was in motion,
There was no easy way to stop it. I'd say there was no way to stop it. She wasn't a reporter anymore. She was Nellie Brown, the hopelessly insane girl no one wanted to deal with. While waiting for transfer to Blackwell's island, Nellie had plenty of time to observe the other women locked up around her. Some were clearly suffering. They were scared, confused, lost in their own minds. But others seemed heartbreakingly sane. There were women who spoke lucidly, begged to be released, tried to explain themselves, and were met with cold stares or worse, open mockery from the staff.
One woman, Nellie reported, was a woman who had worked as a servant until she had suffered a breakdown from being overworked. She had lost her position, had moved in with her brother, and this brother, unable to afford to support her, he simply had her committed to Bellevue. She said there was nothing wrong with her mind and that she had tried to explain this to the doctors, but they wouldn't listen to her. That is such a... Like, that is... It's so horrible. Can you imagine? You have a job in a household. You are overworked and abused until you suffer a nervous breakdown from the overwork and abuse. So you go to your brother for a bit to, like, rest and recover and find a new job, and he commits you to an insane asylum. Yeah.
And that basically meant you're in there for life. I mean, I can't... Yeah. Talk about nightmares. Nightmares. The nightmares are coming up because the first night at Bellevue was horrible. There was no heat to speak of. For bedding, Nellie was handed two thin, worn-out blankets. The fact that she was handed two instead of one blanket was already a rare act of kindness, the nurse explained to her, and Nellie realized something chilling. She wasn't just pretending to be trapped anymore. She was really trapped. She tried to keep herself warm in her bed, lying on an oilcloth and wearing only a thin, short, flannel nightgown. Her clothes, they had all been taken away from her before she went to bed.
By the way, an oilcloth was exactly what it sounds like. It's a heavy cloth soaked in linseed oil to make it waterproof. It was usually slapped over mattresses to keep bodily fluids from soaking in, and Nellie later wrote about how the oilcloth felt like freezing cold to the touch and stiff and unyielding and smelling faintly of old oil and dampness, and it didn't warm her so much as trap whatever miserable scrap of body heat she could generate. Imagine sleeping under a raincoat someone forgot to wash, and that's about the level of comfort Bellevue offered. Ugh, miserable. And the food wasn't any better.
Meals were barely recognizable. Thin, watery broth, stale bread, sometimes a piece of spoiled meat that was more gristle than anything else. Hunger gnawed at her constantly, but the smell and taste of the food were enough to make her gag. So the nurses would then offer her a glass of milk and some crackers. During the day, several reporters would be asking for Miss Nellie Brown because the judge back at Essex Market Police Court had ordered that her name be published in the newspapers, just in case any family might come forward to claim her. The son sent someone to check if there was a story there, a missing daughter, a runaway, maybe even a wrongful commitment.
But when the reporter asked the staff about her, they waved him off. Hopeless case, they said. Delusional, dangerous, not worth wasting any time on. Nellie, staying perfectly in character, responded to reporters' questions with the same vague confusion she'd used on the doctors. I'd love to read you just a short excerpt from Nellie's book that made us laugh. Nellie writes, quote, I had hoped to get some rest on this my first night in an insane asylum, but I was doomed to disappointment. I heard someone at the door inquiring for Nellie Brown, and I began to tremble, fearing always that my sanity would be discovered. By listening to the conversation,
I found it was a reporter in search of me, and I heard him ask for my clothing so that he might examine it. I listened quite anxiously to the talk about me and was relieved to learn that I was considered hopelessly insane. That was encouraging. Then came other troubles. All night long, the nurses read to one another out loud, and I know that the other patients as well as myself were unable to sleep. Every half hour or hour, they would walk heavily down the halls, their boot heels resounding like the march of a private of dragoons, and take a look at every patient. Of course, this helped to keep us awake. Then...
As it came toward morning, they began to beat eggs for breakfast, and the sound made me realize how horribly hungry I was. Occasional yells and cries came from the mail department, and that did not aid in making the night pass more cheerfully. Shortly after this, a handsome young doctor made his appearance, and I was conducted into a sitting room. Who are you, he asked. Nelly Moreno, I replied. Moreno is brown in Spanish.
Then why did you give the name Brown, he said. What's wrong with you? Nothing. I did not want to come here, but they brought me. I want to go away. Won't you let me out? He asked me many other questions. Did I ever see faces on the wall? Did I ever hear voices around? I answered him to the best of my ability. Do you ever hear voices at night, he asked? Yes. There is so much talking I cannot sleep. I thought so, he said to himself. Then turning to me, he asked, what do these voices say?
Well, I don't listen to them always, but sometimes, very often, they talk about Nellie Brown. And then on other subjects that do not interest me half so much, I answer truthfully. That will do, he said to Miss Scott, who was just on the outside. End quote. I love it. Do you hear voices? Yeah, I hear them all night long. Everyone's up talking about me. So after several days, two or three, who can say, as days had blurred together in cold and hunger and fear, a transfer to the island was finally arranged. Nellie and a handful of other women were loaded onto a ferry under heavy supervision. The trip to Blackwell's island was short, but for Nellie...
It felt like crossing into another world. Manhattan skyline faded into the mist behind them, and ahead was the looming stone bulk of the asylum. As Annie said before, gray. How did you call that? 19th century, insane, no, institutional architecture? Yeah, 19th century institutional architecture. Gray.
gray, cold, and utterly indifferent. And as the ferry bumped against the dock and the asylum gate swung open, Nellie asked one of the orderlies, what is this place? And he replied, Blackwell Island, an insane place where you'll never get out of. That's kind of mean. It's mean. And I'm sure he also said it in kind of a creepy way. Yeah, I'm sure. At precisely 8.23 p.m., Roger Kwan was not waiting for a table outside his favorite restaurant with his girlfriend, so a passing sports coupe did not splash slash all over her.
making her question why she was dating him. And a second car did not splash her again, confirming her belief. All because Roger skipped it, stayed in, and with the skip app, ordered the best chicken tikka masala she'd ever had, confirming Roger might just be the one. Way to go, Raj. Skip to the good part.
This episode is brought to you by Netflix. Think you know Cinderella? Think again. In the new animated film Steps, the Stepsisters team up for a hilarious adventure beyond the palace walls. Expect monsters, a hot troll, and plenty of family drama on their journey to happily ever after. Featuring Ali Wong, Amanda Seyfried, Nikki Glaser, Bette Midler, and Daniel Radcliffe. Don't miss Steps, coming November 20th, only on Netflix.
So, then she was in. And inside the asylum, the admission process was as impersonal as you'd expect. The women were lined up, stared at, and quickly moved along a mechanical chain of nurses and doctors. No one asked real questions. No one wanted to know if they were scared or sick or desperate to explain themselves. They were just bodies to be catalogued. Nelly later wrote about how, during admission, any shred of individuality was immediately stripped away. You weren't a person anymore. You were a patient number. You were a bad assignment. A mouth to feed. Barely. Then came the initial medical examination. It was quick, cold, and entirely for show.
A doctor who was more interested in flirting with the young nurse than in his patient gave her a cursory physical, a glance here, a nudge there, and once again she was confirmed as hopelessly insane. No serious questions about her background, no careful evaluation of her behavior. The doctors weren't trying to understand the women they admitted. They were trying to move the line along. This also explains this like very...
I mean, they describe it as a medical evaluation or a medical examination, but really, it's not at all. But it does give, I think, more information as to how Lizzie Halliday was able to hide so much stuff on her. Probably. They're not really searching anybody. Although I think with the... I'm still baffled about the Lizzie Halliday hiding stuff on her because that was the sheriff's wife searching her, even. A bunch of... Yeah, there's a few different... That's the kind of... I mean, they would be interested in getting everything off of her, all the weapons and... Yes. You'd think. Just nothing.
The thing about the doctor flirting with the nurse, that part in the book also made me laugh a lot because Nellie Bly describes how the doctor barely looked at her and the nurse was measuring her height. And then the doctor asked the nurse, well, what's the height? And she's like, oh, I can't possibly read it. I don't know how to read numbers. You have to come and look for yourself. And then the doctor and the nurse were constantly like laughing, flirting. I'm like, what the hell? That's the worst kind of flirting. Horrible. Where you pretend to be ignorant about everything. And that's somehow a turn off. I need a big, strong doctor to help her because I'm such a stupid young nurse. Like, please stop. I'm such a silly girl. I don't understand how numbers work. I mean, I maybe shouldn't be the one saying that quote because that's...
fair, but like, you know, I can tell height. I'm sure she was quite capable of reading numbers on a scale. Right. Yeah. So then, once Nellie was officially processed, she was marched into one of the communal wards. I think she was in one ward with 45 other women. And there were rooms, there were some single rooms, and then there were other rooms with up to six people sleeping in there, so there were rows of iron-framed beds. And the windows, they were small and letting in very little light. And the air inside the asylum was so cold. Newly-arrived women like Nellie were thrown into these wards alongside women who had already been worn down by month, sometimes years of mistreatment and neglect. And the atmosphere was heavy with despair. Some women sat silently, rocking back and forth.
Honestly, motionless in their beds, they were just staring blankly at the ceiling. Nellie realized with a sinking heart that this was not a place meant for healing. This was a place where hope came to die. It also became clearer and clearer that her mission was to give a voice to these women who, without a fair trial, had been locked away for life. This wasn't any longer just about exposing bad conditions or writing a shocking story. It was about revealing a system that didn't protect or help the vulnerable. It actively destroyed them. Nellie's mission was to make the public understand that these were not nameless, faceless, quote-unquote, mad women.
These were daughters, sisters, mothers, human beings society had decided were easier to forget about than help. Daily life at the Women's Lunatic Asylum on Blackwell's Island was a routine, if you can call it that, built entirely around survival and submission. Every morning began with the same brutal ritual, the cold bath. There was no warm water, no privacy, no kindness. Also, there were just two towels for 45 women. Oh, and also there were often cold baths in the evening before we were sent to bed.
And I think in her first night in the asylum, Nellie was washed in an ice cold bath and her hair was washed with soap. And then they just put her to bed with soaking wet hair and she was wet under her nightgown. And she said the next morning she woke up and her hair was completely matted. Yeah, the cold baths weren't really about hygiene. You know, these women would be shoved fully naked sometimes into tubs of freezing water and they'd be scrubbed harshly with rough cloth and they'd be made fun of while they were crying and shivering. It was not about cleaning people. It was about control and punishment.
And if you fought back, screamed, or resisted, or even if you just cried too loudly, you were punished even more. And breakfast wasn't any better. The food served to the patients was barely recognizable as food. Most mornings, it was a thin, greasy broth floating with scraps of mystery meat and rotting veg. Sometimes there was stale bread so tough it could chip a tooth. And during mealtimes, women were herded into large, freezing cold dining rooms and made to eat in silence. Any attempt to speak, even if you wanted to ask for more, would earn you a slap or a shove, or worse.
Silence wasn't just encouraged at Blackwell's Island, it was enforced. The rule was simple. If you spoke, you'd be punished. The women sat in long rows, walked silently through halls, sat wordlessly in the day room. Even a whisper could bring you a harsh rebuke. And if you broke the silence more than once, the consequences got harsher. Isolation, beatings, or being tied to your bed. And speaking of freezing, the women in thin clothes were often forced to wait in line in front of open windows for 10 to 30 minutes at a time before they were allowed into the hallways or the dining room or into their wards.
For no real apparent reason at all, except to make them uncomfortably cold. Yeah, yeah. Also, Nelly talked about how other patients would steal your food if you wouldn't be careful. As Annie said, the food was just inedible. She kept saying that nobody could eat the butter, so I'm really wondering what was wrong with the butter. What happened to the butter? Was it just rancid? I mean, you can eat rancid butter if you're hungry. You can. She saw a spider, I'm sorry to say, the spider crawling out of her bread, which is like, ugh. Yeah. What else did she describe? Oh, she says she remembered when she arrived there, she was impressed by how spotless everything was. It was just, you know.
White walls, white floors or light floors. Everything was white and it was all spotless. And she thought, oh, the nurses have to do a lot of work here to keep this space spotless. But then she realized, oh, it's not the nurses doing anything. It's all the patients. The patients were forced to scrub the floors and keep everything clean and to sew and to sew the uniforms for the nurses and these kind of stuff. Yeah. And Nellie saw all of this firsthand. She watched the nurses and attendants and many of whom seemed to take real pleasure in asserting their authority. They would yank their patients by the hair. They would slap them across the face. They would shove them onto cold and hard benches. And the patients were forced to sit there without being allowed to move.
Some of the stuff were indifferent, too tired or overworked, too care. But some of them were cruel in ways that were casual and constant. You know, like schoolyard bullies who had been handed absolute power over people who couldn't fight back. Oh, yeah. It is no surprise that sadists often would seek these kind of employment positions out. Yeah, absolutely. And it's funny. It still happens. I was telling my brother, the cop, about somebody I, an acquaintance of mine years ago, wanted to go into the army and he failed the psych eval. So he tried to join the police, but he failed the psych eval.
So then he tried to become like basically one of these people. All he wanted to do was hurt people. And fortunately, they kept catching the fact that. Oh, that's good. At least. Yeah. At least the system worked there. Yeah. It did. It really did. It really did. But my brother was like, yeah, that happens more than you know. Like there are. Yeah. I'm sure also people who work in meat factories. Right. Well, and I'm sure your husband must experience that on occasion in the army. If you're in the military, you're going to meet people who are in it for. Hospitals. Yeah. Retirement homes.
Like nursing homes where people are really depending on you and there's nothing you can do about it. It's really elder abuse. It's horrible. It's the worst. Yeah. And also on Blackwell's Island, Nelly said that if people complained about the food or that they were freezing cold, the answer would be, well, this is charity and you should be thankful for what you get.
And all of this, this wasn't just about the physical abuse. This was also kind of emotional erosion, the constant reminder that you were helpless, you're voiceless, you're worthless. Every single day from the moment the women woke up to the moment they collapsed into their cold iron beds, the system was working to grind them down. And it didn't take long for Nelly to start seeing the pattern. Many of the women locked up with her weren't insane at all. They were women like her. As we said, poor, isolated, whatever. They were vulnerable.
but who had been accused of madness by whoever. Family members, neighbors, employers, husbands. They wanted them out of the way. Or who were immigrants who had committed the crime of not speaking English fluently. And that's also one of the occasions Nelly describes there was a German immigrant and there was a nurse who very clearly spoke German and the doctor kept asking her, can you translate what this woman says? And the nurse kept repeating, oh, I speak barely German and I don't understand her just because she didn't want to. And this was the German woman. She had been labeled insane because she couldn't answer the questions in English at a court hearing.
Another woman had been committed because she was poor and homeless and had dared to sleep on a park bench. There was no evidence of violence, no delusion. She wasn't a danger to herself or others. She was just inconvenient and nobody wanted to really look at a woman sleeping on a park bench because she's homeless. Nellie also met some elderly women who were suffering from physical illnesses, like arthritis or any mentioned before, dementia, untreated infections, and they had been thrown into the asylum because no one wanted to care for them. Once inside, these women were treated exactly the same as everyone else. They were frozen, starved, punished, ignored, and they wouldn't get any medical treatment. No physical therapy, no medication, nothing.
There was just neglect until their bodies and minds gave out. And of course, the longer they stayed, the worse they got. I mean, that's obvious. Nellie saw women who had been coherent and rational when they arrived, and then they started slowly to unravel. After days of freezing baths and hunger and sleep deprivation and isolation, even the strongest spirits, they crack. Can you imagine going through this for days, weeks, months, years? No. No, I would not do well in this at all.
No. Some women stopped speaking altogether. Some were just rocking back and forth silently the whole day. Some began talking to people who weren't there. And so Nellie realized the real horror of Blackwell's Island. This wasn't a place where people were cured. This was a place where insanity was actually manufactured. You could take a perfectly sane woman, trap her in that system, and within weeks, maybe even days, she would start to completely lose herself. Nellie never lost sight of why she was there. She was working, gathering evidence, paying attention.
Of course, she couldn't take notes for obvious reasons, so she had to memorize everything. Names, schedules, faces, conversations, interactions, the attendance that slapped patients for speaking, the nurses who mocked women who were old or too sick to defend themselves. She counted how many hours women were forced to sit silently on cold benches. She remembered how long it took for the food to arrive, how often it was inedible, how patients who didn't eat fast enough were punished. Nellie also carefully observed the quote-unquote treatments that passed for psychiatric care at Blackwell's Island. There were no therapy sessions, no attempts to diagnose, no rehabilitation. Women who cried were labeled hysterical. Women who protested were labeled violent. Women who did nothing at all, who simply sat and waited, were classified as hopeless without a second thought.
Doctors would breeze through the wards once or twice a day, nodding at whoever seemed quiet, frowning on whoever was difficult, and moving on without really ever speaking to anyone. The nurses in attendance ran the place, and most of them treated the women like livestock. Things to be herded, fed, punished. But I think livestock were maybe treated better, because at least livestock have value. They have value, that's true. Nellie also listened carefully to the other women. She knew that she had to be careful, so she kept her questions simple and she listened more than she spoke. And she trusted that her memory would hold long enough to get the story out once she was free, if...
she ever got free. That was still not certain. That wasn't guaranteed. When it was safe, so when the attendants weren't watching too closely, Nellie would whisper to the other patients around her. She would be asking them how they had ended up there. And the stories she heard, they were heartbreaking. One woman had been thrown in by her husband after an argument, and there was no mental illness, no violence, just the misfortune of being inconvenient to your husband at the wrong time. Another was an immigrant who didn't understand the legal proceeding against her and was declared insane for not answering questions properly. While Nellie was trapped inside Blackwell's Island, the New York world was quietly getting ready to pull the trigger on the second half of the plan, which was obviously getting her out. And it turns out...
breaking into an asylum was way easier than getting back out of one. Joseph Pulitzer's newspaper had assigned a lawyer to arrange her release, but even with political connections, I mean, it's Joseph Pulitzer, right? I know. I mean, I'm not saying that he personally tried to get her out, but he's like the man behind the newspaper that sent her there. But even with all that, with all the political connections, all the people that knew people in the New York world, it wasn't as simple as sending someone over with a note like, hey, could you just release this woman, Nellie Brown? Hi, thank you. Yeah. Once a woman was officially committed, once the doctors had signed the papers and the courts had stamped her as insane, she legally belonged to the asylum, basically. She was under their authority now.
And institutions like the Women's Lunatic Asylum weren't exactly in the habit of letting patients go just because a newspaper sat pretty pleased with sugar on top of it. So the world started by contacting the city authorities, claiming that Nellie, still officially listed as Nellie Brown, had been wrongfully committed and that they had evidence to prove she was sane. They pushed for a hearing, but the asylum wasn't eager to cooperate. Releasing a patient meant admitting a mistake. And if there was one thing the system hated, it was admitting that they could have made a mistake, that they could be wrong. Right. Meanwhile, on the inside, Nellie had no idea how much progress, if any, was being made.
All she knew was that the days were starting to blur together more dangerously. The freezing baths, the silence, the terrible food. It was psychologically corrosive. And Nellie knew that if she stayed much longer, it wouldn't matter that she had gone in sane. Nellie recognized that Blackwell's Island could do the same job to her it had done for so many women before her. It could break her. Back outside in the real world, the newspaper, the world's lawyer, was pushing harder. He managed to arrange a formal hearing in front of a judge, arguing that Nellie Brown deserved to have her sanity re-evaluated. Not because they cared about Nellie Brown specifically.
but because someone important was pulling strings behind the scenes. That is what it took political favors, behind-the-scenes negotiations, and the looming threat of public scandal if the world went ahead and published their story. Finally, after about 10 days locked inside, Nellie's rescue was authorized. Two city officials came to the asylum with orders to bring her back to court. The staff at Blackwell's Island were not happy about it. They stalled. They said she wasn't ready to leave. They insisted that she was clearly insane. But the paperwork was in place.
When Nellie was finally told she was being released, she didn't celebrate or break character. She knew better. She acted confused, cautious, wary, just the way she'd been acting since the beginning. It wasn't until she was outside of the gates, on the ferry back toward Manhattan, that she finally allowed herself to feel it. She had done it. She had survived. And she had the story.
But even in that moment, Nellie wasn't thinking only about herself because she knew exactly what she was leaving behind. She was getting out. But the women she had met inside, the sane women, the sick women, the ones who had no newspaper fighting for them, were still there, still trapped, still at the mercy of a system that would shoo them up and forget them. And I think this is the moment to stop for this week. And then next week, we're going to talk about the publication of her book, 10 Days in a Madhouse. And then we're going to travel with Nellie around the world in a mere 72 days. This woman did a lot. It's impressive. She did a lot. She did a lot.
I told my husband a little bit about her and he was like, that's an overachiever. Yeah, she definitely was. For sure. Do you have something good this week? Yes, I have something. This week I ate my first regional strawberries of this year. Oh, that's exciting. I love them. And they were so, yeah, strawberry season is here. Yay. And that's it. That's my something good this week. Strawberries, they were delicious. They were huge and sweet and smelled like strawberries. Should smell.
You know, this kind of strawberries, I don't know if you have the same problem over there than we have here. So lots of, you know, this kind of, I only buy strawberries during strawberry season, right? Regional. I never, I try to avoid imported fruit. I'm trying to avoid fruits and vegetables to buy it out of season. So I'm trying to stick with that. And anyway, the strawberries that you get out of season here, they taste like nothing, like nothing. They're just water shaped into strawberry form. They don't even smell like strawberries. So I'm always excited for strawberry season. That's why. I understand that. Well, mine is something similar, I guess. Did I talk yet about my colonoscopy? Did I tell everybody about that? I remember saying I was going to have it, but I can't remember if we talked about the results.
So the results were that my, I'm knocking on wood, literally, because my Crohn's disease, I am in my first remission in 20 years. Yay! So good. So I have been very slowly, gradually, like, tippy-toeing back into the world of fruits and vegetables. And I have been eating a lot of pickles, which are so yummy, and grapes, and melon. I've been eating fruit. So, yeah, I'm pretty excited to eat some strawberries, actually. It's been a long time. I hope you're going to get real good strawberries as your first strawberries in a long time. Yeah. Like strawberries are.
Such a treat. And my best friend grows them in pots on her porch. She just has big pots and she grows strawberries in them. My mom has a medium-sized strawberry bed, flower, no, strawberry bed in her garden. And last year she harvested 10 pounds, 5 kilos, a little bit over 10 pounds of strawberries. There's a place on the Cape. Trying to remember now if it's in Orleans or Brewster. I think it's in Brewster, but it might be Orleans. And it's...
There's a strawberry patch where you can, well, there used to be a store called the strawberry patch, which had really, really fun, like handmade crafty stuff and antiques. But then there was an actual strawberry patch and we used to go once a year as kids and just, oh, I used to love strawberry picking and eating all the strawberries. Could you pick yourself? Yes, pick your own. Yep. I used to love to do that as a kid. Yeah. I'm excited. I'm excited to eat fruits and vegetables, everybody. I'm really excited for it.
All right. If you liked this episode or if you just enjoy what we do in general, we would love it so much if you would take a moment to rate and review Fresh All Podcast wherever you listen to podcasts. It's free. It only takes a moment and it really, really helps other people find the show. It also kind of keeps us going. Like if you want to help keep us going, because Johanna can't see a lot of the reviews that are published in the U.S., so I'll always take pictures and send them to her. So we do actually look at all the reviews and it really does make our day when...
You just say hi or tell us something you enjoyed or whatever, you know. Yeah. Also the YouTube comments, the Spotify comments under each episode. It really means so much to us. And now we can even reply to Spotify comments, which is so exciting. It's so exciting. Absolutely. And don't forget to like and subscribe on YouTube. Yeah. Speaking of Spotify and YouTube, you can also subscribe to us on Spotify and YouTube. How would you call that? Subscription? Subscribe to the subscription. You know what I mean? That bonus content stuff where you get early access to our weekly episodes and other bonus content now and then.
And if you want even more of us, if you can't get enough of us, you can find early releases, bonus content over on our Patreon. Just go to patreon.com, search for Fresh Old Podcast. We're going to have our next get-together on 5th of May. That's going to be fun. As Annie said, we finished. Welcome to Chippendale's recaps. And we're now going to start with Inventing Anna. Inventing Anna. And we're going to see where we go for today. That's exciting. If you're interested in supporting us monetarily, but you're not really able to commit to an every month situation, you can totally send us a one-time or as often as you like donation to our PayPal account.
which is freshhellpodcast at gmail.com, and that will get to us that way. I used to be more likely to do that than to join a Patreon when I listened to podcasts, so I just thought I'd mention it. No, no pressure. You don't have to donate anything, but we do appreciate it. You will find all of the links, past episodes, and more about us at freshhellpodcast.com. You can also, of course, email us at freshhellpodcast at gmail.com. We'd love to hear from you. Yeah, all the ways you want to get in touch with us, you'll find on our website.
And if you want to keep up with what we're working on or just hang out with other listeners who are also too far gone to turn back now, come find us on Facebook in the Fresh Health group and or the Fresh Health Facebook page. That's right. Just the nicest group of weirdos on the internet, honestly. Just such a cool group of people. And finally, if you like what you're hearing, the best thing that you could do is tell a friend. Just tell everyone. Tell everyone you know to listen to us, please. Word of mouth is everything for an indie podcast like ours. Yeah. And if you're already working on telling others something, then also please tell your pets we said hi. Hug them, cuddle them, treat them well.
Treat them with kindness. Treat other human beings with kindness. And remember from time to time to treat yourself with kindness, which can be so... Yeah, that part. That part is tough. This is a reminder to check your laundry. You might need to turn that over real quick. And just remember, if you're going through hell, keep going. Tschüss. Bye.
This episode is brought to you by Netflix. Think you know Cinderella? Think again. In the new animated film Steps, the Stepsisters team up for a hilarious adventure beyond the palace walls. Expect monsters, a hot troll, and plenty of family drama on their journey to happily ever after. Featuring Ali Wong, Amanda Seyfried, Nikki Glaser, Bette Midler, and Daniel Radcliffe. Don't miss Steps, coming November 20th, only on Netflix.
Spooky season is almost here, and if you're looking for something a little darker this fall, take a journey into the supernatural side of Japan. I'm Kevin O'Shea, host of Supernatural Japan, a podcast exploring Japan's ghosts, haunted places, strange urban legends, mysterious yokai, cryptids, and some of the darker corners of Japanese history. From haunted tunnels and abandoned ruins to vengeful spirits, bizarre creatures, and legends that have terrified generations, every episode takes you deeper into a side of Japan most visitors never see. So this spooky season, turn down the lights, put on your headphones, and discover Supernatural Japan. Find Supernatural Japan wherever you get your podcasts, and subscribe today.
Japan can be beautiful, but sometimes it can also be terrifying.