Skip to content
E282: Nellie Bly (part IV) episode artwork

May 16, 2025 1 hr

E282: Nellie Bly (part IV)

from Fresh Hell Podcast Hosted by freshhellpodcast

In the final part of our Nellie Bly series, we follow her through yet another reinvention ...as wife to industrialist Robert Seaman and, after his death, one of the first female CEOs in the U.S. We look at her lesser-known interviews with a ten-year-old Helen Keller and the terrifying Lizzie Halliday, and how she returned to journalism under William Randolph Hearst after her business collapsed under fraud and bankruptcy. She exposed corruption in the adoption system, was one of the first female war correspondents during the Great War, fought for women’s legal rights, and quietly placed abandoned children with families from a room at the Hotel McAlpin. Nellie Bly, Nellie Bly podcast, women journalists, WWI correspondent, adoption scandal, Love o’ Mike, Fresh Hell podcast, journalism history, investigative reporting, women’s rights history, Hotel McAlpin, 1920s journalism, forgotten women in history, Nellie Bly death, orphan crisis, legal rights for women

Episode details come from the podcast's RSS feed.

Embed this episode

Ready to play

E282: Nellie Bly (part IV)

0:00 1:00:16
of matches

Transcript Auto-generated, may contain errors

This episode is brought to you by Netflix. Think you know Cinderella? Think again. In the new animated film Steps, the Stepsisters team up for a hilarious adventure beyond the palace walls. Expect monsters, a hot troll, and plenty of family drama on their journey to happily ever after. Featuring Ali Wong, Amanda Seyfried, Nikki Glaser, Bette Midler, and Daniel Radcliffe. Don't miss Steps, coming November 20th, only on Netflix.

Hey there, I'm Susie and I'm the host of Beyond the Ferns podcast. Each week I take you beyond the headlines into the stories that linger long after the news fades. From chilling true crime and unsolved cold cases, to paranormal encounters, cults, and extraordinary survival stories. It's a little bit of everything for everyone. Whether you're drawn to mysteries, fascinated by the strange and unexplained, or simply love a good story, I focus on the truth, the details, and above all, justice for the victims and survivors. So buckle up, things are about to get a little scary. Follow Beyond the Ferns wherever you get your podcasts. Thanks y'all.

You're listening to the Fresh Hell podcast. Fresh Hell contains stories of a disturbing and often graphic nature and is intended for a mature audience. Please don't let your kids listen to this or they might turn out like us. Hi, I'm Annie in Massachusetts, birthplace of Tupperware. And I'm Johanna from Austria, birthplace of the croissant. Allegedly. Debatable. It's not French.

No, it's not. I had no idea. We were the first ones to do a croissant and then the French took it and made it better. Let's see. There we go. See, this is the kind of facts you get with Fresh Hell. And that's because you're listening to your favorite international podcast. The podcast hosted by two women who may never circle the globe in 72 days, but will certainly circle every rabbit hole until someone makes us stop.

And we still have not met. Before we start, we want to say a huge thank you to our Patreon supporters, the newest ones, as well as our long-time supporters. You are, of course, the reason that our indie podcast keeps running. And you're funding things like our hosting on our website, research books, and, you know, the occasional existential breakdown over sources we only find at the last minute. Always! Why is that a thing? Do you also always find last-minute sources that kind of contradict everything you just researched before and took notes for, like, five days? Yeah, sometimes. Sometimes. But then, usually I have enough back info to tell if something's wrong.

Yeah. If you're not on Patreon yet and you like what we do, we'd love to have you there. We've got kind of bonus content, early access, live online get-togethers. How much fun was the last get-together? Oh, so much fun. We did all like top five lists of things that made us happy, movies and music and all kinds of things. And I think next month we're going to do the sad songs. Yeah. We're going to get real into the morbs and we're going to talk about all the things that make us just really cry. So I'm looking forward to crying with everybody next month.

Also, we are now already elbow deep in our newest Cinema Macabre episode-by-episode recap. This time we're tackling, inventing Anna. This is a big one. These episodes are really long. I feel like we're kind of getting into our groove now with the episode recaps. In any case, if you want to take a look at any of this, and of course we're on video for all of this, which...

is fine. I like to be a voice that is not seen, but I enjoy looking at you while we are recording. So yeah, if you're interested, you can check out all the tiers at patreon.com backslash freshellpodcast. And really, truly, again, thank you to everyone who helps us keep doing this really weird little show the way we want to do it. Thank you. Thank you so much. All right, now it's time to wrap up Nelly Bly's life story. Annie, could you give us the shortest recap possible? Of course.

All right, so I'm going to keep this as quick as you did last week. And those of you who still need to listen to episodes one, two, and three, please do that before this episode, because trust me, this woman deserves the spotlight. So in episode one, we covered Nellie Bly's early life. She was born in Pennsylvania, unfortunately lost her father and her stable family life at a very young age. She was ambitious from the beginning and willing to throw hands or at least sharp sentences at any man who said women were only good for sewing and swooning. She broke into journalism by writing a furious letter, went undercover in factories, and then in episode two,

faked insanity to expose horrific abuse inside an asylum. Episode 3 followed her 72-day race around the world with one small bag, no chaperone, and absolutely no tolerance for being underestimated. She beat the fictional Phileas Fogg and her surprise real-life rival, Elizabeth Bisland, and came home a household name. And now? Now we're going to find what happened afterwards. So last week, we left off with Nellie returning from her record-breaking 72-day trip around the world. Headline famous, celebrated, and very suddenly unemployed because not long after she got back, she did something very unexpected. We already mentioned it last week. She quit her job. Now we don't have an exact date for her resignation, but it likely happened within a year or two of her return in early 1890. She was still writing occasional pieces, but the relationship with the New York world had soured.

Nellie had just pulled off not one, but two of the most successful stunts in journalism history, and they still didn't give her a raise, so she walked. But before she leaves the world to pursue her interests, we need to mention the interview she did with 10-year-old Helen Keller. At the time, Helen was already making headlines. Now, depending on where you're listening from, you may or may not be familiar with Helen Keller beyond the vaguely remembered school play or a joke somebody probably shouldn't have told in 1997. But Helen Keller was, and still is, one of the most extraordinary figures in American history. She lost both her sight and hearing after an illness when she was just 19 months old. It was a mystery illness, but it was most likely either scarlet fever or meningitis.

After that, she could no longer see, hear, or speak. So by all the standards of the late 19th century, Helen was written off. Her family, while loving, had no idea what to do. Doctors were mostly useless. No one thought a child with such disabilities could ever be taught, let alone educated. Enter Ann Sullivan, Ann with an E. Herself visually impaired and just out of Perkins School for the Blind in Boston. She arrived when Helen was six, and within weeks, she changed everything. Sullivan introduced manual alphabet fingerspelling, and it was like the floodgates opened.

Her mind had been fully there the entire time. She just hadn't had any key to express it. By age 10, Helen was reading and writing. She had learned Braille and raised print, and she was communicating fluently through touch. And the public was obsessed. The newspapers called her a miracle, a scientific curiosity. Some people thought it was fake. Others just wanted to see for themselves. And that's where Nellie Bly comes in. In July of 1890, she met Helen and Anne in person. Nellie was completely in awe. She described Helen's poise, her confidence, her memory, how the child could repeat entire stories after a single reading.

could instantly connect new words to abstract ideas, and how she clearly understood humor, tone, and even irony. Nellie was amazed that Helen asked questions about the world, that she had opinions. When Nellie asked her what she wanted most in the world, Helen spelled out, to speak like other people. We now know this young girl would go on to do far more than that. Helen Keller eventually became the first deafblind person to earn a college degree from Radcliffe, that's the branch of Harvard for women, in 1904. She learned to speak, wrote 12 books, gave speeches around the world, and became a fierce advocate for disability rights, women's suffrage, labor reform, pacifism, and later in life, even birth control access. Really remarkable. Now, if Helen Keller was one of the most inspiring women Nellie ever interviewed, Lizzie Halliday was easily the most...

terrifying one. We told you all about that in our episodes on Lizzie. In 1894, Nellie visited Lizzie at Medowan State Hospital for the Criminally Insane, where she was being held after one of the most disturbing crime sprees of the 19th century. And as you already covered all of this in detail, we really don't need to tell you more about that today just this much. Even though Nellie kept her cool when she sat across from Lizzie face to face, inside she was left shaken. She later wrote that Lizzie was the most horrible human, the most horrible woman she ever had seen. The way she stared, the way she spoke, the way she shifted from calm to deranged in a blink.

It all made Nellie genuinely nervous. And when Nellie Bly is unsettled, I think that tells you a lot. Yeah. Like if Steve Irwin says to you, now be careful, this thing's dangerous. You're like, okay, well, if Steve Irwin thinks it's dangerous. Exactly. Anyway, this was all after she had already left the New York world. But Nellie didn't disappear into obscurity. She was still famous, still being written about and still getting offers. And like a lot of writers, suddenly flush with name recognition. She did what many of us would do. She tried her hand at writing novels. Actually, she had hoped to use her fame and accomplishments in journalism to launch a serious literature career.

Between 1889 and 1895, Nellie published at least 12 serialized works of fiction. These weren't high literature. They were sensational serialized novels, things like melodrama, romance, crime, scandal, all published weekly and devoured by a massive working-class readership. Titles included things like The Mystery of Central Park, The Secrets of the Street, and Eva, The Adventurous. Now, if you're wondering why you've never heard of most of them, there's a reason. For decades, we only knew about one of them. It's the mystery of Central Park. The others? They disappeared. No cheap paper, mass publication, no preservation. They weren't reviewed, they weren't reprinted in book form, and they absolutely were not taken seriously. Are they literary masterpieces? No. Even Nelly later dismissed them as a kind of writing you do when the bills are due by, you know, churning out fast-paced pulp fiction under the name that still draws in readers. But they're still important, and back in the day, they sold.

And for a few years, that's how she made a living. So here's the thing. As Johanna said, for a long time, everyone just sort of assumed that Nellie Bly wrote one not-so-great novel and kind of left it at that. It was called The Mystery of Central Park. And it wasn't quite Sherlock Holmes or Nancy Drew, and critics have been politely ignoring it ever since. But then, in 2019, a writer named David Blixt, who was researching Nellie, stumbled across something no one expected. She didn't write one novel. She wrote 12. But 11 of them had kind of gone missing. They'd been serialized in a cheap, wildly popular weekly.

called the New York Family Story Paper. This was published by Norman Monroe, the same guy who made a fortune printing her madhouse expose. Nellie signed a deal with him in 1890, reportedly worth $40,000 over three years, which would have been an astronomical paycheck for her at that time. Most star reporters would earn somewhere around $5,000 annually at the time. And Nellie, a woman, it's honestly hard to say what she might have earned, but certainly not as much as her male counterparts. Unfortunately, these stories were not preserved. No one archived them, and they faded into obscurity.

That is, until David Blixt started poking around a British edition of Monroe's paper, a near-identical reprint with the delayed publication, and found the missing pieces. And just like that, Nellie Bly's lost novels were found. Eleven serialized works buried in microfilm across three continents. Toronto, London, Sydney. Barely legible, mostly forgotten. And now, finally, restored. They are pulpy, gothic, melodramatic, and full of cliffhangers. Some are smart, some are silly, but they are 100% Nellie Bly.

clever, angry, emotional, and driven by a deep sense of justice for women who are overlooked, manipulated, or outright discarded. This is what David Blixt says about her debut novel in an article on ignoranceisblixt.com. That's an awesome, really, really good. website name. Quote, how I discovered the lost novels of Nellie Bly. Clearly Bly had hopes for her literary career. Alas, to that point, her record for fiction did not seem promising. Her debut novel, The Mystery of Central Park, had been published a year earlier, first serially in the pages of the world, then in book form. The story was a murder mystery loosely based on her 1888 expose, Infamy of the Park.

While not nearly at the level of, say, Conan Doyle's recently published A Study in Scarlet, Bly's short novel made use of her intimate knowledge of New York and contained the same massive end-of-novel confession that Conan Doyle employed in his first two Sherlock Holmes novels. If Bly had been hoping to make a splash in this new career, alas, it was not to be. Of the four books released in Bly's name between 1888 and 1890, her work of fiction was her least regarded. Today, the mystery of Central Park is ridiculed for its stilted style, thin characters, and rather haphazard plot. Everyone tends to shrug off her novel as an ill-fated endeavor, a bump on the road of her true career, reporting. What strikes me about the first novel, though, is the story of the murder itself. An innocent girl becomes the kept woman of an unscrupulous and ambitious man. When he tires of her, rather than marry her as promised, he murders her and leaves her body propped on a bench in Central Park.

So, yeah, if you want to check out Nellie's novels, they are available. What was next in Nellie's life? What could possibly top exposing the abusive mental health system, racing around the world, interviewing important historical figures left and right, and writing pulp fiction? Well, Nellie, again, did something no one expected. She flew to the moon. No, she got married. In 1895, at the age of 31, Nellie married Robert Seaman, a very wealthy industrialist. He owned the Ironclad Manufacturing, which is a company that made steel containers, like oil drums, milk cans, the kind of thing.

So let's talk a little bit about Robert Livingston Seaman. I wonder if he's any relation to Jonathan Livingston Seagull. Do you know Jonathan Livingston Seagull? No. I'll tell you about him later. Some of our listeners are going to know Jonathan Livingston Seagull. It was a famous book back in the day, I think about a seagull. Wait, is it Jonathan the bird? Yeah, he's a seagull named Jonathan Livingston Seagull.

Oh, it's so sad. I remember the movie. Is it the same one? Probably. I just know it under the name The Movie Jonathan. Maybe. If there's a sad part in it, my family hid it from me. Imagine the way Phoebe Buffay's family hid all the terrible things that happened in Disney movies from her. But there's a movie, right? Jonathan Williamson Seagull. I remember the book. There might be a movie. We're probably talking about the same thing. Yeah. It would be pretty great if we weren't.

So Robert Livingston C. Mann, he was born in 1822, which means by the time he married Nellie in 1895, he was 73 years old, which makes him two years older than Queen Victoria at the time. And a full 42 years Nellie senior, for those of you at home who are too exhausted to do the math. Yeah, that's a pretty big, he's old enough to be her grandfather. He had started out as a working class mechanic and unlike a lot of rich men of the era, he actually earned his money slowly and methodically and apparently without fraud charges, which already puts him ahead of half of his peers. I mean...

So then he founded Ironclad Manufacturing Company, a company based in Brooklyn that specialized in making steel containers. So as I said, milk cans, oil drums, water tanks, garbage cans, you name it. Basically, if it was cylindrical and needed to be indestructible, Siemens' company made it. By the 1880s, Ironclad was doing very well. Siemens had multiple patents to his name, employed hundreds of workers, and he was considered a true self-made industrialist with a reputation for keeping his books clean and his head down. He wasn't flashy, he wasn't scandalous.

He was, by all accounts, a quiet, serious man who worked a lot and avoided public attention. So when he married Nellie, people were confused, to say the least. Nellie had made her name calling out wealthy and corrupt men, which, granted, he was wealthy, but he appeared not to have been corrupt. Also, he wasn't a newspaper man. He wasn't from her social circle, and he definitely wasn't part of the stunt reporting scene. But from all accounts, he absolutely adored her. He respected her. It's sad that he admired her work. He treated her as an equal and encouraged her ambitions, even if they had nothing to do with oil drums.

And despite the absolute jaw-dropping age difference, Nellie was his very loyal life partner. And again, there were no scandals, just, you know, peace, safety. They enjoyed each other companies. Yeah, the important stuff. Yeah, you know. And all through April of 1895, newspapers in New York and Chicago kept speculating if Nellie indeed had a love interest and was about to be married, or was she even already married? And mid-April, Nellie finally admitted that, yes, she was now a wife. This is from the Rock Island Argus, Monday, April 15th, 1895, page one.

Quote, Nellie Bly, now a wife, the well-known newspaper woman married to a multimillionaire. The Morning Advertiser says, Nellie Bly, who is one of the best-known newspaper women in the country, is no longer Miss Elizabeth Cochran. She is now Mrs. Robert Seaman. Her husband is one of the directors of the Merchants Exchange National Bank and a multimillionaire. He lives at 15 West 37th Street and is nearly 70 years old. The marriage occurred on April 5th at the rectory of the Church of the Epiphany on Ashland Avenue in Chicago. Reverend Theodore M. Morrison performed the ceremony. The contracting parties, that's romantic.

The contracting parties had met at dinner in the auditorium hotel two weeks before and conceived an instant attachment. Mrs. Seaman was interviewed by a reporter and said, I cannot deny the rumor. I was married to Mr. Seaman in Chicago. He left the following day for New York. Owing to my business affairs and to his, we both desired to keep it secret for a time. It is his wish, as soon as arrangements are completed, to make a formal announcement of the wedding. Sickness in my own family also caused us to delay its publication. End quote. So the press, of course, had a field day. Many wondered if this was just...

Her latest undercover stint, you know. Can you imagine? Right? Like the original Real Housewives of New York. She's even getting married to go like...

undercover as an industrialist's wife. Yeah, it's true. And so other people also thought that it was her way of escaping the grind of daily journalism. Nellie had been burning herself out. She was getting migraines. She just, she'd hit a ceiling. And there was a man who admired her, had money, and offered something journalism rarely had, stability. This is a snippet from an article that was printed in 1915 in the Imperial Valley Press, Tuesday, January 12th, 1915, page one. Quote, Miss Nellie Gly, Mrs. Elizabeth Cochran Seaman.

is undoubtedly the best-known woman newspaper writer in the world. In 1889, she started out to equal the fanciful record around the world of Jules Verne's hero. She not only equaled Verne's fictitious feat, but she exceeded it. She told about her lively trip in a series of stirring narratives which put her name on the tongue of every man, woman, and child in Europe and America. This was only one of Miss Bly's famous stunts. She met her husband in a curious way, sent to Chicago to study the conditions among the women stockyards workers.

She put on hip boots and slaved with them in the abattoirs for several days. This brought on pneumonia, but not before Miss Bly had written and dispatched the story of her experiences. While Miss Bly was laying ill in a Chicago hotel, Robert Seaman, a New York manufacturer, was also confined there by sickness. He admired Miss Bly's pluck, and she became his wife. End quote. Did Nellie Bly love Robert Seaman?

Hard to say. She never gushed about him in print. There is little personal correspondence to ultimately cast a verdict. But what we do know is she admired his mind, she respected his work, and when he handed her the keys to his company, she took it seriously. It may not have been a love story, but it was a powerful partnership, and they made the most of it. Which brings us to the next chapter, how Nellie Bly became one of the first female CEOs in American history. Because of course she did. She did everything. She did. So after their wedding, Nellie and Robert Seaman settled into his home on West 37th Street in Manhattan.

They even did a bit of traveling. They did a long European trip in 1896, which sounds absolutely lovely. And then in February 1904, something awful happened. Robert, who was now 82 years old, was hit by a horse and a wagon while crossing the street. He survived the initial accident, but never fully recovered. And the trauma triggered further health complications. And so on 11th of March 1904, he died of heart disease brought on by his injuries. And so overnight, Nelly became the head of his company, the Ironclad Manufacturing Company. And not in name only, she was listed as owner, president and chief innovator.

By 1901, so even before Robert's death, Ironclad was already being promoted as, quote, owned exclusively by Nellie Bly, the only woman in the world personally managing industries of such a magnitude, end quote. And that wasn't just a marketing fluff. I mean, of course, they were kind of advertising it because she had a name. Her name was recognized as a brand. Of course, you're foolish. You have to take advantage of every single thing you can in business. At its peak, Ironclad employed 1,500 workers and could produce 1,000 steel barrels a day. And Nellie Bly, who was the famed journalist, the asylum infiltrator, the world traveler, now full-on industrial magnate. At first, things were going really well.

like really, really well. In fact, 1904 was a big year, not just in a negative way because Robert died, but because Ironclad began producing a new steel barrel design that would go on to become the model for the modern 55-gallon oil drum. Yeah, the same you see still everywhere in the US today, seen in countless gangster films or, you know, it's just the right size to stuff a body in. Some sources like to say that Nellie Bly invented that barrel, but that's probably not quite accurate. The patent actually filed by a man named Henry Warehane. So he was one of the company's trusted engineers. Still, it happened under her leadership and she...

absolutely left her own mark as an inventor. Nellie, under her name Elizabeth Cochran Seaman, held her very own two patents. One for a stackable garbage can and one for a milk can with a unique seal. Both useful designs in an industrial world that hadn't really considered sanitation a priority. And on top of that, she hadn't forgotten her moral values and core beliefs at all. She ran the company as a kind of progressive experiment where she implemented progressive reforms. There were paid sick leave, access to healthcare, fairer wages, better working conditions. In the early 1900s, that was revolutionary. I think Henry Ford implemented his famous social benefits program in 1914. So that's a decade after Nellie Bly.

This episode is brought to you by Netflix. Think you know Cinderella? Think again. In the new animated film Steps, the Stepsisters team up for a hilarious adventure beyond the palace walls. Expect monsters, a hot troll, and plenty of family drama on their journey to happily ever after. Featuring Ali Wong, Amanda Seyfried, Nikki Glaser, Bette Midler, and Daniel Radcliffe. Don't miss Steps, coming November 20th, only on Netflix.

Looking for a hauntingly unique podcast this spooky season? Listen to I Talk to Ghosts for chilling ghost stories, genuine in-studio medium readings, and a virtual seance table where the spirits have an opportunity to speak directly to you. Find I Talk to Ghosts on all the fine podcast apps, including Apple Podcasts, Spotify, and YouTube. Happy haunting. But running a steel empire wasn't just about innovation. It was also about trusting the right people. And Nellie, for all her instincts in a newsroom, may not have seen what was coming. Because Nellie was not a numbers person. And numbers are kind of important when you're running a steel empire. You think? I mean...

Yeah. So as biographer Brooke Kroger put it, quote, Nellie was hopeless at understanding the financial aspects of her business. End quote. She just trusted the wrong people and eventually they robbed her blind. Hundreds of thousands of dollars quietly siphoned off by her own managers. That is Arabian steeds on heirloom carpets eating croquembouche money. This is just, it's too much. By 1911, ironclad manufacturing was tangled in an ugly bankruptcy litigation. The company collapsed under the weight of fraud, debt, and illegal bills. And Nellie never saw it coming.

And just like that, Nellie lost everything. She was broke, the company was gone, her fortune embezzled out from under her, and she was left with a name and not much else. But if we've learned anything about Nellie over the past episodes, I think we can safely say that Nellie was not into self-pity. And so, in her late 40s, an age when most women of the era were expected to disappear into a shawl and a rocking chair, Nellie Bly did something she hadn't done in nearly two decades. She went back to journalism.

Now, this wasn't the New York world anymore. Her old stomping grounds had changed and she'd burned a few bridges along the way. But William Randolph Hearst still knew a valuable name when he heard one. Johanna, I know the Hearst dynasty is another one of your interests. Are you going to end up doing a William Randolph Hearst episode someday, maybe? You know, every time I hear William Randolph Hearst, I always think of...

That's such a weird combination in my brain, but Citizen Kane and Citizen Kane's mansion, Xanadu, and then I hear Olivia Newton-John, Xanadu. Sorry for the singing. Xanadu for me is, oh God, what is it? The Rime of the Ancient Mariner and Xanadu, Koblikon, the Pleasure Day of the Creed? Yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah. Exactly, yeah. Oh, God. Pet interest, yes. But not only William Randolph Hearst, also George, the patriarch of the Hearst family, and of course, Patty. You know, I actually do not know that much about the whole thing with Patty Hearst, so I'm officially requesting an episode because that's a lot to talk about.

All right, so let's just get into the quickest of explanations as to who this William Randolph Hearst was. He was basically the original media tycoon, decades before Rupert Murdoch or Jeff Bezos bought their first headlines. Yeah. Born in 1863 to a wealthy mining family, he took over the San Francisco Examiner and turned it into a sensation. Then he went national. By the early 1900s, he owned more than two dozen newspapers and magazines and radio stations would follow. And then eventually...

What's next? Movie studios, of course. His style was loud, emotional, often manipulative. He's often blamed for pioneering what we now call quote-unquote yellow journalism, you know, sensational stories, dramatic headlines, and just enough truth to keep him and his newspapers from being sued. He also ran for office multiple times, but never quite got there. He was obsessed with fame and influence, and when Nellie Bly needed a new home for her writing, Hearst hired her. And say what you will about Hearst, and believe me.

I think we will when the time comes, but he understood that Nellie had something to say and that her name was still worth something. So he brought her on board at the New York Evening Journal and gave her column space. But this time, Nellie wasn't doing stunts. She wasn't faking insanity or hunting down girl-stealing procurers in Central Park, something she actually did at the height of the ripper craze. This time, she was pulling her focus back on social injustice, especially where it hit women and children the hardest. She wrote columns about unwed mothers being treated like criminals. She investigated adoption rackets.

where children were sold or swapped like cattle. She covered orphanages, poor houses, and the abuse of working-class women, calling out powerful men who let it happen or profited from it. She also did something she'd never really had the chance to do in her younger career. She started writing about herself. She shared memories of her early reporting days, her childhood, and the bizarre things people had sent to her in the mail after her trip around the world, including, apparently, an offer to be queen of an island nation. She also started showing up for something she hadn't reported on during her world days, the women's suffrage movement.

By the 1910s, suffrage had moved from whispered salon topic to marching in the streets national fight. Women were protesting, organizing, getting arrested, and making headlines. And Nellie was right there with him, not just covering the movement, but advocating for it. She went to suffrage parades. She interviewed organizers. She wrote essays about the sheer idiocy of denying women the vote after letting them run households and teach children. In one column, she asked plainly, quote, can anyone give a reason why women should not have the right to vote? And then followed it up with a long list of reasons why they absolutely should.

She wasn't just pro-suffrage. She was annoyed that it was even still being debated. But she really brought something important to the conversation, too. Visibility. By the 1910s, many of the younger suffragists didn't remember her early stunts, but older readers did. She was famous. And fame meant reach.

And unlike some of the more elite suffrage leaders, Nellie had spent her career writing for working-class readers. She knew how to talk to people who weren't hosting fundraisers or sipping tea in white dresses. She could take the high ideals of suffrage and bring them down to the ground, to the factory girl, the shop clerk, the single mother with no safety net. She reminded women that their lives already were political, even if no one had ever let them vote. She made it clear, women's rights were no longer an issue for the next generation. They were urgent, immediate, and deserved the same fierce reporting she'd once reserved for correct asylum doctors.

or intelligence officers scamming young servant girls. I think we can all agree that by the time the Great War broke out in Europe in 1914, Nellie Bly had already lived several lives. I mean, journalist, novelist, industrialist, bankrupt, back to writing as a columnist. But the one thing she had never done, yet, was to be a war correspondent. That spring, she traveled to Austria, not to chase a story, but to sort out some business issues connected to her late husband's company. And as it turned out, she walked straight into one of the most explosive moments in modern history. Because while she was there in Austria,

On 28th of June, 1914, the Austrian Archduke Franz Ferdinand and his wife were assassinated in Sarajevo, which, as we all now know, lit the match for what became World War I. And if you haven't listened to our episode on the Habsburg tragedies, especially the second part about the assassination of Archduke Franz Ferdinand, I absolutely urge you to bookmark it because the whole story is wild and it's still one of my favorite episodes that we ever did. Yes, and it shows up all the time on Jeopardy. I can't even tell you how often. I mention it all the time that if you listen to our podcast, you're well suited for a lot of Jeopardy questions. But the assassination of Archduke Friend Ferdinand is a biggie. Like the whole Habsburg, like all of it. Such a good episode, Johanna. So Nellie was in Vienna when the assassination happened in Sarajevo, and it was pretty clear that this would lead to war. And so, of course, Nellie did what Nellie always did. She stayed. And when the war began in earnest that fall, she sent word to the New York Evening Journal, the Hearst paper that had been publishing her work ever since her ironclad days.

And they gave her a new title, Special Correspondent, and she became one of the very first American women to report from Europe's Eastern Front. She was embedded in Austrian Galicia, that's now Poland, and she sent dispatches from cities like Przemysl, which at the time was a fortress under siege. From there, she wasn't writing about military strategies or heroic speeches, she was writing about the realities of war. On the ground, in the mud, the shell fire, the rain, the chaos. She hid in trenches, she was caught in bombardments.

She traveled with officers, artists, editors. She was in this kind of strange little caravan of wartime observers trying to survive long enough to file the next copy. And back home, American readers followed her updates under headlines like, hides in trenches as Russian shells rain about her, or nowhere to hide and as slippery as ice. She described valleys strewn with bodies, soldiers unable to be buried because the shelling never stopped. She wrote about doctors so overwhelmed they couldn't treat anyone properly, you know, just triage and move on.

Nelly also visited the field hospitals and witnessed the gruesome reality. In Budapest, she found a military hospital where ten languages were spoken across the wards, and the nurses came from five different countries. It was part battlefield, part barbell. Dying soldiers were quietly moved to soundproof rooms so their cries wouldn't terrify the others. She told the story of one man, a Russian prisoner. He'd been shot, left in a trench for eight days, both feet frozen solid. They fell off, basically fell off on the train right to the hospital, and when Nelly arrived, he was barely alive. His legs were gone, his body was failing, and he was asking for his children.

And she couldn't stay in the room because it was just too much for her to take. Another man, she wrote about, had taken a shrapnel to the face. His jaw was shattered in 32 places, hanging in pieces against his chest. And the best the hospital could do was try to hold it together with, like, wiring. Yeah, and these were just the ones that actually made it to a hospital. And one of her more furious dispatches, Nellie asked, quote, how could emperors, czars, and kings look on this slaughter and ever sleep again? End quote.

Well, because they're not looking at it, are they? Yeah, it's just numbers on papers they get every day during breakfast, basically. War changes people, and it changed Nellie too. She had seen pain, poverty, and injustice before, but this was something else. This was systemic devastation. As a natural consequence, she began to question the purpose of the war. She began to write about the waste, about the politics of death, about how thousands of men were being destroyed, not for victory, for nothing. In January 1915, she filed one of her most heartbreaking reports and ended it with this.

Quote, travel the roads from the scene of battle, search the trains, wounded, frozen, starved thousands are dying by agonizing torture. Not hundreds, but thousands. And as they die, thousands are being rushed into their pest-filled trenches to be slaughtered in the same way. Oh, we Christians. End quote. This woman, who had spent decades trying to believe in human progress, was deeply disillusioned by the horrors of quote-unquote modern warfare.

Her writing contributed to the growing anti-war sentiments in the U.S. And while it didn't keep America out of the war, it absolutely added to the voices saying, don't rush into this. Look at what it actually is. Oh, and at one point, Nellie was suspected of being a spy because, of course, she was. Of course. This is from the Chronicle Tribune from Friday, January 15th, 1915, and was printed on page 5. Quote, Miss Nellie Bly arrested a spy. That rhymes. I like it. It does. Enjoys thrills.

World's most famous newspaper woman describes experiences in Hungary. Second of thrilling narratives. Quote, Satolya Cevilceli in Hungary, November 6th. I have been arrested as a British spy. I had not gone 10 yards into a churchyard until one officer stopped and spoke to me. I could not understand his words, but I inferred from his motions that he wanted to see my papers. I had none. They were all in my bag at the station. Being pocketless is the greatest hardship a woman has to endure. Amen. So true. I tried to make him understand where my papers were. He looked suspicious. Another joined him.

They discussed my case. I did not know whether to stand still or walk on. Crowds began to gather. Two gendarmes with naked sabers and Spanish feathers in their caps pushed through to hold back the increasing mob. Everybody was excited except myself. I was enjoying the new experience. I studied the faces of the mob as the officers and gendarmes endeavored to obtain information from me. They spoke Hungarian. I spoke Americanish.

We did not make rapid progress. I was not in the least fearful of the crowd. The market stalls were deserted. Buying and selling had ceased. I was the only object of interest. When I caught the eye of a woman, I would smile. An answering and sympathetic smile would be returned. The men smiled less quickly and then in an awkward, embarrassed manner. Between me and loyalty, they were a little undecided. Only the officers and gendarmes were fierce. Grave and determined, no smile answered mine. Finally, they motioned for me to proceed. Two, placing themselves before me, two behind. A woman darted from the crowd to my side. She laid a sympathizing gentle hand on my arm.

She looked at me with kind black eyes. You are American, not English, she asked brokenly. I am, I said, patting her trembling hand reassuringly. I knew, she said, confidently. The two gendarmes took her by the arm and tried to pull her away. She spoke to them in eager appeal. They listened impatiently. They say you are a British spy, she finally said despairingly. I am from New York, I explained. Tell them I am with the Kriegspresse people. Our train is at the station and our crowd is somewhere in the village. Her explanation found no belief. They are very queer here now, she apologized, but you must go with them. I will stay by you.

I lived in Cleveland once. I love Americans. End quote. What a lovely woman. And brave, really, to intercede like that in a situation. So after covering the war, through mud, blood, and heartbreak, Nellie Bly finally came home. It was in 1919, and she had expected to return to, I mean, maybe not comfort, but at least her own home. Instead, she found out that one of her brothers had taken everything. The house, what little money remained. All of it was gone.

legally gone. She'd left New York with a little money, and she returned with even less. And so, once again, she did what she always did when the world tried to shove her off stage. She got back to work. She returned to the New York Evening Journal and picked up right where she left off, writing opinion columns, social criticism, human interest pieces. But this time, her focus had sharpened. She wasn't just angry about poverty or injustice. She was angry about the law, about how easy everything she owned could be taken, how a lifetime of work and struggle could be erased. So again, she started writing about legal reform, especially for working women. And in the middle of all of this, she did something even more unexpected. She adopted a baby.

It started with the story that made the papers in December of 1919. Someone left a seven-month-old baby boy at Grand Central Station, bundled up with a note that read, quote, to somebody, for the love of Mike, take this kid, give him to Nellie Bly. He is seven months old and healthy as they make them, end quote. The press, of course, went wild. They dubbed him, Love a Mike. The baby was taken to Bellevue Hospital, and when Nellie Bly heard, she rushed to visit him. The public response was immediate. People offered to adopt him. One couple, the Wences, even came forward claiming the baby was their son, who had been kidnapped months earlier. It made a great headline. But it wasn't true. Because when Nellie wrote about the situation publicly, compassionately, the baby's biological mother came forward. She explained that she had left him there in hopes that Nellie would find him a better life. She wasn't unloving.

She was desperate and wanted more for her child. You might wonder why the mother would have asked for Nellie to find a new home for her son. Well, even back in the 1880s, she had often written about orphans and adoption and the trafficking of children that sometimes went with it. One of the articles she had written for the New York world in 1889 was entitled Nellie Buys a Baby. The article started with the following, quote, I bought a baby last week to learn how baby slaves are bought and sold in the city of New York. Think of it, an immortal soul bartered for $10. Fathers, mothers, ministers, missionaries. I bought an immortal soul last week for $10, end quote.

So this is a topic that had always been very close to Nellie's heart, and after she returned from Europe, Nellie had quietly started helping to place orphaned and abandoned children with families personally. From a room at the Hotel McAlpin, she ran what was essentially an informal adoption agency. People sent her letters asking for help adopting or surrendering children. She interviewed families. She made decisions. She tried her best to keep siblings together. This wasn't for publicity. There was no agency backing her. It wasn't a nonprofit. There was no funding. It was just Nellie doing what she could do to fill the gaps that the system refused to address. And then she formally adopted a child herself, a boy whose name we don't know, but she gave him a home. She was nearly 60.

She had pneumonia more than once. She had very little money, but she was still trying to take care of someone else. That was the final shape Nellie's activism took. Not fame, not headlines, not stunts. Just, you know, showing up quietly for the people who needed it. In December of 1921, she filed her final column. A few weeks later, she got sick again. This time, she didn't recover. Nellie Bly died on January 27th, 1922, of pneumonia at the age of 57.

She didn't leave a fortune. She didn't have a big funeral. But she left behind a body of work that never stopped pushing for something better. She told the truth, even when no one wanted to hear it. She fought the fights most people didn't even know existed. And she never stopped asking the question that launched her career. What are girls good for? And then she spent the next 30 years answering it, better than anyone else ever could.

And so this is it. This is the final part of Nellie Bly's life story. Well, part of it. There would be a lot more to talk about, but we think if these four parts have piqued your interest, you can go down a whole huge rabbit hole of your own. Of course, we're going to link to the sources we used, and there are so many books, documentaries, other podcasts to listen to. You name it. There's a lot out there. Yeah, absolutely. All right. What a woman. That's also my something good for this week. It was such a joy for me researching.

the life of Nellie Bly because, you know, I think most of us know a little bit here and there, but not the whole picture. I didn't know the whole picture. And researching a person who did so much in her life is so inspiring. And I also found, and that's why something good, I found what a role model she is still for many young children today because there's so many young girls who dress up for Halloween, for example, as Nellie Bly in her famous travel coat and the bag she had. And I think it's amazing. I love it. I mean, she died more than a hundred years ago and she's still an inspiration and a role model and a trailblazer. Absolutely.

That's kind of like, I feel like you researching Nellie was sort of like when I was researching Garfield. It's like, oh gosh, there's more. Like I have to put, wait, there's more. There's still more. Yeah, that's right. And it's also something, I mean, we research the most horrible, horrible things humanity has to offer. Yes, we do. Garfield's story and Nellie's life story, there is a lot of tragedy and a lot of horrors in there, but there's so much good in there that just gives you hope. Yeah, you don't want to lose sight of the good. How about you? What's your something good?

It was just my birthday this past weekend. Thank you. I know. I'm 48. Amazing. Yeah. It's... I don't know. I guess I never thought I'd live this long. But thank you so, so, so much to all of the people who left me. Just the nicest little messages. I really appreciate it. Yeah. That's just really lovely. Paul had some cousins who are in town from the UK who I enjoy their company very much. And so we just had a really low-key weekend. We went for a drive on Sunday. We went for a...

for a nice long drive, which was just beautiful weather. So we took the convertible and just went for a pretty drive. It was really nice. I enjoyed it. So it was just a nice weekend. That's all.

Isn't that sometimes just the best? The best, yeah. The convertible is new to us. Many, many moons ago, when my aunt passed away, she had a little bit of cash left in her stuff. So my mom and my sister and I used that money to buy a used convertible for my dad, who had always wanted to have a convertible. But he worked as a social worker, so he just drove very, very simple basic cars. He took such excellent care of his sister-in-law, my aunt, all those years with her illness that we were thrilled to be able to get that for him.

And then just recently, it's starting to get hard for him to get in and out of it. So it's in our garage now, just so it's not sitting for too long. That's a story for another time. Maybe on Patreon. I have a video of us surprising my dad with a car. Kind of a highlight moment. I love it. He deserved it. He did. And it was great because like the last several years of my mom's life, like she really wasn't very mobile. And so it was nice, you know, like even if she couldn't really do anything, he could put her in the car and they could go for a drive and listen to music.

Yeah. All right. I think that's it. That's everything. If you want to support the show, you know the drill. Please leave us a rating, write a review on the podcast app you use, tell your weird, history-loving friends about us, maybe also your normal friends. They might enjoy an episode or two. You'd be surprised. So often people will find out that I have a true crime podcast and they'll immediately say, oh, no, I don't like, I don't like murder, I don't. And I say, no, no, no, that's not...

That's not really what we do. I mean, we do, but that's not... That's not all we do. That's not all we do. Yeah. You can also subscribe to our show on your favorite podcast app. Please, please, please like and subscribe to us on YouTube. That really helps our algorithm. And come say hi on Patreon if you would like some early access to our regular episodes, bonus content, and some other really cool perks, including Cinema Macabre. It's new. It's where we talk about truly questionable true crime miniseries and documentaries and reenactments with our full chests.

Sometimes on display somewhat. It's fine. And our outfits are on theme most of the time. That's right. But yeah, if you just want to come say hi, email us or come hang out on Facebook, we'd love to hear from you. Thanks as always for supporting this very, very independent, very stubborn little podcast. So stubborn. So stubborn. We just won't quit. That's right. We need to write a book. Well, two. One with recipes and one traveling book. Yeah. We probably have enough. I keep thinking we have enough to just write a book. Yeah.

All right, please tell your pets. We said hi. Hug them, cuddle them. Treat them kindly. Oh, update from Cem. We went for his annual checkup. It's been one year since we discovered Lefora. And he's doing as well as he can under the circumstances. He still didn't have epilepsy episodes, just his tremors. His dose has been increased and he got two other medications. But the doctor said it's, well, it's, you know.

It's what it is, but he's doing well under the circumstances. Good. Good. Be kind to your pets. Be kind to your fellow human being. And also, sometimes, be kind to yourself. That's the hardest part, being kind to yourself. But do it. Please. For us. We'd appreciate it. That's not a question. That's an order. That's right. You have to be nice to yourself or I'm going to be so mad at you. So, yeah. Just remember, if you're going through hell, keep going. Tschüss. Bye-bye.

This episode is brought to you by Netflix. Think you know Cinderella? Think again. In the new animated film Steps, the Stepsisters team up for a hilarious adventure beyond the palace walls. Expect monsters, a hot troll, and plenty of family drama on their journey to happily ever after. Featuring Ali Wong, Amanda Seyfried, Nikki Glaser, Bette Midler, and Daniel Radcliffe. Don't miss Steps, coming November 20th, only on Netflix.

Hey, new to Spirits Uncorked? We're Elizabeth and Erica, and this is what happens when you take a sister's group chat, turn it into a paranormal podcast, and add wine. Not sure where to start? If you love good, true ghost storytelling, check out episode 12, Personal Encounters on Lake Linear Part 2. If you love historical mysteries with a touch of nostalgia, listen to episode 45, Rasputin's Curse and the Last Romanoff Princess. Yes, that one takes us back to our childhood. Whether you're here for the ghosts, mysteries, or wine in conversation, we want you to join us. Search Spirits Uncorked wherever you're listening now.

I got two over the list. And add wine. I'm like, Jesus. Like, you don't have to sound evil. I just have to do it one more time. That's all.

Frequently asked questions

How long is this episode of Fresh Hell Podcast?

This episode is 1 hour and 0 minutes long.

When was this Fresh Hell Podcast episode published?

This episode was published on May 16, 2025.

Is there a transcript available for this episode?

Yes, a full transcript is available for this episode. You can read the complete transcript on the episode page.

Can I download this Fresh Hell Podcast episode?

Yes. Use the download control on the episode player to save the publisher-provided media file.