When a child is in hospital, a lot can change for the whole family, but you can help. Round up your order total to the nearest dollar at a McDonald's drive-thru, front counter, kiosk, or with your mobile pickup order in the McDonald's app. And the difference will be donated to Ronald McDonald House, giving families with sick or injured children what they need to stay in their child's fight. So when it feels like everything changes, the most important things won't. Make your next visit to McDonald's a feel-good moment by rounding up at participating McDonald's restaurants in Canada. App download and registration required.
This episode is brought to you by Netflix. Think you know Cinderella? Think again. In the new animated film Steps, the Stepsisters team up for a hilarious adventure beyond the palace walls. Expect monsters, a hot troll, and plenty of family drama on their journey to happily ever after. Featuring Ali Wong, Amanda Seyfried, Nikki Glaser, Bette Midler, and Daniel Radcliffe. Don't miss Steps, coming November 20th, only on Netflix. You're listening to the Fresh Hell podcast. Fresh Hell contains stories of a disturbing and often graphic nature and is intended for a mature audience. Please don't let your kids listen to this, or they might turn out like us.
Hi, I'm Annie from Boston. And I'm Johanna from Austria. And you're listening to your favorite international podcast. The podcast hosted by two women from different continents who never met in real life, but who still keep track of each other at all times. It's true. I mean, I think we start to worry if we haven't heard from each other in more than 24 hours. Definitely. Yeah. I don't think, not even when you're on vacation, I don't hear from you for more than 24 hours. No, no, no. Yeah, it's wild. So before we get into today's episode, please allow us to give a huge, huge, huge shout out to our newest patrons.
Sean Gibbs and Aaron Beveridge. Thank you both so very much for your patronage. We really appreciate it. Thank you also to James H. for your PayPal donation and very kind words. We appreciate it very much. Do you love the podcast and want a little bit more fresh hell in your life? Well, you can support us on Patreon. We post extra content, early access, some behind the scenes rambling and the occasional mildly cursed surprise. It helps us to keep doing what we do, primarily researching the strange, the macabre and the forgotten. Just thank you. Thank you. We honestly would have had to completely stop this after.
A year of sort of losing money as a hobby, you know, so you help us break even and we are just so grateful. Thank you. Thank you so much. So much. We really appreciate you. All right, Johanna, what are we going to talk about today? Would you like to tell them?
Yes, I would love to tell them. First of all, let me start by, I think I've mentioned it several times, I myself am Catholic. Annie, who is now agnostic, an agnostic humanist, was born and raised a Catholic. Yeah, once a Catholic, always a Catholic, as my late mom would say. But no worries, please, this episode will not be a religious deep dive. We're not going on a mission here. No, that's right. Nothing like that. No, unlike CCD, there will be no test after that.
However, we will take a look at what happens behind those closed doors where the divine authority meets a lot of human ambition, I'd say. We gotta tell you a lot today. From the corpse of Pope Formosus being dragged to court, to smoke signals and conspiracy theories, this is the dark and weird history of the papacy and the Vatican in general. That's right. Because on 8th of May 2025, white smoke rose from the chimney above the Sistine Chapel, signaling to the world that a decision had been made. Habemus papam. We have a pope. So what exactly is a pope?
Well, the short answer is he's the Bishop of Rome, the spiritual leader of over 1.3 billion Roman Catholics. And according to church doctrine, the successor of St. Peter, who, legend has it, got the job directly from Jesus. St. Peter, or Petrus, as we refer to him, was one of the fishermen that followed Jesus, you know, as his apostle. And Peter was famously the guy who denied Jesus three times and still somehow got one of the most important positions in the Roman Catholic Church.
Fun fact, his name wasn't always Peter or Petrus. Simon was his original name, but according to the Gospel of Matthew, Jesus gave him the name Peter from the Greek word Petros, meaning rock. You are Peter, and on this rock I will build my church. From that point on, Simon became Simon Peter or just Peter and was positioned as the foundation, the rock of the early church. He became the first bishop of Rome, which eventually made him the prototype for every pope that followed. In the end, Peter was martyred in Rome, allegedly crucified upside down because he didn't feel worthy to die the same way as Jesus Christ did. And today, allegedly, that's what we believe as Catholics, he's buried beneath St. Peter's Basilica. That's right.
The early popes were mostly martyrs, bishops of a persecuted underground church under Roman rule. But everything changed in the 4th century when Emperor Constantine legalized Christianity and eventually converted. By the end of that century, Christianity became the official religion of the Roman Empire, and the papacy became a political force. During the Middle Ages, the pope wasn't just a religious figure. He was the head of state, often richer and more powerful than kings. Popes crowned emperors, launched crusades, collected armies, and excommunicated monarchs. At one point, the papal states controlled a good chunk of central Italy, and popes regularly got dragged into local wars and dynastic feuds. Some of them were genuinely holy men. Others were absolutely not. The Renaissance gave us some of the most colorful popes in history, like Pope Alexander VI of the Borgia family.
whose papacy was soaked in scandal, nepotism, and suspicious deaths. By the 19th century, the papacy's political power had largely faded. The papal states were absorbed into the New Kingdom of Italy in 1870, and the Pope retreated into the Vatican, declaring himself a prisoner. That standoff lasted until 1929, when the Lateran Treaty between Mussolini and the Church established Vatican City as an independent, sovereign state, a tiny, self-contained country as it remains today. Since Peter's days, 266 popes have officially followed him. The exact count gets a little messy depending on how you handle the anti-popes, the rival claimants to the papacy, usually installed during times of political or theological chaos. But the Vatican's list stood at 266 until the beginning of this month when a cardinal from Chicago was announced as successor of Pope Francis and therefore the 267th pope under his chosen name, Leo XIV.
Robert Francis Prevost is the first U.S. American to hold the papacy. And by the way, he also holds Peruvian citizenship. I think he speaks, is it five languages? I think something like that, yeah. Yeah, definitely. He did a lot of missionary work. Missionary work. I thought it was also interesting when I was watching all of the Pope, the papal coverage. You know, I was on, I just had the news on watching it the whole time. And one of the things they were saying a lot over here, I don't know if you heard it over there, I imagine it wouldn't be something that would have come up. But before the decision was made, people were saying, well, it won't be an American because they decided a long time ago it could never be an American because...
you wouldn't want to risk combining the strength of the American military and also being the head of the church. Like, that would be too much power. But happy to say, I guess things have equalized a little bit. Yeah, I don't think the pope doesn't hold that much political power anymore as he used to back in the day. Right. And, you know, I'm glad to say that the last two popes, it seems like their most political statements are just praying for peace, which...
Who's going to disagree with that, right? But we are here for the long, long ago stories, the history of popes that have long turned to dust for the sort of creepy and crazy and not so crazy conspiracy theories and legends all surrounding the Vatican. And there are so many stories. We couldn't even pick like 1%. That's just too much going on. If you've ever looked at modern society and thought, wow, this is all kind of a crazy circus going on at the moment, I'd like to gently inform you that in the 9th century, the Catholic Church literally put a dead pope on trial.
And I mean an actual legal trial in a basilica with a corpse. So let me tell you about the Cadaver Synod, or if you want to sound fancy, the Synodus Horrenda, a name that, yeah, translates roughly to horrible synod. And for once, that's not an understatement. It's really not. This is terrible. So when we talk about corruption in the church, people usually think of money and power and politics, which it is. Don't get me wrong. But what they don't usually picture is a pope putting another pope on trial, a dead pope.
dug up, dressed in papal vestments, propped up in a courtroom. And this truly happened in Rome in the year 897. And it's considered by many historians to be one of the most grotesque episodes in papal history, which is no small claim, I think, considering all the competition of crazy stories. That would be an interesting, like, top ten list. Top ten, yeah.
All right, so let's start with the man at the center of this controversy. It's Pope Formosus. Before his election, Formosus had served as a bishop of Porto, and he was also sent abroad as papal legate, acting as a diplomat for previous popes. He had a reputation for being very well educated. He was politically savvy and not afraid to get involved in kind of imperial power struggles. This would eventually come back to bite him in the butt. In 1891, he was elected pope. And at the time, there was an ongoing conflict of who should rule the Holy Roman Empire. On one side, we had Arnulf of Carinthia.
was a Frankish king with backing from German nobility and on the other hand was Lambert of Spoleto, an Italian nobleman with very powerful family connections in Rome. So both wanted the imperial crown and whoever the pope endorsed had obviously a very clear advantage. And Formosus chose to support Arnulf and he invited him to invade Italy and later crowned him Holy Roman Emperor in early 896. So that move placed him in direct opposition to the Spoleto faction that did not forgive easily. And only a few months later, Formosus died. And you'd think, okay, that's about it to the story. But it was not. Because the political fallout was just getting started. Formosus' successor, Pope Bonifatius VI, lasted only two weeks before dying under circumstances that were, depending on Jesus, either natural or extremely convenient for some people. And after Bonifatius came, Stephen VI, a pope who was politically aligned with the pro Spoleto faction. So the same one Formosus had opposed. Stephen had no interest in letting Formosus rest in peace.
Less than a year after Formosa's death, Stephen had his predecessor's body exhumed from its tomb in St. Peter's Basilica. It had been about more or less nine months. So the body was reportedly in an advanced state of decomposition. And I think there's no surprise there. No, that's too soon. There's a real window, I have to say, if you're going to exhume somebody. I think there is for sure like a sweet spot probably. And it's not nine months. Formosa was dressed in papal robes and placed on a throne in the Basilica of St. John Lateran. I mean, I think it's nice to put on nice clothes on him and place him on a throne at least.
It could have been worse. Let's keep it at that. It could have been worse. Also, it was very nice. He kind of got a defender, a defense attorney. He was assigned a deacon to speak on his behalf. Do you think that job was kind of that people really wanted to do that? I think not. I'm not sure. I think that's the kind of position where you're just like on the wrong side either way. But is there that no such thing as bad publicity? No, but I think if you speak for somebody who you know is...
Dead? No, not dead, but the people who want to put him on trial obviously hate him. Oh, I see. And are also the ones who are in power. I think it's a very dangerous position and not a very thankful job. No. No, I should not think so, no. So anyway, the body was accused of having assumed the papacy illegally, of having been the bishop of two places at once, so Rome and Porto, and of violating church law by leaving the post to become pope. But honestly, these were not uncommon infractions in the 9th century, and they had never warranted a posthumous trial before.
But Stephen VI's real objective wasn't justice, it was erasure. If he could invalidate Formosa's entire papacy, then every decision Formosa had made, including the appointment of bishops and the crowning of Arnulf as emperor, would be nullified. So this was a very strategic, retroactive purge. Surprise, surprise, the corpse was found guilty. His papal garments were ripped from the body, the three fingers used for blessings were cut off, his body was reburied in a common grave and then just for good measure it was dug up again and thrown into the Tiber River.
And if you think that this whole thing just went over without anyone opposing it, you are wrong. People in Rome were actually outraged. Formosa's body washed up at the riverbanks. Some claimed that even in death the former pope was performing miracles. Riots broke out in Rome and the public was horrified. The nobility was very uneasy because they don't like people rioting and the clergy were deeply divided on the matter. Stephen VI didn't last long after the synod. He was deposed, imprisoned and strangled to death in his cell later that same year.
And in his place came a series of short-rained popes, some of whom reversed the cadaver synod, only for others to later reaffirm it. Formosa's corpse was eventually reburied with proper rights and the church later passed laws to prohibit future posthumous trials. Do you know these signs you sometimes see mostly on the internet, but also sometimes in real life that say stuff like absolutely no sword fighting in the elevator or microwaving your shoes is not allowed even if they're wet? And you wonder what the fuck happened here to make this sign necessary in the first place? Yeah.
If you could please not bring the deceased and decomposing into the courtroom while wearing ceremonial robes, that would be super. So good. Thank you. Also, from a modern viewpoint, it is so, so crazy to hear and think about all the times popes just died under very mysterious circumstances. And of course, speaking of mysterious, sudden and unexpected deaths, there's just no way we do not at least briefly talk about Pope John Paul I. Just very, very briefly.
Because in the long history of the papacy, few deaths have inspired as many rumors, conspiracy theories, and whispered accusations as the passing of Pope John Paul I. He had been pope for just 33 days, the shortest papacy in modern history, when he was found dead in his bed on the morning of September 29, 1978. Officially, the cause of death was a heart attack, but the circumstances surrounding it left just enough gaps, just enough inconsistencies, to keep the speculation alive. And for some, those speculations never really stopped. He was born Albino Luciani in Italy in 1912. Warm, humble, and pastoral, he was known as the Smiling Pope, but he was also, according to many Vatican insiders, planning serious reforms. He had spoken openly about addressing corruption in the Vatican Bank, confronting financial secrecy, and reassigning or removing
several high-ranking officials, some of whom were deeply entangled in the Vatican's banking affairs. And that's where the theories begin. The Vatican Bank was in serious trouble in the 1970s, linked to illegal transactions, mafia money laundering, and the scandal-ridden Banco Ambrosiano. The head of the Vatican Bank at the time, Archbishop Paul Marcinkus, was already under scrutiny when Pope John Paul I became pope. There are claims that Luciani planned to remove Marcinkus and others just days before he died. What deepened the suspicion was the Vatican's handling of the death itself. No autopsy was ever performed. There were conflicting reports about who found the body, what time it was discovered,
and even whether the Pope was wearing his glasses and holding papers when he died. These details may sound trivial, but for a highly ritualized institution like the Vatican, the lack of clarity was unusual, and it invited questions. The most famous account fueling the conspiracy came from David Yalop, whose 1984 book, In God's Name, claimed John Paul I was murdered to prevent him from exposing corruption. Yalop implicated a network involving Vatican officials, Freemasons, and Italian business figures. The Church dismissed the book as fiction, but it became an international bestseller. Was he murdered? There's no definitive evidence. But the Vatican's secrecy, its refusal to allow an autopsy, and its own internal power struggles gave the story enough oxygen to endure. The timing of his death, just as he was supposedly preparing to make sweeping changes, made it honestly look very suspicious. And then, of course, all of us Gen X Catholics know John Paul I's successor, John Paul II, who was pope for over 26 years. That was a long papacy, a very long papacy. It was.
At Desjardins Insurance, we know that your real estate business requires coverage that matches your unique needs. That's why we can help you save more when you insure multiple buildings under one policy. So you can spend less time managing insurance and more time with your clients. Get insurance that matches your business. Request a quote today at Desjardins.com slash business dash insurance. Certain conditions apply.
This episode is brought to you by Netflix. Think you know Cinderella? Think again. In the new animated film Steps, the Stepsisters team up for a hilarious adventure beyond the palace walls. Expect monsters, a hot troll, and plenty of family drama on their journey to happily ever after. Featuring Ali Wong, Amanda Seyfried, Nikki Glaser, Bette Midler, and Daniel Radcliffe. Don't miss Steps, coming November 20th, only on Netflix.
And just because you mentioned that John Paul I's papacy was the shortest one in modern history, and it's interesting because in the olden days, in the medieval times and renaissance, that was way more common. And the shortest papacy in the history of the Vatican or in the history of the Catholic Church was Pope Urban VII, and he held the position as Pope or the Bishop of Rome for 12 days. Wow. Can you imagine? Oh, congratulations, you're Pope. Oh, now you're dead. Must have been tough. I laughed longer than that at the gap.
Yeah. Yeah, there's truly no shortage of dark chapters in the history of the papacy. There are power struggles and corruption and murder. And the occasional course trial, it's all been done. Plenty.
But through it all, there's been one very consistent theme, and that's the complete and total exclusion of women from any kind of meaningful authority within the church. I mean, don't get me wrong, women could be saints, they could be mystics, martyrs, abbesses, visionaries, but they could not lead, they could not preach, and they certainly could not wear the ring of the fishermen. Or could they? What if a woman disguised as a man would have ended up as the bishop of Rome? Could such a thing ever have happened? I am of course speaking of the story or the legend of Pope John.
The novel Pope Joan by Donna Wolfo Cross was first published in 1996. And if you're Gen X or older, and if you were even remotely curious about hidden histories or women who'd been conveniently edited out of the narrative, you probably read that book. The story takes the medieval legend of Pope Joan that a woman disguised herself as a man and rose through the church hierarchy to become pope in the 9th century. And it reimagines it in richly detailed historical fiction. It follows Johanna, born into a very brutal and superstitious world that has no patience for an intelligent girl at all.
She teaches herself to read, outsmarts her tutors, survives raids and personal loss. And eventually she enters a monastery disguised as a man under the name Brother John Anglicus, before she ultimately rises to the highest office. The book became an international bestseller, translated into over 30 languages. I was completely obsessed with the novel when it first came out. I think I devoured it in a weekend. And for me, as a young woman, late in my teenage years, the possibility that there might have been a female pope, especially one with my name, that was fascinating to me.
And of course now I know that the novel was historical fiction and it took a lot of liberties. Back then I didn't really care. Of course now Annie and I always want to know what is what, so let's talk about what's actually behind the story of Pope Joan, the myth, the medieval records, the inconsistencies, and the very strange endurance of a figure who may have never existed. Did you read the book? I have not read the book. You did not? No, I don't think I did. I don't think I did. And now I'm like, oh, should I? But you heard about it, right? I have definitely heard about it. Yes, absolutely. So the most common version of the legend says that sometime in the 9th century, a highly educated woman, often identified as Joan or Johanna, disguised herself as a man, entered religious life under the name John Anglicus. Some accounts place her origin in England, others in Germany, in Mainz. Still others say Athens.
We all know medieval sourcing was not what you'd call rigorous. Yeah, she was from away. She was from away. She was not from Rome. She was not from these parts. She's not a local. Because of her intelligence and her love for learning, she rose through the ranks of clergy and then she was elected pope sometime between the reigns of Pope Leo IV, who died in 855, and Pope Benedict III. Her reign supposedly lasted two years until her true identity was discovered in the most dramatic way possible. She gave birth.
In public. During a procession. According to the more brutal version of the legend, the crowd turned on her immediately because oh my god, she must have been a witch. She was dragged from the streets and killed on the spot. Other versions say she was removed quietly, imprisoned, or sent to a convent. Either way, her name was allegedly erased from papal records. Now, the earliest known written version of the Pope Joan legend appears in the 13th century, about 400 years after her supposed reign. It's found in the chronicle of Jean de Méli, a Dominican monk in Metz who included it in a compilation of papal history. His version was short and offered no name, but it laid the groundwork. But it laid the groundwork. A woman disguised as a man who became pope and was exposed when she gave birth.
A slightly more detailed version appeared soon after in Martin of Opapa's Chronicon Pontificum et Imperatorum. So this version gave her the name Johannes Anglicus, said she was English and placed her reigns squarely between Leo IV and Benedict III. So Martin of Opapa was a Dominican friar working inside the papal curia. His chronicle was copied and translated into multiple languages and in short, this version of the Pope Joan story was considered credible, or at least credible enough to be included in what was essentially the church's official historical timeline. Once in circulation, the Pope Joan legend took on a life of its own.
And by the late Middle Ages, she was not only part of popular histories, but also of visual culture. There were statues of popes in the Siena Cathedral carved in the 15th century, and allegedly it included the statue of Johannes VIII, Femina de Anglia. That statue is long gone and historians disagree about if it ever truly existed. And if so, what it actually might have depicted, but some think it was a statue that depicted Pope John. The legend then was repeated by major chroniclers, including Jan Hus, Petrarch, Boccaccio.
Protestant reformers in the 16th century picked it up and ran with it, like Martin Luther cited Pope Joan as proof of the corruption and fallibility of the Catholic Church. So basically she became a rhetorical weapon. She was often framed as evidence that Rome could not be trusted, especially when it came to authority and truth. They made it possible that a woman became pope and then they basically lied about it. So don't trust the Catholic Church. Don't trust Rome. It didn't help that for centuries the Vatican's own official papal list contained confusing or inconsistent numbering of popes named John, skipping numbers or listing John XX, even though no such pope had ever reigned.
I agree it looked suspicious, even if it was probably just a bookkeeping error. Let's be very clear here. There is no contemporary evidence of Pope Joan's existence. There are no papal documents, no letters, no coins, no inscriptions. Her name doesn't appear in any official Vatican source until the 13th century, by which point it was clearly legend. And yet, some elements of the story just won't die. There's the famous claim that after Joan, the church instituted a ritual involving a very special chair with a hole in the seat through which a cardinal would verify that the new pope was, in fact, male. The existence of such a chair is real.
There is a 15th century example with an open seat that exists in the Vatican museums, but there's no record of it being used for any inspection of the kind. Then there's the claim that her procession route was altered, that future popes would avoid the spot where she gave birth. And again, this is purely legendary. There's no documentation supporting any papal detour or banned streets. The Catholic Church has officially dismissed the Pope Joan story as fiction for centuries. So basically the Vatican says she never existed. Most modern historians agree, but the way the story was told allowed to circulate and was kind of half-heartedly suppressed.
It kind of created exactly this, what did I want to say? It created this kind of atmosphere or this kind of perfect setting of ambiguity that keeps people asking questions. It's a really interesting legend. I think it would capture the minds and hearts of a lot of people. You just mentioned the infamous chair with a hole in it. So, listeners, once again, here we are with a mystery chair.
Officially, it's called the sedia stercoraria, and allegedly it's a stone or marble seat with a large conspicuous hole in the middle. People believed it was used during papal coronations to check, physically, that the new pope was, in fact, a man. The story goes that after the scandal of Pope Joan, a cardinal would reach into the chair, feel around up there, and then in Latin, he would say, testiculos habet e bene pendentes. Translation, he has testicles. And they hang well. I feel like I can feel another t-shirt request coming on. Just the Latin. So, the Vatican, of course, denies that this ever happened. And what do historians think? Well, that chair might have been a reused Roman birthing seat. Or a toilet. But it's not the only curious item or weird ritual in the Vatican. You know there's more. It's the Vatican. Just ask Robert Langdon. It's fascinating. It is honestly...
I would love to know. It's much in the way people think, they wonder about what does America really know about Area 51? What does America really know about anything around the world? I mean, anything around the whole world. Maybe the Vatican actually does know. You know? The Vatican to old history is what the United States is to modern history when it comes to secrets or hiding things, in my mind. Yes. Yeah. So there's also, we need to talk about, the Roman Catholic version of Maxwell's silver hammer.
So sometimes you'll hear that when a pope dies, the Camerlengo gently taps his forehead three times with a silver hammer, and he calls his name just to make sure he's really gone. So like, tap on your head. Hello? Tap. Are you really dead? Tap. Peter, are you in there?
But don't get too excited. There's no solid evidence this was ever a real ritual. No official record, no confirmed instance. The part that is real? The Camerlingo does call the Pope's name aloud to declare his passing. No hammer required. But to be fair, the whole protocol of everything that needs to be done when one Pope dies and another one is elected is just vague and secretive enough that it leaves enough room for speculation and rumors. There could absolutely be a silver, like, zombie check hammer. Like, excuse me.
It's possible. But even if nobody tap, tap, taps on the deceased Pope's forehead, there is one thing that absolutely gets smashed with a hammer. Me. No. Sorry. And that's the papal ring. Every pope receives a gold signet ring called the Ring of the Fishermen in honor of St. Peter. When the pope dies or resigns, the ring is ceremonially destroyed with a hammer in front of the cardinals. It is very dramatic, for sure. Yes, like, he's dead. Now let's smash his belongings. That's right. No, there's a very, very practical, real reason for doing this, because, of course, the ring was once used to steal documents. And destroying it ensures that no forged papal orders are issued in the awkward in-between period known as Sede Vacante. Literally.
I'm going to start calling my shower the room of tears. And they say women are being emotional and dramatic. I know. But they're crying, some from spiritual overwhelm, others probably from the sinking realization that they now have to run a global institution with 1.3 billion people and zero days off. It's a tremendously important position, regardless of what your particular beliefs are. And I think the other thing that's so striking is you take a new name as you become hope. So you're kind of saying goodbye, in a way, to who...
You were before, aren't you? Like you take a new name, you have a new identity, like you are transformed by this right. Absolutely. No, I get it. It must be overwhelming. Oh, yeah. And also, most ways, I mean, there have been popes who kind of resigned, like the last benedict. But for most popes, it's like, okay, I'm going to be doing this until I die.
Like this is it. Was Benedict the first to resign? In modern days. In modern days, yeah. But it happened a couple of times. You know what I find most fascinating or most intriguing? It's the Vatican secret archive. 100%.
Granted, it's not technically secret. I think the name just comes because in Latin, the secreto means private or set apart. And it's fine. It's fine. The Vatican private archive doesn't sound as cool, though. So they renamed it to the Apostolic Archive. But just like Twitter, most people still think of it as the secret archive. And there are records not intended for the public, or at least not until the church decides you're ready. And the church almost never decides you're ready. The archive contains over 53 miles of shelving with documents dating back more than 1,200 years.
It includes state papers, papal correspondence, and so much fragile velum. So much. Too much. You know they have, like, human skin books, too. Because, like, if Harvard has them, there's no way the Vatican doesn't. Yeah. I wonder about the stuff that was, like, yeah, like when we get into the woo-woo of things, you know, like things that were...
confiscated and things that were, you know... All the witchcraft, demonic, satanic things. Yeah. Like, what are they if... I kind of... This is what I used to wonder. If the US government is hiding the truth about aliens from us because they don't think we can handle it and they think we'd lose our minds and panic, what is the Vatican keeping from us? I mean, if there are demons... I mean... In case you didn't guess already, you can't just walk into the secret archive. You have to be a credentialed scholar. You have to submit a formal request. And even then, you're monitored while viewing the material. There's no photography, no scanning. Pencils only.
obviously no food or drinks and absolutely no browsing. So you have to tell them beforehand, look, this is what I want to look at. So, of course, everyone assumes they're hiding something there. Yeah, and to be fair, they might be hiding something there. I mean. What do we know is actually really in there? I mean the material that's been confirmed, cataloged, and in some cases even digitized. There are the trial transcripts of Galileo, who was condemned in 1633 for suggesting that the earth might maybe possibly not be the center of the universe. How dare he? How dare you? There's the excommunication bull of Martin Luther, who launched the Protestant Reformation and got officially disinvited from the church in 1521.
Then there's a letter from Michelangelo complaining that he hadn't been paid for his work on St. Peter's Basilica. There's the Gigno parchment, which shows that the Templars were absolved of heresy by Pope Clement V, even though most of them were still burned alive. On Friday the 13th. Then there's the correspondence between the Vatican and Henry VIII, including his request for an annulment from Catherine of Aragon. I think we talked plenty about it, and if people have to listen to more stuff about the wives of Henry VIII, they would rather die. One of my all-time favorite reviews ever. But we know the Pope denied, and that prompted England to say, fine, we'll just start our own religion then. But what do we think might?
be hiding in there? I just don't know. We have to be very, very clear. There is no evidence whatsoever that the Vatican is hiding UFO wreckage or the Antichrist's baby photos. But could they be hiding those things? Yeah, I think they could be. Absolutely, yeah. Is the Vatican hiding documented proof of alien life? Probably not, but they do run the Vatican Observatory, which is one of the oldest astronomical institutions in the world. And they've made a surprisingly open statement about the possibility of extraterrestrial life.
Jesuit astronomers have publicly said that if aliens exist, they too are part of God's creation. Which is really a very chill stance for a church not historically known for rapid doctrinal flexibility. Let's just say. So, of course, some believe there's more to it that the Vatican possesses classified records of alien encounters, recovered craft, or ancient sightings interpreted as divine visitations. It's not likely, but it's not impossible. In 1917, three children in Fatima, Portugal, claimed to have visions of the Virgin Mary. She gave them three secrets.
Two were revealed in 1941. The first secret was a vision of hell. Lucia, one of the children, wrote that during one apparition, the Virgin Mary showed the children a terrifying vision of hell. Quote, We saw a great sea of fire, demons and souls in human form, like transparent burning embers, all blackened or burnished bronze, floating about in the fire. End quote. The second secret is more political in nature. Mary told the children that World War I would end soon, but that a worse war would follow if people did not cease offending God. Now, the third secret was kept.
well, secret in the Vatican, until 2000 when it was finally released, allegedly. The official version was a symbolic vision involving the, quote, bishop in white being shot, widely interpreted as a reference to the 1981 assassination attempt on Pope John Paul II. But critics say that version is incomplete or edited, that the true third secret is apocalyptic, something about global disaster, the collapse of the church, or the rise of the Antichrist. And that is still locked away, classified, indefinitely. The Vatican says that everything has been disclosed, which, as we all know, always calms conspiracy theorists right down. They're like, oh, well, if you say it's like that, then it's definitely like that.
There could be evidence of the existence of Pope Joan, because some definitely speculate that buried in the archive is a forgotten record, a letter, a council decree, or a suppressed chronicle referencing Johannes Anglicus. And of course, another big one, documents related to Pope John Paul I's death. Listen, it's entirely plausible that internal memos, correspondence, or investigation notes exist somewhere in the archive. Whether they say anything interesting or anything at all is not a question entirely. And let's not forget all the stuff no one knows even exists. Exactly. The Vatican might be hiding things it doesn't even know.
It's hiding. And who knows? Records were sometimes misfiled, mislabeled, or stashed away by secretaries who died before they could catalog their work. Also, are we not still finding new, like, biblical writings from time to time? I mean, everything is just changing all the time. All the time. And honestly, if there ever worked an archivist who tried to get rid of some papers as quickly as I am,
You know, in an out-of-sight, out-of-mind way, good luck ever finding these. Because I can hide things so well that nobody, not me, sometimes my husband, because he knows me too well, he finds those things on the first attempt. But yeah, I'm like this kind of person who just put away the clutter. Same, same. I'll never find it again. I just found a stash of things that I bought for a bunch of kids, nieces and nephews and stuff, on our trip to Hawaii back in 2015. That's like the scene in Christmas Vacation where he finds the Mother's Day gifts. I was like, oh, I don't think they're going to want state pens and license plates with their names on them now that they can drink legally.
At precisely 8.23 p.m., Roger Kwan was not waiting for a table outside his favorite restaurant with his girlfriend, so a passing sports coupe did not splash slush all over her, making her question why she was dating him. And a second car did not splash her again, confirming her belief. All because Roger skipped it, stayed in, and with the skip app, ordered the best chicken tikka masala she'd ever had, confirming Roger might just be the one. Way to go, Raj. Skip to the good part.
Your favorite Starbucks flavor is coming home. Introducing new Starbucks Cinnamon Dolce by Nespresso for Virtuo. Ready with the touch of a button on your Nespresso Virtuo machine? These pods are the perfect way to start your day with the Starbucks cafe quality you love. And they're super easy to customize however you like. Discover new Cinnamon Dolce and the full range of Starbucks by Nespresso for Virtuo pods in your local grocery store today.
So, yeah, there's definitely the possibility that some materials may have been deliberately suppressed centuries ago and never rediscovered. There are documents no one has requested in 500 years because no one knows they're there. It's such a conundrum, isn't it? Like, you have to know specifically what you want in order to look at it. But you don't know what they have. In 2020, the Vatican announced a full digitization project of the archive, which will take decades. And if anything especially odd turns up, I'm sure they'll tell us, right? I mean... Yeah, definitely. Definitely. Maybe not. Probably not.
I'm excited. I'm excited to see. It's just going to be a whole bunch of hard-to-read Latin. All right, let's end this journey through papal drama and Vatican weirdness with a man who really should be remembered for reviving education in Europe, but instead got stuck with the nickname, the Pope who made a deal with the devil. His name was Sherbert of Oriak, and he would eventually become Pope Sylvester II in the year 999. Not 666. Not 1999. 999. And also not 1999. It's 999. Yes, yes, yes. 999.
No, he's not Sylvester from New Year's Eve holiday that was Pope Sylvester I, a much earlier and much less controversial figure. Gerbert was born around the year 946 in the region of Auvergne, which is central France, and he entered a monastery in Aurillac at a young age where his brilliance became immediately apparent. He was very clearly gifted, not just in theology, but in mathematics, astronomy, logic, and I don't know whatever else passed for natural sciences in the 10th century. In the 960s, Count Borrell of Barcelona, impressed by the young monk's intellect, took Gerbert to Catalonia, where he studied under Christian and Muslim scholars. this part is very important. Because Muslim Spain at the time, particularly in cities like Cordoba and Toledo, was a place of preserved classical knowledge. Classical for them back in the day. So think Euclid, Aristotle, Ptolemy, philosophy, science, mathematics that had been lost or ignored in most of Christian Europe. Gerbert had access to this material. He learned Arabic numerals, the abacus, even possibly encountered early ideas that would lead to mechanical clocks, astronomical devices. And when he returned to France, he brought this knowledge with him.
In a world where the church still thought numbers had moral value and most people believed that the earth was the fixed center of the cosmos, Gerbert's ideas were radical. They were not per se heretical, but they were definitely kind of tiptoeing the line to dangerous territory. Yeah, and Arabic numerals, we should maybe mention, that's how we look at numbers today. Arabic numerals are 1, 2, 3, 4, 5, and of course Roman numerals are what Americans have to contend with every Super Bowl. By the 970s and 980s, Gerbert had become one of the most renowned teachers in Europe. He taught at Reims, served as tutor to future emperors, and advocated for what was essentially an early version of the liberal arts curriculum. Mathematics, astronomy, rhetoric, logic. He's credited with reintroducing the Ibacus to Europe, promoting the astrolabe, and possibly building early mechanical devices to demonstrate planetary motion. I'd say this man was definitely in the same league as all the other overachievers we already talked about on this podcast. Gerbert's intellectual influence eventually brought him...
into the orbit of Otto III, the young Holy Roman Emperor. Otto was a big fan of reforming the Church, restoring the glory of Rome, and of course, installing his own people in key positions. And then when Pope Gregory V died in 999, Otto helped install Gerber as Pope. And he took the name Sylvester II, deliberately echoing Sylvester I, who had reigned during the time of Constantine, so the first Christian Roman Emperor. And for a while, things looked very promising. But being too smart, too foreign, educated, and too close to the Emperor made Sylvester II a...
perfect target. After his death in 1003 a series of legends began to circulate. Legends that had nothing to do with his policies and everything to do with fierce superstition and the church's general suspicion of anything that sounded too smart. The most famous accusations were he had studied black magic in Muslim Spain. That he had owned a brazen head, a mechanical automaton that could answer yes or no questions and predict the future. That he had built clocks and machines that moved by themselves. That he had made a pact with the devil in exchange for knowledge and power. One particularly persistent story said that he died when a demon dragged him out of bed and hurled him into hell for trying to seek forgiveness too late. Except for the demon story, none of this was true. I'm just kidding. I'm just kidding. None of it was true. Not even the very believable demon story.
But it didn't matter. The damage was done. As we already learned from Formosa's story, posthumous character assassination was a very beloved medieval hobby. It's just too easy to discredit someone once they are no longer around to defend themselves. You rewrite their legacy in a way that reinforces your own authority, which is exactly what happened with Sylvester II. His intellect was too threatening, his background was too weird and foreign, and his ideas were too modern. So he had to be recast as a satanical pope, a dark sorcerer, a man who knew too much and paid the price.
Of course, the real Sylvester II was not a devil worshiper. He was a scholar. He was a teacher. He was an inventor. He was a reformer. He was one of the first people in medieval Europe to argue that faith and reason could peacefully coexist and that learning, real learning, was not something to be feared. Fun fact, according to legend, his tomb in the Basilica of St. John Lateran would sweat or become moist as an omen preceding the death of another pope. This phenomenon was noted in several medieval chronicles and it added to the creepy mystique surrounding Pope Sylvester II.
By the way, speaking of paranormal activity in the Vatican, if there is any place on earth that should be crawling with ghosts, it's the Vatican. Oh, yeah. I mean, it sits on the ruins of Nero's Circus. It's built over an ancient necropolis. It houses the bones of dozens of saints, several popes, and probably at least one guy who shouldn't be there. At least. At least. There's probably at least one guy who shouldn't be there. There are hidden rooms, maybe with more bones behind them, locked doors, and centuries of blood-soaked politics of every sort. And so much murder. So much murder. Like, so much murder. So much. It's too much murder.
But guess what? Well, some of you might know, the Vatican doesn't officially acknowledge hauntings. Which is shocking, I know, for a religion that makes a big deal out of the Holy Ghost. That's the only ghost. So, if you're going to visit the Vatican and you don't encounter ghosts, don't be disappointed, because there is so much more to see. Even though it's the smallest country in the world, it holds one of the largest concentrations of priceless art on Earth. Roughly 70,000 pieces are in its collection, although only about 20,000 are on display at any given time. The rest, tucked away in climate-controlled storage, off-limits to the public.
Which is fair. I, too, hoard beautiful things and refuse to explain myself. But in my own defense, I don't really own anything the public would love to see in a museum. You know, I'm not hiding any international treasure here. Just a little dragon. I'm a small dragon. That's right. I do. I'm a magpie. I'm a crow. I like shiny things. It's fine.
The Vatican Museums are enormous. They stretch over nine miles of galleries, corridors, and chapels. They house everything from ancient Roman sarcophagi to Egyptian mummies, Renaissance masterpieces, medieval icons, and 21st century religious kitsch. The most famous work, of course, is Michelangelo's Sistine Chapel Ceiling, which was painted between 1508 and 1512, arguably the most viewed neck injury in human history. And beneath it, the Last Judgment, where the saved float upward and the damned are being pulled down by the demons.
and absolutely no pants. No pants. Estimates of the Vatican's art collection value range into the tens of billions of dollars. But of course, none of it is for sale. And what you see, that's just the tip of the gold-plated iceberg.
Behind the scenes are vaults, storerooms, and archives filled with works of art that haven't been seen by the public in decades, maybe centuries. Some are being restored, some are too fragile to display. Some, well, frankly, the church doesn't feel like sharing. Have you ever heard of the Clavigero? No. You haven't? He's the chief keykeeper of the Vatican Museum, so clavis is the Latin word for key. And as of now, the current Clavigero is a man named Gianni Crea, and yes, he carries actual keys, nearly 3,000 of them. That's awesome. And every morning...
At 5.30 a.m., he and his small team begin their ritual, which is walking the entire length of the museums, which is, as you said, over nine miles of corridors. I forgot to convert it to kilometers. Should be like 15 kilometers, more or less. And they are unlocking more than 300 doors by hand. It's a very silent private procession. And for luck, if you wealthy patrons or head of state or invited scholars, I think it's one of the most coveted experiences in the world, you know, to accompany the clavigero in the morning on his rounds. You can go through the museums with no crowds, no cameras, just you, you know, the echoes, the Sistine Chapel completely empty. How do you get the job, you might ask? Well, you train for years. You start as an assistant, you learn every key and lock by heart, and eventually you become the only person trusted to carry the whole kingdom.
On a keychain. You think he has a cool keychain? Yeah. Literally? It must be one of those, like, giant ones, like in Game of Thrones, you know, where it's just... How much do you think it weighed? 3,000 keychain? Maybe you should send him a fresh hail keyring. A keyring. We should. Let's do it.
All right, I have one last story. It's about Michelangelo, the man who painted the most iconic ceiling, and how much he absolutely hated every single second of it. Michelangelo Buenorotti was a sculptor. That's how he saw himself. He was trained in stone, obsessed with anatomy, and famously uninterested in anything that involved paintbrushes or following instructions. And he was one of the greatest ever. That's right. Amazingly talented. So when Pope Julius II ordered him to fresco the ceiling of the Sistine Chapel in 1508...
Michelangelo wasn't thrilled or honored to have been asked. He argued. He begged to be excused. He even accused the Pope publicly of sabotaging his career out of envy. Julius was not exactly a patient man. The job was not optional. Michelangelo spent four years painting that ceiling, on scaffolding on his back, paint dripping into his eyes, developing infections, and slowly wrecking his neck and spine. He wrote a poem to a friend during this process. Quote,
I've already grown a goiter from this torture, hunched up here like a cat in Lombardy, or anywhere else where the stagnant water is poison. My stomach's squashed under my chin, my beard's pointing at heaven, my brain's crushed in a casket, my breast twists like a heartbeat's. My brush, above me all the time, dribbles paint, so my face makes a fine floor for droppings. My haunches are grinding into my guts. My poor ass strains to work as a counterweight. Every gesture I make is blind and aimless.
My skin hangs loose below me. My spine's all knotted from folding over itself. I'm bent taut as a Syrian bow because I'm stuck like this. My thoughts are crazy, perfidious tripe. Anyone shoots badly through a crooked blowpipe. My painting is dead. Defend it for me, Giovanni. Protect my honor. I am not in the right place. I am not a painter. End quote. In another letter, he simply called the chapel, quote, this miserable chapel. And yet?
He finished it. I mean, he was literally going through his own personal hell and he just kept going. Yes. And it's wild how he hated it. He thought it was a terrible painting. My painting is dead. He was so talented. I mean, the fact that he hated painting and didn't think he was super good at it, it really makes me feel guilty about my imposter syndrome. He was so talented.
Have you been to the Vatican City? Not yet, no. No. It's on my list, though. But first I want to go to Pompeii, so. Same, same, same. That's right. The Spanish and Pompeii are the two things I really want to see in Italy. Everything else, I can take or leave, but I really would like to see...
Pompeii and Venice. It's crazy to think about that we haven't even scratched on the surface with this episode, this fun little episode. We haven't talked about the counter-popes. We haven't talked about Napoleon and this whole rumor about him ripping the crown out of Pope's hands and crowning himself, which is a whole other story. But we haven't really talked about the Borgias and crazy. The Borgias could be their own episode like the Habsburgs. Definitely. Definitely. For sure. Do you have something good this week? My something good is I started...
dabbling a little bit into learning Italian. I speak Spanish and French, so that's already two Romanian languages, and it helps a lot with Italian, but I always wanted to learn Italian. I think it's a beautiful language. I love Italo Pop. Always have since the 80s. Always.
And I'm so thankful to just start learning new languages for stuff like Duolingo, which gives easy access, let's say, like this for free. Absolutely. Nice. So yeah, that's my something good. How about you? Nice. I had a really nice time last weekend. Paul and I went to see Tina Fey and Amy Poehler on tour. Their tour is called the Restless Legs Tour. The name made me laugh because, of course, like a lot of people my age, I have the restless legs. Yeah, Amy Poehler is from Burlington. So there were some really funny local jokes.
And Rachel Dratch, who I adore, is also from this area. And so she was on stage as a guest appearance. So that was really fun. I got to get out with friends that I just don't get to see as much as I'd like. And it was a fun night. And I also wanted to recommend the film Conclave. Have you seen it? I haven't seen it yet, but isn't it crazy that it just came out last year, I think, and now...
Yeah. Yeah, I don't want to give any spoilers a lot at all. Even if you aren't religious, it's a really excellent film about sort of how it all works. I definitely recommend it. Oh, cool. I'm going to watch it. Because the whole time I was like, I think that's kind of boring because, I mean... No, no, no. It's really good. And I mean...
The actors in it are all pretty amazing. So no surprise that the performances I thought were excellent. But yeah. All right. I'm going to watch it. Thank you. All right. I think that's it. If you made it all the way through secret archives, ghost popes or zombie popes or whatever, mechanical brazen heads and Michelangelo's neck pain. First of all, thank you for listening. Thank you. Second of all, you're our kind of people. That's right. And if you haven't yet left us a rating or review, you can still be absolved. Please do it. Do it now. It helps other wonderfully strange people to find our show. That's right.
If you want more of this early, ad-free, and occasionally even weirder info, you can join us over on Patreon or get early access by subscribing on Spotify. We are also on YouTube, so please like and subscribe, and then you can stare into our logo while you question the papal line of succession. And you can find all of it, everything you need, including our contact info and our P.O. Box at freshhealthpodcast.com. That's it. That's it.
Please tell your pets we said hi, hug them, cuddle them, give them treats, keep them warm, keep them cool, whatever is needed. And be kind to them. Be kind to your fellow human being, no matter if they're Protestant or Catholic or agnostic or whatever. That's right. We're all in this together. We're just trying to navigate it in different ways. 100%. And be kind to yourself. Yeah, that's sometimes the hardest part, isn't it? But just try to be a little nicer to yourself, please. We would be so grateful if you would. Forgive yourself once in a while. That's right. And until next week, if you're going through hell. Keep going. Tschüss. Bye.
This episode is brought to you by Netflix. Think you know Cinderella? Think again. In the new animated film Steps, the Stepsisters team up for a hilarious adventure beyond the palace walls. Expect monsters, a hot troll, and plenty of family drama on their journey to happily ever after. Featuring Ali Wong, Amanda Seyfried, Nikki Glaser, Bette Midler, and Daniel Radcliffe. Don't miss Steps, coming November 20th, only on Netflix. Should you grow a playoff beard? What about a playoff mustache? A playoff soul patch? Rated playoff mutton chops? Or maybe just playoff stubble? Whatever you grow, it's up to you. Just like it's up to you to ask your doctor about Wigovie.