Skip to content
E293: MURDER - William Desmond Taylor (part II) episode artwork

Aug 8, 2025 1 hr 13 min

E293: MURDER - William Desmond Taylor (part II)

from Fresh Hell Podcast Hosted by freshhellpodcast

In part two of our three-part look at the mysterious murder of William Desmond Taylor, we pick up with the powerful (and possibly romantic) figures in Taylor’s life, and trace the final days leading up to his death. You’ll hear about his complex relationship with set designer George James Hopkins, the bond he shared with Mabel Normand, and how the evening of February 1, 1922, played out—including what Mabel saw, what the neighbors heard, and what the valet found the next morning. We walk you through the shock of Taylor’s death, the chaos at the crime scene, and the bizarre claim that silent film sweetheart Mary Miles Minter had been secretly engaged to him. William Desmond Taylor, Mabel Normand, Mary Miles Minter, silent film, Hollywood murder, 1920s scandal, George James Hopkins, Charlotte Shelby, unsolved case, Taylor murder, Paramount Pictures, Hollywood Forever Cemetery, silent movie stars, Hollywood history, classic Hollywood, true crime, film noir, media circus, famous unsolved murders, Fresh Hell Podcast

Episode details come from the podcast's RSS feed.

Embed this episode

Ready to play

E293: MURDER - William Desmond Taylor (part II)

0:00 1:13:19
of matches

Transcript Auto-generated, may contain errors

In every small town, behind every closed door, a story waits to be uncovered. On Our True Crime Podcast, we dive deep into the cases that haunt communities around the world, from chilling cold cases to crimes with unexpected twist. No detail is too small. Hosted by us, Jen and Cam, two lifelong friends who love telling a good story. This isn't sensationalized news. It's real cases, real people, and the chilling details that keep you up at night. Our True Crime Podcast brings the facts, a little perspective, and just enough humor to remind you you're not alone in being fascinated by the darker side of life. Our True Crime Podcast.

where bizarre crimes, meticulous research, and genuine friendship collide. Subscribe today if you dare, because sometimes, the scariest stories are the true ones. If you're enjoying the podcast you're listening to right now, and you've got a love of the paranormal, then I'm Rob Kirkup, and I think you might enjoy my show, How Haunted. Every other Friday, I take you to some of the most haunted locations across the UK, with the occasional trip overseas, as we explore the dark history behind each place, and the terrifying ghost stories set to haunt them.

Across the year, there are seasonal specials too, including Christmas episodes packed with real listener ghost stories. And every October, the podcast goes weekly, a themed month building towards a big Halloween spooktacular. You'll also join me on real paranormal investigations, ghost hunts in seriously unsettling locations, with audio from the night, so you can hear what happens as it happens. So if you're ready for creepy locations, grim history, and stories that follow you long after the lights go out, search How Haunted wherever you get your podcasts. And join me as together we ask, How Haunted. You're listening to the Fresh Hell Podcast. Fresh Hell contains stories of a disturbing and often graphic nature and is intended for a mature audience. Please don't let your kids listen to this or they might turn out like us.

Hi, I'm Annie from the US, where our national bird is technically the bald eagle, but emotionally it's probably a turkey with anxiety. And I'm Johanna from Austria, where our national animal should be the marmot, endlessly screaming into the void like, hey, hey, hey, you know, that kind of... Steve. Anyway, you're listening to your favorite international podcast. The podcast hosted by two women who never met in real life and yet somehow managed to share a suspicious number of opinions. So many opinions.

Before we start, we want to say a huge thank you to our patrons. Seriously, truly, you are the reason that this show still exists. You are supporting independent podcasting. You're helping us to stay ad-free as much as possible and helping us to keep digging into these strange forgotten corners of history. And if you're not on Patreon yet, now's a good time to join us. We release a brand new Cinema Macabre episode every week. Plus, we do live monthly get-togethers. You'll also get early access to episodes and some bonus content. That's at patreon.com backslash Freshell Podcast.

Now, Johanna is going to give you a recap of last week's episode, part one, in five sentences or less. Just one thing before we start. Speaking of last week, sorry for leaving the show so abruptly, but I think Annie told you I had a complete power outage. We had a thunderstorm and all of a sudden everything was gone. I had to quickly switch to my mobile internet to even be able to tell Annie what happened. The power was gone for more than two hours. Did you listen to that yet? The end of it where I'm like, hey guys, I could still hear you. I could still hear her clearly through our phone connection.

None of her recording devices were obviously going to work anymore. Nothing anymore. Listen, it's wild times here. So, all right. Okay. We talked about William Dean Tanner, a married Irishman who vanished from New York in 1908, abandoning his wife and daughter without a trace. He reappeared in Los Angeles under a new name, William Desmond Taylor, where he built a successful career and cultivated a reputation as a moral reformer in an increasingly scandal-brown industry.

That's just two sentences. You didn't say how long the sentences are allowed to be, so here we go. Listen, I'm not judging. We also introduced the two most important women in his life, Mabel Norman, a brilliant but very troubled comedy star. He tried to help through addiction and marry Miles Minter, a teenage actress under the control of her domineering mother. And possibly maybe madly in love or just really, really infatuated with William Desmond Taylor. So yes, three sentences. Really, that was amazing. Well done.

So, yeah, so last week we talked about three of the most important women in William's life, his wife Ethel, Mabel, and Mary. But there was someone else, someone whose name rarely appears in the headlines, but who may have mattered more than any of them, George James Hopkins. Hopkins was a brilliant designer, first of theater sets, then of silent film interiors, and eventually, decades later, some of the most iconic films in Hollywood history, Casablanca, A Streetcar Named Desire, My Fair Lady, Dial M for Murder. That was all him. He won four Academy Awards in total, but in the early 1920s, he was just a young, exceptionally talented set designer who had recently returned to Los Angeles to work in the booming silent film industry. And it was there, at the studio, that he met William Desmond Taylor. Hopkins would later recall the first time he saw Taylor. Tall, elegant, and completely magnetic. His heart was racing. At least, that is what he apparently wrote in his unpublished 1981 memoir, Caught in the Act, which would become one of the major sources for later books about Taylor's murder.

Hopkins said that his mother Una, herself a well-known designer and magazine writer, adored Taylor and actively encouraged the connection. Soon, the two men were working together and living together. What began as a crush quietly became a romantic relationship. Now, we don't have love letters. We don't have photographs. We basically do have somewhat of a first-person account in an unpublished book that was allegedly then used by another author. Sounds complicated? It is. So take everything with a grain of salt because there's no definite proof for any of this.

Hopkins wrote that as time went on, they became less secretive. In April 1921, the two men attended an opera together, Mary Garden in Othello. And while they didn't walk in together, they sat side by side in the front orchestra. Not exactly hidden. And they did this in full view of Cecil B. DeMille, Jesse Lasky, and all other major film industry figures of the day.

Professionally, the partnership was just as strong. Hopkins worked as a set designer or production manager on several of Taylor's films, including Nurse Marjorie and The Top of New York, which turned out to be Taylor's last film before his death. They collaborated on The Soul of Youth, a film that dealt with poverty, morality, and redemption. Hopkins also designed a scene in The Furnace. So all of these very successful collaborations. And then Taylor was murdered. But we're not there yet.

Before we're getting into the day of the murder, we need to tell you a bit about where it happened because the geography of Taylor's little corner of Los Angeles is kind of important. And it explains a lot about how witnesses saw what they saw and how some of them didn't see nearly enough. As we mentioned last week, William Desmond Taylor was living at 404B South Alvarado Street in the Westlake neighborhood of Los Angeles. And as I already told you, back then, Westlake was a desirable upper-middle-class area filled with manicured lawns, apartment courts and very quiet bungalows. And this wasn't what we picture nowadays as Hollywood-level wealth, but it was definitely comfortable and very close to the studios. It had a bit of an East Coast feel, they say. One journalist described it as a place where people took afternoon walks and cared deeply about their hedges.

The property itself was an upscale complex made up of eight Spanish-style bungalows, each divided into two units and arranged in a kind of U-shape around a shared central garden. So this means that the two-story houses were rather close together and opened into a shared courtyard. Yeah, courtyard. I wouldn't call it driveway because I don't think cars could drive there, but I added a kind of drawing. How would you describe it? It opened up to a U-shaped path that would lead down to the street, right? Yeah, I really like it.

So often you would see this kind of design, but it would be like a courtyard and that would be everybody's backyard and everyone would share sort of a back garden. But in this, it's sort of flipped and reversed. So there's this really pretty courtyard area that serves as everybody's sort of front walkway, front garden, if that makes sense. I think it's really nice. It looks like I would be into that. I think it's really nice. Yeah. Yeah. And these weren't like sprawling mansions. The buildings were separated by these narrow walkways. And it was so close together that every sound and movement, I think, carried. Also because of the U-shaped form, right? Right.

I'd guess you hear your neighbor come home, you know, you'd know who had a visitor, you'd hear a gate creak or, you know, a door slam, things like this. So, Taylor lived in Unit 404B next to him, basically in the closed end of the U, if you want. In Unit 406B lived neighbors Faith and Douglas McLean. I think he was also working in the film industry. Was he an actor or director? I don't really recall now. William Spangalo was very tastefully decorated, reflecting Taylor's interest in art and design. Probably, maybe, influenced by George Hopkins as well. So he had really good furniture, he had books, antiques, and reportedly kept a grand piano in the front room. Nice. The walls had paintings and photographs. So he had a valet and cook, and his name was Henry...

Peavey? Peavey, I think. P-E-A-V-E-I. Yeah, Peavey. I would say Henry Peavey. Peavey, yeah. And this man handled the day-to-day chores and, you know, the errands. And for all the rumors that would follow, there's no evidence that this bungalow was kind of a party house. It was orderly. It was respectable. There were apparently multiple entrances to every unit. You had a front door. Like, you have to imagine you have this kind of Spanish-style bungalows.

And one bungalow shares two units, right? The A unit and the B unit. And the entrance doors are practically right next to each other. Right. And then you'd also have like a small service entrance off to the side and a back door. And the windows had curtains and Taylor kept things really private. And if a shot would be fired inside one of the units, it would be absolutely hurt by anybody who was nearby. And that's probably exactly what happened. Let's start with what we know about February 1st, 1922, the last day of William Desmond Taylor's life.

It was a Wednesday and reportedly an unusually cold day for Los Angeles. The day started like most of William's days did, quietly. Taylor was, by all accounts, a man of habit. Henry Peavy had arrived at the bungalow around 7.30 that morning to begin breakfast and open up the house. Peavy had only been working for Taylor for a few months, having replaced the previous valet, Edward Sands, a name we will absolutely be talking about later. Peavy prepared breakfast, probably set out the newspapers, and carried on with his usual morning chores. Taylor, meanwhile, got dressed and did a bit of correspondence. We know he wrote at least one check that day. He also received a delivery from the drugstore, possibly personal toiletries or over-the-counter remedies. Throughout the day, Taylor had a handful of visitors and errands, though he stayed mostly close to home.

He was in the final stages of post-production for The Top of New York, and while there's no record of him going to the studio that day, he may have made or taken a few phone calls about it. That evening, sometime between 6 and 7 p.m., Mabel Norman arrived at Taylor's Bungalow. We already talked about it last week. Mabel had developed a substance abuse habit. And the truth is, by that point, Mabel wasn't just partying. She was falling apart. She'd been self-medicating with morphine, cocaine, and alcohol. And her career was wobbling. The recent death of her friend, Olive Thomas, from a supposed accidental overdose of mercury bichloride in Paris, had really shaken her. Mabel became convinced that she'd soon follow her friend. And it was William Desmond Taylor who stepped in and said, enough is enough. He helped her to get clean, got her into a sanatorium, and stayed a steady presence when the rest of Hollywood either looked the other way.

or just wanted her back in front of the camera. Taylor had been encouraging her to seek treatment, and it's believed that they had a conversation about that during her visit. Some reports say she picked up a book that he had bought for her. Others say she dropped off or returned something of her own. Whatever the reason, it wasn't a short hello. They chatted for nearly 45 minutes and by all accounts, it was a warm and pleasant evening. Mabel would later say that they laughed a lot. They had a couple of orange martinis and caught up on the latest mess involving Taylor's valet, Henry Peavy, who had been arrested the night before for lewd conduct in a public park. That morning, Taylor had to go bail him out. I mean, that does sound like...

two very close friends just catching up about their day, right? Yeah, yeah, exactly. Like we, when we called, like, what have you been up to today? Exactly. I mean, it's not as exciting as these people's life because we barely leave the house, but yeah. I mean, I don't know, Johanna, that 2 a.m. skunking, that was some pretty intense stuff. Well, that was very exciting, yeah. Jam's grass blades in the middle of the night. We live very... True, our life is exciting. That's right. We live very, very exciting lives. Wait until I tell you how terrible our maid has been lately. Also, the maid is me. All right, so...

So they have this 45-minute or so visit with each other. At around 7.45 p.m., Taylor walked Mabel to her car, which was parked just outside the court. He left the front door unlocked, because why wouldn't he? He was just stepping outside for a few minutes. A chauffeur was waiting to take her home. According to the driver, Mabel and Taylor said goodnight, exchanged a few final words, and she drove off. That would be the last confirmed sighting of William Desmond Taylor alive. Somewhere between 7.50 and 8 o'clock p.m., just a few minutes after Mabel left,

Neighbors heard a loud sound, like a car backfiring or a heavy object dropped. It wasn't alarming enough for anyone to run outside immediately, but it was definitely noticed. In particular, Faith Cole McLean would later say that she heard something sharp and sudden. This is an excerpt from an article from the San Francisco Examiner from Friday, February 3rd, 1922. Page 1. Quote.

The McLeans sat down to dinner at 7.30 last night, according to Mrs. McLean. While the second course was being served, the maid claims to have heard the footsteps of a man in the alley in the rear of the house, running between the two houses. She spoke of that occurrence to Mr. and Mrs. McLean but thought more of it until today.

At 7.50 o'clock, however, six minutes after Miss Normand had left the tailor home to go to her machine, Mrs. McLean heard a shot, and peering hurriedly out of the door, saw a man leaving the tailor home. End quote. I love that they call it a machine. Yeah. She went out to her machine. Also, so...

I love how everyone has like a personal assistant servant valet. Yeah. And this is really upper middle class. It is. It really is. I want to see the interior of these houses. Are they still there? I mean, we have a couple of... No, it's a parking lot now. Oh, bummer. We have a couple of photos of Taylor's bungalow interior. Nice, nice. Because I'm just curious to know how big it was. I don't think it was even that big, but it had like a second floor or first floor, depending on where you're from. Second floor. Yeah. Got it. Okay.

All right. Now, so this this sighting becomes one of the most debated and analyzed sightings in the entire case. Faith described the man as being well dressed, wearing a muffler or scarf and a hat that was pulled low. You know what? When I read that the guy was wearing a muffler, I thought muffler from a car. And I was so confused. Why was the guy wearing a muffler? I never heard that expression for like a scarf kind of thing. It's not a super. Well, it's confusing, too, because it can sometimes mean like a thing that goes around like your neck. But it can all like a muff is the first thing that you put your hands into. Exactly. Yeah, that's. Yeah.

She said he moved casually. In fact, she initially thought it might have been Taylor himself. The figure gave her what she described as a, quote, strange look, not quite hostile, not quite friendly, and then kept walking and disappeared into the dark. What the neighbor didn't know is that Taylor was already dead. We'll get into the discovery of the body soon enough, but for now, keep in mind, whoever that man was, it wasn't William Desmond Taylor, which means someone else had just exited his home moments after the sound neighbors would later identify as a gunshot. But nobody called the police. Not yet.

The neighborhood was quiet. People went back to their reading, their dinners, their evening routines. The lights in Taylor's bungalow stayed on, but no one thought much of it. At least not until the next morning when Henry Peavy arrived and let himself in and found his employer lying dead on his back on the floor of the living room. Okay, so I have to say that researching this case in old newspapers confused me more than it did clear up things for me. I think just because this was such a high-profile case and you know how the media was back then and the articles they wrote and they were all really like extra, extra, real about it.

So there's so much misinformation out there. It's a little bit difficult to really know for sure what happened, where witnesses might confuse or misremember things, or where somebody just made things up. But yeah, bear with me. I picked the most interesting parts that I found that I think made the most sense from everything that I read in the sources that people think that's how it went down, right? So, this is from the Los Angeles Times, Friday, February 3rd, 1922, page 2. Quote,

I ran from the house, Peavey said, and the folks around here say I made a commotion. The neighbors came running and later they took the body away. End quote. Yeah, so basically Peavey panicked, he ran screaming from the house calling for help and he flagged down anyone who would listen and someone finally phoned the police. But long before LAPD officers could arrive or would arrive, word spread. Because this wasn't just any death, this was a famous film director and the studios moved fast. Charles Eaton, whose Paramount's general manager, showed up almost immediately and no one stopped him.

Charles Eaton had somehow been tipped off before the authorities even. And Eaton didn't just, you know, stop by to wring his hands and cry and, oh my God, William Desmond Taylor is dead. According to several reports, he got straight to work cleaning house. Think Mr. Wolf in pop fiction.

Multiple witnesses later claimed that Eaton ordered studio employees to enter Taylor's bungalow and remove papers, personal items, and possible evidence, all before the LAPD could start the investigation. One source said they took a basket of documents, another claimed love letters had been taken away. The details vary, but the pattern is the same. Someone came in, grabbed what they didn't want made public, and left. I think at best this was a very inappropriate response by a studio exec more concerned with avoiding a scandal than preserving a crime scene. And at worst, it was a deliberate cover-up. Eaton and his team were managing a potential scandal, I think. Because the second this story hit the press and it was going to hit hard, the studio needed to make them sure the headlines said, you know, beloved director slain and not Hollywood cesspool exposed. You all know by now that Taylor had been a very respected figure at Paramount or in the whole film industry, I'd say. He was polished, charming, articulate.

a British gentleman with a military background, very elegant. He looked great in a suit and in a tux, and he looked great on the red carpet. I love that in one article he is described as, quote, gentlemanly drinker and loose spender. And I think that sounds a little bit like Dean Martin and Sammy Davis Jr. That's how I picture it. Yeah, I can absolutely see that.

But you also know by now that he had a few secrets. He was, in short, a complicated man, and Paramount had no interest letting the public or the police dig too deeply into any of it. So Eaton did what studio fixers in early Hollywood were often paid to do. He stepped in, he cleaned up, and hoped the press would move on. But they didn't.

But we'll talk about the media frenzy that followed in a minute. Let's just look at this crime scene a little bit more. By the time LAPD detectives arrived, closer to 8.30am, almost an hour later, they were stepping into a thoroughly compromised crime scene. The damage had been done. This was no crime scene in the traditional sense. The house was open. People were coming and going. Neighbors had wandered through. Studio men and friends of Taylor were already inside. This is a level of contamination you'd expect to see more at an 1830s murder than a 1930s murder. I read somewhere that the police arrived and thought there was a party going on.

That's exactly it. It's insane to think that the police would arrive and think there was a party and that the man was killed alone. It's not like he was killed during a party. It's... Yeah, yeah. So yeah, as you said, according to multiple witnesses, it felt like a party scene than the scene of a murder. Whatever clues might have existed were now tainted, moved, or lost entirely. Any hope of a clean investigation vanished with that first uninvited footprint across the living room floor. And to make matters worse, the body hadn't even been examined properly. An alleged doctor on site took one look at Taylor and suggested he had died of natural causes.

he mentioned something about his stomach hemorrhage. This is the same article from before. Quote, At first, it was believed the death was of natural causes, probably brought about by a hemorrhage. It was not until a considerable time after the remains were taken to the Ivy Overholzer undertaking establishment that the discovery was made that Mr. Taylor had been shot. The wound was in the back, entering at the left side in a line under the heart. A steel-jacketed bullet apparently had been used, and the wound had practically closed up, thus making detection at first difficult.

Petey said he had been in the employ of Mr. Taylor for about six months. Mr. Taylor had lived in the apartments at the Alvarado Courts about two years. The scene left in the magnificently appointed apartment occupied by Mr. Taylor showed little sign of a struggle. The overturned chair was the only indication of a struggle or of the haste of the assailant to escape. The door, which has a night latch, was locked from the outside, but the latch was set so that no key was necessary to accomplish this. A writing desk was situated near the door, against the front wall of the room.

On this desk were the many papers indicating that Mr. Taylor had been preparing his income tax returns for this year and adjusting other business. Some scenarios also were scattered about. On top of the desk was a picture of Mabel Normand. In place of honor, on the top of the upright piano, was a photograph of Miss Normand. Three in all were conspicuously displayed. End quote. They say every mystery leaves a mark. Some are loud, sudden, unforgettable. But others? They just vanish into the shadows.

I'm your host, Hopper Daily. And I'm Mackenzie. And every week I tell a story to my best friend. She's hearing the story for the first time. And just like you, she doesn't know what's coming next. And I always have so many questions. So many. Disappearances, unsolved murders, eerie cold cases, and the occasional haunting twist. And here's the thing. You don't have to know the case to feel the chill. You just have to press play. Because in every case, there's always something left behind. A clue. A feeling. A final trace.

Follow The Final Trace wherever you listen to podcasts, and come find what still lingers in the shadows. The Final Trace. New episodes every True Crime Tuesday. If you're enjoying the podcast you're listening to right now, and you've got a love of the paranormal, then I'm Rob Kirkup, and I think you might enjoy my show, How Haunted. Every other Friday, I take you to some of the most haunted locations across the UK, with the occasional trip overseas, as we explore the dark history behind each place, and the terrifying ghost stories set to haunt them.

Across the year, there are seasonal specials too, including Christmas episodes packed with real listener ghost stories. And every October, the podcast goes weekly, a themed month building towards a big Halloween spooktacular. You'll also join me on real paranormal investigations, ghost hunts in seriously unsettling locations, with audio from the night, so you can hear what happens as it happens. So if you're ready for creepy locations, grim history, and stories that follow you long after the lights go out, search How Haunted wherever you get your podcasts. And join me as together we ask, How Haunted. So they finally figure out at The Undertaker that it wasn't a natural occurrence, but he had been shot likely at close range. The bullet had torn through his left lung and lodged in his heart. And no one in the house, not TV, not the studio men, not any of the early responders, had noticed, apparently, due to the lack of blood. What do you think? How is that possible?

I think the way it's described, it almost sounds like the bullet went in, but there was no exit wound. And it sounds like it hit his heart almost immediately, which would have stopped his heart from pumping. And then if he landed on his back, I think with his, I'm guessing, I don't know if we have autopsy photos, I would expect some really massive amounts of blood pooling in the back, like way more than you would normally see because of internal bleeding probably, but his heart wouldn't be pumping. So probably the pressure of just him lying on it was enough. It seems wild to think that's possible, but.

I think that's the likely explanation. And there was no sign of a robbery. His wallet wasn't touched. His watch was still on his wrist. His monogrammed cigarette case sat right where he had left it. So yeah.

Yeah. So what's next? Yeah, next, Mary Miles Minter and her mother Charlotte Shelby appeared on the scene. Exactly when they got there is a little bit unclear. Some reports placed them at the bungalow within hours. Others say it might have been the following day. But whenever it was, Mary's reaction became the next week headline. According to multiple newspapers at the time, the young actress was very distraught. She reportedly cried, fainted, and told officers, onlookers, and then eventually reporters that she and William Desmond Taylor had been secretly engaged for the past six months or so.

Now, whether that was true or not, we don't know. There was no concrete evidence, no engagement ring, no written confirmation from Taylor himself that this relationship ever even existed in the way Mary described it. Many of Taylor's friends believed Mary had been infatuated, but that he kept a relationship at a distance, treating her more like a gifted but emotionally rather vulnerable protégé, or maybe little sister. That's how I imagine it, anyway. It might have been her honest, grief-stricken belief. It might have been a desperate attempt to claim some control over a situation spiraling into something that could potentially be very scandalous. Whatever the motivation was there, once Mary said it, she couldn't unsee it. And the press ran with it, because of course they did. She was a huge star. He was a huge star. It wasn't just that Taylor had been gunned down in his own home. It was that a teenage movie star...

had been hiding a secret engagement to a middle-aged man. One who, it now appeared, had also abandoned a wife and a child, had gone off to war under a fake name, and may have had a second secret relationship with a male set designer. So there is a lot going on there on the surface. And just when it seemed like the story couldn't get more salacious, the letters were found. Dozens of them. Long, emotional, handwritten declarations of love from Mary to William. She called herself his little girl wife. What was it last week? Daddy. Something like that.

She begged him to return her feelings. She told him no other man would ever be worthy. And here's a question you may be asking yourself. Why didn't Eton remove Mary's letter too? I mean, apparently he had time to discreetly collect the more delicate personal materials, including what's widely believed to have been romantic correspondence from set designer George Hopkins. So why not gather the stack of love letters from Mary Miles Minter?

So it's an excellent question, and I think there are several possibilities. At that moment, Aiton's first priority was probably protecting the image of William Desmond Taylor, and more importantly, the reputation of the studio. That meant grabbing anything that could spark a public scandal bigger than a tragic love story. Evidence of Taylor's possible relationships with men? That would have been catastrophic in 1922. Much harder to spin, and really kind of impossible to recover from.

Whereas, by leaving Mary's letters, there was still a scandal. But she was the studio's golden girl, a household name. If those letters came out, and they did, well, the narrative could be reshaped. Maybe the public would see her as a grieving would-be bride. Maybe her tearful statements would do the trick. And let's not forget, there's a very real possibility Eaton just didn't have time to do a thorough sweep. He knew the police were on their way. He may have only had minutes, maybe less, and needed to prioritize. And what he prioritized was removing any hint that Taylor's personal life wasn't in line with the studio's.

squeaky clean image of masculinity and heroism. I'm thinking two other possibilities. One is that maybe he wasn't even aware that these letters existed in the first place. And my other thought now is what if he left them on purpose to be found so that, you know, you just want to hide the fact, maybe hide the fact that he is bisexual or homosexual, but love letters from a very young woman in love with Taylor could kind of, you know. Right, that he's straight.

yeah yeah i think i think that's very possible i think they could have used mary as a scapegoat to to hide the you know the gay affair the relationship that he a very valid relationship we'll talk more about that later but it's ironic really isn't it because the letters from george were hidden and the letters from mary were left behind but like Now, today, it would be the letters from Mary that would be the shocking thing. And sure enough, back then, it was Mary's letters that caused the media firestorm and arguably did the most damage to everybody involved. And wouldn't you know it, just as soon as the media was starting to get really invested in the whole, we were engaged story, the story changed. The studio's PR machine kicked into overdrive. Mary's mother, Charlotte Shelby, went into full-on crisis mode. And within days, the narrative had been flipped. There had never been a relationship, they said. The engagement story?

A misunderstanding. A moment of hysteria. The letters? Nothing more than the overwrought fantasies of a teenage girl with a crush on an older man. But by then, it was too late. A contradiction had been clocked, and the press, sensing blood in the water, went in for the kill. To the public, Mary now seemed unstable at best and deceptive at worst. If she lied about being engaged, what else was she lying about? If she loved him, was she angry with him for rejecting her? Was this about jealousy? Heartbreak? The tabloids had a field day. Some began to hint that she might have had a motive for murder. Others accused her mother of acting on her daughter's behalf. And Mary's image, so carefully cultivated by the studio for years, crumbles overnight.

Gone was the sweet ingenue with the curls and bows. In her place was a cautionary tale. The starlet would love too much, said too much, and wrote too much. And the thing is, Mary was never a suspect. Not officially. Not when it came to the authorities. But that didn't matter. The public had made up its mind. The damage was done.

In trying to protect her daughter's career, Charlotte Shelby may have guaranteed its destruction. And what's worse, if Mary had told the truth that first day, if there really had been an engagement or even a quiet romance, then she wasn't a liar. She was a young woman in love who got silenced for the sake of spin. But truth wasn't really the priority here. Containment was. I think if they would have just stuck with the we were engaged story, she would have been fine career-wise. Don't you think? Probably. Yeah.

I think for most of us today, it is a bit hard to imagine how many insanely famous people were involved in this whole thing. We can't really understand how famous Mabel Norman or Mary Miles Minter were. They were not just some fringe names. This would be like if a beloved director, say someone with Spielberg or Tarantino level fame was found murdered and suddenly Julia Roberts and Jennifer Lawrence were both caught up in it with their mothers and love letters and a shady studio cover up. That's how famous these people were. It wasn't a Hollywood scandal. It was the Hollywood scandal. And so, of course, the media was all over it.

If this happened today, we'd be talking non-stop push notifications, a TikTok breakdown of Mary's love letters, Reddit conspiracy threads about Mabel and cocaine, a live-streamed crime scene blocked off behind a ring of influencers, filming tearful updates by the minute almost. The Daily Mail would have a 36-photo gallery of Mary arriving in widow chic. I don't know, TMZ would have tracked down Taylor's ex-wife within hours and, you know, someone would have made a Spotify playlist titled Who Pilled William Desmond Taylor? And it probably would have been Annie. I was going to say, is that a dig at me personally? Because you're not wrong. It's fine. So yeah, but this was obviously 1922 and even without social media, this exploded. Newspapers could not print fast enough. Headlines screamed about Hollywood's decadence. Remember all the scandals, drug-related and otherwise, that just shook LA? And Taylor had been a vocal advocate for cleaning up the industry. And now he was dead, shot in the back. And every major paper from Los Angeles to New York.

was printing speculation as fact. Was it a lover? A jealous rival? A spurned woman? A drug ring? Blackmail scheme? Maybe all of the above, or none? People who had never seen a silent film in their lives suddenly knew the names Mary Miles Minter, Charlotte Shelby, and Mabel Normand. The press tore into them all. Mary was painted as a foolish, heartbroken child. Mabel, already famous for her cocaine use, was vilified. Some even tried to imply that she was the dealer Taylor had tried to expose. And Charlotte? A stage mother with a gun and a temper? What more could they ask for?

If you listened to our episodes on P.T. Barnum, then you might remember his very famous credo, quote, there is no such thing as bad press. And we think Mary Miles Minter would wholeheartedly disagree, because for her, this whole thing was basically a career-ending disaster. Before her name became tabloid shorthand for Scandal, Mary Miles Minter was one of the biggest movie stars in the world. I know that sounds like an exaggeration, because you've maybe never heard of her, but she was genuinely everywhere. By the time she was 18, 18, she had starred in over 50 films. That's not a typo. More than 50 movies in less than three years. And yes, we're talking early 1920s, silent cinema here, where churning out one-wheelers was the norm. But even by those standards, Mary was a phenomenon. Her movies brought in big money. And...

I don't know. I just this is a case that Johanna definitely brought to my attention. And it's one of those things that the more you learn about her, the more infuriating it is, because this was clearly like a victimized, groomed, abused child who was then punished for having been. Do you know what I mean? Like these are these cases from Hollywood that, you know, I think you could tell so well where.

This poor woman, you know, I mean, it's awful. It's awful. I mean, we talked a little bit about these things already in the Chateau Marmont episode. We did. Yeah. So much going on. So much horrible abuse and exploitation. Yeah. And I really think, I think she was infatuated with William Desmond Taylor, but I think probably, and we talked about it last week, because he was kind to her maybe. And she was maybe at this age where she just wanted to find out. And marrying a man who is kind to her definitely was a good option. This is it. And also, you know, she was groomed by her mother and by the industry. And so.

I think also for her, in her mind, she's at that place where if somebody is kind to her, then how does she show kindness and thanks back? You know, it's with her body and with everything, you know, and I can totally understand why she would have fallen for him immediately. But I don't think he ever saw her as anything romantic ever. I think so neither. I think so neither. She was definitely a victim. And I'm also absolutely certain that her face was used in newspaper ads as well. I couldn't find any when I was looking through, you know, a couple of old newspapers online, but I'm certain. She was beautiful. Mary Miles Minter is, when you imagine, like, you know, like we talked about, like the Gibson girls and that like early, early-ish 1920s, very ethereal, just, she's beautiful. There's just no, nothing, nothing else to say, really. It's sad.

And it's no wonder that studios loved her, audiences adored her. She was earning thousands of dollars a week, which was astronomical at that time, especially for a teenage girl. She lived in luxury, she had top billing, and was widely considered one of the most promising actresses of her generation. For a moment, it really did look like Mary Miles Minter was going to be the next Mary Pickford. And then, the Taylor case hit.

And all of it, every contract, every endorsement, every fan letter, just poof, gone. And of course, Mary wasn't the only one who lost everything in the fallout from William Desmond Taylor's murder. Mabel Norman's career didn't die that day, but it never fully recovered either. Mabel had been one of the most powerful women in early Hollywood. As we said last week, she directed Charlie Chaplin. She headlined massive comedies. She was funny and magnetic and smarter than most of the men running the studios. But she was also exhausted and broken and dealing with a drug addiction that had nearly killed her before Taylor intervened.

As you said before any, the death of Olive Thomas had absolutely shaken her and now her closest friend had been murdered and she was the last person to see him alive. Mabel too, just like Mary, was never officially a suspect. There was no evidence against her, but the press didn't need evidence. They had the optics. The actress, the martinis, the rumors, you know, all that, that was enough. She kept working for a little while, you know, tried to carry on, but the stain just didn't wash off. Her next big film opened to press protests. The audience didn't want to laugh with her any longer.

And no worries, we will be talking way more about what happened to everyone involved next week. I think in this case, it was the studio response which only made things worse, right? Paramount tried to spin the whole thing, even floating the idea that Taylor might have died a hero, protecting Mabel from drug pushers. Eaton's cleanup crew had clearly tried to control the narrative, but all they did was fan the flames. Reporters wanted to know, why was the crime scene disturbed? Why was evidence taken? Why did the studio get there before the police? If this had happened in 2025, there'd be a podcast by the end of the week. Netflix or Peacock would have a miniseries in production.

before the autopsy was complete, and TikTok's armchair detectives could already have a theory about how the Zodiac killer was actually Mary's illegitimate son. But this is 1922, so it was just front-page hysteria day after day after day. There were exclusive, I'm saying that very sarcastically with very large finger quotes, exclusive interviews with everyone from distant cousins to former butlers. One tabloid even implied the killer was a German spy that Taylor had uncovered during the war. Another accused his valet, Henry Peavy, of being part of a gay love triangle gone wrong, based solely on the fact that Peavy had been arrested for, quote, lewd conduct in a public park and didn't act masculine enough while mourning. Peavy, of course, was black and the racism was blatant. The press dragged him mercilessly using coded language like unmanly and strange behavior, even though the police never charged him with anything related to the murder.

Yeah, as you said, the coded language was very big in the day. They wouldn't just come out and call somebody a homosexual. No, no, no. But, you know, everybody knew what they meant when they said unmanly and, you know, like flamboyant. Sure, there were code words too. Yeah. And can I just add that in 1922, being arrested for lewd conduct could have meant a lot of things and not necessarily for a fact mean that he was a pervy guy jumping out naked from behind the bushes. Let's talk about it for a second. When William Desmond Taylor mentioned that he'd bailed his valet Henry Peavy out of jail after he'd been arrested in a park for...

said lewd conduct, that phrase would have carried a lot of weight, but it also meant next to nothing, legally speaking. Lewd conduct was an extremely broad charge. It could absolutely mean something sexual or indecent by the moral standards of the time, but it could also mean something entirely benign. It didn't take much. Being alone in a park at night, especially if that park was known to the police as meeting place for gay men, that was enough. You didn't need to be caught in the act. You didn't even have to be talking to anyone. You just had to be there, just out for a walk in the evening, in the dark, through the park. That was it.

And yeah, as you said, Henry Peavy was black, which only made it easier for police to target him. This was Los Angeles in the 1920s, and racial profiling, harassment, and arrests without evidence were not exceptions. They were standard practice. It is also worth pointing out that the LAPD had a long tradition of using charges like lewd conduct to intimidate people, ruin reputations, or simply assert power. If you were poor, or queer, or in any way considered undesirable, this was the tool they could use. There were sting operations, false arrests, and plenty. Plenty of what we now call entrapment.

Yeah, it reminds me of like an early precursor to the stop and frisk movement where it was just a way to arrest people they wanted to arrest. So yeah, Henry Peavy, maybe he was engaging in something sexual. Maybe he just went for a walk in the wrong park at the wrong time, being the wrong color in class. We'll never know. One thing that's also worth mentioning, and I don't know what the situation was back at that time, but I know now, unless things have changed, if you were a man who was caught urinating in public.

In some states, that also carries an indecency charge with it. And this is the problem. You are then put on a sex offender registry because of having your genitals out in public. But I really struggle with that because I do think there's a very important difference between someone desperate for a pee and someone intentionally showing off genitalia to strangers for the fun of it. You know what I mean? I mean, I really hated that here in Vienna.

I've seen a lot of penises out because men urinate in the street and I hate it and I think there should be way harder punishments for that. fees to pay, but not being called a sex offender. Because as you said, there's a difference. There's a difference. Oh, no, it's the same. You know what I hate? Oh, I have such a rant about that. Yeah. But that's not the point. That's not this episode. But, you know, in Vienna, for women, it's so hard to find public toilets. And if there are, you have to pay 50 cent or a euro even now. And because they know women are just not going to pee in the streets. That's right. But for men, the urinals are often free of charge to use. And they're always open and never locked down. Yeah. Because they know men will just pee if they have to pee. So what the fuck? I agree.

I'm sorry that I have to be so open about this, but please make public toilets available for women. Yeah, I was just going to say, it reminds me of like when you walk around public gardens, sometimes like big parks or things like that, and you will always see men in bushes peeing, which is fine. Like, fine. But like, what are the women supposed to do? Maybe we should all just start squatting and peeing in public. And you know how hard it is nowadays to have 50 cent points with you? Everybody pays everything with their cards. Yep.

It's horror. No, I know. That's a very European thing, having to pay to use the toilets. And I always have to explain to people, you know, when we go overseas, but totally agree. I don't understand what the deal is. Why can't we just have, you know, free, clean public public restrooms, please? I would happily have my taxes cover that in places because we need them.

So what we do know is that this arrest, this one vaguely morally loaded phrase, got picked up in the press and fed into the narrative of secrets, vice and scandal surrounding William Desmond Taylor's murder. And that's all it took to make Henry Peavy get another convenient shadowy figure in a case that was full of them. Meanwhile, meanwhile, the who is who in Hollywood was publicly grieving William Desmond Taylor. I just love to say his full name. It's so fancy. Yes.

It's nice. This is from the Los Angeles Evening Post record, Monday, February 6th, 1922. Of course, page one. Quote, Mary Miles Minter lays rose on dead rent. Sounds weird. It does, yeah. A little. Quote. There's the breath of roses, scotch header and hyacinth in the air where Mary Miles Minter said goodbye to William Desmond Taylor. Crowding by the simple bronze casket to gaze upon the stern, silent face of the dead Canadian soldier and motion picture director, men and women, young and old, little guess today the affecting drama that had been enacted in the solemn little room of the Oberholzer Chapel at 10th and Hill Street. It was early Friday afternoon that Miss Minter came to view Desmond's body.

She carried a dozen black Prince roses intertwined with fern. That sounds lovely, by the way. I was going to say, I bet they were beautiful. And she saw the beloved form. Upon a couch, she burst into tears and asked a friend who was with her to leave the room. The door closed behind him, and for a few brief moments, she was alone with Taylor. Eyes overflow as she gazed at body. When Ivy H. Oberholzer, funeral director, opened the door, a little later she was standing bowed over the body, her tears falling upon the gray silk robe in which it was clothed. Oh. They couldn't say he, in which he was clothed. They had to call him an it there.

I get it, but. Turning to the mantle upon which she had placed the roses, she drew forth a single bud and laid it across Taylor's chest. Then, sobbing her grief, she left the room and was driven away in her car. Miss Minter's rose bore no card. Today, slightly withered but still fragrant, they adorned a green vase upon a mantle near the bronze casket. Underneath the casket was a spray of American beauty buds and Scotch heather sent by Mabel Normand. Attached was a plain little white envelope containing a card upon which the star had written her name.

Back off the little bouquet of white hyacinths that graced the casket, there may be another of those vague and delicate schoolgirl romances that add color to modern life. She was only a slip of a girl. Somewhat timidly, she left the automobile, crossed the street from the undertaking establishment, hurried up the steps, and left a floral tribute at the door. Beside the hyacinths lay a single English rose to which was attached a card signed Louis Ammons. And hearing these words, the English rose and the motion picture regret the loss of a great man.

Among the callers this morning was H.E. Stockwell, gray and slightly bent under his 73 years. I worked for him, he said, looking at the form in the casket. He was a fine man. Four years ago, I played the part of a minister presiding in a mission meeting in the slums in Kathleen Williams' picture out of the wreck. Under the dead director's name, the Motion Picture Directors Association has pressed in the prawn's casket a simple phrase, our big brother. There are two blue chevrons on the left sleeve of the captain's uniform. The head rests on a soft pillow of silk. The military cap lies at the base. End quote.

We would love to end this part with an article about William Desmond Taylor's funeral, which took place on February 7, 1922, which was a Tuesday. The following is from the Oakland Tribune, February 7, 1922, page 10. Quote, Thousands of Screen Folk Pay Taylor Final Homage by Pauline Payne International News Service Special Correspondent While hundreds of doves fluttered about the belfry and cooed in the eaves of that famous old landmark of Los Angeles, St. Paul's Cathedral, which stands facing Pershing Square, thousands of the most celebrated stars of the cinema world today, thronged to the picturesque Gothic church to pay final tribute to the murdered director, William Desmond Taylor, whose funeral was solemnized at 2 o'clock this afternoon. Perhaps never again will there be seen together so many of the internationally noted beauties of the screen or distinguished actors and producers.

as today were to be found weeping in the dignified old pews of the pro-cathedral, as the huge crowd of the morbidly curious. That's us. That's hi. He began to fill the streets about Pershing Square in an effort to gain at least a glimpse of the funeral cortege as the body was brought from a mortuary to be placed in the chancel of the Pro Cathedral. A special detail of police in charge of Sergeant McCaleb took command to prevent any undue demonstration or traffic congestion. That's a weird way of saying that he took he was in command of them. Just threw me for a second. Sergeant McCaleb was assisted by two specially detailed motorcycle policemen to keep the long lines.

sorry, to keep the long lines of motor cars, limousines, and elegant oops and electric sedans moving. And I can't stop laughing because it reminds me, if you know, you know, and your airports are maybe exactly the same, but if you're ever going to Boston Logan International Airport, we always tell people that they just have to get ready to drop and roll. And we'll just open up the back and let the bags fall out as we go because the police, the minute you pause to let someone out of the car or like get someone into the car. They start blowing their whistles and they're like, keep it moving. Really? Yes. And so sorry, that is immediately what I was like. Two specially detailed motorcycle policemen to keep the long line of motor cars, limousines and elegant coops. I just keep imagining like, let's keep it moving, folks. Keep it moving. If you know, you know. So although the casket, let me get the laughter out of my voice for that because this is serious. This is serious. It's all serious, but it's just funny to me because I'm a terrible person.

Although the casket, draped with the flag of Great Britain, was removed quietly from the mortuary parlors, where the dramatic ceremony was held over the body shortly after 12 o'clock, the crowds were already congesting the streets about the church when the cortege arrived. Immediately upon the arrival of the body at the cathedral, attendance of the church and intimate friends began bringing in the great masses of floral offerings which were kept at the parish churchyard. End quote. Oh, that's nice. Yeah, it all sounds very, very...

Posh and fancy. Dramatic. Dramatic, yeah, that's the word, dramatic. I also read in some other contemporary articles that both Mary and Mabel collapsed during or after the funeral and that Mabel even took a couple of weeks to recover. I could see that. But what do you expect from 1920 Hollywood silent movie stars? Right, right. Right? And honestly...

With Mabel, you know, especially Mabel, they were actually very, very close friends. It's, you know, we talk about, you know, she took a couple of weeks to recover, but that's nothing, you know, like when you lose a very dear, loved friend. I still constantly cry over my friend April, who's been gone 12 years. Madness, you know. Absolutely. Two weeks to recover is the least, you know. William Desmond Taylor's final resting place is in the Cathedral Mausoleum at Hollywood Forever Cemetery. He's tucked among a truly legendary cast of compatriots. You can still swing by and visit his crypt, by the way. Is it crypt or it's like, is it a crypt? Or a vault? Is it a? A vault, I think that's the vault I'm looking for. Anyway, it's marked under his birth name, William C. Dean Tanner. And once you're there, you can visit some other celebrities like Douglas Fairbanks, Cecil B. DeMille, Rodolfo Valentino.

Judy Garland, Mickey Rooney, Tyrone Power, trailer voice of the 80s and 90s, Don LaFontaine. In a world. In a world. Yeah, exactly. That guy. And even punk royalty with Johnny and Didi Ramon. So when you stand in that mausoleum, you're literally surrounded by Hollywood history. I want to go there so badly. And it's funny because I've been to San Francisco in the Bay Area and I've been to San Diego and I love both of them. And I haven't been to LA area yet. And I know the Moose wants to visit, but I was saying to Paul, I really feel like that's what I have to now wait for Johanna to do because... Oh, yeah. Like...

I feel like if you come out here, if we get you out here at some point, we could spend like a week here and then fly together to LA to do all the things. We definitely would have to take a drink at the Chateau Marmont. Yes, we got to stay there. One night, just one night. All the other places will stay at some scary seedy place. That's how I do it. You know, that's how I stayed at the Dell. We're going to end up in one of these, I don't want to say Airbnb, but you know what I mean, in the movie. What was it called? That just came out like two years ago, the horror movie. Oh. I'm completely blanking now. Get out? No, no, not get out. Barbarian.

Did you see that one? What was it? Barbarian? No, I haven't even heard of it. Watch it and that's the kind of place we're going to end up. I don't know about that, but you're probably right. Yeah, 100%. But yeah, we have to do old Hollywood together because I've never been. Have you been? You haven't been. No, no. Just been to the South. Yeah.

Which is also good. So. All right. Next week. That's it for this week. Next week, part three, we will talk you through what came after that. What we just talked this week, you know, the investigation. If we can even call it that. That's right. The long, long list of suspects. The studio, the wild theories. And yes, Annie's favorite supposed deathbed confession. So exciting. Did someone actually get away with murder? Yes, they did. Because we still don't know who did it. Spoiler alert. Yes, they did. Somebody got away with it. Do you have something good? No. I do.

I do. Okay. My mom always recommends movies and TV shows to me. And usually they're not, you know, my kind of tea. And I'm always like, yeah, yeah. They're probably the kind of stuff I like. And I'm always like, yeah, I gotta put it on my list. I gotta watch it. I never watch it. I never do. So my mom was here. She slept over and I watched...

Drop that gorgeous with her and she loved it. And then she said, can we watch the ghosts? She's obsessed with the ghosts. I love the ghosts. The British ghosts, the German ghosts, the American ghosts. And she loves the American ghosts the most. They're all so good. And I'm like, okay, fine. We're gonna watch the ghosts. Rolling my eyes internally because I thought if my mom recommends it, I must hate it. It's gonna be stupid. Sorry, mom. And then I couldn't stop watching and kept watching and watching until it was like midnight and every time we were just like, okay, just one more. And she watched it now for the third time with me. And so next day she went home and I kept watching and the whole time she was texting, are you still watching the ghosts? And which episode are you yet? And the ghosts and the ghosts. And then...

It's this kind of bonding. I love this. And she's so excited because I finally love something that she recommended. And she's like, which ghost would you be? And I would be this ghost. And it's the cutest thing. Which ghost would you be? Which ghost is mom? I think my mom would be... Well, I don't think my mom would be a ghost. I think my mom would be... If she were a ghost, she would be Pete. But she's more like Sam. And I think I would be Isaac. You know, like the historical know-it-all. Yes. I am afraid that I'm a weird combination of...

Oh God, I'm going to mess up people's names. I think I'm a weird, I'm like a combination of Hetty and who's the singer? Alberta. But then a little bit of flower mixed in. I feel like if Hetty, flower, and Roberta... You're a little bit of flower, definitely, with the forgetting things. Forgetting things and just getting confused. I have no short-term, I have no functional short-term memory anymore. It's fine. This is fine. And then it was so cute because she's just watching it on Netflix, and there's just two seasons. And she's just watching it with the German, the dubbed version, because she doesn't speak English. And she was like, you think they're ever going to make another season? And so I looked it up on IMDb, and there's still like, season five is coming out.

And on Amazon here, I just bought season three, the dubbed version. And she's going to come on Friday and I told her, mom, I have another season of the ghost. And she's like, oh, my God, I'm so excited. Oh, I love this. She doesn't even know which ghost went up. I love that. So I want to watch the German one. I got to figure out how Misty and I can watch the German one dubbed or with subtitles or something. I got to see if I find a link for you. Yeah, because I've seen the British one and the American one, but not the German one. And I'm a big fan. Big, big fan. Remember when I told you last week that there was a spindly garden spider hanging out in the corner? So now there's now there's two.

There's two of them now, Johanna. He has a little friend. It's not. I know. It's another big one. So again, as long as they stay in that corner, it's fine. I just have to remember to leave the office door open in case something flies in so they can eat it. Otherwise, I don't know how they're surviving. Oh, they're gonna. Trust me. I have this toilet spider now living with me for well over a year. Yeah. It's still the same toilet spider? It's still the same. I hadn't seen the toilet spider for like...

I want to say three months. And I thought the toilet spider died or maybe somebody killed it and didn't tell me, you know, people are like this. And I was really, I mean, this is sort of weird because I'm scared of spiders, but I'm getting better now that we live in the house. But I was kind of sad because like, oh, the toilet spider is dead. And then like three weeks ago, the toilet spider was there again. And it's the same toilet spider. That's awesome. I took a look. Yeah. Is it a jumpy one? Is it one of the fuzzy jumpers or is it? I don't think we have the fuzzy jumpers here. I found a fuzzy jumper in the house last week, Johanna, and I let it out of the house.

I picked it up with a piece of paper, you know, like a piece of tissue in my hand and just gently. I think that there is a family of them had babies on my back deck because there's been so many of them this year. And I'm so glad that that account with the little fuzzy jumping spiders has made me like I feel guilty for accidentally killing them and trying to get them away from me previously. Now, you know, I'm trying to have a lot more confidence and less fear around arachnids, at least the ones I can see. It's very hard, I know. It's the ones you can't see that you really have to be scared of, isn't it? Spiders, mostly. You know what else I wanted to mention that was something good? A longtime friend of the show, Brendan, who's been in our patron group and a listener since way, way early on, just got engaged. Congratulations. Yeah, that's something good. Congratulations, Brendan. So excited. The great Brandini. I know. He messaged me yesterday. Not yesterday. I don't know when it was. I have no sense of time. He messaged me the other day and he said that he's going to send us an invitation. I'm like, we're going to try to be there. Very exciting news indeed. Yes. So, yeah, I think that's it. That's it.

If you liked this episode, please take a moment to rate, review, and subscribe. It truly helps more than you know. Also, please recommend us to anyone who might be interested. Word of mouth is incredibly valuable for independent podcasting. Yes, and you can now subscribe on Spotify and YouTube for early access and bonus content, or support us directly on Patreon, where you get your weekly cinema macabre and monthly live get-togethers, among other things. That's right. Come join our Facebook group, check out our website at freshhellpodcast.com, or email us your theories, comments, or Halloween story submissions, and your alligator and crocodile stories to freshhellpodcast at gmail.com. Just easy as that. And it is that time again for spooky fuckery season, and like last year, there will be a giveaway. So make sure you like our Facebook page, join our Facebook group, check out our...

Instagram. And if snail mail is your thing, you can send us something at our PO box. That's on our webpage as well. Yeah. Also, if you sent us your Halloween submission already in previous years and we didn't use it in one of the episodes, please do me the huge favor and send it again. I kind of don't find anything anymore. I had like an extra folder and it's all like gone. I'm sorry. I'm terrified of our mail. I'm terrified of it because I feel like I get it. Like I'm, yeah, I'm, I'm the worst. I'm sorry. Please tell your pets. We said hi, hug them, cuddle them, kiss them, treat them kindly.

Be kind to your fellow human being. And most importantly, no, I always say that. It's not what I mean. It's not most importantly. It's also important. All is equally important. Be kind to yourself. It is important to be kind to yourself, for sure. And as Winston Churchill once famously said, if you're going through hell, keep going. Tschüss. Bye.

Right now, in the most profitable countries in the world, millions are sleeping on the streets. More are losing their battles with addiction. Somewhere else in the world, a disease is spreading faster than we can track it. Nuclear treaties have unraveled and the risk of war hangs in the balance. These aren't separate crises. They're colliding in this moment while the systems built to stop them are falling apart. Meanwhile, the doomsday clock has moved closer to midnight than it's ever been. It's 85 seconds to midnight.

My name is Jackie Maranti, and I host a show called Cause of Death, 100 Seconds to Midnight. If you haven't listened to my podcast, you should. Horror movies did not invent most of the things that scare us. History did. You've seen seances, haunted houses, cursed objects, werewolves, creepy puppets, ghosts, and occult rituals. But what if the history behind these things is even more wild than how they're depicted on screen? That's the idea behind Lunatics Radio Hour. Hi, I'm Abby here with Alan. Hello. And we're horror filmmakers and enthusiasts. We trace the things you see in horror back to their historical roots. Where did the idea of the vampire come from? Why did people eat dried up mummies? Why did a bunch of clowns riot in 1855? And why did people dance themselves to death in 1518?

Every episode starts with something familiar from horror, folklore, or the supernatural, and then we go backwards. Into the history, beliefs, traditions, and real events that helped create it. Because sometimes the strangest part of a horror story is finding out that people really believed it. Lunatics Radio Hour, the history of horror. Listen wherever you get your podcasts.

Frequently asked questions

How long is this episode of Fresh Hell Podcast?

This episode is 1 hour and 13 minutes long.

When was this Fresh Hell Podcast episode published?

This episode was published on August 8, 2025.

Is there a transcript available for this episode?

Yes, a full transcript is available for this episode. You can read the complete transcript on the episode page.

Can I download this Fresh Hell Podcast episode?

Yes. Use the download control on the episode player to save the publisher-provided media file.