Skip to content
E294: MURDER - William Desmond Taylor episode artwork

Aug 15, 2025 1 hr 16 min

E294: MURDER - William Desmond Taylor

from Fresh Hell Podcast Hosted by freshhellpodcast

In the third and final part of this Hollywood murder saga, we talk about the murder scene, all the possible suspects! Who had a motive? And who may have been protected by the studio system at all costs?We’ll walk you through the possible killers — from studio insiders and jilted lovers to the ones no one saw coming — and look at how the investigation quickly fell apart under pressure from powerful forces. We also take a closer look at Margaret Gibson’s jaw-dropping deathbed confession, and what, if anything, it actually proves.And finally, we’ll tell you what happened to all the major players in the years and decades after the murder that shocked early Hollywood. Keywords:william desmond taylor, hollywood murder, silent film scandal, margaret gibson, mary miles minter, mabel normand, charlotte shelby, early hollywood, unsolved mystery, true crime podcast, fresh hell podcast, hollywood forever cemetery, studio cover-up, 1920s hollywood, deathbed confession, classic hollywood, vintage true crime, film history, roscoe arbuckle era, murder mystery

Episode details come from the podcast's RSS feed.

Embed this episode

Ready to play

E294: MURDER - William Desmond Taylor

0:00 1:16:47
of matches

Transcript Auto-generated, may contain errors

Looking for a hauntingly unique podcast this spooky season? Listen to I Talk to Ghosts for chilling ghost stories, genuine in-studio medium readings, and a virtual seance table where the spirits have an opportunity to speak directly to you. Find I Talk to Ghosts on all the fine podcast apps, including Apple Podcasts, Spotify, and YouTube. Happy haunting. What will you be scared of next?

You're listening to the Fresh Hell podcast. Fresh Hell contains stories of a disturbing and often graphic nature and is intended for a mature audience. Please don't let your kids listen to this or they might turn out like us. Hi, I'm Annie from Boston. And I'm Johanna from Austria. And you're listening to your favorite international podcast. The podcast hosted by two women who never met in real life and who really don't need to in order to be real friends and in order to run this podcast together. That's very true. So, Johanna, I have a problem. The corner spider from last week that had a friend.

I don't see the friend, Johanna. There's only one spider. Maybe the friend was not a permanent guest. Maybe he just, you know, came over for a cup of spider tea and then just went back home. Oh, maybe he went behind the curtain to try to catch bugs or something. All right. This is fine. This is... Listen. Oh, wait. Is that... No, that's not him. All right. Maybe he'll reappear. I just hope he's not in my hair because I feel like he's for sure in my hair. Okay. Let's talk about murder because the spider situation is upsetting.

Sorry, friends. Hi. If you're enjoying the main show and you want even more fresh hell in your ears, you want us in your ears more. If you want us to be in your ears more and eyes, come join us on Patreon. That's where we host Cinema Macabre, our weekly bonus series where we watch true crime inspired television so you don't have to. So far, we've discussed the penile chaos of Welcome to Chippendales, the adulterous nightmares of candy, and the fake luxury world of inventing Anna. It's great.

It's like I always say, why watch a 20-minute TV show when you can listen to the two of us describe it to you in approximately 97 minutes? Right? It's so true. You'll also get access to our monthly live get-togethers. So, listen, independent podcasting only works because of listeners like you, and we're incredibly grateful for every single one of our patrons. So come hang out with us over on Patreon. We saved you a seat. Yes, and thank you to everyone who keeps supporting our show, no matter in what way. All of you are important.

Just one more info about Cinema Macabre during the summer weeks. While Annie is being fancy traveling, I will entertain you with some minisodes talking about old movies. And once all the traveling is done, I think that's going to be okay, but we will tackle a brand new true crime show. We haven't decided on which one yet. So if you have any suggestions or wishes, let us know, right? Definitely.

Alright, now let's dive into part three of the William Desmond Taylor case. Annie, give us the quickest of recaps, please. I would love to. As always, though, if you haven't yet listened to part one and part two, please do that before listening to this final part. Otherwise, you'll be missing out on a lot of vital information on what's even going on. For everyone who needs a quick refresher, in part one, we look at the life of William Desmond Taylor, born William Cunningham Dean Tanner in Ireland, who reinvented himself in America after abandoning his wife and child. We follow his rise through early Hollywood as a respected director.

his connections to major stars like Mabel Normand and Mary Miles Minter, and the carefully curated persona he built in the public eye. We also explore the glamour and rot of 1920s Los Angeles, the studios, the scandals, the drugs. In part two, we covered the final days of Taylor's life and the chaotic aftermath of his murder. We discussed his close friendship with Mabel Normand, the crime scene, the studio interference, and the bizarre arrival of Mary Miles Minter and her mother, Charlotte Shelby. We ended with a full-blown media circus that followed, which shattered careers in the process. Yes, thank you. So last week we told you how Mary Miles Minter first claimed that she had been engaged to William Desmond Taylor only for her PR machine then making her deny those claims and how that ultimately was a big part.

that led to the end of her career. This is from the Riverside Daily Press, Friday, February 3rd, 1922, page 1. Mary Miles Minter denies engagement, quote. No, I was never engaged to Mr. Taylor, I regret to say. The youthful actress told the United Press today. Stories that I visited him at his home on the afternoon of the day he was murdered are absurd. I was at my home reading a book. I've seen very little of him since my return from Europe some months ago. He didn't have an enemy in the world. He was too fine a man. Everyone admired and respected him. I doubt the rumors that he was married and has a daughter in the East.

He would surely have told me so if it were true. To my mind, William Desmond Taylor can be compared only to God. I could use every adjective of praise in the English language, and still I could not explain to you what a wonderful man he was. End quote. So Los Angeles police got to work on what was supposed to be a proper murder investigation. Unfortunately, they were already several steps behind. The scene had been contaminated, studio executives had removed who knows what, and the media was circling like seagulls around an open picnic basket.

But officially, the case was on. Let's start with what investigators actually did find at the scene. In William Desmond Taylor's pockets, police found a wallet containing $78 in cash, which today would be just under $1,500. That's a good amount of money to have in cash at home, I think. That is a not insignificant amount of money. Although, we also have to remember, these are the days before credit cards and things, really, right? So, if you were going to be running some errands, going grocery shopping, I don't know. I assume if you had it like a man...

What's the word for like a... I keep wanting to say manservant, but that's not quite the vibe I'm going for. Well, his valet, you know, right? His valet, exactly. It's like, it keeps reminding me of, like, in Inventing Anna, the attorney who, and his wife, that side, you know, Anthony Edwards plays, and, like, how every morning, like, his breakfast is ready, and here's his paper, turned to the section he likes. Like, how do you get one of those? Does anyone know specifically? I mean, there are these, yeah, there are these, usually, well, if you're British, for example, but also the very wealthy Americans hired them directly from the Butler School, which is in Britain, yeah. This is why I need the lottery.

think of everything that i could get done if i had someone way more capable than me just organizing my life for me amazing absolutely anyway So yeah, so he has this cash in his pockets, which as we said, that's a lot of cash. He also had a silver cigarette case, a Waltham pocket watch from right here in Waltham, Massachusetts, very famous industrial area. He had a pen knife and something that we thought was very bittersweet. He had a small locket with a photo of Mabel Normand inside. On his hand was a two carat diamond ring, all valuable, all untouched. So it doesn't seem like robbery was at all likely. Even if they would have thought, well, we cannot sell them.

You know, the monogrammed silver cigarette case or the ring because it's, you know, it's going to raise questions. But the money, they will have taken the money. Totally. Why wouldn't you have taken the money, right? So according to Taylor's accountant, the director had shown him a large amount of cash the day before. Money that now couldn't be found anywhere. And it was never recovered and never traced. So if robbery wasn't the motive, was it a staged scene? Or was the cash removed in the flurry of unauthorized visitors before the police arrived? It's frustrating because we just can't know. There's so many unknowns the way the scene was so contaminated.

And I mean, it's also possible that people, the looky-loos started to take stuff like as a souvenir right away. Totally. If somebody walks into like his office or his bedroom or whatever, however the house was, and just sees a giant pile of cash there, why wouldn't you take some of it? Who's going to know? This is pre-hidden cameras everywhere, you know? Yeah. I mean, he's not going to need it anymore, right? I can totally see somebody saying that, right? Of course, yeah. So...

The official time of death was eventually set at 7.50pm on February 1st, 1922, just 15 minutes after Mabel Norman had left his bungalow. If that's accurate, then the killer either watched her go, this is, I don't like this, watched her go, slipped into the bungalow through the unlocked door, and so, snuck in that way? Or maybe the murderer was already inside, like hiding somewhere waiting. That's, I don't like that at all. That part. Both options are terrifying. No, that's the scariest. Oh, okay. So when police began to speak with Taylor's friends and colleagues, things got even murkier. A couple of studio acquaintances claimed that Taylor had recently mentioned receiving strange and unsettling phone calls. Now that could mean something, or it could be classic Hollywood attention seeking. Everyone wanted to be a part of the story.

And some people, whether consciously or not, started inserting themselves into the narrative. I was going to say, you know, I almost wonder if some of the calls Taylor received mentioning as being strange and unsettling were from Mary. Do you know what I mean? Like if he was getting these like daddy, daddy, daddy, I love you, I love you, I love you, I love you. That would be because like we said, I think we mentioned last week, like I don't think either of us think that he saw her in any kind of romantic way.

But, of course, this also includes Mary Miles Minter, because then she dropped the bombshell that Taylor had once confided in a mutual friend, uh, director Marshall Nealon. According to Mary, Nealon had told her that Taylor had become quote-unquote delusional in the weeks leading up to his death. He supposedly made paranoid or bizarre statements about some of his social acquaintances, including Mary herself. And Nealon apparently believed Taylor was slipping into quote-unquote unsanity. Do we believe this? Maybe? Maybe not? It's hard to know if this was a genuine concern.

or just damage control disguised as posthumous diagnosis, right? What we do know is that the case was instantly radioactive. Los Angeles Undersheriff Eugene Biscaluz, who would later go on to head the California Highway Patrol, warned a reporter from the Chicago Tribune, quote, The industry has been hurt. Stars have been ruined. Stockholders have lost millions of dollars. A lot of people are out of jobs and incensed enough to take a shot at you, end quote. And that, right there, tells you everything about the tone of the investigation.

It truly seemed as if the goal weren't solving a murder, that the bigger goal was to minimize any possible fallout. Even decades later, in 1968, director Cain Vidore said he interviewed one of the original detectives on the case, William Michael Cahill Sr. According to Vidore, Cahill admitted, quote, we were doing all right, and then, before a week was out, we got the word to lay off, end quote. That's so crazy, right? Yeah. Could it also be like this was used as an excuse because the police didn't really, maybe they were not doing all right and having like, but then again, I mean, we know so many stories of these things happening in the old time and golden era of Hollywood where they really, the studios really heavily influenced police investigation. Oh, yes. Anyway, there were at least a few suspects and theories and I think it's time to talk about them. Let's start with Mabel Normand. Of all the names linked to William Desmond Taylor's murder, Mabel Normand is the one that makes people go, wait, seriously?

For a good reason. So Mabel, we told you a lot about her already. She was a Hollywood powerhouse. Brilliant, brilliant comic, comedic actor, writer, director. But in 1922, she was also battling a serious cocaine addiction. I think she was also an alcoholic. Deep exhaustion. And, you know, I also mentioned last week this fallout and this kind of fear she had ever since her friend Olive Thomas had died the year earlier. So Mabel had been going through hell and she had met Taylor around that time and they became very close friends very fast.

He was older, educated, and stable, and she was this whirlwind. And I think that's what she really needed. He was giving her stability and support that she desperately needed. And their friendship and their bond, I think, was really genuine. The exact nature of their relationship is still debated. Were they friends? Were they lovers? Were they a little bit of both? Whatever it was, I think Taylor really deeply cared about Mabel. And I really think he tried to help her and save her and urge her to get clean and to check into a sanatorium.

What then would have been her motive? Could she have been involved in his murder? Well, first, she was the last known person to see him alive. That's never a great look, right? As we told her last week, she left around, I think, 7.47, 7.45 p.m. And how would she even have done it? He walked her right to her car with a driver. Mabel got in and drove off. And this is confirmed by her driver. And what motive would there have been?

I mean, one line of gossip was that William had threatened to expose the drug dealers supplying Hollywood. And again, not for his own benefit, but to protect Mabel and probably other friends he had. I'm sure he had other friends who were battling the same issues. Oh, yeah. He was furious about to hold drugs head over her and supposedly wanted to go public. That's the rumors, right? That's the gossip. And if that would have been true, and that's a big if here, it opens the door to all kinds of sinister possibilities. Like, was Mabel afraid he'd name her? That that would ruin her career?

Did someone else connected to her want him silenced? Let's be very clear here, there is no real evidence linking Mabel to the murder. She was grilled by the LAPD for hours multiple times and her alibi held. She was cooperative, she was absolutely devastated, she even offered a reward for information. I read somewhere thousand dollars, which would be like twenty thousand dollars today.

And it was Mabel who shared with police that William had bailed out Henry Peavy, his valet, that very morning. And that's, you know, that's what started them going after him and the press going after him. Her name, Mabel Norman's name, was dragged through the mud. And the press was brutal. They accused her of everything from romantic obsession to being a drug mule. And the truth, probably, Mabel was a deeply troubled woman, but not a killer. She had her demons, yeah. She was connected to multiple scandals, but even the most creative tablet writers struggled to make her a convincing suspect once all the facts were there.

Like, I just don't see a timeline where that could have worked. No, I don't think that they had a romantic relationship. I do think that he was gay. And we'll talk more about that maybe at the end. But I don't think he would have ever been romantically interested in her, which is partly why she was able to trust him to the depth that she did. I think they had a deep, deep connection in the way that, you know, it's kind of a trope sometimes, isn't it? Women having gay male friends. But the sad truth is that most men.

will not probably experience a really deep friendship in the way that women experience friendship. Women tend to be much more, and this is obviously not a blanket statement, I'm not talking about everybody, but in the broader scheme of things, especially back in 1922, your relationships with women would have been much, much, much closer than they even could have been with men, especially in 1922. You think so? Yes. I think the relationship between women started...

I think for a very long time, women have been made have been better against each other and made to feel like competition all the time. Yeah, I understand that. That's never been. I mean, I think that can be an issue. Fortunately, that's not really been like my feeling is like we can't be competing because I want you to win too. I just think that they were very, very close friends. And I think she knew who he really was in his soul and accepted him because she wasn't a conventional person, you know.

No, I agree. I too think there was nothing romantic between them. I think they were family. I think they were chosen family and loved each other deeply, very deeply. I mean, he had an amulet with her picture in it on him the day he died. And there were three photos in the house, like on the grand piano. But she's a safe person too. Like if she knows what his deepest secret is, then it's easy for him to have pictures of his best friend, you know, his family out and let people draw their own conclusions. Because then if people don't know, it's easier for him to focus on his true relationship, you know?

Yeah. Well, so we both agree that it's not, it wasn't Mabel. She didn't have anything to do with it. So now that brings us to the other superstar that was involved in this murder. America's sweetheart, Mary Miles Minter. With her long golden curls, corseline face, and squeaky clean image. So let's talk about motive first. Mary made it no secret that she was infatuated with William Desmond Taylor. She admired him, adored him, idolized him.

She also told people she loved him. Whether he returned those feelings? Well, that's unclear. There are sources that suggest he cared deeply for her but maintained a platonic, perhaps even paternal, relationship. Others think there may have been a brief affair. What we do know is that she wrote him a lot of letters. Some of them were cringe-level dramatic, even by silent movie standards. Remember the one that was just I love you, I love you, I love you, I love you, I love you 50 times or however many times? It's like, that's the one you expect to find like hair or toenail clippings or something. You know what that reminds me of? You remember that scene in... Now I wonder if they took that from there. You remember that scene in...

Singing in the Rain. Yes. Where they are doing the first talkie. And Gene Kelly has this monologue where he kisses her arm and he's like, I love you, I love you, I love you, I love you, I love you. Remember that? I do. Oh, I wonder. Because they also took the name of Norma Desmond from Sunset Boulevard. That's actually a fact. They took Desmond's name, middle name, and Mabel Norman's name. They kind of put that in there. That was the inspiration for the name Norma Desmond. I love that.

So maybe the I love you, I love you, I love you, I love you is like they took that from another overdramatic silent film. It totally could be. Yeah. But that love you, I love you letter, that was among the stack of letters that police did find when they searched Taylor's bungalow. She'd written to him often, sometimes several times a day. One theory is that Mary was devastated by rejection. If Taylor had ended things or had never reciprocated her feelings to begin with, did she lash out in a moment of jealous rage? Did she show up uninvited? Was there an argument that turned deadly? It's all, of course, pure speculation. But public sympathy turned to suspicion. Legally.

Mary was never an official suspect. She was questioned, sure, but the LAPD and the DA focused most of their attention elsewhere. But still, the damage was done. Taylor's death didn't just end his life, it pretty much ended Mary's career. The scandal haunted her even though there was never a shred of real evidence tying her to the crime. But the love letters, the sudden appearance at the bungalow, and the wildly conflicting narratives, it all made her a character in a real-life film noir.

Right now, in the most profitable countries in the world, millions are sleeping on the streets. More are losing their battles with addiction. Somewhere else in the world, a disease is spreading faster than we can track it. Nuclear treaties have unraveled and the risk of war hangs in the balance. These aren't separate crises. They're colliding in this moment while the systems built to stop them are falling apart. Meanwhile, the doomsday clock has moved closer to midnight than it's ever been. It's 85 seconds to midnight.

My name is Jackie Maranti, and I host a show called Cause of Death, 100 Seconds to Midnight. If you haven't listened to my podcast, you should. Hey, Fresh Hell fans. My name is Brandon Sheck-Snyder, and I'm the host of the podcast Southern Gothic, a show that explores the history behind some of the American South's darkest days, greatest mysteries, and most chilling ghost stories. Look, I know you enjoy listening to podcasts. I mean, you are here, right? So I just want to invite you to give Southern Gothic a listen as well. Together, we'll explore some notorious haunts like the legend of the Bell Witch and the infamous Waverly Hills Sanatorium, as well as a number of the absolute eeriest legends and pieces of local lore that...

I bet you ain't never heard of. So y'all, join me on Southern Gothic, available now on all your favorite podcast apps. So let's continue with Mary's mother, Charlotte Shelby. And let's talk about her background for a minute, because I think we didn't really touch upon that yet. So she was born Lily Pearl Miles in Louisiana in 1877. And from a very early age, she understood that the world didn't offer many opportunities to women who were not willing to make their own.

She was ambitious, calculating, and very, very focused on one goal, turning her daughters into stars. And it worked, at least for a while. Her older daughter, Margaret Shelby, was the first to be pushed into the spotlight, but it was her younger daughter, Juliet Riley, of course, under her stage name, Mary Miles Minter, who became the family's golden goose in a way. Charlotte lied about Mary's age to get her into film work, falsified documents to make her eligible for acting, because they already had protection for children back then, which I found interesting. I thought that came way later.

Then she basically took over every aspect of Mary's life. She controlled her daughter's finances, career, and even her personal relationship. Charlotte's control obviously came with a cost. Margaret became deeply resentful and struggled with addiction and mental illness. Mary, for her part, seemed alternately adoring her mother and then also be terrified of her. Mary, at times, was earning tens of thousands. And I think I read that Charlotte was funneling a good chunk of that into real estate investments all over Los Angeles. And I think she just planned that if Mary ever decided to cut ties...

or, you know, God forbid, get married and stop acting, then Charlotte's gravy train might end, run off the tracks, and then she would have a decent nest egg. If this was a murder mystery novel, Charlotte Shelby would be the character you side-eye from page one. You'd think she can't be the murderer because she's such an obvious one, right? She's overbearing, ambitious, she has all these secrets, and allegedly a very handy little pistol. Charlotte wasn't just Mary Miles Minter's mother, she was her manager, her gatekeeper, and also, in a way, her jailer. And, in many ways, the architect of Mary's very short but very spectacular career.

She lived through her daughter's fame, micromanaged every single decision and had complete financial control. And yeah, Mary made a fortune and basically Charlotte kept most of it. So when Mary fell in love with William Desmond Taylor, a man 20 years or more than 20 years her senior, Charlotte's reaction wasn't exactly warm. By some accounts, she detested him. Not because he was older. She didn't care about that, I think. Not because he was technically still married. I don't think they even knew that at that point. But because he posed a threat. Not just to Mary's career, but to Charlotte's power over Mary.

Let's talk about motive, and I think we already have a couple going on here. Charlotte had plenty of motives. Taylor reportedly tried to distance himself from Mary, whether it was because of her age, his own past, pressure from the studio, we don't know any of that. But Mary was deeply attached, and Charlotte was always looking out for Charlotte. She may have seen this as the start of a shift in the power balance. A man like Taylor with his own money, with influence and morals, if he married Mary, he could push Charlotte out of the picture entirely.

He was probably also the exact kind of man who might say to a young woman, you know, maybe your mother shouldn't be controlling your entire life. And Charlotte was not having that. Some rumors claimed Taylor had been helping Mary gain control over her finances, or at least he was discussing it with her, and that alone would have been a deal-breaker for Charlotte. Even worse, the idea that Taylor might expose some of her financial maneuverings if Mary found out how her money had really been handled... I mean, allegedly, we don't know if Mary knew all the things.

Charlotte did with her money. Right. You know what I mean? I do, yeah. But yeah, if that could have happened, it could have meant lawsuits, jail time, oblique humiliation, and I'm pretty sure Charlotte wanted nothing of that. Remember that older guy who had an affair with Jean H. Mary, James Kirkwood Sr. We already read to you a part of the memorandum in, I think it was part one of this trilogy, and we said we will get to it a little bit more. And here are two more excerpts. Quote.

Investigation at the present time, although handicapped by the passage of time, indicate that Kirkwood was in Los Angeles at the time of the Taylor murder at about 7.45pm on the night of February 1st, 1922. He may have even been working on the same lot with Mary. All directories of the period give his address as the Los Angeles Athletic Club. then the habitat of many screen personalities, including Mickey Nealon and others. It was at the club that the story was widely circulated that Mary one night went to Taylor's bungalow and taking off all her clothes, begging him to have intercourse with her. Mrs. Shelby is said to have arrived a few minutes after Mary left and demanded her daughter. Taylor refused to have anything to do with the girl after. It is well established, however, that the mother considered Taylor a menace to her control over her money-making daughter and hated him accordingly. In a statement taken in New York in 1925 by former chief deputy district attorney Harold Davis, Mary recites that her mother tore up the earth

when any man came around her. She recalled on one occasion, according to the transcript of the statement, that she was present at the railroad station in Santa Barbara or Los Angeles with Kirkwood and others, and the mother, being momentarily displeased with Mary, asserted that she would kill anyone that came between her and Mary. That's a direct quote. So she said directly, I would kill anyone that came between me and Mary. Man or woman, and even included a dog belonging to one of the company.

The theory of every person closely connected with the Taylor case, Taylor's personal friends, intimates of the Shelby family, has always been that Mrs. Shelby either killed Taylor or influenced some other person to do it. It appears that Kirkwood had a romantic interest in Mary at the time of the murder and was also in a position to have been under the domination of Mrs. Shelby. He had committed statutory rape when he had intercourse with Mary at the age of 15 and he was still married to his first wife in 1922 and seeking a divorce. And then the memorandum continues. The mother then took this collection of letters and kept them

In a safe deposit box, they were given to Mary recently when Mary's mother supposedly kept these letters to hold over Mary's head. But Mary says that throughout the many rows between her and her mother, since that the letter never mentioned the missives. Sorry, it's so hard for me to read. This one's a hard... It's somehow weird. Yeah, this one's really hard to read.

Margaret says that her mother once declared that she was keeping the letters so if anyone ever accused her of murdering Taylor, that she could prove that if she was ever going to murder anyone, she would have murdered Kirkwood at the time. The assortment of letters from Kirkwood contain little factual evidence and are mostly devoted to the outpouring of a man obviously infatuated with the young screen star. He speaks of writing two and three letters a day and all the missives were ended in a long series of X's or Kisses. Typical of the character of these fervent letters, is the following extract. Quote, my sweetheart, my wife, the mother of my children. End quote. The last salutation was underlined. In the letter, Mary wrote telling Kirkwood that all was over. She mentions an operation performed by Dr. Hutchinson.

It seems that Kirkwood or Mrs. Shelby arranged for this abortion. Only five persons says Mary ever knew of the extent of this romance. These were her mother, her grandmother, now dad, her sister and Kirkwood. Mary claims that this definitely ended her romance with Kirkwood and that when she met William Desmond Taylor a year or two later that she realized that her affair with Kirkwood was merely an infatuation and that she really was in love with Taylor. She says, however, that a year after Taylor's murder in February 1922 that Kirkwood came to her and wanted to marry her. She says she refused him because she was still in love with Taylor's ghost.

And a short time later, having obtained a divorce from his first wife, he married Lila Lee. End quote. She was still in love with William Desmond Taylor's ghost. She just didn't want to marry a rapist. That's right. Okay, now let's talk opportunity. So Charlotte owned a rare .38 caliber pistol, the same caliber used to kill Taylor. That detail alone is enough to keep her in the suspect pool forever. When police asked her about the gun, she said it had been stolen years earlier, which is convenient.

Even more suspicious, after Taylor's death, Charlotte allegedly fled to Europe with Mary. She stayed gone just long enough for the heat to die down. When she returned, she refused to cooperate with investigators. And when the case was reopened years later, she fought to keep certain court documents sealed. Why? In 1938, Charlotte's other daughter, Margaret, reportedly accused her mother of the murder. And a grand jury opened an inquiry, but nothing ever came of it. No charges and no arrest.

Was it because Charlotte was innocent, or because the case had gone cold and Hollywood still didn't want its skeletons dragged out into daylight? Either way, Charlotte's reputation never recovered. She spent the rest of her life denying she had anything to do with the murder. And to be fair, there's no direct evidence that she pulled the trigger. But of all the suspects, Charlotte Shelby had the means, motive, and an absolute lack of remorse required to be the villain in this particular story.

By the way, you might wonder, and fair enough, how anyone could seriously suspect a woman when we have an eyewitness who swore she saw a man leaving the scene. That brings us back to Faith McLean, the neighbor who caught a glimpse of someone exiting Taylor's bungalow just minutes after the presumed time of death. At the time, she described the figure as a man in a slouch hat and muffler. Sounds like someone from the movies, which honestly describes everyone in this case. It's true. Everyone. Everyone, yeah. But in a later interview, Faith admitted something that throws a wrench into everything.

She couldn't actually be sure it was a man. The figure was bundled up, the lighting was poor, and whoever it was moved quickly and in a very non-descriptive way. She said that the person could just as easily have been a woman dressed as a man. It also cast doubt on how much weight we can give to any of the early statements made during what was, let's be honest, total chaos. Yeah, so we talk a lot about how insanely unreliable eyewitness testimony is. It's really not as reliable as you'd think it is. No. Anyway, we're not done yet with the list of suspects. Next up, Edward Sands.

If William Desmond Taylor's murder were a game of glue, Edward Sands would be the valet with a motive. Sands was indeed Taylor's former personal valet and secretary, and he was hired in 1920. And right from the start, this guy was sketchy. He had a background thick with petty crimes, including forgery, embezzlement, and desertion from the US Navy. He had a habit of using fake names, and he had previously been employed by multiple households, usually just long enough to learn where the valuables were before moving on. Or rather, disappearing. With the valuables.

Despite that, Taylor trusted him. I mean, I'm sure he didn't know anything about all of this, right? So he hired him, he left him in charge of his home when he traveled. And this obviously turned out to be a terrible idea. In 1921, while Taylor was away on a trip to Europe and New York, Sands forged Taylor's name on checks, Taylor's signature, raked up personal charges on Taylor's accounts, and then robbed his home. He made off with clothes, jewelry, and I think Taylor's car, which he ditched in Glendale that was later found. Taylor, surprisingly, didn't press charges for a reason we can only guess.

Maybe he didn't want a public scandal. Maybe there was more to their relationship than we know. Or maybe he just thought Sands wasn't worth the trouble. Whatever the reason was, he replaced Sands with Henry Peavy and tried to move on. And in the weeks before Taylor's death, there were signs that Sands might have returned to Los Angeles. You remember those disturbing phone calls Taylor had allegedly talked about? Yeah. Some believed Sands had been hanging around the neighborhood and it was speculated that he might have tried to contact Taylor again. Or scare him. Or possibly even extort him. And so when Taylor was murdered, Sands immediately became a suspect.

But by then, he had vanished. Again, poof, gone. Never formally seen or heard from again. Investigators were never able to find him. There were reported sightings, some believable, most of them not believable at all. One source claimed he was working as a cook in a remote location. Another one had him overseas and decades later, in 1936, there were rumors that Sands had been picked up for questioning in another matter and admitted to having worked for Taylor, but denied any involvement in the murder. Now, whether that was really him or just another Edward Sands wannabe is very unclear.

Motive? Plenty. Revenge. Fear of being exposed. Resentment over being replaced. Possibly knowledge of something deeper. Was he blackmailing Taylor? Had Taylor threatened to go to police after all? Did Sands return to rob him again, only for things to go sideways? There is also the theory that Sands had knowledge of Taylor's private life, perhaps something involving his past or his sexuality or his finances. We just don't know.

That's right, and that brings us to the man who replaced Edward Sands, Henry Peavy. He was the man who found William Desmond Taylor's body on the morning of February 2nd, 1922, and from that moment on, he was a central character in the investigation. But was he a bystander in a Hollywood tragedy, or did he know more than he had let on? Let's start with what we do know. Peavy had been working as Taylor's valet since mid-1921, brought in after Edward Sands had forged checks, robbed the house, and vanished. Peavy was reportedly cheerful, polite, dedicated to his work.

But he was also a bit eccentric. Described in the press as flamboyant, he stood out in the conservative, uptight world of early 1920s Hollywood. He liked to wear colorful clothes, had a high-pitched voice, and he was known to be dramatic. Naturally, the media had a field day with him. Why do I keep imagining from the Invincible Kimmy Schmidt, Titus, like that character? Me too. I was thinking of Titus Andromedan. Yes, and I love it. Oh, but yeah, you could see why that would be somebody they might go after. Okay, so as we told you before, the day before the murder.

Peavy was arrested in a public park for what the LAPD called quote-unquote lewd conduct. The exact charge has never been fully clarified, but many suspect it was related to his sexuality. Homosexuality specifically, being both criminalized and scandalized at the time. He was bailed out the next morning by Taylor himself, who reportedly treated him with kindness and discretion. That was on the morning of February 1st. That night, Taylor was murdered. And the next day, it was Peavy who found the body.

So, now let's talk about the police and the press, because both were openly suspicious about Peavy from the beginning. They grilled him relentlessly, fixated on his arrest, his demeanor, his mannerisms. He was described in the papers as hysterical and shrill, and reporters mocked his way of speaking. It was classic scapegoating, flamboyant, black, possibly queer, and in the wrong place at the wrong time. The odds were stacked against him. And yet, the LAPD could never actually place him at the scene of the murder at the time of the crime. He was supposedly at home. There's no evidence that he had a motive. He had no reason to kill Taylor.

Taylor had just helped him out of jail, and by all accounts, treated him decently. Was there a motive? Not a strong one. Some speculated that Peavey might have snapped over the arrest or feared Taylor would fire him. Others floated the idea of a lover's quarrel. But there's no indication Peavey had any kind of romantic involvement with Taylor. What he did have, though, was knowledge. He knew Taylor's habits, his routine, the layout of the bungalow, who came and went. If anyone knew what secrets Taylor kept, it was probably Henry Peavey. And that's where the theory creeps in. Maybe Peavey didn't kill Taylor, but maybe he knew who did.

There were rumors he may have cleaned up the crime scene before police arrived. Not out of guilt, but because studio executives ordered it. Or maybe he removed or hid something to protect Taylor's legacy. When pressed by the cops, Heavey seemed evasive at times, but never actually changed his core story. And to be fair, after days of being interrogated by hostile detectives and ridiculed in the national press, most of us would get a little wobbly too.

In the end, Peavy was never charged. The police eventually dismissed him as a suspect, although the public never really did. He faded into obscurity after the media frenzy died down and was remembered mostly as the oddball valet who screamed when he found the body. In every small town, behind every closed door, a story waits to be uncovered. On our True Crime podcast, we dive deep into the cases that haunt communities around the world, from chilling cold cases to crimes with unexpected twist. No detail is too small. Hosted by us, Jen and Cam, two lifelong friends who love telling a good story. This isn't sensationalized news.

It's real cases, real people, and the chilling details that keep you up at night. Our True Crime Podcast brings the facts, a little perspective, and just enough humor to remind you you're not alone in being fascinated by the darker side of life. Our True Crime Podcast, where bizarre crimes, meticulous research, and genuine friendship collide. Subscribe today if you dare, because sometimes the scariest stories are the true ones. Hey, Fresh Hell fans. My name is Brandon Sheck-Snyder, and I'm the host of the podcast Southern Gothic, a show that explores the history behind some of the American South's darkest days, greatest mysteries, and most chilling ghost stories. Look, I know you enjoy listening to podcasts. I mean, you are here, right? So I just want to invite you to give Southern Gothic a listen as well. Together, we'll explore some notorious haunts like the legend of the Bell Witch and the infamous Waverly Hills Sanatorium, as well as a number of the absolute eeriest legends and pieces of local lore that...

I bet you ain't never heard of. So y'all, join me on Southern Gothic, available now on all your favorite podcast apps. Of course, the police and the media had a couple of other theories who could have possibly done it. For example, they tried to link it to another murder that had taken place. This is from the Los Angeles Evening Post, record Friday, February 3rd, 1922, page 3. Taylor's murder is similar to that of Joseph Elwell. Quote.

New York, February 3rd. The murder of William Desmond Taylor, motion picture director in Los Angeles yesterday, recalled to New Yorkers the mysterious and as yet unsolved murder of Joseph B. Elwell, bridge with the king, more than a year ago. Both men were alone in their homes when an assassin's bullet snuffed out their lives. Both were popular with women and in some ways were men of mystery, who might have been slain for any one of several motives. In neither case was the slayer's weapon found, nor was it apparent how entrance was gained to the home of the victim, all doors being locked at the time. A woman is believed to be the central figure in each crime and jealousy the motive. End quote.

One of the most persistent alternate theories is that William Desmond Taylor was the victim of a blackmail attempt gone wrong, maybe over his past as William Dean Tanner, or possibly related to his rumored sexuality. Some believe someone knew something and came calling for a payout. And then there's the lover's quarrel theory, specifically that Taylor may have been in a romantic relationship with a man, possibly even George James Hopkins, and that a private dispute turned deadly. I think this comes mostly from Hopkins' unpublished memoir and Charles Hyman's later book based on it, both full of detail but very light on proof. And if that's not dramatic enough, there's always the idea that organized crime was involved. Maybe Taylor got in the way of drug sales or ticked someone off who was a little too dangerous when he was trying to help Mabel Norman get clean. But again, no evidence. Others think that Taylor wasn't even the intended target or that police or the studio knew exactly who did it but chose to protect their, for example, golden stars or their profits and made the case disappear.

In the weeks following the murder of William Desmond Taylor, the Los Angeles Police Department made a lot of noise, but not much progress. Tips poured in, suspects were named and eliminated, the press feasted on every single rumor, but no arrests were ever made. And the longer the case dragged on, the more muddled everything became. The studios had closed ranks, evidence had disappeared, and the most promising leads had either fled the country or lawyered up. And eventually, the investigation just stopped. Officially, it remained open, but in reality, it was shelved. And just like that, the case went cold. Never to be solved. That is...

Until 1964, more than four decades later, when legendary director King Widor reignited public interest in the case, and we briefly mentioned him before. He had been obsessed with solving the murder and had even conducted his own private investigation. He believed, and claimed in later interviews, that he knew who had done it. But he was feeling a lawsuit from surviving relatives, so he never published his findings. Still, Widor believed it had been, dun-dun-dun, Charlotte Shelby, and that the studios had covered for her. And then came the so-called deathbed confession.

And you know how much I always hope for one of those in any cold case. Enter Margaret Gibson. She wasn't in the spotlight during the original 1922 investigation, but decades later, she suddenly became one of the most tantalizing suspects in the William Desmond Taylor case. But let's rewind. Margaret Gibson was born in Colorado Springs in 1894, but grew up in Los Angeles. She began acting in silent films around 1913 and had a successful, if not particularly headline-making, career. She was attractive, talented, and it would turn out a bit of a chameleon.

Sometimes she was billed as Patricia Palmer, sometimes as Margaret Gibson, and she appeared in dozens of short films and a few features. She worked with William Desmond Taylor early in both of their careers, which is key. They starred in a few films together around 1914 and 1915. So yes, they absolutely knew each other. And while their exact relationship is unclear, they moved in the same industry circles. According to some sources, Taylor may have helped her land roles when she was still on the rise. Others believe there may have been more to it than that. But Margaret's story starts getting really interesting.

and dark around 1917. That's when she was first arrested for vagrancy. And then there were some other allegations, which included opium dealing. She was acquitted, but had to change her screen name to get away from the scandal. She was arrested a second time, only 21 months after the murder of William Desmond Taylor. This time, she was involved in a federal prostitution and blackmail scandal. The details are murky, but the case involved a shady group accused of extorting wealthy men by luring them into compromising situations with women and then blackmailing them.

The charges were eventually dropped, however, the scandal left a permanent stain on her career. After her film career fizzled out in the 1920s, Margaret Gibson faded from public view in every possible way, and by 1935, she had vanished entirely. For reasons still unknown, she suddenly packed up and fled the U.S. for Singapore. Once there, she married a man named Albert Lewis. Their marriage appears to have been stable and affectionate. Gibson, now going by Pat Lewis, had no intention of returning to the States. Instead, the couple spent their years drifting around the Bay of Bengal and the Indian Ocean. Ceylon.

India, Burma, Java, the Straits settlements. They dreamed of retiring in South Africa or Australia. But in 1940, Gibson became seriously ill with a bladder infection, and there was simply no good medical care where they were. With World War II escalating and shipping routes under constant threat, she had no choice but to return alone to Los Angeles for treatment. It's wild, isn't it, to think that, like... It's so wild. That's a wild life. I think her husband was killed in one of these bombings attacks during World War II. Oh, yeah, yeah. I think he was working for an oil company there. Wow.

The thing I can't get over is, like, if you got a UTI in 1940, it's true. Like, what would you do? There was no... What would you do? Yeah. So, by 1949, Margaret, or Pat, was living quietly and modestly in a sparsely furnished house tucked away behind heavy vegetation in the Hollywood Hills, where she lived alone with her gray cat, Raja, and spent her time gardening and keeping to herself. I get it. Yeah, I was just going to say, live in the dream. Her neighbors barely saw her. Groceries were delivered. Her home was a kind of fortress of solitude, or maybe penance.

Then, in October 1964, Gibson suffered a massive heart attack. Knowing the end was near, the reclusive former actress, now a devout Catholic, begged for a priest. But it wasn't just spiritual closure she wanted. In a panic, she reportedly confessed to neighbors that she had murdered William Desmond Taylor back in 1922. I killed William Desmond Taylor. I shot him. Her confession was overheard by a friend or caretaker, the accounts vary, who told the story to true crime author Robert Giroux years later. Giroux included it in his 1990 book, A Deed of Death.

and believed Gibson to be the most likely killer. According to those neighbors, she had already made disturbing comments the night before while watching an episode of Ralph's Stories Los Angeles about the still unsolved Taylor case. Gibson became agitated and allegedly blurted out, I killed him. I thought it was long forgotten. When the heart attack hit, she doubled down. She needed absolution and she wanted the truth out. Now, to be very clear, there is no recording, no written confession, no police report, just the word of a few people who say she said it.

Let's try to look at the could she even have done it, and if so, why? Well, Gibson had indeed been in Los Angeles at the time of the murder. She had once worked with Taylor years earlier. She had a criminal record, including a federal fraud case. And the theory that Taylor may have been target of blackmail, you know, in the wake of the Arbuckle scandal, had always been floating around.

Other theories involve jealousy, a failed romance. Others speculate he was helping her financially and threatened to cut her off. I think that's unlikely, though. Still, others wonder if she was mentally unstable and simply held a grudge from decades earlier, possibly for no reason at all. And there's even a theory that she knew too much about Taylor's private life, especially if, as many believe, he was in a long-term relationship with men, for example, George James Hopkins, and that things escalated fatally. The sad truth? We will never know.

But does Margaret Gibson's deathbed confession actually line up with the known facts? Yeah, it does. At least, let's say it like this, it doesn't contradict any of them. No. But without evidence, we are left with yet another unsatisfying Hollywood ending. And the LAPD, they never followed up. Probably because by then, I mean, what's even the point with everyone involved being dead? Also, how convenient, right Annie? All of the original police files and physical evidence had mysteriously vanished by 1940. Oh no.

How mysterious. Margaret Gibson, aka Hatt Lewis, aka she had a lot of other stage names, is buried at Holy Cross Cemetery in Calvo City. And if her story was true, she took the details to her grave. And if it wasn't, she might have just pulled off one last performance. You know, the dying starlet with a scandalous secret.

So yeah, this case was never officially solved. But what became of the people at the center of it all? What happened to them later in life? So, Mabel Normand. Mabel never fully recovered from the Taylor murder scandal. Though she was never a suspect, just being the last known person to see William Desmond Taylor alive was enough to drag her name through every tabloid in the country. Her career limped along for a few more years, but her health and reputation were both in decline. In 1924, things got worse when her chauffeur shot and killed Cortland S. Steins, using Mabel's pistol.

She wasn't involved, but the headlines didn't care. And after that, she was radioactive in Hollywood. She made a few more films, but retired from the screen by the end of the 1920s. Her final years were spent battling tuberculosis, the disease that would ultimately kill her. She married actor Lou Cody in 1926, a friend from her early days in film, and he cared for her during her long decline. Lermond died on February 23, 1930, at just 36 years old. Mary Miles Minta was only 20 years old when the scandal hit, but by the mid-1920s, she was out of Hollywood for good.

She did try a brief return to film in 1923. She appeared in her final movie, The Trail of the Lonesome Pine, but by then the public had largely turned on her. The press painted her as everything from a naive wife to a dangerous Lolita, and producers just didn't want the baggage. Mary officially retired from acting in 1924. She had made over 50 films. She later said she never really enjoyed acting anyway and had only done it to support her family. That may or may not have been true, but it was the narrative she stuck with. And I can see that, honestly. I can see why she wouldn't have liked it.

Definitely. For the next several decades, Mary Miles Minter lived a surprisingly quiet and private life. She later reconciled with her mother and kept claiming her love for Taylor all throughout her life. She stayed unmarried for a long time, even though her former lover, James Kirkwood, proposed to her a year after Taylor had died. We read that in the memorandum. Yeah, gross. She never returned to acting, even though she got occasional offers. And in 1957, she married a real estate developer and the couple stayed together until his death in 1965.

And then she lived in relative obscurity in Santa Monica. Then, on 8th of January 1981, you could find this next article on page 13, because nobody cared about Mary Miles Minter anymore in 1981. This is from the Santa Cruz Sentinel. Quote, silent film star injured in robbery, Santa Monica, California. Former silent screen star Mary Miles Minter, who was robbed of $10,000 in antiques, jewelry, and cash, was recovering in Santa Monica Hospital from a broken wrist and other injuries received during the robbery, authorities said. Santa Monica police said Miss Minter,

A semi-invalid was asleep in her home early Tuesday when she was awakened by three intruders, one of whom matches the description of a man sought for two other robberies and a rape in Santa Monica. The robbers found Miss Minta and ransacked her house. Items taken by the thieves included a cedar chest filled with old linens. This was the latest in a series of misfortunes to hit the 70-year-old former actress as popular as Mary Pickford at the height of her career, since she became a Hollywood star after World War I. End quote.

So that's sad and upsetting. And apparently they later figured out that the perpetrators were a former living companion. So I guess somebody who was hired to take care of her. That's awful. Horrible, right? And other people he brought with him. I also read that the total they stole was valued more than $300,000.

In 1984, Mary Miles Minterland died of a stroke at the age of 82. discreet, and frankly indispensable. By the 1940s, he returned to Hollywood where he finally got the credit he deserved, designing films like Who's Afraid of Virginia Woolf, The Music Man, and my personal favorite, Auntie Mame. He won his fourth and final Oscar in 1969, but for all of his accolades, he died in 1985, largely forgotten, his personal life and his years with Taylor still missing from most histories. What do we think? What do you think? Who did it? Well, the deathbed confession is interesting. What do you think?

I think Charlotte Shelby probably hired someone. Yeah, I think that's likely. Kirkwood or somebody else. I think she would have been capable of convincing people. to do something like that for her. Yeah, I agree. And she had a lot to lose. Yeah, she had a lot to lose. Especially, I think there was maybe a bigger threat there than we would have even maybe known. Like, we don't really know what the unusual conversation he had, you know, the disturbing and unusual conversation he had was. You know, it's possible that Mary opened up to him about just her past experiences. Like, he might have told her the truth of everything that she went through being, you know, used and abused by Kirkwood or Kirkland? Kirkwood. Kirkwood. I keep wanting to say Kirkland, the brand.

Yeah, because that was horrific what happened to her. And so it's possible that she actually just gave him enough information. I'm just saying we don't know that any of this happened. But in my mind, it's possible that she gave him enough information where he was like, you know what? I will. Let's get married because then at least I'll be in charge of you and not your mother anymore. And if he was if he was a closeted gay man, then she's the perfect.

Yeah. You know, there could be potential benefits to everyone involved. We don't really know. I think it's equally as plausible that he never had that conversation with Mary and that he just was trying to help her and could see she was in a bad way. And she was over the moon, crazy pants in love with him because, again, of her past trauma and abuse. It's just so hard to know. And we don't even know if the Kirkwood thing was the only thing that happened to her because I can see her being really taken advantage of. Bye.

studio executives, for example. Absolutely. And you know, her mother didn't care if she was on anybody's couch as long as it benefited her and got her the job. I'm pretty sure her mother was, I don't want to blame people or accuse them of anything, but I can see her as this kind of stage mother who would be like, well, you gotta do what you gotta do if you want to be a star. That's it. Yep, exactly. And that's the crazy thing because she didn't even want to be a star. Like she was pushed into this before she had, she was a kid, you know?

The only thing where I think, well, maybe it wasn't Charlotte Shelby or maybe she was involved, because why wouldn't she have made sure that the letters were taken from the bungalow? That's true. If it was, but if she hired someone to do it, they might not have known to even look for anything. Maybe it was just the studio executives who took stuff that they thought. Maybe that's why they arrived so quickly on scene and tried to look for the letters. Maybe that's why they appeared there, but didn't get a chance to find them. Yeah, it's possible.

I just feel like, I mean, we're never going to know, but my interpretation of the whole thing and who can say, but my suspicion is that he was a gay man who got married because that's what you did and had a child because that's what you did. And then I think something happened to him in his first family that shook him up, that changed. Yeah, something happened to force him. I don't know whether he met a man. Or maybe he didn't want to bring scandal on his family. Well, that too. But I think he just realized that he couldn't live this lie anymore, that he couldn't just.

do the thing for the rest of his life like he was living a lie and he needed to be and you know I think there were probably a lot of reasons why he fled and it's really really complicated but I suspect and I could be wrong I suspect that his sexuality really had something to do with that and that's why he went like you said that's why he went to another coast and and I think he did have a probably a very deep and meaningful relationship with George James Hopkins because there's no reason to doubt what Hopkins has said after the fact like there's nothing in it for Hopkins to be like you know we loved each other the deathbed confession is a tricky one because I might have already told everybody this story, but, you know, my mom had a long, long health battles and she'd end up in the hospital pretty frequently. And she was in there once for a really bad infection that had gone septic. And so she was in the hospital and she'd watched an episode of Law and Order. Like she loved all the, you know, I get my love of this from her, all the crime procedurals, all of it. But she started confessing to all of us about a bunch of murders she'd committed because that's what had been on TV the hour previously. And so she was very earnestly telling us about like where she had buried the bodies and like where she had all the money. And she was so convincing. I was like, dad. And he's like, no.

If Margaret Gibson saw this segment of Ralph's stories, this segment about William Desmond Taylor just the night before, and she got really agitated about that. Yeah. I mean, that would make a lot of sense, yeah. How damaged was her brain during the heart attack? Yeah. Because it is, you know, like you can't suffer a massive heart attack, I don't think, with some, I don't know. I don't know.

I don't think it was Margaret Gibson, though. I don't. It could be. I mean, yeah, it's all possible. I just don't. I mean, anything is possible. Anything is possible. Endless possibilities. But wow, this was such an interesting case, Johanna. Well done. I had no idea about so much of this. I just think it's so interesting. It's a really, really interesting case, definitely. And I think people really, it's hard to understand how famous these people were back then. Right. Yeah. I mean, obviously, don't get me wrong. Movies back then was not a huge thing that they are now. Yeah. They were not known worldwide on all the continents everywhere, but they were huge.

early movie stars. Definitely. This reminds me of the last Downton Abbey movie where, you know, Mary's becoming like a talkie star. She has the right voice for it. There's going to be a new Downton Abbey movie. That's my something good. That's your something good? No. Well, it is. Yeah, I'm excited about that. Do you have something good? My something good. You remember all I told you about my surprise cherry tree and how I made marmalade of those cherries in my garden and that kind of kicked off some marmalade phase in my life and I made marmalade from apricots, blackberries, and...

from something called mirabel plums, I think in English. They're called grichel in Austria and Bavaria. And you find them in the forest. And so I went to pick that and made marmalade of that. That's my something good. And he said, I have the most idyllic life. I think you do. Yeah, I think it's pretty amazing. Your day's like, I went to take the dog for a walk in the woods and we collected all of these berries that just grow wild in the forest. And then I came home and I made marmalade. And I'm like, this is great. And I took my bicycle to the market for my vegetables. It's like, I want your life.

I'm like, I am still in my pajamas and I don't know where that other spider went. So listen, it takes all kinds. That's me and my spider sitting here in the corner. Oh, you know what's exciting? Actually, you guys are going to laugh at me. Some of you are going to laugh at me. Here's my something good. So I am going watch. I'll come back later and say, nope, it didn't happen. But I am going to get a bra fitting tomorrow at Nordstrom's. That is exciting. Yes. I have been wearing a sports bra since COVID.

And I have absolutely no idea what size I am. And I went to get measured a while back and the place near me had closed. So the only option was Victoria's Secret. And that was ridiculous because they were like, yeah, you're a 36 double D. And I'm like, uh, I don't think that's right. So I'm going to go find out tomorrow. Spoiler alert, that's definitely not right. So I'm going to go find out tomorrow what's actually going on and get a real bra again for the first time in, oh yeah, six years.

It has to be done. That's amazing. It's kind of shameful. I really think every woman should get properly fitted for a bra. It's life changing. It is. Says the person who hasn't worn a bra in years because I don't do bras anymore. Same. I know. All right.

that's it that's it okay so if you enjoyed this episode please please take a moment to rate review and subscribe wherever you are listening don't forget to follow or what else do you do that's it right that's all the things it helps more people find our show like the more people who like it the more likely it is they are to recommend it to someone else you can subscribe on spotify apple or youtube and i mean subscribe to special content like if you don't want to do patreon you can access the early and bonus content through apple spotify and youtube so if you have any questions or problems let us know A huge thank you to all of our subscribers on Spotify that we already have, to our Patreon supporters. You all are the reason his show keeps going, and we are so beyond grateful. If you want to support the podcast and get access to our bonus series, Cinema Macab, that's a Patreon exclusive, as well as our monthly live get-togethers, head on over to patreon.com Fresh Hell Podcast and join us there. You can find our Facebook group by searching Fresh Hell Murder. It's a lovely, respectful community of weirdos like us. You can also visit our website at freshhellpodcast.com for sources, merch, and everything else.

You are also welcome to email us at freshhallpodcast at gmail.com. Or if you're old school, send us something creepy, delightful, or just say hi via snail mail. Don't forget, we're already collecting your creepy, spooky, or just plain weird true stories for our annual Halloween episode. And just like last year, there will be a little giveaway for one of you. And we also are asking for your crocodilian letters because it turns out a lot of you have a favorite crocodile or a favorite alligator that, you know, took over your neighborhood swamp for a bit. And we want to hear about it. So send us those messages too and just label those croc talk.

So thank you so much. We just really appreciate you all. Thank you, thank you, thank you. And that's it. Please tell your pets, your spiders in the corner, your dogs in your bed, your cats on your kitchen counters that we love them, we miss them, tell them we said hi, hug them, cuddle them, treat them kindly. Thank you for loving the unloved, the slimy, the scaly, the slithery. Thank you. Be kind to them, be kind to your fellow human being, and also sometimes be kind to yourself because that also matters. It does. And just as Churchill said during World War II, if you're going through hell, keep going. Tschüss. Bye.

What would you do if you came face-to-face with something you couldn't explain? On Real Hauntings, Real Ghost Stories, every episode features a real person sharing their true encounter with the supernatural moments that changed how they see the world forever. These aren't fictional stories or dramatizations, just firsthand accounts of what people have seen, heard, and experienced in the unknown. Some are unsettling, some are emotional, and some will stay with you forever. Search Real Hauntings, Real Ghost Stories wherever you listen to podcasts and start a paranormal journey like never before.

Do you ever feel like the world is a nightmare? Like each day is scarier than the last? Then you'll love Scared All the Time. I'm Chris Kalari. And I'm Ed Ficola. And we're scared of everything, so we started a podcast about it. On each episode of Scared All Time, Chris presents a deep dive into a brand new fear. And Ed makes jokes so we can laugh instead of scream. From sharks to elevators. And earthquakes to human sacrifices, Scared All the Time leaves no scare unfeared. So check us out on Spotify or anywhere you get your pods. Scared All the Time. What will you be scared of next?

Frequently asked questions

How long is this episode of Fresh Hell Podcast?

This episode is 1 hour and 16 minutes long.

When was this Fresh Hell Podcast episode published?

This episode was published on August 15, 2025.

Is there a transcript available for this episode?

Yes, a full transcript is available for this episode. You can read the complete transcript on the episode page.

Can I download this Fresh Hell Podcast episode?

Yes. Use the download control on the episode player to save the publisher-provided media file.