EPISODE · May 13, 2020 · 1H 9M
EDSG Episode 25: Emails, Metaplot, and Elves
from Earthdawn Survival Guide · host Josh H & Dan B
* Email from Spencer: Getting back into Earthdawn and thanks for the podcast! * Email from Rob: Clarifying earlier comment about recorded actual play. * Any plans for the EDSG to talk about the connections with 1879? * Rob will be doing an Earthdawn one-shot for an actual play podcast and will let us know! * Josh’s Soapbox: Metaplot * Focus of the Iopos book on the city and people in it rather than the Deep Lore. * Elven Nations did not go into ancient immortal elf secrets. * The story of the immortals and powerful beings is interesting. * Focus on kings, dragons, and immortals can result in not leaving room for the player characters. * Word of the day: Deprotagonization * Sourcebooks should be gameable, not a novel focused on favored NPCs. * Potential pitfalls of a living setting. * Can’t assume that every game has the same interest in the Deep Lore. * Josh avoids a rant on the obsession with continuity, canonicity, and trivial minutiae. * Only so much space in the book, so choices must be made. * Elves! * Lots of information to take in about them in Earthdawn. * The trouble with elves in RPGs and related backlash. * Elves are people. * The Elven Court and a twist on the cliche. * Tension between Blood Elves and Unprotected Elves. * Lest you forget, Alachia is awesome, but also a garbage person. * Philosophy of the Wheel of Life. * Weaknesses of the Wheel as presented. * Lots of detailed rituals described in the Denizens essay. * Descriptive, not prescriptive. * Elven crafts form as much as function. * Family size and the realities of population sustainability. * The stereotype of long-lived races, patience, and relationship with time. * Number crunching the elf player character. * Combat-type elves should probably focus on defensive talents that lean on their high Dexterity * Good Troubadours and magicians * Fast, agile, middling karma, fragile. Find and Follow: Email: [email protected] YouTube: https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCeoifzUuBjez9V6wnvzom3g Twitter: @EDSGPodcast Josh on Twitter: @LoreMerchant Dan on Twitter: @boice_voice Get product information, developer blogs, and more at www.fasagames.com FASA Games on Facebook: https://www.facebook.com/fasagamesinc FASA Games Discord Channel: https://discord.gg/uuVwS9u Earthdawn Guild Facebook Group: https://www.facebook.com/groups/earthdawnguild Earthdawn West Marches: https://discord.gg/hhHDtXW
What this episode covers
* Email from Spencer: Getting back into Earthdawn and thanks for the podcast! * Email from Rob: Clarifying earlier comment about recorded actual play. * Any plans for the EDSG to talk about the connections with 1879? * Rob will be doing an Earthdawn one-shot for an actual play podcast and will let us know! * Josh’s Soapbox: Metaplot * Focus of the Iopos book on the city and people in it rather than the Deep Lore. * Elven Nations did not go into ancient immortal elf secrets. * The story of the immortals and powerful beings is interesting. * Focus on kings, dragons, and immortals can result in not leaving room for the player characters. * Word of the day: Deprotagonization * Sourcebooks should be gameable, not a novel focused on favored NPCs. * Potential pitfalls of a living setting. * Can’t assume that every game has the same interest in the Deep Lore. * Josh avoids a rant on the obsession with continuity, canonicity, and trivial minutiae. * Only so much space in the book, so choices must be made. * Elves! * Lots of information to take in about them in Earthdawn. * The trouble with elves in RPGs and related backlash. * Elves are people. * The Elven Court and a twist on the cliche. * Tension between Blood Elves and Unprotected Elves. * Lest you forget, Alachia is awesome, but also a garbage person. * Philosophy of the Wheel of Life. * Weaknesses of the Wheel as presented. * Lots of detailed rituals described in the Denizens essay. * Descriptive, not prescriptive. * Elven crafts form as much as function. * Family size and the realities of population sustainability. * The stereotype of long-lived races, patience, and relationship with time. * Number crunching the elf player character. * Combat-type elves should probably focus on defensive talents that lean on their high Dexterity * Good Troubadours and magicians * Fast, agile, middling karma, fragile. Find and Follow: Email: [email protected] YouTube: https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCeoifzUuBjez9V6wnvzom3g Twitter: @EDSGPodcast Josh on Twitter: @LoreMerchant Dan on Twitter: @boice_voice Get product information, developer blogs, and more at www.fasagames.com FASA Games on Facebook: https://www.facebook.com/fasagamesinc FASA Games Discord Channel: https://discord.gg/uuVwS9u Earthdawn Guild Facebook Group: https://www.facebook.com/groups/earthdawnguild Earthdawn West Marches: https://discord.gg/hhHDtXW
NOW PLAYING
EDSG Episode 25: Emails, Metaplot, and Elves
No transcript for this episode yet
Similar Episodes
Apr 15, 2026 ·28m
Mar 12, 2026 ·14m
Feb 17, 2026 ·21m
Feb 14, 2026 ·11m
Jan 5, 2026 ·61m
Dec 29, 2025 ·33m