This message comes from Viking, committed to exploring the world in comfort. Discover the heart of Europe by river on an elegant Viking longship with thoughtful service, destination-focused dining, and cultural enrichment on board and on shore. And every Viking voyage is all-inclusive with no children and no casinos. Learn more at viking.com. Carbon monoxide. You can't see it. You can't smell it. And without an alarm, you may not know it's there. Install carbon monoxide alarms on every level of your home and test them monthly. The more you know, the safer you'll be. Learn more at embridgegas.com slash safety.
Welcome to some very famous people you've never really heard of. Bite-sized biographies of the famous, the infamous, and the quirky in less than an hour. My name is Philip D. Gibbons, and there is more information about me, this podcast, and a bibliography at bitesizedbiographies.com. There are also photographs of many of the individuals and items mentioned in this podcast. At the conclusion of part two of this presentation, there will be additional suggestions concerning further information about today's subject, Edward Snowden, American Hero, or Malignant Traitor.
If you have enjoyed this presentation, please like us at our Facebook page, Some Very Famous People, and follow us on Twitter at Philip D. Gibbons. Subscribe to my YouTube page at Noblesse Oblige. Please note that all bite-sized biographies are now available on Spotify. And please tell a friend about my podcast. Now let's continue with our story about Edward Snowden.
Laura Poitras initially dealt with her own awkward nervousness by setting up her photographic equipment, tripod, camera, etc. She suddenly announced that she was beginning to film and for the next five hours, Greenwald questioned Snowden on his background, education, or lack of it, his intelligence, employment history, political outlook, and motivation for involving himself in such an incredibly risky and potentially felonious undertaking. Greenwald also wanted to ascertain whether Snowden was doing what he was doing out of his own free will and not as a result of some casual recklessness or irrational lack of understanding. The journalist was impressed by this aspect of Snowden's sincerity. The whistleblower, after explaining in great detail what he felt was the deep dishonesty and illegality pervading America's intelligence agencies, he resolved that, quote, if you are not acting on your beliefs, then they probably aren't real, and I don't want to be a person who remains afraid to act in defense of my principles.
And unlike the embittered, alienated, older loner that Greenwald had expected, Snowden was a young person, involved with a woman he clearly loved, living a prosperous lifestyle on an island paradise, pursuing a lucrative career with endless potential and possibilities. Greenwald was also surprised by Snowden's current transparency in terms of how he conducted his trip to Hong Kong. He traveled openly, paying with his own credit card, specifically because he did not want to be accused of being in the service of a foreign country or security service. He was acting on his own and strictly by himself. This was important for several reasons, most notably because Snowden knew once his identity was revealed, the U.S. government would attempt to portray him as a traitor who compromised national security and aided U.S. enemies. They would also attempt to dredge up any even remotely negative aspect of his employment history to minimize his organizational stature and disparage him personally as an erratic, disgruntled malcontent. He also maintained that he was hoping to avoid incarceration, but that if that was an eventual outcome, he had decided he could live with that, knowing that he could not live with the knowledge.
that he did nothing to bring this impropriety to light. This last component of Snowden's conversation impacted both Greenwald and Poitras deeply, and they resolved to move forward with the same sincerity and fearlessness that their contact so clearly evinced. In another shocking revelation, Snowden also explained that fairly early on, Greenwald would be free to reveal the leaker's identity. He added that he had actually deliberately not covered all of his tracks. He knew that without doing this, it would subject many co-workers to at least harsh investigation and possible false incrimination. He also wanted to be able to get ahead of the inevitable attempt to characterize him personally, and he wanted to dictate the facts surrounding his motivation and behavior rather than have the U.S. intelligence and media establishment attempt to take control of that process. Greenwald was hoping to delay that self-identification for as long as possible, knowing that Snowden might possibly become as big a story as the eavesdropping revelations themselves. Greenwald was personally impressed but outwardly maintained a hard-nosed demeanor to ensure that Snowden withheld
nothing and remain credible. Poitras filmed the entire session and the two men concluded with an agreement that before Snowden's identity was revealed, Greenwald would publish three to four blockbuster stories. Snowden agreed that once he identified himself, he would attempt to go undercover and would not grant any media interviews. They also agreed that any documents that were made public could not potentially harm any single employee or operative, understanding that if they did, the U.S. government would claim that they were dangerously jeopardizing the safety of individuals.
Greenwald quickly wrote up a succession of stories that he hoped to publish over the course of the next four days. He got the assistance of McCaskill, who also was finally introduced to Snowden, who had no issues with his presence. Guardian editorial, previously resolute in their support of the project, now began to go down the same route as some of the more mainstream outfits like the Washington Post. In fact, initially when Greenwald was reluctant to get involved, Laura Poitras had enlisted another reporter, Martin Gelman of the Post, who she knew and respected. Snowden sent him some top-secret documents as well, but ultimately Gelman, invited to come to Hong Kong, refused based on advice from the Post's attorneys who claimed that any discussion of classified materials in what was technically Red China might be wiretapped by the Red Chinese and legally charged by the U.S. government as enabling the illegal distribution of classified material to a foreign entity, a crime. The Post had also advised Poitras not to go, which she ignored, and they also pulled their previous agreement to fund her trip.
Now the Guardian editors in New York were holding a publication based on their attorney's assertion that the US government needed to be allowed to respond to what potentially was going to be published and to be allowed to at least make the case as to why the newspaper should not do that. Undoubtedly, that would involve the nebulous assertion of threats to national security, but the Obama administration had recently become even more strident, subpoenaing the records and phone calls of a Fox News reporter, James Rosen, in an investigation of leaks provided to Rosen by a State Department analyst concerning North Korea, setting the stage for a possible prosecution of Rosen. At the very least, this was very intimidating and ominous behavior. Greenwald was concerned.
that allowing the U.S. government this advance notice would prompt a similarly aggressive response. A conference call did transpire in which a core group of NSA and DOJ higher-ups did try a last-ditch effort to stall and then intimidate Guardian New York editor Janine Gibson. But in the end, after 48 hours of legal due diligence, the first Guardian-Greenwald story featuring Snowden information hit the newspaper's website. It focused on the government's secret program to compel Verizon via a secret FISA court order to turn over millions of customer records on a daily basis without any suspicion of wrongdoing. It also noted that Verizon was prohibited from disclosing
this eavesdropping request or the specific court order itself. Snowden's fears that his immense personal sacrifice would be in vain and Greenwald's skepticism about corporate media's frequent reluctance to alienate the Washington elite were both completely unfounded. The first Guardian story exploded like a bombshell across every spectrum of America's journalism infrastructure and dominated the news cycle completely. From his hotel room in Hong Kong, Edward Snowden kept CNN on perpetually, relieved that his efforts had finally come to fruition. But this was only day one of many news stories. Day two featured a description of the NSA's operation known as PRISM. It's programmed to eavesdrop on all of the major internet and tech companies' customer base, including Google, Apple, YouTube, Yahoo, and Facebook. Although for The Guardian, it was now a mere formality, they again contacted the U.S. government to inform them of this impending publication. Although at this point, there was probably nothing anyone within the NSA or DOJ could do to stop publication, this interaction had two curious after-effects. The first was there only hours before The Guardian released its story, Barton Gelman.
And the Washington Post released their own PRISM story, rushing it up by days when Gilman had previously told Greenwald and Snowden that he would not publish until the upcoming Sunday. It was clear that some government official on the conference call with Guardian editors on the U.S. government side had leaked to Gilman that the Guardian was about to publish the PRISM story. Not wanting to be scooped again, the Post got it out first. And if they couldn't stop the story, at least the feds could deny the Guardian another scoop. The other result of the PRISM story was an ironclad denial from the Internet companies that such a program existed.
This wasn't true, but perhaps in the short term, this was a ploy to minimize the uproar. The PRISM story only exponentially increased media and public reaction. Because it involved internationally accessible internet websites, eavesdropping intrusion affected a much larger group of people. And unlike WikiLeaks, in which American media was mixed in its response, with some corporate outlets calling the organization dangerous and an aid to terrorists, all of the coverage, which included extensive interviews of Greenwald live from Hong Kong, were completely positive and negative with regard to the U.S. government's behavior. But for Snowden, anxiety ratcheted up when a remote security censored his Hawaii resident.
Incidents detected the presence of two individuals, one from Booze Hamilton, the other an NSA security official. They were obviously looking for him. Although Snowden did not know it at the time, this investigation was routine in that no one understood the gravity of what Snowden was up to. They merely knew that he was AWOL, and the follow-up was standard procedure. No one made the connection between Snowden's disappearance and the Guardian revelations, but both Greenwald and Snowden dealt with the anxiety that at any time there could be a knock on the leaker's hotel door, and it could be hauled away, never to see the light of day again.
To that end, Snowden again resolved to publicly come forward and identify himself as the source of the NSA information. Initially, Greenwald was opposed to this idea, believing that Snowden was unintentionally helping the U.S. government and putting an immediate target on his back. But Snowden wanted to get ahead of what he felt was an inevitable disclosure of his identity, and he believed the U.S. would do everything in its power to discredit him as both an employee and as a person. He also wanted to shield any co-workers from suspicion and even wrongful implication, as well as insulating his family and loved ones from scrutiny and media stigma.
Laura Poitras prepared an 11-minute video of Snowden discussing his background and his motivations that ran with a published article written by Greenwald that ran in the UK Guardian at 2 p.m. Eastern Standard Time Sunday, June 9th. The weekend posting allowed the public to absorb this information without any kind of U.S. government official response. Before the article even appeared, it was decided to at least minimize the chance that Snowden would be detained by even local authorities. The whistleblower would be conveyed by two prominent local human rights attorneys to a safe house location.
These individuals had actually proactively contacted Greenwald, who was highly visible, giving several follow-up media interviews, discussing his articles. It was also only a matter of time before Snowden's local hotel location was discovered by the media. Greenwald was already being hounded and followed by journalists at his local hotel, the W. By the time the Guardian article appeared, Snowden, aided by a Greenwald ruse to distract any media intent on his location, had snuck out of his room and was safely headed to the first of several safe houses he would occupy for the next few days. At this point, both Poitras, Greenwald, and McCaskill left Hong Kong, figuring there was nothing they could do to further help him, and Greenwald already successfully provided with Snowden's entire cache of documents. Snowden effectively completed the first aspect of his mission, bringing attention to U.S. government malfeasance and even potentially illegal behavior. Now he would have to seek refuge as the most wanted man on the planet. The inevitable response of the U.S. government began on June 14th, when Snowden was indicted for violation of the Espionage Act, and on June 21st, Snowden's extradition was officially demanded.
Snowden's lawyers appealed to the United Nations for assistance from the local Hong Kong government to provide some interim sanctuary, but possibly at the behest of the Chinese government itself, this plea was refused, and it was strongly suggested that if Snowden wished to involve the UN, he would have to do that from his country of citizenship. Unfortunately, that meant Snowden would quickly be arrested. It was at this point that Snowden had the good fortune of an addition to his legal team of Sarah Harrison, a senior member of WikiLeaks and an expert on asylum issues. especially experienced after the legal travails of Julian Assange. Clearly with the support of Assange, Harrison began to strategize on how to get Snowden out of Hong Kong as quickly as possible. Luckily, via the coordination of Laura Poitras through encrypted computer discussions, Harrison communicated with a whistleblower in his hideaway, actually a hovel in one of the poorest neighborhoods in the city. Based on Ecuador's willingness to help Assange, but with no time to reach out to the Ecuadorian government directly,
Harrison arranged through the Ecuadorian Council in London to issue what is known as a laissez-passer, a temporary diplomatic document that requests that an international country allow the bearer to pass to a final destination, in this case, Ecuador. As soon as she was able to secure this document, the WikiLeaks editor hired a van and rendezvoused with Snowden, their plan to literally head straight to the airport. Even the airborne route that Snowden needed to take to Sanctuary was involved in Circuitus, first to Moscow, Havana, then Caracas, and on to Quito, Ecuador. There was no direct flight from Hong Kong to Ecuador, and even if there was, it might be a risky proposition. Anything was possible if the U.S. became aware of Snowden on a plane heading through the airspace of a nation friendly enough to the U.S. to facilitate a forced detour. As Snowden would eventually learn, such caution was not paranoia.
but this route was probably the safest possible, with all four destinations relatively or even overtly hostile to the U.S. But first, Snowden had to get out of Hong Kong. At the airport, he wore a quasi-disguise with a hat pulled over his eyes, avoiding recognition and having no trouble passing through security and passport control. Even after boarding the plane, Snowden didn't feel comfortable. Despite it being an Aeroflot jet, he expected local police to storm the interior at any time, Harrison sitting next to him to provide a barrier to anyone who might even recognize, or worse, a journalist who had tailed him successfully. Once the plane was airborne, Snowden relaxed.
the first leg traversing Chinese, Mongolian, and Russian airspace. His next big hurdle would be Moscow and a 20-hour layover, if even made it out of the transit area. The completely benign attitude of the Chinese and even local government in Hong Kong may have been the result of an unwillingness to get involved in any aspect of either detaining or even turning Snowden over to the U.S. Now, with the leaker headed to Russia, this was no longer their problem. which they seemed to prefer. Snowden and Harrison arrived at Moscow's Sheremetivo Airport on June 23rd. When the American was stopped at passport control and told there was a problem with his documents, Harrison insisted on accompanying him to the conference room and meeting which awaited. There, several members of the Russian equivalent of the FBI were seated around a table, with one obviously senior official taking the lead. He began by pleasantly explaining to Snowden that the Russian government bore him no ill will, and in fact would love to have an individual with such specialized skill and talents working with them. Before he was able to continue with various inducements, Snowden cut him off.
knowing that any willingness to even listen to such an offer might be used as leverage to allege that he considered becoming an agent of a foreign government. He explained respectfully but forcefully that he had no interest in working with any intelligence services, and in fact his computers, which were in a knapsack right next to him, had been wiped clean of any sensitive information. The leaker even encouraged his Russian interlocutor to look for himself. The governmental official looked almost hurt by the inference that he might question Snowden's veracity. He countered by saying that he only wished to help. Harrison...
brusquely responded that they only wished to make their connection to Havana. The Russian official suddenly became quite serious and explained that under the circumstances, that would be quite difficult, if not impossible. You see, your government minister, Mr. John Kerry, has canceled your passport and instructed all airlines to not allow any access to flights. Momentarily taken aback, Harrison then grabbed her laptop and ascertained very quickly that this was not some sly Russian trick, but was in fact headlines on every website in the West. Snowden again refused a direct request to help with his situation if he was willing to impart sensitive information.
Snowden and Harrison were then consigned to the airport's transit area. Snowden's laissez-passer ignored. During this time period, numerous countries were contacted in an effort to locate anyone willing to grant Snowden asylum. Not only was this effort unsuccessful, even governments like Ecuador and other South American regimes, formerly sympathetic to the idea, balked, warned off by the U.S. Surprisingly, on a personal basis, subsequent Russian treatment was quite beneficent up to a certain point. A room was located with at least modest accommodations, and despite the Spartan environment, the two made it work. The U.S. immediately demanded Snowden's extradition, but because no formal extradition treaty between the two countries existed and such an agreement had been rejected by the U.S.,
was deemed impossible by the Russians. Additionally, Snowden had not committed any crime under Russian law, so his removal to the U.S. would have been, from a Russian perspective, extraordinary. While Snowden languished in airport limbo, another incident greatly influenced the ultimate disposition of the whistleblower's fate. On July 2nd, 2013, the president of Bolivia, Ivo Morales, after attending an international conference on energy exports in Moscow, boarded his presidential jet en route to La Paz. But upon approaching Western Europe, the pilots were informed that the countries of France, Spain, and Italy were refusing to grant the aircraft access to these countries' airspace. The plane was, for refueling reasons, forced to land in Vienna, Austria. And while accounts differ, it is believed that all occupants were forced to display their passports.
Whether it was Morales' own remarks a few days earlier in which he indicated he would be willing to convey Snowden back to Bolivia or U.S. intelligence discerning from WikiLeaks that such an operation was imminent, Snowden was not on the plane. Publicly, the incident caused the Obama administration a great deal of embarrassment and enraged many governments in South America to the point where at least three such countries, Nicaragua, Venezuela, and again Bolivia, all officially offered Snowden asylum. However, some observers believe that the U.S. government was actually trying to intimidate any country that might attempt to remove Snowden, and it was presumed that the U.S. would once again forcefully detain Snowden in a similar manner if he left Russia in another country's government jet.
Snowden also came to believe that Russia might be a better long-term alternative, as the political stability of any South American country was never guaranteed, and with a change of governments, a new regime might be quite willing to hand Snowden over to the United States. However, this incident did influence international perspectives about Snowden's fate. Vladimir Putin himself getting involved in public comment about the case. With the U.S. now perceived as somewhat of a bully on the reverberations of the extent of NSA eavesdropping, in which it was becoming clearer every day that the spying was extensive and indiscriminate, the likelihood that Snowden would then be offered up to permanent imprisonment in the U.S. became unlikely. After Snowden struck out in his asylum requests externally, it was hinted that if he applied for at least temporary asylum in Russia, it would be granted. Clearly, the Russians decided that if he was not going to be sent to the U.S., then he should be allowed out of the airport. The status of temporary asylum, good for one year.
was granted on August 1st, 39 days after Snowden entered Sheremetivo's transit area. Exactly where and what Snowden did initially during the initial time period of his release has never been revealed other than when his one-year residency permit expired, he was granted an additional three years of asylum. Sarah Harrison remained in Russia with Snowden until November 2013 and her belief that he would be able to live without duress or harassment from the Russian government. Although Snowden's life and status in Russia remained murky, the fallout from his revelations continued unabated for months and even years after the incident. The U.S. government's response was essentially twofold. It attempted to squelch a massive political and public relations disaster that not only affected international relations, but underlined public American cynicism concerning privacy and ever-expanding government authority. But there were also repercussions concerning Snowden himself and the failure of American intelligence agencies.
U.S. politicians seemed as concerned about Snowden's ability to obtain and remove such a massive amount of data without detection and even how such a junior employee could be granted such access. His background and conduct became the subject of an extensive congressional investigation. As Edward Snowden predicted, the results of this investigation would be an attempt to diminish him as both a person and an employee. It called him a serial exaggerator and fabricator, detailed and denigrated his academic record, described his first position as that of a security guard, despite this job requiring a top-secret clearance, a clearance the government granted. It also diminished his role at the CIA, calling his job there entry-level, and detailed specifically his immediate difficulties with both supervisors and management chain of command.
even during his training period, his repeated counseling during overseas deployment concerning his behavior in just a six-month period, and his unauthorized return to Washington that led to his transition out of the CIA. But this report also detailed failures on the part of both the CIA and NSA to adhere to their own basic safeguards with an employee who had, at best, an unusual academic background and a checkered work history. Several routine background investigations or polygraphs that were administered during Snowden's employment were either incomplete or flawed. One such background check merely contacting Snowden's mother and girlfriend. And any attempt to denigrate and minimize Snowden and label him as a malcontent and renegade only added a fundamentally alarming but unstated revelation.
Namely, how could such a dysfunctional individual not only gain access to a vast amount of sensitive information, but also do this while completely undetected after the fact? The lack of security and procedures within the intelligence agencies themselves were underlined by Snowden's ability to leave the country, buy a plane ticket in his own name, and travel halfway around the world without any U.S. law enforcement awareness, even after the first Guardian stories were written. It was not until after Snowden came forward publicly that any person or agency of the U.S. government had any idea who or where he was.
Additional revelations and official U.S. government comments on the subject only made the situation even more embarrassing. A typical example came from Barack Obama himself, who commented on the Charlie Rose program on June 18th, only days into the Snowden uproar. What I can say unequivocally is that if you are a U.S. person, the NSA cannot listen to your phone calls by law and by rule unless they go to a court and obtain a warrant and seek probable cause the same way it's always been.
left unstated was that the bulk collection of communications involving non-Americans was ongoing and also involved collection of any American citizen's interaction with a foreign national. Such a statement could and did have ramifications for U.S. communications concerns doing business internationally and especially internet concerns like Google and Facebook. Obama also left out that the process of obtaining a FISA warrant to eavesdrop on American citizens was essentially a rubber stamping process in which law enforcement had only had such applications rejected in a minute number of cases. Obama, like many U.S. government officials, played the anti-terrorism card in, of all places, Berlin, when only weeks after Snowden's revelations, he stated, we know of at least 50 threats that have been averted because of this information, not just to the United States, but in some cases, threats here in Germany. So lives have been saved. General Keith Alexander, the head of the NSA, chimed in as well. The information gathered from these programs provided the U.S. government with critical leads to help prevent over 50 potential terrorist events in more than 20 countries around the world.
Within months, these claims would be completely debunked by various official and unofficial entities and also became additionally irrelevant with the revelation that even the personal cell phone of German Chancellor Angela Merkel was subjected to specific wiretapping, as well as the eventual headline that numerous other heads of state received the same surveillance. Foreign business conglomerates like Brazilian oil company Petrobras were also subjected to systematic eavesdropping, a development that raised even more ethical issues concerning how such data could be employed commercially. by U.S. competitors or whether or not this information was disseminated within the U.S. business community. Glenn Greenwald summarized the response to the anti-terrorist justifications from the U.S. government when he stated on CNN shortly after the Merkel report,
What we revealed is that the spying system is devoted not to terrorists, but is directed to innocent people around the world. None of this has anything to do with terrorism. Is Angela Merkel a terrorist? As a result of the Snowden incident, Congress in 2015 passed the USA Freedom Act, which specifically placed restrictions on NSA mass surveillance. Did this stop the type of intrusion that was widespread in the decade immediately following 9-11? Somewhat, but probably not entirely. And when dealing with any of the agencies like the CIA, NSA, or even FBI, such revelatory information is deemed classified with little accountability or transparency.
especially to the public. Even a government intelligence or law enforcement agency's request for a FISA warrant is conducted in front of a FISA court with only government officials present in total secrecy. Is illegal surveillance of both Americans and international citizens still conducted routinely? Based on previous actions, one would have to conclude that the answer is unequivocally yes. An indication of how closely the U.S. government intelligence community still remains tied to the American tech industry is underlined by the subsequent career path of NSA head general Keith Alexander. Although some American politicians, most notably John McCain, called for his immediate termination, Alexander was allowed to retire from the NSA in 2014 after founding and serving as CEO of the cybersecurity company IronNet, which eventually went bankrupt after burning through
a great deal of venture capital and employing numerous former government intelligence officials, Alexander left the company shortly before it was delisted from the New York Stock Exchange in 2023. A year later, he accepted a position as a member of the board of directors of Amazon.com, a post he still holds today. As of 2025, Edward Snowden remains in Russia. Despite some talk of clemency during the waning days of the first Trump administration, this did not occur. Although little is known of his day-to-day existence, some fundamental facts have surfaced about his current lifestyle. At the conclusion of her Academy Award-winning 2014 documentary about her Hong Kong interaction with Snowden entitled Citizen Four, Laura Poitras included footage of both Snowden and Lindsay Mills cooking dinner in their residence in Moscow. Mills, although initially crushed by Snowden's disappearance and harassed by both U.S. media and the FBI, reconciled with him as early as 2014. She eventually moved to Russia and the couple married in 2017. They currently have two young sons.
Although Snowden was rumored to have worked in some technical position for a larger Russian cyber-related entity, this has never been verified. He wrote a book in 2019 and has paid lucrative speaking fees almost always conducted via the internet. Although American intelligence officials and some within the media continue to both villainize him and portray him as at least a Russian intelligence asset, he has always vehemently denied giving any information to any Russian or any other intelligence agency. He was granted Soviet citizenship in 2022, but is a dual national, technically, despite the revocation of his passport. He also remains an American citizen.
Thank you for listening to part two of this podcast about Edward Snowden. Information for this podcast came from the books Permanent Record by Edward Snowden, The Snowden Files by Luke Harding, and Nowhere to Hide by Glenn Greenwald. There are also additional photographs, bibliographical and musical information at bitesizedbiographies.com. Thank you for listening. Please tell a friend about Bite-Sized Biographies.