Hello and welcome to Fourth Estate, a show about journalism. We're coming to you from Tewa's The Iron Sydney on the Gadigal lands of the Eora nation, right across Australia on the Community Radio Network, and directly to your device across the globe via podcast. I'm Tina Quinn and it's a pleasure as always to have your company. This week on Fourth Estate we look at what's been a very big week for social media news.
Billionaire and so-called free speech warrior Elon Musk has gotten himself into a war of words with the Australian government. He's defying orders from Australia's E Safety Commissioner to remove a video of the wakley stabbing from his social media platform X, formerly known as Twitter, and it's raised the ire of politicians from across the aisle. We'll do what's necessary to take on this arrogant billionaire who thinks he's above the law, but also above common decency and the idea that someone would go to court for the right to put up violent content on a platform shows how out of touch Mr Musk is. I think he's social media, nobody knows social conscience.
He has absolutely no social conscience, someone will let you be in jail and they'll cut you way thrown away. It's just the beggars belief really doesn't it, that this guy, this egotistical billionaire thinks that it's more important for him to be able to show whatever he wants on on X or Twitter or whatever you want to call it today. It's more important for him to have his way than to respect the victims of the crimes that are being shown on social media. I think it's a bit of a narcissistic cowboy frankly, he gets off on this stuff.
It's all part of a bigger discussion around censorship. What should be shared online? Who should decide and is it really possible to stop the spread of violent imagery on the internet? To discuss I'm joined by a reporter for the Sun Herald and friend of all the stage Amber Schultz welcome back Amber.
Hi Jim. And political reporter for Guardian Australia in Canberra. Josh Butler, thanks for being with us Josh. Yeah thanks haven't you.
So to give a bit of background I might go to you first. What is the e-safety commissioner asking for exactly here? Yes the e-safety commissioner has ordered a number of social media networks to remove videos of the Wakely Church stabbing which obviously that awful attack there that very infamously was live broadcast, the church service on the internet. Most of the social media networks complied or at least said that they complied with that order and obviously Twitter or your ex said that you had complied with what they, you know, the part of the order that they wanted to comply with and so that they weren't able to or declined to meet all of the parts of the order and that's what this federal court case popped up a few times in the last week goes to about whether ex has fulfilled the, I guess the requirements, the requests of the order of the e-safety commission.
Does the government actually have grounds for the takedown actions they're seeking? Well they do. The e-safety commission has actually a quite a broad range of powers. The e-safety commission is quite an interesting sort of body, there are other governments around the world that are sort of similar, you know, sort of online safety, you know, commissioners or bureaucrats or so forth but the e-safety commission in Australia sort of, you know, they like to talk about how they're doing sort of world-leading or industry-leading work in keeping people safe, you know, what they say is keeping people safe online so it does have quite a broad range of powers to do.
I mean obviously ex is disputing sort of, it's sort of niche but it's not really niche. They're disputing this part of the order or part of the ex-safety commission's request that it should block the content for not just every Australian who has, you know, their online networks set to being in Australia, it's saying it should also block the ability of people who are in Australia but use a VPN or a virtual private network which, you know, without being said two-depients in the details basically, you can sort of portray yourself as being overseas in Sweden or in America or whatever. Most people use those sort of things for very innocent purposes, maybe it's what you want to watch the American version of Netflix or something like that but the ex-empty commission is saying, well, we've asked you to block over every Australian, I mean, every single person in Australia and ex's responses will, you know, and I think I'll be really interested in the outcome of this particular argument. Ex is saying, well, that would essentially make us have to block it for every single person on the whole planet and the e-safety commission or, you know, any government agency anywhere in the world shouldn't be able to make laws for the rest of the whole world, basically.
So it is quite an interesting particular situation that we've got here. So the e-safety commission says their concern here is that people in Australia can most likely get around that Chio block with a VPN or do you think they're also worried about people outside of Australia saying the footage? I think there has been, I guess in this animation made that, you know, the average person shouldn't maybe be able to see that footage. I was quite interested yesterday that Bishop Marmarie actually came out and said that he didn't agree, you know, the person who was the victim of that stabbing attack, you know, so that he didn't necessarily agree that all the video should be taken down.
The e-safety commission's order is about Australia, I mean, it's about the jurisdiction of Australia. I'm not sure if I've seen comments from them sort of talking more broadly about whether the video itself should just be, you know, globally blocked, I think that's a different sort of argument. But essentially this is about what people in Australia are saying or not saying. Amber, do we know what grounds an Australian agency has to restrict content that's outside of Australia?
Is there international, you know, Joshua's sort of touching on that, but is there international law which governs what countries can force companies to do outside of their borders? You know, as far as I know, and this is why it's a really sort of contentious issue, I think X has come out and said, look, we do have locked it, that's fair enough, but to come out and have this done on a global scale, I think raises certain questions. So there are regulations around, you know, like child sex, material, things like that, you can have sort of global lockers on, global regulations, but things like violence, I think it would be the first time that Australia, that a government or Australian has tried to do this on a global scale, you know, and I think it's really interesting because it does raise questions about what country should be able to block material in other countries from being seen. And that's exactly X's argument is that Australia doesn't have jurisdiction over its global users.
So Elon asks us basically trying to tell us all that Australia's E safety commissioner isn't the boss of him, right? But the legal standpoint that X is trying to put forward is a bit more substantial there. Their point is about free speech and the impingement of free speech, is that right? Well, that's exactly it.
So I think X has obviously taken a bit more of a nuance to him saying that this is free speech. This is about censorship and trying to govern an entire world and what all of X's users can see. Elon Musk has come out and said a few certain other words, you know, he's called the E safety commissioner, Julian Van Grant, a communist authority and the Australian censorship commissioner. So he's really playing on this idea that this is a regulation of jurisdiction.
This is affecting free speech. Right. So apparently Julian Van Grant's a communist. Okay.
That's exactly it. Yeah. Okay. I mean, we are going to sort of graduate from these sort of commies versus capitalists sort of narrative that we've gotten in popular culture.
Yeah. It's a question. Like I ever said, like, you know, touching on that sort of communist thing, like it was just, you know, obviously Julian Van Grant is not a communist, but yeah, I think the time you use censorship commissar or something like that, which is like a communist party sort of term. A lot of this stuff has been sort of quite childish.
I think like, you know, obviously this is if people, you know, follow Elon Musk online or aware of the sort of stuff that he generally sort of does. I mean, I think his responses here have been pretty on brand for the kind of stuff that he does kind of brand that he has. He's posting all these like memes about it and, you know, like real boomers sort of memes. Okay.
He called, you know, Jackie Lambie, the Tasmanian Senator spent a couple of days this week, you know, really laying into Elon Musk. I think she said, you know, he should be in jail and, you know, he's a, you know, call him a few choice sort of insults. And then he, you know, she, and she deleted her, deleted her ex-account. And then yesterday, day before, Elon Musk, you know, says that she's a, it wasn't like a danger, a danger to Australian society or a traitor or something like that.
It was real sort of weird back and forth. They're between, you know, Jackie Lambie and, you know, the World's Riches Man. I thought it was quite, quite interesting development in this. Did we ever think that we'd be waking up to Elon Musk and Jackie Lambie having a bit of an argument or a stanchal?
Those are two names. I think they're both saying the same, you know, sentence. I think what's gotten really interesting as well is just how personal the attacks are. I mean, we expected it from Elon Musk, but something that's, you know, in front of court to have sort of everything out of the easy, and Chris Minnes and just so many people pile on Musk, you know, and Albiniz says that like Musk chose ego and is showing violence over common sentence, whereas Minnes has called him a narcissistic billionaire.
Like it's really gotten into childish personal attack territory, which is quite interesting to see from an entire government, sort of all walks of like a politician's piling on Musk and of course him responding. You've got to pick up on that. I mean, I'm not sure if you might discuss this a bit more in detail a bit later on, but that that is exactly one of the things that I've found most sort of striking about this last week, sort of covering the politics of it from Canberra. Is the bipartisanship of it or?
Well, no, no, it will sort of. I was just sort of interested by this end of this contest every day of who could have the spiciest kind of quote about Elon Musk. It wasn't. Yeah.
And I realized that, you know, these, these whole issue kind of, you know, the roots of it go back to these awful stabbings that were in Sydney in the last couple of weeks. And, you know, so horrifically speaking, I think that's been lost a little bit in the last. A few days of conversation, but there are a lot of, you know, really multi-layered issues at heart here. I mean, there's, you know, talk about, you know, mental health and violence against women and, you know, access to weapons and, you know, watch lists and, you know, what the authorities are doing about terrorism and, you know, encrypted messages and all these sort of things.
But, you know, these are all really big thorny, tricky issues that don't have immediate solution or at least one that we've heard yet. And I sort of found it quite striking that like as soon as this came along, Elon Musk, you know, big billionaire, he's you know, not very popular in certain circles. Everything, politician, like jumped on it. And, you know, I don't mean this in a way of, you know, standing up for Elon Musk.
I think, you know, comes to the territory. Like, I think he enjoys, you know, being the villain in the story or whatever. But I did find it really interesting that like the one thing that all these politicians could agree on, like, you know, the bipartisanship, like you said, Tina, was, you know, they all hate Elon Musk and everyone wanted to give the juiciest quote about him. Because we didn't got the coalition jumping in here.
I mean, they're usually the, you know, the purveyors are protecting free speech. But, well, yeah, I mean, maybe not a strong sort of personal insult terms, but, you know, there has been, you know, a lot of concern raised about, you know, the coalition of the Dusted Office idea that they've had for a while about age verification and age assurance on social media. You know, they've raised that issue around, you know, under age people having access to online pornography and that sort of thing. But now they've sort of broadened it to say, well, you know, there should be more blockers on the age of people to get a social media account and that sort of thing.
So, there has been, you know, I think there is a bipartisan push for some kind of big, you know, crackdown on the big, scary, big tech companies. And I think that is on the way. But just also a bit of background to Julian and Grant, now she's American and she's previously, she used to work for X and Twitter as well. She has as well.
So she's quite, you know, well versed in these sorts of things and since taking the role, she's also being quite forward in a lot of the things she's there and quite not heavy-handed but willing to use the tools at her disposal in order to sort of crack down on some of these social media giants. And I think it's come, you know, her posting and some of her actions have come at a really interesting time, not only, you know, because of Elon Musk's takeover of X, but also because of the news media bargaining code and misinformation and disinformation voluntary regulation. There's been so many movements to try and regulate these media giants in the last couple of years and Julian and Grant is really fighting an uphill battle to get the X to comply or to get these sort of regulations in motion. Because she's a former senior official at Twitter, do you think she's able to say, she knows how to inflict the most pain on the company, where it fails to make what she would ding community standards.
She knows it's, you know, soft underbelly or where its weaknesses are. I mean, yes and no. So she's fighting X with this stabbing post, 65 specific stabbing posts with a fine of $785,000 a day. You know, she would know the Achilles heel of X.
I think she would know where to look and what to point out. But it just, you know, as this case shows, it's not working particularly effectively. I think when a regulator comes up against such a big personality who is using his sort of defiance against governance and using these sort of very large topics, like free speech and very inflammatory topics, like free speech, I think it shows that, you know, she should have all the powers in the world, but she's still really, really struggling to deal with these, you know, giant faces, these giant industries. So you actually think she's finding a losing battle then?
Look, honestly, I think this shows, you know, there's a quarter and Twitter still isn't complying. They did comply, you know, with the geo blockers and we have had a metering Google comply. But I think just the fact that everyone must can come out and just, and flat out refuse to record what seeks volumes. You know, I don't think that she has the power in this relationship at all.
Josh? It is a really interesting question. I'm not sure if it's a losing battle. I think I think all the points at Amber just raised that are all really good points to say, you know, these big tech companies don't like to, not to say that they don't like to listen to governments, but I think they don't like to be told what to do with their own property and their own platforms.
A lot of these tech companies started out with, you know, quite a commitment or, you know, philosophical adherence to, you know, free speech and marketplace of ideas and let's all debate this and blah, blah, you know, don't impeach my free speech, which I think is really, really important. It is a tricky one where it does come up against exactly this kind of issue of, you know, we're all free speech and what sort of thing until it does harm or until it, you know, can be shown to maybe cause harm or, you know, at least it's further harm or something like that. I'm not sure if it's a losing battle, but I think, I think at this point it is tricky. I think, you know, I'm not really sure what they can do to X if they don't comply with it.
They can find X, but I think very famously they don't really have a lot of staff here in Australia or maybe any staff. Obviously they collect some level of revenue through advertising and so forth. I wouldn't be surprised, you know, I just need people and I have no specific knowledge of this, but I wouldn't be surprised if there is some sort of movement towards, you know, trying to tax some of these companies at a greater level on, you know, maybe they don't have operations here or an office or that sort of thing, but you know, they do collect advertising money from Australian sources, Australian companies, you know, the Australian government still advertisers on a lot of these platforms, including Twitter, I think. So, you know, I wouldn't be surprised if there is some move towards trying to tax these companies differently or more, but this is also a growing kind of movement, not just here, but around the world.
You know, Little Australia is, you know, very small fish in a big pond and we think about, you know, all the governments around the world that Twitter and Facebook and TikTok and whoever have to deal with. So I'm not really sure that, you know, one country going out on its own, like the Lone Ranger, is going to change like the free speech policies of Twitter, but if Australia does it and America does it and the UK does it and all the countries around the world do it, which they are doing. You know, for instance, Canada is, you know, tried to do their own version of the new bargaining code last year and Facebook just like shut off all the news in Canada, like they did with Australia in 2021. I think when we tried doing the new bargaining code the first time around, you know, there is a push, you know, the countries to sort of reign in the power of the big tech giants and, you know, one country on its own can't really do a lot maybe, but if there is a sort of concerted global push, which there is in a lot of areas, you sort of have to think that, you know, the tide eventually does start to turn.
I think that's why we're seeing so many companies dig their heels in and just say that they won't, you know, the news media bargaining code, I think, sort of made the dominoes fall for a lot of countries around the world to start advocating for similar things. And then that's why I think Elon Musk and Twitter are fighting this order so hard because they don't want to set a precedent that other countries could do the same thing. You're listening to Full The State on the Community Radio Network, my guests, Amber Shultz and Josh Butler. So look, it does actually raise a bit of an interesting question here.
I mean, would we be happy if X abagged the request of another country? So, you know, say Russia or China or the United States, if they were saying to them or requesting that they take down content about something in those countries, would we be pleased? I think that is the argument that they're sort of making. And I do have sympathy for that argument.
I've seen people make the argument that, you know, what if it was, you know, footage of the Tiananmen Square, you know, tank incident or something like that, you know, what if it was footage of, you know, insert massacre here? I think that is a fair point to say. But the flip side of the argument is this isn't this particular incident with the church stabbing. This isn't, you know, just like an embarrassing video for the government, it's not like, you know, something embarrassing video of the Prime Minister and the government wants to take down like the political purposes.
This is, you know, a stabbing an incident that, you know, obviously allegedly there are charges going on and there's a counter-arrayed this week, links to this incident. This is like a lie part of allegedly a lie of, you know, counter-terror incident. You know, this person, maybe people were allegedly inspired by, you know, religious extremism. It is a bit of a different kettle of fish.
And this is what, this is part of the argument that hasn't really got a whole lot of play is that there are, you know, classification standards and that sort of thing about what sort of content people should be allowed to watch. This was a video of, you know, the Prime Minister picking his nose or, you know, something like that. And the government's like, take that video down to it. Like that will be one thing.
But this is something that, you know, authorities, experts, you know, have said is something that shouldn't be on the internet. Not just, oh, we would like it not to be there because it's embarrassing. It's, you know, something that has been deemed to be graphic, terrific, violent content. Because the concern here is that it could radicalize other people and, you know, it could encourage copycat sort of attacks to happen or I think those are all facts.
I think you're definitely. Look, I think it's important to know that this injunction currently only captures 65 specific posts and new uploads won't be blocked or banned under the current order. So it's not, it's not as simple as saying we're blocking, you know, the entire world from seeing what went down. We're saying these specific videos.
I, you know, I do think it's concerning if other countries started to do this. I don't think this case would set the precedent for that. But I understand it is a really worrying argument. I think the sort of bigger issue than just this one video because there are millions of similar videos, there's millions of ways people can be radicalized online.
There's so much material out there. I think the bigger discussion should be not just on censoring this one video on this one attack. It should be about, you know, what social media giants are doing to regulate the material seen online, what classifications are there and is it enough? And how are they moderating that online content to sort of stop people from being radicalized or being exposed to this sort of radical videos where they might, you know, be sympathetic towards them.
How do you think the government's going though in winning this argument in terms of to the Australian people? Because we've heard this week from ASIOs, Director-General Mike Burgess and the AFP commissioner, now, Reese Kirschor, the AFP commissioner, he's arguing that there's no absolute right to privacy when it comes to social media and encrypted messaging services. Are those comments concerning to it all now? Because I think it would definitely be raising the eye of many Australians around the country.
I'm not sure if it's going to get everybody on-site. I do find it concerning. Obviously, it's a problem that Meta and X have been accused of hindering police investigations. Obviously, the police do very, very amazing things when it comes to taking down, you know, child sex abuse, reams, and they do that through infiltrating these networks and through accessing things that the public, you know, can't access.
But I think it is concerning simply because we have had so many allegations or cases where the government and regulators haven't handled our data correctly. A huge example is police in Queensland accessing domestic violence victims, new addresses and phone numbers and things like that. And then it just gets bigger and bigger from Medicare data and so on and so forth. So I think the public has sort of lost faith that if the government had access to these sorts of things and if we didn't have this right to privacy, what protections are in place?
It's a little bit, they need to prove themselves before they can ask us or other social media giants will they trust in how they handle that? In 2018, Facebook established an oversight board which claims to make independent decisions about content on Facebook and Instagram. Do we know if that's been an effective way to tackle this question of free speech versus the need for content moderation? Amber?
I think when it comes to voluntary codes, you know, it's always concerned. I think sort of whilst companies say that independent and voluntary staffing is a massive concern. I don't know what's happened with Facebook and Instagram. I don't know what the outcome of that is.
But there has been at meta at X and absolute culling of moderators of the teams that are in charge of this. So it's really hard to say what the impact is. I'm not completely aware of what that's done. But I do think just asking companies to do it themselves is always going to be a real problem.
Yeah, I would agree with that too. I mean, part of what the government's next transfer of legislation in this area is talking about whether some of these voluntary codes should be made mandatory, whether there should be government oversight or the East Hoechner Commission oversight on some of these codes, make them more enforceable, more penalties, that sort of thing. On the Facebook oversight board, that did get a lot of play when it first came out. But I think it only really deals with a relatively small number of cases each year.
I mean, like I know that's very understandable when you think about how many billions of people have Facebook accounts. Obviously, they can't moderate every single discussion or every single complaint or report on Facebook. But I think that is part of the discussion that we're having here about for a long time, a lot of these codes. And not just for the social media company, we're talking about there's all these reviews like supermarkets and this sort of thing.
I think there is a broader reckoning in society about how much power and leeway we give to big companies of whatever industry and whether some of those big companies have prioritized profit or growth or expansion or shareholders or returns or whatever metric you want to use, prioritise that over the safety or the enjoyment or the lives of their customers, users, what have you. So I think there is a broader discussion. And this is the tech companies are one very big part of it about the power that big companies have in our society at the moment and whether they've been sort of left to their own devices for too long and whether the power that they have amassed is maybe too too much, too powerful to let them run themselves. So it's definitely a watch this space situation.
I think so. I mean, the governments like the Outline a broad range of things that they might plan to look at over coming weeks and months. So I think we might see a number of big changes on a number of different levels around the tech industry specifically in the not to do so future. Just changing tech a little bit here.
In the last fortnight, there's been two extremely violent events that have happened across Sydney. What responsibility do you think we really have as a media when it comes to reporting on these issues in a way that doesn't create more harm on top of what's already happened? If I can jump in again, I find this really interesting because of the way sort of graphic content is treated in different countries. I spent several years living in Spain and they will show absolutely gruesome images on the front page of paper with no blurring.
So it really comes down a little bit, I suppose, to public appetite and what people are comfortable seeing. I think, especially the media has lost so much trust in its audiences. And we frequently see people disengage from the news because they struggle with what's being presented, how it's being presented and the sort of constant bad news coming out. And I think if someone isn't ready to see graphic images like that, if they're just growing their feeds and they're confronted with it, I don't think that that's fair on them.
I think they sort of had consent to be shocked by graphic imagery. So I think when the media not only displays those images but reports on it, we do have to be very careful in using the correct terminology, making sure we're not further inciting violence or making people aware of certain channels where they could access that material. It is really a fine line between reporting and promoting. Josh?
Yeah, I think with a few obvious notable examples in the last couple of weeks around the person that was wrongly identified as the stabber in Bondi, I think mostly the coverage of these particular incidents has been, I think on the whole relatively responsible and could have been a lot more explosive or a lot more sort of incendiary in a worse circumstance. I think, I didn't really interest in how much coverage, some of these particular online influencer news personality, fake news people have gotten in the last couple of weeks, there's been a few that have been covered extensively in the mainstream media and given a bit of a platform. I think there is always that argument between giving something the appropriate scrutiny and light versus amplifying something unnecessarily. I think in these situations, obviously there is so much chaos and so much confusion in the initial periods when these incidents are happening.
It is very hard to report on these things sometimes. I think on the whole, there has things where relatively responsible. I think most of the mainstream outlets did a pretty good job of not blowing this up out of proportion of what it was, these incidents out of proportion for what they were. It will be interesting, I think more ongoing, there's a broader conversation to be had around not just these incidents, but what they say more broadly around social cohesion and sort of unity and that society.
I think that is a tricky discussion for the media to have and I'll be interested to see how that plays out of the coming weeks. These stories aren't going away, both these awful stabbing incidents I think will have quite a long tale, I guess, in the stories to tell and probably a lot more to come. I'll be interested to see how they are reported ongoing, I guess. Well, on that note, I'd like to thank our guests on for the State this week, Josh Butler.
Yeah, thanks. And Amber Schulz. Thanks so much, Nina. And thank you for listening to the program.
This edition was recorded at the studios of TUISER and heard across the country on the community radio network. Fourth Estate is produced with the assistance of the community broadcasting foundation, a big thanks to the foundation for their continuing support. Make sure you subscribe to Fourth Estate on your favourite podcast app, so you can hear us talk about media, politics and a lot in between. We'll be back with more next week, of course, but in the meantime, you can stay in touch with us on Twitter.
Our handle is Fourth Estate AU. I'm Tina Quinn. Thanks for listening. Stay well, stay safe and we'll catch you next week on Fourth Estate.