Skip to content
Elseworlds Exchange: Frank Miller's Superman & This Week’s Comics episode artwork

Jun 26, 2019 1 hr 15 min

Elseworlds Exchange: Frank Miller's Superman & This Week’s Comics

from Elseworlds Exchange Hosted by ComicPop

Tiffany and Sal recap/review some of the biggest comics of the past two weeks! See more at http://youtube.com/comicpop and help ComicPOP keep the lights on (and catch a super-secret Patreon-only podcast) at http://patreon.com/comicpop.

Episode details come from the podcast's RSS feed.

Embed this episode

Ready to play

Elseworlds Exchange: Frank Miller's Superman & This Week’s Comics

0:00 1:15:07
of matches

Transcript Auto-generated, may contain errors

This episode is brought to you by Patreon, specifically the Comic-Pop Patreon. Go to patreon.com.com.com and find out more about how you can keep the lights on here at Comic-Pop. And don't worry, we've got plenty of fun rewards, including early access to videos and weekly updates about what's happening here at the studio. That's patreon.com.com.

Alright, let's get on with the show. Weeding down upon the underworld to smash gangland, come a friend of the unfortunate enemy of criminal. In a serious, powerful character, a problem to the police, but a good state of law. Hey, welcome to Authoracum Sound.

Welcome to this show here on Comic-Pop, YouTube.com. Don't forget to like this video, subscribe to our channel, click the bell for notifications. If you want to, check out more that we have to offer. And if you're even more hungry for more Comic-Pop, be sure to patreon.com.

Slash Comic-Pop, check out all the tiers and rewards. We just created a new reward. It's very exclusive. Three slots, there's two open out of three right now for the Golden Age tier.

Are we creating a little Comic-Pop box? Just a bunch of stuff in the office we thought you might enjoy. And if you sign up first, first three, you get a little poster signed by the crew. That's cool.

Yeah, that's kind of neat. If you like that kind of thing, if you want that kind of thing, go check it out. See if it's something you want to check out. Outside of that, we're gonna talk about some books this week.

Tiffany is more than me. I'm gonna be talking most exclusively about the much hailed Superman year one. And when Mary anticipated, it was one of the first announced black label titles. And so, here it is.

It's finally here. The day has arrived. Frank Miller's Opus, where he's gonna take his take on Superman, unless you count the last three books he wrote that also co-starred Superman. So, let's jump in.

You have a couple more books on me. I really only have one because everything else I read was just catching up because of the news earlier this week that, like, Doctor Strange was going to be canceled. Oh no, Doctor Strange did cancel. I mean, like it is, oh no for me, but I know in the back of my mind that there'll probably be another Strange book coming out at some point because they'll do Doctor Strange.

The movie will, yeah, when they start with Doctor Strange 2, you guarantee a comic book time. Exactly. So, I'm kind of like, all right, I have not been digging Wade's run. I know a lot of people have been.

It's just not been my cup of tea. So, I was like, let me catch up on it just in terms of that. So, that's why I really did this week and it's fine. Sure, yeah, of course.

I mean, like, it was not your cup of tea when it started. It was getting great. And like, honestly, it just feels like right now he's just like throwing everything at it. Like, he's just like, oh, this, that, this, this, whatever.

Well, I'm sure they probably sold him, like, because behind the scenes, basically, I'm sure Wade is privy to Sapolsky's ear. I'm sure he was like, you're probably only gonna get like 14. Right. I'm understanding he's moving on to like a two-storm book.

Yes, he's gonna be doing it as a one. So fine. Which, by the way, like, great idea and I like the concept. What's funny about that is from the get-go with this book, I was like, it's like Wade wants to write Fantastic Four.

Probably does. He has written them in the past. He's done a good job with that team. So, so...

Makes sense. It's going to seem a storm. I'm like, yeah, you got what you wanted by not writing a book I cared about. Right.

So, thank you. This runs so far. I'm just kind of talking about it in terms of like news, I suppose. Yeah, like a new statement.

In the context of its cancellation, you've caught up in the text. I caught up because I've let it slide. I've been buying it, but just not reading it. It's a real like, tip-take.

Tip-take on what's happening in Dr. Strange. Yeah. It feels honestly like he's trying to like tell an old-school style story, which is admittedly cool.

Yeah. But it doesn't feel like it's as tight as it should be. Like, it has like a, you know, it doesn't matter. Let's just like, I need this plot to happen kind of like get-go to it.

Right. And now it's just like, it's almost as though he's being paid by the villain. Like, how many villains can I get in? Yeah, well, I also want to show, like, I'm only going to use the villains that you can name on one hand.

Yeah. Yeah. And honestly, I think part of like my problem with it as well is the fact that it- It's another example where it's like, Dr. Strange can only tell or be part of world ending events.

Or like, in this case, universe crumbling events, which is what's been going on. Is the idea of Dr. Strange being black as his herald cool? Yeah.

Yeah. Where it earned. Right. Which I didn't feel like it was, honestly.

And it's only for like a hot second. No. That's a problem that Marvel has in general. Yeah.

Where it's like, they don't want to build towards the thing that is awesome. Yeah. No. It's like, you're in a pitch session and you're like, okay, we're going to do like these 13 to 14 issues.

Yeah. And then they come to this moment, boom. Then we're going to do that. And they're like, whoa, whoa, that boom moment.

Can that happen to like the first issue? Yeah. And it's like, well, I mean- Like, could it like not? Yes, it can, but it doesn't- It wouldn't really be as satisfying like- Right.

Yeah, but we're trying to sell comics. Right. And he's not so much. He's a herald and name only.

Mm-hmm. Like he does not get to power cosmic or anything like that. He's literally just because Dormam is clearly in the dark dimension. He's like, basically the crux of this is the Dormam who gets shoved to the dark dimension.

And since he's a being of science- No, galactus gets scented to the dark dimension. I know, because Dormam is a dark dimension. Galactus gets shoved into the dark dimension. And because he's a being of science, which I was like, he's a cosmic being.

Yeah, he's a technically science. I mean like- I don't know because like honestly it's like, I always thought there was something, yes, sci-fi about cosmic beings, but also something intrinsically supernatural about them. You know what I mean? Maybe it should take.

I don't know if I would agree with you, but I definitely wouldn't say that Galactus is a science-fiction villain. Right. Exactly. I mean, he is like typically he is defeated via science.

Yes, and his origins come from being like a guy. Like a real man who has changed by the big bang. Exactly. But like he is a force of science in this and a force of nature as well.

Like they're like, you throw them in the dark dimension, it's gonna, it's gonna, it's gonna be a mystical dimension, it's gonna mess everything up. Everything's gonna mess it up and it's going to cause things to basically start unraveling in our, our dimension and this one. Okay. And I was like, I guess, but like it's more than they just keep saying it.

Right. And it's like we just keep saying it and then it's fact. Yeah. That's the kind of like- That's not enough.

It's not enough for me. And honestly, Wade's entire run has felt like he's just doing what Aaron did. Because what took away magic in Aaron's run, it was a cult of science. Yeah, cult.

Right? Like I'm just like, dude, come on, come on, you're better than this. Yeah. So anyway, I don't know, like I'm sad that the years that I've had of having Dr.

Strange books is coming to an end. Yeah. I feel like there's ups and downs for me and I think for a lot of people because just because I loved Aaron's run doesn't mean everybody loved Aaron's run. Just because I was less a fan of Kate's but now like Kate's is more than Wade's.

Yeah. You know what I mean? Hopeless for me was just, that was a shame. Right.

You did tie ins and you didn't do it well. No. Sorry. But like it's sad for me, but I, it's gonna be back.

Oh yeah. It's gonna be fine. And I just hope that when he's back it's with gusto and not with a rehashing of everything because like it's really easy for everyone to be like, all right, how do I deal with Strangers Magic? I'll take it away from him for a while.

And it's like we did that and we did that really well. Yeah. And now we're doing it again and we did it before and it's just like it's enough. Yeah.

It's cool. Just tell a normal story. Exactly. Okay.

It's gonna be fine. So if you hadn't been on the Dr. Strange bandwagon, your voice is right. It's true.

Yeah. So we should be coming out on Wednesday and then there's basically five or issues. So I'm interested to see if he's gonna wrap up this arc in 15 and then tell him any arc. Yeah.

I mean like, well, if you remember Mark Wade's last word on Dr. Strange wasn't his mini series, the Doctor is Out, which was set up by Bendis making Dr. Strange lose the title, Source or Supreme. Wade set up his mini series.

We invented a new character, had that character in some trouble and then left her in limbo. Yeah. Well, she's back. I know, but I'm just saying like when he stopped writing that mini, that was it and he didn't give it a satisfying conclusion and then immediately picked up about 10 years later.

Right. And I feel like we're not gonna get a conclusion on this either because he has set up so many little threads and there's no way he could possibly satisfy him. Tie them all up. No, I'm sure he will tie them all off because I think he, because of all of the telling not showing that's going on in the book.

I think that's probably he'll be like, oh, and I'm sure there'll be a scene. I can imagine it right now where Strange isn't the sanctum and he's talking to a character that's just created to bounce words off of. Sure. And they ask him questions about like, what about this, this, this, and this.

It's like, you know, like eight panels or whatever and Strange is like, oh, that and then just barely spreads the surface. Sure. Yeah, because he's got, he's got, what's her name came back? Do I can't remember what it was?

No, that's Z. No, that's Zoma. That's Aaron's creation. I meant his creation came back.

Yes, no. He's got the accountant, the mystical accountant. Right. Oh, he's setting up the fact that he, like, he and Cleo might be rekindling a romance.

Yeah, probably not though. And you have five issues left. Yeah. There you go.

What are you going to do? I don't know. But I just want to do a little recap because we've only been talking about Strange probably in like a couple of months. Yeah.

And just with this news, you know, that happened. It kind of got overshadowed for me because of the retiring of the vertigo label and the ramifications of that. Honestly, and I know a lot of people are like, what does it matter? Or not a lot of people are like, what does it matter?

They were, yeah. It's all moving over to it just under the black label and it's, he's going to sneeze. Okay. See, that was like unsatisfying.

Anyway, for me, it just comes out of the fact of what vertigo meant back in the day. It was the idea of like what images become in a way where it's like independent creators, like creating things with having basically a larger audience to speak to and having the ability to tell an adult story for an adult audience. Yeah. Add a lot of like meddling.

I've heard it go by the wayside with the departure of Karen Berger, obviously. Yep. And it's just been languishing in like mediocrity. Yeah.

Upon its reinvigoration. I think once ago. Yes. I think they made a mistake in putting game and basically not in charge, but like okaying the stories because the reason given was successful with Sam and was because he had an editor like Karen Berger who wasn't intrinsically tied to that universe and instead he selected just one universe to expand upon instead of like going back in and delving into what made vertigo so great.

Right. So for me, it's just, it's sad to see that time change and the fact that now everything will be under DC fully and so I don't think we'll be getting that level of story any longer. Yeah. The other problem that I had, somebody who asked me to weigh in as well about the vertigo thing and people were really like kind of vehement about how little it matters.

You know, they were like, why are you getting so upset about it? Which actually I think is a good indicator that like we should be talking about it and that like it's a good thing to be discussing because we're rattling cages and making people upset and the reason why they're getting upset is because they don't like understand nor do they respect it and they don't want to hear the bad news and they don't want to think about a larger looming issue at large and that issue is this because I've heard a lot of things I heard I saw actually a former vertigo author talking about how it's like why are we talking about this death when we should be talking about all these great imprints from these independent publishers that capture 0.02% of the market like maybe because it's one thing to have an independent publisher making groundbreaking comics that no one's reading. Yeah. And it's another entirely to have 50% of the market share behind independent esque titles Yes.

And encouraging newer authors to get into the industry on a higher profile level right? Vertigo represented that and the dissolution of vertigo I'm sorry. The dissolution of vertigo represents a fundamental shift and an embracing of what we've all kind of been thinking about and talking about quietly to each other that Marlon DC really don't give a shit about comics anymore. Yeah, I think it's it's not even that I think that it shows I think it shows a fundamental mistrust between the corporate and the creators.

Well, certainly both have had their issues with each other. Yes. And that's always been a thing. Right.

Well, I was literally just reading an interview with a game in which they mentioned the fact that like when he was during this time period of writing Sam and so this is back in the 90s and he was pretty much wrapping it up. He was on the kindly ones who had kindly ones coming out and then the wake was going to follow. And I mentioned that they mentioned the fact that like the interviewer was like you've been writing this basically unhindered by anyone in charge. Yeah.

And like just how incredible that is obviously and it comes down to the fact that they trusted him as a creator because he had the ability to self edit himself right like more than can't. Well, yes. Like self edit himself in like he trusted his audience with a certain level of maturity but he didn't push it too far necessarily. He took ownership and accountability for the story.

That's the big caveat is accountability because like no editor wants to take accountability for like stifling a creator. No creator wants to accountability for the impact that their like creative footprint has on the audience. Right. Right.

And I feel like it's better like not that there's like a there's like a fine line here between like censoring creativity. Yeah. But like I feel like if creativity needs to be if you need to have accountability on your creativity, isn't it better for the artists to have that accountability than have someone tell them they can't do it. But I can't trust that a creator will be that way.

And so you need oversight and adversity does breed ingenuity. Right. So I believe in the editor creator relationship. I absolutely agree with that.

But I think the reason that like back in the day vertigo flourish and the way that it did was first of all, those books did start in under DC to begin with and they realized they're like, oh, these are actually kind of not. I'm sure they got a lot of backlash like retailers who were like, what do you do? Yeah, this is hard for us to just slap the DC label on it. Let's shift it over here.

Yep. But the creators who were creating at that time period had a great relationship with their editors. Yes. And the editors were able to trust them in what they were putting out there.

Also they knew they were putting it out under an adult like label. Yeah. And so they were able to tell their stories the way that they wanted to tell them. Yeah.

It just comes down to the fact is like with what we've seen happen with black label, we think. Oh, black label. We're not going to be seeing the maturity that vertigo had. And that's why I'm sad.

And honestly, seeing what they're going to be doing with some of these characters, the fact that Swamp Thing is going to a young adult comic and little Johnny Constantine will be debuting in a middle grade comic. That's really like it's like a slap in the face to vertigo fans. Straight up the watchman babies joke from the Simpsons. Like it is basically just like, okay, so I'm going to take this fundamentally adult themed character and I'm going to turn them young and I'm going to make them for an all ages audience.

Like, and I can imagine people devil's advocating because I don't know why the people within the industry or within the fandom want to devil's advocate things that are in direct opposition to their own interests. We're like, I mean, isn't there room, isn't there room for a child themed? Yeah. Constantine, can't we have a toddler book watchman?

Can't we have a V for Vendetta that is just for kids? And it's like, no, yeah, because they're fundamentally not oriented for that. Because when you change it to that degree, because they were created in this circumstance to be oriented for a specific target audience, when you change it, don't you change it to the point where it is unrecognizable as the thing it was? And what's the point of making an all ages Constantine anyway?

Like, who are you trying to get? Yeah. Well, how many children under the age of 12 are reading Constantine or who are not reading Constantine who would suddenly become flourishing DC Comics fans were only they were to get their hands on all ages Hellblazer book. Right.

That doesn't make any sense. Yeah. And it's, it's such a fundamentally tone deaf response to how the industry is reacting to a constant flourishing of alternative of alternatives to itself. Like the industry is like, well shit, it used to be that we were battling against like, Oh, I don't know, Tiddly Winx, Jax, Saks and television and movies.

But now I got to deal with like streaming services and video games and movies, TV, everything else. And instead of just catering for markets that are specifically for those things, we're going to like consolidate everything and sanitize it to a point where it's unrecognizable and it appeals to no one. Yeah. And so it has no flavor now.

Congratulations. Um, it's so frustrating to hear that the company that created something that like set set ablaze the comic book industry creatively is now doing almost practically the opposite. We are in the same year, we're publishing a watchman sequel. We're going to be putting out a Constantine kids book.

Yeah, I just end we're like, and we're dissolving vertigo. Right. I wanted to, I wanted to double check. And yeah, there are several articles about this.

The name of the Constantine graphic novel for middle grade DC kids, middle grade readers coming out in 20, 20 and 21 is the mystery of the meanest teacher colon a Johnny Constantine graphic novel Johnny Constance by Ryan North. Boy. Yeah. So that's what we're looking at right now.

So stupid. It is frustrating the fact that this article or the articles of these various things came out like two days ago. It was like, we found it was being dissolved. Here's this line up for all these young adult things.

And it's like, I get it. You're scrambling for ideas for that. But don't take these characters from so far from what they once were. Yeah.

The other thing is like, I've been seeing like, well, what about making hellblazer like a teen only book? You know who read Sandman and Hellblazer? They weren't 45 year old men. No, it was like, it was high schools and.

It was a senior high school. It was 13 year olds. Yeah. It took 19 year old.

I'd say 15. I think really. Here's the thing. When I was 13, I was starving for adults, or in itself.

That's fair. And because comics kind of slipped under the radar, I was able to get it. And now it's even easier to get all to get adult ages comics without having to run them past my parents. Right.

So like, no, publish the real shit. You know, it's not the movies. We're like, oh, we're going to buy a ticket for the Toy Story movie, but I'm really going to go see the already movie. Right.

I don't think you have to worry about that anymore. But like, just put out the books. The audience will find it. Yeah.

I can't make that book anymore because no one's buying it. Like Dr. Strange. Exactly.

But like, no, the collapse of vertigo, now in reality is like, it's an imprint. It's a label. Anyone can bring it back. You get a new editor or whatever.

No, and it may. But it's a thematic like representation of the overall problem that we've been talking about for a couple of years now. To the point where they were like, oh, we're making black label. It's this adult themed.

Oh shit. We can't have too many adult things in there. Actually now it's going to be like an else world book and actually also you don't even really need vertigo because we're going to put the vertigo books out here. Yeah.

Oh, but you can't though because they can't be too envelope pushing. Otherwise, we won't put them out or we'll censor them to the point where damned, which should have come out like a year ago, is the finally just coming out next week. Right. What I was going to say, can you imagine in this day and age someone's pitching preacher?

Yeah. No. Actually, I'll do you one better. They pitched a Superman is Jesus book to black label.

They approved it. Oh, and then after damn, they're like, never mind. And they canceled it. And but but but I will say this.

DC did give the creative team the luxury of being allowed to take that book and bring it to an independent publisher where they can be where they can finally have their have their message. Great. We're going to have the audience will find it. Right.

If your comic shop orders the the goddamn. It's just frustrating that this is happening and it's like in direct opposition to success and to rationality because like damned would have sold like gangbusters if you would just leaned into it. Yeah. But no, and vertigo could have been something if you actually had like an idea behind it, just like new 52 would have actually been like a successful idea.

It was successful initially in finances, but it wasn't a successful creative endeavor because there was no forethought. It was just a reaction. It was an opportunity they took without any planning. This is DC's problem every time.

Yeah. They never took the water for ice before they plunge right in. No, absolutely. We have to jump in.

We have to keep going. Yeah. That's your final thought on the vertigo thing. Oh, no.

That's Johnny Constance. Johnny Constance. That one really pissed me off. There's so many other titles coming out under these young adult readers.

And he was like, do I love the idea of creating young adult content? Yes. They did that. Didn't Bendis have a whole thing?

Yeah. I think they're being rolled into this. Right. Wasn't that like the Wonder comics?

Wasn't that like the whole initiative? Yeah. No, I think it's all being rolled into this. But I appreciate that.

I love that idea. But don't announce this right after you say you're retiring. Well, that just shows no one in the wheel. We're going to cancel the vertigo and in the same sentence talk about how we're like, I don't even know what the term is.

Yeah. It really feels like, again, it does feel like a slide to the face. It really does. It's like, it's a piss in the face.

Yeah. And I get a lot of people. Vertigo's been dead. And it's like Vertigo never was given a fair chance.

Again, they handed it to Gaiman and other people who were like working on that and developed the Saman universe. That's not what Vertigo was. Saman was a piece of Vertigo. Yeah.

But there were so many other hands that went into that and so many other creators who went into that and it was such a mistake to hand it to a single creator and not just bring in another strong editor. And then you released the hashtag, remember Vertigo. Yeah. That the amount of books I saw from that tag and from the conversation that followed over on Twitter and actually in our community tab, if you go to our community tab, you'll find a conversation you can jump into if you're on YouTube right now.

That's great. But like a ton of books, no, no, like Sandman's Shore, but also Preacher, American Vampire and so on thing and like, why the last man's and none of them are in the same universe and all of them are except for Saman's Wapley. But like, for the most part, most of them are not in the same universe and they all are so different from each other. It's like Vertigo wasn't a Sandman universe title.

No. What are you doing? No. Vertigo was just like, Vertigo.

They don't know what to do. Yeah. No, they really didn't know what to do and they had lost their guidance and they lost their way. And I think DC editorial clearly had too great of an influence on what was happening over there.

They went the safe route because they felt like they could trust Neil and I think you can't show Neil what should be fair. Neil didn't write any of these books. No. No said that's okay story.

That's okay story. But he didn't write them. Yeah. Well, and DC clearly didn't have any real belief in it because like, how many of you bought it?

How many of those books survived? Yeah. How many of those books were promoted in any significant way? No, it's true.

They were just, it is what it is. So we'll be saying goodbye to Vertigo for the time being. Yeah. And again, it doesn't mean it can't come back.

I know people are like, it's going to come back and it's like, yes, it might never be the same. No. And like it may just be one of those things where it's like, that's fine. Like maybe it should be.

Yeah. Or like it just needs to be respected. Right. And the creations that came out of it need to carry weight and receive them.

Yes. Well, I mean, I think they need to carry the weight of what they were and what it meant for a while. Yes. And like we need to not forget that comics can be adults, for adults and they can't have adult themes in them and they can tell great stories.

And we can still have comics that exist for all ages. Yeah. We can still have them over there and it's okay for Vertigo to have existed and for like folks like Transmitment or Polloten to have existed as well. Yeah, exactly.

So we also wanted to mention that this is a collaborative show despite the fact that we've been talking. We've been talking. If you use the Super Chats, we encourage you to voice your opinion and share your thoughts or ask your questions and we'll make it part of the show. Well, we focus entirely on the Super Chats just because we allow the chat to have its own conversation, Super Chats for our conversation and also because it keeps these lights on over here.

So thank you very much. Let's jump into them. As if C. Now, first keep Comic-Pop draws.

It was great. Thank you. It was a show that we created to be created entirely. It was a great like, you know, drawing challenge show.

Didn't do nearly as well as we expected. But like I was doing it again. We're going to keep doing it anyway because it's a good show. I don't care.

Yeah. Sometimes it really feels like there's like a boot on our channel. Like the way that there's a boot on the car. Yeah, like you can't go.

Like there's just like there's something in the way that is like actually external. Flashable says, tip your hat is dope. Thank you. I love my hat.

Thank you so much. Matt Shirley, do you think Burns Luther will ever come back? I mean, I feel like he never really left. Burns Luther was like a scientist, but like an evil mad scientist.

But he kind of blended the whole like, business man. Yeah, he's way more than real. He's whatever the hell. He's whatever Snyder wants him to be.

He's whatever they think an evil mega conglomerate owner would be. Well, he's whatever like a, I don't know. He's like all men in the Christ on two earths. Zach Maxfield says, thoughts on Chimp's adartical run.

It's great. Pick it up by to the Darcy's Daredevil. It's a great series. You'll be glad you did.

Skorros is, although it was creatively driven, Vertigo still had some shifting. Some cycling of creativity like Elis Hell laser. Shoot for not being published at the time. Yeah, there was creative stifling shirt.

I mean, like they didn't approve everything. No, it wasn't. That's not the point. No, no, the point is that most of it was approved.

The fact is like, Game and also in the interview I was reading mentioned that there was an artist he really wanted to work with. But Karen Berger was like, I don't think that's a good idea because it was a little too cartoony. And it was probably a good call. Right.

Like, editors there to help a creator should be there to help a creator create the best possible product. Yeah. Like creation. Exactly.

Price 80 40, cel rants, you know, there's a sad thing very much. I appreciate it. Felix, no Laskos is sticking to the man sale. I mean, like, I don't know.

I'm just saying these things because like we are all like many like that's how I feel. I'm not trying to like stick it. I'm just, you know, we just get it out there. Just thoughts out there.

David 22's a sale. Give watch when baby's a chance. It could work. Yeah, right.

And then it can be an animated series and it can be a toy line. I mean, like, you know, the sky's the limit as far as the marketability watch. Kevin Vous is these shoots and own a milestone. It does.

DC like acquired milestone, but then didn't realize they had to pay their creators every time they like made money off of it. And so they tried to make a secret deal behind the backs of the like owners slash owners of the estates of the creators of milestone to create milestone 2.0, which is why you saw an announcement from milestone characters and then nothing ever happened about it. They don't talk about it because like they tried to create like a parallel milestone that allowed that used characters that like they got like signed off on and also characters that were like creation adjacent. Again, more of shadable shit.

Carl Rodriguez turn mature characters all ages, but also force a fun and youthful super boy, super son. Everyone loved to grow up. DC logic not listening since always. Exactly.

Yeah, it's there's nothing but contradiction. Yeah. Now, like that being said, like if the Bendis book really did like if the issue where John turns into a teenager was like crazy great sales and the response from the audience was that of like overwhelming positivity, then like over the first to shut up about it, you know, you're like, you know, or at least at the caveat of like they changed John into a teenager, which sucks for me, but not for everybody because apparently I'm wrong. Like, you know, I'll definitely add that caveat if you can prove it, but you can't because it's not because it's still up as R.E.D.

has to take a hard drinking chain smoking, even fighting, even fighting like asshole and turn him into like a little boy. Isn't that fun? Yeah. And I will bow to smile.

Mjounyane says, Hey, so how do you feel like this is a very reactionary top down initiative from DC's parent company response to boy DC stuff sure is too dark for me. I have no fucking idea. It feels like they felt like they were spiraling out of control and had too many things going on. And so they were like, just scale it back.

I don't know. I would love to know like how much is like the three or four creative voices behind the scenes that drive everything that happens to DC and how much of it was corporate because like it's easy to say like corporate overlords ruin everything AT&T Warners, but like I don't know that and I don't know that because like I don't have a statement. I don't have a name. I don't have anything to back up any any kind of like true stance on that subject.

I mean like you can say anything, but without evidence, you're only as good as like people's belief in what you're saying. Yeah. So like you need to have some kind of like foundation of truth at the core. And so like I don't know how much of it was, you know, parent company driven.

Yeah. I know that like forever, one of others didn't give a shit and left DC alone. Right. And now they're not.

Yeah. Like or now DC is suddenly like really concerned with image. So I'm sure that's a thing. Yeah.

Greg Demage says, Hey, did you hear Ironheart is meeting Dr. Strange? I didn't wait, it's not writing it. I'm a chitter.

TARDIS man 85 says, Hey, Sal, what do you think of medieval in debt in debt? Come on. I had a while here to sit here and figure that out. I was like, I dropped that book.

I don't care about the Arkham Knight and I found it really boring. I love Tomasi, but like I couldn't read it anymore. There you go. I dropped that book.

I don't know who that is. I'm sorry, but thank you very much for the recommendation. Before we jump into the other book that we want to talk about, the book we actually want to talk about, I do want to like give a shout out to the fact that I picked up Aquaman. This is like the most Aquaman I've ever read.

It's two issues right in a row. Yeah, I know. Thanks to the amazing art of Victor Bugdanovic. It's great.

I know the show. He reminded me that it was coming out, thanks to a spectacular panel that he tweeted of The Mother Shark being, you know, all of an Arthur's face basically. It's just a spectacular gorgeous panel that he created and he might be a princess. I want to tell you, like based on the bombshell reaction of that issue, I would, or at the end of the issue, I'd say it's the best time to be reading Aquaman.

I honestly, here's the thing, guys. I'm not like not saying I'm not a fan of Aquaman. I'm just not an Aquaman reader, so I've just been really enjoying these past two issues at this issue in particular. I really love the exploration and celebration of the romance between Merra and Arthur and how, in love, they are how they're treating Arthur Curry right now with a bit more humor, which I'm really digging on.

He just really wants to hang out with her and be with her and stuff like that. She's like, I'm a woman of Atlantis right now. Exactly. And spoilers, she's pregnant.

Yes. And that's a big bombshell that leads to her killing him, which leads to this whole Mother Shark incident, right? I kind of love that. I mean, I've always thought that they were a great pairing, again, having not really read them all that much.

She just wanted to see them together. I like their relationship. It's like weirdly realish. You know what I mean?

It's not all perfect and so kind of daisies. No, that's great. And this clearly is not, obviously, she just can't handle his reaction because he's having all these inside thoughts and not sharing them because he's not ready to share them and she can't handle that because she just told him something that's truly life-changing for both of them. Yes.

And he wants to leave. Right. And so she loses control of her abilities and ends up killing him and clearly herself. Right.

And so she comes back though. So they're both back. I'm really interested in this now. I have no idea honestly what's been going on, but I'm loving the art.

I feel like Victor has come so far in his artistic career and I can't wait to see more of where he is going with this. So just all in. Yeah. All in.

Totally. Yeah. And it's like just don't use him anymore. Yeah.

Greg the Mage says, who's Magic System? Do you like that or DC or Marvel or both? For both of you guys, the question is that and why. I understand Marvel's better, but I feel like it's more childlike, like it's more silly and fun.

DC's feels like it has actual weight and like complication. I find magic to be impenetrable and difficult to really like grasp. And I think that DC does a really good job of reflecting that my lost in the woodsness about magic, which I like, you know, like part of the trees and the red. That there's these elements that all make up this patchwork that is DC magic.

I think that's really cool. Although I also find it intentional and I want to read about it. Marvel's it's like magic. Someone has a mutant ability to control it for God's sake.

Like that's, I get that because I don't have to get it. It's literally just Stanley versus anybody else. Like Stanley's like, how about he has magic? I don't want to write anything anymore.

Like how much is whatever? Like I'm in. That's my magic for me. I like them both.

I think what you feel about DC's is that like we've seen a stronger development of that and again, in part due to the fact that we have characters like Wonder Woman and you have the ability to literally pinpoint like the supernatural and mystical elements of the Greek like Pantheon going on that literally you have a Pantheon right there. And like so I think that's a little bit easy. Pantheon and Marvel too. I know but it's a little more I feel like it's more in your face here because like Wonder Woman still.

With Wonder Woman being directly from it. I mean, but you know she's part of the Trinity. Yes. I mean like yeah, her piece is an adventure and like, you know, she's not a yeah.

She's still relevant. Right. Exactly. And honestly, you know what the fludge Wonder Woman's origin to make her work currently is like well, you know, it's funny that on the other hand you do a Thor and his but then they go back and forth as to what it is is it actually magic is it not as whatever.

You know what I mean? Like so there's been that going on. I think though we find often in DC again, thanks to a lot of Vertigo books, there's more development in terms of magic. Yeah.

And like a lot of those who have been writing that really pay attention. Yeah. And like honor the creations of those who come beforehand. Right.

Obviously I love Dr. Strange. Let's be honest, it started off with just a bunch of random mumble jumbo that they found and just threw at the walls and like from that lore was created. Obviously the other side is doing that as well.

Right. And I think that there is some deep lore involved with you know, Dr. Strange in particular and Marvel itself. But I think it's just like explored.

Yes. At least currently. I think it's just like magic recently. It was like, oh no, that was that was that was yeah.

That was a mistake. Right. So anyway, yeah. Yeah.

So Superman, yeah, one this book came out and I guarantee it won't be too late when book two comes out. So okay. It's Frank Miller's version of the origin of Superman. Yeah.

It's set in the millivers. So it's the same Superman that fights Batman and Darnette Returns and everything after that. Right. Which is bizarre.

Yeah. It's actually kind of like too bad. Well, it's just I don't understand because like you seem to indicate that you indicate but you thought you would hurt that like Frank really likes Superman and like he's looking forward to telling the story. It's like then you can't put it in the Millerverse.

No, because Frank was like, no, when you read about Superman, you're reading it from Batman's perspective. It's all horseship. Like the fact is Frank said in interviews that like the reason why Superman like looks like a Jack Loonie-Kashapah thug and the reason why such toolbox is because you're looking at it from a bat. I'm writing a Batman book.

Right. So obviously like no one will be as cool or great as Batman in the Batman book. But I'm writing a Superman book like Batman will look like a lunatic anarchist asshole jerk if he were to be in it. Like so it'd be very, you know, and it's like no, you're just no.

Yeah, you just want to have your cake and eat it too. Yes. And that's what it is. This is a complete, it's just another origin of Superman.

Yep, that's what it is. And it's Frank's version. So like everyone's insane and it does take liberties and changes some fundamental things. That doesn't change him because it's own universe.

Right. I struggled a little bit with this book honestly at times, especially with the narration. Oh, big. I was like, who's the narrator?

I think Superman. Yeah, but that was what I was like, oh, Superman. Oh, maybe it's not Superman. Right, Superman.

No, it's not Superman. Like the way that the tenses change the like I guess the perspective of them like what level narrator they are. I was like, I don't know what's going on here. Yes.

I mean, I'm not sure if people are anticipating not only our reaction, but also reading it themselves because they're like, oh boy, Frank Miller, he's out of his mind. Let's see what his crazy dark night strikes again. I'm actually amazed at how boring this is. Yeah.

Like, I like slow burns. I enjoy Superman origins. And yet this was like really hard to get through every time that I was like I came to a chapter break because it feels like several chapters in this book without there actually being like identifiable chapters. Yeah, yeah, yeah.

I was like, oh, yeah, well, I need to take a break. But then I realized if I did, I forget everything that happened in the last part of the story. I don't know how like simultaneously generic and also boring it was. I mean, it's very harsh to say that this book was boring and generic.

So anyway, what do you think about this book? I didn't think it was boring and generic. I was of course expecting a little more lunacy. I think I found more of that sort of like what the hell's happening at times.

The dialogue didn't quite flow away. No, not especially. No, whatever. Like I get it fine, whatever.

But like what I did enjoy about it was the part, the portion in which Clark is in school, but not in high school or maybe he's like a freshman. He's a freshman. He's a freshman. He's a freshman time.

I mean, it would be like, yeah, it's like, here's a bunch of kids together. They're having a good time with the going on adventures and that kind of stuff. And there was something kind of endearing about that, honestly. Yeah, I was actually taken by the very beginning of Clark going to school.

Yes. I was like, oh, I was thinking I was like, where we're going with this? Like I kind of liked Clark and his father going to school. That made like zero sense.

Like, why is there a parade? Oh, I don't know. There's always a parade. It's multiple.

The idea of Clark like being an outcast deliberately the fact that he like gravitated toward like the freaks. Yeah. That felt more I think you're right about the Stephen King thing that felt more like a stranger things influence than anything else Oh sure what is that influence? Oh, yeah, but I mean like but some people don't understand that like yeah It's what is this Clark a friend like I don't know There's a lot of like okay, you need to throw away your preconceived ideas of like what a Superman origin is I guess Clark Can Superman is in order to really appreciate this book as its own because like all the characters are Versions of the characters you remember unless they're new like everyone in Clark's friend group Yeah, we're also there a little bit, but he is in no way influential in Clark's life No, I think he is like I really took the other group of friends like as actually a clever plot device And I'm gonna put clever in quotes.

Yeah, and the Frank put in there where it's like Clark gravitated towards them because of who he'll become Yeah, like he is he is drawn to those who need help and those who can't stand up for themselves Even if he doesn't recognize why yeah, and perhaps it's the echoing of Jorrell obviously that was like going on It's like flying through space. No, or perhaps it is the echoing of pa himself. Yeah, I don't really care But like I can I was fine. I feel like I needed a little more page time to actually develop a little what more of their relationship I kind of get it.

I just don't I think it I think Frank's assuming you know, right But then he changes it because like you know, you know, you know, you think you know who pa is right then you watch like man Steel and pause like maybe she's like people die. I'm gonna jump in a tornado But like and that's not pa right but then you also like we've killed like livestock because we to burn today like whatever Yeah, this pa is like I get him and there's a couple moments that like actually echo my own childhood where you know these like Clark is asking pause at the dinner table like what do I like what do I do do I hit them? Yeah, you know, do I try to talk them down? He's like you talk to them and then you hit them yeah, and I'm like, yeah, okay I get that spot but like this was also like I don't know he's kind of insane well I feel like well yeah early the first few pages of this it's like it's almost like Frank's Dustin off the cobwebs Yeah, he didn't go back to fix it.

Frequently asked questions

How long is this episode of Elseworlds Exchange?

This episode is 1 hour and 15 minutes long.

When was this Elseworlds Exchange episode published?

This episode was published on June 26, 2019.

Is there a transcript available for this episode?

Yes, a full transcript is available for this episode. You can read the complete transcript on the episode page.

Can I download this Elseworlds Exchange episode?

Yes. Use the download control on the episode player to save the publisher-provided media file.