Hey, you have a show or YouTube channel, podcast, or relevant product that you want to promote at the top of the Elspers Exchange? Well, not your chance, man. For 50 bucks, you'll get a month's worth of plugs at the audio version right here at the Elspers Exchange. Right at the top of the show, first thing you'll hear, and it'll probably still be my voice, but you'll write up a short one minute plug, we'll record it and toss it to the front of the show.
Or, alternatively, for 20 bucks, you can get a month's worth of plugs at the end of the show, right after you hear us sign off, same deal, one minute script and plug for your stuff. How do you take advantage of this incredible opportunity? Just go to thereelconicpop.com, hit the contact button at the top and fill everything out and work it out through PayPal. We do reserve the right to reject or accept based on our own personal taste.
I'm not going to plug your Nazi podcast, man. I'm sorry. You know what? I'm not sorry about that.
But you're not going to do it anyway. So go to thereelconicpop.com, hit the contact button at the top of the page, fill everything out, and we'll work it out. All right, let's get on with the show now. Waiting down upon the underworld to smash gangland, come a friend of the unfortunate enemy of criminal.
In mysterious, all powerful characters, a problem to the police, but a crusade of law. Hello, everybody, and welcome to Comic Pop, I'm Sal. I'm Ben. And I'm Tiffany.
Today, we're just going to take a topic, rip straight from the comic book headlines and then hash it out for you guys. And then you can take the conversation and carry it on in the comments down below. Today, we're going to talk about the versus topic of what's better, arguably. And this is not necessarily, there's no different answers.
I don't think it's just a way we might come home. Who knows? Yes. What's better?
Just creating brand new characters in the mainstream big two universe or letting new characters inhabit the roles of established popular characters. I cite the all new all different Marvel, replacing WASP, Captain America, Spider-Man, etc., etc., or in DC, having people sub in for Batman or becoming new Superman and so forth. Should they just start making new characters and just push them really hard? Or should they just try and try letting younger, newer folk inhabit these iconic roles?
Which is better arguably? And really, where does that go? Where does that conversation take us? So I've seen a lot of chatter about this topic.
And I've just, oh yeah, off the bat, you know, I've seen Marvel push new characters. And in fact, DC is going to be starting to create and roll out new characters after the dark metal stuff. They're going to start making new, yeah, no question, it's going to be uber metal. But they're going to be creating new characters and putting them out there and trying new stuff and pushing them.
Never a mosaic? No. Yes. Yeah.
Yeah. Because we read an issue of it. Why didn't we care about mosaic? Was it because he was a crappy character?
Because arguably there's some people who say that he's a really great character. Or was it because Marvel insisted upon him? Or was it because there's just so many damn characters I just don't have time or money to a lot to a new guy when I regularly buy Spider-Man? But that's kind of a different conversation.
Like you're questioning why people like your character. We want to discuss what's better. What's better move? I think it depends on the intent.
Right. Oh, and by that I mean look at Ms. Marvel. Yes.
The original Ms. Marvel Carol Danvers I think is more successful as Captain Marvel. She was an Air Force Captain. Yes.
And while yes I appreciate the lineage and the heritage of keeping up Ms. Marvel being the first character to carry the moniker Ms. after it was created. Yeah, there's some feminist undertones.
It means something. Exactly. It does mean something. It's not just feminizing of Captain Marvel characters.
No, but I do like Kamala Khan feeling that role being a fan of Ms. Marvel and wanting to take up that mantle but not being her 100%. I think a very different character than that. Yeah, but I think that's a good example of that working.
I agree with that. I think that everyone would agree that Ms. Marvel succeeded. And I think it's because they went in a totally different direction.
You know, they weren't just like here's a character that you know the name of. They're doing something pretty much like the other character like in the 80s Jim Rhodes took over from Tony Stark and became Iron Man. And it wasn't like a big thing where they put it in every USA Day article. They write a Wall Street Journal analysis about what that meant for the culture.
It was just what the roads is my friend. It'd be like if you know I wasn't here and then one of you so did for me. Like that's what it would be like. It was the natural, professional character.
But think about this without creating new characters you were not going to have an expanded universe without creating new characters. You're not going to have any superheroes. Well, you're not going to have Jim Rhodes, a seven for Iron Man once in a while. You're not going to have the X-Men.
You're not going to have Superman. Those were all created. They were new when they were. And I see what you're saying, but it's easier to sell a book based on the legacy and history of a character than it is to sell a book.
Or to try and start a new one. Yeah, exactly. In a world where it is a Marvel or DC universe, you're more successful in creating characters and independent books because those books typically aren't tied to one another. I mean, I'm the built in audience for independent comics is expecting new and different characters and expecting a character that they've never seen before.
In fact, maybe even seeking that kind of experience when you, I guess you're implying that a regular consistent Marvel DC reader is a Marvel DC reader because they're on here for Superman. Yeah. Like you said, it's a shared universe. Yeah.
I mean, here's a really terrible analogy. Okay. I love Dynasty Warriors and they keep adding characters to it, right? Did they exist in history?
I'm sure they did and they did some degree but they keep adding them in, right? And they might be fine characters and they might have rich history. And someone's like, oh, that's cool. At the end of the day, I just want to play the original guys.
I'm still playing Lulu. Well, I never played Lulu. I got to tell you. But like, come on, you and like, you know, sounds out.
Like, that's who I want to play because I like their stories and I've played them about that was in times and I don't care. So let's translate that into this. It's like, okay, Marvel, you've created some new characters. Look at them go.
I like the repetition of it but I recognize it as repetition. Yeah, so you're not, you're like, okay, I'm not breaking new brown. No. I just work well.
And I know that and I will only go into it. On the other hand, I am an independent comic reader. Yes. And you, you, you, you buy other games that are not as a franchise.
I do, I do. Like the strange. Yeah, but like, what I'm saying is like, I feel like I can see both sides of this quote. Fair enough.
I was wondering, does it make more sense especially when you take a brand and put a new character into them? Like for, like for, or someone who is always constantly changing, like, imagine the Spiderman universe. Yeah. Spiderman 29.
Yes. You've got so many different characters that can be a Spiderman. Yes. Do they have their own merits or in a sense, are they just diluted versions of Spiderman?
Right. Do you just want to go back? See, that's the thing. For me in the Spiderman world, the more Spider characters the worse it gets because I think you are diluting the brand.
That said, there were characters they created over time that have since then contributed their own legacy and their own character. Spiderwoman, for example, Jessica Drew is her own Spiderwoman. Yeah. But then again, I think Julia Carpenter was her own Spiderwoman and then she became Adam Webb and so forth.
But like the more Spiderman you add, which is why I was never a big fan of Spiderman. It's why I was never a big fan of Spider-Verse because it was like, hey, look how interchangeable and disposable these characters are. They're all the same. Look at how unremarkable Peter Parker's story is when it comes down to it because there's a thousand of him.
You know, not just like, oh, Spiderman 29 kind of works because Miguel O'Hara is not Peter Parker. Very different character and in a very different setting and he's set apart from Spiderman. Here's a funny about Spiderman just in general because for the most part what you're talking about is more or less the creation of new characters who happen to have Spiderman. Exactly.
It's very rare. It's not happened. It has happened when people have taken up the mantle of the Spiderman. Yeah.
But for the most part it is just new characters being created. It's like a character that has Spider-Powers because they kind of brand that works. Yeah, because they're like, well, we're just gonna make them Spiderman. That's what's weird about that.
That's actually your thing about intent because is it because somebody has a great idea for this character and then having Spider-Powers is just incidental or integral to their character or is it because someone in editorial or someone who wants to make a lot of money says, you know what I've noticed? People like the Spider-Powers and the costume and if we put those together and then we apply them to any character I will, I'm guaranteed sales. And if that's the case, that sucks. Like that sucks and I think it sucks because not only does it, will it ultimately ring hollow, you know, people will, they say that especially in art, the cream rises to the top.
Yeah. You know, so if your character is made for selfish reasons and it doesn't have any real integrity, then the readers will tell you why not behind it. Right. Right.
At the same time then we have a Harley Quinn book. Or you have, we're done by the huge fan-out. That's fair. I mean, like, what is in Harley Quinn is one of the four pillars of the DC?
Right. And she's a good example of a new character created that, you know, had nothing to do with taking up the mantle of another. No. Just a new character created that everyone now enjoys.
Oh, it was literally like a Robin to Joker. Yeah. But like a part timer and then became literally one of the four things that keeps the DC afloat. Exactly.
But I think right now people tend to not care for new characters because we've seen too many new characters created as plot devices. That's true. And if I could cite Ulysses from Civil War II. Yeah.
Although it's interesting, I always hated Layla Miller. She was created. She's the Ulysses of the House of M. And yet Peter David and some other writers did interesting things with her.
Yeah. But at the end of the day, what they did with her was I want to do something with the character I want to create. I'll just take that character and then put her name on whatever. There's no real progression for Layla Miller.
It's literally one day she's somebody else. They just start writing her as somebody else. So. She went from not interesting to interesting but not because of a character progression.
Let me ask you now. Jane Foster. Yes. Jane Foster established character.
Right. Established character becomes Thor. Is she now a new character or is she just taken up the main floor? Right.
That's okay. So I think that Jason Aaron would argue that she's Thor. Okay. She didn't become female Thor.
The idea of like girl Thor or she Thor or you know that Thor is not the message he wants to present. It's not what he looks at it when he writes Thor. Right. He sees Thor.
That's Thor. Even though there's a physical being also named Thor that's over there. Yeah. And that for me is like you can't have that.
And I don't mean like you can't do it because obviously they have done a two-some claim. I just mean that you muddy the waters. And I don't mean like you need it to kill Odinson. Right.
But if there's two physical beings named Thor, someone came first. You know and it's not just because she picked up a hammer and she has powers. It doesn't mean that she's that guy over there. Right.
You know if you if he disappeared. You know what I mean? Yeah. I was a maid.
That was a maid. Now she's Thor. Right. But because she was just she is made in in place next to Thor, she will always be another Thor.
And by maybe for some people she is the definitive Thor. And that's fair. I'm not even arguing the merit or or or or negatives of James law enforcement being Thor. But I think that like it's just in the it's in the execution.
Yeah, it is in the execution. I know there's a hotpot issue within humans and the fact that it's so easy to just make characters now because of your Genesis. Yes. So for me that comes down to intent as well.
You know what in the 90s the same exact thing with mutants. Yes. And so that's why you so many mutants and that's intent. Yeah, but you know what's funny?
The writers who got the characters were like I have to create characters. First of all, what was me? I have to create. Damn it.
But at the same time it's also like but there's a quote of creation. Some things are. Mero is not going to be a long lasting character unless you carry over her as an example of things that you shouldn't create. Right.
Like I just did. Again, come on. In human. Good example.
Right. I have another good one in my opinion. I know people might not agree with me but kick-kai-joe. Right.
And I guarantee you if they made kick-kai-joe 15 years ago he wouldn't. Oh yeah, absolutely. Absolutely. It's easier.
He was born that way. But it's obviously because the story that they tell about him is something that is interesting. And intrinsically inhuman? No.
It's intrinsically monster. I see. By the way I think that's more inhuman than mutants because they're human's officers. They get cocooned.
Right. And then they met a more fun. I'm also supposed to say insects. Yeah, exactly.
But a giant insect becomes monster. All the insects are attacking a city. It's going to. Like if you grow mosquito to be the size of a car, it would attack people.
That's certainly a difficult hold up its own weight. That's fair. Yeah, it would be crushed under its own weight. Although if you're dealing pin particles at a different store.
Well, there you go. Okay, here's an idea. Hey, come in and become a giant man. Right.
Yeah. He keeps- When he's no longer Ant-Man. Is he then a new character or does he just have a new power? Mmm.
Yeah, that's a good question. Because with Hank Pym he has become Yellow Jacket Lost Giant Ant-Man. Like he has been many characters. Okay.
And Scott Lang was Ant-Man as well. Well then, okay, is it based on the mantle you take up or the name you take or the person who's- Yeah, like, well for me, the thing is I'm not a huge Ant-Man fan. So like I don't have a dog at that fight. You know, it's somebody who's the one for Ant-Man.
I'd be like, I don't know. I mean like Hank Pym's been- Here's the thing. Scott Lang has always been one character. Right.
He's always chosen to be Ant-Man. Right. Hank Pym has wanted to be like nine different people. So if it's a case of who wants it badly?
Right. Oh, give it this guy. Like if it's Batman, like who's Batman? For some people it's Dick Grayson because he did such a great job.
And because it was so well executed. A lot of people were like that's my favorite era of Batman was Dick Grayson's filter. For me, Batman is and always shall be Bruce Wayne. Okay, so with Ant-Man.
Yeah. You know, he's a character, he has interesting stories, he's certain- Which Ant-Man? Just in general. Ant-Man, the character.
Ant-Man, some Ant-Man, Zuh. Yes, Ant-Man. Ant-Man have been known to do despicable things. Right.
Some who cannot escape it. No, he was a yellow jacket during that time. Well, he didn't smurk the Ant-Man. That was great, awesome.
So, but it's seemingly less important who is behind the Mask of Ant-Man than did she's had Ant-Man. Whereas with Superman- Yes, it is important. It's the Callile of Clark Kent and Superman only to be on the same page. Right.
Because it has to do with his legacy. Yeah, but isn't there a legacy to Ant-Man? Well, I'm not saying that, I think it's different. It's interesting because Superman simply is who he is.
Clark Kent is almost the mask. Yeah, it's Superman. Like Ant-Man is just the name that I use when I talk to Ants. But like if I were to be big, then I can call Giant Man.
It would be weird to be called Ant-Man. But like Superman, whether he's asleep or he's going to the bathroom, he's always Superman. Right. And I'd say it's more important to recognize the character that you're reading because here's the thing.
If Peter Parker is going to sell a book where he is just the CEO of the company and has never seen it. He can do that? Interesting. Then do Superior Spider-Man because...
Well, he did. It was right. I know, it's not an example of what's weird about that. It's still the same character.
It's still the same guy. But yeah, differently. Yeah. It's a very interesting...
It was a great execution of that trope. Yes. And again, that comes down to the intent, which I think leads me to another good example of a good changing of the mantle in Robin. Yeah.
Yeah, Robin is an identity. It's not about who is Robin. No, but each person who takes up the mantle of Robin, it's something else to the table. I agree.
But the changing of the guard via Robin always makes, well for the most part makes sense. Yeah. And there's a little... Until it's Deviant.
Well, there's a legitimate reason behind it. Yeah, yeah. Dick grew up. Right.
Jason died. Yeah. You know, like... They forgot about him.
You know, like there's a lot of reasons why they move on. Yes, exactly. Now, here's where we get into some gray area that I don't know how far we want to delve in, especially since it's kind of wrapping up. I do want to make note of it, especially in the more recent Marvel news in general.
I'll character like Re-Rere Williams. Right. Re-Rere Williams debuted in an Iron Man book. They sold her before they even had a name for a character as Iron Man.
Re-Rere Williams was billed as a replacement Iron Man. Even though she never really technically was Iron Man. She didn't impersonate Iron Man. She didn't like take up the mantle of Iron Man, although she thinks that she's take up the mantle.
Like Dr. Doom is more an Iron Man than she is. She's a new character called Iron Heart. Yeah.
Even though Marvel's trying to build, even though she's headlining the Iron Man book. If they had a lot of faith in the Iron Heart character, then put a book called Iron Heart. Why is she in the Iron Man book? Will people buy that?
No! That's the issue. Right. And that's really at the end of the day, it's about sale.
Right. But I do think that Re-Rere Williams and Jane Foster show us two different intents. Yes. And they're the same idea.
Yep. And two different intents behind them. Yep. And I think one is more successful because there was a clear cut intent and the other one is less so because they were at 100%.
Yeah, they didn't go full. They didn't back it. No, it didn't. Which is weird because if you don't believe in it, you don't have a shortage of other things you could do or other characters you could use.
Yeah. But did they learn from the Thor problem where they're not calling her Iron Man because they still plan on bringing Iron Man back at some point? Yeah. Or with Thor, you have Odinson and you have a book called Unworthy Thor.
That's what's open to him. He'll say over, yeah. You assume at some point since that Thor still exists, he will then become Thor again. Right.
I think with Iron Man, they are hedging their bets because they have two Iron characters right now who aren't either of them or Tony Stark. Yes. And so I think when it comes down to it, they just didn't believe in one or the other. If you were to do a split decision right now, what would you prefer?
You know, it's funny. I've seen so many new characters created that are just utterly disposable and I've seen better executions in the replacement of the legacy character that I have in the execution of the big two engineering a new character. Right. So if, going to my head, I've got to say, I think I've seen a better executed legacy replacement than I've seen a new character.
Although I think that flies in the face of creativity and I think that I would rather it be the opposite. I'd rather love to see new characters fill up the area. I love to see the young Avengers become the new Avengers. You know, but they're not publishing other Avengers books.
But like that hasn't worked out to your favorite. It hasn't worked. It hasn't worked. And I don't know why, but I've seen, I think it's more successful, but I think at the end of the day, replacing legacy characters more successful.
But I'd rather see new characters created. I can get behind that. I think from a marketing standpoint, it's easier. It's way easier to just replace the other characters.
Yeah. I think right now with the landscape, the way it is that they're too afraid to try a new character. Which is weird because both of the big two are subsidized by large corporations. No, they are.
So there's absolutely no reason to be afraid of change and difference. Yeah. Although it's funny because Marvel made some significant changes and differences. Right.
And it resulted in deteriorating sales and a lot of heavy quizzes. Right. And again, I'm only thinking from Marvel and DC. Yeah.
In image, it's totally different. Totally different topic because I'm really excited and they're constantly bringing in new characters. Yeah. Invincibles creation and how successful he was.
Right. Exactly. And then killed or moved by. And if you don't do whatever, like the brand new, just there they are.
Yeah. Totally okay with it. But I think in terms of Marvel and DC, it's like you said, it's more successful. Yeah.
It may not be right, but it's more successful. What do you think? I'd rather see the creation of new characters, but in order to do that, especially with Marvel and DC, I want to see the characters not having books being read about them. I think it- I think- Stop making a Spider-Man book.
Like you're going to make a new Spider-Man character. Yeah. If you're going to make a Spider-Man character, stop selling the other Spider-Man book. Or if you're going to create entirely new character with their own different powers, maybe cut back on something other titles so that there isn't so much competition.
Just forcing the market to start buying these new characters. Right. But here's the thing. You don't.
That's really hypocritical because you hate that they're forcing you to read a new one. They're forcing you to read a new one. They're forcing humans into you. Yeah.
They are. Yeah. They're insisting on you. Yeah.
That's a conversation. That's another topic. So yeah. We'll see you guys next time with another topic of course, but thanks a lot for hanging out with us.
Let us know what you think in the comments down below. Keep the civil and above the bell to stick on all shows. We'll see you guys next week on another episode of I'm Sal. I'm Ben.
I'm not dipping in it. I'm watching. I'm Ben. I'm Ben.