Skip to content
Elseworlds Exchange: Should Tom King Finish Batman? episode artwork

May 24, 2019 52 min

Elseworlds Exchange: Should Tom King Finish Batman?

from Elseworlds Exchange Hosted by ComicPop

The ComicPOP crew discuss whether Tom King should be allowed to finish his 100 issue arc on the Batman title, despite rumors he will need to end it prematurely. See more at http://youtube.com/comicpop and help ComicPOP keep the lights on (and catch a super-secret Patreon-only podcast) at http://patreon.com/comicpop.

Episode details come from the podcast's RSS feed.

Embed this episode

Ready to play

Elseworlds Exchange: Should Tom King Finish Batman?

0:00 52:04
of matches

Transcript Auto-generated, may contain errors

This episode is brought to you by Patreon, specifically the Comic-Pop Patreon. Go to patreon.com.com.com and find out more about how you can keep the lights on here at Comic-Pop. And don't worry, we've got plenty of fun rewards, including early access to videos and weekly updates about what's happening here at the studio. That's patreon.com.com.

Alright, let's get on with the show now. Waiting down upon the underworld to smash gangland, come a friend of the unfortunate enemy of criminal. In this area, our powerful character, a problem to the police, but a crusade of hell are. Tom King is fired off a Batman.

That's what I would be saying if it was actually corroborated or confirmed by any significant source. However, it seems to be that there's a big hullabaloom going on in the comic industry about Tom King no longer being on Batman. In fact, most recently at the time of this recording, we've only heard news reports from outlets that I love so much that are saying and confirming that Tom King is not on the list. Tom King himself has been on Twitter and said something to the effect of, I love my fans, I really appreciate all the kind words you've said.

It's very non-committal reply, but also not denying anything either which he's quick to do if there is a case for that, which he's done on Twitter before. The most recent thing was from Ryan Higgins, who said he heard from DC directly that Tom King's Batman is ending towards the end of the year, short of his long-talked-out 100-issue run. He has more projects coming up for DC, which will be announced in the coming months. Tom King signed an exclusive deal with DC, removed from Marvel 2 DC, take over Batman, and also do a number of other projects.

One of which was the Mr. Miracle mini-series and the much maligned and discussed heroes in crisis mini-series event at a place. This is only a few of the things that Tom King should be doing with DC in the coming years, though the idea that he's been kicked off the book supposedly and reportedly may put a monkey in that which as well. Though I've seen, in fact, Mitch Jarrah's, who was working with Tom King on the Mr.

Miracle series, also recorded saying that there's lots of really, really fun stuff with Tom King coming in the future. In the wake of this. No one, including DC, nor Tom King himself, has said outright Tom King's run ends at issue 85. But, according to news outlets and also other creatives in the industry, publicly, that is the case.

So we're operating on that? Information alone. Yeah. And if that's not the point of the end of this episode, we're not going to talk about that.

Oh, is he fired or not? That's not the discussion. This question is, he has said that his story for Batman will be 100 issues. In fact, only a couple weeks ago from this recording, he has said that his run was going to be extended by another three to five issues.

So in fact, Tom King's run would include an extra couple of issues. He actually just finished a meeting with the higher ups and not the DC higher ups, a parent company higher ups. One of others, 18-teen, who were briefed on King's plan for a, quote, generational change for Batman. Batman would be changed for generations and that it would be a huge seismic shift in the character and the book.

And it was a very positive meeting. And then a few days later, we heard about this. So my guess, I mean, that's unsubstantiated, it doesn't matter what my guess is. No, because it's not real.

Like, it's not based on any fact. Because there's way too many factors here. Yeah, it could be that they pretended like it was a great meeting and then when he left, they said that's the whole boy. It could be that the meeting was not great and that they were all in agreement that it was a bad idea.

It could be that none of that had anything to do with it. Or it could be like, this is a trick of the words and it's not that he's off the book, he's changing Batman in such a way. That's not gonna be called Batman anymore. Actually, the whole thing is a marketing scheme and the Batman will end it at five and it'll be called something like Batman and Son or some other book.

I mean, like really? That's literally the actual thing that could happen. That's a fact that it practically happened because with issue 50, the marketing team was like Batman and Count were getting married. Here's an arc about it that leads up to it.

Here are a thousand very covers. Here's a midnight release and it didn't happen. Someone said that was a botch. Or were getting married.

But they are, they are getting married. They're in the process of getting married and then they don't. And then they don't. Hey, look, if they got that license.

Yeah, and they were. But like, that was a full-bait and switch. Someone said a marketing flop? Yeah, it didn't really work in their favor.

It was certainly a rug pulling. Yeah. I mean, it's not a flop. No, that's true.

It was a marketing triumpth. Yeah. The book felt like nuts. No, it wasn't very kind to those who were excited about that in particular.

It was a lie. It was a lie. It was a lie. And it looked at him lying.

It was a fear. If you couldn't return your comments, people would have. Yeah. But you can.

But that's what I'm saying though, is that like we're just going to kind of be generally talking about this because we don't have any information and we don't know the future. Well, and the question I want to pose to the group is, let's say for the sake of argument that King is no longer writing that mid-issue 85, it's not his choice. He's cut short. He's cut short.

He's cut short. Or he's cut short. Or he's being asked to wrap it up. Yeah.

Finish it 20 issues early. Yeah. Yeah. Is that cool?

And should he be allowed to finish? I've seen a lot of chatter where people are like, like it or hate it, let the man finish the story. Sure. Yeah.

Regardless of whether it's selling well or not. There's a lot of conflicting reports about how well it's selling. We do know that a Hulk book is outselling Batman right now. Yeah.

So maybe that is a factor. But it's something to consider when thinking about this change and this decision. Right. So regardless of whether it's cost, whether it's creative, should the man be allowed to finish a story?

Yeah. I would say no if you want to get someone an idea of being like, all right, look, you have to know what's going like coming down the pipeline like we need to end it early. We were going to do 20 issues early, but maybe we'll only do it 10 issues early, but you have to approve everything by us so we know what's going on. So we can release it.

Honestly, if the book is selling poorly, yeah, Canon puts me outside. And I would poorly is a relative term. Well, because it's the number one book at DC. Yeah.

And it outselled a lot of Marvel books. So yeah, but it used to be outselling like every book. Yes. And some would say and by the way, the book is twice monthly as opposed to when it was on Snyder's run, when it was doing it was monthly.

And so yes, Snyder's books didn't sell anywhere between 95,000 copies per month. Kings books are eight and 85,000 twice a month. Okay. So they are selling more Batman than ever, but they still to produce it twice when you break it down.

The cost doesn't work out. Yeah. It doesn't work out. Okay.

And arguably like your people are following that story. Even if more total books are being produced because you're doing it twice a month. Exactly. So I mean, that in and of itself, the fact that time is released, the number is the fact that you really don't know how books are sold.

Yeah. All right. Say it's just an issue of cost. What do you do?

Do you cancel other books to keep Tom King running? Do you change the team so that you're making you're putting less money into the books for the first time that you can finish it? If that's the case, no, you don't do that thing. You don't screw over other creators.

Just so this person can finish their run. It sounds to me. Overall, you're like, you shouldn't get to finish it, regardless of it. Whether it's like because the higher up say, you're losing money.

And also because if you get to finish it, maybe other people don't get a chance to write or create something like regardless, no, I would say, yeah, I would say, no. I think there's a good reason to let him continue. If so far everything is saying, like, there's a reason why the numbers aren't showing and there's a reason why we want to stop it early. Right.

If that's already where you're going, you don't say, well, let's just let it go. Right. I mean, I really want to end it and the right financial decision is to end it but like I really want to see what happens It's a what? There's nobody running the company.

Yeah, no. No, there's that running the column and there's no comic publishers They would ever do that and so far I haven't seen anything in King's run that says oh no You have to let him finish because this is gonna be great Well also because like every issue is essential to the main story because I'm here to tell you it isn't there's an entire arc That is just simply dream sequences. So like maybe maybe don't give the guy who's best suited for a 12-inch Action series a hundred and five issues. Yeah, yeah, and that's that's it for realizing I don't want to get into that too deeply But I do want to just pose the question and and and devil's advocate I understand the idea of letting creators like you give creators a run and you want to finish it Yeah, and I understand like that makes sense probably much of the time however We're not talking about like a 12-inch run.

We're talking about a hundred issues and arbitrarily so by the way Yeah, not like well, I'm gonna contract is for a hundred issues or or talking about super a hundred issues It's simply I want to have a hundred issues straight of my book and I will keep writing it for a hundred issues Right, like what if they let you yes like and yes I've been a man to stand for that to be a hundred issues But if I start writing a book and I say like I'm gonna write five hundred issues of this book and I'm on issue one You can't argue that like well, he should be allowed to finish those five hundred issues because he said he that's what he was gonna You know like yeah, there's there's a limit right and it's if it was commissioned as like a 12-issue run And he said issue like ten. Yeah, let's finish obviously we're only two issues for another 20 issues to finish That's a lot. Yeah, just let someone like play out something that you feel is not working right? That's I was gonna say like it's another 10 months right essentially.

We're looking at an apparently a year of publishing Yeah, but something that is they don't want to publish even if it's regardless across a book They don't want to make anymore. I'm gonna give you 10 months and 20 issues to continue to produce if Some of your issues have just been filler where they really don't add on to the story the question is like well Then really what are you giving us right right? He should be able to finish a story that he has been writing if that has been the planet It's not since he's not doing arc like every seven issues or so is an arc. No, it is Oh, yes, I thought it was one overall arc.

It is an overall arc with many arcs better sold in trade paper facts Right, right. No, I know I know but like he does have like he's like no like this is the end of my grand office Yeah, it's all part of the same story But they'll have some arcs that can be read out of right which I struggle with because like when you're in it's like not that a creative Line of work is really any different than any other line of work You know, I mean you don't fulfill the job you're supposed to do at work. You get fired You know what I mean? Like that sucks anybody getting fired sucks, right?

It's not a good position I want to be in but like that's what I'm saying like it's like it's bizarre because it's like yet in this instance There are a lot of people who are invested in this who do like it not insignificant number. No, no However, we are talking about DC's flagship book and like my Concern is that were they to allow him to do that is DC relies least DC comics relies a lot on Batman Yeah, right and so you're talking about not just Tom King and his family You're talking about DC and everyone who works for them and their families who need Batman to be as successful as possible along with all of their Comics, yes, and so like right but and so like I can see the thought process here if it is simply a financial thing If they're looking at these numbers saying like our projections are not looking as great as we're hoping and we don't want to be Responsible for having to let other people go. Yeah, and exactly so like that like yeah What a Batman is selling underperforming at such a rate I mean I mean like literal people who work in the background like editors or like you know Adventist since like other people like that who it's just like they have a job But now we can't afford to keep everybody everybody like certain people can't get a raise if they deserve it that kind of thing Like it's the kind of things you don't have to think about because it's like you're always faced with the fact that there's a writer and Artist yeah, but there's also an anchor and a colorist and an editor and a letter and you know I mean all these people work on just these books and there's a lot of people behind them and like And there's people who literally go and get paper for other people and you know what I mean like It's all the things that a company exactly and it's not like we're not talking about one smaller books Yeah, we're not talking about on people's work Yeah, and apparently the creators have been allowed to end it on their own volition right because it's like To end the book and it's been an underperformer monthly right for you But it is a smaller book and it's not really the backbone of like probably their financial planning I gotta say like this would be so unconventional But I'm trying to figure out a way where everybody gets what they want that DC can let this go and start with a new team But the fans of King can get the ending that they have been promised this entire time They've invested for 71 issues. So what if they let King his colorist his letter or his artist?

Yeah, everyone working on the book keep working on Batman, but it only comes out digitally That's not the printing costs I significantly diamond doesn't have to worry about selling it stores Grand you're gonna have a whole argument there about the local comic stores. What if you don't sell through commissality? Only sell through DC digitally. That's what we're not selling a Batman book that essentially no they'll still make Batman right No, it would just be they would just restart the number just like they did with like a reverb came okay But we're gonna hit the end of this run become like else worlds or do it or I don't know I don't know I think the idea is you just tell the new creators like where King's run you and right and I being said though Does he even know King said he's gonna change the character or I believe for a generation So like what if that's part of DC's decision to let him go and they're like no, he's not that's not gonna happen though Right, we saw where it's going and we don't like and then they don't let him finish that story if he wants to finish a different Yeah, then that's a great idea.

No one knows black labels anymore Yeah, the whole thing it's 105 issues and it's a black label book and actually that makes more sense They're really just digitally now and then trade later In fact reprint the entire rebirth run volume one all the way to whatever volume right now Yeah, I mean to issues and just read that could potentially be confusing I get and explain it very carefully and even if they are going to end up like asking to leave and end it earlier The next Batman arc is gonna have to pivot off of that and dig around So that's why I do they do but I say I do like I do the else world so though Where it's like if they do do that and like they're at Tom King you have to end here So the next creative team can keep going King could then release the like but what if yeah, I guess they want it Yeah, what what what then how about? Instead, yeah, this is what would have happened Yeah, and so fans could grab that as well like if they wanted to because look That we know why Tom King is being let go of theory Yeah, why is Tom King so special? How about every other creator that's been kicked off a book on ceremonies that didn't get to finish their story Why does King get his own whole book? Yeah finish his story?

I know there are many creators over the last several decades who have been unceremoniously kicked off books unfairly or unjustifiedly or We're still telling narratively appreciative good stories that didn't get a chance to counter your argument though Slop did get to finish. Yeah, he did get to finish a spider-man book even though He was at a point where everyone was like stop I guess the numbers were in his favor. Well, yeah, but I guess like for me like here's the thing I'm not gonna we're not like nobody here is reading King's back. No, I'm just devil's advocate Right, but what I was gonna say was like it's not my cup of tea It's not for me.

I know that but I'm not like gonna go in it is it is viscerally for a lot of people No, it is my man Right and like and so what I'm saying is that was like while I'm not a fan of this Batman I can relate to that feeling how many TV shows have been canceled that only a handful of us enjoy right and like you desperately Just want more of it and at times you do get it in this firefly. We got serenity in the case of far-scape We got an ending. Yeah, you know what I mean? Like just things that just went away.

Yeah, you know And it was like and justifiably much a terribly speaking right, you know It just didn't sell yeah It didn't sell right but like the fan base just wanted more and while not everyone was watching firefly or far-escape or castle even honestly I think it shows that were canceled deadwood. I was just getting a movie I was gonna say I wasn't watching that like those who were watching it meant a lot to that And so to get any kind of attention means something to that specific person and like I don't know I think like that means a large enough character that there's enough room to give him either an alternate ending book or whatever Because like look like it's funny and again This is going to go into the whole creative job Yeah, I've been in positions where I have like not gonna let go on a project necessarily for some of them back to me Just like this is not going anywhere we want it to and like first second You think you might be kicked off the job as a rabbit designer if I fail to design something that you want Yeah, even if you're wrong by the way that what you want like There's that's their prerogative to get rid of me because I'm not My job is to sell whatever exactly they're willing exactly if I were an illustrator And I was illustrating a book and I failed to capture the moments they were looking for I would be let go Yes, I would give given a chance, but then I would be probably let go right because you can't afford to do that Yeah, and Batman sells DC. Yes, however. I mean Batman is still selling.

It's not like it's not selling anything It's still there never one book. Yeah, so it's like but that's kind of the problem right? I guarantee is subsidizing so many other lesser books that don't make it right. It's literally like that means to oversell Yes, you're paying for yourself.

You're covering your own expenses guarantee you that yes, but that is carrying Yeah, we need Batman to reach Batman's potential because if Batman sales drop by 10% or 15% You're talking about like how are my hundreds of thousands of dollars? Yeah, you know nightwing sales drop by 10% You're talking about a fraction of that. Yeah, it's really matter That's why you can get on people's world go finish We're like we're not carrying the company yeah, your sales haven't dipped enough for it to like substantially alter and we just won't Pray as many right yeah, the other way to play devil's accurate about this what other book at DC is so important to hold on to that You do have to cut Kings Run short because it's not there simply isn't one because like Superman should be the other book right because Superman is the The face of superheroes literally the most recognizable superhero or at least you should be next to Batman and Spider-Man Those are the normal spider-man show you the number one seller DC Batman Superman show you and Superman's like four or five Consistently at DC the decision to change King must be financial Batman sells Regardless right if people are so unhappy with Kings Run that the sales have dipped to the point where they notice It means that people who are buying Batman because they absolutely buy Batman are not buying it But like it's actually dipping to a degree where they're like even the people who who blindly buy back books because it says Batman I'm trying to buy it and like that is an unfathomable concept because Batman should sell X amount of units regardless of who they should have a Monkey could be typing on a typewriter and it's long as it has Batman on title It will sell 75,000 copies like no matter of the quality of the book But what if Batman always has an additional 30,000 people who buy it and that's like what's happening right like you can't afford to lose those exactly Every person who is like a reliable Batman buyer remains a reliable Batman buyer It's not enough And I guess what they're possibly if that is the case that possible what they're seeing is that it's like okay Just because they're not buying that book and their rotation doesn't mean they've been spending that money at DC They're probably not buying anything at all right. Yeah, it's not like oh well.

I'm gonna look for another bat type care Where's moonlight like no, they're not doing this like they're saving their money Yeah, I'm just not gonna buy it go buy a marble book even if they do want to spend that money There's no telling they're gonna send it No, they need you know instead of spending as a loss right or if they're spending $4 a month fewer Maybe they're buying a video game or they're paying their cell phone Yeah, no, it's it's true now what does frustrate me about this is the fact that if it is due to financial It's not something that it turns out to be creative or turn that to be something that's positive You know what I mean? Where there's like no change in the name we're changing the name or talking to leave and work on some other larger like project It ends up being just that it's not his choice. It's like higher up So just like no, but I'm making money get out. This is the worst way to do this honestly It's amazing how often that happens because it's like the worst possible position.

Yeah, and I mean that because it's just like I again I just literally made their I know their business, but they're creative business, but they're still business, but you just said money is more important than our stories Yes, I get that I get that but what you're not saying that you're in furry man. Yeah, you know Do actions not speak louder than words I ask you People are buying the book doesn't that mean the story is not good enough right and it's like that's such a bullshit thing to say It's also the exact thing a publisher. What's yeah, no it is and it's like again here's a thing. I'm not reading Batman So I can't judge its story, but history comic history is filled with books that had a great story It didn't sound yeah because nobody cared and they were like wait Was so great.

Yeah, why did why were my yeah, exactly many current indie books? Yeah, I fall into that fall into that but not only that but like We nobody wants to see the company divided no and this one has kind of done that some degree I mean I'm kind of at this point where like I look not everything's gonna be my taste right and I'm okay with that You know what I mean like if someone's enjoying it cool, right? I mean it's like everybody hates it also like the fact is like he doesn't need me fired me to enjoy that man Yeah, like they're playing Batman stories for you to catch up on instead, but This I think will create potentially more division and whoever comes on it next will never get a fair shake Like they can earn on their take pass anyway, but they might be celebrated but people who hate well No, I mean in both ways you might have people who are comparing to Tom King and say like well I'm gonna give this a really hard time and I'm a little bit more critical eye because it's not the ending I wanted this isn't the book I was looking forward to this in Tom King's run Yeah, then you're gonna have the people who don't like Tom King or on this and like regardless of his flaws They're gonna be like well, it's not Tom King. That's right.

Yeah, that writer will never actually get to write to Batman Yeah, and like without him Yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah, you know what you do you just stick some sacrificial lamb on it for like 15 issues And then you transition to the new No, I had a different version of this my my pitch was you don't have that you have like a stopgap where you get like an Uncriticizable on Neil Gaiman an Alan Moore and Grant Morrison to come in and write a like mini Yeah, it's like maybe it's not continuity or it is or whatever Okay, right outside of that that realm right give everybody a chance to just calm down on both sides Yeah, let everybody yell at it or not and then start a new yeah Yeah, I mean it's a good idea financially just because you get a big character I'm gonna bet that roundswell of boost to sales. Yeah, you got that too. So you hopefully you dig into your pile of like story ideas Mm-hmm. What do we got kicking around?

Yeah? Yeah, I think no is just like you dig into your roll of X of 12 Yeah, yeah, you got that bitch. Yeah, you got one you got a big one. Yeah big one.

Yeah, like yeah, yeah Yeah, small one. I'll make your name the big one. Yeah, like it's just like Benign yeah, yeah doesn't change isn't blow the doors off It's just a Batman story straight up there it is and then the next team starts over and they have a fighting chance Right. That's just fresh.

I mean that's definitely the way they should do it Which is why it's almost certain thing won't because it's the because it's not the absolute worst idea to possibly do and that's like What seems to be the decision-making capabilities of publishing is like what's the worst way to eat the shit sandwich? I mean you might have people that also just don't look at it like oh well I'm just not a fan of Tom King, but I want to read Batman I mean, I'm sure there are people that are like it's not my cup of tea But I still like the characters don't like buying the book and they might just look onto it and be like oh Well, so I'm also coming on okay. Well, it's not gonna stop me from buying Yeah, we absolutely will have those people it's just not an ideal situation, you know what I mean? It's not a situation of a creator would want to necessarily be yeah the creator coming on the creator leaving You know, yeah, and like by the way, it's making the worst possible ways to handle this like man I bet DC really wishes they had control of an narrative.

Oh my god Yeah, because it is what happens well There's just always rumors all the sudden and like regardless of what ends up actually coming out as the truth or what do we'll always be colored by Their own I saw an article that was like this is what Tom King tweeted 22 minutes ago and then and the tweet was deleted So there was no evidence of what was said and I'm like this is not an article This is just you're feeding into the machine the machine by the way of houses Not like you know, this isn't a vanity fair article. No cruise. We're talking about yeah We're talking about like a tonne king. Yeah, right in the comic book.

Yeah, and we're treating it like it's entertainment tonight Exactly. Well, it's like and then you get down to the fact that like some news outlets are so hungry for any click Of any kind that they'll do this they'll stir the pot. Yeah You know and it's like, you know, again, we don't know what's actually happening right now. Yeah, yeah Not to know yeah, I would prefer if DC really made this decision if they told nobody right then a few months from now announced You know, yeah, the cum kings like last issue.

Yeah, we'll be wrapping up his story When he was early, but that's what he wanted to do. Yeah Now that's fine Exactly, like it's so do you listen like it's a perfect or the truth I do agree that is shitty no but like If we're talking about companies and what the prerogatives are and how they should be handling it if like tonking should be allowed to finish his story It's like well, you should have lied. Yeah, well, you should have controlled If you have to fire him you have to fire him and you also have to control how that information was disseminated to the public Yes, and it's like if you drop the ball there and maybe you should be firing it Like then your decision to do that in the first place is faulty Yeah, your inability to control a story that is for a cast of thousands as opposed to millions or hundreds if anyone actually care They're talking about percent of percent of the careers that maybe you would talk about and it's like oh Comfort green Batman. No, that's like 100-20 people.

Oh, but then those people who read the Internet for news about the behind the curtain like oh, that's like 20,000 people So it's like oh to entertain 20,000 people. Yeah, and then these are all big. They don't make me up Yeah, they're just saying like they're taking a fraction of a fraction of a fraction you like destroyed well I would say DC isn't trying to entertain those people. No, no fail to prevent those I feel like the news outlets right there was that you can't but they were right there Yeah, yeah, yeah, we'll die though.

Yeah, we'll die without that. Oh, yeah I'm not blaming them not Blaming them for not jumping on the story Like Right and like honestly, I will give them props. They haven't had any sort of major reaction Right, I think you usually do and when like let's say Batman's penis is exposing comic book that they published They created a line to be able to publish and then they And see that's what is interesting now now that all these rumors might be one of those two well Yeah, but it's like all these not all these rumors are Million never gonna truth and it's like whatever DC ends up doing let's say they don't they just let him finish it All right, people be like is that a reaction right? Yeah, you want to keep the pressure the fact that they haven't said anything makes it seem like they're trying to figure out Oh, they're like ha ha ha we got I bet we're speaking bad hands.

Oh, yeah, I think it's bad publicity. Yeah, well why do people hate this book so much? Let me go find out. I'm really trying to continue DC cancels highest ranking comic book like yeah, it's true.

I mean like the fact is it could be I mean That's possibly not key of alien and a lot of new coke It gives them a lot of credit. Oh, yeah, I know I know I believe the new coach was great Yeah, but like it's a brilliant piece of fiction to imagine that it was actually a pleasure near to fail So the coke would come back it's a nice spin. Yeah, it's all about the spin. Yeah, so far we haven't had a spin from DC No, we don't have anything yet.

Which tells me that it wasn't accidental release Yes, they would have been deliberate. They would have had the message already presumably. Yeah, oh and a DC hit release Yeah, yeah, well that's what I thought it could be a marketing ploy No, I saw a tweet from a writer from a rival publisher make a more declarative statement about it Then I did DC in any capacity and Kings like thanks for being a fan right now Isn't it a mission of any no and that could also be depending on what's in his contract team You're not actually be able to say I'm sure he's not like anything You know what I mean? And so like him not saying anything right now he's Tom King He should be able to like wave his dick around he shouldn't have to do anything like he's no employee right But like he wants to get work at other companies Care maybe he's just being kicked off Batman But he's definitely yeah, you can't Yeah, you don't and like so like legally speaking to like yeah, well he's a smart person.

He will he will let them Let them just run. Yeah, it just it does just stuff that if this is the course of this then like it didn't come from DC or Tom King directly Like they should be able to tell their own story. Yeah, huh? Social Tom I think that there's room.

It's not I don't even I don't believe he has any more of a right to finish his story than anybody else Because so many other creatives have had their stories wrenched from them unjustifiably, right? But it's Batman. There's room Yeah, there's literally a Snyder couple of book that's coming out That will sell like gangbusters they get to do their book Can you lose his book? Yeah, I'm also doing his book.

Yeah, there's enough back books and have money for that title for him to be able to finish it Yeah, there's there's money to be made. Yeah, I have a feeling that it might really be just they didn't like the direction Yeah, that it was gonna go and oh no, we can't do that and so if you can't do that that's like well Then there's no point and he might have even decided well, they're not gonna let me do that Yeah, this is so I wanted to tell him if I can't tell it's gonna be like baby I'm good. I can wrap it up at the end of the year then yeah following the same logic train about The money and about how there's room for King to finish a story that sounds to me like DC didn't make this decision because Batman damned number one sold like nuts. Yeah, and all they had to do was print more and it would have been the number one book for like a month Or two yeah, and they didn't that's like the first time I've ever heard of them ever doing that and it wasn't because DC said We don't want to make money that was for my Warner Brothers decision For me, this is the exact same thing if you are throwing money away by not manipulating Tom King fans and buying two Batman books So then that's a Warner Brothers 18 decision, and they're just like I don't know how the company works Oh, I know is I don't want his status quo to interfere with the plot of the Batman Yeah, well, I I may know how the company does she works, but I don't care right because I care about is my bottom Everything else is related to that man.

It's not a comic. Yeah, it's bad into the brushes right so like if whatever he's gonna do Which I know it is might rock the boat. Yeah, then it's gone It's exactly and I will make that decision in like a second. Yeah, and I won't think about it again Yeah, I want already something right about it I'm thinking about lunch and DC publishing like everyone at that level who is so important and so high up are powerless Yeah, and they're just like they're just beholden.

They're like look at all the money just sitting on the table. Yeah, that's yeah That's comic book. Yeah, exactly. We're both changed.

No, yeah, that's not it's funny. You think that's a lot of money Have you ever seen Harry Potter money? I'm just I'm just wondering like you ever seen Harry Potter money? No, like gold coins?

No, I got my own Yeah, I'm swimming in a bat or a bolt like Scrooge brick and man Nolan trilogy coin I'm still and you're telling me that oh, you're worried about the bathtub of money that you're losing here Yeah, we're on two different planets man Exactly and that's probably why like there's so much misinformation and why there's so much like you're saying this guy's because like people We're talking about two different industries that are in bed together It probably shouldn't be and it's a possibility that DC cannot come out against one of other people. I can't They can't there's no way that you can't listen everybody. I want I'm gonna finish it you but dad says I can't I'm sorry That's the breaks of being owned by a parent company You should see what they want like marbles and wait like that I'm sure they'll be satisfying for a minute to tweet But it would be their jobs. Yeah, and so this is probably like Signically speaking this is probably the best decision they can make Okay, well again That's only saying if it is a negative thing right and not someone's misinterpretation of knowledge because I was just thinking about his Conversation with Batman or with Warner Brothers about the future and how positive it was yeah, what if that conversation was okay King you can't do that.

How many said you come consult on the Batman? We're gonna have to wrap this up at the end of the year because we're gonna need you yeah Yeah, I have to finish I'm not gonna get my 105 issues, but I will be getting a lot more money because I'm gonna be an executive producer You know what I mean and like and so what the news outlet here is is getting kicked off the book Yeah, they don't hear the because of XYZ that might be happening. Yeah, it is getting kicked off the book though What the DC comic book reads can't finish up his original story, but he's like I got a new story Yeah, I got another one of the Actually, I I I'll finish up this other version of the Batman story I mean like the reality is like that could be it any of it could be it but but objectively speaking yes I was gonna say what would suck is if if that was the case if Tom King was like okay, yeah, bye I don't care about these people I don't care about Batman or the character I mean I care about Batman as a movie character I had an idea for a story, but if you're gonna pay me like 20 times You know all the whole speculation all fake should he be allowed to finish it Just a bit of you should be allowed to finish it if he wants to finish it and he's being kicked off against his will Should he be allowed should these make allowances to give him his 20 issues? No It's gotta be a company decision if the company decision is to kick him off the artist can't be the artist the creator cannot say you have to let me finish I'm sorry.

They can't can the fish should the fans be demanding that that was that a reasonable thing to demand the fans are allowed to demand that But the fans the fans can say like I'm not gonna buy the next issue that comes out Nick and friend that I don't say I would you be like your right fans? Like that's bull crap what do you see there? Like how do you feel about it? I understand you're saying like it's a company is like saying no and like they can do whatever they want So like no, but like what do you like okay?

So you should I get to a point where the fans say and now I want Batman to like just start killing all of his villains and the fans call for it Enough should he do that no yeah? So you care about like the character because I care about the character how do you feel about this particular issue with the character and his My right is right I'm not being able to finish right. That's just it I have no investment in the character in what Tom King is doing right right? Right, so you're just I don't think I don't think it's a good idea I think if the business is gonna do it the business has to say no you're kicked off right and I don't think the Fans should petition hard enough where DC backs off.

I think that would be a bad decision company. Yeah, yeah I tend to agree. I do the like the idea of giving it another path Shoot, so like no you can't finish you can't write Batman 85 through 105 Yeah, but you can write like the adventures of dark batman. Yeah, whatever you want to call it Yeah, that man nightmares issues 85 through 105 It's gonna be over there.

Yeah, but like we're saying Batman is going over and it sells as well as the primary book you can write that Batman to the cows Yeah, I think that If it were in issue 50 absolutely not that many is 20 issues left I think the book sells well enough. Why not? It's a little more than 28. Yeah, no 28 That's that sucks that's half of what that's a little more than half of what I said was inexcusable Yeah, but I think the book sells well enough and I think that I'm not enjoying it Yeah, but it's gonna end soon like the light at the end of the tunnel I just let it in.

Yeah, it's not a change in Batman forever. Wait, I know it won't Like because there is no such thing as I read like it just done See it literally undo it tomorrow. Sorry and then just on Kings making change in here as a crisis. I guarantee you they could they have a story Yeah, ready to make the whole book just in case the last issue sold worse than the first issue I I have no belief in permanency in comics So like for me as a seasoned some I'd say grizzled comic book reader.

I would say like I why not? Right, so don't ask for more but like you get the finisher arc So that at the very least I can judge it based on what it was able to accomplish So like when fans tell me that the tongue kings run was the best run of all time. I can declare it at least say no Yeah, I can't say well, you wasn't able to finish it though. Exactly now There's like now it's I can't ever criticize time Kings run because it was is wrenched from him And then at the very least you can have your book and say this is the book that I asked for and if I didn't like it I don't like it as a pure product right right I mean likely the thing that didn't have any blemishes and it was it was King's book to succeed with or ruin Right as opposed to like DC being like I think I know better.

Yeah, you you buy a large dog What do you think I think I don't ever want to be in the position of making a call like a man to cancel someone's creative work Like right before the finish line right before the finish line and also like having to look at like, you know Financials and be like I don't know I can't see it in the future But it looks like it's not doing well. Yeah, exactly the fact is the whole system's broken And there's no real way to look at like pure numbers. So you know I'm really basing this look at the viewer We can't see right, but I mean even still you can't look at what's gonna happen You can't look to see the next arc how things are gonna go what if it's general change for Batman actually was gonna get in like new Reader like that literally wouldn't like you couldn't pay me enough money to want to make that choice. No, you probably could But you know like I again like I'm so like I'm both sides of this because I'm just like financially speaking I don't want it to see DC like suffer.

Yes, you know as a company I don't like the upper echelon. I mean like the everyday working folk. Yes, but also I don't want to see like people who like like less or selling books Yes, yes, but that's also not fair But on the other side, I don't want people who are invested in so invested in this story It's not getting an ending you know what I mean? Like you put a lot of time those who have read it for this long Yeah, you find like and I mean that like I'm not saying that's a long time to be reading the book Yeah, and with the knowledge at least two arcs in that it will end at this point Yeah, I guess that's about three years if it came out twice a week later Yeah, but you're still getting 14 more issues right to wrap it up I mean like the fact is if one arc wasn't a dream sequence Maybe that's the whole thing.

It's like I'm 2020 if you know maybe you want to put that in But also like if he's best suited for maxi series in miniseries Which he knows how to construct and maybe he does have like a master plan and like that dream sequence arc is like so Essential when you get to be under your nose That's cool. That's great. What a payoff that would be for those who are fans who are reading it exactly and but there are many right Sometimes you don't get to finish right sometimes life's not fair If you're playing in a hundred and five, it's a little bit. I know you gotta expect Maybe I'm not gonna be able to but now can you imagine though like think about this for one second You're a smaller creator working on books at DC or Marvel, right?

And you're watching this go down right now, right? Someone who's writing Batman who does is selling well, maybe not as well as they want and they They got fired right like this is high as their winning creator Yeah, the top talent in the industry right now who's writing the flagship number one selling anyone could write this book and sell it Title yeah for the most recognizable super hero on a planet. Yeah fired. Yeah, how many four issues or whatever before the end?

Yeah, how terrified are you? Oh, like trying to do And like how much can that possibly in the future cycle the creativity of those who just want to keep their jobs? Yeah, I hear you but like that's how it always is isn't it? I mean enterprise didn't expect to get canceled after four seasons right a cutthroat industry Like if you haven't figured that out that like anybody can get like cut off in the middle of their story Then like you're gonna learn that lesson eventually right so like yes It sucks but unless the whole industry is like about to change I never do that I'm gonna say like you might as well learn that I guess I'm just concerned with the optics of this very specific situation and the potential Pappeth this will now take it that if this is what ends up happening, you know what I mean?

I will say that it positively speaking DC will definitely not let this happen again Right which is like I guess that also means like maybe that was gonna get a hundred issues right Well, I'm not sure think that like maybe more what we're gonna say okay And it's orally they'll be more stringent and more like overbearing under creators Whoa, what direction is that? That's like that could be good and that could be bad but I don't like that But my also my other concern would be like if they're like we never like we won't take a risk like this again How often then will Batman or other books be changing writers and teams for the good or for the bad Yeah, like you know what I mean like well How fresh will the character feel after 20 years if like we're not allowed to make changes and There's no way of knowing that being said like if you have a bold new idea for Batman There's about like four different labels you could use to tell that story and if it's sold out sold The main Batman book then I guess that's the new status quo And I mean like that's gonna be how it goes. Yeah, or at the very least you're gonna be the new hot The new hotness that's brought on to the title to write that story Yeah, I mean like I always maintain everyone when amazing spider-man was so disappointing and they were doing the renew your bow story It was set in different universe. I'm like listen buyers if renew your vows out sells amazing spider-man That's gonna be the status quo.

Yeah, because they're gonna say oh they're jumping ship to this book. They want that it didn't Right, but it's all pretty well and it did send some of a message where it's like, yeah, there are people want that They're still number. Yeah, you know and they're definitely buying the amazing book. They're buying that one I mean there's a message right now being said that people are still reading the tongue King run Right.

Oh, yeah, no, it's that I mean like it's selling and there's such a little reaction to this change that like they're enjoying it Well, this rumor. Yeah, yeah But we're talking about people making a rocket on the internet. That's not the same as people buying the book Yes, the hell see that like every will know one three times that is a negative that represents five billion people Exactly and then we got a joke But like no, it's it's true because that is how a lot of publishers in the last like decade have been influencing policies They're like the Twitter verse blew up about this and it's like yeah, but like people still bought the book Yeah People can manipulate social media and do yeah for less but no one's just gonna buy thousands of copies of your books just to improve the numbers Yeah, I mean like they tried I know everyone's ready didn't do well and they came out of dvd and they were like okay fire Okay, brown coast every five copies with dvd and I'm like no A little creamy. Oh, I'm not gonna do that.

Oh, I don't want yeah I'll just buy the one. Do you think you should get us ending or not? Yeah, should it be an offshoot? What do you guys think?

Get a terrible team. Yeah, everybody can come together. Oh, yeah The producers it up. Yeah So well have it happened to be the longest running team.

Well, no, they'll do terribly So everyone will still think of tongue care really when the next team comes on. They'll be like my god. They're here. Yeah.

Yeah Yeah But it sells everything Is the shit show every month like I can't believe it's all start bad. They were out of the wonder all the time Yeah, just paint Batman green with yellow stripes But I can't possibly like this. Oh, what a saddle on it Yes, anyway, we'll see you guys next time another episode of comic line one other crazy thing happens for the comics that we can talk about for a while I'm so I'm not doing watching you're talking about he man there. Yeah, yeah I always do it that we even do the thing we're all like we talk about it afterwards You

Frequently asked questions

How long is this episode of Elseworlds Exchange?

This episode is 52 minutes long.

When was this Elseworlds Exchange episode published?

This episode was published on May 24, 2019.

Is there a transcript available for this episode?

Yes, a full transcript is available for this episode. You can read the complete transcript on the episode page.

Can I download this Elseworlds Exchange episode?

Yes. Use the download control on the episode player to save the publisher-provided media file.