Skip to content
Elseworlds Exchange: The Sony/Disney Spider-Man Problem episode artwork

Aug 22, 2019 1 hr 9 min

Elseworlds Exchange: The Sony/Disney Spider-Man Problem

from Elseworlds Exchange Hosted by ComicPop

Sal and Joel discuss all the facts about Spider-Man leaving the MCU. See more at http://youtube.com/comicpop and help ComicPOP keep the lights on (and catch a super-secret Patreon-only podcast) at http://patreon.com/comicpop.

Episode details come from the podcast's RSS feed.

Embed this episode

Ready to play

Elseworlds Exchange: The Sony/Disney Spider-Man Problem

0:00 1:09:00
of matches

Transcript Auto-generated, may contain errors

This episode is brought to you by Patreon, specifically the Comic-Pop Patreon. Go to patreon.com.com.com.com and find out more about how you can keep the lights on here at Comic-Pop. And don't worry, we've got plenty of fun rewards, including early access to videos and weekly updates about what's happening here at the studio. That's patreon.com.com.

Alright, let's get on with the show. Weeding down upon the underworld to smash gangland, come a friend of the unfortunate enemy of criminal. In a serious, powerful character, a problem to the police, but a crusade of a law. Hey everybody, welcome to the L-Sport Exchange, I'm Sal.

And I'm Joel. Forgive my outward appearance, some might say that based on the news we received over the last 24 hours, I'm just sweating and I'm just completely frothing at the mouth. The reality is, it's like 85 degrees outside, there's like, I don't know, 80% humidity. And my mom decided that today was a good day to take the front door off her house.

And I was like, what are you doing, mom? So I had to go over there, I had to help her put the door back on. Then my dad showed up, whole family house arrived, I'm not going to drag you guys into it, if I will. At least at the top of the show, I'm not a 50% sweaty mess because of the Spider-Man thing.

But the rest of it is actually the key to making your air conditioner. That's why. So if you're just tuning in to the show because you can't get enough self-flagellation over the sports-vide-em situation, we'll be able to exchange the comic book and comic book adjacent to the topic show that we have here. We chat about those things are better now, we're going to talk about this Spider-Man Sony Disney thing.

And we're going to try and be as diplomatic and as objective as possible before we then devolve into our own personal opinions. Because someone has to go online. Getting more direct into it because we want to sift out all the crap because you're hearing quotes, you're hearing figures, you're hearing numbers. And I want to be able to attribute those quotes, those figures, those numbers to people, to corporations, to specific accountable sources.

As opposed to being like, somebody said, in intern got a sandwich, he heard that it's over. The venom is going to go to the MCU. We don't need any of that. So let's just try and focus on the facts.

As my old college press used to say, we're going to Joe Friday this bitch. Just the facts. So before we do that, I want to welcome you to the show. This show is supported by viewers like you.

Of course, the ads help. But we also have a thing called Super Chats where if you do want to have a question, a comment or something else, you want to mention in the show and you want to have it read organically into the show, you super chats to do so. And we will address hopefully every single one of you. So like this fine person as well, who says first, great contribution, but also your first, technically correct, which is the best kind of correct.

No one can take it away from you. You are first on this episode. So let's jump into it. I'm sourcing a couple of my like collective data from CNBC.

Take that as you will, the article is below this video. You can check my sources and grab those right now. That was posted this morning, like between eight and 12 this morning, Eastern Standard Time. But basically, according to CNBC, let's talk about the original deal, the deal that set this whole thing up, right?

Yes. Basically, Sony and Disney had a send receive agreement, a contract with each other in which Sony would allow Marvel's creative team to integrate Spider-Man into its cinematic universe. And Sony would put up 100%, I'm sorry, and Disney would put up 100% of the production cost. Yes, which a lot of people don't seem to understand that part.

Right. So Sony allows Disney to use Spider-Man's character and pay 100% of the movie in exchange. Disney will receive 5% of, and this is something I haven't heard a lot of, the quote, first dollar gross, which is to mean 5% of the ticket sales on the first day of release. Yes.

Not opening weekend, first day. By the way, I'm only sifting out and addressing the facts and the information I'm not getting into like how I feel about it right now. I don't want to hear that I'm being a shale because I'm quoting actual facts. Here's the deal.

5% of the first day ticket sales and Disney as a result retained the merchandising rights of the character. Which they always had and never lost when they sold the rights of Spider-Man originally. I had always heard and I didn't have anything to back it up. I always heard that they had Sony had a percentage and they traded in 100% merchandising for total gross.

Again, I don't have that link, so I'm not going to address it. Right. But to put it into figurative terms, Spider-Man Homecoming had a domestic $117 million opening weekend, roughly about $39 million the first day, which means based on first ticket for a 5% gross Disney made, approximately $2 million. Off of Spider-Man Homecoming.

Which ate much when you compare it to the other movies. It was also like the biggest opening Sony had, like was it ever or just in years? Ever. For a home, I had $105 million opening weekend, which accounts to about because it was a three day opening weekend, accounts about $61 million for the first day, which if you translate that into Disney Box is about Disney made off of Sony's highest grossing film of all time, $3.25 or $3.25 million.

A fraction of the budget that movie cost, yeah. That being said, this means the initial deal that Disney made roughly $5.25 million on two movies that they went 100% financed. That said, they also won 100% of the merchandising rights of the character, which according to Hollywood Reporter in 2014, earns approximately $1.3 billion with a B dollars a year. As Krusty the Clown said, merchandise, that's the sweetest plum.

That's the sweetest plum. Disney earned $1.3 billion off of Spider-Man alone six years ago. Yeah. Now, could that have gone up?

Probably. Most corporations think about only satisfying their investors' bottom dollar and always trying to increase or duplicate or triplicate their profits, which of course is unsustainable, and it's why corporations are completely insane. But let's get into that another time. So, basically, Sony is basically getting the billion dollar gross from the movie and Disney earns probably around the same, if not a little more proportionately, through merchandising.

Because, you know, t-shirts and toys and what have you will always cost more than a movie ticket. Exactly. I've heard people banding around like they get the comic money. They don't even think about it.

No, that's a teardrop in the ocean. We're really talking about here's backpacks, action figures, dolls, sleepwear, costumes, like children's outfits, that kind of merchandising. Which, by the way, Disney was already kind of using and making already. So, it wasn't like Sony gave up the ability for Disney to make money off of Spider-Man.

It was more that, like, proportionately speaking, Disney makes about a billion and a half dollars a year off of Spider-Man merchandising rights. And Sony was happy to now suddenly start making about a billion dollars for Spider-Man movie. Free. Yes.

Without having to really do anything but just sign the paperwork and let them use their shiny toy, which they, you know, we'll talk about opinion stuff later. Exactly. I don't want to get into that just yet. I just want to talk about what happened, what is reality, where we are.

Right. But yeah, that's it stands right now. Exactly. So, according to Deadline yesterday, Deadline was the article that I saw that broke the story.

Disney proposed a 50-50 co-financing deal. Right. Disney's Disney and Sony would pay half the production cost of the movie and then split the profits. Part of the problem with speculating on this kind of thing is because we haven't heard anything from either source.

We just heard insiders and sources that say that was the proposed deal. Yeah, I forget if it was the same article too that said Sony's counter-offer, the only counter-offer that I've heard of in this whole web, no pun intended, was Sony saying it's like, well, what if we just keep the deal as it is right now? Us keeping 95% and doing 5% and doing whatever moving forward into the future. Exactly.

It could be that Disney may have offered something else, but my guess is they probably did not. No, which, again, that's business, that's hard, you always want to start with your biggest one. We're just Tom Holland following all of this. He's still under contract for at least two more, yes?

With Tom Holland, we haven't had any direct word from Holland, but we do have only two things. One, Holland is under contract for two movies, which by the way means absolutely dick. Andrew Garth was under contract for one other Spider-Man movie he pissed off the head of Sony, some would say deliberately, and not by the way, not Sony Pictures, Sony the corporation. Yes.

And so he was unceremoniously terminated from the project and a reboot was hastily rushed into Marvel's receptive hands. But Ben Affleck was under contract too and we saw what happened there. Exactly, but Tom Holland is technically under contract for two more Spider-Man movies. Today, within a couple of hours, Tom Holland reportedly unfollowed Sony on Instagram.

Ooh. That's that, and by the way, we're just Joe Friday-ing this, it does the facts. In the modern digital age, that's ending a strong message, especially for a young person like Audrey. That is a 19-year-old's message.

I don't know how old he is probably this point. But, you know, here is the official word we've heard from one of the two companies. The official word, quote, much of today's news about Spider-Man has been mischaracterized and has written this characterized recent discussions about Kevin Feige's involvement in the franchise. We are disappointed, but respect Disney's decision not to have him continue as a lead producer on our next live action Spider-Man film.

We hope this might change in the future, but understand that the many new responsibilities that Disney has given him, including all their newly added Marvel properties, do not allow him for him to work on IP. They do not own Kevin as terrific, and we are grateful for his help and guidance and appreciate the path he has helped us. He also helps put us on which we will continue. A lot of double-speak there.

Sony also put this up on Twitter at one in the morning, Eastern Standard Time. I don't know what that is in LA time, but that seems very weird to come up with a statement at that time. It feels like a reaction that if you were to interpret it, as some might have already, it reads passive-aggressive, and it does foist a lot of, like, I don't know, shade on Feige. While, like I said, double-speak, they said, you know, good for him, he's terrific and we're grateful for his help.

They also say that he has many new responsibilities and he may not be up to the task of working on this character based on how much work he has. Even though he's overseen like three phases worth of Marvel projects in all of their forms, but no, he's not up for this, though. Right, now that being said, that's conjecture, it's simply this is the context, but it is, and here's the thing. So these are all the things we know, these are the facts, the facts that we know.

Sony has a statement that says, Kevin Feige is not producing an X-Men movie, there is going to be another Spider movie coming up soon. Due to Kevin Feige's lack of involvement, we can infer a lot of things, but right now, all we know, no, officially informally, for many of these companies is Feige is not going to be producing the next Spider movie. That being said, probably means Spider-Man's not the MC anymore. Because why would you get rid of Feige?

Right, especially because, and these are, this is back to conjecture, we have heard a number of reports over the last couple of, about 12 hours, that say that Feige apparently had been ghost producing a couple of other Spider-Man movies and Spider-Man adjacent projects at Sony? Interesting. These new Lord and Miller projects, probably. Yes, that maybe Spider-Verse had some involvement with Feige, and that apparently maybe Feige was upset that he didn't get producer credit on some of these movies.

Ooh, so again, the perfect Hollywood storm of bruised egos, and power players, and greed, and everything else. Right, now again, not trying to paint any company in a bad light, we will be doing that shortly, but before we do that, I want to say, Sony just made the first move publicly, and Tom Holland made a move publicly as well, regardless of how silly or contrived your childhood might have been. And so, and so, and a lot of reputable news sources are according the same source that are saying that Disney suggested a 50-50 split and 50-50 take. Right.

Again, no substantiated source, no person has said that, just sources and insiders and whatnot. That's all we know. Yeah, that's all we know right now. It's still a very fresh news story.

Now, there was another little thing here, and again, this may very well have also been conjecture, this could have just happened and been unrelated. There was talk to that, apparently during all of this, during like a whole 12-hour Twitter storm and everything, Sony's stock actually took a pretty major hit. I think it's back up now, but I think there was a moment there where it actually took a bit of a tumble. Now, I don't understand anything about the stock market.

Yes. I've seen, I saw that number. I wouldn't have sold my Sony stock based on that number. It wasn't a plummet as much as it was a dip.

It was an immediate dip, and it was an immediate reaction, and it's the market does that anytime anything happens. If the government decided, the US government, since this where I am, decided to invade a country, the stock market would take a hit if the government decided to start a trade war, it's talking about change and fluctuate. Like any time any major mover and shaker within the industry makes a big change, the market reacts and usually unfairly. Naturally.

So with that respect, I believe Sony took a dip of like 0.5% or something. It was very negligible, and like I said, I think it recouped its loss right away. It is. It's back up this morning.

I checked it before we started. Yeah. I did a thing. Oh, yeah.

Oh, yeah, exactly. But it's a reaction because they did it like an hour and a half before the closing bell. So, you know, there was a reaction. I'm glad there was a reaction because that's the most influence that studios can react to.

Because here's the thing, regardless of how much everyone enjoyed or didn't enjoy, Spider-Man in the MCU, the companies don't care as long as it makes the money. Absolutely. I made a comment yesterday in which I had heard, and again, unsubstantiated and never heard an official source by I remember hearing a rumor and it was circling everywhere and every popular YouTube channel and blogger jumped on it that if our home doesn't make a billion dollar Spider-Man is out of the MCU. Right.

Right. Remember, I remember hearing about that. I remember hearing that also. Oddly enough now that it has made a billion dollars, he is also out of the MCU.

Feels like maybe he was always going to leave the MCU. Feels like maybe that was already the plan. Maybe the reason why Spider-Man wasn't mentioned during the Comic Con announcement was because I knew this was going to happen. That being said, okay, so let's look at this from a perspective of money and companies.

Right. It's one would be quick to judge Sony based on its previous history, based on its speed, based on its desperation to create a franchise, based on its desire to make a more BS movie starring Jerry Leno. It's short-sightedness and creative bank rough-edness. I know a lot of people were circulating the clip today of Andrew Garfield talking about the bad time he had on the Spider-Man movie.

Absolutely. It's a rough notwithstanding, Avi Arad. And his influence... Pascal even, who had her own major controversy scandal before any of this happened.

People forgot that Disney did a nice job shining that up. Oh, and Tom Rothman having torched the Vox X-Men brand and then made a lateral move over to Sony, and now he's in charge. Oddly enough, I heard that apparently Pascal might have been more of a champion at the MCU Spider-Man than Rothman, who is more than happy and more than comfortable dealing with his own pocket universe because that's what he's been dealing with in comic book cinema forever. He's only had the X-Men franchise, which I think has had more losses than hits.

Yeah, he did Jumanji too, didn't he? He did. Well, yes. So, but that's to demonize Sony.

I want to do that right off the bat because this is the same problem that I've had when Marvel failed to connect its connected universe over at Netflix. Right, there was a lot of pettiness going on there too. The fact that Disney can't keep its own television and movie houses in order, if it's buying Fox, could pay the Netflix contract fee and then immediately fast track a Charlie Cox Daredevil movie or any other new Avengers or Avengers, or Avengers, Jason, Defenders character movie, frustrating. So listen, Disney is absolutely culpable in terms of being uncharacteristically cheap.

So here's the deal. Sony has one cash cow as proven by the Men in Black failure and the moderate success. I would say pretty substantial success of Venom. Way more successful than they thought it would be.

Absolutely. And even let's throw Spider-Bursing there too, might not have made as much money as the other ones, but I won an award though. That's pretty good. And it was damn good critically claimed.

Yes, which they're not getting much critical acclaim, so they could use some of that. Absolutely. So one cannot necessarily blame Sony for wanting to hang on to the only thing that makes them any money. The only stick they have to shake.

And again too, I've even made the argument there. It's like, yeah, Venom and Spider-Burs, you guys wouldn't have made that if you could still have made live action Spider-Man movies though. Yeah, absolutely. The other thing is, you know, I remember Sony was in a dire straits back during the Emoji movie period.

Oh, yes, that's right. I remember like, rumor, certainly that Sony was up for the people at Sony top brass, not Sony pictures against Sony Corporation. We're considering maybe even closing that studio. That's like how dire it was and felt over at Sony.

And Sony too has its own internal problems too, because they have the American branch you were mostly dealing with here, but then we have the bosses over in Japan who make the actual real decisions. Absolutely. So there's a lot of go-between. Absolutely.

So like with Sony, I can imagine them feeling rather desperate and rather put over a barrel by Disney coming to the table and being like, hey, I know we still have like two more movies to make or whatever, but like what if we were to take more money. And I can see Sony, especially because Sony does what Sony does, immediately reacting and kind of a defensive and public reaction. Hey, now just because you do all the work doesn't mean you should get half the money. Right.

And also like this is the only thing that has succeeded for us and it hasn't even been really like a full year. And now you want to take more? Yeah. Like you just bought Fox, like you don't need this too.

You don't need extra money off of Spider-Man. You're going to make X-Men, it's going to be huge. We're already making a good, we already have a good thing going. Oh, beat the beast, oh, right.

Now, I want to get into more of that in a minute, but before we do, there are a lot of people that have questions and comments and I want to get into them really quick. So Adam has the most as well. My one more day theory is done for, I guess. Rescue number one says Disney is in the wrong, they are asking too much.

That aside, Marvel got screwed. Sony only has those rights because they practically stole them from a bankrupt Marvel and the rights should go back to them. There's no heroes in this situation. That's why when I see people picking their camps and you know waving the flag is like guys, no one's the good guy here.

Right. And especially because like, and that's the other thing I wanted to get into. This is all a manipulation game that is used to put pressure on studios and it's their negotiation tactics. Oh, no doubt.

I'm almost certain that the only reason we heard about this is because someone from some camp let it out to be like, all right, then you don't want to do this. Well, let's let the fans decide what they want. Oh, what's that? We're going to boycott everything you do moving forward.

Oh, I wouldn't do that. And that's the thing. That's why I think most of these like news sites are happy to post like this kind of data without any actual source because it's like, it's probably an official word. No one's taking the credit for it.

Well, what was the thing I said there? It's like, look, do you do you want half of something that has been proven to be great and proven to make money or do you want all of something unproven that might crash and burn? Well, especially, I mean, Sony isn't exactly the most creative group of people. It killed it twice before.

Yeah. But that being said, the whole thing could also be a horseshit smoke screen that is used entirely to manipulate the other parties. The thing that really gave me pause was, okay, so like, and by the way, like it's a dick move. It's a power move coming to the table.

I take 5%. I'm thinking of increasing the percentage by 45. It's a gangster move is what it would be a shame if something happened to you. It's a straight up gangster move.

It's a kind of move that a powerhouse normally plays. Yeah. But the fact is, even on a microcosm level, if you're haggling, you go lower than what you want to pay or higher than you want to get because you know there's going to be some wiggle room. What I'm sure Disney did not count on, which is by the way, I think in Sony's prerogative was being like, oh, nothing.

Yeah. Like, no counter. You're trying to haggle with a crazy person. That's exactly right.

Like, no, you understand. You're trying to negotiate hospital bills with a terminal patient here. Yeah, you can't get blood from a stone. You want to get nuts, breaks a bottle.

Let's get nuts. Let's tweet about it right now and see what happens. Oh, no one's happy. Yeah, geez.

We did. And in that desperation, they turned to a man who they didn't quite understand. Josh Bowman says, don't worry, Minnesota's weather is crappy too. Damn it, Adam, stop beating everyone.

How big of an influence do you think this will have on the MCU? Honestly, I think it'll have virtually no influence on the MCU outside of my involvement and interest in it. Really? My interest in the MCU has begun and ended with Ken Spider-Man being this.

Really? Interesting. It has always been that way. It has never not been that way.

That being said, I have holy and enthusiastically enjoyed. Iron Man, I think, is one of the best that we hear movies ever made. I love The Interconnected Universe. I love all of the stuff.

But I've always been watching it with that hope and caveat of Spider-Man being in it. And now that he's not, I have virtually, and now that he's not, and the next big thing is eternals, I couldn't be less excited. Oh, that's a shame. Like, straight up, not interested.

While I also have misgivings and concerns about major corporations owning everything blah, blah, blah, blah. I also don't understand why major companies with super power don't use it to get things that they want. So I don't understand why Disney would make that move and seem and be so greedy when they don't need to be, and when there's absolutely no precedent for it. Like, what are you doing?

Again, the perfect confluence of ego and greed and shortsightedness all coming together. This could not be more of a Hollywood story is what this is. Yeah, no, it'll be an amazing article story read post one day, like a whole of the details. No hack to give us real concrete evidence.

No, that's a shame. The only reason why we even know how this only thing worked out with Marvel in the first place. Exactly. I think people truly forget that in what Dyer Straits Sony was.

Amazing Spider-Man killed the franchise for a second time. Amy Pascal and a bunch of their CEOs. Huge racist email scandal. They were looking terrible.

They needed someone to come and save them in this situation. And indeed, oh, here comes the mouse. Get on my boat full of money. I mean, what was it?

Can't say that production says this is a huge loss on both studios part. My disappointment is immeasurable and my day is ruined just as everyone was here. Solid. I hear you, man.

J. Joseph Frazier, if Marvel Sony don't renegotiate and D23 doesn't reveal anything spectacular, this may be my stop to get off the MCU train. Not enough is my attention. Frazier, you and I are in the same boat, man.

D23, they got it. D23 has to be. Here's the entire cast of Fantastic Four. They need to really, really blow some skirts up with some steam here, ladies and gentlemen.

Otherwise, it ain't going to happen. See, that's so interesting because in my mind, I'm like, what will Spider-Man's impact be on the MCU? Honestly kind of negligible because we've had an MCU without Spider-Man. Yeah, it will be weird for a little bit.

But I think we can survive without Spider-Man. Maybe Ant-Man will show up in more things now or maybe Shang-Chi will all fall in love with him because the actor is so charming. Listen, I have nothing but hope for Shang-Chi. I want Shang-Chi to succeed.

We talked about Shang-Chi. It needs to be a hardcore, real, like practical effects, wire work, kung fu flick. But for me, in my interest in MCU, it begins and ends with Spider-Man's involvement. But that's what's funny about it is that Spider-Man, you know, the MCU can survive without him.

But I don't know if this Spider-Man can actually divorce himself from the MCU at this point without feeling really weird and hollow. Especially after the cliffhanger from the last one to be like, okay, so we're not going to mention Happy Hogan or Iron Man or the Snap or anything else ever again because we literally can't. Nope, literally the next one is going to be, he's still upset but this time he's about his uncle Ben and also Venom. Yes, and also, which is going to seem so fucking weird now because we have a Spider-Man-less Venom origin movie but Eddie Brock hates this teenager who's never worked in the news industry before.

What about that thing? There are a lot of creative people over there, there are a lot of uncreatable over there. But there's a lot of creative people out there who could come up with some reason. Listen, if you read Spider-Man comics you know that like there's a million reasons why Spider-Man should just call the Avengers and Venom's like crushing a skull but he doesn't.

So you couldn't still make Marvel-less Spider-Man movies. There's no argument against that being a thing. But would you want to see him though? There's even no argument against them being good Marvel-less Spider-Man movies.

Arguably everyone says Spider-Verse is the best Spider-Man we ever made. And there's nothing but Spider-People and no Marvel stuff. It's true. So it can be done.

Hell before that Spider-Man 2. One of the best superhero movies ever made according to every list out there. You could argue, again, Marvel-less, no other characters, no other ancillary characters. So like there's room.

It's true. The question is now that I know. Exactly. And will the fans accept that now?

Can they walk backwards in this story? Can you go from an all-you-can-eat buffet to it? It's like, okay, now the value menu. And here's the thing.

It's not even about can they do it. But should you? We're in a position where we were more or less promised to slash sold this. I'm going to see the Spider-Man movies on the premise of this.

Yes, well that's a good director. But yes, Feige is also an excellent producer and sneered those movies in those directions creatively speaking. I want those movies. I don't want to be in this position where I have to then pick, choose and guess.

And honestly, like, and because we're dealing in the billions of dollars here, we should also, we all know, because you're also doing this tactic of airing your dirty laundry in public, we know it doesn't have to be like this. No, exactly. And we don't have to have a world where we have to like just get over it and get used to it. Like you could just pay a little more and fix it.

But we won't because our pride is tied up as now. And that's what it is. It was just profits, they just pay it. But it's not, it's about egos and pride.

Which ruin everything at the end of the day. I know. Nate Nog helping us out. Zee-birm.

Guys, this is a Sony film company known for making bad decisions. I don't know if it's a Geni Teratovsky Popeye movie for the emotional. Oh, I know. That being said, that Mocha movie made money.

I know it didn't. I never seen a popeye movie, I didn't see the emotion movie either. But I also didn't see Popeye. I just seen it because I like Tarkovsky.

I like Tarkovsky too, but like, Popeye, price 80 40, this could be fixed in continuity, spoilers for far from home, whether it could be an adaptation of Back and Black and Spider-Man no more, where it's almost assassinated in Peter's office being Spider-Man. Yeah, you can do that. That's one. Yeah.

There's any myriad of reasons that you could use or argue. Hell, Spider-Man, persona non grata and nobody wants to talk about him. That's fine. True.

say Peter Pock and never came back from his European vacation. Right? Hell, they just make a Miles movie through it. What are the rules around Miles?

Because I assume it was Spider-Man and everything Spider-Man adjacent. My assumption is it's all Spider-Man. I think there's a couple of like, Kavya, it's like, O'Rania. Gwenpool, by which I mean Gwen D'Alene, pool P-O-L-E.

Right. Not Gwen Stacy. Yeah. W.

Vang, O-O-1-3. The next Spider-Man movie isn't in phase four, so they'll have to figure it out. Do you guys think they'll start to marginalize him at Marvel, like with toys and comics? That was one immediate concern I had, but it's one that was a sawdust when I saw Donny Kate's tweet.

He was like, nah. Yeah, not dog. And I, he makes compelling argument because here's the thing. Spider-Man is and always has been the Mickey Mouse of Marvel.

He's the mascot, he's the face of the company. And he always skirted that. He's always ever green, but now that being said for the five other Spider-Man books that are going on right now. Eeee.

Which if you're a person who doesn't like too much Spider-characters and think it kind of dilutes the brand by having 18 Spider-people running around at the same time, not so bad. But I doubt it really depends on what Pearl-Monner's reaction is going to be and whether that's like a thing. Because he's not known to be reactionary and spiteful or anything. Right, even if they're in the wrong.

The Iceman says, hey, interesting situation. This feels like James Gunn all over again. This is Alan Horne making another dumb decision. Feels like Disney sabotage this corporate effing with Marvel's creative.

I mean, a little different. I think that Spider-Man has no role in any of the phases because he is not owned wholesale by the company and therefore can't actually be like a linchpin character. It's why he doesn't have as many hooks in stuff as say like Captain America or everyone else did. It's why he plays such an active role in Tony Stark's life but also isn't in any of the key scenes that define the character.

Exactly. And while like Peter Parker doesn't hold the gauntlet for too long and whatnot. Like it's a whole thing. So I don't know if it's creative or if it's more just like, the creative people are just told don't use any Spider-Man stuff.

We'll let you know when you can use Spider-Man stuff. Trenton Brown says, the only way I'll somewhat be okay with Sony having full control is if they leave everything to Lord and Miller. Which sounds to be what they're going to do with it anyway because Spider-Verse did so great and now they're putting them in charge of literally their entire Spider-Man arm. I think that's a horrible idea because I don't agree that Sony will believe in them enough to do that.

No, because they're like actual artists with actual ideas that are clever. And they're not executives at the company. They don't own any percentage of the character. Avi Arrat, however, could literally kick in the door at Lord and Miller and go like, oh, there's not enough venom in this movie.

And oh, there's not enough sinister stuff going on. Like I need to make toys. I am a toy man. He's a toy man.

By the way, he and Perlmutter worked at Toy Biz when Toy Biz bought Marvel and then used that purchase to become executives within the company. Crazy. That's how bad off Marvel was. Cash Money in the Bank.

Thank you very much, man. Love the name. You can't fathom why these companies don't see this as a lose lose. They should both be ready to make concessions, too much focus on direct dollars and not enough on dividends paid by cross marketing, shared, fandom, et cetera.

You said it. You said it. It's the literal golden goose situation. It's like, well, we could cut the goose's throat.

Or we could both just be happy making the money we're going to make forever now or ruin it for ourselves. Do you like golden omelets that keep your tummy filled all day? Or do you want to have goose one night? Exactly.

It's a terrible idea. I hear what you're saying. I completely agree. Nan Chit, Nan Chikit, Naik says, I apologize.

I put your name. I have never wanted any company to fail as much as the nostalgia and milking monopoly that is Disney. Kate's tweets, if you want to see Spider-Man with Rest of Marvel, there is still the comics. There's definitely the comics.

It's going to be the purest example of Spider-Man you're going to see. And so you're good. The reality is, if you love Spider-Man, you're good. And you don't.

I never saw the venom movie. You didn't miss anything. Right. I've seen enough scenes because I was like, you've got to watch this.

I saw the lobster eating scene. I saw the make out with the symbiote girlfriend scene. I saw the end of the movie. I've seen another movie to praise what we say.

I've seen the movie. I was like, I've seen enough to be like, no. This is not a movie for me. It's more for people.

People saw a lot of people like it. I get it. See, I don't even think that. I thought it was barely a movie.

I thought it was a connection of scenes. You might have watched it in the best way ever, actually. Kind of into scenes. I've only seen key scenes that are fun.

I didn't get to see any of the scenes where any of the scenes were like, oh geez, oh my god. I didn't see any of that. I'm doing a New York. I'm doing a voice.

I do every time. But yeah, I didn't need to see venom. And I don't need to see so many Spider-Man movies. I don't need to see MCU movies that I don't have interest in.

It's true. And you're not alone. No one felt they needed to see dark Phoenix or New Mutants because they knew it wasn't connected to anything and it wasn't going to go anywhere. I wonder, will this be the fate of Spider-Man now?

Now that people are kind of wised up a little bit. Now they're meta-watching. Yeah. Could it be that the failure of the Netflix Marvel shows was more because people started to catch wise to the fact that they weren't connected in any way and that they were never going to be?

I think that had a lot to do with that. That had a lot to do with why I didn't see the third season of any of them. Same here. Because we didn't know what's done yet when we were watching Daredevil.

Yeah, I was just like, this is just so good. It is. I didn't bother to watch any of the last seasons of any of the other ones. Because why should I?

I have enough entertainment jockeying for my time. I don't need to see something that I know isn't going to go anywhere. Not to mention the stuff we're just making ourselves. Two mics one take.

Can you see such a way towards Sony offers Disney Venom and other Sony characters for more cut of the profits of Orkery even put love the show take care. Thank you very much, man. I think that the plan, and this is again conjecture. So please don't quote me.

I don't mean to cover my ass, but I do want to be clear, because I care about the facts. Absolutely. I heard that the offer from Sony was, let's work on weaving everything together, which up to an especially venom. Right.

Let us play in your sandbox. How about that? Can we get a little FaceTime here in this, you know, biggest media franchise in the universe? Right.

And you know what? Like, fine. Again, like, you know, if the Clintars or whatever you want to call them, we're in Guardians, that'd be kind of cool. Yeah.

I guess that'd be fun. I'd be fine with that. But yeah, I can also see Disney's reticence to be like, no, you are the smelly-kitten class. Here's the thing with Disney and how their boneheads, I was reading an article I think a week or two ago, in which executives are still concerned, slash don't understand what to do with Deadpool.

Oh, yeah, I read that too. And I'm like, are you stupid? Do you know anything? They were too massive hits.

Don't change anything. Like, how do we? Well, what if I want to put Deadpool in the Avengers movies and stuff, but he'll say the F word. And it's like, but people want to see the F word movies.

What do we do? Here's what you do. You make our rated Deadpool movies, and you make Deadpool not our rated in the Avengers movies. Yeah.

And then you make a meta joke about it. Hell, you'll bleep him. Yeah. Right?

Like, is it jarring? Sure. If you don't overdo it, yeah. Like, it's what they do in the Avengers comics.

Absolutely. Like, give me a break here. Have a big explosion drown him out, or the honk of a horn drown him out when he says something naughty. Or just have like, Falcon Cap, like, say language and hit him with a shield.

You know, whatever you want to do, all it takes is being creative, which apparently, some of these people are completely incapable of doing too bad they're dealing in the billions of dollars in a creative field. Iceman says, read reports. Sony did counter off for 70-30. Marvel had zero production costs.

Sony paid costs to Disney 150% of all Saudi properties, not just the MCU. OK, I did read the report. I didn't say anything about the all properties, but, you know, drop me a link and I'll take a look at it. In the meantime, yes, the Sony 70-30 article was another unsubstantiated report that was an addendum to the deadline article, which was not in the CDC article, which is the one I'm quoting.

So thank you very much for your $35. Raskin on one else says, Bredside, now with Sony back in charge, we can now see Uncle Ben die for a third time. You know they're going to do that, too. It's just like, we don't need any of that.

Like, give me a break. I agree. Like, it's funny. Like, I know you're just a joke.

In the darkest, you know, far future, you know, if Holland's just like, I don't want to do this now, I would like to buy myself out of my contract. Does that mean we're going to be staring down, you know, the fourth Spider-Man in Under a decade? Yes, absolutely. Or more likely because of the success of Spider-Verse, Sony will do miles.

Those do miles. That would be the sooner we move. Yeah. Fair enough.

By the way, I say thank you very much. What was it? Tavia says, Sony Disney screw us fans all the way by taking Spider-Man away. Yeah.

That's the thing is that the only people who were hurt by this deal, because everyone's making off like bandits. Everybody's making miles. Everybody's doing OK. The only people who don't get what they want is the fans.

I know. And in a dystopian cyberpunk future where corporations run everything, can I at least see the movies I want to see? Right. Can I at least get to see the movies that you kind of like indicated or promised you were going to give me in the first place?

Yeah. By the way, they owe me nothing. Promising a movie is not like it's more like you go out to dinner and your parents will offer to get you ice cream afterwards. But then it turns out like it's kind of like too late for ice cream so you don't get ice cream.

You're still disappointed even though you understand rationally that you don't owe ice cream. There's way too much entitlement in geek spaces these days anyway. So like we want to say we are not those people. Exactly.

Exactly. And I don't want to like deny anyone the kind of movies they want to see. Oh yeah, please be upset if you're upset. Part of the reason why I was kind of like fine with the Sony deal was with the success of Spider-Man like oh look the the the the vocal minority of people who want to see an MCU list Spider-Man have a whole universe that's well made that's great and fun to watch all to themselves.

So it allows us all to have what we want. See it's just because there are a lot of people who like the MC movie just because I like MC Spider-Man doesn't mean that you don't get your own Spider-Man. I own 16 Spider-Man. I was gonna mention the game too but then I'm like oh wait there's a ton of MCU stuff in the game.

Oh and it's all gone because Sony literally bought that company the day they made the announcement. They sure did which that that should have let us know right. Yeah no MCU stuff in that game I guarantee that's equal is done. Yeah like that's equal will be all Spider-Man know like and for no reason.

Hey what happened to the Avengers they died in a house fire. They didn't exist. They never existed. What are you talking about?

What Avengers? You mean that TV show from the 60s right the British one? Exactly. Master Master Master.

Master Master. Master. Sorry. I know Disney seems greedy but the original Sony deal seems more like a test trial than the 50-50 deal with something that Sony knew was coming.

I think that's probably accurate. I would argue with you about that. Yeah I mean like a 5% of the gross a 5% of the initial ticket sales of the first day. Yeah feels like a water testing deal.

Totally. They had to have known this is coming. I feel like that's probably why they were prepared and why they fast track that spider-person movie why they were quick to make that then a movie white more business is in production right now. They were like we got to start doing this shit so that when the hammer drops we can tell them FU and leave.

And I mean I guess looking at the glass half full here I mean be happy you got to pretty damn good Spider-Man movies and a bunch of cool cameos in the Avengers movies and anything else and before it was all said and done. Right I agree. Mr. About it they can bring in Spider-Man from Force Works now.

Oh yeah that's right the one that they still kind of own. Yeah yeah that's right that's right. Julia Carpenter. Yeah.

Good costume. Looks like Venom though. Mmm but do they care I mean we're in total spite mode right now. True Trenton Brown now you mentioned it's all I always thought that if Spidey was ever out of the MC they could always bring in Aranya for their Spider theme hero needs.

Agreed. Yeah she could be Spider-girl I think that's the idea. I think that Sony has Aranya Spider like or maybe she has to be Aranya and she can't be Spider-girl either way. Aranya I take Aranya I mean like I'm not my Spider-Man is Peter Parker.

I would like to see Peter Parker interact with this Marvel Universe. That's my so it's not about a character that sticks to walls. I mean it's not about the powers about that character being in the costume. But yeah I might have Marvel could do that but I think Marvel is hurting for characters with powers.

No. So they don't meet me at this point I wouldn't push it. I would just be like all right well I guess we'll just put all our energy into X and a band after. Yeah.

TV says it could be the perfect time for DC to introduce Blue Beetle or sideways to the big screen or maybe not. Well I mean really like DC has their own troubles. Go to Warner Brothers right now and say Jaime Reyes like who's that is that the kid who gets us lunch. Seriously though like I mean I would be surprised if Blue Beetle showed up in that Titan show.

Oh yeah that's that's coming out very soon actually. Oh is it? Yeah like they they're rushing through production on that they were filming here in Toronto like only a couple weeks ago and it's gonna be on like next month. Nice.

Yeah I got to watch it. It's not good I watched episode one and I was done. That's not good. I watched most of Doom Patrol and all the Swamp Thing.

Oh Doom Patrol is so good. Swamp Thing I watched episode one if it got canceled. I'm like I'll finish this one it's all done. It's all great except for the last episode.

Naturally because they already said it's like and here's where we ran out of money. I was just wrecked you can you see. It was like it was like an animation show of course like I didn't finish drawing the rest of the scene. Jay Frazier says I'll only take another Uncle Ben if they make it meta and cast Joe Pesci.

That thing I like doesn't really reference I like that idea. That's pretty good. Doom 2018 says with Peter Parker out of the way freeze up Star Industries we seized by Trask and have the Sentinels be based on the Iron Man suit. Alright.

I don't see it doesn't really need to be a part of that you can just do that anyway. I don't think you're gonna do that but you know Sentinels man. Sentinels should be cool and should look cool. I don't think he needs to tie them into the Iron Man to make them work.

Plus isn't that a little derivative of the whole Ultra on suits? Yeah. De Momo helping us out in Big Bad Way. Thank you very much.

No comments. Well thank you very much anyway. Appreciate it man. If you have one drop in the chat and I'll talk to you.

So yeah honestly like I said like my big thing was this kills my enthusiasm for the MCU pretty much wholesale. That's so sad. I know I like the MCU and I appreciate it but like I've always been watching it with the hope and the eye towards it being Spider-Man connected and without him like the wind is out of my sales. Of course the other thing I have to say is we don't know.

No it's true. We know that Sony threw the first punch in terms of making a public statement about the situation and making it rather declarative. Kevin Feynman will not be producing the next Spider-Man movie which will still come out. Yes one way or another.

So that's that. That being said and because we're dealing with egos, producers, credits and other problems I guarantee you that Disney probably will almost certainly not want to equal or concede. But Disney could easily say let's go with the original deal or let's make the deal a little sweeter for you. We're going to give you 5% of first day sales on Spider-Man merchandise.

Dickish response but like something that says how about this? Disney could afford it and that's my real problem. Like Sony, Sony's going to act. Sony has never acted outside of character.

I've never respected anything less or more from them. They're a weird company. I'm not surprised by it in the least. It's a fact that I hired Tom Rothman after he left in Dick's Grace from Fox.

It says pretty much all you need to know. The fact that Aviard has an office there. All you need to know really. But Sony's going to act with Sony's going to act.

Disney got enough money. And I know that to a rich person, to a mega corporation, that is like Nails Notchalkboard. It's never enough. Never enough.

My shareholders need more. They expect more. The reality is you just launched, you're about to launch the thing that's going to kill Netflix. You've destabilized the entire streaming market.

You own Star Wars and practically buried it. You own The Simpsons now. You own The Simpsons and you're going to do Jack squat with it. How about you at the very least pony up the dough and fix this?

Like, because you have the power to do it. Because you have the money to do it. And that's in this town, in that town, in that area, money is power and influence and producer credits are like the icing on the cake. But the reality is like you have the money, you could fix it and you won't.

Or we could just buy Sony wholesale. And I mean, like, I heard a couple of rumors about that. I've never making that suggestion of years ago. Sony would never sell in this climate.

No, especially not now. Again, egos are in it. And it's also a battle of East versus West now because again, people forget Sony is a Japanese company. Yeah.

Well, also, Sony has this real problem because Sony is Sony. Sony thinks that they can do it on their own. Yeah, which I hate to say, if you paid money to go see you Venamine theaters, you helped with that sense. If you go see the rerelease for Far From Home, you are telling Sony you're going to see their movies.

Yeah. And like, I don't want to hurt another company. I don't want for companies to have to behave like this. And I don't want to pick sides in this thing.

I just want Spider-Man in the MCU. I just want to make sure that I'm willing to make choices based on my preferences. I think that the Venom idea was kind of dumb. I didn't like that idea.

I didn't go see it. I encourage other people who agree with me not to do that. But like, you know, Sony has a place in this world. Sony's making that Ghostbusters movie.

I'm going to go see that. Like, I'm looking forward to it. It looks like after a significant failure, they finally figured out, oh, I need to get the right people on these projects. People who want to be working on these projects.

Frequently asked questions

How long is this episode of Elseworlds Exchange?

This episode is 1 hour and 9 minutes long.

When was this Elseworlds Exchange episode published?

This episode was published on August 22, 2019.

Is there a transcript available for this episode?

Yes, a full transcript is available for this episode. You can read the complete transcript on the episode page.

Can I download this Elseworlds Exchange episode?

Yes. Use the download control on the episode player to save the publisher-provided media file.