Skip to content
Elseworlds Exchange: What if Disney Ditched Marvel Comics? episode artwork

Aug 10, 2017 57 min

Elseworlds Exchange: What if Disney Ditched Marvel Comics?

from Elseworlds Exchange Hosted by ComicPop

Sal and Joel discuss a nightmare scenario offered up by a Disney-themed blog. See more at comicpop.net and help ComicPOP keep the lights on at patreon.com/comicpop.

Episode details come from the podcast's RSS feed.

Embed this episode

Ready to play

Elseworlds Exchange: What if Disney Ditched Marvel Comics?

0:00 57:43
of matches

Transcript Auto-generated, may contain errors

Do you like Transformers? Check out the Transmissions Podcast at TransmissionsPodcast.com A twice weekly show that covers everything from the toys of the 1980s and today to those god-awful live-action movies. The main Transmissions show talks about the latest toy news and releases. Did you know there's a whole market of unofficial Transformers toys that pay homage to classic characters and figures?

I didn't. Transmissions has you covered on all the official Hasbro and those unofficial third-party figures. It's a little known fact that Transformers comics have been getting critical acclaim in the past few years. And Transmissions Alt Mode reviews all the latest Transformers from IDW, and occasionally looks back at the classic Marvel and Dreamwave books too.

Of course, it's also talked about Transformers and other media like TV shows, where releases end, yes, even the Bay movies. If these shows sound like fun, check them out at TransmissionsPodcast.com Find their shows on iTunes, Stitcher, and Google Play, and also check out their Discord server to talk with the hosts and other listeners. You will find everything at TransmissionsPodcast.com. Alright, let's get on with the show now.

Waiting down upon the underworld with my ganglin, come the friends of the Unsuck of the enemy of criminal. Any serious, all-powerful character, a problem to the police, but a true state of law. Hello everybody and welcome to the Ultimate Change, I'm Sal. And I'm Joel.

Today we're gonna talk about Disney and Marvel, which feels like we're what, a couple years late to the conversation? And maybe by a little bit. Yeah, but we're talking about something that not everyone is discussing, and I want to talk a little bit about it because I'm sure this article is going to be gaining more traction as we go. If you're not familiar, check the description box below the video where you will find a link to an article by the Kingdom Insider, which is a Disney fan site that wrote an article regarding Disney's acquisition of Marvel and what the future of Marvel holds.

The reason I'm also looking at this for the first time. Yeah, the reason why I'm linking to this article, the reason why I'm talking about it, is because I read it this afternoon and it got stuck in my craw to a degree that a few things normally do. It really bugged me and I really wanted to talk about it mostly in a way to kind of like, assure myself it wasn't going to happen, but maybe in a way to get myself used to the fact that it might just happen. Yeah, when we were banding around topics where today you pitched this one right out of the gate.

And I think my first, what was my response? Oh no, oh God, no, this is a nightmare scenario episode is what you're pitching. Exactly. So let's talk about the nightmare scenario, the article in question.

And by the way, this is the only place I'm actually seeing anyone talk about it. I'm sure it'll be spinning out of control. That said, there's also some pings and some detractions from the article and websites themselves. We'll get into those as well.

But in the beginning, let's just talk about the topic overall, which is will Disney stop publishing Marvel comic books? They're basically saying that to give you a TLDR of the article, it basically says that the comic industry is hurting. DC admits it. And the fact that Disney owns Marvel and basically makes as much from one movie as they do, they make more money from one Marvel movie than they do for the entire year of publishing from Marvel.

Which is fucking insane. It's like, I guess that's true. That really is scary. And the concept is basically, or rather the conceit of the article is if Disney has what they perceive to be a depreciating, not as appreciating asset in terms of the IP of Marvel, but more owning a money hemorrhaging company that what will they do?

And it's like, Disney can't get rid of Marvel because they basically make Marvel makes so much money for the movie. It's an IP factory. Exactly. But the comics themselves don't make them, I wouldn't even say nearly as much money.

I don't think they make them any money as far as they are concerned. As far as Disney's bottom line is concerned, it's like an afterthought publishing books and publishing comics in general. And even though they can say, well, you can get your ideas from the comics and you need more new comics, you get new ideas, the reality is you don't because you can just reboot them every five years and just keep telling the same damn stories over and over. Or tweak them.

Like Kevin Feige doesn't need to refer to the comics at all ever again. I mean, James Gunn himself completely took the Guardians of the Galaxy part and gave you every time that you see something related to Guardians of the Galaxy comics, especially like the Guardians 3000 or like, the Zans Astra, you are lucky to get that reference. And it's only because it's like a little like, wink, it's not anything. So to say that Marvel publishing is like a form that produces great new ideas, I don't know if that's true.

And that's definitely not what the article's saying. The article's saying like that's not true. Movies will just movie studios just make whatever. They'll just tell their own stories.

And that'll be that. Yeah, I'm skimming through it now. It is a lot of doom and gloom. So at the end result, they're suggesting that Marvel will simply, if they decide they want to make comics at all, is they'll just license the intellectual properties out to whatever publishers want to tell stories about them and pay the most money.

Jesus. That concept just rocked me to my very core. The idea that- Fucking terrifying. The idea that like, okay, fantastic for X-Men.

We're talking about properties that Marvel is right now, fucking with, because there is some movie fuckery going on. And on the deepest, most optimistic level that's maybe like pushed down by cynicism and truths to like a little like small ball that's left inside your soul, you believe one day it'll be better. One day they'll fix it. One day they'll get them back or they'll stop.

Maybe the guy at the top will leave, maybe Fox over Lent, maybe the money'll go away, maybe the money'll come back, like maybe whatever. We've been down this road before. Have we really? I don't think so.

Marvel- It's similar to the crash of before, like the energy around it feels similar. We were always together. The Marvel House was always in order. Even if they didn't have their money or their druthers to publish really good books, they still had- how do I say this?

They still had the whole house together. They were never like marginalizing their own properties to stick it to some other company. Right. But now we're seeing a house that's kind of divided.

We're seeing a split up house. We're seeing Marvel kind of say like, eh, whatever about this, eh, whatever about that. In fact, the split between Marvel Studios and Marvel TV is allowing the companies to be confusing and frustrating. It used to be that it was all connected and now maybe not so much.

Maybe one day they'll say, ah, screw it. The Netflix shows are their own universe. And maybe Marvel Comics doesn't want to support the TV version of everything. So we'll just ignore that.

Or maybe we'll ignore the movie version of that and just further divide the house. But ultimately, at the end of the day, my concern is that while the most of us consider that the Marvel can never truly be divided, especially now that it's owned by this big parent company, we'll never see the house ideas fall. Because it's built on a foundation of money supported by the mouse. This suggestion indicates that perhaps we'll never see the house come back together.

And that by the time that anyone would get their heads out of their asses or get the money needed or the studios to screw up or everything to get together, maybe Marvel will stop public or maybe Disney will stop publishing Marvel Comics altogether and you'll never steal those families together. Like what license Spider-Man? So like IDW can make some Spider-Man books and boom studios can make some Spider-Man books. Maybe DC can do a couple of crossovers with Spider-Man.

Which is an insane idea to think of. But Spider-Man can never crossover with Captain America again. Because they don't exist in this universe. That's nuts.

The idea that like, oh right now we're frustrated that like the Fantastic Four are only 50% message mentioned in comics. We're looking at a future and honestly we're looking at it because it's real. I'm just saying we could be looking at a future where we'll never see Marvel whole again. And that is fucking scary.

Yeah it is. It's a little crazy to think about because it's like why would they do that? Why would they cut their nose to fight their face? We see them do it.

All the time. We're seeing Marvel already hurt themselves. You have an intellectual property like Fantastic Four. Which, briefly word has said, doesn't sell.

You know where we cancel the book because it's not selling. Hickman's saying we cancel the book because the movies are not being run by us and so we don't want to support them. At the end of the day. That's not true.

Right. At the end of the day you're damaging your own brand by letting only one source tell their stories. Mm. And especially if that source isn't you.

And Marvel still is hurting their own properties by not putting the best people on their books and not putting all the attention necessary. Because at the end of the day Marvel is a book publishing company. Yeah. I mean at least it used to be when it was purchased by Disney it became an intellectual property farm.

And I think that's what Disney was looking at. I don't think Disney was. I don't think Disney even wants to publish comics or books. I don't think Disney sees that as a that as a that as a boon for them in any way.

Well I mean that's always kind of in the case for Marvel. Like the last time they were in trouble and they got bought out that's what they were looking for. Where it's like no I want my own mini Disney with all these characters. Which is funny that they would end up being bought by Disney anyway.

Yeah. I mean we're seeing Disney which could be producing a crapload of Star Wars comics. Licensing out the Star Wars I'd these two other comic book companies. That's shocking.

Like I didn't even know that when I just again I'm reading the article. But why is that? Why are they giving it not giving it back to IDW but letting IDW start making them. I don't know but no the Dark Horse and Star Wars before so it's.

That's right now it's IDW. But it's like that's bizarre. Like that's really weird that they were like I literally it's like it's like you having a printer your house and being like I want to print this out but I'm going to go across town and have someone else printed and actually because they have a better print and like arguably they don't really have much of that. Like the printers are saying it's just like I have my own but I rather use somebody else's.

Yeah well but why are you using the extra steps why don't you do this in house. Yeah you have the tools in your backyard just use them. That's I mean they have been doing it in house and it has been success. I'm looking at this IDW thing they have coming out it's like in all ages Star Wars book that they're trying to do basically more aimed at kids than like what Jason Aronim is doing right now.

Marvel has produced and does produce children oriented books they have their own line. Marvel actually is older than IW should marvel have people within the company that know how to produce children's books. You would think. I mean come on.

Also saying to the Archie comics people now are apparently going to be making a series of little digest books based on Marvel here is which I actually think is a pretty good idea. I think it's a great idea but it's also like Archie's gonna produce Star Wars books we're already seeing them license out Marvel characters and whether you agree or not Star Wars are Marvel characters. Yeah. I don't mean to say that like Star Wars and Marvel are the same thing I'm just saying like Marvel produces Star Wars books if you want to buy a Star Wars comic whether it was published by Dark Wars or it's published by Marvel you only have one source except for IW and only for the kids oriented stuff it's kind of bizarre and it's kind of scary and it's kind of doomsday scenario but this is the where we live in where it's like everything's a game of games scenario so it's not at least it's worth addressing so that we can do talk about it because maybe the more we talk about it the more likely we can stop it or or voice art is pleasure because damn do I not want that to happen I grew up I was a Marvel kid I grew up like when I was a little kid I read Batman Superman and Marvel books and Marvel was like the most cohesive universe for me and everything was in everything filled with fit into each other everything worked with each other everything you know worked like worked in sync whether it worked well you know it was another matter but at least for all the stories that I pursued you know worked pretty well the idea of imagining a fragmented Marvel house where it's like yeah whatever happened to Hawkeye oh yeah Boom Studios makes a Hawkeye book it's very it's very game of thrones is it where it's like we need someone to unify all these kingdoms I don't know Alex in the chat actually mentioned something interesting where he was like Disney saw Power Rangers as a depreciating asset so they sold this they did just probably back to Savan which is a I never thought that would happen I remember when they bought it's like oh shit Disney owns power so fuck they sold it back when I heard that I was like that legitimately is a once-in-a-lifetime thing that that because what's the point of selling back something you paid a frustrating amount of money to retain when you you're so big you could just farm out whatever you're doing like look at it like the article that itself which by the way we'll get it to the nature of the article in a minute or rather the source of the article but for now I just want to say like with with respect to power rangers and selling it back like it's unheard of oh yeah like how many people do we know you know using a microcosm example like how many people do you know own some kind of very very valuable collectible betting that they got that they purchased and then went you know to sit in my shelf and then sold it back rather than sit on it you know maybe it's not on a shelf it gets in storage or something especially Disney who is kings of sitting on shit i mean gargoyle's they won't let Greg why's been doing anything with gargoyles they're just gonna sit on it right couldn't they just sell gargoyles back or license out gargoyles or something else and by the way i'm not saying the gargoyle's like a golden goose that has a bazillion franchise opportunity but it's pretty cool it's cool and it's a thing but it's something that doesn't it isn't like why sell why not sell Mickey you know i'm saying like Disney you know gargoyle's is not intrinsically tied to the Disney mythos so it's like you could you could conceivably sell off gargoyles you could conceivably sell off star wars you could conceivably sell off marvel and that was my response to this article in the most knee jerk hopeful kind of way i was like no if you don't know what to do with marvel comics and you can just sell it back or like someone else will buy marvel comics and publish the books and then marvel will make movies based on whatever they want and the comics will be made by somebody else maybe DC will buy marvel comics and else but like the other thing that was almost a thing that happened a long time ago let's talk about that for a second um if you guys are not familiar back during the jim shooter era of marvel it was wonder brothers and boy do you see they saw DC as a depreciating asset they couldn't make any money on Batman movies and they were like yeah let's get rid of this shocking to thank so they so uh wonder brothers came to jim shooter at marvel and said uh and correct me if i'm wrong it's not jim shooter but like i'm pretty sure it is what's your answer i went to shooter and they said like do you want this do you want the IP of DC comics because like you make you make com it's literally the kind of thing you'd imagine a movie studio doing being like yeah okay i don't know anything about comics but like you seem to know it's like hey ken Smith you mentioned superman and you know like dick and like and boob's you you must be an expert expert on superman you want to do superman you want to do superman like hey you publish comic books would you like to own Batman and superman we don't obviously know what we're doing with them and they came very close to he was only like a couple million dollars short apparently i was interested i always heard the story jim shooter said no the jim shooter said that if one of our is unwilling to do anything with them then no so i'm thinking of shooter buying another comic company he came up with it's literally like i thought the story went but like shooter goes eh like if if one of our brothers didn't know what to do with Batman then Batman must not be worth the money and just passed which is terrifying um or not terrifying but like i would like to visit i would like to bring to rick santia's portal gun universe to see the world of marvel and dc under one publishing house it started in 1987 like holy shit that would be some crazy shit yeah so i was thinking of shooter because it's like he had valiant and he had all these other things and he tried to buy multiple other comic companies he's had a fascinating life jim shooter if you ever like corner him or get a chance to talk to him like he is totally worth chatting up because even like regardless of other creators opinions of him which are divisive and strong um the dude is a wellspring of information any season to comic book veteran you have a minute of their time take it because it's worth it it's like he was there man he was there in the shit for all this stuff you remember so i mean like okay so let's imagine a world we've already imagined a world where uh disney could say shit man book comic publishing what a waste of time and money i really don't want to do this anymore what are we gonna do instead like if we if we cancel them all there will be how many people buy comic books right like i don't know like a million a million people maybe maybe less you know buy comic books overall uh do i want to deal with a million angry fans it's a drop in the bucket for us though it's like it would be a PR nightmare like imagine if like 200 thousand people just you killed it would be like it's more than a comic company you killed an american institution right and do we want to be the bad guy in that story not necessarily okay fine we got published we got published comic books all right well first of all uh we're gonna publish like half of them you know marvel like we'll just we'll cut half of the amount of publishing what are we doing like 45 books you know what we bring down to 12 you know more than half we're gonna have 12 books it's a hard 12 and that'll be the writing on the wall i think if marvel goes like hey listen we're streamlining our publishing line and we're gonna get rid of like more than like two-thirds of our comics but don't worry that means that we're gonna really get to focus on the really good stuff and really like just tell you the best possible stories we can i would start worrying and maybe selling some of my marvel comic stuff yeah right not anything anymore but yeah no i get well it's by the same article to you link me to says you know if this is a future if this is a potential future if this is a days of future past year yeah where marvel gets either sold off or segmented off or whatever that would hasten the death of the direct comic market even more which i think that's another big problem that affects all of this the direct comic market is unsustainable the first or anything about the direct comic marketplace it's unsustainable it is only uh supported by by two major companies and it's archaic in the year 2017 and it's supported by monopoly it's only the only distribution method is one company and that is and there's no other industry that's like that america and it's like what are you doing uh so there's a lot of change that would need to happen in order for the comic book industry to be prepared for a move like that by disney and normally i would say like disney wouldn't do that but we just yesterday saw disney pull out of their netflix deal and then offer to create their own creator for netflix which by the way is a fucking stupid idea yeah i'm not a big fan of it either i'm talking about yesterday i was just like hey disney could you not contribute to the further polarization of our media because like the last thing anyone wants to do is go to like six or seven different goddamn places to watch movies and to each the battle days of cable are coming back now in the future we will need six different packages of streaming services so i can get my hbo so i can get my amazon my hulu my netflix funny thing is like i watched a i watch a lot of my conversation about this people were just like hey um uh let me let me just do a little bit of like a step-by-step process of how this is going to go uh can i watch it on nephlix no can i watch it on amazon no can i watch it on hulu no okay then i'm gonna steal it and there's nothing you can stop that and there's another dimension from that conversation like can i watch it if i'm in canada or australia no fuck you no fuck you i'm stealing it by jacking german the superchastic what if they started releasing underselling or depreciating characters to the public donate no one wants change she's just throw them out i don't think that disney will do that only because that gets them no money yeah and disney is famous for never letting anything they own falling in the public domain.

they have manipulated and fucked with the american copyright system forever mikki mao should have been in the public domain like two three decades ago but they've lobbied congress every time to get his you know thing extended and they always do it and it's actually the years between when copyrights by her have been extended because of disney's litigation so like disney releasing something to the public domain would be ironic but i don't think feasible i don't think they would consider a net gain for them anyway and massively hypocritical too because walt disney when he was alive knew exactly the importance of remixing you know stories from the past all the great disney films are all based in fairy tales in one way or another or mythology you didn't own that you didn't write that you took it and remixed it and made it your own exactly um now of course let's remind me i do want to talk about like refuting this doomsday scenario please do let's bring the spirits up let's give some hope so first of all the disney insider or the kingdom insider dot com uh they have uh they have fewer followers than they have following on twitter i noticed it it's kind of like niche niche niche website i've never heard of it until you brought it up to me i never heard of it until it was brought to my attention and so and by the way that's not just diminish what they said it's not to diminish what they're what they're what they're devil's advocating because regardless of the source if it causes a great discourse and if it makes us question um the establishment in some way that's legitimate or we find some legitimate conversation out of it then it's valuable so whether the disney whether the the the the kingdom insider or not is a valuable resource or or trusted uh place to get your information is is irrelevant because all they're doing is asking a really kind of like pointed question they're saying what if this happens it's not an unfeasible scenario to imagine even though it seems unfeasible because you know how can you um it's been 75 years jacar very just elevated 100 birthday like it would be possible that that 50 percent of the comics publishing market could disappear over the whim of person it's it's also true you know in we live in an era where lots of things i thought were impossible ended up happening i never thought disney would own star wars but they do not exactly i never thought i'd see a star wars sequel i'd want to see uh i never like when napster came out i was like this is it and it was gone in a blink of my and then it was in different versions actually napster could be an interesting microcosm for to happen in the movie industry like or like a media industry where it's like all your all your movies and tv were from this one source and then that one source was broken up and then all these shittier sub sources like kazan morpheus limewire and limewire all came out i came about out of it and it's like and then that was like a wild fucking west of getting trotus worms and so as a result like things had to change and what's what's that thing marv says in uh synced it is the battle day the all the other day all in nothing day by the way kiddos if you're wondering what napster is just google it but uh don't talk shit about limewire why was my trusted source but you say in here man but we were limewire kids but even then by the way i was not uh i'd not trust limewire no no it was a steal that's not exactly it's no honor amongst these it was a frickin russian roulette style situation is what it was okay not today yeah like i you know i might buy my guns from this fellow he might be a really really good deal but i'm not gonna ask him to watch my kids you know yes exactly let's let's keep our two lives separate here look we're both not saints here but i know you might just send me a trotus but anyway uh the fact that this website like we talked about that website uh oh you're groosh art oh there's one that was a decent option that just completely fell apart sound cloud uh it might be falling apart uh as we said i fucking hope not i finally uploaded the entire backlog of comic multiverse that i just failed i just went to go to somewhere else i know you did staying on topic uh this so okay let's talk about the positives um i don't see dude oh okay that's the thing about this idea this concept of this thing is that like it was so scary to me and i couldn't get it out of my head because if disney owns something that doesn't make them any money if i owned something that was a money pit and didn't make me any money i would get rid of it yeah like i would just just just just for me if i had a shitty car that every month i had to go and like fix or put money into and you know what i mean like and my kids were driving around and terrorizing the way that people are complaining about how it's like you know the comic book and like these marble comments coming out and like they're really poorly reviewed or like people are complaining about them or like they're not as good as they should be like there's a lot of there's a lot of criticism about marble comments right now so it's like okay so some of it found it a lot of it not i would say okay i've got this i got this publishing company and it's costing me money to make these books and people are complaining about them even if like even if we don't have a good day what is happening you know like i would get rid of it and so it's like it's hard to imagine a world where just me wouldn't just get rid of it but if they did get rid of it would they uh would they would they license out the characters would they try to keep the most profitable characters would they do like a reverse marble thing or like marble's like that's what i was going to say because like when marble wasn't trouble they licensed out their characters to every movie studio and it's taken them many years to try and get as many of them back as they can wouldn't be funny if disney did it the other way and they're like look we're just keeping the characters we have movies about but then again like they don't know what will hit and what won't no one could have predicted that the gardens of the galaxy was succeeded oh god uh but people love it um and maybe that's enough to keep with their like look this this is like a big golden barrel here let's not kill the goose that lays the golden eggs yeah now that's the other thing is like maybe marble is or maybe disney is smarter than they are giving it credit for it's a they've been around for a long time and like listen this thing you know we someone here explained to me that it's it's important to keep this publishing house in order and you know it behooves us to keep it the way it is i don't see that as being a logical reason to keep marble and to keep it i think disney understands the power of symbols too where it's like you know marble is like the coke of comic book world it needs to survive in one form or another because that logo is synonymous or at least in the movies but in comics too you know that means something when we slap that logo onto something and you know that's worth more i love that marvel with red and dc to like dc literally chose blue as they are coke and pepsi which you know if you're a coke guy is like i don't know about that they're they're the coke and pepsi and everything else that breaks down and red and blue they're the crips and bloods exactly um but they're also in that they kind of we're in this together until now like dc and marvel needed to support each other because the conflict industry is getting smaller and these books do need each other's support i mean it's just kind of it's it's a weird world we're living in where people have been predicting the death of the conflict industry for some forever forever and i've always been the first one to say like shut up the conflict is going to die would be dead by now comics aren't going anywhere like if it comes and they're not because it's an art form and art forms don't die no they they are some of them like are replaced by more efficient versions of their of their former cells but even some are remixed and remastered yeah but comics i mean like comics are cave drawings in you know in prehistoric times they are modern-day mythology as they said in uh what is it that uh one movie yeah uh unbreakable yes that's the one thank you i almost called it shattered i'm like no wait he didn't shatter because he's unbreakable yeah uh no it's it's not easy to imagine that it's gonna die but like it is easy to uh to make bold and doom-esque predictions about it the industry survived a lot more ridiculous bullshit and i don't see it dying anytime soon but i do see the industry being irreparably changed and oh yeah to a foundation as a result oh that the paradigm has to shift i've been saying forever the future is digital and we see both dc and marvel making strives in there marvel is just coming out now with some of its first digital exclusive series it's funny in that article that i referenced in the description box below this video uh the article mentions digital as kind of a sign that things are going to get worse you know they're like really and i think that they were using digital as a way of saying that's going to be like a cost-cutting measure like you'll see comics going tomorrow like graphic novels and digital they should do that anyway they should because i mean yeah cutting cost is a good thing and furthermore being digital you can reach way more people like as i've said before uh what is it a bunch of books are finding huge audiences that are being there like on the top of the amazon list and all these other lists because they're reaching an audience that wouldn't normally walk into a comic store the most frustrating thing about digital sales is that they don't factor into the overall sales numbers of that's incredibly dumb well again that's incredibly possibly overlook that at this point in in world events see that's the direct market and that's the diamond influence i'm sure the love it doesn't go through us it doesn't fucking count i don't know how that could be possible like i don't understand how you'd be so short sighted as to say like eh well like yeah but um the only numbers that matter are the ones that are sold through the direct market no like i i want to know other business in the world does that yeah i want to i mean like can you imagine the music industry is like no no no we only count the sales of cds well sorry about like crazy um and as we get more and more accustomed to digital i mean like that's that's the future whether you want to be or not so it's time to start facing forward and applying that to your publishing initiative but uh but let's talk about this this this this overall looming cloud overheads and refuted or try to like put salt in it make it go away i don't know how to destroy clouds but uh hobo jojas said cds still exist yeah in your aunts car apparently or at least in mind they still sell cds there's a cds store in my mall i'm like why the cds store in my mall just closed down which it's funny we already saw the cds stores kind of have to try and adapt and change to the time like hmb's what's all we used to all be about music never about music and dvds and like graphic t-shirts and like comic book and a hot topic stuff no it turned into an fy or a like an all-purpose like pop culture store and then they die anyway which is good because i got 50% off of captain america world i was very happy about yes i profited from the destruction of someone else's company yes mom finally there's finally this affects Joel in a positive way i'm like and listen two stores shut down in my mall 10 years ago and fy and the cds store this year alone both stores came back that's really that's mind bending there's an fy and a cds store in my mall i'm like why are we taking a dramatic step backwards our comics like our our is media all cyclical and people want physical media again i don't know but it's i would say it is i would say most media is circular in one way or another people can say like millennials hipsters blah blah blah but like are they are they that's that strong in numbers that we need to start getting there's a bookstore in my mall too the borders shut down a book's a million opened up what is happening so yeah i mean like tying this into our conversation like just because marvel would view publishing comics as a loss for them doesn't necessarily mean that means that they're going to break up the house ideas and throw all these characters into the wind and hope that they all like land someplace profitable now because that because i would argue they're bigger than the companies at this point again they're part of the fabric of pop culture most of them true enough and some of them are intrinsically tied to each other like yes and it'll be hard to make them not work just look at spawn and how frustrating and hard it was to try and change chapel to priest like that in and of itself was frustrating and stupid and they still had to pay money to rob life every time they referenced chapel which was every time they talk about his orchard a mind-bending retcon of palooza yeah and it's just one thing there's one guy and now you got a universe that's all connected to each other through through through publishing books that's sir Toby brings up a good point here hey market dynamics people want to accessorize their homes and can't do that with digital copies fair enough i agree with that but uh why don't i just go on amazon and buy shit like yeah that's i mean i understand i'm building these things and making them but i understand i'm being in the stores i guess you could sample it but that's why like best buy exists they're basically just like you know best buys themselves they're popular by they're basically like malls companies rent out shelf space from best buy to sample their merchandise and keep it there so you can then try out the new logitech or that brand they don't just sell keyboards they sell these companies keyboards and then if i really hate paying shipping and handling that yeah but no but no no question you're gonna save money then go into best buy but anyway uh so okay let's say marvel is hell bent on doing this let's say let's say it's true and marvel is like fuck it we don't want to make just just just superficially we don't want to make comics anymore what is a solution that satisfies us kind of a fan what what do we hope happens what what do we make a video suggesting that they do give it to someone trustworthy and someone who the fans like like who's a good steward for all of this parent company like do you think they should be a huge company or think they should be owned by a single person or you think they should be owned by a by a by a non-profit organization like oh shit i actually kind of i mean they'll never give it to a non-profit organization but i kind of like that where it's like you know the the institute for the for the visual arts or something the boy scouts of america why do i play marvel well hey uh what is it here in uh what is it canada what is it what one of the major hockey leagues is owned by like the teachers pension fund and some other shit it's funny i've seen a lot of suggestions in the chat like what a fox a boy i don't want that first of all uh i could think of worst companies but i could think of better companies yeah fair enough i could sell it to someone said sell it to vindies like yeah sure he's got money yeah for now uh i could see uh i could see one of brothers buying marvel and just being like screw it and what's interesting is uh getting back to the jim shooter thing it really quick here here and more since i find it hard to switch digital uh keep up it is hard thank you it is hard listen once you do though you don't look back you save so much base because i had a i had a lousy comic book uh retailer experience and uh going to kamikazeuchi was like yeah i don't know if i want to do this i wake up in the morning i look at the books that came out this week i buy them and then i read them on my desktop and it's amazing it's a beautiful feeling is i did that today too i read secret empire and i read superman yeah um but like let's say one of brothers buy is marvel just the marvel publishing line let's say disney goes ask really we got star wars we don't need marveling war which is a crazy thought the fact is that's a that's a conclusion that i don't see that i would not be surprised them to do it and the reason for that is simple disney has always been trying to find some kind of intellectual property that appeals to boys that's their thing that's why they bought it in the first place because they're like look we got our princesses we got our girl brands we can't make boy brands that will buy boy brands that's why they spent like a hundred million dollars on a tron sequel because they're like what boy brands do we own tron that's why tron's legacy by the way is underrated and awesome but why tron got a hundred and somewhat million dollar sequel 25 years after the first and a connected television series that was as intellectually thought-broken as the that's right i forgot about that plus kamik or not did they make a comment they probably did tron comic but like uh plus a wicked soundtrack that's a fucking amazing soundtrack that has transcended the movie itself but uh that's that's marveled or that's disney being like we got it we got to kill the boys then they then they bought marvel kind of out of nowhere and then they bought star wars and i want to say that star wars was the first offer they made i want to say that behind the scenes this is just here say i don't know this for certain and maybe it's not true or maybe some version of it is true but i want to say that marvel went to door or do disney went to door so they said like how much for star wars and he's like fucking no because he's towards lucas and that's my knee-jerk reaction as well it's my baby damn it then they went then they went to marvel and they're like somebody how much how much said you know marvel has like a fuckload of really profitable characters like like if you came up at man you might as well inspire man you know that here's a blank check so they're like screw it okay and they got it for a good number they get their marvel property then jor's was calls to back up and goes you know i am kind of interested in selling how does eighty billion dollars sound cool i think it was only four really i think it was something more than that it was only four billion i think it was similar to the marvel acquisition but it was it was like it was four billion dollars it was like and they're like uh yeah i mean it's still a cometically large amount of money that i will never be able to grasp like what i do with four billion dollars you know how uh you know how we talked about like you can never say no like how shooters should have never set note of the disc to see offer like of course you take the lucas deal and then they think themselves oh shit well now we have two major boy brands like what i guess we could do you know what i mean i i i could just see disney kind of being confused and kind of frustrated by the fact that now have these two major properties when they were gonna pull go all in on both of them um all the davis and superchats is why isn't idw licensing marvel for comics not an option so it's the problem for having confidence towards true but the problem is that they're not licensing marvel publishing the question is whether they'll split up the characters so i got to only publish spider-man comics or idw only publish captain america comics that would be so weird to open up like a spider-man comic and see an idw logo and and and have him be and have him live in a vacuum because like as much as we're all kind of used to it because of sony and those movies i i i for me it's always been wrong because he's spider-man alone in the universe that's frustrating they're kind of fixing that and the sardarski stuff now it's like look no he has friends he has people comes it's connected i just mean in the sony movies like the sony movies themselves those are like it's just spider-man and you know an occasional american flag uh so many american flags but yeah um i think that disney was kind of like oh we didn't really anticipate getting both of them um but i can see disney being like okay screw it we need to get rid of them and then just calling somebody and it couldn't be one of our lives it could be another publishing house it could be somebody who's like can you imagine if like we could imagine if the folks over at valuent were like okay that would be crazy hey hey hey we're in good with the folks from valuent i hope they get it um but by the way this is all here say we don't really know what's happening we're just saying like what if disney decided that marvel comics was not an appreciating asset the properties are fine the movies are good but these comics aren't making any money what if god forbid but what if and not even god forbid but what if and this is a very realistic possibility what if um marvel infinity or more adventures five sucks and people stop going to them again a dark future scenario i mean like and it's it's a very realistic scenario to imagine that like the that the bubble will burst in terms of comic book movies um i don't know if it's even a bubble this one i think it's more like a genre but i can i i agree so i also think that if it was a bubble that would burst but every genre has highs and lows i mean like there was a time when hollywood was like we're not making westerns anymore and then somebody really really good western and they're like okay make more westerns and then the floodgates opened up again or like we're gonna make a science fiction movies and like or we're not gonna make any more science fiction we screw that and then they went oh well uh this one science fiction was really good let's make a whole bunch of science fiction movies i mean i think the thing that helps comics out is that because the genre is so vast you can tell a space opera with a bunch of you know space pirates you can tell a spy story with a man dressed in an american flag you can tell this that and the other right um another option image buys more buys the marvel comics publishing edition what would that look like that would actually just destroy everything because image doesn't own any of the ip's that they publish no it's all creator owned which would mean if image would do it would it be like that some bylaw within the image contract means that all the characters go back to the respective estates and creators like that terrified like wow what a what a clusterfuck that would produce that's a litigation nightmare yeah then then you'll never see any marvel anything ever again you can barely see milestone characters because one person's wife won't cotton to being screwed out of money which in fairness she's 100 percent in the right they did that without telling her like you gotta cross your teeth and dot your eyes and you're gonna do anything regarding money and other people who have some kind of stake in it um here and Morrison says some spicy comics on the way sell hope you enjoy thank you oh uh but uh so okay we talked about like larger companies owning the marvel properties it could be the disney might just say and like okay we're not going to publish monthlies anymore maybe they'll be like okay well like what does sell trades trades sell and they get critically claimed because you can put them on lists um booklists i'm saying but like trade sell pretty well and they're cheaper to produce than the monthlies i mean you don't make as much but maybe you do if you do if you only make like 13 trades a year yeah i mean you could see marvel reduced to be a just graphic novels it's just we're reprinting all books and we're only printing self-contained graphic novels that maybe they're connected to it sells in their own universe or not i'm just looking here uh brands you didn't know disney own because i'm trying to think seriously now like yes who would be a good steward for this who someone i would actually trust with this if you wanted to sell it back because disney that's the funny thing is that when disney sold power rangers back they had a place to sell it back too like they had an interested party now internally there could be like a memo that says like who would buy marvel you know saying to somebody like like just just put this out there put this out there into the universe like who would buy it you know and then see the shark show up jack-a-grams suggest kamicellity buys it for his digital exclusives oh shit i mean like kamicellity can all race start making digital exclusives it's true kamicellity being independent like group could just do whatever you know they could they could uh they could do all kinds of stuff the fact is like marvel and limited is just a response to kamicellity anyway well what about maker studios maker studios buys marvel that's well that's owned by disney anyway i know here you can have it we'll just pass it down the line yeah yeah just we'll just bring it yeah like lower and lower and lower on the tote bell like different smaller companies that owned the disney oh it's just running for them and then vice news can have it because apparently vice media is also owned by disney which i did not know yeah and that's the thing that really frustrates me because like any of it is a terrifying scenario as joe jamaisian like i don't like any of these suggestions when they said when they said when they were like disney's bought marvel i'm like oh that sucks because it means that they never have to take risks again it means they never have to like push harder it's gets and you know what i guess i was right because like they really don't like they don't have to work as hard they don't have to try as hard they don't have to like push the industry they're not ever going to be desperate you know it comes with job security the creators are will be desperate and scared because they're dependent on producing these books and if they don't make these books they don't get these jobs they'll have to go out into an even into a 50% smaller market if they have to leave i don't know it's that's that's the most depressed where i worry about the writers in the artist because it's like well obviously you want all the companies to do well because that means there's enough work to go around not only for the writers and artists who are already in the business but for the little guy who wants to break in yeah and by the way this is this is also a proper public conversation or not a conversation but an art like i read yesterday about google um they're talking about like transcribing all the all these books from libraries into google and this library was talking to the google executives and they were like well what happens when google doesn't exist anymore and they they were counted that like the executives just had the thought it never occurred to them that there would never be a google and it's making me think like well what if like you know what if there is no place for marvel what if marvel doesn't exist in ten years like what if what if disney decides like screw it and they just break up everything and it all just goes to the winds like but because disney owns everything you never you don't know who really owns anything like it's it's a terrifying prospect to imagine a world where like everything is owned by like one or two companies especially when companies don't last forever despite the fact that some of them might be really old it also seems we're heading that way to a future where everything in the world is just owned by five companies anyway so excited to suggest what are some best marvel comments to read now i really take defenders it's a solid series check out defenders is sweet charles soul is putting in great work on darit devil right now infamous iron man but uh the floor of course has been killing it jason air just hasn't stopped killing it on that book i of course really dig mis marvel that one continues to be really nice like there are as we've always said even though we sometimes doom and gloom on the current state of marvel there's good creators making good books yes as long as you hire good hungry creators you will always have good comics um the question is you know at least with this episode how long will that last and will they like will the marvel comics that we've known forever because i'm getting back to the very beginning of the conversation when i was like man we all kind of take take it at face value that like maybe fantastic for will come back one day like maybe come at fantastic for me and maybe that's probably in the MCU but definitely marvel will start making fantastic for comics again and maybe actually the more likely scenario is that we're gonna see more scenarios like this we're like we're not gonna see as much iron man books anymore and we're not gonna see as many like uh x-men books anymore and we're not gonna see anymore spider man books anymore like this is a hard to imagine but it's like epic this is all in service to the bottom line of a major company who's who's vested interest is not in making comic books and not in making art and making money i mean like marvel is never looking at me god they were i mean like you hear the early stories of stanley talking about like his creation of the characters just i just wanted to make a character that would sell sike and eat and it's like you inadvertently create art through expression of your like ideas absolutely but like they've always been trying to make make a dollar and it's it's a terrifying prospect to imagine that like a company that has no interest making books bought a book publishing company yeah um and you know they did it just to get the ip's and it could be that like maybe like here's my suggestion for how they can fix it or or how they can handle it uh they sell or they they make marvel's own company right and it breaks up into a number of shareholders who own that company or a couple of little boarders records of the company right Disney divorces sell from that company but before they do and separate it into its own company they make a contract with that company that says that if you are going to make a movie based on any intellectual property it has to go through disney first all right you know we get right we get right of first refusal yeah yeah i mean like i can see that being a thing where it's like it just basically kind of goes it that for me that's the most ideal scenario because it allows Disney to make marvel movies which they're obviously capable of doing so yeah so allows marvel to kind of go back to where it was which is making comics and being masters of their own fortune and yes and be yeah and directing their ship in their own direction like i think that that's the way that you can save this this this this horrible future or prevent this horrible future this possible horrible future this possible day is all suggested by a random website that just posits the idea but it got the wheels turning in our head at least yeah so Joel what is your suggestion how do you what would you do or do you like mine i mean i like your idea i would definitely like to see marvel if this is the case and you know disney does decide that they're ultimately not worth anymore i would like to see them go to a proper stewart to you know someone who would respect the company's history their iconic status and their place in pop culture i know that's not all we don't always get our wish we don't always get what we want yeah i don't know it's it's scary to think about because i don't want to live in a world i don't want to live in a world where i remember marvel being one one cohesive thing i mean like look at the reaction from marvel fans when you marginalize their characters oh we're talking about selling off fantastic for fox entirely and like fox make their own fantas were comics we're not talking about like you know getting putting the x-one on the wrong planet and letting them live in their own reality we're literally just talking about like not publishing fantastic four books and kind of not giving a shit about what kind of good x-men books there are like yeah and look at the reaction and then you have a world where like maybe we just won't make them anymore or maybe we'll just license how the characters and let and let valion have punisher you know like it's already frustrating to imagine a world where like where mr fantastic is not helping to lead the direction of the marvel universe in continuity it's secretly but like even that's not gone he could be we don't know he's stretchy can make himself look like anybody well he's got to you know he's got the hours and he's god they can always pull that and it's like no guys i was here for every major event i was the wind blowing through your hair right i was the one who carried you on the beach because i love you that much yeah thanks mr fantastic god there's no way that you know you invent a sweet hovering carrying machine you have to work it uh it this reminded me because i was thinking of that in a in the newest green arrow issue he teams up with superman and like they have a little conversation it ends with aali going hey thanks america's dad super that's amazing yeah um so i guess what i'm gonna do is we're gonna wrap up and i want to show us this question into the hands of you guys the listeners and viewers and say and don't just say like fox sony like Ted Turner just like i'd like to know what you would do with the marvel publishing line like you know what would you like let's say they called you and said you know you figure it out they hired you your job as a disney executive is to figure out what to do with marvel comics sell it off keep it internal how do you fix it what you do to make it profitable for disney i'd love to know i also had a little shout out too because you know obviously on this show we like to talk about cool projects our fans are working on right uh well a fan of ours karaofol who is a hardworking independent wrestler has a huge show this week in brooklyn so if you're in new york on august the eleventh you can see him and his tag partner nick iggy take on british strong style at battle pro that's awesome this is pretty here i know you don't uh follow wrestling self a british strong style or actually a pretty big deal okay so it's so it's actually cool that one of our fans is going to be taking them on i think that's awesome i think kara likes the show but his tag partner doesn't know no he does it i see him on twitter he forces him to listen to the show what's the um what's the uh the parlance for uh for wishing luck to a wrestler that's good it's fine like i yeah or don't get over i think you want to say whatever you do win loser draw get over okay get over with the crowd thank you julford dulgimean this uh doubles advocate to uh fall exercise about what would happen if disney just decided oh yeah i'm not thinking about marvel comics fuck it that is it these are fun i mean you know we do lots of silly fun topics but every so often it's nice to show we can be serious here at the else world exchange okay in there you gotta get in the mud uh if you love something you got it you got to be willing to ask whether it's worth it or not you know gotta shake the tree see what falls out it's true it's true so uh don't ask you never know thank you for hanging out with us and listening to us ramble on about comics in general and uh we'll see you guys next week and all the weapons of the else was exchanged i'm sal i'm jul and we'll see you next week

Frequently asked questions

How long is this episode of Elseworlds Exchange?

This episode is 57 minutes long.

When was this Elseworlds Exchange episode published?

This episode was published on August 10, 2017.

Is there a transcript available for this episode?

Yes, a full transcript is available for this episode. You can read the complete transcript on the episode page.

Can I download this Elseworlds Exchange episode?

Yes. Use the download control on the episode player to save the publisher-provided media file.