Skip to content
Elseworlds Exchange: Worst Superhero Costumes episode artwork

Jul 20, 2017 1 hr 6 min

Elseworlds Exchange: Worst Superhero Costumes

from Elseworlds Exchange Hosted by ComicPop

Sal and Joel talk about the worst superhero costumes and re-designs. See more at comicpop.net and help ComicPOP keep the lights on at patreon.com/comicpop. Visit podcastawards.com to help us win!

Episode details come from the podcast's RSS feed.

Embed this episode

Ready to play

Elseworlds Exchange: Worst Superhero Costumes

0:00 1:06:33
of matches

Transcript Auto-generated, may contain errors

If you're listening to this podcast, you're probably a fan of comic books, movies, and other areas of pop culture. If so, you should check out the Sci-Fi Pie, a blog with reviews, analyses, theories, top 10 lists, and more about, but not limited to, Marvel DC and Star Wars. The Sci-Fi Pie also explains certain things when it comes to the legalities of your favorite entertainment companies. Do you want to know why Marvel is able to publish comics with Star Wars characters?

Or why they seemingly have a mysterious embargo on X-Men characters in video games, even though Fox only has movie rights to them? There was also recently a series of posts discussing the pros and cons of a story having main character armor. Read it before Part 2 comes out. In addition to all of that, the Sci-Fi Pie lately started doing interviews with people who have benefited a certain industry or fandom.

Check everything out that I just mentioned, www.scifipie.me. Again, that's sci-fi pie.me. Also, don't forget to follow at sci-fi.py on Facebook and Sci-Fi underscore Pie on Twitter. Now let's get on with the show.

Welcome to the ultimate exchange of Sal over there's Joel. We're going to talk about the worst superhero costumes and redesigns. We're going to leave out movies because that's a whole show unto itself. As we discovered in the pre-show, we can actually talk about this quite professionally.

Yes, yes, for quite a while. So instead we're going to talk about just the worst superhero costumes that we've ever seen and that have made certain lists, but the ones really, I'm really looking forward to finding out the ones that we personally are like, I saw this and said no. It should be interesting. Yeah, so we're just going to go down a list of things that are pretty much by and large, going to largely consider to be some of the worst costumes and redesigns.

There's a bear swath of material. In comic book history, yeah. So let's kick things off, I guess, with the one that I think might be one of the worst costume redesigns I've ever seen, for one of my least favorite characters of all time. And that would be Warrior for Geigart.

Yes, he literally became the ultimate warrior. Yeah, and like, okay, so I really liked Geigartner's Green Lantern design. It's nice. The best is a good touch.

It makes them different from everyone else. It's cool. Yeah, it's like he goes, listen, I love vests and I will be damned if I'm going to retire my look just to make up just to be a member of this team. No, forget it.

I'm going to make a Green Lantern version of it. I'm unique as fuck man. Yeah, and he has crap all wearing. Yeah.

Yeah, so when they eventually threw that out, he became the warrior. It was like, oh, and if you have not seen the warrior, go look at it. Geigartner warrior and you'll see it's basically, like Joel said, it's literally the ultimate warrior, but it's on Geigartner. And he has alien augmented bio suits, like a symbiote, basically.

Yeah, because Geigartner had some alien heritage we didn't know about that was awoken. Yeah, and it could make his body turn into any kind of weapon that he needed for the situation that he was in. He Swiss army man. That was weak.

Not only was it a weak idea, but just the worst possible reason. I loved the glee in which Jeff Johns got rid of all the warrior shit in like Green Lantern Reber. Yeah, it's just like, yeah, the fucking alien shit just blew up inside of him. It killed him and now it's gone now.

Now he's just back to being human. Yep. Oh, and he's also killing him again. Yeah, never ask about the warrior ever again.

Yeah. They were referring to it in the beginning of Reber. That was like, oh, Green Lantern Reber, not Reber DC Reber. Man.

So so fun to make jokes about, especially because I hate a Geigartner. I'm like, I hate Geigartner. He's derivative. He's obnoxious.

Nobody likes writing for him because he's just a douche. Oh, also, he looks like total crap. Didn't didn't he have an era there for a little bit where he had Sinestro's yellow ring and he wore like a Fonzi leather jacket and like blue jeans with the cops turned up all the way. He certainly did.

That was the Geigartner era. That's the Geigartner that I knew. I knew him kind of like post Green Lantern. I'd write a little bit of Gussley international.

I'm like, who's this phony Green Lantern? Get out of here. Then the next time I see him again, he's wearing it's basically just his vest, but in a jacket form and instead of having a lantern logo, it's a G. And by the way, I loved that idea.

I loved the idea that he got Sinestro's ring. He's like, you don't want me to be a member of your freakin' core? Well, I'll just steal your bad guy's ring, which back then wasn't part of like a thing. It wasn't like it was.

You didn't need to be worthy. You didn't need any of this other shit to wield. You could just pick it up and use it. Pick it up and use it.

And it was rare, but it was not really about fear as much as about being yellow. I loved it. I like Rebel without a call as Guy Gardner. Lorenzo Llamis, Guy Gardner.

Even though he did kind of still look like a chump. It's the bowl cut. The bowl cut in the G. I love he sewed into his own branding.

It's like, yeah, G for God. That's for Guy Gardner. That's right. Somebody just reminded me that he also, of course, had the wonderful bowl cut.

Wow. Which he rocked for a long time. He would lose the bowl cut when he became a red lantern. Remember that?

You let it grow out into a full-on glorious mullet with like a whole-cogid walrus mustache. He got crazy cool hair when he was warrior, but nobody goes into the barbershop and goes, give me the auto-autavious. Give me one of those. The bowl was good enough for my father.

It will be good enough for me. Damn, it'll be good enough for me. Have they ever shown Guy Gardner's father? Because if so, I would love to know if he also had a bowl cut.

That's a good question. I would like to know that. Who willingly bowl cuts themselves? When I was a very small child, I rocked the bowl cut.

Not by request. If it was under request, I would have gotten the Egon Spangler from the end of it's serious. That would have been a mistake in half. At least in the bowl cuts, my parents had straight hair back then.

I would have been fine. But to be like, oh, I look like I have a cannoli on the top of my head. I'd be like, no, I want to look like Egon Spangler from the end of it's series with the rat tail and the cannoli. That would have been a friendship ending experience for me.

As a guy who went to school in Northern Canada, which is a lot like the American South, I went to school with many a mullet and many a rat tail kid. And I will say, at least for the rat tail kids, at least they could always just tuck that under the collar of their shirt. Mullet? Not so easy.

No, the only thing you could do with the mullet is just put a baseball cap over it. Oh, well, that's the uniform right there. Hey, isn't there a superhero that has a baseball cap and people keep pretending that's part of his costume? Oh, yes, you mean a hero who's always offended me for a long time because of this stupid lateral costume change?

Yeah, Arsenal, Roy Harper. What the fuck was with the hat? Whose idea was like, no, he needs hat? Hat, done, nailed it.

Not just any hat, trucker cap. It's so lazy. It's so stupid. He looks so crappy.

And the worst of it isn't just that it sucks. It's that people defend the hat. I know that bugs me too, where it's like, guys, he's supposed to be the sidekick of Green Arrow. He should look a little like Green Arrow.

Everyone else in the Green Arrow camp has a hood. Yeah. Just put a goddamn hood on him, especially because of the costume he has now, where it's like he's not even trying to be red arrow anymore. No, look, I'm Arsenal.

There's more black and military stuff in it. Literally, if he just had a hood on it, it'd be a great costume. And in fact, I think some people showed me there was concept art floating around of the DC rebirth design. He was supposed to have a hood, but they doubled down on the hat.

Why? Why do they want to look like out of the extreme? Oh, okay. I want to look like the crappiest 90s composite character of all time.

Baseball caps are not costume, my friend. No matter how badly you want to disguise it, it's a fucking hat. But here's the thing, look, people just think the hat was dumb because it was facing this way so you could see the build out all the time. You know, it looks like you just rolled out of bed and had to cover up the hat.

What do you want to? What if we just spun the hat around? And that will be his new costume. Yeah.

That fixes everything, doesn't it? Yeah. It's like he's going to an intervention where everyone's like, you wear the hat everywhere. It reeks.

It's disgusting. It's gross. You went to your father's funeral wearing that baseball cap. You have to take off the hat.

All right. All right. How about this? What if I wear it backwards though?

And it's like, no, but why are you wearing it at all? It's like literally it's like, I can imagine Roy Harper used to wear a dew rag and they're like, no, no, you can't do that. You can't get away with that. He's like, fine, baseball cap.

Okay, sure. Whatever. Compromise. Yeah.

Yeah. Like he wore a far dumber hat and this was the compromise. I mean, it has to be it. Just like, he's like, listen, if I don't wear the hat, then I have to wear a giant foam cowboy hat.

Duh! They're a big sombrero. Yeah. Either it's going to be a somb, I want to look like either Speeding and Zollas or a douchebag.

No, no, fedora. He's way into fedora. Now, if he were to wear a fedora or at the very least, like, it'd be amazing because he's a Titan. He's amazing if while he's at the headquarters, they just switch hats every like every couple of days.

Listen, you want to go out and wear your costume? You're going to have to put on a hat and the only hat available right now is a yarmul. So go for it. Or a, yeah, or a Wendy hat from Gravityfall, one of those great big Canadian hats.

Like, to something like that or yeah, or a beret or yeah, I love the idea of swapping them out. Every time he puts on a different hat, it changes his personality like Bugs Bunny. Yeah, exactly. I'm playing a character.

If he wore the fedora, he'd have to be like, hello ladies, you know, like the... Which he basically is anyway. Oh, no. I don't...

Here's the thing. No, that would be fine with if they wrote a story that showed that like Roy because of all his drug use or whatever is like prematurely balding on top. What's the word? He's hiding being bald.

I don't want people to know I'm bald. I'm getting a premature bald spot, guys. Then wear a hood. Wear a cowl.

I don't know. Where nothing. There was a whole era where he did the Hawkeye thing where he just wore nothing on his head. Right.

Just wear a t-shirt with your logo on it. That's a big thing people are doing, man. It is. What, uh, when did he get that hat?

Do you know? Was it a 90s all over? It was just no. It's no 52.

That was Scott Love Del's dumb idea. That's awful. Damn it. That is just another like, another indicator, the new 52 was not all silver and gold, man.

It's true. And it's funny you're still, I remember when James Tainan took over that book. He was at least smart enough. This was only for like an arc, but he was smart enough to take the piss out of the hat.

Yeah. So like not only would he wear a dumb trucker cap all ouch, uh, ushered in a kushor, but he would have like stupid slogans, like stupid Larry the Cable Guy shit written on it. God damn it. Is at least Tainan would go that far to draw attention to and be like, no, no, no, look how stupid the hat is.

Also, it was at that point too. Roy Harper got really into wearing like denim cutoffs. See, now somebody at DC is having a joke. Yeah.

That is exactly what that is. When did Roy Harper become a redneck? I missed that secret origin. I don't know.

I mean, they need to start like working that in like when Roy Harper, first of all, we're on her own pickup truck. Secondly, Roy Harper also when he's not like talking to anyone or like at the team, when he's in his car, he is listening to gut bucket country southern redneck rock. Yeah. But anyway, let's, this is the new character for him now.

This is the new lore. Yeah, he's a redneck now. The end. I could literally talk forever about how stupid that had his for Roy Harper.

Just how DC has treated Roy Harper so shilly for so many years. He's doing better now, but the hat still reminds me of all the bad shit. Yeah, don't forget. Yeah, exactly.

Roy Harper keeps trying to work in NASCAR, like trivia or tickets in every conversation. Did you catch? Did you catch? Turn hard fucking breaking his car.

I don't watch that show. I don't know. I only watch the newest NASCAR race. No.

No. Yeah. Well, Roy, I'm not interested in that. I propose that if you see when terrible redesigns, Starfire, not another look down.

Can we talk about how horribly objectificate like objectify? The thing about it is I was trying to go back and like look at other starfire costumes because I remember having a real when it came out and you're just like, what are you doing? And I was like, why does it just wear nothing? And just have like have fire over nipples.

And just have like a fiery vagina and she can just be called fire crotch. And it just ended. But like I went back and looked at all over costumes and they're all kind of objectifying. They're all kind of like, no, I just, I got a sweet bod and I want people to see it.

And it's like, first of all, right on. But secondly, what? It's a little weird. But I mean, you know, at least in like a Wolfman Perez era, she had a character that you could latch onto and could like end shit in the La Delle era.

And here's a horribly objectified costume and a nothing personality and a nothing character because I can't write women to save my life because apparently I have a real problem with women actually in life. That's the thing is that with when it comes to Starfire, if you can, we were just legitimizing where Harper's had it. I mean, like listen, he's a redneck. He's going to wear the baseball cap.

He's going to have, you know, a vest that's made of denim. Like it's going to be part of his character. He drives a pickup truck, which is also red and faded. The doors will not match the same color paint as the rest of the car.

You know, that kind of thing. At least then you understand that. He's only drinks and drives. Yeah, he does.

I read it. But with Starfire, it's just like she's hot. And in orange, I want to see her boobs, but they won't let me show them. So I'll show as much as I possibly can.

By the way, Mullage, Shali, I'm sorry about the pronunciation, man. That's just how I roll. The worst costume I've ever seen was Red Tornado. I didn't look at it.

How was it? Was it real bad? It was pretty ugly as the thing. Like it's funny.

That supergirl show is actually pretty hit and miss when it comes to costumes. Like their banshee is 100% comic accurate. You're like, wait, why does banshee look so good? They're like live wires?

Like, I can kind of see what you were doing. And then you get stuff like their Red Tornado where it's like, ooh, yeah. I've seen it. Okay.

I just looked it up. I was like, yeah. I mean, he looks like a rusty robot, but it's not with the crab. Even their Martians look better.

Their Martian manhunter and their Miss Martian actually look pretty good. Yes, I've seen their Martian manhunter. Yeah, Starfire. There's actually a trend of, hey, we got to redesign a female character.

Let's give her the most objectifying costume possible and not even like Link it with her character. Like, for example, I saw it on a lot of these lists and a lot of people have said it. Powergirls OG costume with the boo window. People have a real problem with that costume.

I respectfully disagree if I like Powergirls as a character. I disagree with the objectification thing. And I think that part of it, here's the thing. It very much is.

Okay? Like, you don't put a boo window into a female superhero's character like costume without saying, I want to look at these boobs. Oh, oh, the boo window is incredibly silly, but let's not forget to. The boo window probably saved her life when they destroyed the original Earth 2 and they only saved her in Huntress from it.

It's because they were pretty ladies and artists wanted to continue to draw pretty ladies. And I remember there being a long standing like kind of running gag within the DC Pantheon with the artist. That's true. Where they're like, hey, I bet I can make her boobs bigger in this issue and then they just keep making her boobs bigger.

Or even from the story standpoint where they would keep joking and retcon being like, well, what is the origin of the boo window? The one I always kind of liked was like, you know, I used to have a symbol here, but I don't anymore because I don't know what my place in the world is and it's to show that, you know, I don't know what I am type deal. No, I like, okay, so let's follow the rabbit hole a little bit when it comes to Powergirls and her origins or at least the her mental justification for costume. If it is her being like, I reject the house of Elle, I reject my origins as Superman, she rips the crest off of her outfit and instead exposes her femininity instead she's like, no, I own the fact that I am a superwoman.

That is what I am. I think they did that recently in the new Earth 2 book before that finished up. I think they did that because she was supergirl. But then she ripped off the symbol.

I think they did just the hat. I kind of take that and I can kind of argue the point of being kind of like pro feminism and kind of being like a feminist ideal, even though it also is like we're looking at her boobs. But like, I remember what's it called, Amanda Connors run on Powergirls, very much about her owning that design and her owning her being like, look, I want to wear this. I want to show it off.

That's what I'm doing. Like a good writer artist duo can make anything acceptable. I agree with that. So, or at least, well, I'll put an asterisk and almost anything.

And is Chatsaint 2 sex positive? Yes, exactly. She's like, no, like, listen, I got a great rack. I want to focus it or even if I don't want them to see it, like, I want to show off like, I am a woman.

This is how I identify as being a woman. Therefore, here's my here's my window. Or here's my symbol. Exactly, which is the absence of a symbol.

There's a lot to unpack with Powergirls. I think she gets unfairly maligned. A lot of people actually read some of the better work. They have put some thought into her.

She might not have begun as, you know, anything less than pure titillation, but I think she's become something more agreed. Agreed. But it's funny because there's a trend when it comes to, as we said, female redesigns and female costumes where it's like, I got like, either I'm going to either they have a terrible idea or straight up no idea. It's true.

It was a perfect example of that. The few. And there's only been a couple handful of times they've redesigned Wonder Woman's costume. Agreed.

Agreed. When it comes to Wonder Woman, there are fewer iconic, more iconic costumes. And when it comes to female superheroes, there are, she's second to none, then with Wonder Woman's costume. Yeah, I think it's one of those things where it's like, now guys, you hit it out of the park the first time.

Yeah, stop drilling, you hit oil. There's quite a few of those examples in this list. You'll hear me say it again and again. Wonder Woman's one of those words.

We nailed it. Sometimes she'll wear the bikini bottoms and sometimes she'll wear the skirt, but either way, the armor, the exposed shoulders, sometimes she'll get a cape, but most of the time she won't. It's merely decorative. But I do dig the cape for fancy formal affairs.

She's like, oh, I need to wear a cape. Exactly. I'm fine with that. But then there's Wonder Woman from the 70s where she just wore a disco full-body suit.

Because she was a mod. She was running a clothing store at that time and she didn't even have powers. Yeah, that's right. Actually, it's funny.

People talk about Wonder Woman. She's the only female superpowered hero for a long time. She was deep-powered for a surprising, long period of time. They basically made her a super spy.

They made her a Miss Peel who ran a clothing store by day and had boy troubles. I guess she was just inspired by, or the creators at the time were inspired by the Avengers show. Yep. Just like too bad because I'm one of the people who was like, man, the movie was really bad, but the show was really boring.

Also, every time I would catch the Avengers, I go, whoo! And then I'd be like, oh, it's not my Avengers. It's the boring and British ones. You got excited then, unexcited.

Yeah. But yeah, I mean, there's a mod costume. There's that 90s costume where they were like, give her a jacket. And hot pants.

Hot pants. Like, just show off those strong and Amazonian legs. And it's like, what are you doing right now? And even right before the New 52, they redesigned her again.

Let's give her a jacket and pants. And I remember that was like a really, like one of those like internet outrageous ones. I was like, I'm making a mountain out of a mole here. Oh my God, they gave her pants out there.

I remember the outrage about the pants and being like really kind of upset that so many people were against giving her pants. And in the end, that fucking matter because the New 52 happened and it all got dropped away. That was her design for the New 52, was Jack and Pants. And they were like, okay, what if we got rid of the pants?

We'll keep the jacket. And then what if we get rid of the jacket? And then what if we get rid of her entire New 52 origin? Yeah.

Yeah. One of my favorite holdovers from that is what is it, the original injustice gods among us in video game. That's one of the alternate skins that's in there. Is it really?

Yes, it is. Nice. Which made me think where it's like, oh, you can line up the production of this with the production of the New 52. And if they're like, no, no, we really want to push this new costume.

Yeah, I can believe it. I mean, I didn't think it looked bad. I thought it definitely made her look a lot older. Yeah.

Yeah. For whatever reason. Oh, it's like, oh, I'm wearing a sensible jacket and pants. Right.

Well, here's the thing. It's chilly. I must wear some kind of decent outfit. But yeah.

Did you freeze? Okay. Here's my carefully quiet. I was letting you talk.

Thank you. Apropos more DC terrible blunders. Can we talk about Booster Gold over to like, I've always, when I was growing up, I always hated Booster Gold's costume. And then doomsday broke it and he made me miss it by getting even worse costume.

Yeah. Yeah. He's had a couple bad runs, Amy. I mean, by the way, having being in the middle of rereading 52, I love Booster Gold's costume.

Oh, it's really nice. I really do. I always gold works well together. Yeah.

But I always thought it was totally lame. But like, I got to tell you, it's the context. It's the character Booster Gold would wear a costume like that. Of course, he would be loud and abrasive.

He's loud and abrasive anyway. Yeah. But hey, it's 1997. Let's give him some armor.

And don't forget that big dumb star and a silly ass mask. And like, what was it with the gambit mask that everybody was wearing? Where it's like, no, I'm going to put a sock, but just cut out the face. And keep my hair though.

I want my hair poofing out the top. Like Holly was such a trend-sender, the trend-setter there, Remy for a little bit. Now no one wants to dress like Amy. We're not even gambit dresses like gambit.

He doesn't. He's the only one who could pull it off. He's the only one who was like, that's totally lame. I'm glad you mentioned the armored look, too, because I think that's brought down many heroes in the 90s by like, you know, let's add a lot of stupid armor to it.

Cap had an ugly armor cost. Captain America's. Well, because I don't remember if this was the time when Captain America was like, drugs are bad. Apparently, Super Soldier Serum, that's like steroids.

So he got it expelled from his body. He's like, oh, I'm just tough. Or if it was the time when like, he just, he lost it. Or war the fuck off.

And in any case, he was like, he was weak. And then I remember who made him the suit. I want to say it was Iron Man, but I don't think that's right. But somebody made him like this big, stupid Captain America armor.

He looked like such a jackass. He didn't last very long, but like, it's still a, it's still a blight on the Captain America costume. That said, the Captain costume was pre-cut to him, that's him. That was pretty bad.

It's funny. At least the armor costumes, some people have a bit of nostalgia for it, because you'll still see Cap's armor costumes show off every so often. Like, what was it in the lead up to the last Secret Wars? Him and Iron Man had a fight.

And because like Steve was all old and she was like, oh, I'm gonna get my armor Captain America. I remember, he died in that armor. You did? Now that, that is a cool throwback.

I think people are a little less nostalgic for that than they are for the energy shield that Steve made for. Which by the way, every time it shows up in Agents of Shield, I go, oh, I'm surprised and delighted it's there. Works for Colson, didn't work for Cap. No, but I'm expected to see it in every Avengers movie at some point.

I'm like, where's the energy shield? But the fact that Colson has it, I'm like, I'm good, I'm in. Colson is such a fan. He's like, hey, I know this is from issue number 137.

Also, it's like, it's a shield. For she, you know, and man, the last time you used it was the best. He cut a robot map. That was really good.

But yeah, armor is, it's armor is, daradabble, let's talk about daradabble shitty armor. Yeah, I always liked it. Did you know? When I was growing up, I'm like, it came out, I'm like, this looks really cool.

It was 90s arrific, that's for sure. He's got the sharp that will hurt you shoulder pads. But I always kind of liked it. I was like, it's not too dissimilar from his regular costumes.

I think if they got rid of the like, sharp armor and they just kept it, if it was just black with red accents and it was a black towel with like the red neck thingy, I liked it. I always liked it. I thought it was cool. Which is more or less kind of what he's rocking now with the like, hey, we kind of split the difference between the TV show and daredevil as he stands right now.

When they debuted the Shadowland armor, I'm like, how is this any, how can you say this is cooler than the daredevil 90s armor? At least the 90s armor still comes back every so often. There was a great bit in one of the last issues where daredevil like he hit his head really hard and he was seeing like different versions of himself. So, hey, him in yellow, him in the arm or him in the Shadowland black suit and they were all talking to each other and they all like represented different sides of his personality.

Yeah, I read that issue. It was tight. Even 1602 daredevil was there too. The guy just went to cover his eye.

That's right. That's right. That was 1602 so good. Yeah, I'll still take his homework and that is just like how many alternate versions of daredevil can I put in here?

Exactly. No, I loved, I kind of dug daredevil's armor and the little like, yeah, I thought it was cool. I thought it works. At least to some degree.

I get that it was, here's thing, it was really weird. If you ever read Fall From Grace or just watch our episode of Backages on it? I did. It's, it comes out of nowhere and it's for no reason.

It needs to be some kind of reason. I remember when Spider-Man got his like steel armor. It was on the cover of the issue. It was like a hologram.

Not hologram, but at least a shiny like foil cover. And holographic as well. I think the holographic webs in the background. He has it for like I think maybe two pages and then it gets destroyed.

And it's just like, blow me. That sucks. Like that's not only did it look stupid, but it also didn't serve any plot point. It was just so that we could say that he had that probably so they could make the goddamn toy for it.

Oh, probably. As far as armored costume goes and this might surprise people, you know what I think the dumbest armored costume is? What? And it's to a character who arguably already had armor, but they put it in all the wrong places and they also changed his color scheme.

Yeah. People forget this suit, but Deathstroke back I think also in the 90s had an absolutely terrible redesigned suit where it was blue and he had like trash can lids on him. He looked like a big oboe. Yeah, check that out.

I'm putting in the chat and I'm putting it here for people to see so they don't think I'm absolutely crazy. Yes, he did. And man, does that suck. It really did because like again, the Deathstroke suit is pretty perfect.

You know, the orange and the black or sometimes it's orange and light blue depending on what arrow we're in. Yeah, for me, it's funny. I like, I always thought that the Deathstroke suit when I was when I first I was a kid, I thought it looked kind of like a mess. I was like, okay, so it's basically just Taskmaster or it's basically Captain America, but with like a Spider-Man mask.

And then the more I saw the more I grew, I mean, I kind of dug it. And especially because like the history of Deathstroke and how like the mystique of Deathstroke and how he works really kind of supersede the costume. It's like Dr. Dune.

Or it's like Dr. Dune's work at Toonik objectively speaking. It's kind of lame. Dune owns it and makes it work.

By the way, Aaron Lanatelli says, New to Do Green Arrow. Yeah, fuck that one. I don't remember that one. Which one he had like several.

There was the one he had when the books first started, which was literally just, hey, let's do the green arrow from Smallville. People remember that, right? That show hasn't been off forever. Let's take away his beard and let's give him some stupid doggles.

When you give your character doggles, that's okay, we're out of ideas for stuff to jush this up. Completely. No, I see it now. I completely remember this character design.

And I mean, like, yeah, it's basically just a hodgepodge of a bad idea and what they were doing on the show. Then they threw that away. Then Jeff Lemire came in and the book got good again. But the costume was literally just, can we kind of put him in what he's wearing right now on the show, but not really?

Yeah. And Lemire's like, fuck you. I will split the goddamn difference is what I will do. He'll kind of have his own thing going on, but he will look not dissimilar from the TV show.

Yeah. And they threw that away for DCU and they gave him like a Native American inspired costume. He had like moccasins and he had like armbands and stuff, which it didn't look bad. He actually had an arrow symbol on his chest for like the first time ever.

Yeah. Yeah. Man, there's nothing better than just him looking like Robin Hood. I don't like the hood.

I would rather wear the hat. I don't. Yeah. That's for me.

That's that's I enjoy the hood, but some of my favorite stories are him looking just like Robin Hood with a little hat. I want the arrow flint green arrow. It's hard to justify the arrow flint version, even though I think that's the best. I thought it was weird to giving him a bunch of Native American inspired gimmick.

It's like, dude, you're not even sort of Native American. Roy is sort of Native American. Yeah. And he's too busy looking like a jackass.

Yeah. And he's too busy looking like a redneck. I guess all he was just like, oh, my sake doesn't want this cool shing world. Take those moccasins.

I'll take this band. I'll take everything. That sucks. Apropos like overly complicated and stupid.

Like if any broke don't fix it designs. It was such a flash in the pan. It didn't really last that long, but enough for when the DC and Marvel crossover they had to put in there and cement it in forever. Thor's awful 90s gambit in the costume.

He watched as am and you're like, Thor's not the funny thing she's am and he looks like a goddamn jackass. With his armored crop top and too much blue and too much terrible hair. And his dumb sock face mask and his like and straps straps everywhere. No, this is so much cooler than the original Lee Kirby design.

Oh, yeah, way better. Yeah. I mean like, yeah, X-Men Orange's Tangerine says current Spider-Man with those super glowing eyes and Spider-Lago agreed. No, I hate it.

Moving on. But yeah, folks suck. I don't hate that stuff as much as you, but I understand it serves no like actual practical purpose. No, it's just it is literally cosmetic to the point where it's like, I just want to say we changed it.

It's new for new sake. It actually doesn't add anything. So much to the point other writers make fun of it. Yeah.

Well, it's as obvious and dumb as the organic webbing. Like what are you doing? Even the movie, they're like, he's got it. He's got it.

Cause they're trying to convey that it's like, no, it's advanced technology or a power shooting out of it. You know, in the movie, where's the exact same kind of suit and it looks like his regular Spider-Man costume. It's kind of like garbage. But Thor's history of bad redesigns.

Honestly, for me, like, cause we can talk about Thunder Strike and his ponytail. Oh yes. Another kind, DZorific. Yeah.

Like, I'm basically Thor, but I also have to wear this cool jacket and jeans. Like it's like, it's like, it's like, it's like, Grant Morrison's action comic Superman, but it's Thor. He's so extreme. If they ever said what happened to Thunder Strike is Thunder Strike dead in continuity or pinky costume.

I think he's dead. I don't remember. Cause if he weren't dead, they would bring him back. Like, they would be your own thing.

Cause like, I think Jason and everybody used him. I think so too. In fact, I'm waiting for Jason Aaron to drop the mic and be like, okay, so you don't like my Jane Foster, all you mouthy people on the internet. Well, guess what?

You know, they changed Thor once before this, right? Let me introduce you to Thunder Strike. You could have him right now. It's true.

I gotta say, Thunder Strike, like, the best Thor redesign that I remember having, you know, during my reading lifetime for Thor, was when he just had a beard. Now, that was Eric Masterson Thor basically just hiding in plain sight, but Thor the beard. That's cool. That works.

You want to give him a beard? Cool. In fact, it works. It works so much.

He has it in the MCU forever. And he also has it in the comics right now. So I think that's a good example of a good redesign. It's like, hey, go a little bit more medieval with my costume.

Get a little side cake, cut my hair, much like how Hemsworth is going to have in the new movie. And grow a beard out a little bit. I gotta say, no, Quapelle's redesign when they did the Jane Microshissitski Thor. That's like the best redesign you'll possibly do for Thor.

That's pretty definitive. That's a pretty good luck. Yeah. I even like Ultimate Thor redesign with like the six pauldrons and everything.

What's with Thor basically? It looks like Thunder Strike. I know. I know, right?

But it's the real Thor though. Yeah, but it's Thor. We have not yet. I mean, it's been almost 40 minutes.

We haven't talked about Batman. Oh, yeah, man. Batman. He's had some good years.

He's had some bad years. And I can't. We can talk about the 40s. We can talk about the silly stuff and the zirrenaur costumes.

But let's just stick to the stuff where it's like, no, we have to redesign. The Batman outfit is broken. We have to change it. How do you feel about the spiky shoulder pauldrons and the ridiculously long ear?

I always love it. But for me, it's funny. I don't consider it to be a redesign. So much as I consider it to be artistic expression.

I think that it's more like this is what Batman looks like in an idealized form. When Batman's punching criminals or riding in the Batwheel, you don't normally see the spikes. And the ears kind of get a little bit lower. I don't think it's much of a redesign as much as an artist being like, and he's got his cape being six miles long.

It isn't really that long. But because it's billowing in the wind, I want to convict motion. There's another guy who did that. I believe his name was Spawn who basically took those things and turned them up to 100.

Spawn is one of the best new designs of the 90s and of the last 10 years, or of its own decade, because damn does Spawn work. Despite the fact that it's literally just, can I get Spider-Man in some chains and a cape? Can I get Spider-Man Thor's cape and just make him have chains? Can I put Spider-Man, Ghost Rider, and Thor all in one thing?

Oh yeah, I can, and I can sell lots of them. Can I cheat every so often by just having him be 90% cape? Awesome. Yeah, and by the way, looks rad.

Compulom is bones. Just drawing big ass capes. I mean, that's awesome. You wouldn't have the new B2B2 run without Compulom's and badass spawn capes.

True. And by the way, Spawn with those shitty redesigns as well. Sure did. First Spawn costume, you stop drilling, you hit oil.

Wait, I could take more. Like how about if I get a big stupid anchor in the form of a spiky boot around one foot? We have to put it over on the other one. Well, no, then I would hit, then I would rub together.

Just one. And how about the cape is torn now? It's tatters. What?

Why would it be tattered? Isn't it alive? Fuck you, it's ripped now. Ooh, get rid of that really awesome mask you like.

How about instead we show your gross hamburger face and you stitch it together using a shoelace and we'll reference the fact that Batman cut it in half, but then we'll incontinuity say that he did it instead. What? What's that? Why am I reading Spawn anymore?

I gotta quit. That's basically it. You summed it up. I mean, yeah.

Medieval Spawn? Great design. I love Medieval Spawn. It was awesome.

Yeah, but anyway, we're talking about Batman. Yeah, I know where we got totally off topic. I mean, what did you think of Azriel Batman's costume? Batman 500, the first one.

The first new Batman costume. What do you mean back in the day or the new one they're just showing off now? Well, the new one. No, no.

The one back in the day. Like it debuts cover gold, bald, shoulder pads. Oh, I mean, in the 90s, I thought it was fucking sick as hell. But I grew up and I'm like, this is horribly busy and over-designed and perfectly symptomatic of everything that was wrong with the aesthetic of that time.

Yes. It was where I've almost come around and I'm ironically enjoying it now because it's so horrible. No, I agree. I thought it was sick as hell as well.

I was like, they closed the mouth. Holy shit, that's amazing. Then they give him like the arm spiky things, but on the legs. And the cape feeds into this cool, like, widow's peak on his chest.

There's a spotlight on his chest for some reason. Also knife fingers. No, they also drop the trunks. And a lot of it rocked until you realize it's a joke and making fun of an image.

That's what Kostada says now. I don't know if that was actually the back when he did it. No, I think the Batman, I think Nightfall and the decision to make Asriel and the Batman was, that was like Danielle and Neil and stuff being like, no, you don't want us to change Batman. They're basically saying that Kingdom Come was the distillation of everyone's opinion at DC about image and stuff.

But they're like, no, you don't want Batman to go away and be a killer and be like those monsters over there on the other side of the pond. It would be shitty. See? And then everyone would blow it and be like, no, stop lying.

Frequently asked questions

How long is this episode of Elseworlds Exchange?

This episode is 1 hour and 6 minutes long.

When was this Elseworlds Exchange episode published?

This episode was published on July 20, 2017.

Is there a transcript available for this episode?

Yes, a full transcript is available for this episode. You can read the complete transcript on the episode page.

Can I download this Elseworlds Exchange episode?

Yes. Use the download control on the episode player to save the publisher-provided media file.