Hello and welcome. You're listening to Fourth Estate, where we talk to journalists and journalism. We're coming to you from 2SER in Sydney on Gadigal Lands of the Eora Nation, right across Australia on the Community Radio Network, and directly to your device across the globe via the podcast. I'm Monica Atton.
Well, last week saw some pretty distressing news for journalism with the shuttering of Buzzfeed and Ten Daily. In both cases, it brought to an end not just two diverse and original voices in the domestic media space, but also what was meant to be the way forward with digital news made for digital natives. Buzzfeed was smart, direct, and free from the print legacy's way of thinking. Now, News Corp has announced hundreds of job losses to facilitate the company's restructure of its journalism output to go, believe it or not, digitally deeper.
In this edition, we are going to try to look forward, be constructive, but what lies ahead for digital news media. So I'm joined by Josh Butler, who until last week, when it was closed, was working at Ten Daily. He has an extensive career in the media, as for such a young age, including being editor at Huffington Post. He's been a news reporter at the Ila Wara Mercury, and he's also written for Junky.
Josh Butler, welcome to Fourth Estate. Returning to Fourth Estate, we have Saffron Howden. She is a journalist and co-founder of Quickly News. She started her career as a cadet journalist at AAP and has worked with Danny Telegraph and the Sydney Morning Herald.
She's also worked in regional media at the Northern Star on the New South Wales North Coast, and over the last couple of years, has gotten to know the regional news industry from a very different vantage point, while touring the country offering training through the Google News Initiative. And welcome to you, Saffron. Thanks, Naka. Well, the media has had a shocker of a year, and if you've been listening to Fourth Estate over the last few years, you'll know that recent years have not been too flash either.
And as we recorded, News Corp announced hundreds of new job losses. So why can't the media get a break from endless disruption and job losses? And dare I ask you this time, is there a way forward from this mess? And more importantly, is it close at hand?
Josh, let's start with you with someone recently employed at 10-Davy, which as we know it is no more. You worked there for over two years. What did it bring to the table in your view that was different? And are we upset about a guy just because there's been so much loss?
Look, I think what we brought to the table and what we started out with from the very start was, and I think everyone sort of says this, but we did try and do things a little bit differently. I mean, obviously when General Ten started a new website, obviously General Seven, General Nine, ABC, SBS, every other sort of major mainstream news channel. How do we have something had one for quite a while? So we started off with a website we knew we were kind of behind the eight ball a little bit, I guess so to speak.
So for us to kind of just try to do just straight news, just kind of like the making potato sort of vibe of the day-to-day news wasn't really going to work. So when we came in, we said, you know, part of the mission was we kind of had to try and do things a little bit differently. I think we did do that. We looked at an audience, you know, obviously, General Ten is kind of the always seen as a younger person, sort of audience, kind of 50 sort of network.
And that was the sort of audience we tried to cater to. We tried to look at an audience where people might not have been political junkies. They might not have read every single newspaper every single day and kept up with every single development of Parliament House and Global Affairs and that sort of thing. We tried to figure out a way that we could get people who weren't typically news junkies to care about and understand and want to read the news.
And I think that really, really, particularly, I mean, whenever I was writing for our audience, I'd try and think about, you know, how can I get someone who wants to know about property prices, who wants to know about what's happening in Syria or in Iraq or in, you know, parts of the world you don't really hear about too often, what's happening with petrol prices. And people who want to know this sort of stuff, but they're sort of intimidated by, you know, the way that maybe other big mainstream outlets sort of cover that sort of thing. And it's hard if you're an irregular news consumer to suddenly jump into the middle of the story about a developing scandal in politics or something. But what's curious is, I mean, Ten has a reputation for trying to do things a little differently and for appealing to a younger demographic, Ten only was kind of waiting right into that space and from what I gather, having a degree of success as well.
So it seems odd that when you're trying to penetrate a new market digitally, that you get the boot. Yeah, and it was, you know, a disappointing sort of announcement last week for all of us. And from what I know about what the decision was made and the last sort of thing, and you know, it's not really my place to kind of talk about all that sort of stuff. But we've been told that it was sort of a decision made from way high up of our sort of corporate owners in the US, which is, you know, CBS and Viacom.
And it's unfortunate. And we're always disappointed from what we've been told it wasn't a decision made on this side of the ocean, if you want to make. Yeah. So COVID-19, let's talk that a little bit, because it's, it's, it isn't just a wrecking ball for digital sites, newspapers, which were still in print mode, have been either closed or moved online.
So COVID is kind of doing what any number of previous financial shocks have failed to do and deliver pretty fatal blow. Is that how you see it, Saffron? Is COVID just accelerating? Is it a new force or is it just accelerating old problems?
Unfortunately, I think it is accelerating problems that pre existed COVID-19 and obviously a whole range of businesses across the spectrum have been affected by the pandemic. And news is one of them. And can I just say, Josh, I was devastated, by the way, to hear about the closure of 10 daily. And I'm really sorry for you personally.
I know it's difficult for so many working journalists at the moment. I think that we're definitely seeing the pandemic has sped up a process that had already started. You know, we'd already seen, for instance, last year the closure of, you know, some of the women news television bureau around, around the country or along the eastern seaboard. We'd already seen papers move to the digital space that were struggling already.
I think that the fact that it's happened so quickly, so many affected, so many communities and readers and audiences affected all at once is what has got us talking about it. And frankly, we should have been preparing better before this. But how do you prepare, so far? What does that look like?
Well, so we've known that news has been affected by, you know, a business model that wasn't functioning very well anymore. And I think we've been really, really, really focused on that. And all of the assistance that has gone on to news media organizations has been focused on finding the right business model. And I think what the pandemic has showed us is that news, particularly at that local level, is actually an essential service.
And, you know, if you look at it at times like the bushfires, we genuinely see journalists as providing an essential service. And I think we need to very rapidly move away from the idea that journalism needs to turn a significant profit in order to justify itself. Well, that's a bit problematic, isn't it? I mean, at the end of the day, journalists need to be paid.
It has to be journalism. It can't all be publicly owned or pay for. So, I'm not quite sure where you're heading with that. How would you, what kind of business model then, would be appropriate?
Well, I think we need to start looking much more at journalism as a not-for-profit operation. We've been, it's very hard for people to get their heads around this because for so many decades, news has made so much money through advertising. And it simply doesn't work anymore. And there's a work at a time like during a pandemic when obviously advertisers disappear, and then we're losing something that is so fundamental to our communities, and so fundamental to civil society, because it relies on a market that doesn't actually function anymore.
So apart from then, apart then from a move to give news media, you know, DGR status, where does that leave them? Where does that leave news media? How do you mean sorry? Well, if you're saying that we ought to be seeing it as a not-for-profit enterprise, I was assuming what you're talking about there is that should be, there should be some taxation structure that would assist news organizations.
Absolutely. So I think we need to fundamentally restructure the way we look at news. And I think we've probably also given the impact on local communities, there needs to be a much greater focus in the way we regulate and structured a news business on the local, independent-owned community-owned sort of structure. At the moment, there's sort of an assumption that media organizations are generally large, that they've got a fair bit of power behind them, a fair bit of financial resources.
It's not the case anymore. I mean, one really hardening thing that we're seeing coming up this pandemic is we've had a range of new news outlets which are locally owned, open up around Victoria and New South Wales and South Australia, as we've got new newspapers in our act and Southern Highlands in Portia, in Narracort. And these, unless we sort of assist them with structural changes, it's going to make it difficult for them to survive in the long term because our entire system is set up to deal with large media companies, like News Corp, like Nine, like Seven, very large organizations that got teams of, you know, they've got legal teams and commercial teams, these smaller operations and public interest journalism operations which are essential to our communities. They don't have that and the system doesn't currently support them.
It's interesting, isn't it? I mean, so would you see those kinds of organizations also being remaining somewhat reliant on advertising? Well, do you think that we'll see a move away from the traditional reliance on advertising that we've had in News Media, Saphron? Well, we're definitely seeing a move away from advertising as a, you know, sort of underwriting of the business model for journalism.
There's no doubt about that. I think they're probably particularly at a local level. They'll always be a space for some advertising. I mean, you've still got that basic idea that, you know, advertisers and I'm thinking about a local community here, they want to get in front of people and the way to do that is to take their brand to where people want to be, which is finding out about, you know, their local community news.
So I think there'll always be that, but I think it's going to be a much, much, much smaller part of it. You've also, by the way, I'm not suggesting that, you know, news organizations should be all not for profit. I think you can mix it up. You can have a little bit of advertising.
You can have a little bit of subscriptions and I think you definitely need to start pursuing much more very quickly and more rigorously than not for profit model for news. And we've got to make it a lot easier for news organizations to be able to register for that. So Josh, is there a lesson here for digital media that if your business model is advertising reliant, you don't have much of a business model? Yeah, I've been thinking about this for a long time.
And obviously in the last couple of weeks, it's, I've had a lot more pause to think about this sort of thing. It's hard because I always look at this, I'm going to say I was expert and I don't know anything about media sales and advertising and that sort of thing. But for me, it seems like, you know, those rivers of gold have classified them in newspapers dried up, you know, 10 years ago when somebody invented cars, guide and domain and eBay and gum drink and what sort of thing. And we still haven't figured out how to make money out of news yet.
And it still seems that so much of advertising departments and sales teams and so on trying to sell McDonald's and add as your banner on your website. I think that that point that you made this effort about, you know, that diversification of that business model is really interesting. I'm not sure if anyone really here in Australia has really hit that nail on the head yet. I mean, I've been thinking a lot about whether news organizations might need to be funded by some sort of wealthy benefactor or have some sort of charitable trust or something behind them, like something like the Guardian sort of model where they have, you know, that they pull a lot of money out of this sort of wealthy benefactor at some point.
I mean, I'm not sure if I don't know how to go. It's very complex road. That's a whole different argument, I guess, in itself. But I mean, maybe there's some room for a bit of everything, you know, sort of cherry picking from a few different buckets.
I mean, I don't have a lot of faith in this idea of, you know, trying to get Google and Facebook to cough up their advertising money. I don't think that's going to be the road out of this. But maybe there's a bit of that. Maybe it's a bit of, you know, a bit of charity.
Maybe it's a bit of government grace. Maybe it's a bit of, you know, getting people to subscribe. Maybe it's a bit of this sort of freemium sort of model where you get, you know, five articles, three a month, get paid for that. Maybe it's a bit of, you know, you subscribe, you know, micros or transactions where you pay like 10 cents or 50 cents for an article at a time.
I don't think anyone's sort of hit this model yet. I think it has to be a bit of everything. I'm not sure. Okay.
So let's talk about subscriptions for a moment because taxation breaks aside. Certainly the legacy media that has spent a lot of time and money pivoting to digital prior to COVID. I would have slightly better position though, as we've seen of course this morning and use copper are cutting. But so from do you see the future of digital news media as being, at least in part, in some parts, subscription based?
Look, I think there's a place for that. I think we do have to grapple with the fact that we need journalism for democracy to function effectively. And they will, in order for that for journalism to play that role, there needs to be some journalism that is freely available. And that's because not everyone can afford subscriptions.
And yet they still deserve to get information about, you know, their local elections and what's happening in their local community and during a pandemic, you know, where to get your local COVID test if you need it and that kind of thing. So I think subscriptions have a role to play. I think the Guardian model that Josh has mentioned is very interesting. I don't think it works for every news organization, but I think you could probably do something with that at local level as well, where you've got people committing funds who can afford it in the local community, knowing that not everyone can.
And then you've also got that mix that we've just talked about. So I think there are different ways to tackle it and the idea of sort of one hard, you know, paywall is probably not the definitely not the only option and certainly not one I'd be consuming at the moment. No, and paywalls are of course a particular problem for younger consumers because they tend to not be able to not be able to afford subscriptions. Josh, do you see that as an issue?
Yeah, that's an interesting question. And I think it's definitely one that people do bulk out. I mean, it's not just younger audiences. I mean, you know, I think there is a bit of a sort of vibe here in Australia that people aren't really that willing to subscribe to news organizations just, I mean, you know, even just this week, I saw a very respected figure in the media, how about someone Twitter because they share an article behind the paywall.
And while you share an article, the description to view and that sort of thing, I think it's really that sort of reticence to jump on and pay for news. But at the same time, I don't necessarily agree that young people especially might not be into that because I mean, I know that myself as a young person, I subscribe to Netflix and to stand and to Spotify and to a few other things that cost 12 bucks a month or something like that. And I don't think a lot of news organizations even charge that much. So I mean, what's kind of what's more important to you, whether you want to pay for a Spotify, you want to pay for, you know, having access to news about the day and the world in your country and your local community and that sort of thing, I'm not sure what that sort of disconnect is about yet.
Maybe it's just that we as a news media haven't made the case to Australians that news should be paid for. I mean, obviously people pay for newspaper newspapers and that sort of thing you pay a dollar or $2 or $3 or whatever it is for the paper every day. But people still want to get the news free on the internet. I think that just goes online on the computer that should be free.
Yes. Well, why have we failed in that? I mean, that argument has been mounted and that case has been pressed for several years now. Why is it that we have not been able to convince Australians that journalism is not free and should not be free and can't be free?
I have no answer to that question. I actually have none because, you know, obviously large flagship papers in the US you think about in your Times and the Wall Street Journal and Washington Post and that sort of thing. They're growing their audience. They're growing their subscription numbers to many hundreds of thousands and they're making a lot of money out of those sort of things.
And because they've got this, you know, locked the inscription base, they know that even when advertising dollars fall or whatever, you know, some, the pandemic hits, they're insulated against that sort of stuff to a certain degree because not their eggs aren't all the same basket. So, I don't know what it is in Australia. Is it in part that Australia media has not been prepared until quite recently to take a stand against the big platforms, the Googles and the Facebooks? I mean, it's a time for media that media actually left the dance floor and stepped and stopped making free content for them, locking down behind a paywall, regardless of what happens in July when the ACCC hands down its mandatory code to make the platforms pay for what they use.
Yeah, look, I think there's a few things at work in terms of, you know, people basically educating the white above link about how and news consumers about how important journalism is and why you might want to pay for it or, you know, you know, God forbid, why journalists might actually be need to pay to salary so that they can pay their bills and eat. I think Australia is in a, you know, somewhat in excessation, definitely different from the states in that we have a really small population and so it's a really small news media market. And one of the things I came across when I started Quinkley News as a completely independent player who had no competition is that I realized it was, it was, we were able to get people from all the different media organisations into the room at the same time to talk about something which benefited them, which is so unusual. So, because we've got this really small audience, all the big media organisations in Australia have spent decades competing with one another.
And so it's much easier to, you know, drive a wedge and say, oh, you know, a news call to that, therefore come to us or, you know, Fairfax is terrible, come to us or, you know, Seven's terrible, come to Nine, then it is to work together because everyone's competing for small numbers and each audience member matters in order to make sure you're keeping making money for your business. So I think that's really affected our ability to work together as an industry in Australia because of those old rivalries, which are basically commercial rivalries that were built down into the editorial, unfortunately as well. I mean, when I tweeted last night about the news call, Job Losses, the responses I got from Twitter, people talking about how basically anyone who worked for Murdoch deserved to lose their jobs was, no, no, no, phenomenal. And shows a really, you know, serious lack of understanding of how journalism works, which brings me to my next point, which is that I think journalists have, the industry has sort of taken its audience for granted until very recently.
And we've never really explained how journalism works, why it's important, how it's put together. One of my favourite anecdotes is when I was having a conversation with an ABC TV reporter one day. And we were talking about how no one understands journalism. And she said, oh yeah, I went to interview this guy, you know, as part of the story I was doing, you know, and I had all the research to do and then I had to go to three different locations across Sydney to interview people.
He was one of the people I was interviewing. And he said to me, you know, oh, so how many stories do you normally produce in a day? And she said, oh, one. And so what do you do with the rest of your day?
Any journalist who hears that story knows how ridiculous it is to try and fit two television stories into one day. Yes, yes. And a former presenter of Media Watch, who was often accused of taking a whole weekly wage to produce 15 minutes of television. I'm totally sympathetic.
Yes. So I think we've got a lot of work to do to bring people along with this story and to remind them of actually how it is a fourth estate, you know, that it is actually really important. And we're starting to see that understanding appear quite rapidly when local newspapers have shut down during the pandemic because local communities are only going, oh, hang on, I never bought it, but I still want you there. I went to the local cafe.
I don't want you to stop printing. And people are realizing it matters. And the final thing I'd say, and this is obviously something that I'm personally very passionate about and worked on a lot is media literacy. And that ties into that is understanding better how media works and how it's made up and how to better navigate it.
And I think that that needs to start right down at a young age in our education system. Mm-hmm. Now, I wonder also whether another piece of the puzzle going forward is the possibility that individual journalists will just increasingly strike out on their own. Josh, I wonder whether you see that the individual journalists might put themselves out in front of a small nimble targeted news audience out of the shadows of the big institutional players relying on their own wiles.
You know, Michael West, for example, one vocal example, he was made redundant by the Fairfax Media, then the Fairfax Media Organization. He writes a very successful business focus journalism blog, stroke website, has a small but committed paying audience. Is that a new model to get excited about now? Look, I think it is a new model.
And it's something for some people that excited about it. I don't think it is a sustainable model for hundreds of journalists. I mean, I look at a lot of journalism in the US and there are a number of journalism in the US with a population of 300 million where you can do that. You have a big enough population where if you have a blog or a Patreon or a newsletter or a sub-stack or some sort of personal website that you're charging people a dollar a week or 10 bucks a week, you can make a bit of money out of it.
If you're a reporter, as you mentioned, Michael West, if you're a person who's really interested in very deep, complex financial reporting, there might be enough of an audience for you there. If you're really interested in climate change reporting or a certain topic sports or whatever it is, you might be able to get a small audience. But I don't know if there's enough of an audience here in Australia that dozens or hundreds of journalists could make a living out of that. And again, it comes back to the same idea of how do you get people to pay for your website, how do you get people to subscribe to it at 10 bucks a week or how do you get people to subscribe to it at $1 per newsletter edition or something like that.
I think it's a really interesting model. I think you will see it a lot more because there are a lot of companies that are starting to exactly build this sort of model. Like myself, I do a daily or daily enough newsletter on coronavirus. It's all about stats and misinformation and facts and he's a few stories of the day for people who don't have hours and hours to read every single story on the internet.
But even that, I mean, I have a couple of hundred subscribers and that's great. But I don't think I'd ever get to a point where that could be my main income. I mean, it might supplement some income for people who have freelancers or people who work for the casual jobs at certain outlets or whatever it is. But I think it's really interesting.
I think you'll see a lot more of that in coming years. I just don't think it's going to be anywhere near enough to, I guess, supplant the model of journalism that we kind of have right now and that we're seeming to be losing right now. That's right. Now, you can see it working in the United States.
Here's a function of population. But if all the redundant journalists either go out on their own or even band together, get funding, move forward, produce public interest journalism. Is that from? Were they in audience for that?
Definitely. I think there's, I don't know if you both saw the news or if the listeners saw the news earlier this week out of New Zealand about the CEO buying stuff. Yes, I do see that. And looking at buying from the journalists themselves so that they actually have a stake in the company, I'm watching this with absolute fascination.
I think one of the lessons I learned from Crinkley News is that journalists produce fantastic journalism. They're not business people. And you definitely need to get those expertise in to make sure everything's functioning in the background. But I would love to see some more of this sitting alongside and maybe even part of the community-owned model and and model.
And I'm thinking particularly obviously about local and regional news here, to have ownership by the people working for the news outlet. I think that would be a really interesting model to start pursuing. And I agree with Josh that I think Michael West is an exception rather than the wall. There are some, there are other, he's not the only one in Australia.
There are some exceptions. But the audience is just too small in Australia to allow too many journalists to do that. Okay. So you always need to fall for state on the community radio network and podcast around the world.
Our guests this week are Josh Bucklet and Saffron Houghton. Let's end our discussion on a note that reminds us of the power of media and also of traditional newspapers as it turns out. This week the New York Times made a country and indeed the world take note as its entire front page was filled with the names of the American victims of the COVID-19 pandemic. Saffron what did you think when you saw that front page which on mobile was this scrolling list of COVID victims with just a line about what they contributed to the world.
How powerful was that? Incredibly. I mean I think a lot of people saw that and there was a lot of discussion about a lot of sharing of it over social media. It was a really powerful and unique way to tell this story.
One of the things that had got me thinking about is that how coronavirus has been such a story about numbers. And it's been really difficult for journalists to get out there and do to speak directly to people. So so much of the pandemic has been told using graphs and numbers and figures. And of course numbers can be incredibly powerful but we do it has been difficult to get into the human stories.
I mean we've had a bit of coverage of particularly health workers I guess and that's been really difficult for news for reporters to get because you've got to go into hospitals and it's been difficult. And so seeing all those names in one place like that I think the reason it was so powerful is because it reminded us that behind all those figures were all of these actual people with relatives and moms and dads and siblings and children and yeah phenomenal. And Josh it wasn't in part as well the New York Times do you think saying you know the United States does not have a president capable of leading morally through the crisis. His leadership is incoherent.
So we will more than that. We will do what our government has failed to do. I think at the really interesting point I hadn't really considered it but I think absolutely I mean so even here I mean we hear so much about you know oh you know so many people diver you from the flu or diver you from car crashes or it's not that thing of a deal you know people die all the time but as you said there's stuff I mean it shows that there are stories behind these people they do have interest they are regular normal people just like others are just because of the spreadsheet. But that is a really point that you make them money for I mean this is the fact that so many of these deaths I mean just today the US hit 100 deaths and that is just astronomical and it's like mind-boggling you can't really put that into your head you think about it you know the mcj full of people that that's the work we're talking about.
And like you say I mean so much of us have been waves way but I don't like Trump just sort of saying you know even weeks ago he's going oh it'll be a miracle cure and it'll be over by Chris by beaster and it'll be totally fine everyone should open back up and don't worry about it and US is stronger than ever and a lot sort of thing. It also goes I think just to show you know we've been talking doom and gloom about the media today but I think it goes to show just how much of an impact and how much people still do consider what goes on the front page of a newspaper life in New York Times to be important. It is a statement it is a time and place in the world and I think you know that will be one of those front pages that we look back on maybe in 50 years or one of those things to go wow that was a moment in time like it'll be one of those ones maybe on par with like the moon landing for front pages or you know war in Iraq or front page or Barack Obama elected front pages will be in I guess that's sort of a maybe I think it's too lawfully about how people look back on the news in 50 years time but I think we will look back on that sort of front page and go that was wow that was really something that was like a line in the sense at a moment. Fantastic okay thank you both very very much for talking to us today I really appreciate your time.
Thank you. And thanks for listening to the Fourth Estate. This edition comes to you from the studios of 2SER and it's heard across the country on the community radio network. Fourth Estate is produced with the assistance of the community broadcasting foundation thanks to the foundation for their continuing support.
Make sure you're subscribed to Fourth Estate on your favorite podcast app so that you can hear us talk about media, politics and all things in between. We'll be back with more next week but in the meantime you can stay in touch with us on Twitter. Our handle there is Fourth Estate and thanks to my producer Anthony Dohill. My name is Monica Atard.
Thank you for listening.