This is the Value Investor Podcast with Tracy Rinek, all things value all the time. Welcome back value investors. So I'm sure you're wondering what happened to last week's Value Investor Podcast because there wasn't one. But I did record something last week and was all ready to put it out, but then we had Liberation Day on the day I recorded it and the stock market sold off.
And a lot of what I discussed on that podcast, which was on the Price to Sales ratio, kind of was irrelevant even after just two days. So I decided not to put it out because it would require explaining a lot in the article, but then the people listening to the podcast would be like, this is old, this isn't even happening anymore. So I kind of put it up to the podcast that were before Liberation Day and now those that are coming after. And that one happened to be recorded right on Liberation Day.
So it got kind of messed up. So if you're wondering like, Hey, where's the Value Investor? I need to hear something about value stocks right now with everything going on. That is what happened.
I didn't forget you. It's just that I thought it wasn't probably as relevant anymore. And I try to keep all of our discussions here about value stocks as relevant as I can every week. So I'm pivoting away from the price to sales.
We'll get back to that a little bit later when some more stability shows up in the market because it is extremely volatile still. We've had big sell-offs and now we're having a big rally as I'm recording this again on April 9th. This was the day when the reciprocal tariffs went on at midnight on this day, but they've already been paused. I guess that's the word you should use, paused for 90 days on everyone except China.
They are keeping the 10% base tariff on everyone, but any of the other larger reciprocal tariffs are paused. The stock market loves this. Yes, it only wants to pause. It doesn't want the tariffs.
So everything is soaring and that's where we stand. But I did want to talk about one area that's been beaten up really badly in the last month or so. But even last year, it wasn't all that great, but certainly in the last month. And that is the energy stocks.
I'm back to looking at whether or not their values or traps because the energy stocks have sold off quite a bit here in 2025. It's been one of the worst performing of the sectors. And that says a lot because again, it wasn't that great last year either. So these look kind of cheap.
And by energy, I'm not talking about alternative. I'm talking about oil and natural gas, right? And so should you be thinking about these? Are they really cheap or are they traps?
I think you kind of know where I'm going because crude was trading under $60. I'm not quite sure. I'm recording this where it is right now. It's probably rallying to along with the stock market.
But even at crude at 60, this is WTI or even anything under 65, it gets a little dicey with almost all of the producers. Some are a little more efficient in their execution and have a much lower kind of break even level of say $40 to $45. Some it's much higher. I've seen it as high as $77 for Saudi Aramco.
And again, we're in the 60s. So that's not not too good over there for Saudi Aramco if that's correct information. But the suffice is to say, anytime it goes under 60, which we were for a couple of days, not for very long so far as I'm recording this again on April 9th, then things get a little more dicey for the energy stacks. And they usually do start to sell off.
Also, if you think a recession is coming and a big trade war between the two largest economies, the United States and China, you may not want to own energy as well, right? Because energy doesn't do well in recessions. The earnings do decline. And so we do have a sell off usually in the stacks then.
But another thing to keep in mind. I know I mentioned this before when we've talked about energy, but now it's relevant again because the earnings estimates are on the decline again. But the analysts are always behind on energy when the price of either oil or natural gas is falling, quite considerably when it's falling. The analysts are kind of a wait and see and will wait for the next earnings report.
And then the company will tell us and then we'll cut our estimates, even if the price goes from 80 to 65. And we all know that the earnings are going to be more dicey by declining that much. They still kind of hesitate in the energy complex because it is volatile. I mean, I'm sitting here talking about how WTI was at 56, 57.
And now it might be at 60, 62, 63 in the span of 24 hours. So most analysts are not in this kind of environment going to be moving quickly to be cutting when there's all this uncertainty that's out there. They're willing to wait. But that means when these earnings reports come in at the end of April, beginning of May, then they're going to be cutting again.
And a lot of them have been cutting. But I want to take a closer look at three of the big cap stocks. And I am including big oil here because a lot of people have been hiding out in big oil. We usually avoid big oil because it's a little bit different animal than just the pure play, explorer and producers, commonly called the ease and peas.
Those are just going out there, just drilling, getting it out of the ground and selling it. Big oil includes drilling, getting it out of the ground, but also refining it. They might own refineries. They also may have petrochemical plants where they're turning it into chemicals and selling that.
And they may also have bulk distribution terminals and then service stations, right? The gasoline stations themselves. So it's like a full customer service. Let's say on everything oil and natural gas happens a lot with big oil.
So it's a little bit different because refining might be doing well with good crack spread, but actual getting it out of the ground side might not be that good. Gasoline prices may be high. They're getting a good profit off of the gasoline at the service stations. And heck, they might even have convenience stores associated with those service stations and that aspect of the business is doing well.
So on the chemical side, if the economy is doing well, chemicals are leading indicator for the economy and they may have some pricing power in there and demand to make go up and they're seeing quite nice margins and cash flows on the chemical side. So there's a lot in the air with the big oil. Also big oil tends to be international. So we're going to have more in play with geopolitical issues and some of these that I'm going to talk about today have that.
But I'm also bringing you one of the big US ENPs that I want to look at just to kind of see what the difference was with the big oil earnings estimates versus just the pure play. We're getting it out of the ground. Now the pure plays usually move much more in tandem with the price of oil and natural gas and mostly oil. So now that we've seen it fall below 60, the stocks are going to reflect that with the ENPs.
And remember some of the big ENPs, you know, mostly in the Permian are going to be the big guys by other areas around the United States, including in Colorado, Pennsylvania, some of those shale plays up there. And so it's not all about Permian, but that's a big factor. But we got a lot of big oil in the Permian now too. So without further ado, let's dive right in.
And I do want to start with Exxon. ExxonMobil, ticker, XOM, a lot of people hanging out in this one. And the stock has not really been breaking down as much as I would have liked. I used to own it in the Zex Value Investor and my own personal portfolio, but we did sell a lot of it last year because oil prices were expected to fall this year.
And I knew the stock would get cheaper. There wasn't really a reason to be holding it at that time because I did think we could get it in much cheaper later. And so far that is turning out to be the case, but I would not have predicted a trade war. It would make it so much cheaper.
But here we are. So ExxonMobil, PE of 14.1, but I do caution you on the PE's that they actually are a little elevated right now because the estimates are being cut. And so we have declining estimates. The share prices were holding up until basically until April here.
And now they have started to pull back a bit. But because of that combination, the PE's are a little more elevated. So 14.1, you would really get this really dirt cheap if it was to say under 10 on the PE. But we're not there yet.
Peg ratio of just 2.8, so that's not so great. But you do get that nice dividend with these big oil companies and they have been paying them throughout everything with pandemics, recessions, everything going on. Dividend yielding 3.9% right now for Exxon. That's pretty juicy, almost at 4%.
That's $3.96 a share. So what is 2025 looking like? We have one estimate higher and two are lower in the last seven days. So that kind of goes into the face of what I was saying, right?
About, oh, those analysts, they're not going to do anything until they report. Well, with Exxon, it's a little different story. They are doing something here with Exxon. But that's pretty interesting.
But this is right when we've seen the price of crude fall in the last seven days. Also OPEC plus has increased production in those last seven days. So all of this is happening at the same time. So more oil coming on the market.
So some of the analysts are like, you know what? There's too much going on here. We're going to move and take some action. But one is higher and just too lower.
So we're looking for 7.13 now for the year. That's down from 7.22 in the last seven days. So the two lower are winning there. So they cut a little bit more, but 90 days ago, so 30 or three months ago, analysts were looking for 770.
So they have been slowly bringing it down. And if you look at the price of consensus chart on sex.com, which is one of my favorite charts, you will see those lines for 2025 and 2026 going down into the right. Instead of up into the right. And that is indications that, you know, the analysts are getting more bearish, but not surprising because we now have Brent in the low 60s and WTI under 60, at least before this recent rally, but it's hanging out in an area that means lower earnings.
Now, this is an earnings decline of 8.5% from last year when they made 7.79. So not terrible, but it isn't earnings decline. But if we see crude, you know, going down to the dreaded $50 level or below, which is really equivalent to, you know, $30 to $40 from even five or six years ago, inflation adjusted, we all still kind of thinking back even 10 years ago, like, oh, $30, that's terrible. But it would be even worse now, because even now $50 is the new 30 and 60 is the new 40, really.
I'm surprised a lot of these companies are able to keep their break even as low as they are, given rising costs, you know, they have rising wages and labor costs and all this other stuff, too, that they have to price in there. And yet they're still able to do it at those lower levels. This is still a decline of 8.5%. And as I said, it's still pretty difficult time for the energy complex.
And a lot of the momentum is still pushing to get closer down towards that $50 level. I'm not sure if we'll get there, but in a recession, we could definitely get there. And the energy market is pricing it in already. So Exxon is a Zacks number four rank, actually.
It is already a sell because of these two estimates lower in the last seven days that is taking precedence over the one that's higher. And they are looking at that, the Zacks rank and saying, man, this is looking a little bearish here suddenly. So we're giving it a four. Now they report earnings on May 2nd.
So we're going to hear in a couple of weeks what's really going on, but year to date, the shares down 1.2%. And this is before any kind of rally. Five days, it's now, no, I did look at this after the rally is going on. So five days, it's down, but only about around 7% now because it is getting a nice little rally here on April 9th.
And we'll see if this holds. But it was down about 10, 10, 11% before this rally. So you are getting it a bit cheaper here, but it hasn't broken down. Like some of the E and piece have, you know what the ones I'm talking about, the small cap E and piece are down 30 or 40% in just the last week.
So that's where you're really seeing the hammering happening. And not so much in these big oil ones because these are considered like placed to hide out in and you get these dividends. So that's Exxon XOM. I still do consider Exxon to be one of the premier of the big oils.
And the reason I do like it is because they're in Guiana and that is a huge drilling prospect and opportunity there. And they were first, one of the first in. So I'm liking that they have that. They also did buy Pioneer Natural Resources.
So they do have a huge exposure in the Permian as well. But Permian appears to be slowing. And so you got to be looking elsewhere. And Exxon is so I like it for that reason.
Also, large chemical business. Also quite a bit on natural gas side. So Exxon's the full package ticker XOM again. Okay, our next one is Chevron.
Got to go with the other guys, right? CVX. CS and Charles, V is in Victor X. And this story kind of similar to Exxon, PE of 13.3.
It has a better peg, peg of 1.3. What are the analysts doing? One is lower in the last seven days. Nobody has raised here.
Only one lower. Three are actually lower in the 30 day period. There were a couple lower on Exxon in the 30 days as well. But we're looking for $10.30, $10.30 versus $10.79 just 30 days ago.
So similar to Exxon, the price of consensus is down into the right, just like Exxon. It's starting to pressure it lower. It was 11.35, 90 days ago. So we're down almost a dollar in the last three months on Chevron's earnings estimates for this year.
That is still earnings growth though. Earnings growth of 2.5% because they made $10.05 last year. And so that's a little bit different the next one. This one, bigger dividend.
They've always paid the bigger dividend. And now that the shares are a little weaker, it's even juicier. It's 5% yield now, 5% for owning Chevron, $6.84. And I'm putting out there the actual amount that you're getting that's annual because I always tell people look at what they're making, make sure they can cover that dividend.
Although Exxon Chevron have been very consistent that even if they can't cover it because of what's happening in the oil markets, they will still cover it for at least a while. They haven't even during the pandemic. And when oil went negative, they still had dividends. So that's very impressive.
And they're very shareholder friendly. And they know that these dividends are why people are owning their stocks. So Chevron's a number three because it's not quite as bearish as what Exxon is looking at right here. And this one year to date, it is down but basically flat.
It's down but only 0.07. So it's holding on. That's what I mean about these being a place to hide out. Five days, it's down 8.85.
And that includes today's really super big update. Next earnings reported is on the same day as Exxon. They like hanging out together on May 2nd. Also Chevron, it's trying to acquire Hess.
Remember that deal? That was from last year. Or is it even longer now? I didn't even be longer now.
I think it was still last year. That hasn't gone through because Hess is a partner in the Guyana site. And they have, Exxon has a first refusal for any deal down there. And they're exercising it.
And they're trying to block Chevron from purchasing Hess and then getting access to Guyana. So we'll see how that turns out. They've been fighting about it for a while. They're in court, all that stuff.
And so we're waiting on that. But Chevron, ticker CVX got that 5% dividend. So maybe hanging out in there for a little while. I don't know.
We'll see. And I'm only going to do one stock on the EMP side. I mean, you could do, there's many options. And I'm sticking with one of the big market cap companies because if I'm going to go for big oil and look at these ones over $200 billion, I don't want to suddenly do a regular producer who is $5 billion or something or even less.
So we're sticking with big guys and we're going with EOG resources. Ticker EOG, this is one of my favorites in 2022 when we had rising natural gas and oil prices because of the Ukraine-Russia war. And EOG just very solid on being shareholder friendly and wanting to give any kind of cash flows back to the shareholders, very good management market cap of $57.9 billion. That is considered big for a pure play producer, by the way, especially now that Pioneer is gone.
Pioneer was the largest. Now EOG resources, one of the largest PE on this one of 9.5. So that is considerably cheaper. But that is reflected in what's going on with the stock price.
Year to date, stock price is down 7.5%. And over the last five days down 7.1, but that reflects this sudden rally on the 90-day pause on a lot of the reciprocal tariffs. And it's up almost 8% on this day. So we would have been down 15% over the last five days here.
So you can see the difference in the volatility. You will get whipped around a lot more if oil is going up or moving down in sharp swings than so will these stacks. So have a strong stomach if you're going to be in these pure play E and piece. The peg ratio on this one, 7.3, that is way up there, 7.3.
And they pay a dividend as well, which they just raised 7%. And it's 3.7% on the yield or $3.90 a share. And I've been warning people on stock tweets and even on blue sky and Twitter about what might happen with the dividends with some of these pure play companies because they are just so dependent on the price of oil. They are not hedged.
And if oil were to go even at 55 or certainly at 50, some companies, not all, some companies would likely have to cut their dividend. So keep that in mind. You can't give out what you're not bringing in and at $50. That's very difficult market conditions for these E and piece being unhedged.
So keep that in mind. But I was surprised when I was researching EOG resources, even though I know they have the great balance sheet and I know their shareholder focused, but they have already dedicated and made a commitment for how much they're returning to shareholders for next year. And they put out a three year scenario as well about what free cash flow may look like depending on the different prices of oil for those three years. They have grown their dividend and raised it for 27 years now.
So that's pretty impressive. I think that's a seven 27 years. Either way, that's covering a lot of changes in the energy group. So I'm loving that commitment.
Here's some data on what they have done with the free cash flow. So they are obviously dedicated to having a regular dividend and then above that, they will do more than they're also doing share buybacks. In 2024, they had $5.4 billion in free cash flow. That's huge.
98% of it or 5.3 billion to shareholders. That's also huge. Most aren't doing that. They have a minimum of 70% though going back to the shareholders, but this is way higher.
So they're trying to keep you around. And last year on the share repurchases part of that giving back to shareholders, they raised it a bit end, but they also bought back the shares at an average of $123 a share for 2024. But now the shares have declined. So it's a good buying opportunity.
They were at 106 when I was preparing for this podcast. Now at 113, but that's still well under what they bought the average price last year. So are they buying here? I don't know.
We don't know, but it would be a good opportunity for their share repurchase program for them to be getting at these much cheaper prices. So what does the $5.4 billion look like compared to some of the other more normal years when the price of oil wasn't so high? So in 2022, where it did start to spike up from the Ukraine and Russia war, it was $5.1 billion. But 2021, when we were just coming out of the pandemic still, it was $2.7 billion was the free cash flow and the year of the pandemic, when oil went negative and then rebounded pretty swiftly.
But only after the COVID vaccine was announced in November, that's when oil really started to rally, then they only returned $0.8 billion. So not even $1 billion there, $800 million, they returned in 2020. Still decent free cash flow there. And you can see the growth there in what they're giving back.
So what have they said for 2025? So they have committed $2.2 billion for 2025. And they did say that's anchored by the regular dividend. So we'll see, do they stick with this?
We'll know on May 11th, that's when they're reporting earnings, a lot of these companies will be loathed to cut any kind of commitments or anything. But crude prices and natural gas prices are what they are. And if they fall for a considerable amount of time period, not just a couple of days, but considerable time period, much lower than they might have to change their tune. Now they did give out that three year scenario, like I said, so that was for 2024 through 2026.
And they projected at $85 average per barrel, $22 billion in free cash flows, but at $65, which we had been hovering about a lot this year in 2025, they're expecting only $12 billion. So we'll see where we are. But you can see all the thoughts that goes into the shareholders here with EOG resources. Now EOG, like I said, is a large cat producer.
They're US only, they are in Colorado. They are in the Midwest Ohio Valley area with the Utica shale. They are the Delaware Basin, which is Texas and New Mexico, Eagle Ford, which is Texas, and Dorado Play in Louisiana. So that's where they're focused.
2024 production was up 8%. But with prices is low, you kind of don't want production to be rising because you're not really getting your money's worth if crude is down this low. So will we see some cuts in production or in CapEx with some of these companies? We don't know.
We're waiting. Now, what's going on with the estimates here? Is this a value or is this a trap? Because it's got that PE of 9.5.
Well, one is lower in the last seven days. Six are lower in the last 30. One is higher in the last 30. So there are some analysts also tinkering around with EOG resources, again, blowing away my earlier statement that, oh, they won't do anything until the earnings.
But apparently there's one or two analysts that are brave enough to go out there and start to change their estimates here ahead of earnings because of what crude is doing. But this means we're seeing 1109 for this year versus 1157 just 30 days ago. And that's earnings declined at 4.5% because they need 1162 last year. So is this a trap?
Yeah, these all are looking a little trappy here because of the decline in earnings. But this is common with commodities, as I've talked about many times on this podcast. You are getting the following oil prices right now. So inevitably, you're going to have the earnings not looking so good.
You're going to get the bad. I call them bad sex ranks. This is a sex number three EOG resources. So that's just the hold.
But I would not be surprised to see a lot more of the fours and fives going into this earnings report. And then especially if we start to see production cuts or things like that going on, then we're going to see a lot more of the fours and fives going on. They as an industry, the ENPs year to date are down 34%. And that is a reflection of not these big guys.
But like I mentioned, those smaller ENPs who are just getting really hammered on the sell off. The energy investors are skittish and the smaller companies, they may not be able to pay the dividend. They probably see some fast cuts to dividends. And that will cause a lot of selling as well in some of those stocks.
So you do have the strong stomach if you're going into the smaller of the energy stocks. But even in these big ones, you do too, because even EOG resources is on the more weak side, but nowhere near what some of the small guys are doing where they're going down 30%. We're not saying that. People are sticking around.
We've got these big dividends so far. And it looks like pretty much a good commitment from EOG for that big dividend yielding almost 4% as well. So that's EOG resources ticker EOG. And that's an interesting thing on there under the slide presentation where they said each dollar per barrel increase or decrease in well-head crude oil and conditate price, condesate.
Combined with the estimated change in NGL price is approximately 204 million for pre-tax cash flows. So just something to keep in mind, it does matter if we see even a dollar decline in WTI prices and certainly on the natural gas side too. And it goes right straight down there to those free cash flows. And this is for the pre-tax cash flows, but it's a big deal.
So here we are again with a struggle in the energy sector. Rigs are being shut already. And if we do see energy prices go down to that $50 level, it's going to get into a recession in the energy industry that would be common if the economy is also in a recession. On the flip side, gasoline prices should come back down under $3.
That's helpful to the US consumer. We don't pay as much at the pump than we can spend more at the stores or on entertainment. We can go to those movies this summer. So we'll see where it all plays out, but the better case scenario is that we don't stay under 60 for very long.
And anything 60 to 70, at least is more stabilizing for these companies and their businesses and their employees. And that's good for the industry. But we'll see what happens as we go along. Energy has the habit of overshooting, seeing these quick sell-offs because of events on the global stage or overshooting on the upside.
Quick gains like we've seen during the Ukraine-Russia war when that hit. And so it again is a lot to be in these stocks. Remember Berkshire Hathaway still is an owner of Chevron. And so they've been in this play and are sticking it out from all we know.
And they've got Occidental Petroleum over there as well, the huge position in Occidental, which is ticker OXY. But let me recap these stickers. Exxon again, XOM, as a Mary, XOM, Chevron, CVX, and then EOG Resources, E, as an Edward OGS and George, EOG. So as always, I aim to bring you as many value stocks as I can every week as long as things aren't totally blowing up and it gets to be irrelevant by the time this podcast comes out.
But I think we'll be okay on this energy podcast because it's very volatile. But the story is kind of set for right now here in April. And we'll see what happens with the prices of the underlying commodities, with the global economy and what they say on the earnings. But these companies are used to this and they went through it five years ago with the pandemic.
So they're gearing up again for possible, you know, a little bit of a rough go again. And we'll see. So again, you want to be sure to subscribe, get us on Apple Podcasts. We are on YouTube on the ZX Podcast channel there.
And you can get us just about anywhere you can get podcasts. And I will be back again next week with some more value stocks. This material is being provided for informational purposes only. And nothing herein constitutes investment, legal, accounting, or tax advice, or a recommendation to buy, sell, or hold a security.
Do not act or rely upon the information and advice given in this podcast without seeking the services of competent and professional legal tax or accounting counsel. Publication and distribution of this podcast is not intended to create any information contained herein does not constitute an attorney-client relationship. No recommendation or advice is being given as to whether any investment or strategy is suitable for a particular investor. They should not be assumed that any investment in securities, companies, sectors, and markets identified and described were or will be profitable.
All information is current as of the date herein and the subject to change without notice. Any views or opinions expressed may not reflect those of ZX investment researchers a whole.