Skip to content
Ep. 120 – Purifying Our Practice episode artwork

Apr 20, 2022 58 min

Ep. 120 – Purifying Our Practice

from Insight Hour with Joseph Goldstein

Joseph Goldstein shares his wisdom on purifying our practice through openness to suffering and being compassionate. This podcast is brought to you by BetterHelp. Click to receive 10% off your first month with your own licensed professional therapist: betterhelp.com/insighthour “It is amazing the impact we can have. We shouldn't underestimate the power of these small acts of generosity and compassion”. -- Joseph Goldstein This dharma talk from Joseph was originally published on Dharma Seed

Episode details come from the podcast's RSS feed.

Embed this episode

Ready to play

Ep. 120 – Purifying Our Practice

0:00 58:33
of matches

Transcript Auto-generated, may contain errors

This episode is sponsored by BetterHelp. We talk about mental health more openly now, but asking for help can still feel hard. BetterHelp's latest research confirms it. BetterHelp's 2026 State of Stigma report surveyed 2000 Americans and revealed that 85% of Americans believe getting support is wise.

Yet, 74% say society discourages people from doing so. If you're struggling with mental health, please consider getting the help you deserve. BetterHelp is the world's largest online therapy platform. Don't let stigma stand in the way of support.

Start therapy with BetterHelp. Sign up and get 10% off at betterhelp.com.com. That's better, h-e-l-p.com.com. Slash Insight Hour.

Welcome to the Joseph Goldstein Insight Hour. This podcast is an expression of our shared interest in self-discovery. Join Joseph as he shares his deep knowledge of the path of mind phones. If you are interested in supporting this podcast, please go to beherenownetwork.com.

Slash, Joseph. From one perspective, you can say that a major part of our practice comes down to the awareness of and purification of motivation. There's one Tibetan teaching which expresses this very succinctly. It says, everything rests on the tip of motivation.

In Western cultures, we usually measure the value of our actions by the effectiveness of the outcome, by its success or failure. The Dalai Lama, in one teaching, he said a very different frame of reference, which would be a very different way of looking at how we live in the world. He said that the true value of an action is not measured by whether it's successful or not, but by the motivation behind it. So when we look at our actions in the world and we assess their effectiveness, it's really a call to looking at our motivation, what was behind that action, what motivated it.

We can't control all the conditions in the world. You know, sometimes, regardless of what we do, sometimes this praise, sometimes this blame, sometimes this success, sometimes this failure, but we do have the possibility of training our hearts. Within the Buddhist teachings, there's one particular motivation that is so vast and so skillful and so ennobling of our lives, that it can become the basis of the foundation for our entire life's journey. This is the motivation that's called Bodhijita, that we've spoken about at different times.

Bodhijita means the heart mind of awakening, the awakened heart, the awakened mind. So Bodhijita is the aspiration that we can cultivate, that we can nurture. It's the motivation to awaken, to free ourselves, in order to awaken and benefit all beings. So this is a very powerful seed to plant, the seed of Bodhijita.

May my life, may my actions, may my practice be for the benefit, the welfare, the awakening of all. And although these teachings were more fully developed in the later schools of Buddhism, we also find the same altruistic aspiration throughout the politics as well. There's one discourse in the Middle End sayings where he Brahmin youth, his name was Brahmayu. He was intent on following the Buddha around, just to observe his actions and how he was, he was kind of testing the Buddha to see if he was living up to this claim of awakening.

He said he shadowed the Buddha for nine months, just keeping an eye out. And this is from the Surat. So this is Brahmayu describing how the Buddha would take his meditative seat, as he would come and sit down. He sets his body erect and establishes mindfulness in front of him.

Now what follows next would be good advice for us. He does not occupy his mind with self-affliction, or the affliction of others, or the affliction of both. He sits with his mind set on his own welfare, on the welfare of others, and on the welfare of both, even on the welfare of the whole world. So this is how the Buddha would take his seat, setting his mind on the welfare, himself, of others, and of the whole world.

And then again, in the Buddha's instructions to the first 60 disciples who became fully enlightened, who became aarhan's, he gave these instructions to these 60 aarhan's. He said, go forth, O Bikus, for the good of the many, for the happiness of the many, out of compassion for the world, for the good benefit and happiness of people and devas. Let not too go by one way, teach the Dharma excellent in the beginning, excellent in the middle, excellent in the end. Proclaim the noble life altogether perfect and pure.

Work for the good of others, you who have done your duty. So right from the beginning, right in the very earliest texts, this altruistic aspiration, you know, as the foundation for practice is there. We can understand and practice bodhijita on two levels. One level is called relative bodhijita, and that is the practice of compassion.

The other level is called ultimate bodhijita, and that is understanding the empty nature of the mind. So relative level is compassion, ultimate level is emptiness. And it's said that when both of these are present, compassion and emptiness, enlightenment is unavoidable. So when I read that, I thought, well, these two would be worth exploring.

Ultimate bodhijita, relative bodhijita, compassion, emptiness, enlightenment is unavoidable. So tonight I'd like to explore these, what they are by themselves, how they interrelate, and how we can put them into practice in the world. So relative bodhijita is compassion, and it manifests as compassionate response, compassionate action in the world. It's called relative because this compassion is operating on the relative level of beings.

We're sending compassion or having compassion for ourselves, for others, talking about self and other, concept of being. That's the level on which this compassion is operative. So what is this feeling? You know, when compassion is strong, it's that feeling in the heart that wants to alleviate suffering.

That's the movement of the heart. In the face of suffering, it wants to alleviate it, wants to bring it to an end. When we have compassion, then our hearts are opening, open to the suffering that exists, both in ourselves and in the world, and it overcomes indifference, it overcomes apothe. It's this feeling which moves us to act, it moves us to take action.

And it's this very feeling that said to have motivated the bodhisattva on his very long journey to Buddhahood. It was this compassion at which to alleviate the suffering of beings. Now, Vidaly Lama said something very interesting about this quality. He said, compassion and love are precious things in life.

They are not complicated. They are simple, but difficult to practice. So I find that very interesting. Why would such beautiful and ennobling qualities like love, like compassion, even though they're simple, they're not complicated, why are they difficult to practice?

I think we really have to look at this in our lives and in our experience. So compassion arises in our willingness to come close to suffering. If we're not willing to open to the suffering that's there, compassion is not going to arise. The problem is that even though many of us may want to be compassionate, and perhaps in many situations are, it's not always easy to open to the suffering that's present.

This is not always an easy thing to do. Just as there are many times in our practice and in our lives, when we don't want to open to and acknowledge our own pain, in the same way there are many times when we don't particularly want to open to the pain of others. There are very strong tendencies in the mind that keep us defended, that keep us withdrawn, that keep us indifferent, that keep us apathetic in the face of suffering. And this indifference is often unacknowledged, and it's a great barrier to compassionate response.

So just as an experiment, to see how this is working in your own practice here and in your lives outside, watch the response or the reaction in the mind the next time you're facing a situation of suffering. It might be some pain in the body. It might be some painful emotion that's arising, maybe feelings of discontent or fear or envy or jealousy or unworthiness or shame, or loneliness. Now there's a long list of unpleasant emotions.

Is our first response, oh good, let me open to this. Let me explore, sometimes perhaps, hopefully more now than six weeks ago, but very often our first instinctive reaction to the pain to the suffering, whether it's physical or emotional, very often our instinctive reaction is to pull back. We don't want to open to it, because, precisely because it's painful. You know, might be interactions with a difficult person.

That's really a great time to watch how we're responding. And if somebody's being difficult in our lives, are we open or do we pull back? Do we not want to be with that difficulty? Dalai Lama has, and this comes I think from Shanti Deva, there's a great practice.

He says, your enemies teach you patience and you should honor your enemies. They teach you patience. You know, we've talked a lot about patience and how valuable it is and what a powerful power me it is and how helpful it is. But when we're in some conflict with somebody, do we remember this?

Are we actually packed? Oh, thank you. This is a chance for me to practice this power me of patience. I'm so grateful to you.

It's not so easy to do. You know, so again, it has to do with our response to suffering. What is it? Are we open to it?

And it doesn't have to be huge suffering. Sometimes it's just mild difficulty. But can we watch? You know, what our response is?

Is it openness or is it withdrawal? Is it closed? We can watch our minds not only with respect to what's happening to us immediately, but how do we respond to suffering in the world? You know, in the media and we get so much information about just huge natural disasters.

You know, a political or religious violence, you know, or racial injustice and oppression. What happens when we face these situations, either in person or through the vivid images of the media? You know, when we are brought close to the suffering, what do we do? Do we feel uneasy?

Do we withdraw? Do we turn away? Or do we let them all in? So this is something for us to look at in ourselves.

This is not theoretical. This is how we're responding to the truth of dukat, of the truth of suffering in the world. It was really interesting for me and I could see all of these different tendencies, these different ways of responding to a growing awareness of suffering. I could see all of them at work in my own mind in these last five or six years or so.

It was at a point when IMS really committed itself to diversity and to doing the work of beginning the work of undoing racism. You know, both in the gross and more subtle ways it manifests, both in society, in general, in our own lives, here as an institution. And so beginning to do this work, it was so both eye opening and heart opening. And one of the most striking and unsettling aspects for me, was to see how easy it was for me as a white person in this opening, to the racism that is present, how easy it is to stay uninvolved and unaware, because it didn't touch me personally.

And so it was striking and it was so shocking to me to see that level of disconnect with something that was so prevalent in our society. So these are the tendencies that can be in the mind. This is just one example and one arena. There are many examples.

You know, how do we respond to global warming? And the potentially disastrous consequences of what's happening. Suffering on a massive scale. It's hard to let it in.

It's hard to be open to it and then to be responsive. So we need to just take a look in all of these different situations where we come close to suffering, where we're beginning to open up, just to see what our response actually is. Now, Stiknath Han said, compassion is a verb, meaning compassion is manifest as action. It's not enough to admire these qualities of loving kindness or compassion from afar, to appreciate that they're noble qualities, but somehow removed from our daily life interactions, or cultivating the met and compassion only in the solitude of a meditation retreat.

It's really not enough. So the great question for all of us, in all our various arenas of life, whatever they may be, the question is, how can our hearts stay open given the magnitude of suffering in the world? You know, is it even possible? So this challenge is not theoretical because our practice is about the transformation of consciousness.

It's about the purification of motivation, the purification of our hearts, that increasingly makes compassionate responsiveness the default setting of our lives. Rather than withdrawal being the default setting or being closed, the default setting. So this is the transformation that we're engaged in. Compassion, developing it and acting on it requires many associated qualities.

It requires openness. It requires interest. It requires mindfulness. It requires equanimity.

So that we can learn to let things in, we can let the world in, with all the different kinds of dukkha that come with that, can we let it in without being overwhelmed by it, without drowning in sorrow. So a big part of the development of compassion is learning to simply be with the truth of how things actually are. And this is the great gift of mindfulness to compassion. Mindfulness connects us to what is happening, both personally within our own minds and bodies and to the world around us.

Now we're doing this, in every sitting, in every walking, as you go through the day, every time you're willing to open to some difficulty, when you're willing to open and feel and experience a pain in the body or an emotional pain. When you're being mindful and open in that way, that is the doorway to compassion. We're beginning to open ourselves to the experience of suffering, and that is the cause for compassion to arise. But so interesting, you've probably experienced this many times in your own lives and perhaps often on retreat, to see how when we are more willing to be with our own pain in a compassionate way, when we're open to it, rather than pushing it away or denying or avoiding or being indifferent.

And we can be open to it. The more we open to our own pain in suffering, the easier it is, the more courage we have to open to the pain and suffering of others. There was a Zen teacher in California. His name is Lou Richmond.

Some years ago, he came down with a terrible life-threatening disease of his viral encephalitis. It was really a devastating illness. He was in a coma for two weeks and brain damage. It took three or four years for him to really recover from this illness and for a while it wasn't clear what he would recover.

And he came to a very interesting understanding through his illness. He said, sometimes when I'm asked to describe the Buddhist teaching, I say this, everything is connected. Nothing lasts. You are not alone.

This is really just a restatement of the traditional three marks of existence. Everything is connected, non-self. Nothing lasts, impermanence. You are not alone suffering.

I don't think I would have expressed the truth of suffering as you are not alone before my illnesses. But now I find that talking about it that way gets at something important. The fact that we all suffer means we are all in the same boat and that's what allows us to feel compassion. There's something so true about that.

I found in myself that when I can feel going through some difficulty, some pain and really open to it, it's so easy to feel compassion for anybody else who might be experiencing that same pain, realizing we are not alone. We're all in the same boat together and understanding that and realizing it really breaks down the barriers of separation. It allows the compassion to flow very freely. So the beginning of compassion is empathy.

And this happens when we take a moment to stop and feel what another person may be feeling before rushing on with our lives. Now in this stopping is its own practice because many times we may be cognizant. We may know somebody else is going through something. So intellectually we say it.

But often we don't take the time, even if it's just for a few moments, to actually stop and feel it, to let it in, to feel what the other person is feeling. So this is the movement of empathy. Empathy is the hard mind of inclusion where it takes everything in Río Khan who was 18th, 19th century Zen poet and Zen master, Hermit, and wonderful stories about lived up very poor up in the mountains in his little hut and wandered the villages playing with the village children and wrote the wonderful haiku poetry about his understanding and realization. And in a couple of haiku, which I'll read, he so expressed this sense of inclusion of taking things in.

It may seem that I'd locked myself away from the people of the world. And yet why is it I have never ceased to think of them. If my arms draped in these black robes were only wide enough, how gladly I would shelter in them all the people of this floating world. Now it's just that sense of open-heartedness.

And it's open-heartedness also with a sense of poignant humor because the few kamas are so extraordinary. He had this open-heartedness even towards inanimate objects. I'd forgotten my begging bowl, but no one would steal it. No one would steal it.

How sad for my begging bowl. I'm not that. The poor begging bowl. Nobody wanted it.

We can practice developing empathy in many different kinds of situations. You know, it might be in the distress of the restless person sitting next to us in the meditation hall. You know, what's our reaction? Is our reaction why are they disturbing my meditation?

Or is our reaction a sense of feeling the discomfort they must be in? So right there in this very simple situation, we can really watch and see what is our conditioning. And can we, even if our first reaction is irritation or annoyance, can we see that going to be mindful of that? And see, no, there's another possibility here.

You know, and drop back into that open-heartedness of empathy. Sometimes it may be practice empathy with regard to the people who are very close to us, maybe in intimate relationships, and really feeling suffering that they may be going through. Some years ago, in the long evolution of IMS as an organization, it's 37, 38 years now, organizationally we've gone through lots of ups and downs and times when it was very useful as it has been happily, has been lately for the last many years. But earlier, we would go through some big, big organizational storms, figuring out, you know, how do we do this.

And remember one board meeting? This must go back 15, 20 years. There was a lot of conflict. You know, people just had very different ideas about directions and what we should do.

And so we were having this very heated board meeting with lots of opinions flying back and forth. And I could feel myself being very attached to a particular point of view and getting really tied in my own way of seeing things and very annoyed at people who didn't see it as clearly as I did. And then at some point, the suffering that I was feeling became so obvious. And this is really the great prompt of suffering when it becomes so obvious just what is going on here.

How am I getting so caught? How am I getting so lost in this? And I did something. It was just a little mental move that was so freeing and liberating.

So we were in this meeting and all this conflicts. So I just stopped for a moment. I just kind of settled back to a few deep breaths. And I asked myself the question, where are these others who had the opposite points of view?

Why do they feel the way they feel? They're not irrational beings. Although I had thought so a few minutes before. But when I could just stop and make some space in myself, well, why do they feel the way they do?

It was amazing the space that opened up. It actually allowed me to see things from their perspective. And as soon as I did that, the whole energy of the conversation changed. Instead of this polarity and fighting the visiveness in seeing the different perspectives, then it became just an interesting exploration of what the best thing to do is.

So this is another kind of empathy where we're in a situation and we allow ourselves to feel something from another person's viewpoint. Bonchai, the great 16th century Zen master, a Japanese Zen master, one of my all-time favorite teaching lines. He said, don't side with yourself. Just that.

If you did nothing else for these three months, but leave here with that, that would be a tremendous accomplishment. Because how often are we just deciding with ourselves, we're caught in our own viewpoint. Don't side with ourselves. That means opening.

That means empathy. That means being willing to feel, to see, to understand what other people are feeling and understanding. Now, there may be times when people really are behaving badly, you know, we're doing really harmful things, whether to ourselves or to others. And our usual reaction to that might be, you know, anger at the harm people are doing and judging how bad they are.

But is it possible to stop and feel what is going on in a larger context, even in very extreme circumstances? There's one story which, you know, I came of course years ago and it's such a powerful example of this. It's a story of one of the physicians to the Dalai Lama, Dr. Tenzin Chodrick, who was imprisoned by the Chinese government for 17 years, imprisoned in torture, just one of these horrible scenarios.

And he was eventually released and came to this country and there was an article just describing, he was describing himself, how he had survived, not only physically, but how he had survived emotionally and mentally, keeping his heart free of hatred, free of anger towards those who, you know, were so brutal to him. He said, he understood that his enemies, you know, his tormentors were human beings like himself and that his guards were also people in adverse circumstances. That's an amazing enlargement of context. You know, his understanding that they were creating this very unwholesome, unsquoted glomer that would bring this immense suffering back to themselves.

He was able to see this. He said he never forgot the commonality of the human condition, you know, and that all actions, their fruit, all actions being results. But what's so amazing when I read this, you know, it would be so easy to think, oh, yeah, they'll get theirs, you know, his calm, the comic wheel turns, but he wasn't holding that understanding as a vehicle of revenge. He was holding as a vehicle of compassion.

So he could see the suffering of his tormentors, of his guards. That's a huge enlargement, you know, of the context of understanding. This very intense situation. And it's important to understand that in situations where it's possible, sometimes we do need to take appropriate action, you know, to set proper boundaries, to redress injustices.

All of these actions can be taken. Very strong actions. There's one phrase in Tibetan Buddhism, which expresses this possibility. It's called wrathful compassion.

You know, where a strong energy is needed to stop something that's harmful. But it's essential that we look at the motivation behind them, you know, or our actions coming from a place of anger and hatred, or do they come from an understanding of the immense suffering that's being caused. Compassion is that movement or that response in this situation, how can I help? How can I help alleviate this suffering?

That's not resentment. That's not anger. That's not hatred. How can I help alleviate this suffering?

There was an interview with Anksan Suu Kyi just after she was released from house arrest, I forgot how many years, many, many years of house arrest in Burma. She had an interview with an Australian newspaper just after her release. And they asked her, you know, upon your release, don't you want to bring these generals down? These generals soon?

Brutalized Burma? And she said, no, I want to bring them up. That's an amazing response. No, I don't want to bring them down.

I want to bring them up. That's the move. That's the heart of compassion. So empathy brings us close to suffering.

Empathy, you know, is that opening of the heart where we can begin to feel the suffering either in ourselves or in others in the world. But compassion takes us a step further. It's not only feeling what others are going through, but it's that move that's initiative, that energy to act, to respond. As compassion grows, we begin to take a very active engagement, you know, with the suffering in the world, responding to the suffering in whatever way is appropriate, in whatever way is possible.

Sometimes we may act in very small and unregarded ways. You know, it may be a small gesture of friendliness or forgiveness or generosity. One practice that the Dalai Lama said he does, he's small but profound practice. This would be an amazing thing to really work with.

He said, I tried to treat whoever I meet as an old friend. This gives me a genuine feeling of happiness. It is the practice of compassion. So imagine taking that on, you know, that whoever we meet, I tried to treat whoever I meet as an old friend, our lives would be a great up, up swing of joy from happiness.

We're meeting our old friends all the time, you know. But do we remember to do this? I mean, the habit of withdrawal, the habit of indifference, you know, can really take hold. So it's a practice.

We shouldn't overlook the small opportunities, you know, for compassionate connection. I think many of you are probably familiar with the famous butterfly effect described in chaos theory and science. You know, the scientific, the one scientific sentence I barely understood was about chaos theory was sensitive dependence on initial conditions, which as I understood it means that in a non-linear system, a small input into the system can have a very big output, can have a very big result. So the example given was that of a butterfly flapping its wings in China two weeks ago can be the cause of a hurricane developing here, you know, small, tiny input, huge output.

So some years ago, as an example of this, but there are many, of course. A few years ago, I saw a documentary which is called a small act. And in the mid 1970s, the documentary was about the Swedish woman named Hildebach. I was just making a small monthly donation to some group that was supporting education in Kenya, you know, helping, helping kids from impoverished villages continue with their education.

So she was just often Sweden, you know, and it was a small monthly gift. One of the kids that was sponsored, his name is Chris Maburo. He was able to finish his schooling, his high school schooling. He went to the University of Nairobi, finished their graduate when to law school, got a full bright to Harvard, got a master's degree in international human rights law from Harvard, went back to Kenya, set up his own foundation to help really bright kids, you know, who needed help to continue their education.

And so there may be hundreds of thousands of kids transformed by this chain of events, you know, a small monthly donation that's the butterfly flapping its wings. And then, you know, it affects this brilliant Kenyan boy. So that's maybe a little bigger butterfly flapping its wings, creating a whole foundation. So it's amazing, the impact, you know, we can have.

So we shouldn't underestimate the power of these small, these small acts of generosity, of compassion. Sometimes compassion manifests as acts of tremendous courage. You know, we've seen them, you know, some of the most famous exemplars of this in the world, you know, that become icons in a way. Think of people like the Nelson Mandela, you know, An San Suu Kyi or Dr.

King or Gandhi, you know, who have a courageous vision, you know, that motivates these acts of compassion of non-violence, of love, that transformed whole societies. So it's huge, huge impact on their own societies and in the world. You know, just motivated by compassion, by visions of justice or peace or freedom can affect so many people. Sometimes compassion shows itself, not necessarily as kind of this long-term vision of what's possible, but sometimes just in a spontaneous moment.

And there's one story of this, which just epitomizes that it's a remarkable story. Maybe some of you remember, some years ago, there was an incident in New York and about somebody who ended up being called the subway hero. So he was on the subway station platform. He was a black construction worker who was standing on the platform waiting for a train.

A woman had fallen off the tracks, off the platform, onto the tracks and a train was coming. So he saw what happened. He jumped down onto the tracks, lay down flat on top of this woman and the train just passed over them both. I mean, amazing.

So this is what he said. You know, he got, there was a lot of pressing up this. He said, I don't feel like I did something spectacular. I just saw someone who needed help.

I did what I felt was right. I do construction work in confined spaces a lot. So I looked and my judgment was pretty right. The train did have enough room for me.

I mean, in that situation, this is compassion manifesting not as some grand world vision. This is just in a moment, you know, kind of incredibly open hearted guy would have the courage and skill in the presence of mind to be able to do that. So compassion manifests in so many different ways in just simple acts, you know, in acts of tremendous courage and spontaneously. There's no particular prescription for what we should do.

There is no hierarchy of compassion and actions. You know, it's not that one kind of compassion and action is more compassionate than another. That's like compassion. It's a limit.

The field is limitless because it's the field of suffering beings. You know, and so we each find our own way. We find the way that we're drawn to our interests, our parents, our abilities, what touches us. This infinite possibilities for manifest and compassion and action in the world.

And we want to find our own way into this. You know, one way it manifests is in active engagement with the world and the problems of the world. It can also manifest sitting in a cave in the mountains for years, for lifetimes with the aspiration to awaken for the benefit of all. Now think of the Bodhisattva, the Buddha before his enlightenment.

How many lifetimes it said that he spent, you know, as a solitary renunciate, practicing all the parameas. You know, if we took just a little slice of anyone life, we might think, oh, what's that guy doing? How is he helping anybody? You know, and yet it took all of that practice which finally manifests in the flowering, you know, of his enlightened energy.

It was a Buddha. And we're sitting here today, 2,600 years later. And it's quite extraordinary. We're sitting here because of the power of what he discovered.

So compassion can take so many forms and can look so many different ways. It's not to judge the externals. It's really to see what's the motivation. Is it a compassionate motivation?

That can take so many forms. You know, for the Buddha, his aspiration was not to just alleviate particular kinds of suffering, but really to see what the root causes of suffering are. You know, the forces of greed and hatred and delusion in the mind and how we can uproot them. As we undertake this relative Bodhicheta, this practice of compassion, we need a lot of humility.

He said, changes in attitude never come easily. The development of loving compassion is a wide round curve that can be negotiated only slowly, not a sharp corner that can be turned all at once. The development of loving compassion comes with daily practice. You know, so it's not to kind of get seduced by some idealistic version of how we should be, because that only will end in disappointment.

We have to really start with where we are and with a lot of humility and practice and take opportunities as they present themselves. It's another Japanese haiku poet, famous poet, Isa. The cycle really captures the essence of humility. New Year's Day, everything's in blossom.

I feel about average. That's it. I feel about average. And that's the place we start.

So we talked about a lot about relative Bodhicheta compassion, compassion action in the world. I want to spend just a few minutes talking about ultimate Bodhicheta, which goes beyond the notion of self in other. It goes beyond all separation. Ultimate Bodhicheta is the free, open nature of awareness itself.

So, Sigar Kong-Truvimpoche, he expressed in one teaching just how present is the possibility of recognizing this ultimate Bodhicheta, the nature of emptiness. He said, the experience of emptiness is not found outside the world of ordinary appearance, as many people mistakenly assume. You know, we create this notion of emptiness and it's some kind of far off mystical thing. It's not found outside the world of ordinary appearance, as many people mistakenly assume.

In truth, we experience emptiness when the mind is free of grasping at experience. That's what we've been practicing. Liberation through non-clinging. We experience emptiness.

We experience that empty nature of mind, the selfless nature of mind, in every moment when the mind is not grasping at experience. One of the really transformative turning points in my practice, this was a big shift of understanding. Came about when I was hearing teachings on relative and ultimate Bodhicheta, on compassion and emptiness. And then realizing that these two compassion and emptiness are not two different things.

In the union of the two, we see that compassion is the activity of emptiness. In the mind free of self-reference, in emptiness of self, the activity of that mind is compassionate response. And so to see that bringing the two together, not having them as separate goals or ideas or things, but as two different ways of practice, this compassion, which is the activity of emptiness, is not compassion as a stance of the ego. It's not online being so compassionate now.

And it's not even necessarily a particular practice we do, meditation practice, while there are compassion practices. But rather, this compassion is the spontaneous responsiveness of a heart of a mind that is free of self-reference, free of the sense of self. Manifesting naturally as compassion. This really helped me understand the great Bodhisattva vows, that many of the Mahayana traditions are such a big part of.

The vow is basically to save to enlighten all beings. And for years, I had read about that and sounded like a nice idea, but it just seemed impossible. I had no way of connecting that aspiration with anything I could do. Of course, right there was the key.

There was no way of connecting it to an eye, but in understanding the compassion as the activity of emptiness, as we become more realized in this experience of selflessness, then compassion and activity is what happens. And so the Bodhisattva vows are not resting on the shoulders of itself. They're manifesting as the activity of wisdom. So, Dukkha Kinsai, he really just summed all of this up in such a beautiful way, in understanding the relationship of relative and ultimate bodhijata, of compassion and emptiness.

He said, when you recognize the empty, selfless nature of phenomena, the energy to bring about the good of others dawns, uncondrive and effortless. And when we realize the empty, selfless nature of phenomena, the energy to bring about the good of others dawns, uncondrive and effortless. So this is the great work we're all doing here together. Sit for a minute or two, only the merit of all our practice together, be dedicated to the welfare and the happiness and the awakening for all beings.

Frequently asked questions

How long is this episode of Insight Hour with Joseph Goldstein?

This episode is 58 minutes long.

When was this Insight Hour with Joseph Goldstein episode published?

This episode was published on April 20, 2022.

Is there a transcript available for this episode?

Yes, a full transcript is available for this episode. You can read the complete transcript on the episode page.

Can I download this Insight Hour with Joseph Goldstein episode?

Yes. Use the download control on the episode player to save the publisher-provided media file.