The level of experiment. Listen, let me close your eyes and listen. Is that inside or outside? When you're just with the experience, there's no bell, there's no ear, there's no inside, there's no outside, there's just hearing.
As soon as we put a concept of the ear of the body of the bell of self, the inside outside, there's the duality based aspiration. Welcome to the Joseph Goldstein Insight Hour. This podcast is an expression of our shared interest in self discovery. Join Joseph as he shares his deep knowledge of the path of mindfulness.
If you are interested in supporting this podcast, please go to beherenownetwork.com slash Joseph. Tonight I'd like to speak about one of the most important distinctions to be understood in the meditation practice and in our lives. That's the distinction or the difference between our concepts, our ideas, our thoughts about things and the experience itself. This was illustrated, this distinction was illustrated very clearly.
One of the ancient dialogues of Plato, he spoke to the Republic, he uses the parable of a cave. In this cave are a group of people facing the back wall of the cave and they change in such a way that they're unable to turn around to face the entrance. Imagine yourselves now, changing this cave and this is the back wall of it and behind you is a fire and a procession of figures going by, engaging in all the activities, the varied activities of life. Because of the fire, the procession of figures casts shadows on the back wall.
Because this group of people has always lived in the cave and has been chained so they can only face the back wall, they take the shadows to be the reality. That's the only reality that they are aware of. Sometimes happens that one of these people manages to loosen the chains, turns around, and sees the fire in the procession of figures and then understands that the shadows are simply a reflection of reality, they're not the reality itself. And even with greater rarity, it may be that somebody in that cave manages to cut the chains completely and go outside of the cave into sunlight and into freedom.
We're very much in that same situation or predicament as the people in Plato's cave because we have been conditioned for so long to live in the world of concepts, the world of idea, the world of mental construct, and our attachment to those ideas or concepts are so strong that we've begun to take the concept to be the reality. The path of practice, the path of meditation is to begin first, to discriminate between the idea and the experience, and then to go beyond condition experience altogether into freedom. What are some of the concepts which have been so ingrained in our minds that we take them to be real? There's a whole range of them and just mention a few to give you an idea of how strongly conditioned our minds have become.
One concept is the concept of place. The idea that the earth is actually divided into separate states or countries, nations. And these boundaries have some reality other than the reality that we have given them. One story which was told to me by a friend of mine who was traveling to India from Greece, and because Greeks came from Turkey, which was one concept already, she had to go through Russia and Iran and then to do that way.
She described to me the border crossing between Russia and Iran. She said that it was in the middle of this very desert-like countryside. Nothing around for miles very arid. There was a dry river bed and over this dry river bed was a big iron bridge and in the middle of this big iron bridge was a gate locked on both sides.
Do you have the picture? No, the middle of the desert. Nothing around for miles, a dry river bed and a bridge. In the middle of a bridge, a gate, and the gate locked.
She wanted to go from Russia to Iran and so the guards at the one side of the bridge had to call the guards on the other. They came to the middle at the same time. She opened the gate. She crossed the border.
It's like a Fellini movie. And yet how much reality has been invested in that concept of border in separate countries? And if she hadn't gone through that little comedy or drama, it would have been a lot of trouble without the stamp in the passport. But it's totally a creation of our minds.
The minds of all of us. We invest reality into that idea and then we take the idea to be real. Another concept which has been mentioned several times, which is even more deeply conditioned, is the concept of time. Most of us are pretty attached to the idea of past and future, as if somehow there's a reality to them.
And yet when you look and you actually investigate what the past is or what the future is, you see that there are only certain categories of thought or image in the present moment. The only way we can experience past or future is as a thought now. There's a tremendous burden taken off our lives when we see that past and future are now present and that we've created a concept, a construct about certain categories of thought of memories, remembrances, remembrances. We've created that category past and then thrown it out back of us as if it really exists back there, other than as a thought.
And we have regret and we have guilt and we have day dreaming. We do the same thing with the future. Category of thought, we throw it out in front of us. No planning, imagining, fantasizing.
All thought's happening now. But we label it future, throw it out as if the future is waiting for us and we'll catch up to it. And how much of our life is spent in anxiety or anticipation or fear or whatever about the construct that we've created, the story of, it's an old Zen story of this person living alone in a cave and his an artist, and he painted on the wall of the cave a picture of a tiger. And he painted it so realistically that when he was finished he got frightened.
And we do the same thing we have created, the concept of past and future and give it so much weight in our lives that we live conditioned by the imagined reality of those concepts. Life becomes extremely simple and harmonious when we realize that all there is is a succession of present moments. And we learn to trust that and to settle back into the moment, attentive to what's going on. There's the concept of plays, the concept of time.
It's a concept of ownership. We have the idea that we own things, just like for you for a moment to consider or reflect what that could possibly mean. What does it mean to own something? There's a story which I like very much written by Mark Twain in which he talks of a group of horse traders in Russia and in the small villages.
And the whole story is told from the horse's point of view. And from the horse's point of view, they weren't owned by anybody. They were in relationship to various human beings, some of whom were kind, some were cruel. But the concept of ownership never entered the horse's mind at all.
It's an idea that we've created and we get very attached to it. That's the sense of possessiveness. The Buddha talked of us not even being able to claim that we own this body, this mind. Can you say, Cain, go away now?
I don't want you. Do you have control over it? Thoughts stop coming. They're not subject to our control.
If we can't even claim to own this body in mind, when we see that it's just elements happening in their own way, then what reality does it have to own anything outside of this? And yet the attachment to that concept is strong. Another concept, concept of age. You know somebody else got old, you want one?
You want twenty-five, thirty, forty, fifty, seventy, whatever. When you're sitting and paying attention to the breath, how old is your breath? How old is the sensation in your leg? How old is a thought?
You know, actual experience, age doesn't mean anything. It's a concept which we add to the experience we have. And we're conditioned a lot by that concept, too old to do certain things, too young to do certain things. We have certain images of what's appropriate for a certain age and we put ourselves into this box.
And it's totally a construct of our minds. When we come down to the momentary experience, that concept dissolves. Concepts of place, of time, of ownership, of age. One of the most imprisoning concepts that we get involved in.
The concepts we have of self-image. We all have certain images of who we are. We create this image, this idea, and it's like pouring ourselves, those molds that use to pour place of Paris into. It's as if we pour ourselves into a certain mold, the mold being, the particular self-image that we have of ourselves, as being bright, as being clever, as being done, as being successful, as being unsuccessful, as being wealthy, as being poor, as being a great hero, a coward, a lover, a loser.
It doesn't matter. They're all just images that we've been conditioned to believe in, to think of ourselves in that way. And we get very identified with particular roles. Share with you a couple of stories which illustrate the power of roles and the possibility of working with them.
One of the times I was leaving India, coming back to this country, I've been there for a few years, and before leaving, you have to get an income tax clearance form, improving that you haven't been working, you don't owe the Indian government any money. So I went to the office, and I had been in the end of a long time and thought I was prepared. I go up to the desk and I ask the man for the form, the tax form. He says, please wait.
Okay, I was just waiting for that. I sit down, and I wait, rising, falling, rising, falling. Half an hour, 45 minutes. And I go up to the desk and I say, what am I waiting for?
He says, the man with the form isn't here. Okay, I'll go back and I say, now he's in falling. I'm getting some great meditation in. Another half hour, 45 minutes go by.
I go up to the desk and I say, well, where are the forms? They're in the cabin and behind the desk. Why don't you give them to me? It's locked.
Okay, go back. I sit down, I'm watching, rising, falling. Irritation. And sitting being the wonderful, creative space that it is, I have this brainstorm.
As I'm sitting, I go back to the desk and I say, well, where's the key? And he says, oh, it's in the desk. I look at him. I say, why don't you take the key?
And open the cabinet and give me the form. And he looked at me totally straight and said, well, it's not my job. Identification with a role in a rather extreme form. But we all do it.
And it's important to really begin to see the ways in which we limit ourselves, imprison ourselves with this idea of self-image or a role. Role of teacher, role of student, role of parent, role of child, role of employer, employee, million roles, million self-images, all of which are concepts. Had one experience in which I was really working with my own sense of limitation in self-image. Ever since the third grade, my music teacher came into class and told me just to mouthe the words.
No, when everybody else was singing. It's been a trip, which had been reinforced by many friends over the years. I really liked the sick, so there was this conflict. So a few years ago when I was teaching in Boulder in the summer, I saw a list of it in the catalog, of course, the natural voice.
I had a great, a new age Buddhist singing class. That's what I'm looking for. And it took a lot of, it actually took a lot of courage even to go sign up for that course, but I did and I went and the first few classes were fine. There were all kinds of singing exercises in, in a group singing that was terrific.
And one day we had a visiting teacher coming, a woman who was teaching bulk and folk singing. And she had about 40 of us in the class and she had us get around in this circle. And one by one, she would sing a note and we were supposed to sing a back to her. And I know that you're familiar with Bach and folk singing.
At least how she would do it was kind of high pitch nasal, strange to me sounds. As soon as she started doing this, I knew that I had some big trouble. And I'm getting more and more nervous how she's coming around, getting closer. She gets to me.
She sings this note. I do something back. It wasn't even close. It wasn't in the ballpark.
She does it again. The band I go back. This was a very determined woman. Finally, after about 10 attempts, the regular teacher of the class jumped into the situation and gradually led me up to the right pitch.
And I finally got it. The whole class applauded. It was both rather than Bach singing and also very humorous. And my mind was appreciating both sides of that.
And I was appreciating the possibility and the need even to be willing to take some risks to break out of our self-images. Because they were created for one reason or another, a strong condition and created those models, created those limitations. But we don't have to be imprisoned by them. And whether you do it in a very dynamic quick way or you do it in a slow, gradual way, it doesn't matter.
But to begin to get a sense, both of the images that we carry of ourselves, the roles we identify with, and to begin to find ways and to see ways that are appropriate to each of us to break through that, not to be limited by those images. This is a concept of place of time, of age, of ownership, of the role of self-image. Another concept which almost all of us are very identified with is the concept of gender. You know, somebody comes up to you and says, you're a manor woman.
Almost everybody knows. You know, without thinking manor woman. And obviously on one level, there are differences. But on another level, just as with age, when you're sitting, is the breath male or female.
You know what gender is the sensation you need. It's almost like, you know, you go to the ocean and you see the different waves. And on one level, the waves are different. In different shape, different form, different intensity.
And on another level, there's an underlying unity to the waves or handmade up of the ocean. In the same way on very obvious levels, there are differences. On underlying levels, there's a sense of oneness. And that attachment to the particular level of the difference also creates a strong limitation for us.
We don't open to the totality of ourselves if we're attached to that ideal concept. The concept that is the most deeply rooted, it is the strongest conditioned concept in our minds. And the one that is the root cause of conflict and suffering in ourselves and in the world. The root cause of bondage is the attachment we have to the concept of self, of I.
This idea that somehow there's an I, a me, a myself, an ego in all of this. And our life revolves around that sense of I, that sense of self. If there's an I, if there's a self, then there's an other, it's other than self, other than I. And from that beginning, we're lost in duality.
And when there's duality, there's conflict. Color in portray, great Tibetan meditation teacher. In one of his teachings, he said, we live in illusion and the appearance of things. There is a reality and we are that reality.
When we understand this, we see that we are nothing. And being nothing, we are everything. That is all. We live in illusion and the appearance of things.
We live in the world of concepts. We live in the world of ideas. We live in illusion and appearance of things. It is a reality.
We are that reality. When we understand this, we see that we are nothing. Being nothing, we are everything. That is all.
What is the reality that we are? The reality free from concept, free from idea. In the Buddhist teachings, especially in the teachings of the Abhidhamma, which is the collection of texts, the Buddhist psychology, which is a very detailed analysis of consciousness and the body in terms of the elements which compose it. In the teachings of the Abhidhamma, there's a very clear model of understanding.
This process of mind and body without reference to a self, without reference to an I. What I'd like to do tonight is just to explain briefly this model to give you a sense of the possibility of understanding experience without adding to that experience the sense of self, the sense of ego. Sometimes during this talk, at this point, people's minds begin to drift off a little bit. So see if you can stay focused on it because it's a very clear expression.
It's a very clear way of understanding what the whole practice is about. What are the realities that we are, that we experience? The first of the realities, and the four, the cold, the four ultimate realities, the first of them is the material elements, the physical plane. And there are a lot of different ways of describing the physical plane.
In the traditional Buddhist texts, and for the purposes of meditation, it's described very simply as the four great elements of Earth-Aphiling Water. And those are symbolically Earth-elinate means, the sensation of hardness of softness, of heaviness of lightness, those sensations that we feel, fire element is heat or cold, air element is movement of vibration. Water-elinate has the nature to hold it all together cohesiveness, but when you add water to flower and the water holds the flower together. And depending upon these four, our four secondary characteristics of color, of taste, of odor, and nutritional quality.
In fact, when we eat, we gain nutrition from it. So now we'll do a little exercise. If I were to ask you, what are you sitting on? Well, not you, you, probably by now, quite wise.
Take somebody who hasn't done much practice. Say, what are you sitting on the floor? No question. Come to your experience.
What actually is the experience of sitting? There's a sensation of pressure, of warmth, of softness. We then put an idea on it, of cushion of floor. But that's an idea, a construct, a concept which is an overlay to the actual experience of the physical elements.
You go outside. I ask you, what do you see? See trees and buildings in the sky and men and women plants. We don't see trees and sky and buildings and men and women in plants at all.
What the eyes use is color and form, light and shadow. And almost immediately, the mind puts a concept onto a particular color and form and light and shadow and calls it a tree, calls it a man, calls it a woman. Do you see the difference? Why is it important?
We seem to be functioning quite well in the world of concepts. The reason is important and essential in terms of deepening our understanding of reality is one basic inherent crucial difference between concepts and the experience, for example, of these physical elements. And that is that our concepts about things don't change. We use the same word.
I'm Joseph today, Joseph tomorrow. I know you're a woman today, a woman tomorrow. You see a tree today, a tree tomorrow, a tree the next day. And because we use the same word, because the concept is unchanging, we don't connect with the fact that the actual reality of the experience is in constant change.
When we drop into the physical sensations, whether it's a touch of seeing, of hearing, of smelling, it doesn't matter. When we're on the level of experience, we see that change is happening momentarily. When we're in the world of concept, we get fooled into seeing the permanence of things. Because of that sense of permanence due to the concept we get attached.
To the degree that we see the impermanence, the momentariness, the de-conditions grasping, the de-conditions craving, clinging. If we're attached to that which is changing, we suffer. It's like being attached to summer. How do you feel in winter?
Not very happy. When we're attached to that which in its nature changes, we suffer because we're out of harmony with how things are actually happening. We're then not open to the flow of change in experiences. To the extent that we live in the world of concept, we don't perceive the momentary changes that are happening.
For the material elements, the physical elements, that's the first level of reality. The second reality that we can experience directly is that of consciousness, the knowing faculty, that which knows the sight, the sound, the smell, the taste, the thought, the knowing. Mostly when people begin to pay attention to their lives, to their experience, can begin to see the impermanence of physical phenomena. It doesn't take so much reflection or wisdom to see that the body is born and gets older and decays and dies.
Even if we don't honor that very much, most people know it in some level. What we don't know very often is that consciousness itself is changing moment to moment. So that even when we have a sense of the physical plane, the body going through changes, there's often a sense of one observer inside who's watching the passing shot. And so to a little extent, we can let go of the identification with the body as being self, because we know that it's just going through this process of change.
A more subtle level of identification is with the consciousness, the knowing. And we create the idea, the concept of a knower. What happens in the meditation practice through a refinement of perception is that we begin to be aware of consciousness also, arising and passing many times against it. So what's happening is a very rapid succession of mind mumps arising and passing away.
As an example, now you're not hearing and seeing at the same time. It appears that way because the perception is not finally tuned yet, though only the mindfulness is strong and the perception is refined, you begin to see the momentariness of seeing, of hearing, smelling, and tasting, and thinking. And how it's happening successively with each moment, with each new object, there's the knowing of it. So what we are is a, it's a pairwise progression of knowing an object, knowing of a sound coming and going on the sight coming and going on the smell of a thought or sensation.
And as we pay more and more careful attention and experience, this arising and passing away of consciousness, that's a powerful, deconditioning of the sense of self. Because we see the sense of knower, of observer, of witness dissolved into the momentary process of knowing, of witnessing, of observing. There's nothing solid there. It's constantly changing.
So the material elements, this consciousness, the third level of reality, and in some ways the most interesting, in terms of understanding the mind, is a whole group of qualities which arise in different combinations with each moment of consciousness, and they call mental factors and mental qualities. In every moment of seeing, the consciousness is pure. The consciousness simply knows the object, knows the sight, knows the sound. But in every moment, certain groups of factors arise, for example, greed.
Greed is a mental factor. When it arises in the mind, it has the nature to stick to the object. Greed is like glue. And that's the function of its first in mind.
It sticks to the object. Greed is not I, it's not self, it's not mine. It's simply a factor arising in a particular moment of consciousness. Functions in its own way to stick and passes away.
The consciousness is not self, the object is not self, the greed is not self. They're all just processes coming and going. Anger, hatred, is a mental factor. It has the nature to strike against the object.
We hear a sound. Actually, that's using conventional language. What happens is this consciousness of hearing, a moment of knowing, the sound is an object. If the sound is unpleasant, that unpleasantness conditions hatred of some undiertation annoyance.
So in that moment of hearing, hearing consciousness, the mental factor of anger arises or annoyance, has the nature to strike against the object, push away. Anger, hatred, annoyance, irritation, not I, not self, not mine. It's an impersonal factor. Delusion is like fog in the mind.
Delusion arises, can't see anything. Generosity is a mental factor. It's the nature of giving, of opening. Love is a mental factor.
It's a quality of mind arising in a particular moment of consciousness. And it has the function of goodwill and of loving kindness. Wisdom is a mental factor. In a particular moment of consciousness, if wisdom is there, wisdom has the function to illuminate.
It's like if we came into this room and it was totally dark, couldn't see anything. That's the factor of ignorance. Turn on the light switch and everything is illuminated. Everything is clear.
There is no one who is generous, no one who is loving, no one who is wise. It's simply the arising of these factors at different times in different moments, with particular moments of consciousness. So then you might ask, if what we are is this collection of physical elements, which are constantly changing, consciousness, which is constantly changing, in different mental factors, who is being mindful, who is making the effort to concentrate. Mindfulness, concentration, effort, or mental factors.
Mindfulness has the function to notice what the object is. So in a moment of seeing or hearing or thinking, if mindfulness is present, that factor has the function to notice our thought, sensation, or sound. When we're not mindful, this forgetfulness. We're not aware of the object.
Concentration is a factor of mind. It has the function of studying. How then, if what we are, is this collection of changing elements of mind and body? How is it that we all are so deeply conditioned by this sense of self, this sense of I?
If anybody in S1D exists, almost everybody would say yes. Where does that come from? Where is the sense of self and ego of I? Where does it come from?
How does that function? There's another factor of mind, another mental factor, which is called the wrong view. And wrong view has a very particular function, which is to identify with the object or with the consciousness. It's that part of the mind, which when a thought arises, claims it as my thought, my sensation.
I am hearing, I am seeing. That my or I is an extra process to the actual experience. There is a thought. The thought is the thinker.
The thought is thinking itself. There's no one behind it to whom it's happening. The sensation is feeling itself, no one behind it. But because of wrong view, we identify the tendency of mind to add on to the moment of experience, this sense of mind.
The power of mindfulness as a factor is that it's never associated with wrong view. Those two cannot go together. And so in every moment of mindfulness, of every moment of attention, what we're doing is deconditioning this identification with various parts of the process with freeing our mind from that concept of self. Give an example, which may help to kind of get a visual experiential sense of the selflessness of this process.
If you go outside tonight or some night and you look up at the sky and you see the big dipper. So everybody doesn't really know what the big dipper looks like. You look up at the sky and you see the stars and you see the big dipper. Let me ask you a question.
Is there really a big dipper of that? Is there? There's no big dipper. There isn't.
There are stars in a certain pattern and we create a concept about that pattern and call it big dipper. There's no big dipper. And when you can see the stars without the concept of big dipper, let me just backtrack a minute. The concept of big dipper is what separates those stars out from all the other stars in the sky.
So that's the separating device is the concept. When there's no concept, then you look up and you see stars in the sky. You see the oneness of it. In exactly the same way, we are a constellation of experiences.
We are a constellation of sights and sounds and smells and tastes and sounds and thoughts and emotions. And this constellation of experiences constantly changing the moving. Nothing static. Nothing steady.
But it's happening in an ordered way. It's not happening periodically. There's a pattern to it. It's just like there's a pattern to the stars.
We have put a concept onto this pattern, Joseph, and become so identified with the concept, with the pattern that we forget that it's our own construct. We've created, we've created that separation to the extent that I put a concept on this pattern. Just as when we put a concept of big dipper, that's the separating mechanism. You'll never look experiment.
Listen, let me close your eyes and listen. Is that inside or outside? When you're just with the experience, there's no bell, there's no ear, there's no inside, there's no outside, there's just hearing it. As soon as we put a concept of a year of value of bell or self of inside outside, there's the duality, there's the separation.
What I'm suggesting is not to throw out concepts, because actually big dipper is a very useful concept. From the big dipper, you can find the North Star. And it's very helpful. It's a helpful navigational tool.
With all the concepts that I've talked about, they all have their usage. There's a level of understanding which they're very appropriate. But we get fooled into thinking there's a kind of ultimate reality to them and that's where we get caught and attached. Because the reality of the physical sensations which are constantly changing, the material elements, consciousness constantly arising and passing away, these different mental factors arising and vanishing.
The fourth of the ultimate realities is the one that's the hardest to talk about. It's that which is called the unconditioned, on the Ivana. I'm going to suggest an image which may give you a sense of the possibility of what that is. Everything that we are is conditioned to phenomena.
Every consciousness's conditions, sensations, mental factors, the whole world, everything that's known is conditioned. Conditioned means that it arises because of causes. And whatever has the nature to arise must also pass away. All conditioned phenomena are impermanent.
Everything we know is conditioned. So everything we know, everything we experience is changing, is impermanent, is insubstantial in that way. There's also the unconditioned going beyond the norm, beyond the caused. Imagine, imagine a sphere, okay?
And everything that's known, everything, sensations and thoughts and emotions and buildings and concepts and the solar system and the galaxies and everything. The totality of everything that's known is on the surface of the sphere. What we've done is to separate out one tiny, tiny, tiny little corner of that whole realm of experience. We kind of put a fence around and call, this part of experience is made.
This is self. This is Joseph. And everything outside of that is other than me. Now imagine the center of the sphere.
What's the center? The center is a point. A point has no dimensions. There's no width, there's no breadth, there's no height.
We could think of it as the zero center. And then once a bed and text, talking about the unconditioned, analogous to the zero center, it says it is but it doesn't exist. That zero center is not an existing thing. It's zero.
And if that center point is what determines the sphere, it's a very crucial role. What happens in the practice is that as the mental factors of mindfulness, concentration of energy, there are certain factors of enlightenment which we're all cultivating. When they're all balanced and matured, drawn into a perfect course, and the mind is in that state of perfect balance, there's the possibility then of the intuitive opening to the uncondition to the zero center. It's going from what's known to what's unknown, unknowable.
From that perspective of the zero center, we see that we're not just one little part separated out on the surface. We live in illusion and the appearance of things. We live in the world of concepts and ideas. The easy reality, we are that reality.
When we understand this, we see that we are nothing. We come to the selflessness of the process. Being nothing, we are everything. When we're no longer separating ourselves out as being one part of experience, we become the totality.
And that's really what we're doing here. It's not the kind of feel-but although that may or may not happen. And it's not to get psychological insight or what that may or may not happen. But it's really to penetrate to the absolute center, to that zero, to that unconditioned center, from which there's an understanding of freedom.
Are there any questions? I don't think there's no fact of life. There are all conditions by different causes. In other words, and there's no ultimate beginning to where there are else from, but in any one segment, you can begin to see some conditioning.
There's a very simple sequence. We hear Adama talk. And from the talk, perhaps, the factor of faith of us is a confidence. Because of the confidence, that conditions effort.
The confidence conditions effort. The effort conditions, mindfulness, the mind conditions, wisdom. So it's just one factor conditioning another. As I mentioned this morning, some of the very crucial factors, feeling, meaning pleasantness of unpleasantness, which is a mental factor, conditions, craving, and aversion.
There's no one who's feeling aversion. There's no one who's craving. It's just this impersonal process working itself out. Because of feeling, because of pleasantness, when there's not attention, there's not mindfulness.
The feeling itself is what conditions craving or resistance. There's no one behind it. It's just a process playing itself out. And the power of the Buddhist enlightenment was that he penetrated and understood the nature of this conditioned process, which is an amazing, amazing discovery.
The kind of separation or discrimination of the mind in all the different mental factors is likened to taking a glass of water from the ocean and being able to tell drop by drop which river came from. And it takes the mind of a Buddha to do that. Unfortunately, we can benefit from his work. And we won't get that level of subtlety, but we can begin to see through observation how these different factors are working, how they condition one another.
I'd like to respond to a couple of things in that question. One is sometimes there's confusion because Western psychology uses the word ego in a different way than the Buddhist do. And it gets confusing because Western psychology, ego strength, is important and necessary. Ego in Western psychology, as I understand it, has to do ego is the pattern of personality, or the pattern of mind, the pattern of factors.
And in that sense, it is there. It is a pattern to it. And what's important is that the stability in that pattern, because the pattern is not stable, it's very difficult to function. It does not refer to some kind of essential unchanging essence.
And that's the sense in which the Buddha used the word ego, or how it's been translated, the sense of self- unchanging, unchanging eye. That's what's bound to be a concept. So you could think of it in terms of ego without self. The pattern is there, and the stability is important.
And what we're doing actually in our practice is making the mind more and more stable and balanced. In terms of different forms of mental illness, of course, there are tremendous subtleties to the ways in which the mind can get out of balance. But one of the underlying causes is when we lose, when people, when all of us pay attention to the content of our minds, I don't know about you, but I certainly be locked up. When you really pay attention to the whole range of what the minds are putting out, it's nuts.
And, well, it has the whole range. I mean, it's wonderful also, but it definitely has that totally insane sign to it. So that's not women's illness. That's not where it lies, because everybody's mind contains everything.
Where the mind gets into trouble is when the identifying factor is way, way out of balance, and people get locked in, totally identified, involved with a particular thought, a particular feeling, a particular image, and don't have any ability at all to separate out from it. And so what we're really doing on another level is creating the foundation of genuine mental health. That ability to be with whatever comes up, no matter how crazy or how bizarre, if there's no identification, whether there's no problem. It's just a thought, just a sign, just an image, just a feeling, coming and going.
If we're a collection of patterns in a very, very simple design, it's a balling in your own way, then just considering our functioning way, what about this body? So, then is the idea of free will and choice of self-worth is better or wrong? That question of free will and determinism is just inherent in that dichotomy, is endless discussion. And I remember when I was a freshman in college studying philosophy, hours and hours and hours and we just stay up nights arguing, free will, you know, there's choice of whatever things conditions happen to be choice.
And so my sense is just from having gone through that process is that somehow those concepts are not posed correctly. And I could not really give you a satisfactory philosophic answer. Experientially, it seems like they're both true. Everything is conditioned.
And also, there seems to be a choice that we can make to do one thing rather than another. So, good luck. Regarding the concept of ownership, with Mark Twain's courses of capture and illustration, from a point of view, the orientation of the horses, there is no sexuality yet. From a point of view of the people who were using the horses to a large degree to eliminate chaos, they actually is, the identification say, hey, I'm using this horse.
And are we not distinct between attachment in terms of greed or desire versus the fact that the ladies are doing their choices, they want to make one lady go in one pair of socks and somebody else wants another. So we do identify with the fact that, hey, this particular thing or object I'm using, and this one will be something that I won't. Right. I understand.
As I said, I was not suggesting that we throw out the concepts, because all of those concepts have a very effective use, perhaps would be chaotic, you know, without it. What I was suggesting that it is only a concept. It's a useful one. And we should employ it.
But when you actually look at the experience, what does it mean to own a sock? I mean, you put it on your foot and you can use it, as you say. It's like the concept has a function. The concept is useful, but it is only a concept.
And then when you come down to the experience, there's a certain relationship. They're seeing a color and feeling the sensation. And that was the distinction I was trying to make. Not that the concept wasn't useful because it is.
And we use it. But to see the difference between the concept and the actual experience. Does that make sense to you? I would like to ask a notion of self or a few words of psychology, ego.
All the systems suggested to me that do this practice well is very necessary to have a very well integrated sense of self, a great ego structure. And to know that all I try and see or try and stand what is going to develop in the first place. And the mental factors associated with strong ego, I guess, would be the surety experience in the world. A certain way, satisfaction, some of the desires that a young person would have in this world.
Whatever, financial gain, sex, death. And he said, okay, what was the justice, excuse me, fairly true. And in order to do this practice well, it is a good idea of sanity to have a good sense of self. Okay, absolutely.
But the problem is that we're using the word self or ego in different ways. And that's where the confusion comes from. Self or ego in the sense that you were using it, in terms of a stability or maturity of the pattern is helpful. And to some extent, as necessary, although it doesn't have to be super developed, at some minimal level of stability is necessary.
That kind of self or the self used in that way is different than the sense of an unchanging eye and unchanging me around which everything evolves. And that's the selflessness that's talked about in the practice. So it's really two different things that are being talked about. Okay, I think you're the kind of young man who really quite your body just wants to death.
So his sense of stuff is we have time and exactly in the Western psychological tradition for you to be healthy. Yeah, you get your attention. Maybe it's possible to be both remarkable and ironic. I hope so.
Okay, I think that if you have some more questions you could come up. As you go out into the walking as a way of actually applying this talk to your practice, as you walk, see if it's possible to drop into the level of experience where there's no concept of foot or leg or body or ground, but you actually drop into the level of momentary sensation. And if you want to do good things in terms of the elements of light and so having a movement or simply to be just with the momentary changing sensations that are felt. And you'll see the difference.
It's like the body dissolves into just a flow of changing feelings. And it's in that way that we get past the identification with attachment to the concept of body to the concept of self or me. And the walking is a good entranceway into this understanding. Thank you.
What the practice is developing is the balance to relationship to experience on all levels of perception. In other words, at certain levels we see on the sea body and we feel pain in the nature. So the balance relationship to that is just one of openness and acceptance. As the perception gets more refined and we get more and I call it the sub-atonic level, and it's just that momentary is not enough.
Again, what's being about is the proper relationship to it, which means no reaching out, no pushing away, is perfect every minute. Out of that perfect balance of mind, that's the condition. It's out of that balance that the mind can intuitively open to what's beyond that love to the unconditional zero. What about that?
He seems to have that point, but it seems to be more of a problem than there. I see what he just put into the book. Oh, that was way back in the book. I thought, Jesus, what are you playing?
Well, the last part of the story of Plato's cave, let's just have point, it's like somebody cuts the change and goes outside. But now there's two freeing in mind. Then goes back into the cave and as first is really stumbling around because it doesn't adjust. It's hard to adjust back.
In the same way, it's opening to the unconditioned. I'm going to talk more about this later on. Also goes in stages. The first glimpse, it obludes certain defiance of mind, but there's still many left.
It's an ongoing process in the integration of that totally radically different understanding. It takes time. It's like going back into the cave and getting re-accustomed to that. With full and light, one's totally free.
My guess is that there's no integration process. So that's the point that they require, they require God-walled guidance. It does. It does, although the force of understanding is so strong that even others can be rocketing difficult, it's only in one direction.
Who is mindfulness? Mindless, also, as I see plants in my nation, my nation is conditioned by faith, by companies, by effort. There's no one behind it, but because of certain causes in the 19th societies. Now, would you hear something?
And hearing something inspires, and inspires creates the effort, and the effort creates a mindfulness. So there's a whole sequence of causes of conditions behind the 19th. And sometimes you can see clearly, sometimes it's just arising in the moment, the conditions kind of, and you can see it's quite like... Joe, do you mean that it's a case of synchronicity where mind forms arise as synchronicity with the other kinds of patterns that are that constitute what we think of as ourselves, and it just happens in a synchronous way, so it sounds like it feels like we experience mindfulness.
Yeah, thank you. There's one book of the Abhidhamma, which is called the Book of Relations, which goes into great detail of how, of all the ways one moment conditions the next moment. My ninja knows it very well. Basically, I know that the book exists.
For people who have that kind of analytic mind, it's very interesting. For people who don't, it would be totally incomprehensible. And so for those of you who are interested, there's a way of studying it, to understand that. But for our purpose, there's no need to do that.
Yeah. And it's basically at whatever level of perception we have to see, a simple example with feeling and desire, to see how pleasant feeling conditions craving, and unpleasant feeling conditions resistance. It's like there's no one behind that. It's just those impersonal factors working.
Yeah, I was listening to you talk, I'm trying to get a sense of myself as this kind of changing pattern of things and so forth. And it's, to me, that's a concept. No. Right.
Right. So for me, the thing I can think of to do is simply go walk. Go practice. Exactly.
Do the practice not worry about that. Absolutely. It is probably the emphasis on practice during the retreat. And a lot of people can actually understand.
Is the positive is called the middle way? Yeah. Where's the ground? Where are you part?
Where's my, be called a task? No. Mindfulness is the ground. There's not a ground of experience.
It's a ground of relationship to experience. I'll give you an example of what was used. It is if you jump out of an airplane, and the first is just the exhalation of people, and then you go for the parachute, and you realize there's no parachute. Panic.
Fear. Kind of fall and fall and fall and terrified. Until further down the line, you realize there's no ground. Enjoy.
At first, when you realize the sense of seeing that continual change, at first is frightening. Because the mind wants to hold on to some security. Until you see the whole process. It's like there's no one there that's going to hit ground.
That's like realizing there's no ground. You just become the flow of changing experience. But you go through the same kind of perspectives that you would if you were falling out of the airplane. In that example, in the practice itself, you go through a lot of those stages, which I'm going to talk about.
If the inside is so available and the practice is relatively easy, if we can come here in a few days and have so much insight, increment away, whatever. And there's so much suffering in the world. And this inside and practice has been available for so many thousands of years. How come?
How come everybody isn't talk to us from the little kids? And how come everybody isn't doing it? Well, I couldn't ask you. No, really.
It doesn't. What? Sorry. I was going to say, isn't that because it hasn't been taught outside monasteries.
That's a good question. No, it's been taught. Is it available to none? No.
It's been taught in and out of monasteries over the day. Yeah. And in the Buddhist time, actually more lay people got enlightened amongst just because they were many more lay people. No, also to the years.
But here it is. And here we are. And how come? Okay, go into LA and try.
Tell me somebody. And then you'll see why. Not everybody's doing it. Because people's minds are very, very conditioned.
Attachment to opinion. Tremendous, attached to desires. And it takes a great deal of openness just to be willing to hear. What is your flexibility coming up for one's behavior?
It's all conditioned. It's totally responsibility because when you understand the law of karma, the fact that everything was done creates a certain result. I think they're not happening chaotically. They're not happening randomly.
Even though everything is conditioned? Precisely because everything is conditioned. In other words, when is an act based on greed, there's a certain result conditioned by that greed. And that result, in the case of greed is suffering.
The Buddha taught the three roots of suffering, greed, hatred, delusion. Those are the conditioning forces, factors of mind, the thing that came and there are wholesome things which can be happiness. When you realize that, then it's like this total responsibility because it's not dependent on anyone or any other being. The whole process is unfolding according to certain laws.
And here's where the responsibility is not outside. But that also gets tremendous responsibility and also tremendous sense of power and confidence because it is not dependent on anyone outside. And that's why we're going to take care of our directions. That's what Alan was talking about the first night, me at full pen.
All those ways to skillfully moment in moment. And mindfulness is the case. And that's if we're not mindful, we don't know what we're doing. And we're just playing out of the habit patterns.
In every moment of mindfulness, it's the strength and wholesome comment. Is that the free will then that chooses which acts? I those two words just get in the mind and trouble. It's confusing because if there is free will to choose our acts, then who is responsible for every will?
That's the question I've asked. Did you find the firm as the inflation? Right. And the position is also a condition factor.
I think those concepts will drive you nuts. And so I think it's better. Of course, it's interesting. And I spent, as I said, a long time in that discussion.
But I think it's more fruitful just to drop back into your momentary experience and see how it's happening rather than try to fit those concepts onto it. Because my intuitive sense is that they're both true. Yeah, isn't that one of Blake's contemporaries? Both things are true.
Children, I think it's important to get in the past and to get in the past. I'm going to get in the past. I'm sitting here in the last 50 days. And be here now.
And then you close your eyes. There are movies. And you go out, open your eyes and walk out. There are movies there.
You know, up here in the business, I'm not double. And I'll come here and close your eyes and go by again. And then we're chimes in. We're here now.
We're here. I mean, there's no here. And when you say it's the concept of language, the section here automatically inherently in our anyway, language, you'll be here. And it increases the sense of I am here.
You know, I've been building up there, but there's two three days and I haven't wonderful time with you today. I hope you know the good one. No. No, you're quite right though, because in the moments experience, all those concepts are common is an exam is called the sessionist.
Just what it is. Because every time we know what that could be. Please swap.