Skip to content
Ep. 139 – Understanding Desire episode artwork

Nov 2, 2022 1 hr 3 min

Ep. 139 – Understanding Desire

from Insight Hour with Joseph Goldstein

In helping us with understanding desire, Joseph Goldstein explores the three types of desire that the Buddha spoke of and offers several ways of working with desire in our practice. This podcast is sponsored by BetterHelp. Click to receive 10% off your first month with your own licensed professional therapist: betterhelp.com/insighthour This recording was originally published on Dharma Seed “Usually we think that what we want is the object. But really what we want is the pleasant feeling that we think is going to come with that experience.” – Joseph Goldstein

Episode details come from the podcast's RSS feed.

Embed this episode

Ready to play

Ep. 139 – Understanding Desire

0:00 1:03:08
of matches

Transcript Auto-generated, may contain errors

Not only does desire hinder concentration and obscure the natural clarity of mind, the natural openness of mind, but it also, in the end, does not fulfill its promise of happiness. Welcome to the Joseph Goldstein Insight Hour. This podcast is an expression of our shared interest in self-discovery. Join Joseph as he shares his deep knowledge of the path of mindfulness.

If you are interested in supporting this podcast, please go to beherenownetwork.com. The nature of our minds is clear, it's lucid, it's unobstructed. The nature of the mind is simply to know what's arising. The nature of the mind is awareness.

But somehow we don't recognize this simplicity, the empty open nature of awareness itself. We find that we get distracted, we get seduced, we get caught up, in a whole variety of ways, through some very long-established habit patterns, the tendencies. Habits of thought, habits of feeling that catch us again and again. Often these patterns, or these habits, are so familiar to us, there's so much a part of who we take ourselves to be that they remain invisible, so as if we become so identified with them that we really don't even see them.

And it's for this reason that we need to bring a very focused and clear and attentive mindfulness to the working of our own minds, so that we really can begin to see the forces, the tendencies, the conditioned habits that are at play. This is not an easy task. Buddha gave an image of how difficult it is. He said that it would be easier to conquer a thousand enemies in battle, single-handedly, and to do that a thousand different times.

But that would be easier than to train the mind, to awaken the mind. So if you're having some difficulties, it's not that it's a mistake, that you're doing anything wrong. This is a very profound and difficult task. What the Buddha saw, and what we can see for ourselves, very clearly in our practice, is that the underlying causes of happiness and of suffering, in our own lives and in the world, are forces within the mind.

Very often we look out or about in the world and we see the suffering that exists, the suffering of injustice, of exploitation, of violence, is a long list. The underlying causes of the suffering are the forces of greed, are the forces of fear, are the forces of hatred. And the very essential discovery and recognition is that these habits, these forces of mind, are not only out there, they are within ourselves. One of the deepest and most strongly conditioned energies or patterns in the mind, and one which together with ignorance, is at the very root of our endless cycling through Samsara, is the tendency or the habit or the conditioning of desire.

So we need to understand this very carefully, very exactly. The word desire in English has quite a few different meanings. So we need to define precisely which desire we're talking about. Because one meaning of desire is that of greed.

One meaning of desire is that of motivation. And we have a desire to do something. We're motivated to do something. That might be unwholesome.

It might be very wholesome and skillful. So this meaning of desire is different than greed. There's also the desire which entails the satisfying of just basic human needs. You know, food and water and shelter.

And so this again is not the force of greed. In talking about desire this evening, talking about that quality in the mind which is craving, which leads to clinging, which leads to grasping. In the often typical translation of poly, kind of like Victorian English translation, one way they translated this poly word, which is tannha, the fever of unsatisfied longing. That kind of sounds like a Victorian romance.

But it actually touches something. Maybe we're all characters in this great novel. This is the kind of desire I'm talking about. That of greed.

That of craving. Of unsatisfied longing. Of thirsting. That quality in the mind.

The Buddhist folk of three kinds of desire. Three kinds of craving. One we're quite familiar with. And that's the craving for sense-platters.

And that's the kind of desire that's very operative in the world. Second kind of desire he mentioned is the desire for rebirth. Craving for rebirth. And often this is in the context of desire for rebirth in the heavenly realms.

And the third kind of desire, the Buddha talked about, the third kind of craving, is desire for not being reborn. Sometimes when people hear this, these three kinds of desire, the first we can usually relate to, quite easily we understand it. But sometimes the second to seem a little philosophical or abstract. I don't really have the strong craving for rebirth in the heavenly realms.

And I don't think much about being not reborn. But as is often the case within my experience with the teachings of the Buddha, very often something which at first glance does not seem so applicable to my life. When we examine it a little more deeply, or investigate it a little more deeply, it's actually pointing to something very profound. This desire for rebirth will not to be reborn.

Desire either way. Reflect some very basic assumptions about our lives, about how we choose to live. It's pointing to something very deep in us. On the one hand it points to a belief or an assumption or an idea of ongoing life.

Do we have that worldview, that something, some aspect of ourselves lives forever? The Buddha called this the eternalist view. Or do we have the idea, are we living our lives with the assumption that at death it's all over? The Buddha called that the annihilationist view.

And all of us in one way or another, whether it's articulated clearly or not, we're living our lives with one assumption or the other. Either we think it's going to go on, or we think it's going to end. And this belief, even if we're not clearly conscious of it, very much conditions, the choices we make. What the Buddha pointed out is the big problem in both of these beliefs.

We all have one or the other, and yet there's an inherent difficulty in both. Because Earth, the re of these kinds of desires, desire for sense pleasures, desire for rebirth, and the heavenly realms desire for no rebirth, all are constellated around the idea of someone being there. All are constellated around the idea of self. And whether we are conscious of it or not, to the degree that we're caught in these desires, we have these belief systems, we are operating out of illusion.

We can begin to explore very pragmatically this force of desire in our lives when we look at our closest attachments. When we look at the attachments, the closest attachments in our lives, that's when we can see desire at work. For example, we can look at the attachment we have to our bodies. And most of us are pretty identified with our body.

We don't like it when our body gets sick. As it's aging, as it gets older in the face of death. Are we really free in that? Are we free of attachment?

Or are we holding on in some way or other? We can see desire operate very clearly. This is something we all know very well. We can see desire operate in our attachments to people, certain people in our lives.

We can see desire operate in terms of certain things that we want. It's interesting to begin to notice carefully the range of intensity of desire, because it's a very broad spectrum. Sometimes we experience the desire of an overwhelming passion, an obsessive passion, which consumes our lives. People get caught up in this and a lot of great literature is precisely about this kind of desiring.

That's true. I mean, some very great books have been written about this all-consuming passion that can take over in the often destructive consequences of it. Desire can be felt in the form of whatever particular addictive cravings we have. And we all have some about something.

We can see desire at work in recurring fantasies. We're just either sitting on retreat or in our lives just the play of fantasies over and over again. That's an expression of desire. Or even in a very minor way.

Something that happens countless times during the day. We can see desire in just the passing point of wanting something. It's not big. It's not consuming.

Just a thought of wanting rise in the mind and this desire in that. On retreat, the field of desire narrows considerably. I mean, in the world outside we have great scope for the fulfillment of all these things. Here it's a little more limited.

But it doesn't really stop the desire from arising. It just finds a little smaller, smaller domain. In other places, I've noticed it most embarrassingly when I've been on retreat. As I can be doing walking meditation back and forth and very mindful and very connected and very clear.

And I notice the difference between that and how I walk when the lunch bell rings. It's very subtle. It's just that little anticipation which is kind of pulling me along. What is that?

It's just the energy of wanting. It's interesting to see actually somatically how that energy of wanting manifests. It is precisely this. That energetic leaning forward.

It's not restful. It's pulling us out of balance. In this retreat environment, everything's very quiet. People are just sitting and walking.

But the force of desire in the mind. Often we go through periods of tremendous sexual fantasies. All of a sudden, I have a nice hour to sit here. Let's have a good time.

And we go through the balance of this. In the mind, it gets really pulled in. It gets very seduced by it. Or even just getting lost or enjoying our own internal dramas.

It doesn't even have to be particularly exciting. But there's some desire which pulls us again and again and again into whatever dramas we happen to be. We're reliving. Sometimes we see desire in this context.

In a very subtle form, it's just that attitude or that energy of wanting diversion. That's a kind of desire too. You've probably noticed how amazingly difficult it is to pass the balloon board without looking at it. Just in case the new notices happen.

What's important in all this is not that these shouldn't be happening or shouldn't be arising. What's important is that we want to take the opportunity of the retreat to really look at deeply what exactly is happening in our minds. How is this force of desire which runs the whole gamut from consuming to very minor? How is it working in our minds and our lives?

How is it obscuring the natural clarity, the natural openness? We want to discover this for ourselves. It's not a question of just believing what somebody says or reading it in the Buddhist texts. The whole point, the purpose of the retreat is to take this time and to investigate very carefully.

This is a powerful energy. It's at the root of samsara. Can we really look at it? Can we understand it?

In meditation practice, desire also slips in in quite an obstructive way in the form of expectation. It's very insidious because sometimes expectation comes disguised as right effort. We think, oh yeah, I'm just making right effort here, but really it's effort, effort, mesca, rating. Expectation, mesca, rating as effort.

That sends in the mind of wanting something to happen. This expectation can also take the form of comparing minds. We compare our practice in our minds with others, get into competitive sitting. It's a race for enlightenment, it's a race for whatever, some experience.

I got caught by this in one retreat I did. It was the first retreat I sat outside with on Dita and it was very intense and a lot of my friends were sitting and there was this sort of pressure. Of course it was self-imposed and I was getting to the finish line. It was a tremendous obstacle.

I was making myself more and more tight and intense. I was kind of comparing how am I doing that to everybody else here. It was all just projections in my own mind. I had a great teaching from the flowers that were growing right out in the frontier.

I was doing some walking meditation. This was in the spring. Very much caught up in this kind of expecting mind. It was really filled with desire, filled with wanting.

I noticed the flowers and some of them had just begun to come out of the ground. They were just beginning to come out. Other flowers had grown a little taller and the bud was formed. Some of the other flowers, the bud was formed and actually opened the lady.

I thought that those flowers and I realized each one of these is going to blossom in its own time. Nobody's racing. None of them are racing the other others now. This was the natural development, the natural progression for each one.

That was such a good lesson for me at that time, just to relax. I simply had to do my practice and after that it was surrendering to the Dharma. It seemed to let it all happen, let it all unfold as it inevitably does. That was a very helpful lesson to see and understand.

Sometimes desire, practice is in the form of expectation of wanting something to happen. Sometimes desire comes in the form of trying to hold on to some state, which either we have or we had. We had a great sitting and we go into the next sitting with this desire for it to be back. Trying to recreate past experience is like dragging a corpse around.

It's gone. It's over. It's finished. Did.

Let it go. It's such a relief. We don't have to be recreating anything. We simply have to be settled back and open to what's presenting itself.

So that's very simple. There's no pressure in that. There's no tension. There's no wanting.

The desire of expectation always brings restlessness and discouragement. So we want to see this. This is one of the aspects of desire that we want to see very clearly for ourselves. Because when we're filled, when we're caught by expectation, in those moments, we are no longer being mindful and no longer being attentive.

We're no longer aware of simply what's there. So the mindfulness gets weaker. As the mindfulness gets weaker, the mind gets more agitated. It gets more restless as we get more restless.

We get more discouraged. So it's just the spiral downward. Where does it all start? It started with that unnoticed desire of expectation.

We need to see all this very clearly for ourselves. What happens is that we get seduced. We get entranced by various objects of desire, whether they're internal states, whether they're external states. It's like we start walking in this enchanted forest.

We're in this dreamlike state where all we can think about, or our whole reality is for the fulfillment of that wanting. It's all about whatever particular object it is. And we no longer see the very passing nature, the very impermanent nature, both of the wanting and of the object of wanting. A very, very easy example of this is in the well-experienced phenomenon of the Vipassana romance.

You know, people come on retreat in silence, maybe barely know one another. And yet at some point or another, the mind has this tendency to just feel this attraction towards one of the other people here. And the level of projection that can go on is truly staggering. It's like our minds get, I don't know what's strong enough word.

They get captured in prison, something, you know, by the thought of this person. Kind of doing walking meditation. The person happens to walk by sneaky glands and there's a kind of excitement in rush. And if you happen to be sitting next to them and dining room will purposely go on, and this is dining room to sit next to them.

And this whole drama is created. It has consumed a lot of airtime in this whole. In the last 20 years. So again, we just want to see it.

Instead of, it's not that we want to judge it or not. It's just that we understand this very powerful force of wanting. Not only does desire hinder concentration and obscure the natural clarity of mind, the natural openness of mind. But it also, in the end, does not fulfill its promise of happiness.

Now why is it that we keep getting caught by desires? Because it holds out this promise to us. You do this, you get this, you have this, and you'll be happy. And there's that little voice of Mara in our minds, which is very insistent.

What we go after these different sense pleasures because of the pleasant feelings that come. But as you know and will know with even greater clarity and depth, these pleasant feelings are very impermanent. So what happens? We're always going after another one.

And another one, another one, and another one. And this is how we've been living our lives. It's not just on retreat. We keep looking for happiness in the fulfillment of one kind of desire or another.

It's endless. How many desires have we fulfilled in our lives? Countless. Of all kinds.

You know, from the small little ones to quite big and dramatic ones. But there is no end because the pleasant feelings that come from them are very impermanent. So we feel them and they're gone and it leaves us wanting more. This doesn't mean that we shouldn't enjoy things.

That's not the implication of all this. It doesn't mean that we should never act on our desires. What it does mean is that we should see very clearly, and with a very penetrating wisdom, the impermanent transitory nature of it all. And we can really ask ourselves the question in our practice and in our lives.

How much of our life do we want to invest in the fulfillment of these designers? And how big a part of our life do we want to spend in doing this? At one time I was on retreat and I was sitting, I was just going through this run of thoughts. You know, that I was really getting into.

I was just enjoying it. Now I can't even remember what they were about. And at a certain point, I just gave myself a talking to him. And I said, do you want to think, do you want to be free?

And it just kind of crystallized the choices that I was making. It's not that thoughts stop coming, but we can that sense of indulgence. Let me go into this one for a little bit. When we see clearly what's happening, that really gives us the space of choice.

If we don't see what's happening, then we're just acting out all the old habits of our conditioning. So desire for sense pleasures in all the ways, whether it's the physical sense pleasures, whether it's the expectation in practice, whether it's diversion, whether it's great passion, whether it's addictions, whatever it is. Desire for sense pleasures, one kind or another. This is the first kind of craving.

The second kind of craving we're going to talk about was craving for rebirth, particularly heavenly rebirth. The Buddha talked a lot about the heaven-noms. You know, and he talked about it by way of delighting the mind, creating a sense of joy, creating a sense of happiness. And the descriptions are wonderful.

When I first went to India, in practice with Manindra Jai, he would spend a lot of time talking about these sounds, and beings born with bodies of light, and everything beautiful, and they're born around age 16 or 17, just they appear spontaneously, and just ready to enjoy things. The description of these pleasure groves in heavenly musicians, and it's like complete the right on every side. There are even heavenly meditation holes, you know, where we, in our bodies of light, consist in practice, and it's said that Madreya, the coming Buddha, is now residing in one of these heaven-noms to sit around, actually teaching the Dharma. In all of the Buddhist traditions, there are these descriptions of these realms from people who have experienced them in one way or another.

Now as Westerners, I think we tend to have some skepticism about it all, and it reminds me of a comment that Manindra used to make as he would be going on and on about these heaven-noms, and seeing books of, if not disbelief, questioning among the Westerners. He would go on very enthusiastic and excited. You don't have to believe this. You don't have to believe it.

It's true, but you don't have to believe it. Then he would proceed to go on. So on the one hand, sort of the talk or the thought or the reflection of the Devarams really do create a brightness in the mind, and if we can open to the possibility of real delight, on the other hand, this kind of desire also is a trap, and it's like the B buzzing around in the jar thinking, oh, maybe I'll buzz on up to the top for a while, the top of the jar, see what's doing up there. It can go to the top, it can go to the bottom, it's still caught in the jar.

With the desire for rebirth, or even heavenly rebirth, or heavenly pleasures, heavenly delights, or if you don't so much connect with that possibility, you can think of it in terms of desire for heavenly states of mind, heavenly meditative experiences, wanting that kind of experience. It's still being trapped in the jar. It's still being trapped in the cycle of birth and death, and that's why the Buddha talked about this as the second and very important kind of craving of desire to see in ourselves. Are we after something?

Are we after rebirth, whether it's next life or next sitting, or tomorrow? Are we after a rebirth in some realm, in some happy realm? We need to see that, and that can very much condition how we practice. Are you practicing in order to have some experience?

That's a kind of craving, it's a kind of desire. And what it's doing in a way that may not be noticed is that it's strengthening the sense of self. It's strengthening that sense of I who wants something, and that's precisely what keeps us bound. In the same way that their kind of desire for no rebirth does exactly the same thing.

This is the annihilationist view, thinking that it's all over. What we want it to be all over, is also is predicated on the view of self, the idea that there's someone there not to be reborn. This matter is at the heart of suffering and freedom. So it's really important to begin to see how it's operating in our own minds, in our own experience.

The great discovery in practice, really the great awakening, the great illumination, is that there is no one there to either be reborn or not to be reborn. That the very notion of self, the very idea of self, the very concept of self is an illusion. And it's only the ignorance of this, the fact that we don't see it, and the desires which keep coming out of this ignorance that keeps us revolving, in some sort, on this cycle of birth and death. And you can think of it over lifetimes, you can think of it over a single lifetime, you can think of it in a single sitting.

It's a right-wing way, way, way. It's actually an Englishman lived in China and Hong Kong. Very, very wonderful writer. I thought this whole notion of the desires coming out of the sense of self, coming out of that ignorance.

Whether it's desire for sense pleasure, desire for rebirth, desire for not rebirth, or all of it, he said, is like a dog walking up a tree that isn't there. That's what we're doing. We're walking up this tree of self, and it's not there. So how can we use the time of the retreat, and particularly a retreat like this, where there's enough time to really go quite deeply into these matters?

And we can look with very great precision and exactitude in order to understand how desire, in all of these manifestations, how this energy, how this force is working, is conditioning our lives, conditioning our suffering. Most importantly, the most important way of being with it is to be aware when it arises. Because mostly we're not. As I said, it's become so much a part of who we are.

It's usually invisible to us. So as you're going through the day, you really want to keep an eye out. Keep the awareness open so that you see desire as it arises. Recognize the wanting mind, whatever the wanting is for.

It's some fantasy, it's wanting diversion, it's wanting some meditative state, whatever. Really pay attention to those moments of the mind wanting, the desiring of craving. Not with a sense of judgment. Not with a sense of, oh, this is bad, I shouldn't be feeling this, not at all.

It's almost a sense of welcoming it because it's a chance to understand it. This is a great laboratory for you. You can really look and see how is this working in my mind and in my life. Notice the many times a day that it arises.

You're not going to have to wait long. So little things, just little moments of wanting. You hear sound and if you really attend there maybe you'll notice just that moment of wanting to turn to see what it is. Just like something as simple as that.

The head by itself doesn't turn. There's a whole process involved. What is not wanting? What is that desire?

Can you see it? Notice all of these little moments and sometimes every big moments which take you away from the simplicity of simply knowing. The nature of the mind is awareness. It's open, it's lucid, it's clear, it's unobstructed.

There's great simplicity in that. It's desire which obscures that simplicity. So we want to see for ourselves how it's happening. That is no longer theoretical.

We actually, we grock it. Keep in mind that desire is not the problem. It's the identification with the desire. It's the being lost in the desire.

It's not knowing that it's present. That's where the problem is. As you notice these desires arising in the mind, these moments of wanting. See if you can discern how the identification with that desire in a moment actually solidifies a sense of self.

You can feel it. You can feel the contraction of energy. When we get identified with a wanting. The wanting itself is fine.

When we get identified with it. In that moment you can feel it. It's like the contraction of self has been created. So this is very interesting just to look to see.

So it's one way of really beginning to work with desire. Another way is by investigating and exploring the joy of renunciation. Now for some people that phrase, I don't know if I'm using this word right, it's an oxymoron. The joy of renunciation.

That can't be. Because many of us have conditioned to think of renunciation as a great burden. This is a great line from St. Augustine where he's praying to God and says, Dear Lord, make me chaste, but not yet.

And that's generally our spirit of thinking about renunciation. It's good for me, but not quite yet. Or else we do something. We actually have this act of renunciation, sort of like eating beats as a kid.

You know, well, I don't really like it, but it'll be good for me. So very often that's our conditioned way of thinking about renunciation. But we can begin to see it in a completely different way. And it's in a way that really liberates our minds.

And that is we begin to see that addiction is the burden. And that letting go is the freedom. There's one or two examples of this. Just imagine, you know, you're sitting, not now, of course, but before you came here.

You're sitting, watching TV. And there are these endless commercials. Just imagine what it would be like if you wanted everything that was advertised. What the hell the hell?

No, it was. You know, if everything that was advertised, I want that. But fortunately, you know, we've been de-conditioned with regard to the advertisements on TV to a large extent, you know, most of us mute them. So we've learned it about TV, but we haven't really learned it about the commercials in our minds.

All the desires that come up, it's the same principle though. To want everything. You know, that presents itself as an object of desire. I want this, I want this, I want that.

There's a tremendous suffering in that addiction and there's tremendous ease in being able to let them go. Renunciation is not the burden, it's the one thing that's the burden. So if we see this and we have a taste of that, it actually reinforces our ability to still let things pass through. I had another experience of this in practice on retreat.

I was sitting and things were going along quite well. You know, things were just rolling along smoothly. And I had this image that I was just on this highway, or the freeway, when I was pike. And I think on the long coast and cruising along, and then it'd be this big billboard on the side of the road.

Oh, amusement park. Take this exit, whatever our particular amusement park is. And I could just see my mind, I was watching my mind. See this big billboard.

Oh, go visit that. And it's like I would get off the exit, you know, and down the road and play a little while and whatever it was. And then I just have to come back and get back on the freeway. As I noticed this over time, I began to get a little better.

And actually seeing the billboard. I wrecked, oh yeah, that's a billboard. But still the tendency was quite strong. And I find myself still there in the off the exit, but not actually going all the way down the road.

I get off the exit and I see it and I get back on. After going through this a number of times, my mind wised up a little bit, I saw the billboard and I realized I didn't need to get off the exit. Okay, there's this billboard. I'll do this, go here, enjoy this.

I could just see that billboard and stay cruising on the highway. We can change our relationship to this proliferation of desire that arises in the mind. It's not that they're going to stop coming, but we don't have to buy in. We don't have to get off the exit each time.

It comes through awareness, comes through seeing. Look carefully at times when desire is present and when you're caught in it. Whatever it is, you know, to desire for something or lost in a fantasy, whatever. Really pay careful attention to the experience of being lost and then how it feels when we wake up, when we come out of it.

Just notice the difference in your experience. And I think you'll notice that there is a sense of great relief. It's like being let out of the grip of something. Even if the desire was pleasant, even if there was a certain enjoyment to it, compared to the letting go, there's a tightness, there's a tension, there's a bondage.

And you can see that clearly if you watch the transition moment. You're in it, you're in it, you're in it, and then a certain moment. And it's just like being let out of the grip of wanting. So pay attention to that.

So you really know for yourself from the inside, yeah, this desire, this wanting, this craving is suffering. And we don't have to keep by and into it. One of the great liberating insights around desire that comes from being on retreat with is not that much opportunity to fulfill a great many of them. Is the insight, the understanding that desires do not have to be fulfilled to go away.

And mostly in our lives, that's the assumption. We're filled with some strong desire for something. If I don't do it, if I don't get it, if I don't have it, it's going to be gnawing at me. So I have to fulfill it in order to come to peace.

One of the things that we see so clearly on retreat, just through the power of awareness, of being settled back, watching it all come and go, the desire is there, it's there, it's there, it's there, it's there. And then it's not there. That is a tremendous insight. We realize we don't have to do anything about them.

We don't have to act on them. It gives us the space in our lives, then to make some wise choices. There's one more little piece about desire. One, two, mention.

And this gets into a more subtle level of understanding why it's such a strong force in our lives. And why it's so difficult for us to get a handle on it. One of the things that we can begin to notice is that it's not actually the object or the experience that we have the desire for. It looks like that.

On the surface it seems like that. But really what the desire is for is for the pleasant feeling that we anticipate getting with that experience, or that object. To see the difference because there's quite an amazing freedom which comes from understanding this distinction. Usually we think that what we want is the object.

But really what we want is the pleasant feeling that we think is going to come with that experience. How is this freeing? To see it seeing this. And I've noticed this.

And as I've watched desire in my own mind how I get caught again and again. And I've done this with little things. We don't have to be talking about grand passions here. We're talking about the ordinary common place movement of wanting in the mind.

I find myself justifying the wanting mind by the thought, well I'm not really attached to this cup of tea. You know there's a wanting cup of tea and I'm not really attached to it. And so then just go ahead and do it. Because I'm not really attached to it.

Or I'm not really attached to looking at the bulletin board for a thousand times. And I'm not. And so go ahead and do it. It's precisely because that statement is true.

That we miss what's underneath it. It is true. I'm not attached to that cup of tea. And I'm not attached to the bulletin board.

I'm not attached to whatever particular thing it is. Because that's true. I'm missing. I'm overlooking the most subtle attachment to the pleasant feeling that I think will be there in that experience.

And when I reflect on that, I see yes that's what's propelling the movement. And I am attached. I am wanting that pleasant feeling. Seeing this difference for me has been very helpful.

Because I begin to see accurately the pattern or the forces, the way the conditioning is playing itself out. And when I realize before doing something, yeah it's not the object. I'm not attached to that. But when I see, oh yeah there's this wanting for the pleasant feeling.

When I recognize that along with that very often comes the understanding. That feeling is really. There's not much there. When my mind is really focused on what really is happening.

I say, it's not worth the effort just for those few moments of pleasant feeling. And so there's a lot more freedom in the mind. Again, it's not that we never have the cup of tea or that we never do whatever it is. What can we do it from a place of discriminating wisdom?

From really seeing what's going on rather than from blindly acting out is very deep pattern. And if a person means seeing clearly, and Krishna Merti expressed this very beautifully, he said, it's the truth which liberates not our efforts to be free. That's what we're doing here. It's really investigating deeply enough so we see how these forces of bondage are working in our minds, in our lives.

I think the great gift and power and beauty of the retreat, especially this one, is that it gives you enough time to settle in, to concentrate the mind, and to look deeply. And to look deeply from a place of interest, of wanting to discover the mystery of all this. How we get so entangled, how we can become free in this. Learning about desire on retreat, seeing it clearly, begins to free us in the face of desire in our lives outside.

We know when to act on it, when to let go. The mind is clear. The mind is unobstructed. The mind is lucid.

The mind is open. The mind is empty. Desire comes as a visitor. It's not in the nature of the mind itself.

It comes as a visitor when conditions are there. When it comes, we want to see. We want to see deeply into it. I know the other night, Michelle, or more morning, Michelle mentioned how we don't want to practice too tightly.

We don't want to practice too loosely. Just the Buddha gave that instruction to one of the monks' name was Soma, who had been a musician. And he talked about how the strings have to be just right, have the music be beautiful in the same way our effort has to be just so beautiful. Our effort has to be just not too tight, not to lose.

And the Buddha closed this teaching to Soma at the monk. He said, the gift of truth is the highest gift. And the taste of truth is the sweetest taste. And the joy of truth is the greatest joy.

And this is what our practice is about. Let's sit for a few minutes.

Frequently asked questions

How long is this episode of Insight Hour with Joseph Goldstein?

This episode is 1 hour and 3 minutes long.

When was this Insight Hour with Joseph Goldstein episode published?

This episode was published on November 2, 2022.

Is there a transcript available for this episode?

Yes, a full transcript is available for this episode. You can read the complete transcript on the episode page.

Can I download this Insight Hour with Joseph Goldstein episode?

Yes. Use the download control on the episode player to save the publisher-provided media file.