Skip to content
Ep. 140 – Carrying Practice Into the World episode artwork

Nov 10, 2022 57 min

Ep. 140 – Carrying Practice Into the World

from Insight Hour with Joseph Goldstein

In this dharma talk, Joseph Goldstein describes the art of carrying our practice into the world through training in the areas of Right Effort, concentration, and wisdom. This dharma talk from February 1994 at the Insight Meditation Society Retreat Center was originally published on Dharma Seed. "You know, the Dharma's so beautiful because it's like everything feeds into everything else. And we can really begin to be leading our life with this kind of integration. Dharma practice is not a hobby that we do occasionally, it's really how we're living our life." – Joseph Goldstein

Episode details come from the podcast's RSS feed.

Embed this episode

Ready to play

Ep. 140 – Carrying Practice Into the World

0:00 57:28
of matches

Transcript Auto-generated, may contain errors

Now the dawn is so beautiful because it's like creating feeds into everything else. And we can really begin to be leading our life with this kind of integration. Dawn of Practice is not a hobby, you know, that we do occasionally. It's really how we live in our life.

Welcome to the Joseph Goldstein Insight Hour. This podcast is an expression of our shared interest in self-discovery. Join Joseph as he shares his deep knowledge of the path of mindfulness. If you are interested in supporting this podcast, please go to beherenownetwork.com I think the main question that really arises for people is how can we carry the practice out into the world?

You know, here there's a very supportive environment everybody's doing the same thing, more or less. Because you never quite know what people are doing. Out in the world though, it's really not a lot of support. People are not going around repeating phrases of love and kindness all day.

So how do we actually integrate it? I think there are two important principles to keep in mind. The first is that the same effort, the same kind of right effort that's needed on retreat is needed outside of retreat. But this is usually not how we imagine.

I know that there's often a feeling, well, we'll come into our work on retreat and we'll really put energy in the persevering. And then somehow as the reward of having done that, we can go back into our lives and just coast and hope it follows us. I think that's not a helpful way to look at it because it doesn't work. In some way you could think of retreat time as time of learning how to practice right effort.

We learn about how to make correct effort on the spiritual path so that when we leave, we can continue it. Not that we stop it. The Buddha said very explicitly that when we practice wisdom and compassion and love, it becomes stronger. When we don't practice, they become weaker.

So it's not like it's something we get and then we have as a possession. It's a dynamic process. When it's practiced, it continues to get stronger. When it's not practiced, it continues to get weaker.

So we need to really internalize this understanding because it becomes then an inspiration to really keep the practice going. So how do we make effort in the world? What's the nature of our practice? Obviously, it's not going to be in the same form as it is here.

How do we make our life all practice? The Buddha addressed this very clearly. That's what's so amazing about the teachings. It's so direct and so clear and so straightforward.

He talked about three areas of training. But this is what the spiritual path consists of. These three areas of training. The first is a training in morality, truly the training in right action where we pay careful attention to the kinds of actions we take in the world.

With the reference point, are these actions wholesome or are they unwholesome? Are they skillful or are they un-scopable? Are they leading happiness? Are they leading to more suffering?

We can examine this or investigate this in several different ways. We can take a look at our actions in terms of how they affect us in the moment. When we're angry, what is the effect on us? When we're loving, what is the effect on us?

So we're really noticing we're watching. When we're engaged in various activities, how is that influencing the quality of our minds? It's uncomplicated. We just have to look.

We have to be awake enough, aware enough, interested enough, not simply to be living on automatic, but really watching. As we engage in the various activities we are, in working relationships and all the busyness of our lives, as we go through the day, we're paying attention to the quality of our minds. So we see, we see for ourselves, yes, this is a good thing to be doing. This is not a good thing to be doing.

Or maybe we're doing a good thing in not a very good way. I mean, a very simple example of that. We could engage in engagement and basic, clean wholesome activity. But maybe we're kind of in a rush, kind of rushing through it.

So we're getting tight, even though the activity itself might be worthwhile. That's just one tiny example. We need to pay attention. So one way is to notice how our actions affect ourselves.

Another way is to notice how our actions affect other people. And really to refine our sensitivity to the effect our energy has and our use of energy. Because sometimes we may not be intending to be hurtful or harmful, but out of delusion in mind. Or just not paying attention, we might be.

So it's a very beautiful practice too. As we go through our life to really pay attention to the effect of our actions or energy of our movements, the effect that has on the people around us. So we look at how our actions affect ourselves. We pay attention to how they affect other people.

We also look at the long range consequences of our actions. And this is the whole understanding below of karma, which is so essential to Dharma practice, to understanding. It's basic teaching of the Buddha. He called the law of karma the light of the world because it illuminates that which leads to suffering and that which leads to happiness.

It's the understanding that our actions have consequences. They're not just happening in the moment and then disappearing. It's like dropping a stone in water and we drop the stone and it ripples out. The key to examining the karmic consequences of our actions and really taking responsibility in that way is learning to look at carefully and honestly our motivations.

Because karma unfolds according to the motivation, not according to the action. And when one Tibetan teaching says everything rests on the tip of motivation and it's a beautiful expression. It's like everything comes down to that point. What is the motive behind our actions, behind our speech, behind what we're doing in the world?

And it's very subtle. So we have a lot of mixed motives. A big part of spiritual awakening, spiritual path, is just to look very honestly. Okay, what?

Why am I doing this? Is it out of greed? Is it out of fear? Is it out of love?

Is it out of compassion? Is it out of understanding? Is it out of boredom? And when we bring this kind of investigation to our lives, it's easy to see how our whole life becomes the path.

It's not a question of just coming to retreat. It's about how we're living. A very helpful reference point for looking at our motivation, which is very subtle. We really need help, not to look at it because we often can't exactly see what it is.

But just as a starting place in that, is the appreciation and the refinement of the five precepts. Now that really gives us kind of just a basic level reference point for whether our actions are motivated by wholesome or on wholesome forces. And just as a reminder, I'm sure you're familiar with them. I'm not killing.

And really pay attention to times when we might be motivated to swap them a seat over the logo, whatever. And just if we're aware of that research, can we stop? Is there another way? No, not stealing.

But really looking at that in a larger context, sort of wise use of resources. Not committing sexual misconduct. No one retreat is easy because the precept is interpreted as no sexual activity at all, but out in the world. This is a big part of many people's lives, intimate sexual relationships.

As you all know, this is a very powerful energy. It really drives us a lot in our lives at different times. We need to be very careful with it so that we use that energy in a loving way, in a caring way, not in a way that's harmful either to ourselves or others. In the throes of passion, people can get in a lot of trouble.

Because it's such a strong force that often we rationalize our behavior. A behavior that might be quite harmful to ourselves too. Others might involve us in dishonesty, in deception, in exploitation. So it's just to understand that this is also a part of our spiritual practice.

It's not outside of it. We really look at that and use the precept. Not killing, not stealing, not getting involved in sexual misconduct, not lying. There's a lot around speech.

It's a huge area. It's a huge area in terms of bringing our attention to it, in looking at our motivations. In the course of our daily lives, we talk a lot. That's the main vehicle of our communication, one another.

But I think very few people really pay attention consciously to the quality of their speech. It's mostly, we go on habit. How many times is there actually a space between the thought in the mind and what comes out of the mouth? It's difficult to create a little space there.

Because not everything that comes into the mind is worth vocalizing. I mean, on the most sort of basic level, we refrain from basically dishonesty, saying things which aren't true. And that has a lot of refinement. We could think, oh, I don't lie.

We probably all do. We exaggerate. We try to protect somebody. In a many different ways, we might be actually shading the simplicity of what is true.

It's a very powerful exercise to be committed not to lie, not to say in what is in truth. It also doesn't mean that we go around telling everybody the truth of what we think about them. You know, that's an extreme on the other side. The Buddha gave a very helpful guideline for right speech.

He said, say that which is true and that which is useful. But something might be true and not useful in the moment, because somebody is not in space to hear it or it's not the right circumstances. But two really simple things is it true and it's useful. I have noticed so many times in my life just being in a social situation, just taking out with friends in a group.

And I can see impulse is coming up in my mind to say something often totally useless. It's just there is no need to say what sort of has no benefit to anybody. And when I can see that and just see that impulse and let it go, just let it come and go, the mind feels much more peaceful. It's not continually pumping out everything within me.

We're just kind of resting in that space. These thoughts are impulse as they come, but there's enough awareness. Yeah, I don't need to say that. And then we really kind of rest in the quality of inner peace.

Watch how often speech involves speaking about other people. That was another great teaching for me to notice that. But the majority of my speech was about other people. And to try to stop doing that so much.

It has enormous consequences because most of our speech about other people is in one way or another, the judgment. Not necessarily bad. I mean, it could be good. It could be bad.

But a lot of it is some kind of judgment of them. As we quiet that down, as we don't give voice to it so much, what I found is that my mind actually became a lot less judgmental. Because I wasn't feeding it. And as I became less judgmental of other people, I'm even happier result, but became a lot less judgmental of myself.

That was a relief. And it all was being fed by speech which I hadn't been attending to. So it's really a very powerful area of our life. We have ample opportunity to practice this.

Adjunct Sumeto is this wonderful American monk who trained in Thailand and Adjunct Shah. It's not the added. Several monasteries in England. He said something which is counter-countacultural.

It's counter-countaculture. And he said, but we need to do it's not to follow the heart. It's to train the heart. So to counter-culture philosophy, follow your heart.

And this is obviously something in that that was worth understanding. But it's not complete really. It says a lot. It's in our heart.

It's not worth following. And you've probably seen it very clearly. So it's not just a matter of, well, follow your heart. It's really training the heart as we've been doing for this past week.

And the Buddhist terminology in the Pali language, this area of training, just of right action, of moral conduct, ethical conduct, is called stila. That's the Pali word. It is the absolutely necessary foundation. It's also the source of tremendous happiness in our lives.

It's tremendous drive because when we are well established in cila, which is basically non-harming, it's non-harming ourselves, non-harming others, what happens is that our mind is free of remorse. We don't have remorse about our actions because we're taking care of our actions. When the mind is free of remorse, it's happy. When it's happy, it concentrates easily.

When it concentrates easily, wisdom develops. It's really beautiful unfolding from some very basic, simple principles. And it's very tied into the practice of meta because cila is both the nurturance and the expression of loving kindness. And when we're not harming ourselves and not harming others, the motive for that is because we care.

It's friendly feeling. So the more we refine, the more we pay attention to our actions in this regard, the more we practice cila, refine it, the meta becomes stronger. As the meta becomes stronger, it becomes more natural to live in this way. Now the time is so beautiful because it's like everything feeds into everything else.

And we can really begin to be living our life with this kind of integration. It's, it's not a hobby, you know, that we do occasionally. It's really how we live in our life. So this is the first area of training and I really encourage you to reflect about this and to refine the understanding.

Now it's easy to think, oh yeah, I'm basically a good person, I don't cause harm. And in a general way, I think that's probably true. But there are levels of refinement which come from a close attention. The second field of training is called samadhi, which means the development of concentration.

It's really the meditative disciplines. And this gets into some very practical suggestions about how do you keep your meditation practice going in the world. You know, and you've heard this, I'm sure, a zillion times. This will be the zillionth in one.

It's really essential to have a regular practice, to have a regular sitting practice. Just to have a time and day where we just sit down and are quiet. You know, kind of, there's not a level of cooling out. You know, letting the mind settle.

And to do that regularly, it's essential. Sort of like bathing, you know, what would happen if you didn't take a shower for two months? Or a week away? You start to feel really full.

Well, the sitting practice is like, it's just like an inner bath. One of the important things to remember is don't judge the quality of your sitting. It's worth doing no matter what it feels like. Because sometimes your mind will be all over the place.

And sometimes you'll sit and it'll be nice and calm and clear. Just keep doing it anyway. The more you can sit the better. You know, things are twice a day.

Things are three times a day. But at least try to establish a regular practice. I guess one word of advice in this. Don't think it's going to be easy.

I mean, after a retreat, it seems to sit once a day is nothing. For some reason, it's incredibly difficult in the busyness of our lives to keep that discipline. So if you know that it's going to be difficult, you'll give it the appropriate energy. If you think it's just going to be easy, then you're not going to give it the appropriate energy and it'll fall away quickly.

It takes discipline. It takes an effort to do it. Carve out the time. Really what inspires me, I think, the most about the power of awareness is it gives us the freedom to make choices.

If we're not aware, then we're just acting out all our habit patterns. And there's no choice. It's like we're sleepwalking. We're in a dream.

Whatever our actions might be. When we bring awareness to them, that awareness gives us the space to make a choice. Do I want to do this? Or do I want to do that?

I think the Dharma practice becomes very alive in our lives when we exercise this power of choice. And we really start to fashion our lives rather than simply play out habit patterns. So there's a great joy in that. It's like we take back the power in our life and realize we can make choices.

You can work with meditation practice now in a couple of different ways. You might want to just continue with the matter for a while. After one of my times of doing an intensively in Burma, I spent the whole next year basically just doing that. Every time I sat in my daily practice, that's what I would be cultivating.

And it's wonderful. And it really helps strengthen and make it a very strong part of my practice. So it's one way to do it. I really, really devote yourself exclusively to this practice for a while.

Another way, especially for those of you who have experience in Bhagavana also, they combine beautifully. So you could spend the first half of the sitting doing the meta and then going into the pastana. I think you'll notice a difference in the quality of the inside practice from doing the meta. Because first it's just a way of getting the mind focused and concentrated.

And it also softens and makes it more gentle so that when we open up to a general mindfulness, we're much more accepting. We're less judgmental. We've created that inner field of loving kindness, which makes it easier to do the pastana. As I mentioned this morning, it's wonderful to be carrying the meta just in the course of the day, walking down the street, driving your car.

I have a tendency. I like to drive fast. On these roads, when there's nobody on the roads, great. But if you get stuck behind a slow driver, there's not that many places to pass.

So I'm not infrequently up against that feeling of impatience. Why can't I get on with it? Doddling long, 40 miles an hour. It's a wonderful time to do a meta-act.

Right there is the choice. I can either be there in my impatience. I want to get on with it. Or I can kind of sit back and be like, okay, be happy.

And of course, as I settle more into the meta rather than the impatience, I feel a lot happier. It's probably a lot safer also. Just find the opportunities in the day when you're feeling impatient or irritated. But when you're not, when you simply just going along, maybe when in this room be happy, be healthy.

Everyone on the street be happy, be healthy. It's probably better to say to yourself. Although that's an interesting commentary itself. Okay, there's the training in Sila.

There's the training, the regularity, the discipline of a regular sitting practice. We're really cultivating the meditative disciplines. And the third training is that in wisdom. And the wisdom comes out of the other two.

And when Palais called Sila, Samari, Panya, Panya is the word for wisdom. There's like the three foundations of Buddha-Dhana. Wisdom emerges both from our sitting practice and also from a wise attention in our daily lives. It's not limited to when we're sitting.

Wisdom comes when we pay attention. It's so obvious, isn't it? If we want to understand something, we need to be looking. We need to be mindful.

We need to be paying attention. There are different specific things we could highlight. One is pay attention really in times of difficulty. And then you're going along, going along, everything's fine.

And then something happens and there's a glitch. Maybe it's in interpersonal communication. Maybe it's in work. Maybe it's getting behind a slow driver, whatever.

In a particular incident, kind of, tightens us. The training in wisdom is not simply kind of getting lost in that. But let the difficulty, let the struggle, let the suffering be of feedback. This is the time to look at what's happening now.

Where am I getting caught? How am I getting lost? Is this something I'm afraid of? Can I open?

Can I be accepting? It really changes the quality of our life when we use times of suffering in the service of our liberation, rather than simply to lead to more suffering. It's a basic switch in how we live. In some way, I think we learn the most.

When we bring awareness to it, I think we learn the most from times of suffering. Because right there, we're at our edge. In terms of what we're willing to be with, what we're willing to open to. The Dalai Lama talks a lot.

Again, this is in the context also of math and compassion. How one's enemies teaches one's patience. In some way, one's enemies are one's greatest teachers. And it's really true if we can keep that perspective.

Because enemy, whether it's a person or a situation or whatever it is, that's causing us suffering, that is bringing us right there to the point of where we're caught. But we have to look at it in this way. If we get involved in blaming or self-pity or just wallowing in our own suffering, we don't learn anything. So this is a real opportunity for us to train in wisdom and insight.

One other thing that I have found tremendously important, deeply profound in terms of understanding is the recollection, the immediacy of understanding the impermanence of things. We all know it intellectually. We know that things are changing. But to actually bring that understanding alive in the way we're being with things, it's all just disappearing.

Where did this week go? Where did the events of your life before the week go? And it's continuously like that. It's not just this week.

It's like every moment. It's like what over waterfall just keeps when we really pay attention to that. And this doesn't take a lot to say. It's the most salient characteristic of all our experience.

But somehow we get so caught up in the content, that we're caught up in the drama of our lives, that we just don't pay attention to it. And so we get caught and we get attached and we get full of aversion and all the consequences. This seeing, reflection, calling to mind, really being with, just the momentaryness of everything creates a tremendous spaciousness in our lives. Because then we're not gresstent, we're not clinging, we're not attached, we're not holding on.

And on the most fundamental level, to the sense of self. The whole thing is just this process of continuous change of elements of thoughts and feelings and emotions and situations and people and weather and everything. There's nothing really there. And this leads us to the wisdom, the great wisdom, a booted armor, of the essential emptiness at all.

It doesn't make us disengaged. So now this is not, you know, we don't withdraw. There's no one to withdraw. But it's always just another stuck place.

Rather, it's simply becoming one with this flow of continual change and not damming it up, not blocking it. And with our attachments, with our reactions, with our identifications. To see the possibility to just relax and inter it, letting it all happen, the more we see the impermanence. The more we see that, the more we see that, and the more we understand the essential emptiness at all, the freer we are.

This is the training in wisdom. Now we really use our lives for the development of it. It's not something intellectual, it's something that comes from attention. These are the trainings, you know, that you can really carry into your life as you live.

It's not dependent on being, at IMS, on being on retreat. This is a tremendous gift that you've given yourselves. Now just the quiet instillness and the protected quality to develop some strength of mind. Develop the feelings of love and compassion.

Now it's really to live in a really aware and mindful way. Tick not honed, had a wonderful phrase. He said, happiness is available. Please help yourself to it.

And just to connect with that. It is available. Please help yourself to it. So if you have any questions or comments or questions you'd like to mention?

This is really for many trainings. I think it's a question for the Lord. Can you describe it in the history of community? Between emptiness and indifference.

Indifference is a quality of with the draw from experience and it's characterized by not caring. It's like when we're indifferent to something, we pull it apathetic. And in a way, it's being closed off. It's a pulling back, closing off.

Seeing the emptiness of things from just back up a minute. Really the contrast to indifference is equanimity. Because equanimity is there in a very spacious quality of mind. The characteristic of equanimity is impartiality.

We were not partial to this over that. Well, impartiality is very different than indifference. They're not caring. Equanimity or impartiality holds everything.

And maybe you've got a taste of it in the course of the retreat. In working with the different categories of benefactant, frame, and mutual. And enemy. Maybe you touch some place where the mind really was impartial.

But one person was not more important than another person. That's a certain quality of equanimity it holds at all. The question about emptiness really, especially in relationship to met and compassion. There are two aspects of the Dharma that are really essential to understand and integrate.

And that is the understanding of the absolute level and the relative level. On the relative level of experience, there are separate individuals. There's beings. There's the language of I and me and self and you.

And that's all the relative world that we live in. And we inhabit that world a lot. So it's important to inhabit it skillfully. On another level, we understand the emptiness of it all.

Emptiness means there's nothing substantial there. It's like a rainbow. You know, the rainbow is a beautiful appearance. But there's nothing really there that you can touch.

It's an appearance depending on certain conditions coming together. There's no such thing as a rainbow. The rainbow doesn't exist as a self-existent phenomenon. Rather, certain conditions come together and there's an appearance of something.

What we call self is exactly the same thing. Certain conditions come together and there's an appearance of Joseph. Oh, Gene. Oh, each one of us.

So this is the absolute understanding. That there's nothing self-existing. But everything is simply the appearance due to conditions which are continuously changing. When we can bring the wisdom of the absolute of understanding the basic emptiness selflessness insubstantiality and permanence of it all, into the relative level, then we move very freely in it.

So we engage. We're very engaged with people in the world on the relative level. But because of that underlying wisdom, we're not sticking. Because there's no one to stick if we really have that understanding.

So this is how it all kind of blends together. And it's important to have both. Sometimes people get attached to the emptiness. And that really just becomes another kind of attachment.

That's not a true emptiness. But it's like, oh, nobody's there. Nothing is important. That's going more to the indifference side.

People are totally immersed in the relative without any understanding at all for the emptiness. And so they're really caught in that way. Our practice is to bring both together. And that's one of the beautiful things about the balance between metat and vipassana.

In metat and compassion, moodita, all of these are working and purifying the relative level. We're working with the concept of beings. And in vipassana we see the emptiness at all. So the two, these two practices really help us try and integrate.

I would look at the person who's listening to the music. Well, I would look at what your response is to the tightness. Leave them aside for a moment. There's a situation you get tired.

What are you doing with that tightness? Do you have a spacious feeling around the tightness? Or is there a kind of, I don't like this? If there's that, I don't like this.

That I don't like this becomes a condition for pushing them away because they are part of the conditions for the tightness to arise. If you can get okay, relax behind the feeling of tightness. If these people around you're feeling tight, I'm going to breathe into another. It's okay.

I can allow this feeling of tightness. Then you're not ricocheting against those people anymore. Because you're accepting of the tightness and the degree to which we can relax behind the tightness, you'll see that it's another change in condition. And that actually what keeps it tight is how it is like a thing.

It's like that story I told of the dying of the dying. It's how we are relating to unpleasant situations. That's the key place there. I don't think there's a particular need to kind of cycle analyze.

Well, why is it that you get tight around these people? I mean, it could be interesting, but I think there's a much quicker, more fundamental way. I'm just tightness. How are you with that?

Can you be okay with that feeling? It's very simple. When you say you're with it, what's the quality of being with it? Is it with it in a bargaining way?

It gets very subtle. There are many ways that we could be with it that contain aversion towards it. And we could be with it, not liking it. We could be with it, bargaining with it.

We could be with it, stoically enduring it. None of that is what I'm talking about. I'm talking about really bringing that quality of meta. This is okay.

You're really loving it. When you have that relationship to it, it's not a problem. And therefore those people are not a problem. And I think that really begins or helps to de-condition the response to those people.

You all have that situation of being around people who are difficult for us. Let me just get like that. And usually we blame it on them. If only they were different, I wouldn't feel this way.

That's completely the opposite of what we need to be doing. It's just, can we take a deep breath and allow the discomfort? And as we do that, we find that it gets a lot less uncomfortable. And it's great training.

It's analogous interpersonally to learning how to be with the pain in the neck. It's the same thing. It's the pain in the neck. And you know from your experiences, there's a whole training and the transformation of how we are with the pain in the neck.

First time, we don't mind. We hate it. We move. But over time, it's fine.

It's not a problem at all. It's just that discomfort. It's in that context that the Dalai Lama was my friend, the enemy. Because they're really showing us where we are caught.

And also be patient with you. This is a process that don't be judgmental of yourself. You don't do it perfectly right away. It's a practice.

No, that I think is really helpful. I think the recognition of what the feeling is can be tremendously helpful by psychoanalyzing. And I think there's a value for that, too. I don't want to undervalue.

I think that in its own context can be very helpful. I think that if we're unable to come to a place of acceptance of whatever it is, even if we really recognize it, we see this as fear or this is whatever. And the conditioning is so tight and complex around it. It could be very helpful to have somebody guide us through the knots of how they were created and all the different techniques of therapy.

If we are able to come to an acceptance, and part of that acceptance is a clear recognition. This is fear. This is sorrow. This is grief.

This is sadness. This is rage. This is whatever. The recognition is actually a prerequisite for acceptance.

We need to know what it is in order to be able to accept it. But if we're able to do that, then I think we don't particularly have to understand all the history behind it. Because we're able to be with it in a non-identified way. Exactly.

And also, quite a few years ago I was doing Jungian therapy. I know it's really helpful. I didn't feel the conflict in any way. I was mutually supportive.

As long as it feels good and is helpful. It may feel helpful and not be helpful. It was a little bit of a joke. There was a grain of truth in it in the sense that sometimes what feels good in the moment is not necessarily helpful.

There are a lot of things that we do. The third piece of chocolate cake feels great in the moment of eating it. And then afterwards, one is really sick. So it's just to bring wisdom.

But in the example, it really does seem helpful. Be creative and expensive in the method practice. Okay, list two. No, it's not at all.

I think there's a very simple analogy. No. It's the same way you make a commitment to your spiritual practice. Knowing that from day to day, sitting to sitting out how there will be enormous changes.

But because you value the path of practice, that's the basis of the commitment. Not that it's going to always be the same way. It's not. It's continually changing.

But you value the path of the practice so that you're commitment. In exactly the same way in a relationship, you can value a path of relationship. And that's the basis of the commitment. Within that is the understanding of it.

It doesn't say the same. And to the degree that you think it does, it's a set up, a suffering. As we all know. So I think it's simple.

Well, I think there are two things. I think one is the really paying attention. If there was a degree of delusion in the mind or not paying attention out of which the action came. Even if it was not the intention to hurt.

Just the fact that a hurtful action may have happened because we weren't really paying attention. So to learn from that. In terms of the other person, I think it's often just as simple. I'm sorry if that was hurtful.

That wasn't my intention. It was really simple. And that often can save instead of something then festering and getting bigger and bigger and bigger just in the moment of acknowledging that the person was hurt in some way. I'm not just sorry that it was hurtful.

Even though it wasn't your intention to do that. Is that clear? It's just a very straightforward. I think we can be very straightforward.

I'm amazed at how often that can ring. I've seen it myself many times when I make that gesture. Even if I think that I've done something right that somebody else seemed hurt by. Just to say, well, I'm sorry you feel hurt.

It's amazing how to bring people together instead of staying polarized. When we just do like two minutes of metaphor all, sure. I'll get in receptive mode.

Frequently asked questions

How long is this episode of Insight Hour with Joseph Goldstein?

This episode is 57 minutes long.

When was this Insight Hour with Joseph Goldstein episode published?

This episode was published on November 10, 2022.

Is there a transcript available for this episode?

Yes, a full transcript is available for this episode. You can read the complete transcript on the episode page.

Can I download this Insight Hour with Joseph Goldstein episode?

Yes. Use the download control on the episode player to save the publisher-provided media file.