Skip to content
Ep. 151 – No Self, No Problem w/ Ram Dass episode artwork

Jan 25, 2023 1 hr 2 min

Ep. 151 – No Self, No Problem w/ Ram Dass

from Insight Hour with Joseph Goldstein

In this unique offering from the Love Serve Remember Foundation archives, Joseph Goldstein joins Ram Dass for a conversation around love, emptiness, soul, the notion of self, and much more. NEW Meditation Series: Pause, Breathe, Be Here Now with Ram Dass, Sharon Salzberg, Jack Kornfield, Tara Brach, Joseph Goldstein, John Lockley, Ram Dev, Trudy Goodman, Lama Tsultrim Allione—FREE January 16 to 25. Sit in true peace, love, and tranquility. Join thousands of people around the world for this collective meditation experience: onecommmune.com/ramdass “And let’s not forget joy. In you is joy. In you is compassion. Peace. Emptiness. And love. Those are all in you. In you. Now, manifest them in your behaviors. And your thoughts.” – Ram Dass In this episode: Joseph and Ram Dass reminisce about the early days of their friendship and how their relationship has evolved over the years They respond to a question about whether there’s a relationship between love and Tao, exploring the concepts of self (and no self), emptiness, and soul Ram Dass asks Joseph about the concept of dharma and they discuss the way of nature The conversation veers into karma, free will, and whether or not everything is predetermined They touch the mysterious forces at work in the universe and the power of imagination Joseph and Ram Dass respond to a question about developing compassion amidst intense polarization Ram Dass ends with a brief guided meditation

Episode details come from the podcast's RSS feed.

Embed this episode

Ready to play

Ep. 151 – No Self, No Problem w/ Ram Dass

0:00 1:02:12
of matches

Transcript Auto-generated, may contain errors

I like the word conditioned rather than determined, because if everything is predetermined, it just feels like there's really no possibility of awakening in that, because we're just bound by past causes. So I think it's possible to understand that things are conditioned by various forces, and that different conditioning leads to different results. Welcome to the Joseph Goldstein Insight on this podcast is an expression of our shared interest in self-discovery. Join Joseph as he shares his deep knowledge of the path of mindfulness.

If you are interested in supporting this podcast, please go to beherenownetwork.com.com. It's great being together. We can't hear it now. We don't see one another that often.

I hear of you often. We're all friends. Of course, brings back a lot of memories of when we first met in Bogaia in India. People were saying Ramas was coming.

I had no idea who Ramas was. I had been in India for a few years, then in Bogaia. I think you first came there in 1970? Yes, I am with the hordes.

So I had been in this really nice quiet. We had places here. What do we call? Actually, it was a buffalo shed.

He tried to meditate, and I had a party. I was banging on the wall. Why? That was the beginning of a great friendship.

We bought then a Burma. Burma was... We shamed candy. Screwed both there at the monastery with the cider Upan dita.

It was a pretty strict and demanding teacher. But somehow you and he got on really well with him. I think he was as tough with you as he was with me. That's what he was.

Potential. He... I think maybe it was an age thing. He was a comrades.

When Ramas left, he left before I did. He had this great stash of candy of M&M's which I inherited. He was great. He got me through some hard times on this.

More recently, he's been my meditation teacher. There's another story that I have to tell about our relationship because in a fundamental way you were the impetus for the whole past and movement in the States. So first, when I first came back, and I'm sure you don't remember this particularly incident, we were a couple, but when I came back from India, I'd been there for about most of seven years back and forth a few times. I had no idea what to do.

This was all of my 20s, it was in Asia. I came back, I was 30, and I wrote to Ramas. I had no idea. I had no profession.

So I wrote to you and said, what do you think about teaching Buddhism in some college or something? And Ramas just wrote me this brief note back, basically saying, don't even bother with that. And he got off that track. So I started traveling across the country and wanted to see Ramas in California, where he was staying.

So I get there and I call, and this was a day that the mayor was keeping silent, and he wasn't speaking to anybody. And we were buddies, you know, in India. We were friends, not speaking to anybody. So I'm walking down the street in Berkeley, and he's going to the bathroom really badly.

Going to one restaurant, and I ask if I can use it? No. First thing, if India, I was totally shocked, because we would say no. Going to a second restaurant.

Going to the bathroom. No. Going to a third restaurant. There's Ramas.

Sitting. And we get to talking, because when I showed up, he was willing to talk to me. And then he invited me to teach at the university. And so I said, let's talk about the conversation.

I don't understand why I'm saying it. I couldn't go over. No, it's interesting. Because when you left on the bus, from Gaya with all those people, that's how a lot of offerings met.

First met, I decided to say it was a big thing. So I never had that fateful meeting. Yeah. Fadeful meeting.

I'm very intrigued with the concept of no-self. If I understood one of Joseph's recent lectures from the perspective on no-self, Jesus. Joseph describes Duka as anything that is conditioned, unreliable, insecure, or determinant, and therefore incapable of leading to lasting privilege. Dalism has been a huge influence and important part of my practice.

From the Dallas point of view, human being is nature, and as we align with her rhythms, rather than resist them, we get stronger, happier, and healthier by going with the flow. The literature describes the path to follow as human being following the way of earth. Yeah, earth follows the way of the heaven, yang. And heaven follows the way of the doubt.

Joseph, could you speculate is there a relationship between no self and doubt? Rumbas is there a relationship between love and doubt? That's quite a question. Yeah, the good one, the first one, a no self.

In some way, I think it's using a different language to describe something very similar. Because really, I don't want to do that as you will know. You know, one of the meanings of the word dharma is nature. And so connecting with the dharma is connecting with nature.

And the notion of self is itself a construction, which gets in the way of following the way of nature. And as was expressed merely simply, I think it was by Sri Lankan monk, although I've heard it now for many people, no self, no problem. You know, as long as we're kind of contracted in the sense of self, then we're out of the flow of nature. So I can see any, I don't see any dissonance at all.

We've, you know, what was described as the daoist approach and the sense of selflessness or emptiness of self. It seems the same thing to me. See, I have gotten in my bhakti way. I've gotten into soul.

We die into soul land. It's my, and we don't die. Only the ego dies. And the soul goes on and incarnations and all that.

Now how does that fit? Well, you know, as we know Buddhists generally don't use the word soul. I said, no, no. However, I wonder what it would be like, for example, I just, in the way you were describing your experience, whether it would be the same thing to say nature as soul, you know, to die into the nature of the unfolding.

And so we can get caught up on the word. Yeah, that's right. It's words. You know, at one point, I was at this Buddhist Christian conference at Gethsemani.

And after that, they wanted to get a group of Buddhists to write a commentary on the rule of Saint Benedict. So they have four of us to go through the rule and just from the Buddhist perspective. And one of the discussions, Brother David Tambogas was there. In one of the discussions, we came to a place that was very interesting for me.

Of course, he uses the language of love, you know, and it's very full of love. And as I was listening to it, to me, it was describing the same thing that the Buddhists use the word emptiness for. And I just say emptiness and love being the same thing. How can I be the same?

Because emptiness really is empty of self. Oh, you know, and so when self is gone, then there's no separation. And then you go into a moment. Yes.

Well, there's no self is no other. No, self. No other. Then you enter into emptiness.

That's what I was the empty the word emptiness. Got me. Yeah, yeah. Well, you definitely chose the better word.

Between love and emptiness. Oh, I'll take empathy. Most people would do that. You have the better PR words.

I empty. I empty you. But if you take the I and the you out of it, and there's just love or just emptiness or whatever you want to call it. That's what unconditional love.

Yeah. And this goes back in the way to the first question. It really goes back to some realization of selflessness. Selflessness.

Yeah. It's gonna be another word for love. Yeah. Yeah.

Selflessness. Yeah. Maharaji loves me. And I love more than people and love and love and love.

And it goes from heart to heart to heart to heart. It's catchy. Now, emptiness is not me. Well, you know, I think it is catchy in a way because when when I've been with, you know, really some of the great masters who really felt empty of self, they just felt like there was just no one there.

Yes. Being in their present. You kind of to catch it in a way. You know, if could.

The presence could lead you into that space. Yeah. So I think that's what you know, I think that's right. Because the Maharaji is nobody there.

And Maharaji is full of them out. And he is a soul. Therefore, it's a it's a mirroring of my soul. Exactly.

Exactly. I've had exactly the same experience. With some of the really great teachers, like all their emptiness would reflect my neurosis. Yes.

That's what I mean. And it just became painfully obvious. Yeah. But you know, there might be a there might be different flavors, you know, to how people manifest this.

But I think it's when when I come on and the masters, I often I often reflect on my my my a Dharma. Mm hmm. Yeah. What is the word Dharma finally mean?

I actually like the translation of it as nature or the lawfulness of nature or the way of nature, just how things are. But the tree out there is that the tree is darn which it's manifesting its own nature. You know, and you could talk about it in terms of, you know, the physical elements or the life force in it or what it's just. It just seems everything is nature, including our minds.

And it's I think that's what people often don't see. They don't see what they don't see. They don't sell the self is nature. Yeah.

And it's, you know, we get so caught up in our stories. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah.

So I was just speaking with just a few days ago, I was speaking with somebody who's going through a difficult time in a relationship and kind of their partner was, at least from their perspective, not behaving very well in the situation. I started just and this is somebody who's very deeply practiced. So I just started talking about the behavior, not as so not as something so personal, but as delusion acting itself out. Delusion.

Delusion like delusion manifests, you know, in a certain way that manifests as confusion. And I'm not knowing when delusion is the mind is in the mind. So that the nature of what happens is confusion. So if I said about that person, the karma, this is the karma.

Well, sorry, you could say they're creating karma. But, you know, in the quality of their actions, but the fact that they chose to do that action, they were there from past karma. Well, this gets into a very tricky question. And so, you know, we just finished teaching the three month retreat and so toward the end, and this question invariably comes up at least once.

What about free will? It is a free will. Where's it all determined? This is an old condition.

Is it all past karma? So I just reflected back that I had been having that conversation since I was a freshman in college, the free will determining some question. But at least from the Buddhist perspective, not everything that happens to us is a karmic result, but that's only part. That's only one of the causes of things that there are other causes as well.

What do you say about free will? I say that I can say a lot. No, I mean, mostly what I say is that when I really investigate the term free will, the words don't mean anything together. From it, it's a phrase that's been used, but what would free will mean?

The very term implies an agent that somehow is not conditioned by anything. So it's like, for me, it's a meaningless term that is taken on. A huge, become a huge philosophic problem. But well, forget the word free.

OK. If I decide to do something, it was free will, but decide to do something. And it wasn't, it wasn't, it may be to be determined. Well, well, I like the word conditioned rather than determined because if everything is predetermined, it just feels like there's really no possibility of awakening in that, you know, because we're just bound by past causes.

So I think it's possible to understand that things are conditioned by various forces and that different conditioning leads to different results. So that's one of the things, you know, I appreciate about the Buddhist teaching in particular because he gave such a clear map of the mind and of what conditions what, you know, so he said, yeah, if greed will condition this kind of suffering or love will condition this. Well, that bus from Bhagaya to to wherever you were going. And I thought in the bus, again, Danny came up from the back and said, why don't we turn right?

Because it's a very spiritual place. Well, we can go ice cream by going to, we were going for ice cream. And I was ice cream. Oh, in this whole.

So finally, the bus driver said, we ought to have to go one way or the other. And I was really excited. And I turned right and we turned right and Maharaj was here. And he then took us to Dada's home.

And they had started early at night, early morning. They started cooking for 25 people. Right now, what is that about? Yeah, that's a little bit of that.

Yeah, no, it's. I mean, that's a realm. We're going to be so I can't really say much about that. But I can imagine a mind that encompasses time, you know, in that way.

And so it's not I don't have any, I don't have any disbelief in that. But then the question is how does that fit into this question of whether things are predetermined or not? I was sitting at bus deciding. That was my free will.

Well, sometimes I think they're there are forces which are conditioning things that we're not seeing. Yes. And so I'll give you another story. I'm going to tell this much less dramatic, but it's a little bit insane.

So I got into this first time I got into the book for a teacher and I traveled around to different classrooms and, you know, wasn't connecting with anybody. So I was in New Delhi about to buy a plane ticket to go back to Thailand where I had been in the Peace Corps. I'll try to find a teacher there. So I'm walking down the street to the airline office and at a certain point some force stopped me from taking another step.

And I'm not like you. I don't have these kinds of experiences. You know, you're like this full of them. For me, this was very strange.

I mean, it felt like a physical force which just kept me. So I was very kind of, you know, what's this about? So I turned around and went back, decided somebody had given me a new Delhi some acid. Okay.

I'll go to Benares. I can't get to the airline office. I'll go to Benares. I'll take the acid.

Go to Benares. We were on this little house photo or something. Anyway, didn't take the acid there. I'm in the train station to go back to Delhi to try again to go to Thailand.

Yeah. And the thought comes. Well, maybe I'll go to Bhagaya and take the acid under the tree. Under the Bodhi tree.

So instead of turning right, I turn left. I'm going to go to Bhagaya. Go to Bhagaya. There's no energy.

It is. So it's kind of the same thing in some way. You know, there are seem to be forces guiding what's happening. So I think there are, you know, I think there can be mysterious forces at work.

Yeah. It wasn't your mind. No, it's certainly not my conscious mind. Yeah.

So I have a favorite mantra. And this mantra is really the resolution and answer to all these questions. Ready? Who knows?

Who knows? Maybe Maharaj knows. I don't know. And you know, with a lot of these questions, I'll just be on the realm of my understanding.

Rather than having opinion about it. You know about something that I really don't know. I think they're really freeing to just, well, who knows? So when you know that first, that's time we went in the robot.

I think it was the first time I was. I might have been the second. Dude Jim Imprache came to give talks. And he's a great, he's a great, and one of the posters of announcing his talk.

It said he was the incarnation of Sarah Putra, who was the chief disciple of the Buddha. Now from the Burmese perspective, we had emerged for 20 years. Sarah Putra was not reborn. So our minds, minds, do not take rebirth.

For sure. But there's Dude D'Ammitage. You know, he's a great master. And it says, in-pointation of Sarah Putra.

So my mind went on tilt. You know, impossible. And that's where I realized I had no idea. Or like, oh yeah, the Burmese think this.

The bed isn't good, that's all. And I was so freeing. You know, not to feel that I didn't have to have an opinion. Yeah, about that.

About what I don't know. It's obvious in retrospect. Yeah, I've been, yeah, there was a guy that told you the story. This is the guy, a guy was walking by me and he said, you know, the guy that talks to you dead guru?

Yeah, I like him. But he said, well, that's your imagination. And I said, that's great. And it is my imagination.

Because Maharaji can go, if he can break into temples, he can break into my mind. Exactly. But I live in the world that is defined by my imagination. Then when I was a social scientist, I was defined as a logic.

What do you define? I think in the West, people, or culture, basically, I think, the scientific culture is basically materialistic. Not in the pejorative sense. But the material world is the basis of reality.

And I think from a more Eastern perspective, whether it's Buddhist or Hindu, or more generally in the East, I think there's a much more understanding of the call of mind or big mind or awareness or whatever. That's a much bigger experience than material. And so for me, in my better moments, I'm much more connected with that experience of mind. And that's where the term emptiness helps me.

Because it's just empty openness or empty. And in which anything can happen. And so in a way, from one perspective, everything is an appearance in mind. And so that's not the way that person was using imagination.

He was using the more materialistic senses. This is just some electrons in the brain, or a neuron, whatever. Just in a materialistic way rather than an openness of awareness. Could you ask Maharaj?

Can I make an appearance in my mind? Could you put in a good word for me? Although I did tell you, I did mention that recently, he did come to mind in a very vivid way. But it's not usual.

It's psychically, psychically tuned, psychically open to that. Yeah, I think I am too. Yeah. In the light of recent terror attacks and deeply troubling politics, how does one develop a real compassion as we get polarized into us and them?

I get that question a lot. It comes up a lot. And it came up once in particular when I was teaching a retreat just after 9-11. And we were teaching meta, a lot of kindness.

And getting to the place where you send it to the first benefactant friend into the enemies. And there were a lot of people from New York on that retreat. And there is no way that they were going to send meta to those guys. And so it was a really challenging, it was really challenging for me to really, and it took some time.

It was after the retreat was over and it was really, really flack. And if meta loving is really universal, what would it mean in that context because their response was completely reasonable? No, understandable. Well, go ahead.

What I came to was that even in that kind of situation, one could have the wish for people to be free of hatred, to be free of all enmity. Yeah. So there's nobody who we would exclude from that wish. Yes.

So again, it was just reframing the language to say, oh, may you be happy. That's not the right words for that situation. But there are words that encompass the non-sederate. Sure.

That's a... Oh, yeah. But to be compassionate to them. I see in my soul language, I put George Bush on my pigeon table.

And I didn't like him. And I've got a John Bean at Bayon's. You know, all the way among which... Well, and I sat and looked for that.

And I looked at that picture. And what I saw was that soul. That soul had... ...lows the incarnation.

And I can feel compassion for that soul. Well, wait, it goes back to what we talked about earlier in terms of... And this is, I think this is what you're saying, or something like it, of kind of seeing the delusion of the mind and how it manifests. And you can have compassion for the delusion.

You know, of somebody caught in that mind state. You know, I know. That's what I say. We're talking about mind.

No, George Bush's mind. No. You have to speak to your own mind. No, but how you were looking at George Bush reminded me, it's like he was seeing, you know, when you say he was caught in a lousy incarnation.

So in the Buddhist language, we're doing the same kind of incarnation caught in a lot of delusion. And then acting from that place. So I think it's the same possibility. Now with Buddhist incarnations, nothing souls are incarnated from my point.

Tell me what... Just so everybody knows, we have been having this discussion since 1970. So what's that? That's 30, 45 years we've been having this very discussion.

It's so much fun. So in the soul language, yeah. So it's the language of a soul reincarnating. In Buddhist language, it's each moment conditioning the next, conditioning the next.

So there is a lawful unfolding to the process. Just like if you plant a seed in the ground and it germinates and sprouts and becomes a... Sappling becomes a tree, bears fruit. From the Buddhist perspective, there's no one element that is in the seed that is in the seed.

That is carried over, but rather it's a process of the encompassing becomes this, becomes this, becomes this, becomes this. So if one wanted to kind of synthesize these two languages, one could say, I don't know if this is something you would say or not, but that soul is this unfolding lawful process that continues from life to life. And one could use the word soul to describe the process. And the conditioning of it.

Yeah. And that it's lawful. That it's not chaotic, it's not random. Each moment conditions the next, so there is a lawfulness to the unfolding.

Souls are not unlawful. There, no, I said. Well, since I'm not quite sure what a soul is, can't really say it. No, you didn't.

I couldn't even... I'm hoping so. I see a wall. No, I kind of see different language.

And I do come back to kind of in terms of ultimate truth. I really take refuge in who knows. Who knows? For me, it's not of confusion, but just of trying to stay open.

Okay, so there's so much that I don't yet know. And so instead of crystallizing a view, let's see what happens. I mean, I don't know. This actually would be an interesting question for me to ask you because I've noticed that in myself, I much less...

I could say attached to what was dramatic about my views than I was earlier on when I was younger. And even teaching. But the whole relationship to the teachings and to my views has really eased up a lot. It's more like...

Okay, well, let's just see. So I've been interested in it when you look back at your early years of teaching, whether you see a difference now, you know, and how you hold things in the... ...it's just... ...just difference.

And a person comes up and they say, we will listen to you lecture... ...and I... ...you know, completely different. Yeah.

Completely. So an interesting question is whether it's... ...whis ...and just the whole experience is all the experiences. And you see...

...you see those motives. I believe in when I think back to the early years of our conversations. It's like we used to argue these points. And now that seems ridiculous.

Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. Perceptual difference.

You have two million to the perceptual difference. It's been the value of continuing this conversation for 45 years to you, personal. The value has changed. So in the beginning, the value was...

...and trying to convince him. He's okay. Being right. Now it's totally the joy of the connection.

Doesn't matter. It's like... ...it's a vehicle of connection. That's all.

Yeah, that's beautiful. I mean, this is where... ...this is where it comes down to love. It's where it comes down to love.

...in the empty... ...and the empty... The empty... ...the empty...

...the empty... ...the empty... ...the empty... ...the empty...

...the empty... The only one. I'll put in my two sides. All I didn't mean to act.

Going inside. Way inside. Way, way inside. Inside where emptiness and love play.

two terms and freedom and peace and you are inside. You are inside. You will experience those and let's not forget joy in you is joy in you is compassion, emptiness. Those are all in you now manifest them and your behaviors and your thoughts.

All these things are the one the one lives inside you. How about becoming that one if you become that one and I become that one it brings us so close together. That is the ultimate of relationship. Namaste.

How's beautiful?

Frequently asked questions

How long is this episode of Insight Hour with Joseph Goldstein?

This episode is 1 hour and 2 minutes long.

When was this Insight Hour with Joseph Goldstein episode published?

This episode was published on January 25, 2023.

Is there a transcript available for this episode?

Yes, a full transcript is available for this episode. You can read the complete transcript on the episode page.

Can I download this Insight Hour with Joseph Goldstein episode?

Yes. Use the download control on the episode player to save the publisher-provided media file.