Skip to content
Ep. 156 – Doorway to Freedom episode artwork

Mar 22, 2023 1 hr 1 min

Ep. 156 – Doorway to Freedom

from Insight Hour with Joseph Goldstein

Joseph Goldstein talks about how wisdom arises from an understanding of the true nature of impermanence, and how experiencing the truth of change can be our doorway to freedom. In this episode, Joseph explores: The nature of impermanence and why going from an intellectual understanding of it to a direct experience of it can be our doorway to freedom The different ways we can gain liberating insights into the truth of impermanence, including reflecting on death and relationships How, when we begin to see the true nature of change, we start to cultivate Bodhicitta The two levels of Bodhicitta – the relative level and the ultimate level – and how Bodhicitta manifests as responsive compassion “So this is really important because in talking about the impermanent nature of all this and how ultimately unsatisfying it all is, the implication is not that we pull back from experience, as some people might assume. Rather, it’s learning to not hold on. That is the implication, and that is the doorway to freedom.” – Joseph Goldstein This dharma talk from March 25, 2004, was originally published on Dharma Seed.

Episode details come from the podcast's RSS feed.

Embed this episode

Ready to play

Ep. 156 – Doorway to Freedom

0:00 1:01:34
of matches

Transcript Auto-generated, may contain errors

In talking about the impermanent nature of all this, and how ultimately unsatisfying it all is, the implication is not that we pull back from experience, as some people might assume. Rather, it's learning to not hold on. That is the implication, and that is the doorway to freedom. Welcome to the Joseph Goldstein Insight Hour.

This podcast is an expression of our shared interest in self-discovery. Join Joseph as he shares his deep knowledge of the path of mindfulness. If you are interested in supporting this podcast, please go to beherenownetwork.com. Joseph.

A heart of the Buddhist teachings is freeing the mind from the habits of suffering, from the habits of envy and greed, from the habits of mind of fear, of anger, of hatred. And all the practices that we do, all the different practices, of generosity, of mindfulness, of concentration, of loving-kindness, really all have this end goal of freedom. A unique aspect of the Buddhist teachings is that it both begins and ends with wisdom. Wisdom is not a matter of belief, and it's not a matter of dogma.

Our whole spiritual path, or this whole spiritual path, unfolds through our own investigation of what is true. The clear seeing into the nature of our mind comes from this investigating power, and so that's what we cultivate, that's what we practice. So the question for this evening that I'd like to explore is how do we train in wisdom, and what's the investigation that we undertake that illuminates the nature of our minds. In one very far-reaching aspect, and this has tremendously broad and deep implications, in this very far-reaching aspect, we can see that wisdom arises from an exploration and an understanding of impermanence, from a direct, deep experience of impermanence.

Now, we need to go from an intellectual level of understanding to the immediate, intuitive, direct experience of it, because we all know the things change. We know that conceptually, we know it intellectually, we know it somewhat experientially, but we don't quite believe it, because we're not living that understanding. So, somehow we have to make some kind of shift in ourselves, in our perception of it, in our insight into it, so that we are actually living that wisdom moment to moment. When we deeply and truly see the truth of change, the truth of impermanence, the heart and mind relax, and we can feel that relaxation, now it's a letting go of struggle, a letting go of many kinds of suffering in our lives.

We can see this clearly with respect to our changing bodies. If we are attached to them staying a certain way, when they change and they change through accidents, they change through disease, they change simply through the process of aging, of getting older, if we are attached to them staying a certain way, or staying the same, we are going to suffer when they inevitably change. It's very different and difficult to see that these changes are not a mistake. You know, how often does something happen, and we, oh, if only that hadn't happened, as if it's possible that it couldn't have happened.

I know there's a great Goldstein law of the Dharma. This is my contribution to the unfolding of 2500 years of Buddhism. If it's not one thing, it's another. Changes are not a mistake.

It's just the way things are. It's the Dharma. It's the truth of things. It's what happens to everyone.

I had just many, of course, as we all have kind of striking examples of this, but some years ago I had a hiking accident. I was slipped on a rock and it really hurt my knee. It was hard pretty bad that people had to carry me back to where I was saying. That evening, I was in the middle of a busy schedule of teaching, a lot of traveling, and my mind just started to go in this direction of how could I have been so stupid.

I wasn't mindful enough how could this have happened. But then I saw it kind of sort of heading down that direction of self-blame, self-pity, and worrying. That's not the way to go. I just started reflecting on giving a body these things are going to happen.

Another little mantra came to mind which has really proved very helpful to me. I really bring it to mind fairly often, and that is the vopassana mantra of change. Anything can happen anytime. Anything can happen anytime.

We just don't know. Rather, when that comes to my mind rather than that being a depressing thought and a fearful one, it has exactly the opposite result. When I remind myself, this is the law, this is the nature of things. Anything can happen anytime.

I find my heart and my mind relax. Instead of living defensively trying to protect myself from the truth of change, which is rather a futile endeavor. Anything can happen anytime. Just acknowledge it.

That's how it is. And things get much more open and much freer. Seeing the impermanent changing nature of all experience really deconditions our tendency to grasp, to cling, to hold on. I remember having intimations of this very early on in my practice in ways that were helpful.

When I first went to India, and this was after I was in the Peace Corps in Thailand, I went back to India, looking for a teacher settled in in Bodegaia, and began my intensive practice. But the early years were really hard. My mind was very restless, very nodidal, concentrated. I get discouraged, I get depressed, and all these feelings that can happen.

And I remember being in one of those down moods about my practice and thinking to myself, in six months, are you going to even remember that you were feeling this way? No, and not only six months, five months, three months, two months. One week, in three days. And it was just a way by extrapolating over time.

And remembering this truth of change, it really lightened. Realizing that this is a feeling, and it's coming up now. And it's going to change, it's not going to last. What's so amazing about the seductive power of the world, and this really is amazing to me.

When we look back at experience, and we look back at all our past experience, it's so obvious, the dream-like ephemeral nature of it all. It's so clear when we look back. Just think over these days of the retreat, think of your best experience. No, it's just where you're really feeling great.

Think of your worst experience when you felt terrible. Where are they now? In this moment, where are those experiences? They're gone.

It's just like waking up from a dream. Now, this is the strange part, the amazing part. We know that when we look back, and yet when we look ahead at experiences to come, we are continually dazzled by the possibilities. As if the next thing we want to do is somehow going to fulfill us, and make us happy, and make us complete, and know the 10 zillion things that we've done in the past haven't, and we know it.

We know it when we look back, but it's pretty strange. For most of us, this really is our lives. This is how we're living. Now, looking forward and leaning forward, leaning into anticipating just the next event in our lives, the next thing we want to do, the next retreat, the next vacation, the next project, the next relationship, the next meal.

It's always, and even in meditation, we do that leaning, anticipating the next breath. You know, it can get that subtle. Now, have you fantasized at all about the first thing you're going to do when you leave the retreat? Maybe it's connecting with your partner, or telling your friends about your knee pain.

Sleeping in your own bed, having a cappuccine, or whatever, whatever it might be. Yet each one of those experiences, which the mind can so look forward to, and anticipate, and plan, and think about endlessly, is also just going to be very quickly in the past. It's interesting that we don't stop to reflect more deeply on this as a way of unhooking from this samsaric revolution, just going around and around and around. And as we get older, it also seems to go that much more quickly.

There's kind of a wonderful statement somebody read that they said that after they turned 55, breakfast started happening every 15 minutes. And it is really like that. So this is our life. And it's going like that.

It's going very quickly. Now, there's a kind of interesting paradox, something like a paradox, about the spiritual life. And that is that as objects of desire, as objects of wanting, all of the great variety of experience really leaves us unfulfilled. Now, as objects of desire, as objects of wanting, whatever it is, it is ultimately unfulfilling as we have seen from all our past experience.

But these very same experiences, that as objects of wanting leave us unsatisfied, as objects of mindfulness become the vehicle for our awakening. So this is really important, because in talking about the impermanent nature of all this, and how ultimately unsatisfying it all is, the implication is not that we pull back from experience, as some people might assume. Rather, it's learning to not hold on. That is the implication, and that is the doorway to freedom.

So liberating insight, really freeing insight into the nature of impermanence, comes in several ways. And I think it's really worth considering how we can deepen in a very immediate direct way our understanding of change, so that it becomes real for us and we're living that insight. So the first way happens as our mindfulness and our concentration gets stronger and deeper and more stable and steadier. We begin to see impermanence on increasingly refined and momentary levels.

It's almost as if our attention, our awareness becomes microscopic. And in looking more closely at experience, we see that what appears normally as being solid and fixed and stable, we see as being very insubstantial, you know, and in a state of continual flux. And we can see this in very ordinary experiences, in a breath. You know, when we are in a step or in a sound.

That sound is not one thing. You know, when we're listening carefully, there's so many things going on, moment after moment. And the same thing in a breath or a step. They're not one thing, it's not something solid and substantial.

The breath is made up of innumerable micro sensations, or the sensations in the movement. So as our mind gets more steady, we really are tuning in on that level. And it's like looking at a familiar object under a high-power microscope. It's another whole reality that's revealed.

But think of the last time you went to the movies. A really good movie. And absorbed in the story, really into it lost in the story, you know, and with all the attendant feelings and emotions, that might have arisen. And then you glance up, or happen to glance up and you see the beam of light, and you know, projected on the screen.

And you realize that nothing whatsoever is really going on. You know, it's not as if people are really falling in love or getting killed or getting chased, or you know, whatever the movie is about. And it's just so interesting. When we're lost in the story, we are in it.

And we're responding to it. And our whole mind-body is engaged with it. And yet from another level of understanding, there's no one up there. So I want to read something to you, which I recently came across, which is another kind of description of a level of reality, in a way of understanding how we perceive things that we don't usually consider.

It's a little long. And it's kind of a... It's kind of a scientific language that, if you can get into it, it creates an amazing sense of what's going on. So let's give it a try.

Consider a world without consciousness. The darkness is a bubbling cauldron of energy and vibrating matter, locked in the dance of thermal agitation, through shared electrons, or the strange attraction of unlike charges, quivering molecules not free to roam, absorb and emit their characteristic quantum packages of energy with the surrounding fog. Free gas molecules, molecules almost oblivious to gravity, but buffeted in all directions by their neighbors, forms swirling turbulent flows, or march in zones of compression and expansion. A massive solar flux in cosmic radiation, from events long past, crisscrossed space with their radiant energy, and silently mixed with the thermal glow of living creatures, whose hungry metabolic systems pour their infrared waste into the chaotic milieu.

But within the warmth of their sticky protein bodies, the dim glow of consciousness is emerging to impose its own brand of organization on this turbulent mix of energy matter. The active filter of consciousness illuminates the darkness, discards all irrelevant radiation, and in a grand transmutation, converts and amplifies the relevant, converts and amplifies the relevant. Dead molecules erupt into flavors of bitterness or sweetness. Electromagnetic frequencies burst with color.

Happless air pressure waves become the laughter of children, and the impact of a passing molecule fills a conscious mind with the aroma of roses on a warm summer afternoon. I'm going to book called Why We Feel by Victor Johnson. What is really going on? And how much does our own mind and the nature of consciousness and perception create our worlds?

So it's not these different examples. It's not to suggest that we don't engage with ordinary reality, or even with the movies and dramas of our lives. But if we see in some way on a deeper level, if we see that in the movie theater, there really is nothing happening on the screen. If we have some perception that this whole mind body is a system that is somehow creating and interpreting some much more basic elemental energies, then even as we're engaged in the world and engaged with each other, we're less likely to get caught up in our reactions, in our judgments, less likely to get caught up in suffering.

The experience of freedom also comes from a wise and careful attention to impermanence on much more familiar levels. This was kind of a little cosmic. But even when we look at the very familiar levels of our lives, liberating insight can come. We just look at the world around us, and the changes happening in nature all the time.

The change of seasons, the change of weather. We see the changes in the environment. We see the changes in the birth and death of civilizations. We see the changes in our relationships and our work.

We see the changes in our bodies and our minds. It's so obvious. We can really see when we look at everything's disappearing moment, after moment, new things arising. Not only every hour or every minute, but it's really a momentary process.

So just if you can remember between now and the end of the talk, a little experiment you can make, after the talk when you get up and not leaving the hall, just walk out with a very open, choiceless awareness and simply notice the flow of changing experience of sights and sensations in the body and sounds and thoughts that may be coming and really notice how moment, after moment, it's something else. It's arising and passing, arising and passing. All of this is so ordinary that mostly we overlook it. We're just not paying attention to this truth which is staring us in the face.

Everything in the world, everything in the universe is in the state of constant flux. We're kind of sleepwalking through it. Not paying attention. And so we miss the everyday, every moment opportunity to practice the mind of non-grasping.

Now Ajahn Shah, the greatest time master, died some time ago. He said, if you let go a little, you will have a little piece. If you let go a lot, you will have a lot of piece. If you let go completely, you will have complete peace.

Your struggles with the world will have come to an end. And it's interesting to observe the mind, observe the quality of the mind when it is seeing the truth of change directly. Because right in that moment, I think you will find in the moment of seeing directly, not thinking about it, but actually seeing clearly the changing nature. If you check out your mind at that time, I think you will find that in those moments the mind is not grasping, is not clinging.

So we get the taste, a very real taste of freedom. A careful observation of some other very obvious truths. Also can help jolt us out of this complacency, with which we are often living our lives. Out of the deeply rooted habits we have, the patterns of attachment and craving and clanging, some very basic reflections.

One of them is that the end of birth is death and really reflecting on this. The Buddha talked a lot about reflection on death as a meditation object. The end of birth is death, so that for all of us, our lives are just getting shorter and shorter and shorter and shorter until they are over. But how often do we really give serious thought to that?

Mostly, I think our thoughts seem to be in the direction that a lot of other people are dying. But how often do we make the connection? In our culture, if you talk about reflecting on dying and reflecting on death, people think you are a little weird and morbid and the whole culture is covering it up. I mean it is amazing being in a funeral and seeing a corpse and all made up and dressed up.

Sometimes they never look so good. Things we don't like to face the reality. That was one of the great things about India and being an India, the face of death is just so out there. It is a powerful reflection.

It is a reminder. Yes, this is the nature. The end of birth is death for all of us. So it is a kind of thought experiment which might help us connect with this.

If you could imagine being on your deathbed, of course we don't really know how we are going to die, but for the sake of the experiment we will give you a bid. You are on your deathbed. I know you can imagine or might take a little work of reflection, but really we are dying. And to see or get a sense of what is it that the mind would be holding onto?

What is it attached to? Is it attached to the body and fearful of losing it? Is it attached to other people, to the people we love and afraid of letting go? It would be very helpful now rather than at that time to begin to see where our deepest attachments are.

What are we holding onto? Is it possible to practice the letting go now? And to reflect in the time of death what really will be of the greatest value to us? Is it what we have accumulated in our lives?

Is it what other people can do for us at that time? Probably not. It will be our ability to let go, our ability to rest at ease at peace. And none of us know.

This is the great challenge to our practice. Can we practice now? Can we train for that? And a lot of the meditation I really see in that light.

It was a training for skillful, wise dying. There are two great examples which I have spoken of often in talks of people who death just really inspired me in terms of illustrating the possibility of understanding death as a completely natural process. You know, it is not this kind of big scary thing at the end of life, but it is just the end part of life. It is part of nature.

One of the examples is Thorro, who died quite young. He died when he was 44 of TB. And as some books written about him describing his death, so I want to just read a few lines from this. Henry was never affected, never reached by his illness.

Very often I heard him tell his visitors that he enjoyed existence as well as ever, this after some years of being ill. He remarked to me that there was as much comfort in perfect disease as in perfect health. The mind always conforming to the condition of the body. The thought of death he said could not begin to trouble him.

None of his friends seemed to realize how very ill he was, so full of life in good cheer that he seemed. Some of his more orthodox friends and relatives tried to prepare him for death, but with little satisfaction to themselves. When his aunt Louisa asked him if he had made his peace with God he answered, I did not know he had ever quarreled him. I think that's an amazing ease, you know, and of course, you may...

As I have just gotten a sense from his wonderful writings, just his understanding and his connection with nature and the laws of nature and just our own lives being part of that, that's an amazing understanding. So we can practice that, you know, I think the possibility for all of us to come to that place of ease. The other example is that of the death of the 16th Karmapa, and the Karmapa is one of the heads of one of the great Tibetan lineages, and a very, very great being, powerful being. And he died some years ago, the 16th, died outside of Chicago, body riddled with cancer.

And in some books there's a description of the whole process of his dying, and also very much like the row in very good spirits throughout. And even as his body was riddled with cancer and his disciples were gathered all around him, you know, they were grieving and upset and losing their beloved teacher, said that at one point he turned to them and remarked, don't worry, nothing happens. That's like on the relative level, yeah, there's a body that's full of cancer and there's birth and death, but that's like the story on the screen, the movie screen, on the level of a more ultimate reality, nothing is happening. It just appears that all of this is going on.

And so for me it just points in a very profound way to a possibility of this incredible transformation of understanding when we come out of the prison of self, of eye of identification with his mind and body into another whole level of understanding what it is that's really going on or not going on. Don't worry, nothing happens. So the reflection on death, this can really wake us up out of our complacency. We really start to examine, to look and to see the truth of change, the truth of impermanence.

The fact and the reflection at the end of all accumulation is dispersion. And everything we get and gather in our lives, one way or another, is going to be dispersed. And yet we place so much emphasis in our lives about around this accumulation. And it's not to say that we necessarily give it all up and become monks or nuns and live in a cave in the Marluz, but it sometimes seems like an attractive option.

But even as we're living, just our ordinary, more or less middle-class lives, in the midst of things, can we really understand deeply that none of the stuff we have really means anything at all? It really doesn't. You know, it's nice and we enjoy it and it's fine. But there is no basic meaning or value in it.

And so, what are we doing with our energy? The end of accumulation is dispersion. So can we be in the world in a free way? And even enjoy the things of the world in a free way without that sense of craving or addiction to things.

The end of birth is death, the end of accumulation is dispersion. The end of all meeting is separation. And so, all the people we meet, those casually and those intimately, and the nature of all our relationships, they are going to all end one way or another in separation. And again, this is not something unfortunate.

It's just the way things are. This is the truth of change. And yet, how often do we become so entangled in our relationships? That separation from one cause or another leads to tremendous sorrow.

The Buddha commented that in the course of our countless lifetimes, we have shed more tears over the loss of loved ones than there are waters in all the great oceans. Can we wake up? Can we see the nature of our relationships, just like the nature of everything else is subject to this great truth of change, of impermanence? And it doesn't mean a pulling back.

It means a not holding on, a not clinging, a not grasping. When we see the impermanent nature of every aspect of the world, ourselves, our relationships, and we really see repeatedly and directly, not conceptually, when we're really, really seeing it, it re-oriented our minds towards care and loving kindness rather than towards attachment and clinging. So it's not to become uncaring or unloving. We actually become more loving and more caring because it's free of attachment and clinging.

The Buddha expressed the liberating power of this insight, direct insight into impermanence in one amazingly startling statement. I mean, to me, it's an extremely radical statement when he said, it is better to live for a single day, seeing deeply the momentary arising and passing the phenomena than to live a hundred years without seeing it. Well, what is that saying about all the things we so value in our lives? He's saying it's better to live a single day, seeing deeply and incisively the momentariness of phenomena than a hundred years without seeing it.

No matter what else we're doing. Why? Now what's the base? That's a very strong statement.

Because it is that insight when we really see it for ourselves, that de-conditions this powerful force of attachment and clinging and grasping that motivates our lives. It cuts through so much of what causes suffering for us. It's really the doorway to freedom. Now, what grows from this ground of wisdom, this deep seeing on all of these levels and all of these manifestations, the truth of impermanence, the truth of change.

What grows from this ground of wisdom is what in Buddhism is called bodhijitta. Bodhijitta is this rare flower, which means bodhijitta means bodhijitta is wisdom and jitta is the heart mind. So bodhijitta is the heart mind of wisdom and has two levels. On the relative level bodhijitta is compassion.

And it's just that strong motivation to alleviate the suffering of beings. So relative bodhijitta is the aspiration we can cultivate to awaken for the benefit of all beings. I find that it's very helpful for me, and so I just offer this as a possible suggestion, at the beginning and end of each sitting, just to frame the sitting. At the beginning of the sitting, I'll begin just with an aspiration.

You can frame it in different language. May I quickly be liberated for the welfare and benefit of all? Or may my heart be purified for the welfare and benefit of all? So it sets the aspiration of bodhijitta.

At the end of the sitting, the dedication of merit is doing every evening. May the merit of my practice be dedicated to the welfare and benefit of all beings. So it makes our path, it makes our journey very broad, very wide, very connected. That's the relative level.

The ultimate level of bodhijitta is the wisdom mind of awareness. Sometimes it's called the innate wakefulness of mind. The understanding that the very nature of mind is awareness. This innate wakefulness of mind is that mind that is free of clinging, free of grasping.

Now in the nature of this awareness, in some way is the great mystery of our lives, because when we look for it, when we look for this awareness, this ultimate bodhijitta, there's nothing to find. We can't locate it, we can't find it. It's like open, empty space. And yet there is this innate knowing capacity.

When you hear a sound, very convenient having the spell. Okay. Do you have to do anything to know that sound? Do you have to struggle?

Do you have to make effort? No. The nature of the mind is awareness. There's a book by Robert Kaplan about the history of the number zero.

And the name of the book is The Nothing That Is. And when I saw the title of that book, it just completely intrigued me because it seemed just a wonderful description of the nature of mind, the nothing that is. And so the opening couple of sentences of the book, which is about as far as I could get. But it was enough.

It's like I got everything I needed. He wrote, when you look at zero, you see nothing. Look through it and you see the world. Look at nothing and you look at zero and you see nothing.

Look through it and you see the world. That is a wonderful description of this empty open, aware nature of mind. The nothing that is. Now this absolute bodhijitta, the nothing that is, the wisdom mind, is not something we need to look for outside of ourselves.

And this is the great, amazing discovery. It is already here. It is the nature of the mind. It's not something we have to get.

It's not something we have to cultivate. The Buddha gave a very simple instruction, which leads us right into the experience of this. He said, let go of the past. Let go of the future.

Let go of the present. And cross over to the further shore. And the further shore is not out there. The further shore is right here.

It's the mind free of any grasping. Let go of the past. Let go of the future. Let go of the present.

It's an image that describes this movement from delusion to wisdom, from delusion to awareness. And the image used is that of ice and water. Now ice is solid. It's frozen.

It's hard. And in this context, it represents the mind, which is attached. The mind which is clinging. The mind which is grasping.

The mind which is fixated. And when that's what's happening in the mind, it gets very hard and contracted. It's our normal, deluded state when we're caught up and identified with the body, with our thoughts, with our reactions, with our judgments, with our emotions, with awareness itself. When we are identified with any arising experience, when we're holding on in any way, that's ice.

Now we get attached to sense pleasures. This attachment goes very deep. Dalai Lama tells a wonderful story, being at a conference in Los Angeles, and he was just being driven every day to the hotel where the conference was going down the street, where there were a lot of shops selling all the latest technological toys. And at the end of the week of the conference, he made the comment to people, and every day I rode by and I was looking in the windows.

By the end of the week, I found myself wanting things, even though I didn't know what they were. And this is the Dalai Lama. Such a strong tendency, this is a wanting mind. We need to see it.

We need to really pay attention. That's what our practice is about, developing the mindfulness, which sees it, so we're not just caught in the habit of that fixation. We're attached to our opinions about things, not a great arena of attachment, or attached to being right. Even when it's things we know nothing about.

I think it's very instructive to pay attention to that. We have opinions about everything. And it's really not a problem having an opinion. It's a problem being attached to our opinions.

It's the great Zen master Bancai, where he said, don't side with yourself. And that's very good advice with respect to the various opinions we have. Not to get attached in that way. Attached to sense by his attached opinions, attached to the strong sense of eye of self.

And every time we are identified with the thoughts of feelings or body or emotions or whatever, we're creating this sense of self and I am going to get very attached to it. This is ice. This is the mind of delusion. Water represents the nature of awareness.

Of the wisdom mind, free of any cling, free of any attachment. It's unfrozen, it's fluid, it's the mind not clinging to anything. And therefore completely responsive to changing circumstances, because it's not fixed, it's not fixated. Now there's some good news in all this.

And that is that water, or the wisdom mind, is nothing other than melted ice. So the taste of freedom is not some far off experience. It's not something we kind of need to search for. It's rather this very mind unfrozen, unfixated.

So there are two related mantras. These are my own little mantras. That really point to the immediacy of realizing this ultimate bodhijata. They've helped me a lot, and so maybe they will help in your own practice.

One of the mantras is, it's already here. And I've used it very often in my practice when I feel myself striving, reaching, leaning forward, as if it's in the next moment, or as if it's in the next experience, I remind myself it's already here. And in that very moment, I can fshhh, there's the settling back into that open empty awareness. It's already here.

The second mantra, which you need to, with a rather odd syntax, it doesn't matter to what you don't cling. So it's not that you have to practice, practice, practice, practice to get to an experience, not to cling to. If the wisdom mind is the mind of no clinging, why not? Not cling now.

It is always and immediately available. So this in conjunction with it's already here, really can help us drop right back into this nature of awareness. The open empty, the nothing that is, it's already here. It doesn't matter to what you don't cling.

Don't cling now. Sometimes we think we're in water, we think we're not clinging, we think the ice is melted, but it's really slush. Because there are very subtle levels of clinging, which are worth paying attention to. You know, subtle attachments to sense pleasures, even more subtle attachments to meditative states.

You know, to calm, to peace, to quiet, luminosity, to get attached, that's a fixation, that's slush. We can get identified with awareness itself. Even as we begin to taste this nature of mind as awareness, we can begin to identify with that. So again, it's a continual process of refining our awareness, refining our ability to see where we're caught, where we're attached.

As we settle back more and more in the direction of this ultimate bodhicitta, the empty open wisdom mind of awareness free of clinging, it manifests as a great responsive compassion. That is the manifestation of emptiness, the manifestation of wisdom. In the great Tibetan Massadil Gokensai Rinpoche, he said, when you recognize the empty selfless nature of phenomena, the energy to bring about the good of others dawns uncontrived and effortless. This is very important to see the relationship between the relative and ultimate bodhicitta, they are expressions of each other.

When we recognize the empty selfless nature of phenomena, the energy to bring about the good of others dawns uncontrived and effortless. So as we see more and more clearly the momentary changing nature of phenomena, which is what our practice is all about, we really pay attention to what is all around us all the time. We refine our awareness of the momentary changing nature, the mind lets go, in letting go of grasping and letting go of clinging. We actually are watering the seed of bodhicitta within us.

This aspiration to awaken for the benefit of all. So our practice all comes together with greater mindfulness and steadiness and concentration. We see impermanence on clearer and clearer and clearer away on deeper and deeper levels. We see impermanence, the mind lets go.

As the mind lets go, we experience this open empty nature of awareness. That awareness manifests as compassion. We water the seed of bodhicitta within us, the aspiration to awaken for the benefit of all. I just like to close with a quotation from Thoreau again, which I think points to the power of our watering the seed within us.

He said, though I do not believe that a plant will spring up where no seed has been, I have great faith in a seed. Convince me that you have a seed there and I am prepared to expect wonders. It's just planting a seed, it's very humble. We are not creating some big, yes I am going to go out and save the world and very humble.

We are just the seed of an aspiration that our practice and our lives be for the welfare and benefit of all beings. We water it. We water it with our practice. We water it with our lives.

What's it for?

Frequently asked questions

How long is this episode of Insight Hour with Joseph Goldstein?

This episode is 1 hour and 1 minute long.

When was this Insight Hour with Joseph Goldstein episode published?

This episode was published on March 22, 2023.

Is there a transcript available for this episode?

Yes, a full transcript is available for this episode. You can read the complete transcript on the episode page.

Can I download this Insight Hour with Joseph Goldstein episode?

Yes. Use the download control on the episode player to save the publisher-provided media file.