Skip to content
Ep. 159 – Tides of Conception episode artwork

Apr 13, 2023 1 hr 3 min

Ep. 159 – Tides of Conception

from Insight Hour with Joseph Goldstein

Joseph Goldstein talks about how the tides of conceiving continually condition our lives and explores the ways we can directly experience the reality of Nibanna, the unconditioned. This podcast is sponsored by BetterHelp. Click to receive 10% off your first month with your own licensed professional therapist: betterhelp.com/insighthour “Do we buy in? Do we buy into the content? Do we get lost in this mind-created world of ‘future,’ or can we see it as being as light as a momentary thought, a momentary image? Just like a sound arises. But it takes a great deal of vigilance because these thoughts, these tides of conceiving, are tremendously seductive. You know, we’ve been doing this for years, and perhaps lifetimes. But awareness is very powerful, we can actually free ourselves from this prison.” – Joseph Goldstein In this episode, Joseph talks about: How the tides of conceiving continuously arise in our mind and condition our experience The different concepts that we solidify and make real, including our bodies, time, and the mental construct of the self Why the concept of the self is so deeply held and why we’re so attached to it The four realities that can be experienced directly, including that of Nibbana, which is also known as the unconditioned The wide range of expressions of the experience of the unconditioned that is available in different Buddhist traditions This dharma talk from December 5, 1995, was originally published on Dharma Seed.

Episode details come from the podcast's RSS feed.

Embed this episode

Ready to play

Ep. 159 – Tides of Conception

0:00 1:03:23
of matches

Transcript Auto-generated, may contain errors

This episode is sponsored by BetterHelp. We talk about mental health more openly now, but asking for help can still feel hard. BetterHelp's latest research confirms it. BetterHelp's 2026 State of Stigma report surveyed 2000 Americans and revealed that 85% of Americans believe getting support is wise.

Yet 74% say society discourages people from doing so. If you're struggling with mental health, please consider getting the help you deserve. BetterHelp is the world's largest online therapy platform. Don't let stigma stand in the way of support.

Start therapy with BetterHelp. Sign up and get 10% off at betterhelp.com.com. That's better. H-E-L-P.com.com.

Do we buy in? Do we buy into the content? Do we get lost in this mind-created world or future? Or can we see it as being as light as a momentary thought, a momentary image, just like a sound arises?

But it takes a great deal of vigilance because these thoughts, these tides of conceiving are tremendously seductive. Now we've been doing this for years and perhaps lifetimes. But awareness is very powerful. We can actually free ourselves from this prison.

Welcome to the Joseph Goldstein Insight Hour. This podcast is an expression of our shared interest in self-discovery. Join Joseph as he shares his deep knowledge of the path of mindfulness. If you are interested in supporting this podcast, please go to beherenownetwork.com.

In one of his teachings, Babuda said, by overcoming all the tides of conceiving, one is called a sage at peace. It's in the beautiful image to make, the tides of conceiving, which is this proliferation of concepts that continuously sweep over the mind. And they really are like the great ocean tides, which are endlessly ebbing and flowing. These conceptions, these tides of conceiving, continuously arise in our mind, and they color, and they obscure, and they condition our experience.

These tides of conceiving continuously arise in our mind, and they color, and they obscure, and they condition our experience. These concepts take many forms, and they function in many different ways. I want to speak just briefly about how these concepts take root in our minds. We usually have a surface perception of some object, and then we name it.

I'm just very ordinary. We do this all the time. Man, woman, tree, house, car, earth, whatever. There are endless names for the objects which we perceive.

And we assume that this concept that we've created, this name, actually refers back to some self-existing thing. We have a surface perception, we name it, man, woman, tree, house. And then we assume that because we've named it, it actually refers to something solid and real. And we don't stop there.

Based on that assumption of it referring back to something real, something existing, we then proliferate all kinds of judgments, and thoughts, and reactions, and likes, and dislikes, and comparisons. Just as a very simple example, but it's something which I'm sure you've been observing now for the last few months. How rare it is to see another person, and to simply be in the awareness of seeing. I mean, it almost never happens.

We see somebody immediately. There's a name, either generic, man or woman, or specific name. And we think that there's actually some being, somebody there, and our mind gets carried away by these tides of conceiving. And this is happening over and over and over again.

We create home-mind worlds, which we then inhabit for very lengths of time. Mostly we're living in worlds of our own creation. When we look closer though, when we look more deeply at experience, we see that actually there is no solid, solidly existing thing. What we've taken to be so solid is really a constellation of continuously changing elements.

We can see this very clearly, and I'm sure to a large extent you have seen it clearly already, when we look at our understanding, our relationship to our bodies. Mostly we have a concept of body, not only a concept of body, but my body. And that's pretty strongly conditioned. And it's often the immediate response, or the first response to the question which might arise, who am I?

This is who I am, this body. It's a very habituated belief and response. Now we wake up in the morning, we look in the mirror, yeah, that's me. That's our sense of ourselves.

What is that? It's simply a reflection of this form of this body. When we look more closely, and this is exactly what you've been doing for these past months, we see that the body is not something in itself. The body is really a concept.

Can you remember what I mentioned to you or not, but, you know, some friends have had this, laser surgery where they go into the body and there's a camera. They do it by video camera. Now there's this tiny little camera inserted. And in this one case they were removing the fibroid tumor.

And the surgeon is actually doing it by looking at the video screen, you know, and manipulating the knife. And then as the reward of the surgery, you come home with a video of the inside of the body. And it's quite amazing to watch these things, because it says if one is on the inside, and you see the organs and the blood and all that stuff. The innards.

It's very rare, I think, for people to identify with that stuff. You know, we wouldn't really say, yep, the liver is me. The guts are blood. But somehow when it's all neatly packaged, you know, in skin, for some reason we become enchanted.

And we think, yeah, that's who I am. And it's really quite amazing that we do this. And if we looked even more carefully, more closely, you know, we were able to see microscopically on the level of cells, you know, in all the constituent parts of cells, or even more microscopically, and looked at it on the level of atoms and electrons. It becomes even more obvious that there's no one there.

I read somewhere that if all the space were removed from the body, the matter that would remain is the size of a particle of dust. Me, a particle of dust. It's quite astounding what it is we take to be self, you know, what we identify with, and it's because we don't look carefully. Okay, we begin to get a sense of this, to drop down from the level of the concept of the body, the appearance, in the sitting, in the walking.

And then when you do the walking meditation, and you're just with the actual direct experience of the sensations, there are times when the mind leaves aside the concept or image of foot or leg or body. And all there is is pressure, lightness, heaviness, softness, hardness, whatever, just the changing sensations being known. That's what's actually there. And so we get a sense for ourselves not only externally by looking at a video of the inside or scientific diagram, we see in our experience, we actually feel, become aware of the body as an energy field.

And as our mindfulness gets stronger, our perception of this energy field becomes increasingly refined. And sometimes the whole sense of the body or feeling of the body can disappear completely. There are consequences to our not seeing. There are consequences to this proliferation of concept about the body, because when we don't see clearly, and we invest this concept, as we burn back to something real and solid, what happens is we become very attached to the body because we think it's self, we think it's I.

We get attached to our own bodies, we get attached to other people's bodies. Now that would be something to look at. What is it that we're actually attached to or attracted to? When there's attachment to the body, what's the implication of that?

Fear of loss, fear of death. Where does our fear of death come from? It comes from attachment to the body because we haven't seen it deeply and clearly gone beyond the concept. So we create a lot of concepts about physical things, body, man, woman, tree, house, God, the whole physical world universe.

We also create concepts about mental events, experiences that are arising in the mind. We don't usually simply rest in the bare perception, the bare awareness of that experience. We create a concept about it. And there's one example I'd like to mention tonight because it has tremendous power over us, and it's particularly relevant at this time of the retreat.

And that is the concept we create of past and future. We create the concept of time. And it's very interesting to investigate carefully how we're doing this because for the most part, we are imprisoned by these concepts. You're sitting here quietly, watching your breath, minding your own business, and some memories come, some recollections.

These thoughts arise in the mind quite unconsciously, automatically, mechanically. The concept arises about these thoughts, past. We create a concept, past, and then somehow, and this is quite a bit of mental gymnastics, we take this concept which we've created a past and toss it back behind us. If the past is a reality back there from which we're coming.

But really what is happening in our experience? Nothing more than a particular kind of thought arising in the moment. The only way that we experience past is as a thought or a feeling in the moment. And the same thing with future.

We're sitting, we have certain thoughts or images, anticipation, planning. Have you had any plans today? It's quite astounding to see how much of the time we are living our lives in the moment. We're living our lives in the concepts of past and future.

These thoughts arise, planning, anticipating, imagining, we have this idea, create the concept of future, toss it out ahead of us, impute a reality to it, and then living in that mind created reality. Whereas just like the past, the only way we experience the future is as a thought arising in the moment. Now as concepts, past and future are huge. I mean, they're really big.

We're carrying past and future around on our shoulders and they're huge burdens. And yet when we see what they are in our direct experience, we see that they're nothing. They're just a momentary, empty, insubstantial thought in the moment. But so often we're not aware of them.

We're not mindful of the factors only a thought. We buy in to the content. We buy into the concept of time of past and future, which the mind is creating. St.

Augustine said that if the past and future really exist, where are they? And we actually know where they are. They're right here in the moment. All of the past, all of the future actually collapses into a momentary experience.

When it is seen, truly in that way, it is a huge relief. It's like this burden has been lifted from us. It's much easier, infinitely easier, to relate with and to deal with a momentary thought, than to deal with the immensity of these concepts. The concept of past and future of time is a giant tide of conceiving.

I say considering this is particularly relevant now, because as we retreat, it's quite natural that planning thoughts, imagining thoughts, anticipating thoughts are gone to arise. They'll probably come more and more often. This is a fantastic time to free yourself from this burden, to really investigate what it is that happens when these thoughts arise. Do we buy in?

Do we buy into the content? Do we get lost in this mind-created world of future? Or can we see it as being as light as a momentary thought, a momentary? It's just like a sound arises.

But it takes a great deal of vigilance, because these thoughts, these tides of conceiving, are tremendously seductive. Now we've been doing this for years and perhaps lifetimes. But awareness is very powerful. We can actually free ourselves from this prison.

So there's the concepts we create about physical objects. Material is concepts created out of mental events, and time is just one there are many. The most deeply rooted concept that we create and hold and cherish and are attached to is the concept of self. We create a reference point for all experience, as if there's someone to whom experience is happening.

So it's like this. It's like everything funnels back in a V, centered on some concept of I, the observer, the witness, that's who I am. We create a reference point for experience, as if it's happening to someone, and create the concept of self, as if there's someone merely there. The great awakening, great liberation happens when we realize that the self, the I, is a mental construct.

It doesn't refer to anything. It doesn't point to anything. When we drop down or into the nature of experience itself, we see that what is actually happening is, as has been mentioned, empty phenomena rolling on. It's just experiences arising and passing away, not belonging to anybody, not owned by anybody.

What we are is this changing process. So now that the process is happening to someone, there's a nice dialogue between the nun, Vajira, and Mara. This is from the time of the Buddha, this is a little edited version of this dialogue. At one time in Savate, which was one of the main cities of that time with the Buddha, Angar allah, at one time in Savate, the nun Vajira, getting up in the morning, took her bowl in robe and entered Savate for arms.

After eating and returning from arms around, she went into the forest and sat under a tree for her daily meditation. Then Mara, the evil one, wanting to arouse fear, trembling in dread in the nun Vajira, and wanting her concentration to fall away, went and addressed her with a verse. But before I go on, keep in mind that what might induce fear, trembling in dread in the nun of the Buddhist time, is probably different from what would induce fear, trembling in us. Okay, so here's the nun Vajira sitting under the tree in the forest doing a daily meditation.

Mara comes addressing her with a verse. This is what he said. By whom is this being created? Where is the maker of this being?

How does this being arise? How does this being cease? So it's really the question, who are you? Then this occurred to the nun Vajira.

Who could this be? Humin or otherworldly, addressing me with this verse. This must be Mara, the evil one, wanting to arouse fear, trembling in dread in me, and wanting me to fall away from concentration. So the nun Vajira knew this was Mara, and she addressed him back with a verse.

Why prattle on about a being Mara, why talk on about a being? Are you not just lost in wrong views? This, this mind and body, is just a tangle of conditions. Here a being is not to be found.

Just as the word chariot, designates an arrangement of parts. So when there are the aggregates, there occurs the concept being. It is nothing but dukkah arising, nothing but dukkah, which sees this. Then Mara, the evil one, thought, this nun Vajira knows me, and depressed in suffering he vanished from that very spot.

The chariot of this, the simile of the chariot is quite a famous one to illustrate this point. Now that we use a concept to designate an assemblage of parts, but there's no thing in itself which is a chariot. In the same way, we use the word being or self or man or woman to designate an assemblage, the constellation of elements, but there's no thing existing in itself which corresponds. So why is this concept of self so deeply held?

Why is it cherished? Why are we so attached to it? Because it's this concept of self around which our whole lives revolve. We cherish it so strongly because usually in our lives we don't take the time to investigate deeply to examine carefully.

We rely on the surface perception. We see the appearance, we give it a name, we solidify the concept and then hold onto it. Thinking that concept refers to someone, we need to see that what we call self, what we call i, is a constellation of changing elements. Each one of them is momentary and insubstantial.

We don't see the conditioned nature of phenomena. That is everything that arises in our experience is arising due to conditions. Their appearances due to conditions, the conditions change, the appearance changes. Just two examples of this.

I think one I mentioned earlier on in the first part of the retreat, but as a reminder to you, when we go outside after a rain, when the sun is shining and we might see a rainbow. We see this phenomena, we call it a rainbow, we put a name on it. It would be easy to think that the rainbow is actually something in itself. But look back more carefully, what is a rainbow?

I'm not actually sure what a rainbow is, but it's particles of moisture and air and light. The conditions come together and a rainbow appears. But look more carefully, we can see that the rainbow is simply an appearance arising from a certain conjunction of conditions. There's no rainbow thing independent.

There's a Joseph appearance just in each one of us arising from a conjunction of elements, a physical, mental elements. If we can see on that level, then we begin to break through this illusion of I in itself. There's one more example of this which I couldn't bear to let a course go by without mentioning it. It's my favorite example in the world, which is of the Big Dipper.

I'm sure you're familiar with the constellation, the Big Dipper in the sky. And then you look up and you see the stars. You've all been meditating quite a while now. This is the test.

This is your final exam. Is there really a Big Dipper? There's no Big Dipper. Sorry to break the news before Christmas, but there's really no Big Dipper.

We look up, we see stars in a certain pattern, we give it a name, Big Dipper, and then on some level or other, I think, there's a Big Dipper up there. And if you think you don't believe this, what I would suggest is a test. It's on some clear night. And especially if you're familiar with this constellation, go outside, look up at the sky and see if it's possible not to see the Big Dipper.

It's very difficult because we've been conditioned to see in a certain way. So when we see that constellation, it appears in a certain form, we put a name on it, and what does that name do? The function of that concept actually is to separate out those stars from all the other stars in the sky. When we can see free of concept, we're able actually to see the unity, the non-separation and non-separateness.

We are doing the same thing with ourselves. It's like self. I, Joseph, is like Big Dipper. It's a name.

It's a concept to the degree that we are identified, attached to that name and concept. We are imprisoned in separation. We are imprisoned in duality. Kala Rinpoche was a great Tibetan master who died some years ago and has since been reborn in this young Kala Rinpoche now.

He had a beautiful teaching. He said, we live in illusion and the appearance of things. There is a reality. We are that reality.

When you understand this, you see that you are nothing. And being nothing, you are everything. That is all. We live in illusion and the appearance of things.

We're living in the world of concepts and constructs. There is a reality. We are that reality. When we understand this, we see that we are nothing, not identified with anything as being self.

And by being nothing, we are everything. That is all. Because what remains is simply the totality of everything that is. We're not separating ourselves out as being just one small part.

So what are the realities that can be experienced directly? In order to talk to four, four realities. One are the material physical elements which we've talked about. We experience them as changing sensations.

A sight, a sound, a smell, just a material physical world. It's one reality that can be experienced directly. Consciousness. The knowing that arises in each moment out of contact between the sense object and the sense door.

That particular consciousness arises. So visible object, eye consciousness, ear consciousness, nose consciousness. Because that's the reality that we can experience moment to moment. The third reality are what was called mental factors.

All the associated factors arising with consciousness. And we've talked about a lot of them over these months. There are the wholesome ones of love, of generosity, of wisdom, of compassion, of mindfulness, of concentration. They're the unwholesome ones of re-hatredilusion, fear, and be jealousing.

Only afflicted emotions. And these are factors, also not I, not south. They don't belong to anybody. They arise in particular moments out of conditions.

They color consciousness in a particular way and then they pass away. So these are three realities that are conditioned phenomena. Physical elements, consciousness, mental factors. There's a fourth reality which we can experience directly.

And that's what the Buddha called nibana, nibana in Pali or nirvana, the unconditioned. It was a time-onk who also died recently. It was a very, it was a wonderful teacher, quite a free thinker, for being classically trained in Thailand as a monk. His name was Buddha Dasa.

He spoke in a very simple and down-to-earth way about the meaning of the Pali word nibana, that's actually what it means. It means coolness. And it's used in Thailand also very colloquially. So the example he gave, which is quite cute.

He said in the villages, you know, when people were cooking food and they were boiling their ice, and then they took the rice off the stove, somebody might say, for example, wait a little bit for the rice to become nibana, for the rice to cool down. Because that's what the word means. It means to cool down. Let's wait for the rice to nibana of it.

So we can understand the meaning of nibana as the mind which is cooled down, free from the fires of the cholaces, the fires of the defilements. Buddha Dasa said that the more cool the mind, the more nibana in that moment. And so this puts a very down-to-earth understanding of what nibana is about. It's the mind cooling down.

It's the cooling down process. So we can notice through the day the various states of coolness that arise. It's almost like we can pay attention to the nibana thermostat. You know, is the mind heated up or is it cooled down?

A few ways to notice this practically, to actually get an experiential sense of what cool down means. Notice when the mind is lost in some desire, some wanting, some craving. If not tonight, tomorrow or the next day, or hopefully before the end of the course, just wait for the next craving. And if you can, notice carefully that moment of transition when the craving falls away.

You may not pick the craving up at the beginning, but perhaps in the middle. You'll be in the middle of some wanting, some desire. It can be a simple one. It can be a very big one.

So in the middle of some desire, you become aware of it. But pay careful attention to the moment that it falls away. And notice the difference in your experience between those two mind states. Of the mind filled with desire and the mind freed from the grip of desire.

And it's quite amazing because even when there's some pleasantness, some pleasurable aspect of the desire, which is what usually entrances us. If you're attentive enough to that moment of transition, I think you will experience an amazing sense of relief when we're out of the grip of it. It's like, we're caught, caught, caught. And then the mind relaxes.

It's released. Let's go. Right there, you can get a taste of what coolness means. Even more commonly, pay attention to the difference between being lost in a thought and being aware of a thought.

Notice what that difference is. Out of that degree of attention, I think you will notice the heat or the fire or the tension of the contraction of being identified with a thought. When we're lost in a thought, it's like we're contracted into it. In the moment of being aware of the thought, again, the mind opens.

It releases. You can begin to get a taste of the coolness of the nibana of the mind in relationship to pain. Now, when there's some discomfort in the body, very often we're caught in the tension of the resistance of not liking of a version, either in a very gross way or very solid way. And often it's around fear.

Now, on some level, fear of simply feeling the discomfort, fear of feeling the pain. Notice the difference between that state and when we're able actually to open fully completely to just feeling the pain and discomfort, the unpleasantness. It's basically through a certain courage of the heart, a willingness of the heart, a let me feel this. Notice the difference.

You will experience, I think, the nibana, the coolness of that release. All of these examples, watching the mind be free of the grip of desire, coming out of a thought, the relaxation into unpleasantness, all of these point to qualities of nibana, qualities of relief, of release, of openness. Who did that? I went on to say in this context that we actually couldn't live with our nibana because it's this quality of coolness which puts out the fires of greed, of hatred, delusion.

We couldn't live if the mind were consumed by those fires all the time. So many times during the day, we actually are experiencing a coolness. Pay attention to that. That's an important indication, an important inclination of the mind.

When there's temporary letting go of the cholasses, we can call it temporary nibana. When there's the complete eradication of the cholasses of the top of the firemen, we could call it complete or supreme nibana. So this is one way of understanding nibana as coolness, the cooling down of the mind. Now in different Buddhist traditions, even within terravato, not to speak of Tibetan or Zen, but even within terravato Buddhism, there's a wide range of perspectives, a wide range of expressions, of the experience of the unconditioned.

I just wanted to sort of lay out a little bit of the range of the ways it's understood. One perspective on the experience of the unconditioned, the Absolute, is expressed in the tradition of Mahasicaya Dao, and it's very much based, of course, on practice, on realization in practice. And also the suttas and the abhidhama, so it is a very classical interpretation. This is the understanding, and it's a teaching that's found in almost every suit of the Buddha, so it's very common.

It's the teaching about the five aggregates, and that what we call being is really just the play of the five constituents, of material elements, feelings, perceptions, what it calls sankars or all the habituated tendencies and consciousness. Now this is an important point. In this perspective, or in this viewpoint, there is no awareness outside of these five aggregates. There's no consciousness outside of this play of the five aggregates, and all of these five aggregates are considered condition, phenomena, arising and passing away.

So consciousness itself, awareness itself, is seen to be part of this conditioned flow, consciousness itself arising and passing in every moment. So what we do in our practice is to pay attention to each arising in every moment, things are being known, right, sight or sound or smell or sensation or thought or whatever. And as we rest in the mindfulness of each arising moment, what happens is that we go through various stages of insight, and these are classical stages, we call it the progress of insight in this particular model. And we go through stages of tremendous joy and elation when the mind has become concentrated clear, seeing the arising and passing very sharply.

Think Steve spoke the other night, what are called the upa callases. And it's interesting, this is an interesting happening, because at this stage, this tremendous radiance of mind, there's real luminosity and rapture and concentration and mindfulness, and it's all happening wonderfully and effortlessly. Really the fact is in alignment, but they're called corruptions of insight, not because it problems in themselves, but because of the liability that we get attached to them. They're so pleasant and so nice that we claim.

Okay, so we go through this stage and then we move on if we're able to actually stay mindful and just watch all of these states coming off. And we go through stages of real duka, of misery and fear at seeing the, seeing deeply, really deeply, the unreliability and the continual dissolution of the phenomena. But everything is disappearing at the moment. If the moment is like the rug keeps getting pulled out from under us and there's no place to stand.

There's no security. And so seeing this on a very deep level, around is a lot of fear and disgust and misery. This particular time in practice is called rolling up the mat stage, because all people want to do is roll up the mat and leave. We don't like to see this, it's very difficult.

It's a very difficult time. But if we are persevering and we have the right support, we stay mindful of these stages and we come to a place of very profound equanimity. Where the mind settles into a balance in which it is completely non-reactive to both pleasant and unpleasant. And this is a very tremendous state of ease in well-being.

The mind has reached a perfect balance. On this place of equanimity, all the factors of enlightenment are right-being. You know, mindfulness investigation, rapture concentration, calm, etc. There's no craving at this point, there's no yearning.

Not even for the next breath or no craving for existence. The mind has settled back into itself completely. There's no urge for becoming or not becoming. And what happens at that time, this flow of continuously arising conditioned objects, which is happening at the moment, at the moment, at the moment.

When everything is in balance and ripened, can suddenly and abruptly just come to a stop, come to a halt. And the mind, a light, or consciousness, a light on the unconditioned, on the fauna, the unborn. Through the force of non-clinging, non-craving for anything out of that perfect balance, this conditioned flow of the non-stop and the mind opens to it, it's unconditioned. Now in Pali, this is called magafala, or path-fruition consciousness.

And it has the very great power of uprooting from the mind, defilments in different stages, so that they don't arise again. And this is where the model comes of stages of enlightenment. So the first glimpse, for example, of this unborn unconditioned reality, uproots the belief in self in I. It's a very powerful transformation through later development, the further successive stages, slowly greed is uprooted, desires uprooted, restlessness is uprooted.

So this is the model or the experience of purification from this view. O bippoos, there is that sphere where there is neither earth, nor air, nor fire, nor water. Neither this world nor the next, neither coming or going. There is an unborn, unbecome.

O bikus, I shall teach you the unformed, the profound. So this is the mind opening to that reality. We call it absolute nibana. There's a story about Saraputta, who was disclaiming about the bliss of nibana.

They're saying, oh, the bliss of nibana, the bliss of nibana. And one of the monks said, oh, Saraputta, a venerable one. If there are no sensations in nibana, how can it be blissful? Because our whole association with bliss is of blissful sensations.

And Saraputta said, my friend, it is precisely because there is no sensations that it is blissful. So in this light, we understand nibana, or the unconditioned, as putting down the burden of ceaselessly changing phenomena. When we see that what we call self, what we call I, is just phenomena arising and passing ceaselessly. So we introduce the individual to say, where is the end of seeing?

Where is the end of hearing? Where is the end of thinking? We've been doing this endlessly. And so the experience of the unconditioned from this perspective is the putting down of that burden, the relief.

An example which came to my mind, I know the experience of sitting in a kitchen someplace. I'm just talking or eating or whatever. And then all of a sudden, the hum of the refrigerator goes off. And there's that, it's like that moment of relief.

About something that we didn't even know was a problem. Until it stopped and then we realized the disturbance of it. So this is something like that. Now it's this endless hum of conditioned phenomena endlessly rising and passing, and then the experience of the stopping of that and the reality of that peace.

So this is one, both viewpoint and perspective and experience that happens for people. There's another perspective on the experience of nibana or the unconditioned. And it's most clearly articulated in the teachings of the Thai forest tradition. In this tradition, a distinction is made between the consciousness, the conditioned consciousness of the aggregates, and we're rising and passing at each sense door, and what they call jitta, translated as the heart, but the heart meaning the mind.

So the heart mind. And in the experience of the great masters of the Thai forest tradition, this experience of jitta in its unmodified form is beyond the aggregates. There's no sign by which it can be known. Sometimes it's called the signless because it has no sign of impermanence.

And this is the mind free of any kalaysa. One of the great Thai masters who's still living, who was a disciple of Ajahn Mahabua, a person who's spoken about with this very fierce and powerful teacher, his name is Ajahn Mahabua, and he has a monastery in northeast Thailand. He gives teachings about the conventional mind and the mind released. Now the conventional mind is the mind conditioned by the tides of conceiving.

I will usualize all the things that are going on all the time, conditioned by ignorance, conditioned by craving. This is what we're familiar with. But when these kalaysa disappear through mindfulness, through wisdom, then the true mind or the mind released appears in its full aspect. And all that remains is pure awareness, simple awareness, naturally pure awareness.

Now this awareness has no reference point. It has no center. It can't be located in any particular place. It's unsupported, unconditioned, unconstructed.

And all of the aggregates are still functioning. The material elements and feelings and perceptions, and the consciousness of the sense stores in them. Tendencies, they all still function according to their own nature, but the mind which is released, completely released, is not in any way affected by them. So just if you can imagine for a moment, just the mind, the mind empty of any kalaysa, any clinging at all, any attachment at all, pure clear, unobstructed, unaffected by any arising appearance.

This pure awareness does not partake of any feeling except for the feeling of what Ajahn Mahabharata called ultimate ease of the very nature of the released mind, ultimate ease of the highest peace. And what he emphasized in his teachings was that all the kalayas, the defilence, the path of practice, and the simple and utterly pure awareness are already right here in the heart. So it's not something out there to find. It's something to uncover.

This is from the teachings of the Buddha, an explanation of the third and the truth. Now the first noble truth is the truth of suffering. The second is the cause of suffering. The third is the end of suffering, only the final.

The fourth is the path leading to the end. What now is the noble truth of the extinction of suffering? It is the complete fading away and extinction of this craving. It's forsaking and abandonment, liberation and detachment from it from the craving, the extinction of greed, of hatred, of delusion.

This indeed is called nibana. And remember and listen to this that it's not about something outside of ourselves. Right now in listening, drop back into this very space. It's our own minds.

The nature of our own minds, free of greed, free of hatred, free of delusion, right now. And for a disciple less freed, in whose heart dwells peace, there is nothing to be added to what has been done, and nothing more remains to do. Just as a rock of one solid mass remains unshaken by the wind. Even so, neither forms, nor sounds, nor odors, nor tastes, nor contacts of any kind.

Neither the desired nor the undesired can cause such a one to waver. One is steadfast in mind, gained its deliverance. Remember, this is our own minds. One who has considered all the contrasts of this earth, and is no more disturbed by anything whatever in the world.

The peaceful one, freed from rage, from sorrow, and from longing, has passed beyond birth and death. It's our own minds. Freed from rage, freed from sorrow, freed from longing, has passed beyond birth and death. This I call neither arising nor passing away, neither standing still nor being born nor dying.

There is neither foothold, nor development, nor any basis. This is the end of suffering. Hence the purpose of the holy life does not consist in acquiring arms, honor, or fame. Nor in gaining morality, concentration, or the eye of knowledge.

This unshakable deliverance of the heart, that indeed is the object of the holy life. That is its essence, that is its goal. But this is what our practice is all about. It's actually coming to discover this unshakable deliverance of the heart of the mind.

And we do it gradually. We do it in stages. We get glimpses of the mind unfettered by Kalais's pay attention to the quality of that mind, with something as profound and as subtle, and as transforming as the experience of the unconditioned, the unborn, the unformed of Nivana. There will always be a variety of perspectives about it, or ways of expressing the experience.

I appreciate the range because it helps keep our own mind free from any ideas or concepts about it. Can we settle back into the openness of our own experience without preconception, and resting even for a moment in that mind which is not bound, which is not craving, which is not clinging. It's the first thing.

Frequently asked questions

How long is this episode of Insight Hour with Joseph Goldstein?

This episode is 1 hour and 3 minutes long.

When was this Insight Hour with Joseph Goldstein episode published?

This episode was published on April 13, 2023.

Is there a transcript available for this episode?

Yes, a full transcript is available for this episode. You can read the complete transcript on the episode page.

Can I download this Insight Hour with Joseph Goldstein episode?

Yes. Use the download control on the episode player to save the publisher-provided media file.