it feels like everyone's searching for the secret to living longer these days better health sharper minds stronger bodies this is the chonty and the dog podcast i'm dr marcus rani and i'm joined by someone who understands performance and resilience better than most international cricketer chonty rose in this show we explore the science of longevity from how our bodies age to the everyday habits that help us stay strong sharp and resilient as the years go by catch full episodes on the ibm podcast youtube channel and on all audio streaming platforms hello and welcome to a simplified shorty this is chuck here who uh in a moment of being backstabbed by his um uh favorite passion almost got choked by uh headphones that just fell behind on the chair and now that's no kind of a little bit this is incredibly fetishy this is my love for headphones yeah and this is tony and we're going to talk about i thought he was going to say i'm naren and then i'm just going to admonish him for i'm himself and i'm speaking yes hi clearly i'm not uh used to being in a host yet and uh this is like sort of my first attempt at uh taking the lead so let's make it easy for him so that's why i'm glad you guys didn't wear pants so so tony is going to lead this shorty what are we shooting uh today yeah so i'm uh feeling slightly nervous to be honest because you guys have built up tremendous equity over 166 but boss if you are intimidated by the intellectual structure of chuck me and shriek yeah what you should be more intimidated about this is that this is episode number 167 167 of course being the score that previous election scored against australia in 2001 at sydney so yeah that's what you should be more scared okay yeah so anyway all of the equity i am just slightly worried that i might demolish it all in one go so in that spirit i picked a topic where like something was built and standing for over a decade and it was demolished in one go uh the fascinating case of marida flats have you guys heard about this no i know marida is a place in kerala good good job yes yeah okay so this was a building which was built online which was uh under the coastal regulation zone and not allowed to be built they built it anyway and it was supervised by a long series of uh government officials and finally they all decided after it was built and sold to people that it shouldn't have been in the first place and then yeah well done yeah so anyway yeah like i said on 11th and 12th of january this year so like a couple weeks ago uh four apartment buildings with 246 flats which one's an apartment which one's a flat again i have no idea so we go and 46 flats were demolished by implosion in marida which is in hernakulam kerala where i come from and this issue may not have been reported in mainstream media but it was extensively covered in kerala and literally blow by blow i'm going to show you guys a video and maybe you can explain to us what's happening okay cool and the listeners also about this okay basically that's a newsroom full of people laughing while flats have been demolished yeah that's what i was wondering yeah so in i mean if you give it another 10 seconds rewind you'll understand why they were laughing and i'll show you that also okay uh i am not saying that you are banned from saying that could also be a simplified tagline but basically this is a level of recording that was happening in kerala where these uh two reporters uh hid inside a kakus i mean it's funny to say kakus in toilet because they wanted to capture it yeah so basically when these flats were about to be demolished by implosion they had uh it would have been so much more fun if those toilets were in the building that were being demolished but thankfully these guys came out of the closet and basically what what was happening was uh they didn't post section 144 and tiered area because you know obviously explosives were used to bring the building down and they wanted one shot with all three flats being demolished so they hid in one uh toilet this is just their way of saying see what good things section 144 can be used for yeah so basically i was just saying that uh depending on where you started following it uh your point of view may differ right so first you saw like the laughing now you've seen the guy inside the toilet um but basically not everyone knows the full story of what's happened and everyone is obviously opinionated because of the way media that was the story and we need to sort of draw the nuances for us it's simplified it's one nuancy oh my god very hardy boys to get there okay so basically this is in 2020 but if you rewind the clock to 2019 um the story that was covered across media was basically a lot of people outside the flats on a hunger strike against evacuation order which was passed by the supreme court so there were people living in these 246 flats all of them were to be evacuated uh oh i thought it was like uh what's that world famous thing are the shalsing society over here oh okay no but i don't think those are demolished right no they're not just standing yeah no south bombay is uh one of the historic south bombay like uh tower buildings along with gateway of india yeah so uh so yeah in 2019 many of these people had invested their life savings into buying apartments and all and they were out on the streets doing hunger strikes and uh so at that point in time the supreme court had already said that these flats need to be demolished and many arguments were put forward uh and the media covered basically what they were saying and uh basically two of the arguments one was that this has already happened so you know now why go ahead and demolish it because people are already living there the second part was uh you mentioned about the coastal regulatory zone and all that and the classification has changed now so as per the new law it is valid so like you know why demolish it so if this is the place that you're coming in at uh you're obviously sympathizing with the flat owners and you know what nonsense letter of the law and all is fine but according to spirit why you're making people homeless etc so but uh how did it even come to the supreme court in the first place that's uh where we need to sort of simplify a little bit for anyone who's there and listening to it for the first time so if you've been to kochi like you you probably know maradu for uh le meridian which is one of the first hotels that came oh that's where it gets its name from yeah but for everyone else who doesn't uh like interesting trivia is that it is a couple of kilometers away from from taikudum bridge oh and uh this is also that way i'm just saying uh maybe things are two kilometers away from taikudum bridge like i don't know like what's the other direction but none of them also interest of uh listeners who are not really interested who are not really big fans of malayali rock taikudum bridge is like a pretty famous uh malayali band which uh yeah which hosts uh and uh can i ask you to connect uh five spice and taikudum bridge i think that's the best way to introduce taikudum bridge oh damn um okay clearly i that tweet worked well if i already remembers it a long back i put out a tweet that uh so there's a restaurant in uh bombay called five spice which are notorious for humongous quantities so i ordered one from there and i hope i don't get my own tweet wrong but i said something like i ordered two dishes from five spice by mistake and i forgot they use a uh measurement scale where uh one serving equal to uh enough meals for taikudum bridge members for a month correct so momos for over the weekend it is yeah something yeah that's a long deviation and the point being that taikudum bridge has more members than even simplified as horse right 18 also yes yeah so there's 14 more to go for us then back to marida which is uh obviously also mentioned in harry potter in the marida's map sorry but anyway it was a basically it was a nice little green village located in the backwaters and it was a drama panchayatara village and this is very important as time goes by right so uh essentially how did it come to the supreme court uh marida panchayat basically issued uh permits to several builders in 2006 when it was still a panchayat and they started construction of apartment complexes but then people knew that something was up and there's something shady about these permits so vigilance department started their uh you know inquiry but also like uh at this point in time if you normally want to build something in a village you just need approval from the local authorities which is the gram panchayat but in 1986 there's the environment protection act which was introduced after the bhopal tragedy uh and basically in the 1991 the ministry of environment and forests also under the environment protection act uh called for categorization of what is called coastal regulation zone basically um you know areas that are very close to uh biodiverse coast etc what kind of permission can be provided and there are four classifications so there's cr1 which is if it's like very close to mangroves and stuff like that where you can't do any construction uh cr2 and cr3 these are of importance because cr2 applies to urban areas and cr3 applies to rural areas so if it's in a rural area the construction standards are most stringent if it's in an urban area it's a little bit more relaxed right so basically in a cr said uh two area you can probably build a flat if it's you know certain distance away from the tideline right so again this is why it becomes important because uh so essentially you have uh see a coastal regulation zones coming into in 1991 and in 1996 the coastal zone management plan was introduced which basically lays out guidelines as to what you can construct and what you can't etc right so uh in 2006 was when the gramma panchayat gave uh permissions for them to build except they didn't consult the uh coastal regulatory authorities etc small step they missed out but the builders are like okay we've got the permission and five flats started construction and but basically uh these guys found out which is a coastal zone management authority and send a show cost notice to them now uh what is interesting is the builders instead of replying to uh this basic question of how you can do this uh they filed a written petition in the high code sort of stating that uh you know we've already got permission from uh you know the authorities now how can you hold us accountable etc so they continue building the building almost like a dine middle finger too correct sort of like horses bolted now you know right like okay so uh but basically the high code agreed with them saying yeah yeah okay you've got some permissions and all okay you don't need to answer the other thing and but at this point in time there must be a lot of money and toddy exchange yeah this is all conjecture obviously which we shall not get into but basically uh that the backwaters are rather murky oh it's what we just well done so uh there were five buildings that were built at this point but because of these legal hassles one builder dropped out and dropped the project four others completed and handed over flags to people who uh started living there now meanwhile after this uh petition was filed a review was again filed by the coastal authorities which again the high court said it's okay whatever right it's at this point that it comes to the supreme court now is where uh things get interesting because now the uh supreme court uh takes cognizance of what has happened right and and basically there are a few interesting things happening at this point in time so it went to the supreme court and basically uh for once their judgment wasn't 1050 pages long long sermon on uh you know what constitutes a person and a religion building and all that so i went ahead and read it so i went ahead and read the full judgment which is also important because uh bring some nuance into this whole thing right and uh by this whole thing do you mean simply because it has several interesting questions right for instance if you uh think about the people who are evacuated it's like a you know fundamental violation of uh it seems like a violation of you know where they live maslow's hierarchy but also when the case comes to supreme court obviously they have to judge it on merit and interestingly in 2004 itself there was a judgment in the supreme court so much before this uh building permission was even given where in goa there was a case where the crc violations were taken very seriously and um basically uh demolished or whatever and basically also important to notice that it's a biodiverse and fragile uh backwaters and the cases come to the supreme court at a time where climate change is actually meeting its presence felt right and especially in kerala yeah exactly so their judgment actually refers to um you know the floods in udara and in tamilnadu in kerala and how exploitation of uh these uh biodiverse and fragile backwaters is actually uh cause an issue etc right and they've also basically said that the coastal zone management plan uh the high court has completely ignored that by saying that uh you know basically you've only looked at uh the permission that was given but not the actual thing so now basically the supreme court says what we need to figure out is does this fall in uh crz2 or crz3 right because one makes the building valid the other does it and that's when all hell breaks loose basically right so they appoint a committee to sort of figure out uh what is happening here and the committee is formed of the local ias guy the district collector the municipality secretary why the municipality secretary because in uh 2010 uh murder has now become a municipality it's no longer yeah because they married in team lots of actually lots of national highways game around it so now there are like lots of uh you know five star hotels crown plaza and holiday and i mean all of those things around there so basically you've got upgraded so now that is what the supreme court needs to uh decide upon uh and basically what the committee found was that in 1953 it was a panchayat in 2010 it became a municipality uh and the applicable coastal uh you know management plan is from 1996 and therefore it falls under crz3 which means the buildings cannot stand right oh no but since it's upgraded in 2010 uh there is the municipality has a new map of course because they have now a municipality so it shows this particular thing in uh crz3 so it is basically when schrodinger's crz3 so CRZ in the sheets yeah something like that so basically what happened also in 2011 was there was new CRZ notification that was given but and this is the key point that all the TV channels keep talking about is that as per this it is in CRZ 3 and therefore it's valid but the problem is that it was in a draft version and the central government has not actually notified it even though it happened in 2011 so there's a freeze put on what is happening etc so the Supreme Court says since this is frozen it is still under CRZ 3 and even if it was the case that it was standing now when you started the construction it was in CRZ 3 so therefore this building is yeah I think that's where a key distinction need to be made between media reports of people obviously and courts have to judge based on the merit of the year so it's a single point thing that the Supreme Court passes a judgment on whether this building you know standing in an area which is CRZ 2 or CRZ 3 and very clearly it is standing somewhere where it is CRZ 3 and therefore it needs to be demolished that basically was the thing that happened and but now this raises several interesting questions right so okay fine you're evacuating people who bought their flats and hard-earned money etc now what is the remedial action and the compensation right because obviously there are multiple things right and the value of each flat was arrived at 25 lakhs by the Supreme Court or the value on the sale deed now I think Naren you will be in a better place to tell us what the actual value of the flat versus what it is on the sale deed it's usually 4x 3x yeah correct right so basically anyone who bought the flat has screwed themselves by putting a lower value on the sale deed because that is going to determine what it is and irrespective there's also the time value of money right so if you've paid in 2010 and it's been 10 years since then obviously like you expect the money to appreciate and also the compensation has to be paid out by the builders and for 246 flats that works out around 60-62 pros so which means that basically these guys are going to be running from pillar to post to collect although the Supreme Court has directed that the state yeah but if they're bankrupt then I don't think they can be even put into jail or anything correct yeah so basically it will go out of the state tax checker at some point but if you were one of those homeowners I'm sure you wouldn't be looking at it it's a terrible thing to happen a similar thing happened to this building called Campa Cola oh yeah yeah yeah but buildings came up under the noses of you know public oversight public official oversight and they all got away spot free so even in Maradu case I don't think any public officials have saved the heat at all and this makes the public cynical right so the victims basically they're punishing the victims that's what is happening yeah technically as a builder I've got the papers that I mean yeah but yeah so essentially that's the why this case becomes very important is because Supreme Court has basically applied both the caveat tempter and caveat venditor right saying you know you can't just go out and buy a flat I mean you can it might be demolished tomorrow so it also brings about you know what you need to look for look at in case there are any anyone planning can I explain those two terms I know what one of them means yeah caveat tempter is basically buyer beware and caveat venditor is seller beware so in this case I mean if you're basically buying a fake product right then probably the onus is on you in certain cases like when it's pharmaceuticals I'm guessing like you know you can't you have to rely on some official to or some authority to tell you whether it's good or not and that authority is lying then who is culpable so in this case it's like that and they're obfuscating that part of the process yeah who will watch the watchman scenario yeah and also like I mean we're all except for Nareen we're all in our 30s right and probably looking at buying homes at some point thankfully we're in Bombay we never have that thought but otherwise I mean honestly I had no idea that you had to look at something like CRZ rules given that let's say Mumbai, Chennai, Kolkata all of them fall major metals fall close to CRZ something called land usage rules what the title of the property is this is a major thing that I used to see in Bangalore where like you know people would say this is their land but it's always under litigation like if you're buying a flat in one of those places it probably doesn't even you know belong to you in the first place and also there's something called sanction plans which is where let's say an apartment is allowed to build up to 22 floors but they're like okay 30 floors we'll construct we'll get it later but if you bought a 27 floor or whatever it could be demolished tomorrow so there are so many of these implications arising out of this to say like you know you can't just go out and look at a flashy brochure listen to your broker and buy your house etc so the flat is if we broke but yeah I think all these environmental issues are obviously key right we can't you know batter blind eye to it anymore correct yeah so I think some of these nuances are very important and in this case at least I think you know the supreme court has made a very very objective sort of judgment and while the pain of everyone is recognized I think it is also a good wake up call for everyone you know half measures you can't get away with this yeah now with us we'll have to you know think twice before just very inefficient so yeah some good things yeah wow that is heavy yeah but yeah okay interestingly like last week my mom was home and that's why you know I got interested in this topic because she was sad about all the people who lost their homes and I was like okay and then we played a game of Jenga and my mom was playing it for the first time and she's like oh this is a Marita game oh wow so yeah I know I mean now we call Jenga the Marita game and nothing else okay so thank you thank you we'll give you 8 on 10 which I've taken off Nareem I mean the only thing we can say to our listeners is not just caveat emptor and the other one but caveat auditor which is listener beware oh yeah wow so be careful who you're listening to because tomorrow who knows what regulation simplified is violating absolutely which can also be a tagline so stay safe stay safe don't stay at Marita that was a long walk to get to that see you guys next week bye bye bye
Ep. 167: The word is Flat - Deconstructing Maradu
from Simblified Hosted by IVM Podcasts
On 11th and 12th Jan 2020, 4 apartment complexes in Maradu (in Kochi, Kerala) were brought following a longdrawn legal battle. This story was fascinating enough for the Simblified gang to read the actual Supreme Court order and so they had to let people know about their glorious achievement. In this shortie, the quartet try to present a very simblified version of what happened, what it means, and what you should keep in mind if you're in the market to buy a flat. Also, they stumble over the difference between an apartment and a flat. Feat: Thaikkudam Bridge. Link: Supreme Court Order helpfully highlighted by a Reddit user - https://imgur.com/a/vHCNt0a Meet your hosts aka The Ultracrepidarians! Chuck | Naren | Srikeit | Tony Instagram: @chuckofalltrades | @shenoynv | @srikeit | @notytony Twitter: @chuck_gopal | @shenoyn | @srikeit | @notytony Say hello and tell us what you think! We love your feedback. We'd love it if you could leave a rating on Apple Podcasts - it really helps boost visibility and our egos. Simblified is: An Indian podcast that takes things that happen around us and deconstructs them in a manner you can understand and impress your colleagues, next interviewer, date or cat. Run by four folks seeking a return to the "good ol' days of Twitter" - Chuck, Naren, Srikeit & Tony, Simblified has the guarantee of "if we can understand it, you can!" and proceeds to look at everything from technology to politics to weird phenomena to questions you never knew you wanted to be answered. Along the way, you'll hear lots of bad jokes, facts, PG Wodehouse references, and more bad jokes. Hopefully, you'll have a laugh
Embed this episode
What this episode covers
On 11th and 12th Jan 2020, 4 apartment complexes in Maradu (in Kochi, Kerala) were brought following a longdrawn legal battle. This story was fascinating enough for the Simblified gang to read the actual Supreme Court order and so they had
Transcript Auto-generated, may contain errors