Skip to content
Ep. 175 – Instructions on Working with Thoughts episode artwork

Aug 2, 2023 26 min

Ep. 175 – Instructions on Working with Thoughts

from Insight Hour with Joseph Goldstein

In this episode of the Insight Hour podcast, Joseph Goldstein delves into the nature of thought and provides valuable insights on cultivating mindfulness. This dharma talk from May 13, 2023, was recorded at the Insight Meditation Society and originally published on Dharma Seed. WIN A TRIP FOR YOU AND A FRIEND TO OUR 2023 MAUI RETREAT: Maui Retreat Giveaway In this talk, Joseph: Encourages us to notice when we become aware of our own thinking Highlights the importance of recognizing the themes of our thoughts Emphasizes that the past and the future are conceptual models Examines the very nature of thought itself “When we’re unaware of thoughts, unmindful, they have so much power in our lives, they;re really directing our lives. And yet when we are mindful of them, as I say, it is a little more than nothing.”

Episode details come from the podcast's RSS feed.

Embed this episode

Ready to play

Ep. 175 – Instructions on Working with Thoughts

0:00 26:36
of matches

Transcript Auto-generated, may contain errors

When we're unaware of thoughts, unmindful, they have so much power in our lives, they're really direct in our lives, and yet when we are mindful of them, as I said, little more than nothing. Welcome to the Joseph Goldstein Insight Hour. This podcast is an expression of our shared interest in self-discovery. Join Joseph as he shares his deep knowledge of the path of mindfulness.

If you are interested in supporting this podcast, please go to beherenownetwork.com slash joseph. This morning, we're going to emphasize more explicitly one of the most important and challenging aspects of being mindful, and that is quite explicitly making thought the object of the mindfulness. You've probably noticed that we live a great deal of our lives lost in the realm of thoughts, and we often take the thought to be the reality itself. And so, to a large extent, we're just living in the story of our lives.

You know, the thoughts that come into the mind, like everything else, are conditioned by a lot of different things, of our past, and our upbringing, and our education, and society. So, it's not that our thoughts are all original and unique to ourselves. It's just the phenomena of mind, which is basically taken over. In this respect, the practice of becoming mindful that we're thinking, of recognizing that a thought is there and what a thought is, is tremendously freeing.

It kind of takes us out of the box, you know, of our own particular stories and perceptions. And we can see them more clearly, and then assess, in any particular moment, is this helpful, is it not helpful, instead of simply being carried away by the very many thoughts that are arising in the course of the day. Somebody once mentioned a study where they had counted the number of thoughts typically a person has, and I can't remember now, so it's possible I'm making this up. But my recollection is there's something like 10,000 thoughts a day, or some huge number, you know.

And you probably noticed that we are not aware of a good many of them. We're just lost in them, and then at a certain point, we come out from being lost. So for myself, it's a tremendously interesting arena to really pay attention to, and to understand, because there's kind of an immediate sense of greater spaciousness, of ease, of freedom, when we come out from being lost, or when we're aware of the thought as it's happening. Very different space than being lost in it and identified with it.

So I want to offer just a few approaches to becoming mindful of thought, but you may well discover some of your own, you know, as you're practicing. So one of the first things we can do is to pay attention to when we become aware that we're thinking. It's simply to notice. Are we aware of the thought as it just arises?

Do we become aware of it in the middle? Do we become aware of it after it's over, and we remember that we were thinking? You know, we've already come out. And you may have experience of all three of them.

Most likely, predominantly, the last one. Right? Oh, yeah. It's thinking.

So this is, it's not to be looking at this with any sense of judgment. It's just a way of focusing our attention and refining our awareness of thought as a process. So it's simply to notice, you know, not adding a judgment about it, just to see. Then it can be helpful to notice if there are any three dominant themes of the books.

Usually people have a top 10, maybe a top five, I don't know. You know, it might be work, it might be family, relationships, the state of the world, whatever. You know, we each have our own particular affinity for different subject matters. It's really helpful to begin to recognize if there are any particular patterns to the themes of the book, and to see which ones are most seductive.

Because some thoughts may be easier to pick up. They don't pull us in. And other thoughts, for whatever reason, we're just seduced by them again and again, get lost in the story of it. If you can begin to notice, you know, the top few themes anyway, it's helpful to recognize that, to set the intention in the mind, keep an eye out for this.

You know, so just beginning to sit in, you're priming yourself. To be mindful, be aware of those thoughts which most typically carry you away, or you get lost in family tape, work tape, whatever it may be. One of the most prevalent themes for almost everybody are thoughts of past and future. These are very interesting thoughts to recognize as such as thoughts, because it really begins to change in quite a profound way our notion of time.

We tend to think of the past as being back there in the future, someplace ahead of us, and we substantiate these concepts, and we make a thing of past and future, and it's very interesting to observe how much of our mental activity is involved in these big classes of thoughts. You know, and again, within the category of past and future, there may be particular themes, but the larger context of thoughts of past, thoughts of future. One of the most freeing aspects that I found in noticing those kinds of thoughts is the realization that past and future are really concepts. How do we ever experience the past?

It's only as a thought or image in the present moment. How do we ever experience the future as a particular thought or image? If we are lost in the concepts of past and future, it's like carrying, this is going to be an odd image, but two mountains on our shoulders. We're going through life burdened by the weight of past and future one way or another.

And we don't often realize that our experience of past and future is simply a thought in the moment, or a concept weighs heavily, but when we see it as just a thought, it's very light. And so to begin to go through our lives, recognizing when these thoughts come, so we're not just lost in and consumed by the content of our past and future thoughts, but we see them for what they are. It's just a thought. It comes and goes.

And it doesn't mean, as we've said different times, it doesn't mean that we are ignoring the content, but rather by first seeing it for what it is, oh, this is just a thought arising in the moment. That space gives us the space to assess, does this thought need a response? Does it need action? Does it not?

You've probably noticed by now that most of the thoughts we have do not need a response. It's just this endless proliferation in the mind. But some do. You know, when we're mindful of thinking, of past thought, future thought.

So we are disidentifying with it, but it doesn't mean necessarily that we're ignoring the content. We're seeing it and then seeing whether it requires any particular response or not. So it creates a lot more space in our lives and in our practice. So first noticing at what point in the thought process you become aware of it, seeing if you recognize some number of predominant themes and then setting the intention to keep an eye out for them because they are so seductive, so easy to get caught up in, and to make a note of that particular theme.

As I said, work, family, relationships, whatever it may be. Pay attention as best you can to the arising of thoughts of past, thoughts of future, and seeing if you can remember in the moment as you recognize that, maybe a little tagline to reinforce it. Just the thought. Just the thought.

Things get a lot lighter when you see thoughts for what they are. And in the service of that understanding, one of my favorite exercises with regard to thinking and thoughts, especially when there are a lot of them, which is fairly frequent, as the thoughts are running through the mind, to ask the question, what is a thought? So on this level, it's not about what the thought is saying. It's about looking at the very nature of thought itself.

And so when thoughts are going through the mind, we can remember that question, but what is this phenomenon? What actually is a thought? And that question helps direct our mindfulness to look directly, again, not at the content, but just at the nature of this phenomenon. What is a thought?

And my experience in doing that and looking at them is to see that thoughts, in essence, are little more than nothing. When I look at a thought, it's like a little blip in the mind. I call it an energy blip, taking the form of a thought. But when we look, there's nothing much there.

And yet, when we're not mindful of thought, we are creating a whole world, a whole reality, based on the content of what the thought happens to be. So it's quite remarkable that when we're unaware of thoughts, unmindful, they have so much power in our lives. They're really directing our lives. And yet, when we are mindful of them, as I said, little more than nothing.

So to me, this is a really fascinating way of applying mindfulness and investigation to a phenomenon that is just so impactful on our lives. Underlying all of these different suggestions is something that I've been emphasizing, we all have a lot, is that one of the great powering forces in our practice is really interest. If you become interested in this, then mindfulness is easy because of the interest. And so if we're sitting and we're kind of reminding ourselves to take interest in the nature of thought, in what the thought is saying, when we pick it up, that interest is going to define the quality of your attention, of mindfulness.

So, have fun with all your thoughts. When we take our comfortable meditation posture, again, simply settling into the body, awareness of the body, there is a body, there is a body, there is a body, there is a body, there is a body, there is a body, there is a body, there is a body here. And if you're sitting and feeling the whole body, you may become aware of the sensations of the body breathing. And be receptive, nothing to look for.

No need to alter the breath in any way whatsoever. Just staying mindful of the body and aware of how the body is breathing. Really simple. If other bodily sensations become predominant in calling your attention, those sensations become the main focus of your attention.

Types of pressure, heaviness, vibration, whatever it may be. We're just open to those sensations. See how they're always becoming otherwise. And then they're no longer predominant.

Settling back into the awareness of the whole body, of the body breathing. If any strong mind state or emotion becomes predominant, maybe the hindrances, it may be more positive, wholesome states of mind. Become aware. Perhaps even use some mental noting to acknowledge and become mindful of those mind states, those emotions.

Simply something else to become aware of. How they're manifesting in the body and the mind. And then include awareness, mindfulness, thoughts in all the ways that I just mentioned. If at any time it just feels like it's getting too confusing, too many things you're not quite sure what to be aware of, simply come back to the awareness of the whole body sitting.

Do you have any questions about the instructions in your practice? I feel like when I'm noting, I'm also thinking, and then I get to think about how to deal with the noting. Yes. So the question was, in noting, realizing that noting is also just a thought, and how to deal with that with respect to being mindful of thinking.

It is just a thought. You do not have to note thinking after making the note. But I think. that you probably notice there is a difference in the kind of thought it is.

Because most of the thoughts that I was talking about in the beginning are the ones that are uninvited. You know, we're just sitting and the thoughts are coming. The noting is an intentional thought. And so embedded in that already is a kind of mindfulness.

And so I wouldn't, so I'd keep it very simple. I'd kind of use the noting. But also remember that the noting should be very soft, like a whisper in the mind. It shouldn't interfere with the direct experience, but it connects us to the experience.

In the back. Some of my thoughts are actually really good. Does good mean enjoyable? Enjoyable and actually useful.

Yeah. So the question is about noticing that some thoughts are useful or good or pleasurable and others are not. And seeing that the assessment of them as being helpful or not, good or not, is itself another layer of what's happening in mind how to deal with that. I think it's really different functions going on.

So the assessment of whether a thought is useful or not, there's an aspect of wisdom in that. You know, and so there is another mental process going on, but it's actually an aspect of mindfulness. It's, you know, because you're mindful not only of the fact that you're thinking, but you're mindful of the content, right? And I think someone mentioned how one of the meanings of the Pali word for mindfulness, which is sati, means discerning what is wholesome and unwholesome.

So all of that is embedded in mindfulness. I think what you might want to watch out for is how you're relating to the assessment. You know, oh, there's a wholesome thought, there's an unwholesome thought. That in itself is fine, but then, oh, there I go again, another unwholesome thought.

So then you're building a whole reactivity to the assessment. That's not helpful, and so you would want to note that. I have two related questions. One at a time.

You're going down that path of this is an interesting thought. I find myself somewhat paralyzed with do I just let myself keep going? No. Who knows what to come out of it?

And then I'm like, well, Joseph would suggest not doing that. So what is the on-ramp back to either not experiencing that thought or is it back to the body and having the body? Okay, so the question was about what to do basically with thoughts that are interesting or useful. Yeah, fertile ground.

So a couple of things. One, simply to be aware that there is a meditative phenomenon called Vipassana brilliance. We're sitting and we have all these brilliant ideas about this or that. And some of them maybe, but some may not be.

But this is not the time. This is not the time to necessarily explore that. What I would suggest is that if we have some thoughts that do seem very fertile, you know, and maybe worthy of exploring, when those thoughts come in the context of a sitting, really note, kind of highlight that thought so that it's in your memory as something, okay, this would be worth exploring. And maybe after the sitting, not to do the exploration, but just to jot it down so you remember.

If you do that in the midst of a sitting, acknowledging that, I think you will remember until the end of the sitting. Because otherwise, you'll just be spending your time lost in thought, even if they are productive or useful, but it's not the purpose of the practice. So it is coming back to the body, to the breath, and not dragging yourself back, but it's just all gentle. You know, just acknowledge, oh, interesting thought.

What is it? And then back. You know, so it's very relaxed and open, but attentive. And remember what the point of the practice is, which is basically to notice what's arising, whatever it may be, thoughts or images, not meant to include, everything I said about thoughts could be applied to images in the mind.

To recognize what's happening, to see its impermanent nature, that's really the essence. But you can accommodate, you know, those interesting thoughts in a way I mentioned.

Frequently asked questions

How long is this episode of Insight Hour with Joseph Goldstein?

This episode is 26 minutes long.

When was this Insight Hour with Joseph Goldstein episode published?

This episode was published on August 2, 2023.

Is there a transcript available for this episode?

Yes, a full transcript is available for this episode. You can read the complete transcript on the episode page.

Can I download this Insight Hour with Joseph Goldstein episode?

Yes. Use the download control on the episode player to save the publisher-provided media file.