Skip to content
Ep 187 - Aspect: Advanced Session (ft dragonfli.ph) episode artwork

Dec 20, 2019 1 hr 41 min

Ep 187 - Aspect: Advanced Session (ft dragonfli.ph)

from Focused Fire Chat, a Destiny Lore Podcast Hosted by Focused Fire Chat Team

This week, we sit down with special guest dragonfli.ph (aka, Paige) to discuss the lore booklet, Aspect. This episode serves as the second half (i.e., the "Advanced Session"). As always, show notes (with detailed time stamps) will be posted over at www.TheLoreNetwork.com.

Episode details come from the podcast's RSS feed.

Embed this episode

Ready to play

Ep 187 - Aspect: Advanced Session (ft dragonfli.ph)

0:00 1:41:51
of matches

Transcript Auto-generated, may contain errors

Today's chat is brought to you by the support of all our Twitch subscribers. Through the Patreon that you provide the Focusfire chat team through the Twitch platform, we are able to provide you with the weekly podcast as well as the website and other aspects of Focusfire chat. If you have any interest in becoming a subscriber of the FFC and gaining access to some exclusive features over in the Discord server, please be sure to visit our Twitch account and click on the subscribe button. If you're an Amazon Prime member, remember that you do have a free subscription to Twitch every month that can be used for this.

And for those of you who are already subscribers, thank you again for your generosity. Welcome to Focusfire Chat, Explore Together. Welcome to Focusfire Chat, recorded live on December 13th, 2019 over on Twitch.tv slash Focusfire Chat as we continue our discussion over the lore book aspect. This particular episode will serve as what we have come to call the advanced session of the week's exploration, congratulations to those who signed up for a deeper dive.

Before we go any further, however, let's run through a quick introduction of who all we have with us on the show. As always, this is your host Blue Crew 86. And this is the crocheting fiend, Green Eyed Music Leather. Acceptable.

And last but not least in the hot scene as Gizco. We'll have our good friend Paige. Paige, how are you guys? I'm good, great.

I guess you every time with my different names. Yeah, every time I listen to Focusfire, you come up with something just totally out of left field. Great. I try.

It's like for a while there. I was attempting to, yeah, I know I was attempting to write it down because, you know, you had the voice of a flower adjusted and then he would have his weird names. And she's like, you know, I'm just going to do descriptors because those are way easier than actual names. Oh, yeah.

But yeah. But Blue, we are in the advanced episode. Yep, so let's just jump right into it. So we're, if you want to just start at the beginning, you think that's the easiest way to go into this?

I mean, I'd say it's chronological. It's not chronological. It gets wibbly wobbly really fast. It gets really wibbly wobbly.

I think it's interesting how it starts and ends very similarly. Right. I think, I mean, the other thing that I just like, you know, on that note, the names of the entries themselves is, and I know this is obviously probably done purposely. Oh, for sure.

Like, well, as you get deeper into like the actual definitions of the names, it's like, I was like, oh, that probably has something to do. It has everything to do with it. I am so glad you put that in the show notes because that was the first thing I wrote down on my notes. And I'm like, okay, someone caught on to this.

Oh, my gosh. Like the thing is that it started clicking throughout it. The bookings entries are the ones that killed me, though. The Realists and Ear Realists, like that was, that was the thing that I was like, I'm like, okay.

So, so for example, Realists is the first entry. And Realists is a, what's called a grammatical mood, which is used to principally indicate that something is a statement of fact. So basically it's expressing what the speaker considers to be a known state of affair. The example would be something like, he works.

This is a direct dissertation about reality in regards to the present indicative of the word work. So if I say that he works, that means that I am, he is working. Like right now, currently he is doing something. It is real right now.

And then to jump a little bit ahead, Ear Realists is the exact opposite. And that's where, and those are, that's the first and the last entry. So it's like, it's a very interesting dynamic going on. And like the evolution of the definitions as you go through corresponds with the content of those entries very closely.

And so, you know, again, we'll definitely probably touch on them each, each one as we go. But that was one that stood out, like stood out huge, that one. And then I think it's Atelic was the other one. And we talked about that a little bit.

Atelic has very interesting connotations within regards to not just the context of its card, but actually the whole book. Because Atelic is discussing the concept of a terminology or the use of language to indicate a goal or an endpoint. So Atelic is actually something that doesn't have an endpoint. Whereas Atelic is something that does.

And so having an entry that's called Atelic is an interesting component. And then also the entry in itself is talking about the Vex and the garden, and it's an explanation of time from the Vex perspective. Or from a perspective of someone who is pretty familiar with Vex. And that's the one that's Tevis.

And so, and that's where we were kind of talking in the introductory session about the analogy of time as a river. It was really, it's just, again, it's like those three were just the ones that immediately stood out to me. Oh, gosh, yeah. I actually, so I read them all the first couple times and then I went back and I'm like something like I'm missing something here.

So I went back and looked up the definitions after I read the book. And it was so uncanny how directly it, not necessarily affected, but like summarized the entry. Right. Yes.

Yes. Yeah. Because you can look at each entry's name and be like, oh, so basically that's what happens in the story of that entry. Do we want to get into the actual thing that happened in Rialis?

Sure. Sure. So in Rialis, the undying mind lies in the garden, a ruin of metal given over to greenery, a borrow rising out of black soil and rich with nitrogen and thought. Everything in the garden becomes of the garden eventually, shed leaves decompose and fertilize the soil.

So do the bones and unspoken ideas of everyone who couldn't find the end of the maze. So do the wordless songs of the Vex gardeners. They walk between the leaves, encouraging growth, laying down their bronze pathways, the only straight lines in all the garden's tangles. The Vex weave themselves into the garden, and the garden returns the favor.

Harpy's patrol in the air is goblins do on the ground. Their veins wafting in still air on their endless untiring rounds. The pathways lie dull against granite, no powers run through them, not since the hearts stop beating, but the Vex of the soul divisive have programmed themselves to worship the darkness. It has given them power before, and the Vex understand time.

What has happened before is somewhere, still always happening. What will happen is happening now. Soil that lies follow for a season will recover and will recover and produce again, power that wanes will wax again, if the ground is ready for it. The harpy stop where they are, a shutter running through each of them in order, from one end of the garden to the other, a flicker, a wash of power, coming from some more distance, a pulse.

The power it carries lights up the pathways, the mind's eye blinks for a bare moment, under its blanket of lichen. The power passes through the garden over runs the Vex machinery within it, floods the network beyond it, a moment held like the shore after the tide rushes out. There's a moment, modes of something that isn't dust, shake in the air. The bronze pathway's hum, a counterpoint in the goblin song, and the garden's door vibrates with them.

First question, which pulse? Do we know? I can't say conclusively. I don't think we have a conclusively answer to that.

I mean, we have mentions of pulses later on in the cards, which referring specifically to pulses that cradeth feels or senses. It's not necessarily the pulse that we all probably thought of initially, which is the pulse of the traveler going back out. Right, right. Though that does not necessarily suggest, but it does at least bring to light that imagery.

But the garden has laid dormant, mostly, since the death of the heart. But there's another card that talks about how the Vex are trying to regrow the heart or at least protect the heart. So this one doesn't necessarily mention that, but maybe it's an instance of the heart coming back. Yeah, I mean, pulse.

Hmm. Not sure. I mean, we kill the undying mind. That's something that has been said multiple times from a couple different characters of Cyrus and Ikora, which, by the way, still bugged by the fact that the teleported...

They just transmitted it. I know, but it still bugs me. Actually, my personal opinion is they just pushed it off the edge and put it in the volcano. Let it shatter.

And some ungodly, just some citizens who gestured up to the last city. Oh, it's so beautiful. Crash. What was that?

The Guardian's got done with her experiment. Science fairs over. Science fairs over. Ikora won.

Everyone can go home now. But this one, it doesn't have so much... It's more of like a broad spectrum of what's going on. There's nothing like super huge.

That's true. Blue, did you have anything else that you wanted to discuss about this one? Not really on this one. No.

No. Okay. Mirative. Mirative.

Oh my gosh, this one sent me down a rabbit hole. I see that. I'm gonna let you just take after this one. Okay, so this gets into the idea of what is translation.

Like translation of things that don't translate into English and vice versa and all that. So, the base definition of Mirative is it's a grammatical mood that expresses unexpected revelations of new information. Or a surprise. This doesn't...

Mirative does not exist in English. It's not a concept that we have within our language. Because English is what's described as a morphosynthetic system. It's not something that does well with this type of grammatical mood.

And this was actually coined... This phrase was coined by an individual who goes by the name of Scott Delancy. And I believe it was earlier. But the main work that actually discusses this is the Mirative and Evidentiality article, which he wrote in 2001.

And he says, in the intro, he says, Evidentiality refers to the grammatical marking of the source of evidence for a proposition. Mirativity refers to the marking of a proposition as representing information which is new to the speaker. Mirativity has sometimes been thought of as part of the larger category of Evidentiality. Based on evidence from Tibetan, Hare and other languages, it is argued that Mirativity must be recognized as a distinct semantic and grammatical category.

And then he goes on to say that the term Mirativity refers to the linguistic marking of an utterance as conveying information which is new or unexpected to the speaker. And so his primary example is the Tibetan language and how there is a structural difference in their syntax based on if something was intentional or accidental. And it's really interesting, but it gets really far into the weeds as far as translating them. But he goes on to say, and then he also talks about a couple individuals who looked at Hare and then a few other languages that have similar things.

And he also then goes on to say that Mirativity is not directly expressed in the morphosyntatic system of English. Though, as pointed out by Akasuka, it exists as a covert semantic category. However, it can be marked intonationally. The Mirative Intonation Contour is an exaggerated version of the declarative intonation which the tonic rise is considered behind.

So what that means is a declarative sentence where I have this ball of yarn. There's a tonal, like pitches that your voice will automatically go. English has a lot based on tone. There's a lot of implied context with English.

That's why reading text in English is surprisingly difficult because you miss a lot. English is notorious for this. There's no infliction. Because I think we've seen this in Destiny with Purple with our argument about the Warmind entry from way back in D1.

She's like, she put a different infliction on the letter A. Completely changed the card. Completely changed the meaning of the card. And it's interesting to see how that.

But yeah, sorry, go for it. No, I was just going to say the easiest example is asking a question because oftentimes when people ask questions, how are you doing? Where does this place go? You have that where the end of the phrase turns up.

But yeah, tonal explanations. It's interesting when you do a voice study because I was looking at trying to imitate Morla. She actually breaks so many rules. What?

Morla? Morla? Oh, my God. It drives me crazy because I cannot figure out how she's doing it because she reads it in such a way that doesn't follow the normal English speaking patterns.

Her interpretation is different than what ones should be. Yeah, so even just like imitating what she says, if I were to imitate what she says, I can mimic. But if I were to read Arish lines from the lore, it's incredibly difficult to do it in the same way that she would because I can't figure out exactly what rules she's breaking where. Well, it's even like reading or like misunderstanding a text message.

Like, we need to talk. Are you like, oh, we need to talk and like catch up? Or do we need to talk and like have a serious conversation? I'm in trouble.

That's when I send back a gift. I'm in danger. I'm in danger. A little boy sitting on the bus.

But okay, so when Meredith, we were talking about at the very beginning how a lot of the titles are really good at explaining somewhat what's going on in the card. So in this card, Pradeith is connecting with Ishtar Academy group. Like he is connecting to them for the first time. And well, not necessarily for the first time.

No, it is the first time. Well, yeah. It's not. It's not.

It's not. It's not. It's not the word. Yeah.

Yeah. I love that introduction. He's like, what? Yeah, you already said that.

What? So coinciding with like the mere to explaining the card. I think it also explained how we took the card. Because we're all very, I mean, at least I was when I first read the word Pradeith.

I was like, what? Wait, hold on a second. Something's fishy here. And then I read it as if I was going back to no time to explain and listening to Pradeith.

Tell us about what happened and listening to his ghost kind of thing. So I think it also explained our interpretation of the card itself. I mean, Pradeith now is cut off from everything. He doesn't have his ghost or anything like that.

Is it Pradeith trying to, he's getting a little lost in translation? Or is it just the fact that he's unsure of what's changed and why he's able to talk to them? I'm still trying to figure out how it has a direct tie to the narrative concept. So I think like looking back at it, he was very like confident when we heard him back during the no time to explain quest, whereas now he's very like skeptical.

Like, is this really happening? Like, take what they're saying to truth or just kind of his interpretation of what's going on, where he's at now. Makes sense. I think it's funny how he calls out.

Guru is calling it out in chat. He doesn't have a fondness for Ashramir either. I love that. It's not good.

Pradeith's radio is talking to him, which at least it doesn't. He says it doesn't. It's not a familiar voice. He says, because he wishes it at least use a familiar voice upon him or take it or even a mirror at this point.

Right. But later. Like, okay. His voice case, it hurts to talk.

Say again, the hallucination has a new voice. This time sharper. Male. Yeah.

The band number. Do you think that's Shin? Dr. Shin?

Yeah. I think so. But I just love his reaction. He's like, oh, my God.

Uh-huh. He sighs, catalogs, more constellations and is, oh, my gosh, the fact that he's trapped in the cell, which brings up the question, is he just, is it a cognitive trap? Is it a physical trap? Is it yes?

To both? I think it is yes to both because, you know, he's, he's in the vault. Right. Like, so he is, he is physically there, but he's also chatting.

You're relevant. It's just not a metaphor. Um, he's also, he's also trapped outside of time as well because that was the whole thing. Right.

Yeah. He's, he's literally inside the Vex network because that was the whole thing at the end is what they're trying to, that's one of the things that they're trying to get back. So if we move on to the next card, we get our first, I'm going to call it an interlude because it's completely not predus. Does it, has anybody figured out, I've seen theories on it, but I haven't like fully bought into all of them with the Ks and Vs and the, um, carrots, this is like, yeah, for the longest time.

I swear, I was like, I was, I was almost like, God, Seth, you know what my, my brain went with it with the Ks were not in there. I could totally follow this because carrots and Vs are used to notate, um, downbows and up bows and music for young children. Okay. That was like the first thing my brain went to is the, and it talks about silent singing, whether or not this is like a notation of what he's singing.

Oh, you know what, if this, yeah, that's true, but I haven't seen anything as far as like, exactly what this is yet. I haven't seen any like hidden code in here, because believe me, I spent about 45 minutes trying to find something, but it's, you get other speakers. Well, see, that's the thing is, it's the Chari connection there too is, is, uh, gosh, hang on, I'm going to look something up. Continue.

I'll be right back. Okay. As best I can. And because it's a visual thing with the carrots and everything, it's going to be a little difficult to read that, but I'll do it.

Yeah. So no, Mick goes, he is, he is not, he is walking in the garden. He is talking silent singing. And then there's like the little up carrot K, up carrot K, V, up carrot, V, up carrot, V, up carrot, V, up carrot, V, up carrot, V parentheses.

Watch your six. Don't worry about me. Grow, grow, grow in parentheses. He holsters his gun to gesture.

He holsters his gun to drink. His gun is rusted into its holster and he will never pull it out again, parentheses. How bad can it be? How bad can it be?

How can we grow, grow, grow in parentheses? A Titan is a wall, a shield, a cup filling itself to overflowing. The container changes the shape of its contents, but the contents change the nature of the container and the nature is eternity, parentheses. Who knows what's listening?

It's listening. It's saying grow, grow, grow in parentheses. There is a shape that is his mind and the shape is, is protect the shape, is sacrifice the shape is parentheses, grow in parentheses. And then more of like the little carrots and V's in a, looks like five times.

He was named too well. He is his own grave and the cut on his left hand will never heal. So fun, fun call back to, to a pejari in the cut in the hallucination back in D one, I guess hallucination slash not hallucination. Yeah, vision.

Mm hmm. But there's multiple voices quote unquote being viewed here because you have the watch your six. Don't worry about me. And there's multiple, it's almost as if there's multiple instances all being threatened.

They're owned into the same card. Right. It felt very, like when I read it, it felt very stagnant. Like you're stuck at a point, but watching everything go on around you kind of thing.

Mm hmm. He is, he is not, he is walking in the garden. He is talking, silent singing. I mean, it's like stuttering almost.

Right. So the definition of nomic while blue is still continuing and everything is the expressed in or of the nature of short pithy maxims or aphorisms, ignomatic or ambiguous, aka this is going to be very ambiguous. In fact, on this term, we began to use nomic, which is the adjective form of gnome in the early 19th century around 1784 to be exact. I like how you put around 1784.

I wrote that like is a train of conscious thought. So I was reading it and I was like, oh, they actually gave me the full date. Okay. I'm going to go back and edit that real quick.

Blue, blue, blue wrote this in a very gnomic fashion. This was used originally to describe a style of writing slash speech characterized by pithy phrases, which are often terched to the point of mysteriousness. This stemmed form the use of the term gnome taken from Greek word that translates to no in the tales. These creatures were crouched in metaphorical or figurative language, couched.

That makes way more sense. I was like, I went, I looked back after reading and I was like, that doesn't make sense. Couched. Sorry.

They're on couch. They're crouching by couches. They're drinking their brandies and being all mysterious, smoke is billowing in blue from a curtain area. Uh huh.

Okay. See our couch in metaphorical or figurative language often portrayed as being quite clever and always concise in their manner. Because of some gnomic poetry are no thyself. Too many cooks spoiled the broth.

Where did that one come from? I've never heard that one. It's an old English one. It's also too many, uh, too many chefs in the kitchen, you know, too many, too many, uh, I just blanked on the other one.

But yeah, I mean, it's, it's basically if there's too many leaders, there's that everyone's too busy leading and not doing anything. It's a metaphorical con, like short, metaphorical statement. These aphorisms were collected into works referred to as nomologia, nomologia, I don't know, which were anthologies used to instruct younger members of Greek society. One of the more well known of these collections was compiled by Stobaeus in the fifth century AD and remained popular into well, well into the Middle Ages.

So I'm so annoyed that I can't find this. But anyways, what are you looking for? So there's a thing. So like the connection that I made, it was like way back when we first started.

I thought it was the warlock episode and it probably was and I just forgot to write it down. But, um, Pajari is actually a Hindu priest as the term is also there and they are responsible for performing rituals, including Pooja, which is a, like a very specific, a very lengthy ritual, I believe, I'm going off memory here, so I apologize if I misquote, or if I mistake that. But the Pajari is the one who performs the Pooja and, um, and that entails setting things on fire, entails the, you know, the appropriate singing and all that. And that was where when we were talking about Pajari way back in D one, I kind of read up on that and I was like, that's really interesting because we knew at the time we had the warlock class, the sunsinger, which is the emulation and the self-immolation and then resurrection and that tied into and I so annoyed myself because I can't find my notes, but there was a tie-in to an actual Pajari with the figure of Pajari and it was a really interesting, really interesting concept that was, it was around the, the igniting of a, um, uh, it was a, it was a, it was something and I'm so, I'm so aggravated that I don't have my notes in front of me.

But anyways, uh, when you started talking about the singing, that's where I was like, you know what? That actually makes more sense because I'm still reading this as this is Pajari talking. And I know a lot of people say are attributing this to Kabir or Cabir or whatever, however you want to say it in case or whatever, uh, the, the milk stout drinker, um, but the thing is is like when I read it, it's, when I see the part that a lot of people are attributing to the reason that they say that it's Cabir that's writing this, it seems to me actually that's an outsider looking in because he says A-Titan is a wall, a shield, a cup filling itself to overflowing. It's not saying I am a Titan that is a wall, it's, it's, it seems to me that it's someone watching that event and is seeing that transpire from an outside perspective because then you go.

I think that, yeah, I think the cut on the hand is the one I, I, that's my ending argument to his life. Yeah, but then also when you say there is a shape that is his mind and the shape is protect, the shape is sacrificed, the shape is grow. Like it's when it, when it comes to the parts that is about Cabir, there's always a third person, uh, syntax, like he holsters his gun to gesture, he holsters his gun to drink. It's not I holster, my gun, you know, though the, I mean, it could be, it could be put theoretically.

Right. And that's where I was going to say the parts in the parentheses, however, make me wonder. And this is where I can almost see this almost being a case where Pejari might have been in the vault with them. Because again, that's where, again, the only reason I say that is because again, we know that there was a fire team that went into the vault, but we only have three names.

We don't know if it was a traditional 16 grade group. Right. The other thing I would argue is that Pejari, this doesn't necessarily mean in the vault, it's in the next network. Pejari has been known to be hallucinating because he's getting it too involved with the Vex milk and everything like that.

And he's been in the black garden. He's been in the Vex network. Yeah. And well, that's why with the original source of time, it was Vex milk underneath, because I think we had that conversation here, because I think in the new one, it's walking, right?

It's not it. Yeah, because it's on NASA. It's not in the, it's not in the. I think I remember us having this kind of because, because right, because I was the other thing is he, when we see Pejari for the first time, it's, he's thrown himself off of the shores of time, which was a map in T one on off a point B off point B.

Same as the one that's in current iteration. Top point B was the biggest suicide leap, but like that was kind of the inside joke, but he was also a fan. So he was, he was doing it on purpose to get these visions to record them. And that was where he had the vision of the garden.

But the thing is, is with the shores of time, when you throw yourself off, you fall in Vex milk. So he's, he's committing his own suicide, but then he's ending up in Vex. So it's, it's, and then the whole connection there was with the vault of glass armor. We knew at that time that Vex milk was a very powerful hallucinogen.

So there was this, there was this huge connection going on there as well. Yep. You want to move on to the next one? Epistemic.

Yeah. Sorry. I think it's Mr. Mikey says that he was saying that it pretty sure it stayed somewhere in D one, that it was just a three of them going in.

And I, and I understand that because also even in here, we see Pradith mentioned that there was only three of them, my, my one counterpoint, and I, I'm not going to go on die on this hill. So I'll just throw it out there. And then I'm going to leave it. But my one counterpoint is, is that in the same way that Pradith has been forgotten because of the way that he was erased, you could technically argue that there could have been others that were erased in the same manner.

That Pradith would have forgotten the rest of his fires. Well, that the three of them could have been consumed by, what was it the, the, it's not the oracles. It's the, uh, Gordon. Oh, that got lost organs.

Yeah. I mean, it's just, it's just one of those things where it's like, they tried to three and five. There's too many wives. Yeah.

There's too many questions. This is, this is why Paige loves the century is that it answers so much. Yup. Totally.

I actually love this entry because it doesn't answer anything. It doesn't try to answer anything. No. It's just a fun.

And it is. And it, when you say it reads kind of like music, it's almost as if you have, um, that like melody line and then you have your harmony line, it's like two different perspectives of the same thing happening. Yeah. A bit.

It's just really hard to, I don't know, it's just, there's one that's, one that's, there's one that is a constant worry, like a guy answering concerns, watch or six, how bad can it be? How bad can it be? Who knows what's listening? It's like the inner dialogue.

And then you have the, the, not necessarily the thoughts, but the actions that are happening as well as the thoughts. I don't know. It's interesting. Blue, do you want to take on the next one?

Yes. Epistemic. Um, so Epistemic is a term that actually requires a bit of clarification. Um, Epistemic is in itself relating to knowledge and or the degree of its validation.

Uh, so to be clear, it's an adjective which talks about the act of acquiring knowledge itself. It is often, uh, very often confused to be the same as epistemology or epistemological. Uh, epistemology is the study of a lot of study or philosophy of the acquisition of proper knowledge and epistemological is the adjective that refers to epistemology. Um, so the difference is, uh, Epistemic is actually the acquiring of the knowledge, the knowledge itself where epistemology is the study of the acquisition of proper knowledge.

So it's very, very, very slight one. Um, but yeah, chat, chat, chat, like I love English, uh, this, uh, this actually leads to the concept of the epistemic state, uh, which is the, as the topic that discusses the guiding of decisions and what to believe in particular situations. Uh, so this is actually not stating anything about the actual truth of a situation, but rather what is believed or assumed within that situation. Uh, so this is talking about the experience of the individual who is having the experience, not the actual experience, um, which to me makes a ton of sense, but I also have a lot of history with phenomenology.

It's the, it's the perspective of what's going on necessarily what's going on. It's not, it's the understanding of the bias of the individual and how they are perceiving a situation, not the de facto true air, quote, your true situation. Um, and the, the summary of this car really, it kind of talks about that because this is pray to discussing his various visions within the vault. Um, and so he starts off actually and he starts talking about he has, he has watched from a cell for longer than he knows how to quantify sitting inside, looking out.

He's seen so many different timelines. There is no way to tell which are real from a certain point of view. They might all be. Um, and he goes on and he kind of talks about the different iterations of the different timelines.

Just as some things he recognizes, he sees the traveler often, though he can't feel its light through the bars of his cage. Sometimes it hangs over a city so familiar it makes his heart ache. Sometimes it hangs in an alien sky and foreign shapes make airy loops around it, ghost of unrecognizable make. Some visions he gets once, while some come back over and over again.

One recurring image, a piece of the traveler cracked off from its body lying belly up in a forest with a small figure standing in front of it. The figure changes every time, but the sickly glow of the traveler doesn't. Once, he sees a vision of himself, straight-shouldered, warm in the Martian sun, standing between Kabir and Pahannin. Kabir's helmet is familiar.

It's one pray to help make. He was a defter hand with spin-foil lamination than Kabir was out ever was. Kabir has worn that barely five years into their life as a fireteam, worn it for six straight months till he cracked it in half in the crucible. That vision makes Pray to the weep, desiccated as he is, he didn't think he had it in him.

The vault shows him mercury again and again recognizable only thanks to the scale of the sun in the sky. Sometimes there's rubble hanging in space, a planetary ring still forming. Sometimes there's nothing but rubble, and when he turns he doesn't see any of the other planets in the system. Gone, somehow eaten, down to the crumbs.

Pray to wouldn't mind these visions so much if he could only feel the warmth of that colossal sun. Bands are always cold here in the vault. He seaves waves of aliens across the solar system's threshold, emerging into the light from outside the heliopause. Some of them travel with the air of eager, conquering armies, paint fresh and banner snapping.

Some of them move as if they're on the run from something behind them out in the galactic dark. He watches the movements of the Vex. He learns to tell them apart. The shiny silver ones, the brass ones with backs with horns, the ones with eyes glowing white.

Occasionally scattered among them are pockets of Vex stain with vertigress. Their arms trailing shawls of moss. All the other Vex keep away from those ones. Twice he's seen other Vex fight the mossy ones.

It looks like the other Vex are frightened of them as much as Vex can be. The timelines have veils drawn over them, a darkness too thick to see through. They push back through against prey to the sights, resisting. All the timelines he sees could be true for some living being.

He doesn't know which are true for him. He doesn't know if that's a meaningful question to ask. He asks it anyway and he keeps looking. There's no reason not to.

He's got all the time in the world. Do you have an interpretation on this one, Paige? So, hold on, because there's a lot of information being thrown at us, so I kind of had to pick it apart. But I mean, the biggest thing he points out is all those timelines could be true for someone.

But I think the one that stuck out to me is when he's talking about the traveler and it being cracked and there's a small figure standing in front of it. Like, is that us when we get our light back? And did he see that as it was happening or did he see it before it was happening kind of thing? Did he see it as all the guardians who are experiencing Destiny 2 as different realities?

Right. So, I have a weird analogy for how I understand the Vex being able to see into the different times like this. The song, it's 5 o'clock somewhere. That's what's going on.

There's always going to be somebody somewhere doing that. It's always going to be a really dumb way to capture that works. But the other thing that this one really, I mean, it kind of bothers me because you do get the aspect that it's a physical location that he's at. And he's seeing all these different things over and over and over and the question I have is how is he seeing these different things?

Every time that we have gone into the Vex network or into Mercury or anything like that, we've been essentially re-enacting moments in interacting with him there. Is he in a simulation of it? Is he walking through these different aspects? I mean, he doesn't know what is true at this point necessarily, right?

And it's hard to say what is true in general just because Vex is not, they just don't make it easy on you. No, Vex never does. It's like, is the same 14 that we fought alongside in the mission a true same 14? I mean, there's just lots of questions to go into it.

It just makes you want to dig, makes you want to dig, but there's nothing to dig. I mean, there's pieces you can kind of toy with for sure. I think the other interesting aspect of this is he kind of sees how like the Vex covered in the moss, he kind of sees how they interact with other Vex. And I mean, we haven't quite seen that in game necessarily.

We've read about it in lore a few different times. Yeah, so we have done that. But we haven't like, when we go into the black garden, we just see the soul devices. We don't really see them interacting with other Vex.

That's true. My question is, is the reason why the other Vex so not kosher with the soul divisive, the fact that the soul divisive is the grouping that reprogrammed itself to worship. So in other words, it's other compared to the other Vex, it doesn't, the other Vex does not necessarily do that. Does it see it as like a, like a festering wound to the Vex almost, is it trying to get rid of it?

I don't know. Blue, do you have any thoughts? No, I mean, no, not with this one. I mean, again, I think that like we had been kind of saying for, for the rest of the other ones, the name of the entry really does a good job in summarizing it.

He starts, he starts off in a very epistemic, like he's just like, he's just experiencing that he's just acquiring this knowledge. And then at the very end, you kind of start getting into the more epistemological kind of approach, because he's like, okay, but why, like, what does, are any of these actually true? Like, are the, any of these actually matter? And that's where he starts kind of transcending from, you know, the epistemic, okay, this is the information, but why am I getting it?

Why am I, how am I getting it? You know, what's the point of this information? How, what's the meaning of that? Um, do you think, do you think he realizes how he's getting it?

Or do you think it just happens? I don't think so. I think it's just happening. Like, I think that's part of the problem with him, with his experience of this is he's, he's a prisoner of the Vex, and in the prisoner, in being a prisoner of the Vex, he's, he's stuck with them.

And they see time so differently, you know, we'll, we'll talk about that here in a second, but like they, they exist in a whole different level of, of existence. They perceive things. Their, their epistemic reality is so much different than ours, because as a, uh, as a intellectually as a mortal symbiote or a mortal, um, entity, we, we experience time in a very set fashion. We experience the transfer or the, uh, the progression of time very, very linearly.

Whereas a Vex is arguably not that same basic and, or base. And so with their experience, their epistemic of experience is that it doesn't exist that same way. So for them, this all makes sense. Like they're, they're perceiving this.

And you know, maybe he's just piggybacking on what they're seeing because he's in a prison cell and they, you know, he's, they just don't care that he's seen this. Or you know, maybe he accidentally broke into something. The thing is like, because the vault is designed for Vex, it's like you're, it's like he's stuck in an alien spaceship and the aliens don't speak English. I know chat was talking about a rival just a few minutes ago.

Um, and like that's a really good example here because, you know, the, the whole concept of arrival is that in understanding the language, you kind of understand, you know, the, the, the species. Um, and that's not anything new. That's actually throughout a lot of sci-fi literature, you see that. But right.

Point of order real quick. Um, the, I think it's saying that the Vex experience time differently is it's, it needs to be flush out a little bit more and so much that they don't experience time backwards or anything like that, but they, they're able to interact with time in a different way than we do. Yeah. And that still flows in, as far as we can tell in one direction for them, like it's still moving forward, but they can step in and out of it.

Yeah, they're not, they're not anchored in the flow like we are. Correct. Um, and it's, it's hard because there's like time itself is such, it's such an artificial construct, but it's also one of those artificial constructs that has been ingrained in humanity for so long that, you know, the, the idea of, um, the idea of the time is just the idea of actions passing, but, and being able to mark those upon us on a, on a scale of some sort, right? Yes and no, like there is a, like, and this is where it gets kind of dicey because there is varying philosophies of how to tell temporal, like temporal fluidity, like there is, there's issues, there's issues with that because time is, a lot of people would argue that time is outside of things.

Like time is just the way time is, but that's not actually true. Time is something that it's very, it's a very shredding or like experience. Like if you don't pay attention to a clock, you don't know what time it is. Like you might know that it is a certain point in the existence of something.

But your experience of time will, will be fluid if you're, and this is often the case when you're enjoying yourself time, time goes by faster. Yeah. But that's what I'm meaning is that you, when you're observing it and you're marking it, you are setting it onto a scale in, in some ways, elongating it rather than, um, when you're not observant of it and you're just having a good time and enjoying it, it is all the different actions are happening, but you're not making note of minute details within the actions necessarily and creating that elongation upon the scale. And it's just passing very fluidly rather than, I guess, I don't even know a good word.

No, I mean, and that's, and this thing is like, that, and then, you know, from a philosophical standpoint, you can also ask from certain time point, for certain points of view, time passes differently because for you, five minutes might be, but for me, five minutes might seem like an hour, but, but it's based on your experience. Right. And then, but then if you have, if you look at a clock, technically, and this is where this is the part that gets really difficult to like, to see conceive of because we're so used to having a clock that's telling us that tick, tick, tick, tick, tick, no matter what you're doing, it's that tick, tick, tick, tick, you know, and the idea that that doesn't mean anything for a lot of people, for a lot of people, it's very uncomfortable because it's like, wait, what? Like, that is just an artificial construct that we've put into reality that says, we're going to agree that this is, this is air quote time.

But at the end of the day, that's, that's not time, like that's, that's a artificial construct to measure the distance that something has gone, but time itself is something that's arguably more fluid. It's, it's one of those things where it's like, it gets really abstract really quickly because you're talking about very, the variety of experiences of a situation. And then you have to agree if there's a real, if there is a real truth or if there's a set of truth and relativism gets in and messes everything up. And yeah.

And then, and then talk about the relativity to gravity, you know, like you have that whole that issue. Black holes and stuff like that. The thing that gets me as far as easiest way to describe it, it's like looking at music, the difference between like a quarter note and 16 notes. When you're observing it, it looks like it's taking up so much more space on the page, which it does, but it's actually this, like, you could have the same amount of time passed between the two of them.

Just once broken up into sixteenths and the other one's broken up into just a quarter of it, a beat versus four within the beat. Anyway. Moving on, perhaps? Yes.

Please. Before we get down, never end loop of time. I love talking about this stuff because it ties into phenomenology and that ties into like an individual's experience of something, but you have to, like, before you can start really seriously talking about that construct, you have to also like come to an agreement with everyone that's in the conversation that everyone's experience is equally valid with the understanding that everyone's experience is unique and alien to the other. Also equally invalid in respect to that.

That's something that with, like, we always took it in regards to psychology and so phenomenology from a psychological standpoint is really helpful. Phenomenology from a philosophical standpoint gets really hairy really fast because it starts, it can dovetail into very dangerous topics as far as especially with morality and stuff like that. The thing is, it's still an interesting thought experiment, but I would probably, I mean, we would be here all day because it's fascinating, but it takes so long to discuss because every point of view is something that is equally valid and equally worth exploration, even those that don't make sense or are uncomfortable. Actually, sometimes those are more important to explore, and that's where the epistemic and epistemology kind of, that's where the difference is, epistemic is like the actual acquiring of that, which is, again, kind of where we're kind of bringing back into this century.

He has prayed if he's acquiring this knowledge, and he gets into an epistemological standpoint at the end when he asks, what is the point of this? How am I getting this? What is valid here? That is an epistemological question about the epistemic image or the epistemic information that he has gotten.

If that makes sense. So Deontic. Yes, please. So back to philosophy.

Yeah. I was like, back to your favorite topic. Oh, my gosh. The Ansible is a thought experiment.

It was proved impossible. Oh, this one, this one actually from a philosophical standpoint. Really easy to explain. Deontology is a normative ethical theory that is posited within what's referred to as moral philosophy.

And it basically says that morality of an action should be based on whether or not that action itself is right or wrong under a series of rules. So it's set up based on the consequences of the action. So in kind of a short term, it says, ignoring the idea that the end should never be used to justify the means, because the means should justify the means. So, you know, it's like, you know, it's like, you know, it's like, you know, it's like, you know, the end should never be used to justify the means, because the means should justify the means.

If a mean, if the end justifies means that require a sacrifice of doing what is right to achieve that end, that end is in and of itself not ethically acceptable. Okay. And then link with it. It's the do good because you're doing good.

Correct. Because it's going to get you a cookie at the end of the day because you didn't make the teacher that the it's it's not allowing. There's a lot of like, there's a lot of historical examples of like, oh, the ends justify the means, you know, we'll do these atrocious crimes because in the end, we get, you know, fill in the blank of whatever BS reason you want. The argument of deontology is that that should never be acceptable.

It should be that you are doing the thing that is right, and that is just and is good because it is right, just and good. It's not because you don't get you don't get a pass on yes, I'm trying so hard not to say that green. You you are you don't get a pass for doing something stupid or evil because you argue that the end is good, like, it can't be good because in order to get to it, you have to do evil, right, does that and that and that and that's an argument that is very, very, very divisive on moral or moral philosophy because obviously the people who are calling the ends that justify the means don't like that being pointed out and so, yeah, makes things difficult. So in this car standpoint, real quick, sorry, sorry, for a linguistic standpoint, deontic is just simply expressing duty or obligation.

So it's it's again, it's not using ethical. It's just saying it's this is your duty or this is your obligation. I'm done. You're welcome, blue.

So this card's fun because we actually get conversations with some of the Istar team and you get a little bit more of the lovely Dwayne, lovely, lovely Dwayne, but Pradeth is working with them essentially in this one to they're kind of debating all the different aspects going on as well as can he create a radio to call out. Oh, yeah, that's right. He creates something with what he's got. So he's got a few different things, laser pointer, focusing crystal on the long rifle, which he still has his rifle, which is interesting.

I just love the fact that he acknowledges that doing the tide is his own worst enemy. I think it's the I think my favorite line it is in this one is do you remember the first thing we saw the Vex do go for my his throat? No, jump into that frame. Clear through the air.

It's just like, okay, guys. I just love how one of them is so cheerful. I just remember reading the Vex cards or the Vex grimoire cards and putting little voices to each of the Ishtar characters and their personalities are so distinct that even just reading a line without knowing who it was afterwards, you're like, oh, that's that person. And it was kind of nice to see that again in this entry.

It is interesting. And it's interesting to see what this group is doing because this is either 227.13 or 227.204. He's not sure which one, but they're all working together and we do get some clarification about their discharging themselves, not infinite mirror variations of them from different timelines, but simulations all split off from the same base. So he's figured out that they're not it's not like OSIRIS.

It's simulations split off from the original, although OSIRIS is yeah, except OSIRIS has a multiple man problem in love the presentation of that. Yep. But beyond that, there's not a whole lot in here that I would say is like super, super needing to be called out, except for the fact that they're trying to build this radio out and they're using he's MacGyvering it. God, I love it.

The best way to describe it. Yeah. Um, it does briefly talk about losing his ghost, which I kind of thought was a nice full circle after finding his ghost, but it wasn't like extremely significant to that was when we took back to Lakshmi, wasn't it? Yep.

The one that she was like, who is this? What is this? Why are my signatures on this? Yeah.

Why do I? She's just she's like the old lady. Why do I? Why is this familiar?

What is going on? Guys. All right. I think we should move right along then because I don't see too much going on in this one.

Oh, it's our favorite. Ah. Yeah. Time.

Oh, no. All right. So a telek is a quality of a verb that shows an action as being incomplete. So like I had mentioned, whereas telek verbs indicate or refer to events that have endpoints, a telek verbs refer to events or states that don't have endpoints.

Now, linguistic standpoint, this can launch into a critique that every state or event in the world begins and ends at some point with the exception of states that can be described along the lines of existence of the universe, which basically this critique ultimately results in serving as a reminder that linking linguistic semantics to the real world is a futile attempt without considering the intermediary agent of human cognition. AKA, it is like time itself. It's just don't accept it basically it's also argued that a telek verbs are those that do not involve any goal or end point into note actions that are realized as soon as they begin. So the example that a lot of times you'll see for the a telek is the quote as a sentence, she is walking down the street.

The action walking has yet not not yet been finished. So it is a action that is incomplete. She is she is eternal. The point from a linguistic continuing to do so from a linguistic standpoint is in that sentence that sentence as of itself as it stands, she will never finish walking down the street because you know, but then if you enter into it with that's where they refer to the intermediary agent of human cognition, because when we read that sentence, we understand, okay, she is walking down the street, eventually there will be a conclusion to that, but it's not going to be in that statement of it itself.

Action can be fun, which then we tie into that is kind of the explanation that is here with the vex in the garden and the explanation of time. So this is also I'm still really happy that Ishtar linked to Tevis to this card to because that makes me feel better about my initial reaction. You want me to read this card? I think it's because I just love Tevis.

I just love Tevis. It's like a favorite card. So it says describe time. No, really, give it a go.

You're going to say something about a sequence of events, aren't you? And slice off a clock, marching one by one off into infinity. Go ahead. Use your metaphors.

Align. A loop. A flat circle. Heard someone say time was like water once.

At least it was novel. The vex, they're the closest to understanding it. They've got distance from it. If time's a river, then we're fish and they're diving birds.

What's wet mean to a fish? What's it mean to an osprey who's never fooled by refraction on the water's surface? Hold on now, you're going to say, this is a getting a bit abstract, even for the bodiless echo of a dead guy in the garden. You want concrete truths?

Something simple, digestible, a story to keep the dark out? You want time to be a staircase we keep climbing forever. Hey, even a guardian skips back a step or two now and then die with your ghost in range and it'll just pop you back to before that bullet, give you the chance to make a fate you like better. Nothing's been simple on Earth since that big white cue ball rolled up in from the next neighborhood over.

And the stories, they don't work too well as a nightlight anymore. You're going to say, the traveler is our friend. The traveler likes us. It gave us a golden age in garden worlds and guardians.

You're going to say, you wouldn't be alive without it, Mr. Big Shot. Without it, I wouldn't be stuck in the black garden making bets with myself on which goblins are going to be the next to slip on a soggy leaf and fall off a cliff, either. You took my light already.

You better take my advice. I know the void's still calling, but I've come untethered. I can't reach it anymore. So if I'm right, then I can reach you, you keep your ears open.

I don't care how much you hate hearing it. This is important. The Vex understand time in a way we never will. It doesn't matter how long I spend here watching them, doesn't matter how many Jerry rigged portals guardians fling themselves through.

We live in time. They use it as a tool. Any moment that's never happened, any moment that will ever happen, they can go back to it, play it again till they get it right, simulate it. The lights, a counter to that, they come back, a guardian comes back.

They simulate an Indian, they simulate an Indian, a guardian tears through it. They animate. But the Vex and the garden, they bend the knee to the garden's heart. It gives them power till you got lucky.

The Vex outside, they made a different calculation. They run. But the Vex inside make the same deal you make every day of your unnatural life. And who's to say that deal won't start paying off for them again sometime soon?

You can't understand the Vex and you don't want to understand the heart. But is your ignorance any more forgivable when it's willful? Lots of questions and not a lot of answers. Better take care or you'll drown in them, surely as you'll drown in time, whether it's anything like a river or not.

You see? I love that card. So. I just love taverns.

I can't, I can't not read that with the, like, with tevices like with the snarky. Oh my God. Like I just, I hear him like with that, that old elderly growl in the void, like a, and the solar quote that you guys had said earlier was just perfect. So the soul divisive, making the same deal with the dark side, the dark side, the black card.

That's always a, that's a fun thought experiment as to why the Vex that are outside are running and why they don't know what to do with this old divisive also within this one. So it's actually not hard to think about like normally when you die in like a strike, when it's not a darkness zone, you don't go back in time because you, the enemies that you killed are, are still killed. But if you're in a darkness zone and everybody dies and you wipe, you go back and start over. You could also argue that you go back to time, but the time is like that you're, you're stepping backwards and you're actually, your personal timeline is being converted, but you're not affecting the abstract timeline that we are stepping out of the stream and going back in a different place.

Get at the same time. Those, their perspectives of time is still going in the same rate before. Yes. It's like when you, when you read like in comics, like, you know, speedsters, they experience things as going slow or they're, they experience things as a normal time, like flash, like they do this a lot with flash, but they'll show it from his perspective and like he's doing things at a normal pace for himself, but he has, he has expiated or expedited his, his body.

And so from an outside perspective, it's super fast, but to him it's just normal, like it's just normal speed. Is there anything else within this one besides just the fact that we're getting scolded by Tevis and we had the time conversation. It's like, does there need to be anything else? I don't think there does.

I really don't think so. I do think so. If that was delivered in any other way besides like the snarkiness from Tevis, I don't think it would have had as much impact. I don't think we would have believed it was Tevis.

Right. But, uh, Joseph, a Joseph is expressing a command. And Joseph's subjunctive expresses what the speaker slash writer believes should be done in the second or third person. This amounts to a command or prohibition when seen in first person, this usually is called a hortory, hortatory, I don't know what that is, hortory subjunctive, which is a form of the verb used to incite or encourage.

So yeah, yeah, expresses when it should be done now. Is that a good? Yes. Okay.

I'm a danger. I see. I'm a danger. You're like, now.

Oh, no. So this is the card where it talks about the pulses, pulses from outside the vault come quicker now. More copies of the historic collective team arrive using them for a boost leap rogging in from the dark. Their messages are getting out there out to the ends of the VEX networks.

The pulses are getting strong enough that shim thinks they have a chance to boost data even beyond the network to physical reality, whatever physical reality means to them and to Pradeth at this point, lifetimes deep in the VEX projections. Pradeth is attuned to the rhythm of the bolt. When another pulse lines up with that momentary weakness, that lets his radio work, he pushes a message through. It doesn't bounce back.

It has gone through. He whoops, raggedly. It doesn't. They start to send messages, scattershot, wherever they can.

Frequently asked questions

How long is this episode of Focused Fire Chat, a Destiny Lore Podcast?

This episode is 1 hour and 41 minutes long.

When was this Focused Fire Chat, a Destiny Lore Podcast episode published?

This episode was published on December 20, 2019.

Is there a transcript available for this episode?

Yes, a full transcript is available for this episode. You can read the complete transcript on the episode page.

Can I download this Focused Fire Chat, a Destiny Lore Podcast episode?

Yes. Use the download control on the episode player to save the publisher-provided media file.