Skip to content
Ep. 189: Is This Just Fantasy? episode artwork

Nov 30, 2020 36 min

Ep. 189: Is This Just Fantasy?

from Simblified Hosted by IVM Podcasts

Fantasy sports have come a long way in India, so much so that they're the title sponsors of the IPL. But wait, is it legal? Is it gambling? Will God punish us for playing? Naren and Tony try to Simblify the framework in which bets like fantasy sports, poker, and horse racing operate in India. All bets are off. Meet your hosts aka The Ultracrepidarians! Naren | Tony Instagram: @shenoynv | @notytony Twitter: @shenoyn | @notytony Say hello and tell us what you think! We love your feedback. We'd love it if you could leave a rating on Apple Podcasts - it really helps boost visibility and our egos. Simblified is: An Indian podcast that takes things that happen around us and deconstructs them in a manner you can understand and impress your colleagues, next interviewer, date or cat. Run by four folks seeking a return to the "good ol' days of Twitter" - Naren, Srikeit & Tony, Simblified has the guarantee of "if we can understand it, you can!" and proceeds to look at everything from technology to politics to weird phenomena to questions you never knew you wanted to be answered. Along the way, you'll hear lots of bad jokes, facts, PG Wodehouse references, and more bad jokes. Hopefully, you'll have a laugh. For more awesome IVM podcasts, find us at: Website: https://ivmpodcasts.com/ Facebook: https://facebook.com/ivmpodcasts Twitter: https://twitter.com/ivmpodcasts Instagram: https://instagram.com/ivmpodcasts

Episode details come from the podcast's RSS feed.

Embed this episode

Fantasy sports have come a long way in India, so much so that they're the title sponsors of the IPL. But wait, is it legal? Is it gambling? Will God punish us for playing?

Ready to play

Ep. 189: Is This Just Fantasy?

0:00 36:12
of matches

Transcript Auto-generated, may contain errors

I, V, M. The Every day in every way I feel better and better. Every day in every day. So just that guy really gets scared by this young lady named Paul DeCavit.

Yeah, you do that power stance thing in front of the mirror and stuff like that. Not to feel, I don't know. Some people do it apparently. So anyway, so my life has drastically changed this week because the IPL has ended.

And interestingly enough, I have never really followed the IPL since its beginning till about three or four years ago. And there is a reason that changed. It is because of something called the Fantasy League. And Fantasy League's have been around forever since, I think the first one in India was called Super Selector.

And like all beginnings of good things in sport, it also had the hand of Mr. Joy Batajaria. I think he was the one who brought around this Super Selector thing. But then it's changed a lot since.

And in the last few years, fantasy games have really picked up in India. And so you often talk about how you use this podcast for personal edification. I also use it for personal edification to sort of toot my own haunt. So this time I played the Fantasy League and ended up in the top 5,000 ranks in over 5 lakh players.

So like top 1%. But the reason I'm saying it out loud is because I didn't win anything. There's like no money involved. And all I can do is say it on the spot.

So are you aware of Dream 11, Merin? Have you ever played? Yeah, I've only heard of it. But you put together your 11 and based on how they actually perform, you get points.

Yeah, that's right. And the person who gets the maximum points wins the kitty. That's right. And you have to pay in order to be part of that win the kitty thing, right?

Yeah. So your understanding is far superior to mine because I've never played. So the great distinction that Dream 11 brought to the table was while everyone was trying to build a better mouse to better fantasy looking at the mechanics of how you can run it over a season. What Dream 11 said was screw all that.

Indians have no time and patience in ones and all of that. What we'll do is introduce something called a daily challenge where you can basically pick 11 for each match that is there. So instead of one opportunity that is or one league that is spread out over 60 matches, now you have 60 separate opportunities where people can win. And therefore, technically they can put in money as well.

So the thing is basically, you know, Vivo was the sponsor of the IPL last year. And then obviously we developed the allergy for China. So we had to buy all of the China's that were there, right? So which meant that during these COVID times also, Dream 11 surprisingly emerged as the sponsor for the game.

It's nothing bullish about the China shops here. Yeah, yeah, China is OK as strong as its weakest king. OK, something like that. Yeah, but what these guys did was they got the prime sponsorship for IPL, which is not a joke.

So the other guys that were involved were obviously like the hot ones, including there was a rumor that a group was supposed to be bidding for it, that edtech companies actually did bid for it. Of course, Bijus has already put their name front and center on the Indian jersey and stuff like that. So they were well established players, but Dream 11 suddenly came in and put in 222 crores to become the main sponsor, right? So clearly they have a revenue stream.

And how does, let's say, something like, you know, fantasy league become legal in India and on revenue was of interest. And I think that's what we probably discussed today. So. Yes, because I have really wondered about this.

I haven't gone into the other thing. How in the world did they manage to get into a space like this and brought me shut down? Yeah, yeah. That's the one.

Yeah, I think it is actually still working progress, right? Like our last episode where we spoke about how OTT platforms were under the IP and electronics ministry and now has changed to the INB ministry, et cetera. Eventually I'm guessing there will be a regulation here also because other than sex and unity, what Indians cannot stand obviously is responsible adults making their own decisions to throw away their money. So like gambling and all that cannot allow it.

So, but interestingly enough, like it's, it's the laws are very different, the world over, right? So I remember like two of my cricketing experiences, one was in one today where I actually, you know, stood in a long line to get into the stadium and eventually reached an SBI ATM during the monetization. And the other was at MCG in Australia where I was standing in queue and because you know, you're used to standing in queues and suddenly I ended up in a betting house where you can actually place bets on the match that is happening right outside the stadium. But in India, technically these laws have been written sometime in 1867, right?

There is something called the Public Gambling Act of 1867 and it could be running or being in charge of a gambling house as it's called. And I'm guessing this is an 1867 law because the penalty for breaking the law is a fine of rupees 200. I think there's no support agreements. Yeah.

My honest one word, who would choose to be imprisoned for three months in lieu of payment? The first one was called the capital. It drafted carefully. Yeah.

Yeah. Yeah. I mean, unless you're like homeless and jobless and then you want to sort of have like cheap lodging, sales, etcetera, right? No one would want to really do that.

All the data. Yeah. But the point is that the Indian courts since 1867 have always been against gambling because it is an activity which deters the growth of the economy and causes a loss of a man's income. That's what the, you know, pay three arcs of the nation have always thought about it.

And essentially why is that? Because it's gambling involves a wager where there is a certain event which can happen or may not happen, right? And so essentially in the parlance of law, gambling is a kind of contingent contract and contingent contract means that the, there is a certain kind of risk and the outcome of that risk will determine, you know, who is the winner and who is the loser. So contingent contract by law is void.

It's a void contract, but that does not mean it is illegal. So basically what that means is you and I can enter into a wager, but we can't technically go to court. Have you done this? Yeah.

Yeah. You can do the first one say that this is the contingent contract and therefore please go away. Now go to the next place where you'll be tried for gambling in the first place. So, and it's always been heavily restricted, right?

Gambling, but it's also a state subject. So based on the schedule that it lies in, I mean the seventh schedule of the constitution of India as per at least two betting in gambling rests with the states which means that each state can determine it's on laws about gambling. That's why you have those 10 crore rupees a kiln plot. Ah, yeah, we'll get to that.

But so yeah, interestingly in India, Sikim is one state which allows gambling in a restrictive form. The other of course is Goa, right? So there is a Goa, Daman and Du public gambling act of 1976. And what they did was they basically authorized five star hotels or offshore vessels are allowed to sort of enter into gambling.

So basically you will find if you go to Goa, there are several casinos which are all more in the river. Yeah. Yeah. And the reason for that is, yeah, those are Bob Beaman who probably jumped in this for the whole street.

Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. So yeah, either you have to be offshore or you have to, you know, build a five star sort of property to sort of do it.

And I think in dominant you, these delta guys have built one now where it is legal. So now there is a five star, you know, gambling area also. Right. But so technically we've been speaking about gambling so far, but are there the, you know, differences in how certain things are treated, right?

And in India, the court has basically tried to put a line saying there are essentially things that you put money on or games that you put money on, which are either based on chance or mere skill, right? And mere skill is actually then further defined to say it's a game that needs a predominant amount of skill, not that it's fully skill based. And why this came into being, I guess, was because of horse racing, right? Because horse racing and betting on horse racing has been fairly legal in India since I would say the beginning of time, right?

And their sort of explanation for that was betting on horse racing is not purely based on chance, but it is based on several other factors such as pedigree of the horse. Yeah. What the horse had for breakfast. Yeah.

You look at the animal that you look at the rider and you decide that they have it in them. So you're such a good guy. Is it brushing its teeth with goal gait or eating apples and stuff like that? So essentially there is a amount of information that you need to know to sort of say that this horse has a good chance of winning the race, right?

And again, it's not like you can basically do horse races anywhere in the country. There are, there is a nodal authority, which is the tough authority of India. And there are five main race clubs, Royal Calcutta, Royal Western for Mumbai and Pune, Madras race club, Bangalore tough club and Hyderabad race club. And there's one in Mysore also, I think.

Yeah. And the question of membership of these clubs? Yeah, exactly. Yeah.

So not anyone can do it. You would basically need to get membership to these clubs to sort of do it. And I guess the distinction there was anyone who was able to sort of get membership to these were, you know, past aristrok crads and rich people who were basically able to bet the law in their way, right? So technically, the, what I'm saying is that the state should get off its high horse, right?

Because if you're saying betting on horse racing is legal, then what's the difference between betting on a match, right? Like if it's India, Australia, I still need to know, you know, certain amount of things to be able to put money on a match. And that I'm guessing will never happen, right? Because there is obviously like elements of a morality saying gambling is bad, B also the issue of like fixing matches and stuff like that.

So interestingly enough, during these pandemic times, right, when matches were not happening, there was one enterprising fellow in Punjab. And what he did was he conducted a Sri Lankan T20 lead in Chandigarh. So basically hired local players, hired out a stadium and streamed the match on, you know, YouTube and channels like fan code. And basically there was no audience or anything.

And people were putting money on it to say, you know, and what they could do was, because the stream was controlled, there was no high quality cameras and all of that, they could just basically stop in the middle and ask people to either hit a forward or wide or whatever else it was. So yeah, there was a Sri Lankan T20 lead that happened in Chandigarh in July. Yeah, so there is some element of sense to say if you don't regulate gambling or betting or do it in a proper manner, ultimately we are all in it for the spot, right? What happened to the Sri Lankan T20 lead?

Did he make a lot of money? Yeah, so I think he got caught because obviously like once it's on the internet, people ask, right? Like you can't just randomly make up Sri Lankan names. It takes a fair bit of effort to make up once Sri Lankan gave itself.

So why this came up was because fan code, which was sort of streaming this, is actually owned by Dreamleven also. So whenever you get big enough to be able to sponsor IPL, people have their eyes on you, right? And the other thing was to say Dreamleven actually has like investment from China from 10% about 10% of their investment is actually from China as well. Yeah, but other than horse racing, which is legal to be, you can put bets on, but not sports.

The other big thing that you referred to earlier is lottery, which is in some sense is the worst form of gambling because the odds are heavily against you. Clearly, yeah, clearly is back against you. Yeah, yeah, yeah. And there's absolutely no element of skill there.

Yeah, yeah. As a man of mathematics, you should be completely shocked if something like this is legal, but something like betting on one out of two teams is not the right. But again, lottery is also legal only in 13 Indian states. And apart from Sikem Kerala was the big one because the government itself ran lottery.

So they said the money was going towards charity or other things and stuff like that. But it's basically a good way for the state to make a lot of money because of the way lottery is structured. It is pretty, I remember they were lottery for people kids. And they were all like somewhere in the advertising was how buying that lottery would actually help your company.

That was part of it. That was, you know, you would actually, and you know, so you had, when people growing up, all lottery tickets were sort of like blind people. So by the lottery ticket, you would actually help the blind person. That was the...

Right, right. Yeah, I mean, this was the thing. I mean, you know, definitely able people were, I think even in KFL, it was the case that you got a lottery license if you were definitely able and stuff like that. So somehow, but the false equivalence cannot be false.

Yeah, I would have just cleverly marketed for that time. Yeah, it's a completely scam. Just sort of press it up as a social party and you'll talk it around people actually. Yeah, yeah, yeah.

So other than these two, right, where it's lottery and horse racing, which are random, essentially everything that is legal in India is based on this definition of game of skill versus game of chance. For instance, the Supreme Court has said that the game of a Rami is a game of skill, but like three card games like Flush or Bragg or Pimpati or whatever, this is a game of chance. So the term is instead of mere game of skill, it is called a preponderantly a game of skill. And I think where this has actually led to a proper revenue stream first is in poker and poker is Texas-Holden poker, if played over like, you know, multiple hands is actually a game of skill.

So and again, it's up to local interpretation, because again, I think only a few states have legalized poker as well. But what is happening? He's skilled and very, very good poker player. And we both, and most of all, this was probably, it was Amrit for now.

Yeah, yeah. Very good. And I'm seeing. And for a short time, he was actually a professional poker player, where you know, you'd be playing poker full-time.

Right. And he gave up, he was doing really well. He was high-spoke-pervanny. He explained how it was entirely a game of skill, except that chance meant you could be losing despite being far more skilled than your opponents, merely because your luck was bad.

But in the long run, you would really make one. Yeah, yeah. Correct. In some sense, it's comparable to Scrabble, right?

Like anyone, anyone can possibly beat a champion Scrabble player in one sitting, because the tiles may fall a certain way. But over like, if you play 10 times, it's likely that the champion will be two, nine out of 10 times. And poker is similar because you are basically playing, you know, the odds, right? And you're playing probability.

And if you're playing probability, eventually you will win out. Yeah. So what happened basically was the people saw that there was an opportunity to sort of take this online, right? So if you're saying that it is based on a game of skill, then you have like lots of players.

And everyone tends to think that they're really good at this particular game, right? And for poker specifically, with the exception of Andhra Pradesh, Sikim surprisingly, Nagaland, Assam, Odisha, and Telangana, every other state allows it, right? And this was based on a 1967 Supreme Court judgment, which was further reaffirmed in 1996. So I think in some states have it better off like Karnataka, West Bengal, Goa, et cetera.

But basically, if you go on to like, let's say, online poker platform, their legality basically states that if you're in one of these states, which is Anhra Pradesh, Assam, Odisha, et cetera, please don't play. Otherwise, you're allowed to play, which is again fairly random, right? Yeah, completely right. Yeah.

So it's a fairly gray area. But the point is that I spoke of the fantasy league and how I actually grounded out over 60 matches to make no money, right? In some senses, poker is also like that because you need to actually spend hours and hours playing the game, right? To, you know, there's a buy-in and then you have to make a certain amount of money.

And poker, I think technically, a good player will fold more hands than you'll play. It requires a lot of discipline. So you have to basically be, A, know the game very well, B, invest lots of time into it to make very little money. And that's where Dreamleaven basically figured it out to say, you know, what, according to the founder, basically his innovation was same as Chik Shampoo from back in the day.

So he says, the masses in India need a shampoo, sachet, not a bottle, right? So the change that he made basically was to enable betting. It's quite brilliant in hindsight, actually. Yeah, yeah.

Accuse and brilliant. Yeah, because the amount of investment required is very little, right? So you have a match between Mumbai and Delhi. Maybe you watch only, let's say, matches between matches of Mumbai.

So only like 14 matches in a season, right? But you can basically be further invested saying, okay, this side, no, I know my Mumbai players, they're going to do really well and stuff like that. And you basically, you know, put money into it. And the idea is that because there is massive scale, right?

So in India, there are around 100 million players on Dreamleaven totally, right? And about 20% have played a game. So you can basically either play the non-played version for you, or you can put in money and say, you know, I know everything, I will make money. So 20% of 10 crore is not a small amount of people, right?

So what that means is that the higher end payout happens to be in crores and stuff like that. So with one match, technically, you are given the character saying you could make a crore or more. And yeah, so the other thing was infantiously, what usually used to happen was if you even miss one match or two matches, and you forget to make a substitution, etc., it's unlikely that you will win, because it will significantly dent your chances, right? But here it was all about instant gratification.

And clean every match up. Yeah, exactly. And so, I mean, in my mind, it requires way less skill than running it over a period of time, because in a proper fantasy league, which is stretched out over 60 matches, you have, let's say, limited 110 substitutions over 60 matches. So then you have to play a strategy in terms of how you use those substitutions, which matches you put more players in and stuff like that.

Whereas here, practically, you just have to pick 11 players and sit back and enjoy, right? And like I said, the payout is basically a very pyramid kind of structure. It's only like the top five or 10 people make any money. The others, if you put in 30 rupees, you might get back 10 rupees or things like that.

And obviously, so it was not without a hitch. And this freemium model ran for five years without any problems. Then in 2017, one guy basically dragged them to court, right? Saying, I've been putting lots of money into your league, and I haven't won anything.

In fact, he had lost like 50,000 rupees by the time he went to the Punjab and Haryana court. And in a good way, Punjab and Haryana court said that it is a game of skill, and therefore you're probably not skilled enough. So it was thrown out, and it is basically still in a legal state. And they have this in not just in cricket, actually.

They basically once you establish the tech platform in the model and you have net worth effects, it's essentially like any game can be fantasized. So they have it in Kabadi and basketball and stuff like that also. And again, like we spoke last week, this is currently, it's not a regulated industry, it's self-regulated by one, you know, sort of union called the Indian Federation of Sports Gaming, which was formed in 2017 and is actually headed by the guy who's founded Dream Loveth in itself. Yeah, so that's how things are currently.

But like with all of these things, it's much better if there are clear legalities around it, because they are also expecting that this will soon run into legal troubles and it can be left upon the judgment of one judge or the other. Once you've invested significantly in this, then there's always that legal trouble that is behind your back. But there has been a private bill that was introduced in the Lok Sabha in the last Lok Sabha, seeking a mechanism for the unorganized online gaming sector. And it was introduced by Shashi Tharu.

So his point of view was that it's fairly progressive compared to the rest of how India works. He's saying that, you know, put in a statutory framework to ensure, you know, while there are licenses that you also are able to track suspicious betting patterns and basically make it all taxable, right? And he basically says that right now there is an underworld betting market also, right? The fantasy part is basically for the common man like you and me.

But actually there are people who put significant amounts of money into betting gambling and stuff like that, right? So which also leads to match fixing and then open above-board betting system would not do that, and you collect that. Those are the, you know, sort of things that are being discussed. But I don't think it's being discussed anytime soon.

It's currently still continuing in the manner that it is. And yeah, so... Have all our regulations are characterized by these peroxysms of righteousness that sort of affect our law-based economy. Somebody wakes up in the morning and feels that they have to go and clean up the models of this great nation.

And they go and make a stupid law that does exactly opposite. They say, you know, there's a thing. The friend of the biggest friend of the bootlegger is the Baptist because in the US, Baptist are the people who are against pro tempers. They wanted prohibition.

And the moment into this prohibition, we'll get bigger. So this is what... So I think what's actually the road is like. One good thing about having a regulation rather than having a regulation at all is it draws boundaries of what a state can do.

Right. Yeah, so it's good to have... Ideally, of course, you shouldn't have any regulation at all if people are suckers and they fall for it and they find out they're getting scammed. Right.

They should stay away from it. But yes, I mean, a little regulation probably better than regulation. Yeah, yeah, absolutely. And actually, like this fantasy sports globally is expected to touch 10 billion in revenues by 2024 globally, right?

Which means that if this is like the reported regulated market of betting, then imagine the unorganized sector. There's large amounts that is to be there. And even in India, it's supposed to be around $1 billion by next year because the revenue stream for fantasy games is pretty substantial and significant. And therefore, better to have clear loss than nothing at all.

Right. Even the government realizes that people need to go out and spend money in order for the economy to... Yeah, it doesn't matter how they're spending the money they need to go out and spend. So hopefully, there'll be less...

Several things. One is, I mean, I'm going out on the lived here. But I'm pro-alcoholant tobacco being a feeder. Absolutely.

Yeah. And I really didn't like the way they handled crackers. I don't know why they were so brutally harsh on the cracker industry. Right.

I cannot for the life of me believe it's that harmful. Okay, a few people who have... But people who are prone to asthma and who can be triggered by air pollution, they are going to be triggered by regular pollution on the streets as well. Right.

The crackers are going to be really small. So there hasn't really been any scientific study people have just gone. I've demolished the livelihoods of how many people in their entire industry. Yeah.

And for a moment, it's not. So it's really, you know, things are that should be stopped. Absolutely. We should take away common powers to that.

Yeah. I think the only thing that you can say as like a negative of, you know, let's say poker or any of these online gambling things is that it is zero sum in that sense, right? Because someone has to lose money for someone to win money. And the platform keeps raking in money regardless because they take a cut of the overall winnings.

But otherwise, I mean, if you want to do it and you're aware or unaware of it, why not? Go for it. Right. So anyway, I think we've covered two episodes of Indian lawmaking.

What do we simplify to the premier legal legal? I feel probably the day they bring a law which bans funds the first one to make up. Yeah. Yeah.

Yeah. In a value accident, loss and loss kind of, right? You know, so I don't want to face that loss. So yeah, you want to.

Yeah. This was good. And yeah, stay safe. Stay, uh, stay gamble.

Stay or stay better than stay simplified. Yeah. Stay hard. Stay.

Yeah. Yeah. Bye. Bye.

Frequently asked questions

How long is this episode of Simblified?

This episode is 36 minutes long.

When was this Simblified episode published?

This episode was published on November 30, 2020.

Is there a transcript available for this episode?

Yes, a full transcript is available for this episode. You can read the complete transcript on the episode page.

Can I download this Simblified episode?

Yes. Use the download control on the episode player to save the publisher-provided media file.