Skip to content
Ep. 201: Guess Who's Back? (Part 2) episode artwork

Mar 22, 2021 54 min

Ep. 201: Guess Who's Back? (Part 2)

from Simblified Hosted by IVM Podcasts

The gang is back for one last time for the second and final 200th episode of Simblified. Chuck, Naren, Srikeit, and Tony pick up from where they left off in the previous episode and try to Simblify sophisticated things like BigTech and Man's search for meaning. Meanwhile, the banter continues to be unsophisticated. Oh! And there's a surprise at the end of the episode. Add one part news, one part bad jokes, one part Wikipedia research, one part cult references from spending too much time on the internet, one part Wodehouse quotes, and one part quality puns, and you get Simblified. A weekly podcast to help you appear smarter, to an audience that knows no less! Your four hosts - Chuck, Naren, Srikeit and Tony attempt to deconstruct topics with humour (conditions apply). Fans of the show have described it as "fun conversations with relatable folks", "irreverent humour", "the funniest thing to come out of Malad West" and "if I give you a good review will you please let me go". Started in 2016 as a creative outlet, Simblified now has over 200 episodes, including some live ones, and some with guests who are much smarter than the hosts. Welcome to the world of Simblified! You can contact the hosts on: Chuck: twitter.com/chuck_gopal / instagram.com/chuckofalltrades Naren: twitter.com/shenoyn / instagram.com/shenoynv Tony: twitter.com/notytony / instagram.com/notytony Srikeit: twitter.com/srikeit / instagram.com/srikeit For more awesome IVM podcasts, find us at: Website: https://ivmpodcasts.com/ Facebook: https://facebook.com/ivmpodcasts Twitter: ivmpodcasts Instagram: https://instagram.com/ivmpodcasts

Episode details come from the podcast's RSS feed.

Embed this episode

The gang is back for one last time for the second and final 200th episode of Simblified. Chuck, Naren, Srikeit, and Tony pick up from where they left off in the previous episode and try to Simblify sophisticated things like BigTech and Man's

Ready to play

Ep. 201: Guess Who's Back? (Part 2)

0:00 54:32
of matches

Transcript Auto-generated, may contain errors

I, V, M. I can't imagine, call it the final part, not part 2. Just to be clear, next week's episode is like it'd be 1.52, just 2, so much fans. So we are continuing our celebration of the 200 episode of this wonderful show.

And I think let's get started with a coconut, which is broken in 2 parts and... You know, a lot of bad negative stuff has gone into a plus of a pop. Let's get a little nostalgic, it was at your house that we started this show four years back, five years back. five years ago.

Nothing more than a mobile phone and as we famously say, our idea of engineering was to switch off the fan. It was entirely the indefatigable energy of Chuck which started it. You have to do it. I just want to stop Tony before he says some rubbish like we are still stopping all our fans.

I just want to see you guys. I just want to say it as such a veteran you become. I want to fan. Please don't touch the butt and then of course she gets caved on as well.

I guess that started as guests continued. It's like how I think the British. I was thinking more agency-client relationship but the British is another good way. So then what are you?

So okay fair enough if Narayan and I were present and so on. She came in and educated us with railways and English and cricket. I am the bureau thread. I am the bureau thread.

You are the university. You are the university. That's very little work but it's all important also. You are the title of the content.

Okay so a quick recap. We were talking about SPACs in the last episode and then she came and spoke about the unification of the stock market and the entire game stop circus. Now it's Chuck Stern to come up with whatever he has planned. And do you Chuck?

Yeah thank you. So I want to rant or talk about Big Tech. I think it's a big enough topic for all of us. It's a big enough topic for all of us to tech about.

I could have started that slightly better. I'm sorry. So this might be of Dave Brubek's immortal song, Tech 5. At this point we basically take it and go.

This is all the good. Another line that sounds familiar. So Big Tech, what is Big Tech? Firstly it's worth asking that question right up.

Usually when we say Big Tech it refers to the big four or five companies that dominate our lives for better or worse from an internet point of view. That being Google, Facebook and obviously includes Instagram and WhatsApp as well as part of it. Then there is Apple to some extent at least in the US. What else would count?

Microsoft I guess. I feel I miss somebody out. Amazon. Amazon.

It's basically what's on your phone and you use most of the time. It's the origin of the phrase is that a big tech in your pants or are you just happy to see. So there's this fascinating. So it's actually kind of incredible to see how these companies that were just formed about 20 years ago.

Not just communiquity to connect to the previous episode, taken over stock market, valuation and stuff. Big Tech has got even bigger in the pandemic. Something will talk about. It's something called Big Football.

It's just a big football. We are here to talk about it. Big football. Does look like it's being played with Big Football.

Apparently the football refers to the size of the ball. I don't know this. It's a fucking one. Apparently I don't know.

Interesting. The founder. I don't know. It makes sense.

It's a factor. Has it been verified? I don't know. I did it on the Internet so it must be true.

There's a journalist from Gizmodo in two or three years back. Someone called Kachny with the Internet. She did an experiment where she went one week without each of the big four guys. That's Facebook, Amazon and non-Microsoft, non-Microsoft, the other four guys.

And then the fifth week she went without any of them. What is interesting over there is when we think of Facebook, we think of Facebook and to some Instagram, I guess. When we think of Amazon, we think of only the e-commerce. We think of Amazon.

We think of Amazon. Yeah, sure, that's okay. But then you think about what all Tentacles Amazon has its hands into. Amazon Web Services, for example, which is the fastest growing.

It's not, it's now its second fastest growing division. Actually, the ads business is the fastest growing business right now. But AWS is their money making division. Yeah, AWS is the money making division which has in some ways bankrolled the less profitable retail business, which is what you and I associate.

And because of this, and similarly, Google as well. We think of Google mainly as the search engine, but it's obviously a lot more than that right now. Because you can't use Google, it also means that you have no Google maps to navigate. It doesn't make a difference for us at home right now where the challenge is to find the biggest challenge is to find the toilet.

But back in the days when we could go out, that must have been quite a challenge. That's when it really hit her and her readers that when you cut out one of these players, you're crippled in many ways that you didn't see. And hence, look at the amount of control that they actually have over our lives. And this has had a whole bunch of other like downswing effects as well, if that's the right phrase to use.

We think that we live in a technological boom right now. But if you look at the numbers, there are actually fewer companies started in Silicon Valley over the last four or five years than in this 80s. And that's because founders are actually scared to start companies thinking that one of these guys will just copy over the features. And that kind of makes sense.

I look at the president, like Snapchat had a good idea, boom. It suddenly became Instagram. So it was joke that Instagram is actually Facebook's R&D lab. That Snapchat is Facebook's R&D lab.

And like, there are many, many, many. Just can I just say one thing as someone who's worked on the advertising angle, one thing that made me incredibly happy was like two, three years after I started advertisement Facebook. Snapchat is not as robust, but finally one agency provided the dashboard. And their advertising dashboard is completely copied over from Facebook's advertising.

Wow. That's one way of fighting back. Amazing. And you know what's fascinating for me?

Now there's a lot of, we're talking about big tech because it's a news thing, right? A big tech antitrust and all these guys being hauled over to Congress to testify and all that. What's interesting to me is all of them are different. All of them operate in completely different spaces.

They're kind of stepping on each other's toes. But it's almost like this, we big four or five guys are in this together. And our own completely different sort of things like Google dominates some things. Facebook and Instagram dominate like social networking and things like that.

Amazon is completely online retail. And Apple is always kind of like being the outlier in some sense. And I guess that's because they have a completely different model where people, I mean, their whole thing is, they have such a strong brand that people are willing to pay them a lot of money for products. So they are kind of slightly different from the rest of big tech.

Yeah. Imagine a big four that doesn't have Microsoft in it, right? It's like when suddenly you say the big four of football is United City Arsenal and Chelsea and like Liverpool is somewhere else. Yeah, I mean.

Black one, one, one, one, one, one. One. Yeah. But it's almost like, you know, the whole, I mean, Italian cartel kind of business that I take the North side, you take the West side, I take the East side and you take the South side.

And also then later on, seeing the Cola was where the biggest loser of the Cola was not C cooler, right? But you're at the end of the day when I'm making one or the other the option, then there is no third option that can come in. And other people are being divorced around the world, but that's not the best. But yeah, but I mean across the board, these players, the way they operate and the way they're kind of doing it.

And there was a very interesting point you said about the whole lacking innovation where now there is also a huge number of new innovators who are coming in with a store objective of selling their idea to these big four. Yeah. They are designing entrepreneurial ideas to sell it to companies. Yeah.

Because they are a bad thing. I mean, it's much better than like making up fake valuations and getting this. Absolutely. There are close and cons.

But the one thing that I does come out is that every entrepreneur that decides to, that comes up with the idea that I'm going to sell to Amazon is increasing the valuation of Amazon, not just from the fact that they're going to sell them their innovation, but also from the perspective that there is no way. I'm going to consider competing with Amazon. Yeah. But I'm saying it's a safer option.

Right. I mean, historically, and I guess Narain would be best place to say this. Anyway, like 95% of startups or companies that get started fail in the first two years or so. Right.

So it's better to have an insurance policy saying I have an option of like, you know, either wanting to go for the long term or selling out to Amazon or getting into like an investor's key as one of the 20 bits that he places. Right. So I think it's better than what was. Yeah.

You do need money, right? You can't go to your browser and say, I got a great idea. Give me some. My stock exchange for tomato one kilo.

Yeah. But if you take it from an individual point of view, definitely I agree with you, Tony. It is better for that person to have a certain guarantee of success rather than that whole 90% failure thing. But from a larger market and innovation point of view, then 90% failure was what was actually the, almost the hotbed of innovation, right?

That 90% failure was that very strong save of people coming up and also the people who were feeling to try to get into the 10% of the second try or third try or third try. Right. So it depends on the viewpoint of who it is better for. I mean, you're looking at an individual, yeah, I have a better success rate and I'm more sick financially secure.

But here it's, I need to, I'm designing innovation to make AWS better rather than designing innovation to how do I calculate the consumer's life better. I'm looking at how ways I can make AWS or any tech innovation better. Still, still, still, really, I'm tailoring my innovation to improve their larger innovation. So that's where I feel there might be a problematic area of brand new thinking coming through because of how to be between large these tech giants are.

Yeah. Actually, one of the last things that I wanted to mention, but since you brought it up right now. Sorry. That's okay.

It seems like these big four, five players and honestly, we say big tech doesn't necessarily refer to just these four or five players. You see it in other spaces as well. It's basically like in every sector of technology you take, there are one or two huge winners and then it's almost impossible for everybody else to kind of compete, take music, for instance, where it's very clearly a Spotify or an Apple music or whatever else who's kind of conned that and because of that scale, because of that reach now, they're able to wait. And hence, I guess that's just called the fly deal effect or something.

Now Spotify is now able to get podcasts as a result of which the gulf between them and whoever else is fighting. It gets quite a bit. Take something else. Yeah, but for the average podcast, it's a huge opportunity.

Like now you've reached it along with Michelle Obama's podcast. No, but then you have the same problem of discoverability then, right? Become one podcast among thousands and just like the same problem is there on Amazon as well. And just to couple more examples on the earlier point, it's like B2B software for instance, where sales force is worse week and it's getting bigger.

Now, not a criticism as many of these companies are very good and all that, but it does put them in a position to dictate terms to some extent. Like artists, for instance, are Kristoff at Spotify for not paying them enough. And merchants on Amazon are constantly complaining that it's always like a two-edged sword, right? Like you get a lot of leads to some extent, but you know, you don't end up owning the customer.

You have to pay your shit ton of money to Amazon. And of course Amazon can take all the data, might create their own free basis, no, not free basis, but Amazon basis. Yeah. Just say that.

One of the things that you've done, which inspired me to do it later, is that we've parrated a lot of music or software. And then when we made enough money, you were good enough to go back and buy the physical copies or whatever to pay them back. And I actually used a pirated crossword software for four years. I stopped making a process and I started making enough money so then I went back and bought it for 10,000 rupees.

But unless the ecosystem exists, it's not possible for the person lower down the stream to actually make money. So I think there are both sides to it. One of the things that I see playing out is that all everyone when they start off, they're idealistic. So Google starts with don't be evil in Facebook.

So those are the days. Yeah, yeah. And then when you become successful, suddenly your whole operation changes from what can we do new to how do we protect what we have? And the moment the legal team in a company becomes the most important department, I think.

Actually, when we talk about evils of big tech, it's impossible to not talk about gig workers. So in some sense, the most egregious, if I may use that term of all these places, are companies like say Uber or a DoorDash or whatever. You have lots of reports of, so in all these companies, so the end consumer ends up pretty happy if you think about it to some extent. We get a lot of services for free or discounted or we can, at night at 12 PM on a whim, we can decide to order a piece and half an hour later.

But somebody is paying for it somewhere. And that tends to be some sort of worker. Now there's one strain of thought that says, but at least now these guys have some sort of additional income. But I think the system seems to have been rigged against them in some ways.

I guess it's good to see, like in the UK recently, they ruled that Uber drivers have to be classified as workers instead of gig workers. I don't know whether that's a good thing or a bad thing overall. But I think unless you make the whole thing sustainable for everybody, especially the people who run the rails, I don't think, not just the people who actually keep the vehicle running on the rails. I agree with you, but here's the slight counter.

And I absolutely think they're being terrible to workers. But I'm just saying that it's easier to be a left leading liberal in Mumbai than it is in Kerala. I'm now glad that Amazon has finally started delivering. Two years ago, it was like, they would call you after five days of your complaint and say, Hey, a parcel has come for you when you're coming to our office to correct me.

So I'm just saying, it's much easier to be a left liberal when I was a head by then. I'm a well said. I'm a well said. Yes, the gig economy is terrible to work out overall in some way, but it is a more balanced view than a polemical argument.

So I can take the example of what's happening here in Malaysia. So in Malaysia, it's over-routing in the US economy. And I think to survive the pandemic, because of the overwhelming, I mean, the home delivery is now becoming the biggest profession for people over here. And there's people who are actually, who are out of work, who are actually keeping their households going because of this economy.

And so everyone, I mean, Grab as an employer is practically being worshipped right now because they are, the other guys were giving people livelihoods in difficult times, people lost jobs because of constant lockdowns and stuff. And Grab is actually one of the better pain masters over here compared to a lot of other industries which are now shut down. And there are a lot of people who are switching to delivery in some way where they are actually saying they are probably not going to go back to the world of professions because this is much more profitable. It gives them that ability to switch around.

It's incredible right now, when I look at it, the way the economy is evolving, there are working mothers, even smaller children or kids and all that stuff, who are saying that it's easier to take on a job like being a Grab delivery person because they're literally taking their own car. They have their kids in the bag, so they don't need a babysitter. They're just going around making deliveries with their kids. So there's little kids coming and giving the food because the moms say, I'm going to pass the car so the kids are actually going to do that stuff and they're actually spending time with their parents already.

So, I think, yes, there are, and this is of course one, one fact of the economy, there are negative assets as well. But what I've seen is, I think as a workforce around the world, people are evolving with the geek economy to some extent where they are now finding ways of living with this. I have a slightly different thing. I strongly believe that these big guys need to be constantly hounded and pressured into being fair on the geek economy.

Because organizations have a tendency to be mindlessly evil, like for no particular reason. There is to be this thing called Walmart. There is a reason why it's called shareholders. No, not shareholders.

Not shareholders. Walmart is notorious for squeezing out every last bit of profit out of the value chain and delivering it to the customer. Who really doesn't care if a pair of whatever headphones is available for $1.19 when yesterday it was $1.21. But somebody in Walmart went and kicked as all the way from Vietnam to Cambodia to take that two cents away and give it to the Hobo in the world.

Wherever you want to buy it. So, you need to make sure that the system is fair. You cannot extract money from the pockets of helpless people like gig economy. Amazon is selling you something for like $0.99.

And you could pay $1.99. It doesn't matter if it's $0.99. So, Amazon must find some way of giving that guy. At least we should be yelling at Amazon all the time.

There needs to be so much. I'm all for Uber being pressurized. Corporations are mindlessly evil. They are just mind.

The same people who are really nice guys will be happy to pay, give to charities, everything. When they enter their office, they get into the other thing. They are there to suck that half a cent out of the pockets of some super gig water and pass it on to a consumer who doesn't care. Well, well, that's the best two cents I've ever had.

We'll give you four cents without using a discount code. But that's why the anti-trust discussions in the US are so fascinating right now. Because I think it's going to fundamentally change the way companies are looped. So, for those who are unaware of what this whole thing is, a long time back, there was a nice gentleman called John D Rockefeller, who's oil operations got so huge.

Narayan, by the way, was interviewed as a role for that. That's a very crude joke. Are you all right? No, but finally, the US has to the extent that Rockefeller was one of the richest guys in the world at that point of time and possibly the richest person ever in history, if you look at it.

And the US government at that point said, all right, too much. We are going to break this company down. It's acting as this huge trust, hence anti-trust. We broke it down to 16 companies and ironically enough, the value of the 16 companies actually ended up being even more valuable than one company by itself.

And Rockefeller actually at one point of time, his net worth is 2% of America's GDP, 2% of a country's GDP. But that's a fascinating thing with what's happening right now. The focus of antitrust is obviously not it. How does a consumer play at the lowest prices?

As long as the consumer plays at the lowest prices, everything else is fine. It seemed to work okay at a time when there was no internet, but right now, when it takes something like a Facebook account, the consumer's actually paying nothing. So what exactly is, how do we regulate, you can't regulate these companies in the same way as they did 30, 40 years back. And this is author I follow called Benedict Evans.

I absolutely love his analysis and his fake. Anyone who's listening and is a fan of Scott Galloway just go for Evans as well. He's a thing's brilliantly. And one of the points he made is to say, how do you classify each of these guys?

Take Facebook. Are they a media company? Are they a social media person? Are they an advertising platform?

How do you regulate them? What do you slot them as similarly all the other guys? How do they compete with each other? Yes, Amazon and Facebook compete with each other in some ways, but are they in the same territory?

Are they after the same customers? Actually, a lot of redefinition is going to happen right now. And I think you might fundamentally come back to saying, okay, it's not about the consumers paying the lowest price. It needs to be something else.

Now, whether that's something else is something like an ESG or something which BlackRock has been proposing for a while. No, no, I think that's one of the interesting things that's coming out of this whole thing for me. The second thing that I just wanted to say out of this is while it looks like these big 4, 5, 6 or the entrenched player in each industry is absolutely absolutely fine. I can't think of an other multi-vertical e-commerce platform coming up to challenge either on Amazon or the US or like Southeast Asia for instance has their own equal, like Lazada and all that in Singapore.

I think Lazada can go to the bottom of Amazon. No, no, no, no. So, what's interesting is while there may not be direct competition with these guys, what's interesting to me is that there are these niches coming up saying that, okay, we don't want the entire market. We're just going to focus on this one small thing and we're going to do a bloody good job of that.

Like music to me because there's a space that I follow a lot that means particularly fascinating. Nobody is going to be able to compete with the Spotify, Apple Music and all that for a scale level. You guys love it out. You do all that.

But then on the fringes, if you look, there are some very interesting things that are happening. There's a company called Bandcamp for instance where you can buy music directly from the artists and it's a little more expensive but the artists get a huge cut off the money. Now artists are incentivized, obviously put their music up on Bandcamp because they get a lot more money. They still make it available everywhere.

Obviously, but they get a huge cut of the money and fans of hardcore fans of some bands like me for instance. We'll go and make sure we buy it only from a Bandcamp for instance knowing that. And it's in Hanyghind? Are you this one time in Bandcamp?

Oh, goodness. I can't believe I did it. This is how old I become. So to me, that's the sort of interesting things that are happening.

And possibly the biggest anti-Big Tech brand in some ways is Shopify in that sense. Which came up as a way for people who are not exactly pissed off with Amazon but wanted to sell to consumers directly. They ended up building a platform. Today, ironically enough Shopify has become big enough where you can almost say there is a big anti-Big Tech.

Does that make sense? Yeah. That's what I said. When you start out these things, you're very idealistic.

Then suddenly the capitalists take over and then screw. I think a lot of these smaller companies, I don't think they're in it for the same reasons as the bandcamp for instance. I just spoke about having ambitions to the scale of a Spotify. They know that they will go till here and they won't compromise on their, I mean, it's as cheesy as big values.

It's like when Richard Hendricks has to concede the seat to that other CEO. That will eventually happen. I don't think that happens. No, that's the thing.

Look at the company. No one is that idealistic. If you are idealistic, you'll probably last five years and then die out. I guess that's the other cycle we are looking at it.

But I guess these guys have found out a way where they don't need to compromise. See, the things you compromise on values when you need to grow. When you need to, we need to mine our customers data so that we can go from here to here. I don't think these companies want to go from here to here.

They're happy doing this. They're saying we're getting X amount of money a month. That's fine because these guys operate in spaces that just, first, Spotify to say, okay, should we sell high resolution music directly? It's too much of an investment for them.

Maybe like screw it. That's not a game that we want to get into. It's not going to change things for us too much. Slightly philosophical analogy.

Recently, when all these cricketers and Bollywood stars had to parrot the line of the Indian government, Nasser Rinsha has the question that you earned enough a seven generation how much more do you want to protect? Why don't you speak out against evil or tyranny? Because you want to protect what you have. At the end of the day, it's just one Nasser Rinsha who does it as a host like a hundred prominent Bollywood stars and cricketers.

That's similar thing place. You may not want to make $800 trillion or something. But when it comes your way, you were suddenly given, naturally we are towards the basic instinct of one or two. But the thing over here Tony, I think is because each of these companies has built themselves up as being against the big guy.

I think the moment they do something they will get called out. That's bullshit, right? We all like to think of Mark Zuckerberg as like Dr. Evil.

But the fact is that poor guy wanted to have a weight of smash faces together. I think there are just so many ways of sort of looking at this. I mean, I'm sure we have a two-hour session on this. But hopefully we have given you something to think about.

The last thing that I wanted to mention in a second, because I can't go 30 minutes without mentioning the name Scott Galloway at least once. He said something that was very interesting. So if you look at the last few years, Big Tech has been acquiring high NPA industries, like an Amazon, for instance, buying out a lot of Hollywood so that there's a better reason for people to subscribe to Amazon Prime. And hence, basically what he's saying is that they're featureizing an entertainment industry to sell toilet paper better.

Like Spotify is kind of like doing the same thing with podcast right now. Podcasts are, let's face it, right? It's got a lot of affinity as in like all three super fans of Simplified. Two of which are on the panel right now.

Yeah, you never worked with it. So Spotify is somebody acquired an industry that a lot of people care very deeply about. And I think that's an interesting and maybe it's like a little way of looking at it. But yeah, it's very interesting to see how I think revisiting this conversation in two years time will be fascinating.

I think so much is going to change where all these guys are. So many things that could go wrong, so many things that could change, but these guys are here for the time being. And if you have stocks, then HODL as they say. HODL, HODL away.

Yeah, that's all for us. And that's a great segue into what I think Tony is going to talk about is what is the meaning of this topic. Yeah, but the segue is Chuck Fields at the next two years. We'll be sitting on like different stock portfolios.

My outlook is completely much bleaker, right? Like what is the meaning of life and stuff like that. But to be honest, I feel like I've got the rest code wrong for this 200 episode. All three of you have covered something that's here and now and probably in the future.

I actually thought, you know, this is a 200 episode. I don't know how many of you guys did this. Like when you were starting out a new term in school or something, you're like, oh, this term, I'll study properly. Yeah.

I'm sorry. I'm sorry. I'm sorry. And by the time the exam comes around, you're like, oh, you have a proper plan.

At least I had a proper timetable and plan, right? Like I will revise three times before the exam. On Monday, I will do this Tuesday. I will do this Wednesday.

I'll do this. Then two days for revision, then like some mock days and then the exam. But on the final day of the exam, you're like, oh, no, I haven't even covered half the textbooks. Yeah.

I was wondering if you start studying for CAT, right? The average number of pages per day they would cover for the first two weeks would be astonishingly high. And then they would drop up and say, huh, let's start again. Let's start this thing process all the way again.

So as a result of the video, if you take the average engineers CAT-preck material, the first 50 pages will be like super use. So I made this point that actually IMS and time and all can, they can like, after page 50, they can just publish blank and nobody will actually do that. So I feel like I'm not. Yeah.

Yeah. So, okay. So yeah, I got slightly ambitious and said, okay, instead of reading, I'll be trying to read one full book. I don't know if you guys have read this book.

Yeah, it's Victor Frankl's man search for meaning. I've read it. Yeah. See, I mean, I'm going to use this as like a sample size for our audience because obviously like it's privileged men.

I'm going to assume that 50% of you have not read this book. But what is fascinating is that it's as relevant today as it was written. So Victor Frankl immediately after the World War or some of Victor Frankl was this psychologist or psychoanalyst or one of these things who was basically in the concentration camps during World War II. Right.

And he basically got out of it, finally when the war ended. And so, I mean, I'm guessing he's an authority as anyone to speak about man search for meaning. And my book comes with a preface that is written in 1992 by Victor Frankl himself. Right.

And one of the things that he says is that it's a vessel or even in 1992. And that's not like a great thing because he's like hundreds of thousands of people reach out for a book who's very title promises to deal with the question of a meaning to life. And he must be a question that burns under their fingernails. So not a very happy existence for us here.

Right. So that was basically like how he started to write this book and his sort of account is in two parts. One is about what is the everyday life in a concentration camp for an average prisoner. Right.

So like in World War II, there were obviously like Nazis. Then there was something called Kapos, Marine Institute. Right. Basically prisoners who acted as trustees.

Right. And they were prisoners, but like they also like suddenly became like masters and at least had food to eat and stuff like that. And like there was like a proper hierarchy. Yeah, hierarchy in place and stuff like that.

So what he came up with, obviously he was like well qualified even before he went in there and he had like his collaborator of a segment Freud. Oh, okay. Okay. But actually he questions Freud's theory.

He was like, you know, at that level, you're like, yeah, the serious side, side, side, side, side. Yeah. Yeah. Absolutely.

So anyway, what essentially happened was he went into the concentration camp with his first manuscript and like all things. He was stripped of the bare bones, including his manuscript, which was thrown into a dustbin of sorts. And everyone was basically stripped naked, shaved to the bare skin and had a number tattooed on them. So you were basically stripped of all identity and all you were was a number and stuff like that.

But the interesting thing is he came out of this and he, you know, lived in 1997, a full life and how do you find so the man search for meaning is his basic quest. Right. And what he's come up with is something called logo therapy, which Chuck, when we started the episode, what I told you that the logo of the mic should be facing you for. Yes.

Actually, it's not that it is actually that logos in Greek means meaning. Okay. Oh, my logos. Yeah.

That's okay. I can't remember from biology. Yeah. So of the name biogenes.

Absolutely. So who would have thought Chuck, the best advice in life is can you make the logo bigger? Oh, nice. Beautiful.

Can you make the logo bigger? So what he sort of observed was like, obviously, like different faces to what you endure in a concentration camp from shop to apathy to basically just like pure selfishness. Right. And he says like the best of the people in the camps did not survive because they probably gave up their seat for someone else to die or whatever.

Right. So he admits as much. And essentially his Fonda was that while there were people who were of different physical stages, like some well built, some not so well built, he founded the intellectual ones or, you know, who were probably physically more frail, survived longer than the study ones. Right.

Which is a little weird. And that's where he came up with the idea that Nietzsche said that he who has a why to live can bear almost any how. So that's the basic Fonda and where he largely differs from in terms of what we are taught to chase is that happiness is not relevant. It is meaning that makes more difference.

Like can you find meaning to your life. Right. So this is even more important in an era like ours where there is something called the existential vacuum. Right.

So he talks about how like on a Sunday evening, most people feel like this void where you're done with the work for the week and then you basically like watch two movies or whatever and then you dread Mondays again. Right. Like this is existential vacuum of people telling you people not telling you what to do and you also don't know what to do and you're wondering what is your purpose on this planet in life and stuff like that. So that is essentially what he's tackling.

When you take this particular scenario or the concepts that you were talking about that existential void and stuff like that, I've been playing with this thought that I read in an article somewhere that that human because of this in society, we have so many different routes for the quest of happiness. We're all looking for like, what are the different parts for happiness and all that stuff. But since the beginning of time, since there are so many different parts for happiness and nobody really seems to have achieved it in any real meaningful way, is it that the, I mean, true that achieving happiness is never really the quest of humans at all. Like it is that the constant suffering is the way to be because humans will never be happy.

I mean, if they find happiness, it will automatically transition itself into an happiness. It is not going to be a real thing. It's like the plot of what an evil movie or something where humans constant suffering is the fuel that keeps the world going in something like history. It's like a weird combination of social dilemma and that was a Jim Carrey movie, the one where he's the true man show, and the whole bunch of other things together.

Wow, that's a big way. In fact, that would be so awesome. You know, you have this suffering meter and there's one part of the world where the suffering is going down and then the energy levels and the lights are going in. You know, George Carlin had this brilliant set once.

I mean, all of his sets were brilliant. But one of the things is like the humans think a little too much of us is what if our only purpose in life was to actually create plastic in the first place. All right, we got everything we needed, plastic. Humans.

And then once that's done, all right, let's get rid of these guys. So yeah, I mean, we'll try to find meaning for our life and all that. We actually answered that. Like maybe that will answer the question that we were all been asking.

What are we here for? Plastic. Yeah. And even again, the most going back to the most profound philosophers of our time stand up comedians, which is currently disgraced, Louis C.

And everyone is in a shitty thing. You had a thing. You wanted to make it a good thing. You got to a good thing and then it became a shitty thing.

So everyone is currently in a shitty thing. Like there is nobody who started in a good thing. Like there was a thing that was good previously. There is something called Peter's principle.

So every organization oppers and rises to his level of incompetence. So if you're a competitor, you get promoted and you only stop getting promoted when you're incompetent. So you're actually, you know, you're happy you want to bet. So actually Victor Frank's entire book is that it's how to, you know, about finding meaning even in the most miserable situation.

Yeah. He says that regardless of how miserable the situation is, if you are able to find meaning, then you can live. That's basically as I remember it. Absolutely.

Yeah. In fact, on that thing, the whole make America great again phenomenon comes from the question was when America to be great. What is the time that you're trying to get back to? Yeah.

This question has been asked so many times like, you're like, okay, when there was slavery America was in great, when there was like segregation America was in great, when there was like all of these discrimination in blacks America was in great. America was in great. America was in great. It was in great.

Before the British came. Before the British came. So there were two completely different things that I thought of when Narayan and Shri Keit was just saying their references. Both kind of tangentially connected to what Tony was saying with, you know, the larger thing of meaning of life and all that.

One, and she gets to don't throw something at me for saying this, brand purpose. Can you make the logo bigger? No, no, no. So why don't you do it?

I'm on Zoom. Yeah. So no, no, no. We joke about this a lot.

And I'm actually in studying brands over the last couple of years. And it seems to me that the companies that do well and do well, not just from a profit point of view, but you know, just overall have some sense of purpose. And I know that phrase brand purpose has been thrown about quite a bit, but companies who stick to what they believed in tend to be the ones that, you know, sort of do well. And it kind of goes back to the point that you were making, right, which is, you know, trying to find some meaning in life or, you know, whatever.

But I wouldn't elaborate on that too much because I'm sure that I am. You're very right. Because the thing is brand purpose gained prominence because of those companies that did it well and then got screwed up by all the video to try to do it half ass. And then the fact that it's become this parody of itself.

Brand purpose in its essence was that what is the two meaning of what you exist to raise on that through? Why did you exist? Yeah, yeah, I always like a short heuristic for me for whether brands really mean brand purpose and I guess I can be extended to humans as well with respect to values. Are you willing to sacrifice money in order to stand up for your values?

Like if you really say that you are pro environment, for instance, like, okay, I'll call it in the app for an exchange. I'm okay with people burning the Nike's. I want you to do that. I want you to stop buying my product if you support this call.

Because if you just say, I just want to say, I just kind of connected to this. I mean, just to turn the upliftment to meet up a notch a little bit. When I started freelancing, like I just ended up doing a whole bunch of things and to some extent doing that. But I used to read a lot of stuff that other freelancers would write, you know, advice and just things like that.

And one of the most profound piece of advice that I read somewhere was aim to make yourself useful. Because from there, everything else will be derived. If you try to do something like aiming for happiness or one of those broad things, you know, it doesn't end up getting you anywhere. So aim for usefulness and then everything else will kind of work as well.

That's a very nice way of kind of looking at it. So you haven't translated that down yet. I think it goes back to what you were saying. Everyone has their own internal direction, I guess.

And the sooner if you go that out, the better it is. I'm realizing as I age that many of these things that we would laugh at as kids go find purpose in life. That's actually basically something I realized. So just to get back to Frankel, not disparaging your freelance experience.

One of the profound things he said was that, you know, obviously the best of us didn't survive. And pure statistically, because we've been used to numbers, you had a one in 28 chance of making it out alive. Which is like a fairly bleak order. But he made it out and he doesn't leave it abstract.

He's not saying like, you know, don't chase happiness. Everything is missing. He actually makes a very interesting distinction is that like chasing happiness is like asking someone to laugh. There needs to be a reason for you to laugh, which is a joke itself.

So the laughter is an after effect of telling the joke. So in what that translates to is that you shouldn't, you know, happen is not great. He's saying that once you figure out that meaning happiness is something that ends you. So instead of saying say cheese and making some in love, it's much easier and nicer and natural if that laughter comes as a result of telling a joke or something like that.

So and to do, I think you just started on to it beautifully. Yeah. So he actually defines three things. And this is like very easy to follow.

And I can't say this enough times. But one of the greatest things for me to come out and simplify it was exactly one year ago when Marraine spoke about stoicism. And in some senses, it is related to Frankel's theories related to stoicism. So before I go to the three things, he basically says trying to find a universal meaning doesn't make sense.

Because your purpose in life is probably to turn into plastic. That doesn't matter. But asking that question is same as asking like a chess grandmaster like Marraine, what is the best move in chess? Right.

And he's saying that there is no best move in chess. It's dependent on the situation that you're put in and you have to solve the problem for yourself by finding the best move in that given situation. Right. So broadly, he says there are three ways to find meaning in life.

One is by something you do, which is some meaningful work. If you find meaning in work and there are enough people who do, they have a happy or meaningful life. And this where the speakers out in the principal thing is when a lot of people who place their entire existence on work retire, right? And suddenly you find that they were healthy and at their prime and suddenly they just deeper off and become a shell of what they were previously.

So while that is one way, the other way is basically love. And we've all experienced this when you are infatuated with someone or something, you find the best in them and also find your best because of them. Right. So work, love.

And this is something that kept him going during the concentration camp. Like I said, his manuscript, the first manuscript was taken away from the first day he came out. And he was like, okay, I have to go back and finish this book. Right.

That was one thing he found meaning in the second verses newly married wife. Right. And he had no means of communicating with her, but on like every routine day, he would imagine conversations with her and that kept him going. And the third is suffering in itself and not that suffering is great, but you're attitude towards suffering or the courage to stand up in the face of suffering gives you meaning.

So he's saying that you don't seek out suffering because that's masochistic, not heroic. But if you encounter such a suffering and you're able to put a courage stand to it where sort of stoicism also comes in and it's a philosophy towards action and responsibility on your side, then you'll find meaning. So very three simple things which I found was like really profound and a very good way of looking at what can you say as instead of happiness means. Well said.

It is truly a life changing book. I strongly recommend it. I want to read it. And you know, it gives a lot of meaning.

As you're talking, by the way, Tony, I said something about your light changed and suddenly you're a halo. I didn't think it was a life changing game. I'm listening to this. Can't see them, but when Tony went from that moment of bleakness to light the light.

I don't know the light. I think it's the halo. It just ends you. Tony, are you actually like, I've always wondered, like, are you like, like, have you, like, have you, like, lockdown does funny things to people, like, they came to Stocks and I'm like, I'm like, I'm like, my question was larger than that.

I don't want to see the name, but have you been sent, you know, like, from above and I don't mean like the 13th floor. He keeps me going. This is why we have that old, old, there's this joke about like, you don't need to say old. You don't need to say old.

He just does. Like some dude gets ghosted with a headache and he's like, dog headache and he's like, okay, we've been drinking a lot. He's like, no smoking a lot, no lots of women, no, three times. He examines him for a bit longer and he's like, found a problem.

Your halo is too tight. He is too tight. Tony, that was good for me. I actually thought that was, we have done many profundities, but that might actually be the most profound.

So maybe it's good to introspect once in a while even on the show. So look, look at the repeat. And one last thing, it's interesting Tony that you said exactly one year ago that you did that show with Narayanan's voice. It's not because exactly one year and five days ago or one year and one week ago, Narayanan, I recorded an IBM for the first time.

Oh, wow. And today, I'd like to say to you guys live that I'm actually back on Simplified. Yeah, yeah. And not just for this episode, not just for this episode, but for like Tony, I'm not on this.

So, I'm assuming you'll be back as well now. Definitely. I can not be back then. I'm not going to be back as it was.

No, because I've been turned because after 175, I just needed a bit of a break. I think I've got a break. In any case, and other certain projects that Tony and I were doing before have decided to. Because I think, let's just say that we have creative differences.

And yeah, so I'm glad to be back on Simplified. It's so stupid. Similarly, I also like, I didn't have a declared hiatus, but I did have a same self-imposed one work, plus a lot of other stuff. But with the gang back, there is no way I'm not.

Let's go the fab force back. Let's go to this again. Let's all do this again. And this was among the most fun I've had in months.

Yes. There's no way I don't want to continue this. So let's just start it all over again. Yes, quickly.

Stay safe. Stay meaningful and Simplified. I'm sure that we are far. Stay big tech.

Stay big tech. We'll be back to work a little bit. Bye, everybody. And we'll see you again soon.

Frequently asked questions

How long is this episode of Simblified?

This episode is 54 minutes long.

When was this Simblified episode published?

This episode was published on March 22, 2021.

Is there a transcript available for this episode?

Yes, a full transcript is available for this episode. You can read the complete transcript on the episode page.

Can I download this Simblified episode?

Yes. Use the download control on the episode player to save the publisher-provided media file.